Fall 2020 / Inside the Pinelands
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Fall 2020 Volume 27 Number 3 Remembering John Stokes . 2 Protecting the Pinelands During a Pandemic . 3 Science & Stewardship A view of the Pinelands from Apple Pie Hill by Ernest Cozens III. in the Pines . 4 Creating a Truly Inclusive Outdoors Floyd West: Pinelands Protector. 6 by Jaclyn Rhoads, Assistant Executive Director We believe that the Pinelands National regardless of race, color, gender, culture Coming Soon! Reserve will only survive in the long run if or religion. Data from US Forest Service, people of all backgrounds know, love, and National Park Service, and US Fish and speak out for preserving it. Right now, Wildlife Service “suggest deep inequality Online Store Pinelands Preservation Alliance and in the ethnic/racial mix of visitors to our many other conservation groups in New public land.” 1 PPA will be launching Jersey are not representative of our our online store region’s racial and ethnic diversity. We The consequences of this lack of diversity November 15th. have not yet connected with all the people are important to consider. It restricts our political power, deprives environmental Browse our catalog of who should see the Pinelands as theirs to enjoy and protect. groups of ideas that would help them books, apparel and hats! succeed and sends a message that Items will be shipped to you or your loved one. Some of our members, followers, and conservation is pretty much a white supporters may not understand our endeavor. approach, but speaking from the perspec- Find the store here: tive of a Latina, this problem exists. I For the Pinelands Preservation Alliance know what it is like to be called various to be successful in protecting the PinelandsAlliance.org derogatory names by people that I called Pinelands we must engage the whole my friends and to feel like I didn’t belong community, including groups that have in certain professional settings. Even if a been historically excluded. If we don’t, person of color is not directly called out the issues that are critical to preservation or belittled publicly, there is a sense or of the Pinelands will become irrelevant in 17 PEMBERTON ROAD feeling of exclusion in many spaces. It is the minds of a large portion of voters, SOUTHAMPTON, NJ 08088 visitors and supporters. T - 609.859.8860 that feeling of exclusion that we need to F - 609.859.8804 WWW.PINELANDSALLIANCE.ORG eliminate everywhere, but especially in We are starting to examine how racial our outdoors that belong to all people inequality impacts our work and our continued on page 5 Inside The A Giant in the Protection of the Pinelands New Jersey Pinelands Published three times a By Carleton Montgomery, Executive Director year by the Pinelands Preservation Alliance In July, we lost another friend and a applicant for development. Even pioneer of the Pinelands protection when we disagreed strongly – which Executive Editor movement, John C. Stokes. happened on several important issues Carleton Montgomery – I never for a moment doubted John was the planner among the trio John’s deep personal commitment to preserving the Pinelands and making Editor of founding managers of the Pinelands Commission, along with the CMP work for this region’s Becky Free executive director Terrence Moore unique natural resources. And his and regulatory lawyer William creative thinking led to important PPA Staff Harrison. In that key role John was a new initiatives – I think particularly of the Toms River and Oyster Creek Isabella Castiglioni principal architect of the Pinelands Comprehensive Management Plan plans that resulted in better Tom Dunn (CMP), and he deserves enormous protection of important watersheds – Andrew Gold respect for shaping America’s and often enabled the Commission to make the best of a bad situation. Rhyan Grech strongest, most innovative regional growth management program. That Audra Hardoon the Pinelands CMP has been able to “John Stokes was a giant in the Jason Howell protect vast swathes of forests, protection of the New Jersey swamps and waters over more than Pinelands,” to quote Betty Wilson, Alicia Plaag 40 years in the nation’s most who helped found the Pinelands Ryan Rebozo intensively developed state is due to Preservation Alliance and served as Jaclyn Rhoads the vision and regulations that John the Chairperson of the Pinelands and his colleagues created. Commission from 2005 to 2008. Stephen Sebastian John was a superb public servant and Jeff Tober John joined the Pinelands a model of those special people who Commission staff at its founding in dedicate their career to an important Pinelands Adventures 1980 as chief planner and assistant but very challenging public good. Rob Ferber director. He was promoted to become the Commission’s third executive director in 2003, where he served until his retirement in 2011. Distributed to Throughout the years between 1998, PPA members & volunteers, when I came to PPA, and his state legislators, retirement in 2011, I spent countless Pinelands municipalities, hours in conversation, debate and elected officials, occasionally argument with John. and planning boards And after his retirement, John recruited me to help him and others Mailing services generously promote better understanding of the donated by Swift Mailing Pinelands protection program www.swiftmailing.com among officials in the federal Printed on 100% recycled paper government. (made from post-consumer pulp produced in a chlorine-free John was always generous with his time pulping and bleaching process) John was very smart, and always had thoroughly reasoned positions on helping people understand how the Circulation: 550 0 Pinelands are protected. This image policy and development issues. But he was also genuinely open-minded shows John presenting to teachers during Available online at our 2008 teacher training institute. www.pinelandsalliance.org in listening to different perspectives, whether mine or those of an 2 Protecting the Pinelands During a Pandemic by Rhyan Grech, Policy Advocate During an unprecedented global a restaurant, with no specific Zoom. PPA is considering next steps pandemic, it feels that everything building tenants identified, and the with our partners. from “normal life” has been public comment period opened in interrupted. Online food shopping, May 2020. In response, PPA This extraordinary time calls for home schooling and Zoom meetings submitted a series of Open Public extraordinary vigilance, and PPA have become the new normal for Records Act (OPRA) requests to the staff are working to ensure the countless families, and the sad reality Department of Environmental public’s voice is heard. You can stay of illness and loss has impacted too Protection (DEP) to receive the engaged with the issues and make many lives. Nationally, life as we development application and all your voice heard by on our issues knew it has ground to a halt as related documents. A complete file is pages at www.pinelandsalliance.org. COVID-19 draws our focus. With all necessary to fully examine and Click “Protect” on the home page. the closures, working from home comment on a potential project. and social distancing measures, it is Since DEP staff are working remotely, State of the Pinelands easy to assume that construction and access to any paper document Report Coming Soon! development projects have paused. proved challenging, and incomplete In the Pinelands however, records were sent. Back and forth This annual review of state, federal applications to build are still moving conversations with DEP, attempting and local agencies is a thorough forward while New Jersey residents to obtain all relevant documents, account of the public policy actions are understandably distracted. This extended beyond the public that affected the Pinelands National results in circumstances that favor comment deadline. Reserve over the last year. development applicants, as public In the meantime, PPA requested a participation is more difficult right Available online and mailed to our now. public hearing, which would have provided the opportunity to submit members in December. One egregious example is the Jaylin expert testimony and evidence property in Manchester. Located on backing up our arguments. DEP www.PinelandsAlliance.org Route 37, some may remember the denied our hearing request, citing old proposal to build a Walmart on COVID difficulties, even though this site years ago. This property is many other agencies and local Pinelands Commission valuable habitat for the Northern governments have been holding pine snake and Pine Barrens treefrog, public hearings remotely since the The Commission’s offices are closed both state-threatened species. It also shutdowns. DEP did agree to a due to the COVID-19 crisis. Their serves as a sink for nutrient runoff phone conversation to talk through monthly meetings are open to the and stormwater in an otherwise our comments and concerns with the public via livestream on their highly developed section of Toms application, including threatened YouTube channel. River township. PPA and Save and endangered species habitat Barnegat Bay successfully opposed destruction, infringement on a You can call in and comment during prior development proposals because wetlands buffer, and mathematical that part of the agenda. they would harm or destroy rare mistakes in the application dealing species habitat and create too much with the allowable impervious cover Next meeting dates: impervious cover (building roofs, on the site. But our arguments fell on and pavement) for such a site. PPA deaf ears, and the project was Nov. 13th, 9:30 am provided the state with scientific approved the same day. Dec. 11th, 9:30 am reports on the threatened and While the applicant was allowed to endangered species and advocated for enforcement of relevant environ- move through the process unimped- The link to livestream meetings mental protections. Eventually ed, the public was shut out: first, with can be found on their website: Walmart withdrew from the project incomplete responses to OPRA and the application fell apart.