Michael Bench-Capon

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Michael Bench-Capon Empty Names Michael George Trevor Bench-Capon Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Leeds School of Philosophy, Religion and the History of Science September 2013 0 The candidate confirms that the work submitted is his own and that appropriate credit has been given where reference has been made to the work of others. This copy has been supplied on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgement. © 2013 The University of Leeds and Michael George Trevor Bench- Capon The right of Michael George Trevor Bench-Capon to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted by him in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents act 1988. 1 Acknowledgements A lot of people have helped me, philosophically or otherwise, while I was writing and this. I would like to thank these people: The other philosophy postgraduates at Leeds from 2009 to 2013, especially Thomas Brouwer, Wouter Kalf, and Paul Ramshaw. The staff in the philosophy department at Leeds during that time, especially my supervisor, Andrew McGonigal. My examiners, Robbie Williams and Cian Dorr, for their input at the viva. My parents, my brothers, and my grandparents. My girlfriend, Aliya Vasylenko. 2 Abstract Empty names are names which do not refer to anything. Apparently empty names are used in many different ways, and an analysis which looks good for one kind of use can look bad for another. I aim to get a wide enough angle on the issues that the solutions I propose won’t run into that problem. Chapter one is about names which are empty because they were introduced in the context of mistakes and lies. I see how we can assign truth values to utterances containing such names. I also look at how genuinely empty names could be meaningful at all, and examine how they could fit into a Davidsonian theory of meaning. Chapter two is about mental states corresponding to the names dealt with in chapter one. I try to give an account of how beliefs could be subject to rational norms without appealing to their propositional contents. I do this by showing that puzzles about co-referring names can motivate such an account independently, and that the empty name beliefs can fit into this framework easily. Chapter three is about attitude ascriptions and propositions. I consider different ways of responding to the problem of having propositions but no objects for the propositions to be about. I defend an account involving gappy Fregean propositions, and give a semantics for attitude ascriptions which incorporates them. Chapter four is about the names that occur in fiction. I argue that we should take these to be polysemous between a use referring to an artistic creation and a use primarily suited to pretence. For the first use, I survey proposals for ontologies of fictional characters, and suggest one of my own. To make sense of the second use, I use a two- 3 dimensional semantics, which also helps with the problem of negative existentials. 4 Contents Chapter Zero: Introduction 9 Chapter One: Names without Referents 13 1.0 Introduction 13 1.1 Meaningful names without semantic contributions 17 o 1.11 Braun’s problems 17 o 1.12 Braun’s solutions 18 o 1.13 Other routes to pessimistic truth values 25 1.2 Everett’s objection 30 o 1.21 A Millian solution 30 o 1.22 A metalinguistic solution 32 o 1.23 A Fregean solution 35 1.3 Empty names and truth theories 39 o 1.31 Davidsonian theories of meaning 39 o 1.32 The Davidsonian problem of empty names 43 o 1.33 Semantic competence and semantic ignorance 44 o 1.34 More tentative semantic axioms 49 1.4 Conclusion 53 Chapter Two: Beliefs without Objects 56 2.0 Introduction 56 2.1 Frege’s Puzzle 58 o 2.11 Descriptivism 61 o 2.12 Anaphora and drefs 63 o 2.13 Paderewski 67 2.2 A psychological solution to Frege’s puzzle 79 o 2.21 The language of thought hypothesis 79 o 2.22 Dispensing with psychological sententialism 81 5 o 2.23 Problems with co-ordination 89 . 2.231 Anti-luminosity 90 . 2.232 Slow switching 92 o 2.24 A more formal framework for co-ordination 95 2.3 Conclusion 101 Chapter Three: Contents without Constituents 103 3.0 Introduction 103 3.1 Desiderata for a solution 107 o 3.11 The role of propositions 107 o 3.12 Truth intuitions about attitude ascriptions 108 o 3.13 Intentional transitives 109 o 3.14 A plausible ontology 111 3.2 Reifying the constituents 112 o 3.21 Meingongianism 112 o 3.22 Abstract artefcacts 114 3.3 Rejecting the contents 117 o 3.31 Error theory 117 o 3.32 Pretence and paraphrase 119 3.4 Gappy propositions 122 o 3.41 Russellian gappy propositions 122 o 3.42 Fregean gappy propositions 128 3.5 Conclusion 138 Appendix: Sential Semantics for Attitude Ascriptions 141 Chapter Four: Fictional Names 147 4.0 Introduction 147 4.1 Fictional ontologies 151 o 4.11 Van Inwagen’s argument 151 6 o 4.111 ‘If there are fictional characters then they exist’ 151 o 4.112 ‘There are fictional characters’ 152 o 4.113 Yagisawa’s objections 156 o 4.12 Categorizing fictional ontologies 169 o 4.121 Dependent abstracta 170 o 4.122 Platonic abstracta 172 o 4.123 Non-existent concreta 177 4.2 Problems for fictional ontologies 181 o 4.21 Creations or discoveries? 181 o 4.22 Kripke and unicorns 189 o 4.221 Kripke’s argument 192 o 4.222 Descriptivist responses 195 o 4.223 Dummett 197 o 4.224 Reimer 202 o 4.225 Yagisawa 203 o 4.226 Epistemicism and indeterminacy 206 o 4.227 Summary 212 o 4.23 Double lives 213 o 4.231 Caulfield’s fame and other problems 213 o 4.232 Kripke’s story about Sherlock Holmes 215 o 4.233 Interdependent fictional characters 218 o 4.234 The modesty paradox 221 o 4.235 Abstract and concrete natives and immigrants 227 4.3 A sketch of a fictional ontology 230 o 4.31 Introduction 230 o 4.32 Informal presentation of the theory 231 o 4.33 Formal presentation of the theory 236 o 4.34 How the theory solves the problems 238 o 4.341 Creations or discoveries? 239 o 4.342 Kripke and unicorns 240 o 4.343 Double lives 240 7 o 4.3431 Caulfield’s fame 241 o 4.3432 Kripke’s story about Sherlock Holmes 241 o 4.3433 Interdependent fictional characters 242 o 4.3434 Paradoxes 243 o 4.35 Limitations of the theory 245 4.4 Pretence 245 o 4.41 Leaving your sports car in the garage 245 o 4.42 Anchored and unanchored pretence 248 o 4.43 Lewis on truth in fiction 251 o 4.431 Semi-rigid designation 252 o 4.432 Fictional names and attitude ascriptions 255 o 4.433 Note on ‘according to’ 259 4.5 Conclusion 262 Chapter Five: Concluding Remarks 265 5.1 What we have learned about empty names 265 5.2 What we have learned about other things 266 5.3 What we have not learned about empty names 267 Bibliography 269 8 Chapter 0 – Introduction Once upon a time, at least according to philosophical folklore, most people were descriptivists about names. This means they thought that names, like ‘Aristotle’, had the same meanings as definite descriptions, like ‘the pupil of Plato and teacher of Alexander’. Bertrand Russell [1905] gave a famous analysis of definite descriptions which still makes sense even if nothing fits the description, and thus we could be forgiven for thinking that we had solved any problems associated with names which don’t refer to anything, or empty names as we'll call them. Apparently empty names are words like ‘Apollo’ (for a god some Greeks thought existed), ‘Vulcan’ (for a planet some astronomers thought existed), and ‘Santa’ (for a jolly fellow some children think exists). The problem of empty names came back, so the story goes, when people like Ruth Barcan Marcus, Saul Kripke and David Kaplan started challenging the descriptivist consensus. They presented arguments that at least some of the time names behave very differently from definite descriptions. One view which gained some popularity was Millianism, named after John Stuart Mill, which says that the meaning of a name just is its referent. This immediately presents a problem for empty names, because it seems that a name without a referent won’t have a meaning. Even if we stop short of Millianism, we might still want to say that a name’s meaning is more intimately connected to its referent than a definite description’s meaning is to the thing (if any) fitting the description, and this makes empty names a problem. One response is to fall back on descriptivism. I don’t want to do that, and will mostly only consider it as either a last resort or way of treating special cases. Another response is Meinongianism, which in its extreme form says there are no empty names, and all apparently empty names refer to non-existent objects. I don’t want to do that either, but I will 9 leave the view on the table and give it a fair ride. The principal aim of this thesis is to see if we can make sense of the different ways we use apparently empty names without falling back on descriptivism.
Recommended publications
  • Russellians Can Have a No Proposition View of Empty Names
    King’s Research Portal DOI: 10.1080/0020174X.2017.1372307 Document Version Peer reviewed version Link to publication record in King's Research Portal Citation for published version (APA): Hodgson, T. (2018). Russellians can have a no proposition view of empty names. Inquiry, 61(7), 670-691. https://doi.org/10.1080/0020174X.2017.1372307 Citing this paper Please note that where the full-text provided on King's Research Portal is the Author Accepted Manuscript or Post-Print version this may differ from the final Published version. If citing, it is advised that you check and use the publisher's definitive version for pagination, volume/issue, and date of publication details. And where the final published version is provided on the Research Portal, if citing you are again advised to check the publisher's website for any subsequent corrections. General rights Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the Research Portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognize and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. •Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the Research Portal for the purpose of private study or research. •You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain •You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the Research Portal Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact [email protected] providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.
    [Show full text]
  • Truths Containing Empty Names Michael Mckinsey
    In Philosophical Approaches to Proper Names, P. Stalmaszczyk and L. Fernández Moreno (eds.).Peter Lang, 2016. Truths Containing Empty Names Michael McKinsey 1. A problem for direct reference. According to the thesis of Direct Reference (or the DR-thesis for short), the propositions expressed by sentences containing the proper names and indexical pronouns of natural language are a strict function of the semantic referents of the names and indexicals, as opposed to being a function of any Fregean descriptive senses or contents that the names and indexicals might be alleged to possess.1 Another way of expressing this idea is to say that the sole semantic contribution that a proper name or indexical can make to the propositions expressed by sentences containing the term is the term’s semantic referent. Bertrand Russell called terms of this sort ‘names in the logical sense’ (1918, 201). I will call them ‘genuine terms’. Following standard practice, I will call the propositions expressed by sentences containing genuine terms, ‘singular propositions’. Like many others, I endorse the DR-thesis. In my case, the primary reason for endorsing the thesis lies in the modal considerations first briefly introduced by John Searle (1958) and later clarified and forcefully applied by Saul Kripke (1972a), considerations which show that proper names do not have the meanings of contingent definite descriptions. David Kaplan (1989) raised related points to support the conclusion that indexical pronouns are also genuine terms. In recent work I have argued at some length that the DR-thesis entails both that (a) a sentence containing a non-referring name or indexical can express no proposition, and hence that (b) such sentences can have no truth value, that is, can be neither true or false.
    [Show full text]
  • The Development of Mathematical Logic from Russell to Tarski: 1900–1935
    The Development of Mathematical Logic from Russell to Tarski: 1900–1935 Paolo Mancosu Richard Zach Calixto Badesa The Development of Mathematical Logic from Russell to Tarski: 1900–1935 Paolo Mancosu (University of California, Berkeley) Richard Zach (University of Calgary) Calixto Badesa (Universitat de Barcelona) Final Draft—May 2004 To appear in: Leila Haaparanta, ed., The Development of Modern Logic. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004 Contents Contents i Introduction 1 1 Itinerary I: Metatheoretical Properties of Axiomatic Systems 3 1.1 Introduction . 3 1.2 Peano’s school on the logical structure of theories . 4 1.3 Hilbert on axiomatization . 8 1.4 Completeness and categoricity in the work of Veblen and Huntington . 10 1.5 Truth in a structure . 12 2 Itinerary II: Bertrand Russell’s Mathematical Logic 15 2.1 From the Paris congress to the Principles of Mathematics 1900–1903 . 15 2.2 Russell and Poincar´e on predicativity . 19 2.3 On Denoting . 21 2.4 Russell’s ramified type theory . 22 2.5 The logic of Principia ......................... 25 2.6 Further developments . 26 3 Itinerary III: Zermelo’s Axiomatization of Set Theory and Re- lated Foundational Issues 29 3.1 The debate on the axiom of choice . 29 3.2 Zermelo’s axiomatization of set theory . 32 3.3 The discussion on the notion of “definit” . 35 3.4 Metatheoretical studies of Zermelo’s axiomatization . 38 4 Itinerary IV: The Theory of Relatives and Lowenheim’s¨ Theorem 41 4.1 Theory of relatives and model theory . 41 4.2 The logic of relatives .
    [Show full text]
  • Belgian Laces
    Belgian Laces “Le Gros-Chêne”, the Old Oak Tree, around 1875 – from a painting by Auguste Barbier http://ibelgique.ifrance.com/arbresdumonde/chene_set.htm Volume 17 # 65 December 1995 BELGIAN LACES ISSN 1046-0462 Official Quarterly Bulletin of THE BELGIAN RESEARCHERS Belgian American Heritage Association Founded in 1976 Our principal objective is: Keep the Belgian Heritage alive in our hearts and in the hearts of our posterity President Pierre Inghels Vice-President Micheline Gaudette Assistant VP Leen Inghels Treasurer Marlena Bellavia Secretary Patricia Robinson Dues to THE BELGIAN RESEARCHERS with subscription to BELGIAN LACES Are: In the US $12.00 a year In Canada $12.00 a year in US funds Other Countries $14.00 a year in US funds Subscribers in Europe, please add US $4.00 if you wish to receive your magazine per airmail. All subscriptions are for the calendar year. New subscribers receive the four issues of the current year, regardless when paid. Opinions expressed in Belgian Laces are not necessarily those of The Belgian Researchers or of the staff. TABLE OF CONTENTS Member portrait: Don DALEBROUX 62 A Gold Mine of Data, Georges PICAVET 63 Le Vieux Chene, Leen INGHELS 63 Sheldon, NY, Micheline GAUDETTE 65 Wisconsin Corner, Mary Ann Defnet, 70 Perfect Timing, Don VAN HOUDENOS 72 Henry VERSLYPE, Pierre INGHELS 73 Belgo-American Centenarian, Leen INGHELS 74 WWII Memories, John VAN DORPE 74 Where in Cyberspace is Belgium?, Hans Michael VERMEERSCH 75 Those Wacky Walloons!, Leen INGHELS 76 Manneken Pis 77 Passenger Lists, M. GAUDETTE
    [Show full text]
  • Empty Names, Fictional Names, Mythical Names
    NOUS^ 39:4 (2005) 596–631 Empty Names, Fictional Names, Mythical Names DAVID BRAUN University of Rochester John Stuart Mill (1843) thought that proper names denote individuals and do not connote attributes. Contemporary Millians agree, in spirit. We hold that the semantic content of a proper name is simply its referent. We also think that the semantic content of a declarative sentence is a Russellian structured proposition whose constituents are the semantic contents of the sentence’s constituents.1 This proposition is what the sentence semantically expresses. Therefore, we think that sentences containing proper names semantically express singular proposi- tions, which are propositions having individuals as constituents. For instance, the sentence ‘George W. Bush is human’ semantically expresses a proposition that has Bush himself as a constituent. Call this theory Millianism.2 Many philosophers initially find Millianism quite appealing, but find it much less so after considering its many apparent problems. Among these problems are those raised by non-referring names, which are sometimes (tendentiously) called empty names.3 Plausible examples of empty names include certain names from fiction, such as ‘Sherlock Holmes’, which I shall call fictional names, and certain names from myth and false scientific theory, such as ‘Pegasus’ and ‘Vulcan’, which I shall call mythical names.4 I have defended Millianism from objections concerning empty names in previous work (Braun [1993]). In this paper, I shall re-present those objec- tions, along with some new ones. I shall then describe my previous Millian theory of empty names, and my previous replies to the objections, and consider whether the theory or replies need revision.
    [Show full text]
  • Belgian Events - March 2013
    Belgian Events - March 2013 Newsletter of the Embassy of Belgium in London Table of contents ECONOMIC NEWS BELGIUM AND THE WORLD SPORTS NEWS CULTURE INTERVIEW WITH A BELGIAN IN THE UK DID YOU KNOW? BELGIAN CLUBS AND ORGANISATIONS BELGIAN HONORARY CONSULATES IN THE UK CALENDAR OF EVENTS ANNOUNCEMENTS ECONOMIC NEWS Umicore, most sustainable company in the world Umicore was declared the most sustainable company in the world during the World Economic Forum in Davos last week. The Canadian independent media and investment research company Corporate Knights put the Belgian business at the top of their latest Global 100 ranking, nabbing the gold from Brazilian cosmetics company Natura and the Norwegian oil company Statoil. Umicore specialises in recycling technology and manufactures catalysts for cars which reduce pollution. It also recycles materials like gold, copper, nickel and rare metals such as palladium from used car batteries and printing plates. Ecological efficiency is high on the agenda of the company, which plans on-site wind turbines and aims to reduce its level of CO2 emissions by 20% in 2015 compared to 2006. The fact that the corporation has a one-to-five ratio of female representatives on their board of directors and a CEO (Marc Grynberg) who earns ‘only’ 34 times as much as the average employee, ensured Umicore’s exceptional score as far as the social component of the index is concerned. In 1989, Umicore was set up after the merger of mining giant Union Minière and the lead- processing plant Metallurgie. The company became one of the most spectacular and successful industrial reconversions in Belgium and has gradually managed to position itself as a global player among major recycling businesses.
    [Show full text]
  • Oss Personnel Files - Rg 226 Entry 224 12/23/2010
    OSS PERSONNEL FILES - RG 226 ENTRY 224 12/23/2010 LAST NAME FIRST NAME M I RANK or SERIAL BOX NOTES LOCATION Aaberg Caf-3 E T-5 37541999 1 230/86/26/03 Aalbu Sigurd J S/Sgt 37091702 1 230/86/26/03 Aanonsen Olaf H Cpl 32440677 1 230/86/26/03 Abbenante Helen G Cpl A125357 1 230/86/26/03 Abbote Frank Pfc 32985690 1 230/86/26/03 Abbote John A T-3 42048684 1 230/86/26/03 Abbott Delbert H Pvt 35314960 1 230/86/26/03 Abbott Floyd H Pfc 39535381 1 230/86/26/03 Abbott Frederick K Caf-11 1 230/86/26/03 Abbott James E S/Sgt 12063651 1 230/86/26/03 Abbott James F T-5 11102233 1 230/86/26/03 Abbott Norman SP 2/c 5634486 1 230/86/26/03 Abbott Robert J Sgt 12140436 1 230/86/26/03 Abbott Victor J M/Sgt 32455694 1 230/86/26/03 Abee Robert V T-4 34437404 1 230/86/26/03 Abel Arthur A 1st Lt 1181596 1 230/86/26/03 Abel Calvin J T-5 16117938 1 230/86/26/03 Abel John C 1 230/86/26/03 Abele Charles R 1st Lt 462544 1 230/86/26/03 Abele Herbert, Jr. A 2nd Lt 1329784 1 230/86/26/03 Abendschein Norman W Sgt 33191772 1 230/86/26/03 Abernathy James D 1st Lt 343733 1 230/86/26/03 Abney James K 1 230/86/26/03 Abraham Michael K Capt 1010362 1 230/86/26/03 Abrahamovitz Moses T/Sgt 33751543 2 230/86/26/03 Abrahams Isaace L 39090318 1 230/86/26/03 Abrahamson Albert Pvt 32966288 1 230/86/26/03 Abrahamson John D P-4 1 230/86/26/03 Abrams Allen P-7 2 230/86/26/03 Abrams Leonard 2 230/86/26/03 Abrams Melville F T-4 32978088 2 230/86/26/03 Abrams Ruth B Caf-7 2 230/86/26/03 Abrignani Vincent A Maj 1297132 2 230/86/26/03 Abrogast Hazel E Caf-4 2 230/86/26/03 Abromaitis Alexander
    [Show full text]
  • Reference List
    Cyclus2 – Reference list Universities: Poznań University of Physical Education (Poland) University of Regensburg (Germany) R.O.C. Military Academy, Kaohsiung (Taiwan) Saarland University, Saarbrücken (Germany) Universidad Castilla la Mancha, Ciudad Real (Spain) Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich (Germany) University of Lausanne (Switzerland) University of Science, Penang (Malaysia) Stellenbosch University (South Africa) University of Potsdam (Germany) Cheng Shiu University, Kaohsiung City (Taiwan, ROC) University of Taipei (Taiwan, ROC) Jean Monnet University, Saint-Étienne (France) University of Nottingham (Great Britain) University of Bologna (Italy) German Sport University, Cologne (Germany) Leeds Beckett University (Great Britain) Free University of Brussels-VUB (Belgium) University of La Sapienza, Rome (Italy) Universidad de la República Uruguay, Montevideo (Uruguay) Mahidol University, Nakhon Pathom (Thailand) University Hospital Reims (France) University of Franche-Comté, Besançon (France) University of Burgundy, Dijon (France) Tibet physical education institute, Lhasa (China) Belarusian National Technical University, Minsk (Belarus) Shizuoka Sangyo University, Iwata (Japan) Jaingxi Normal University, Nanchang (China) The University of Western Australia, Perth (Australia) Maastricht University (The Netherlands) University of Exeter (Great Britain) Shandong Sport University (China) The Swedish School of Sport and Health Science, GIH, Stockholm (Sweden) Ghent University (Belgium) University of Central Missouri, Warrensburg (United
    [Show full text]
  • Russell and Philip Jourdain a Study of Their Relationship
    Russell and Philip Jourdain a study of their relationship One of the frustrations of Russellian scholarship is that there is often no trace among his papers of the letters he wrote Defore 1952 to his many correspondents. One of the most important missions of the Bertrand Russell Archives is to find as many of these letters as possible; for whenever some are found, new insights and detail s emerge. Without denying the central importance of the papers purchased from Russell in 1968, the most exciting development may be the growth of its section of recent acquisitions from 'other sources. A collection of letters of this type which is of unique importance is the surviving correspondence between Russell and the mathematician and historian of mathematics Philip Jourdain (1879-1919}. Jourdain suffered throughout his life from FriedriCh's ataxia, a crippling palsey which made writing extremely difficult for him. l Nevertheless he successfully pursued a career in research and scholarship. Indeed, all his brothers and sisters were remarkable in one way or another. For example, his eldest sister Eleanor was Vice-Principal of st. Hugh's College, Oxford (and Russell knew her quite we].l in the years when he lived in the city), and in 1911 she and her Principal Annie Moberley caused a sensation when they published pseudonymously a book claiming that in 1901 they had seen Marie Antoinette and members of her court during a visit to Versailles. 2 Philip had strong views, especially in favour of foundational studies in mathematics and against the church, and later in his life he shared with Russell strong pacifist inclinations.
    [Show full text]
  • Flemish Students' Historical Reference Knowledge and Narratives of The
    London Review of Education DOI:https://doi.org/10.18546/LRE.15.2.10 Volume15,Number2,July2017 Flemish students’ historical reference knowledge and narratives of the Belgian national past at the end of secondary education TimoVanHavere,KaatWils,FienDepaepe,LievenVerschaffelandKarelVanNieuwenhuyse* University of Leuven Abstract Sincetheearlynineteenthcentury,westerngovernmentshaveexpectedhistoryeducationto playavitalroleintheformationofanationalidentityandthepursuitofnationalcohesion,by fosteringsharedknowledgeandashared(master)narrativeofthenationalpast.Thisarticle reportsonaqualitativestudythatexamineswhichnarrativesyoungadultsconstructabout their national past, to what extent those narratives are underpinned by existing narrative templates,whethertheyreflectonthefactthatthenationalpastcanbenarratedindifferent ways,andtowhatextenttheyshareacommonreferenceknowledge.Thestudyaddresses theFlemishregionofBelgium,acasecharacterizedbyaspecificcontextofanationstatein decline,whereindiverseandoftenconflictinghistoricalnarrativescoexistinpopularhistorical cultureandwherethenationalpastisalmostabsentfromhistoryeducation.Atotalof107 first-year undergraduate history students were asked to write an essay on how they saw thenationalpast.Theinfluenceofbothhistoryeducationandpopularhistoricalculturewas reflectedinthereferenceknowledgeaswellasinthe(absenceof)templatesthatstudents used to build their essays. Templates were not critically deconstructed, although some studentsneverthelesswereabletodiscernandcriticizeexisting‘myths’inthenationalpast. Keywords:
    [Show full text]
  • DOES FREGE HAVE a PROBLEM with EMPTY NAMES? by Hans Robin Solberg
    DOES FREGE HAVE A PROBLEM WITH EMPTY NAMES? By Hans Robin Solberg hink about the following two identity statements: flexivity of identity), while the second is not and might T carry new information. This is because although ‘Afla’ and (1)Darth Vader = Anakin Skywalker. ‘Ateb’ name the same mountain (the reference), they are (2)Darth Vader = Robin Hood. also names of two different modes of presentation of the mountain. It has been argued that on this picture senses are depen- Intuitively, given the universe of Star Wars and the story dent on the objects that are given (e.g. Evans 1982:12–13, of Robin Hood, (1) is true and (2) is false. Also, asserting 22–33). The argument goes something like this: If sense these sentences in a conversation could, very plausibly, is the way a reference is presented to us, then if there is create either agreement or disagreement. And if I were to no reference there is no way it can be presented to us, i.e. assert (2), someone correcting me on my mistake about there is no sense. Empty names lack reference. So, empty Robin Hood would be right in doing so. names have no sense. In this text I’ll show that Frege’s account of empty na- This wouldn’t be a problem for Frege if he claimed that mes is at odds with the intuitive understanding and use there is no sense without reference, but he repeatedly does. sketched above.1 The text contains four parts. Part I deals For Frege, a sense is meant to be independent4 both of with Frege’s account of sense and reference.
    [Show full text]
  • European Qualifiers
    EUROPEAN QUALIFIERS - 2014/16 SEASON MATCH PRESS KITS Itztadion Teddy - Jerusalem Tuesday 31 March 2015 20.45CET (21.45 local time) Israel Group B - Matchday -8 Belgium Last updated 12/07/2021 16:44CET Official Partners of UEFA EURO 2020 Previous meetings 2 Match background 3 Squad list 4 Head coach 6 Match officials 7 Competition facts 8 Match-by-match lineups 9 Team facts 11 Legend 13 1 Israel - Belgium Tuesday 31 March 2015 - 20.45CET (21.45 local time) Match press kit Itztadion Teddy, Jerusalem Previous meetings Head to Head FIFA World Cup Stage Date Match Result Venue Goalscorers reached Van Himst 24, 33, 69, 10/11/1965 QR (GS) Israel - Belgium 0-5 Ramat Gan Thio 31, Puis 48 09/05/1965 QR (GS) Belgium - Israel 1-0 Brussels Jurion 24 (P) Final Qualifying Total tournament Home Away Pld W D L Pld W D L Pld W D L Pld W D L GF GA EURO Israel - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Belgium - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - FIFA* Israel 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 - - - - 2 0 0 2 0 6 Belgium 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 - - - - 2 2 0 0 6 0 Friendlies Israel - - - - - - - - - - - - 3 1 0 2 3 5 Belgium - - - - - - - - - - - - 3 2 0 1 5 3 Total Israel 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 - - - - 5 1 0 4 3 11 Belgium 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 - - - - 5 4 0 1 11 3 * FIFA World Cup/FIFA Confederations Cup 2 Israel - Belgium Tuesday 31 March 2015 - 20.45CET (21.45 local time) Match press kit Itztadion Teddy, Jerusalem Match background In UEFA EURO 2016 Group B, Israel are on the lookout for a first competitive success against Belgium in Jerusalem as they bid to bounce back from Saturday's 3-0 defeat by Wales.
    [Show full text]