University of Massachusetts Amherst ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst

Masters Theses 1911 - February 2014

1937 A study of the use of diagnostic tests followed by drill in the teaching of agricultural arithmetic. Calton Oliver Cartwright University of Massachusetts Amherst

Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.umass.edu/theses

Cartwright, Calton Oliver, "A study of the use of diagnostic tests followed by drill in the teaching of agricultural arithmetic." (1937). Masters Theses 1911 - February 2014. 2367. Retrieved from https://scholarworks.umass.edu/theses/2367

This thesis is brought to you for free and open access by ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. It has been accepted for inclusion in Masters Theses 1911 - February 2014 by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. For more information, please contact [email protected].

MASSACHUSETTS STATE COLLEGE

DATE DUE

univ. of massachusetts/amherst library;

LD 3234 M268 1937 C329 OP :r^-xxxxxx}JC3Cxxxxxi:aa:axsxj.. ; xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx^xxxxxxxxxxx x x * A 3TOUT * OF TH3 US 3 OF DIAGNOSTIC TSSTS

DRILL II? THIS TEACHING FOLLOW BT | ARITTIMSTIC OF AGRICULTURAL j

. . . . X X X Li X X X

• • • • • ' X X m^ X X X X X By X Gaiton Oliver Cartwright X X

• • • • • x X X X X X X 2 x X * Thesis Submitted for the Degree of Maatar of Science Massachusetts state College X Amherst, ass, x * 1957 X X X 1 X X r,»,,,,...... >.»T^»Mii«iMiiiummiTrix [ ^ ?f rv OOH'iKNXb

I # Introduction 1

A* Statement or problem

8. Justification for its selection

0« Practical application of results

4 II # summary of related investigations.

III. Statement of procedure H

A. General statement concerning study

3. Descriptions of tests

C. Description of criteria

D. Kent-Sisakow tests

E. Diagnostic tests

F. Revised diagnostic tests

0. Master aheeta and Keys to errors

IV# Presentation of data obtained ana interpretation of results 46

V. Summary, conclusions ana suggestions 121 Bibliography i26 Acknowledgment I26

m& CO CO io

Introduction

The students who enter the Essex County agricultural f chool are selected from all over the county. The entrance requirements are the same as for all vocational schools es- tablished and operated under the mith-Hughes ^ct, naiuely, that the applicant shall have reached fourteen years of age and shall be a resident of this county. Further selection is usually made on the basis of the student's project facilities and his interest in agriculture. Consequently, the chronological age of the pupils varies from fourteen to sixteen yoars in the four year course and from sixteen to eighteen years or more in the three year special course. JiB a result of this wide selection, the pupils' training in the fundamental subjects, such as arith- metic, varies a great deal more than in the average local

high school department.

The purpose of this study is an attempt to find out whether or not diagnostic tests followed by drill in funda- mental processes should be used in the teaching of agricultural

arithmetic. Most agricultural teachers and supervisors believe

that only the practical and real life problems closely related

to agriculture should be taught in this and other similar

schools. All agree that students who have chosen agriculture

as their life's work will encounter numerous problems involving »

Paige 2

arithmetic* Likewise « these problems will be even more difficult when they become owners and operators of their own farms*

Furthermore | vocational supervisors have strongly emphasized the practical problems and very little if any time has been allotted for drill in the fundamental processes* The time devoted to the study of arithmetic problems does not per-

mit much review or drill on fundamentals* However 9 many pupils are now entering arithmetic classes with an inferiority com* plex or at least a dread of anything pertaining to figures*

In factf a number of the pupils have very little success in solving problems in agricultural arithmetic* Whether this difficulty is due to weaknesses in the fundamental processes to the lack of persistence and accuracy > or to the lack of reasoning power , must be determined before success in solving agricultural problems can be obtained*

Therefore f if an efficient method of analyzing the weaknesses and difficulties of the pupils could be devised and habits in the easy use of mechanical processes fixed, there would be a great saving of time on the part of the pupils and the teacher* There would also be a saving of money on the part of these future land owners by more efficient handling of their farm enterprises*

while it is clear that the ability to operate a farm with success may not depend entirely upon arithmetical reason- ing, it is evident that the most successful farmers keep accurate ai*d up to date records of all major farm enterprises* * , Page 3

Furthermore, the management of by far the greater number of farme in New England, at leaet, involves the purchasing of materials and equipment and the selling of the products as well as the actual planting, growing, and harvesting of the crops, ill of these enterprises require considerable arith- metical reasoning.

This problem is not just local in its scope as is shown by the fact that the fetate intension -ervice supplies the services of an accounting specialist who teaches the farmers to keep records and accounts of all farm enterprises.

If our students are properly trained to keep these records, they will be able to help not only themselves but also their neighbors

As will be seen in the following chapter, educators

advise the use of diagnostic teste in teaching aritteetic

but to date very few records have been kept to show the value

of such a practice. Furthermore, very few if any studies have agricultural been raaae regarding the use of these tests in

arithmetic. It is obvious that there is much need of further

study along these lines. Page 4

CHAPTER II

Summary of iielated ^nyesy^a^ons

Numerous studies have been made within recent years relating to the use of diagnostic tests in the teaching of arithmetic, but as yet no one has applied these tests to the teaching of agricultural arithmetic, and, as previously stated, very few results have been kept to determine the effect of such a practice upon pupil progress.

The following sunanary of some of these previously made studies will be found valuable for purposes of comparison.

(2 Study, bx Jajejgfc £• 2222m ssA i^mR'9s^£sm >

This is an extensive study of the teaching of arith- metic and gives a simple and clear exposition of the best methods of teaching arithmetic known today* Part One is a

presentation of the contribution which scientific studies have

made toward standardizing the subject and contains a valuable

study of the uses to which arithmetic is put in every day life. Part Two deals with certain fundamental principles that apply organization to arithmetic in general. Part Three explains the

of the subject and the Eiethods of teaching the various topics

which are included in the textbooks of arithmetic in general

use.

The authors express the following conception of

M has testing in arithmetic! In arithmetic the testing process ability two distinct functions. One Is the measurement of the solve to perform arithmetical operations or the ability to Page 5

arithmetic problems • The other function is concerned with finding out the epeciflc difficulties which each pupil is encountering in hie work. The second function is analytical and diagnostic in character

In treating the subject of drill , the authors strongly emphasize the necessity of "intelligently directed practice". In other words, careful planning of drill to fit the needs of the individual pupils. In order to carefully difficulties of plan these drill or practice ses8ions t the

the pupils must be determined by carefully planned diagnostic

tests.

A careful study was made in ..inneapolie of pupils who«ere weak in the fundamental operations of arithmetic as

revealed by the results of standardized tests. It was found

that in many cases the difficulty ras due to faulty habits of

procedure in solving simple arithmetic examples and problems.

The author saysi "The faulty habits of individual the pupils are ordinarily not detected by the teacher when

entire class works as a unit, and they cannot be discovered

from examination of the test papers. Diagnostic tests will

always reveal certain pupils who are below their grade in best ability. The problem before the teacher is to make the

use of these findings." study gEaeji &» X&m (a) This is a detailed study of all kinds of tests and standard- measureniente for teachers. The author presents the " ) Page 6

ized tests and methods of analysis in a clear and precise manner.

The author* s main conclusions in regard to testing

in arithmetic are as follows:

1. The teacher's main objective in testing in

arithmetic is to provide guidance for teaching. "The marking

of numberless sets of papers once looked upon as a moral duty

has probably interfered with teaching more than any one factorj

and it has failed to provide much in the way of needed

guidance."

2. Testing is a distinct aid to the competent teacher.

"The scoring of 6t

formation about the general status of individuals and par-

ticularly of the class as a whole than would be poerible from

merely reading the tabulated results.

3. Only when the teacher is in possession of the

weaknesses and difficulties of the pupils can he hope to do

effective remedial work.

( 1 ^tudy ..lUiaa . Barley ^nd uarion L . >ac^ouald

This is a clear and precise treatment of the stand-

ard practices in teaching. In the chapter devoted to testing

the following principles are emphasized!

1. Give inventory tests to determine what the

learners already know of the unit to be taught or how they

have already mastered certain skills.

2. Give diagnostic tests to determine the needs or

lacks of the learner. The results of such tests indicate )

Page 7

strengths or weaknesses, "In arithmetic it is something to know that a pupil or a class ia weak in long division; it is far more to know in Just what phase of the process the weak- ness lies."

3, The test papers should be corrected by the teacher, "Although scoring papers takes time, it repays the teacher to do this himself because only in this way can he get a picture of the accomplishment of each learner,"

4, The teacher should so tabulate the resultB that the number of pupils failing in each item may be indie ted, thereby revealing the strengths and weaknesses of the teaching as well as the units or processes that nay need further atten- tion,

fttudy b£ Professor £ W, Reagan (V This study deals with the fundamental principles of teaching and is designed to acquaint prospective teachers with the nature and meaning of teaching, the major problems encountered in the classroom, and various Instructional pro- cedures that superior teachers have found to be productive. The chapter devoted to the measurement of the re- sults of teaching emphasizes the following points about the use of diagnostic tests:

1, Diagnostic tests reveal the specific weaknesses of pupils in a given subject or portion of a subject.

2, To make * diagnosis of the weaknesses of the pupil, it is necessary to test hin in detail in each of the fundamental processes. Page 8

3. Educators are placing increased emphasis on diagnostic teating as a phase of teaching. "It is obvious that the teacher cannot assist pupils in overcoming their weaknesses unless he first ascertains what these weaknesses are,

jStudy bv Sdwla £. Ljde, (fs)

This intensive study analysts the instruction practices in mathematics in a selected group of schools all over the United States. A wide variation in subjects taught and study outlines was found. The chapter devoted to research and experiment emphasizes the following facts t

1. It is only through careful tooting that diag- nostic and remedial work of the proper kind can be applied to individual cases.

2. "In most city schools attempting work of thi6 character, even where a department of research exists, the work of testing is independent of that department."

3. Difficulties which teachers seem most often

to encounter concern the slow groups of pupils. "Specific

suggestions which may aid teachers in this connection are

lacking in most outlines."

4. "iit Houston, Texas, fifty pages of the junior

high school outline are devoted to diagnostic and remedial The practice in the four fundamentals of arithmetic." author Btrongly advises the use of such a practice. swell and Lenore John G&) ; tudy py a. T. Bu This intensive study of pupils' weaknesses in the Page 9

four fundamental operations of arithmetic was made in specific Chicago. In addition alone, a list of thirty-three difficulties, from errore in combinations, counting, adding by carried numbers last, to forgetting to add, was revealed namely, these teste. The other three fundamental processes, alarming subtraction, multiplication, and division, showed an

number of specific difficulties also.

ptudy by Pr_._Ojay_ M* Ei^eon, (9)

Announcing the results of an experiment made as a children in the Greater P. (U A. project among 17,000 school education at Boston Area, Dr. Guy &• Wilson, professor of American educa- Boston University, declared today before the simplest of tional Research Association that "even in the seven, tests given in arithmetic, children in grades six, would be and eight have not attained a proficiency which acceptable in any business office." Load The research project VU entitled "Corrective Grades lx beven, and in the Fundamentals of .arithmetic in 9 in the metro- Sight in 15 Representative Towns and Cities politan Boston ^rea. w ascertain He said that the study was undertaken to seven and eight in the number of children in grades six, corrective work representative towns and cities who need

in the simple fundamentals of arithmetic. fact that The results seem to re-emphasize the schools without children apparently can go along through the I age 10

being particularly noticed or taught by the teachers," the Boston University School of education professor continued. "It becomes apparent that teachers do not grasp the problem; do not see what children are doing, or if they to do anything about it. do see, are helpless when it comes A are given to loute procedure is followed $ so many examples be worked out} the answers are cheeked right or wrong, and

the teacher does not know what the child has done to get

the answers. n

It will be noted, upon inspection of the results

of these studies, that all of the authors believe in the practice of using diagnostic tests in the teaching of arith- tests in metic, while none of them refer to the use of these all have the teaching of agricultural arithmetic, and that weak- emphasised the value of these tests in diagnosis; the

nesses of the pupils.

The fact that so utany studies along similar lines a new have been made proves that the problem is not wholly agri- one, but so far no one has applied this practice to stated, cultural arithmetic Leaching, .aid, as previously pupils the effect of these tests upon the progress of the is evident has not been thoroughly recorded. Therefore, it along that there is a definite neei for further research

these lines. Page 11

CHAPTER III

Statement of Procedure

General statement of Facte Concerning This study

The problem which has been undertaken in the preparation of this thesis, then, is to find out whether or not diagnostic tests, followed by drill in the funda- mental processes, should be used in the teaching of agri- cultural arithmetic. In other words, to show that, even in the decidedly practical vocational mathematics teaching, the weaknesses of the pupils must be carefully analysed and corrected by carefully planned drill periods before suc- cessful solution of problems related to agriculture can be secured,

Lide, in hie "Instruction in Mathematics" ( 5) says: "While many abuses have been committed in the use

of tests, too much emphasis cannot be placed upon the use of tests to center the attention of teachers upon the needs of pupils and the necessity of remedial measures."

The problem in this case has been limited to

students of the four year course group, namely, those pupils who have reached fourteen to sixteen years of age, and in

some cases, at least, have had mathematical difficulties

in the public school system. Consequently, they have been can guided to this vocational school with the hope that they fit themselves to earn a living in agriculture. Page 12

I

The Be students have been grouped , as nearly as possible, according to their abilities as shown by a series

of agricultural background tests as well as the intelligence

tests used for oompari«on in this study. The freshmen are usually divided into three sections

which are classified alphabetically according to their ability.

The IA section has the highest ability and the IC eeotion the HA and IIB two divisions of sophomores are usually lowest ability* The A selected in the same manner, but the partial elective schedule

of courses does not permit as accurate an ability grouping in

arithmetic and other related subjects as in the freshman year. description of teata given

All entering students in the r.ssex County Agri-

cultural school are given the -rray Alpha and the Kent-Shakow

Intelligence teste during the first week of school.

The Army Alpha Battery ie composed of a set of eight

teste which are given in the following order: 1, I imple al Reasoning; Choosing Correct Directions j 2, Arithmetic^ 3,

Answers; 4, ;>ame and Opposite Words; 6, Mixed Sentences; Information. 6, Number Series; 7, essential Property; and 8, and The standard time limits are observed, and forms five seven are used in alternate years. twenty The Arithmetical beaconing test is composed of

problems which are arranged in the order of difficulty. 24 The Kent-Fhakow Battery, found on pages 18 to Hospital, was compiled by Or. Grace h. Kent of the Danvers state eets Hathorne, MaeBachueetts. The test forme are made up in . Page 13

and are given In the following order t 1, Hard Directions}

2, Information; 3, Similarity! 4, Essential Property; 5,

Essential Difference; 6, Arithmetical ;leasoning| and 7, sentence Completion. Each test is given with a time limit of two minutes* After time has been called for the last of the eeven tests, the lead pencils are laid aside and the red pencils are given out. The student© are allowed as much time as is necessary to complete all teste. This procedure allows scoring with and without time limits*

The Arithmetical Reasoning test is composed of sixteen problems arranged in order of difficulty. This test has been evaluated by the following two methods? 1, sixteen items, with a two minute time limit, unweighted, one point each. 2, Sixteen items without time limit are weighted as two points follows t One point each for problems 1 and 2; each for problems 3, 4, 6, 6, 7, and 8| three points each for each for problems 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, and 14; and four points problems 16 and 16. In October, 1&33, all students in the sophomore

arithmeU.c classes of the ~ssex County Agricultural ~chool by tn e autn or were given a group of seven diagnostic tests/| These teste were taken from the standard Service arithmetic < 4 )

and were given in the following order. 1, Whole lumbers; lumbers; Percentage; 2, Fractions; 3, Decimals; 4, Denominate 6, limits are indicated 6, Interest; and 7, mensuration. The time on these tests which are found on pages 25 to 34 . Page 14

Those teste were analyzed and the re suite and ffafe* nee see recorded on master sheets similar to the ones found on pages 30 to 41 • The students In the I IB seotlon aere drilled, for about ten minutes at the beginning of each class period, on their .neoses as s.own by these tasts* The remainder of each period was devoted to the solving of agricultural arithmetic problems. Sach studerct was require to keep a notebook in which *ere kept rules on addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division, as *ell as general rules for solving agricultural arith* metis problems* Individual assistance was given to each pupil, as far as possible, to correct the weaknesses in drill as well as in problem solving. In some cases, special assignments were given to individuals on fundamental weaknesses.

The students of the IIA seotion were not allotted any time for drill on fundamentals, and the entire class periods were devoted to the solving of agricultural arithmetic problems, Hlaeh student was required to keep a notebook, which contained only the general roles for solving these problems.

Individual assistance was given to each pupil, as far as possible, to correct weaknesses in problem solving, but no special effort was made to correct the isealcnessas shorn in the diagnostic tests*

st;iden%s were given In tiaroh 9 1934, all sophxiore the first four diagnostic tests again* The results were recorded on the master sheets as before. Time did not permit

the remaining tests to be given. Page 15

In October, 19o4, a group of eight revised tests, as shovm on pages 35 to 38 , were given to all sophomore students in the following ordert 1, Addition; 2, Subtraction;

3, ilultiplicat.ionj 4, Division; 5, Denominate lumbers; 6,

Fraction Decimal Per Cent Equivalents; 7, Interest; and 8,

Mensuration, The time limit3 arc indicated on each test.

The tests were analyzed and tho results recorded in the same manner as in 1933,

The same procedure was used as with last year's

sections, except that the HA group wa3 used for the drilled

section and the IIB group as the check section*

In March, 1935, the name tor.ta were given to all

sophomore students and the results wore recorded in the usual

manner.

In October, 1934, the original group of diagnostic

tests was given to all freshmen students. These were analyzed

and the results recorded in the usual manner.

The students in the IB section were drilled on their

weaknesses in the same manner as the sophomore students, and

the Ia and IC sections wore used as check groups.

In October, 1936, the group of revised diagnostic

testa was given to all sophomore students in the same order

as in 1934, As time did not permit the re ten ting of all the

freshmen in 1934, it seemed advisable to compare the results

of the tests given in the freshman year with those given at

the beginning of the sophomore year. These tests were i Pagv 1G

analyzed and the results were tabulated in the usual isomer.

Consequently* there seemed to be no need of testing this same group of students a^ain*

In October, 193G f the group of revised diagnostic tests was given to all sophomore students in the same order as in previous year®. The tests were analyzed and the results tabulated in the usual mnner#

It seemed advisable to try to eliminate the factor of group variation in ability, so the two sections were rotated in the following manner

The IIA group was used as the drilled section in addition, and the 118 group as the check section. In sub- traction the groups were reversed. To aid In tabulation, the IIA group was used as the drilled section in both multi- plication and division. The groups were reverted again in denominate numbers and in fractional decimal per cent equiva-

lents. Finally, the IIA group was used as the drilled section

in both interest and mensuration.

The procedure was the same as in previous years, 1*6 except that the groups were^, tested at tho end of each drill

period of approximately four weeks* The results were again

recorded as in previous years. Description o£ Criteria

diagnostic . , , The revised, tests used in this study are not standard.

ized tests, but it seemed advisable u> cut down the time used

in testing, due to the restricted time allotted to arithmetic. Page 17

However j the clasB time allotted to arithmetic was the same for all sectioned averaging about three forty-minute periods weekly daring the freshman year and about two forty-minute periods weekly during tihe sophomore year* Consequently*, only one test was given at the beginning of each period*

While it is common knowledge that teachers' marks are extremely unreliable, it was decided to inaKe comparisons of the quarter marks of each group during the freshman and sophomore years* There are so many factors which enter into the quarter marks that in most cases the marks are lower than the abilities shown by the diagnostic tests. For example*, all sophomore students &re given assignments based on class

work | and if these assignments arc not handed in on time the corresponding work is discounted in proportion to the tardi- ness* In most cases the assignment papers were kept by the teacher until the majority of them had been handed in, and when they were returned to the pupils a new assignment was required of the delinquents* This was done to avoid cheating*

Hie freshman marks were recorded by two or three different instructors while the sophomore Mtttta were all recorded by the author. Taken with theae facte in mind, the murks may serve as a partial basis for cougarison of pupil progress* With your pencil make a dot over any one of these letters

F G H I J, and a comma after the longest of these three words: boy mother girl Then, if Christmas comes in March, make a cross right here but if not, pass along to the next question, and tell where the sun rises If you believe that Edison discovered America, cross out what you just wrote, but if it was some one else, put in a number to complete this sentence: "A horse has feet." Write yea,

is or not and no matter whether China in Africa ; then give a wrong answer to this question:, "How many days are there in the week?" Write any letter except g just after this comma, and then write no if 2 times 5 are 10

Now, if Tuesday comes after Monday, make two crosses

circle here or else a square here ; but if not, make a here Be sure to make three crosses between these two names of boys: George Henry. Notice these write two numbers: 3, 5. If iron is heavier than water,

if iron is lighter write the the larger number here , but smaller number here Show by a cross when the nights are longer: in summer? in winter? Give

the correct answer to this question: "Does water run uphill?"

and repeat your answer here Do nothing

skipped the preceding here (5+7= ), unless you the question; but write the first letter of your first name and

of this line: last letter of your last name at the ends l Fage 19

Draw a litie 'Jtt&l&r i£*e wcn3 ihi.t makes t:„u sentence true

Kterk j\ust o:i.. wort! in each 13 ne • Sample: Maple is a Kind of >ug cloud metal tree

1. America was discovered by Balboa Cabot Columbus DeSoto

2. A receiver is a part of a chair painting piano telephone

3. Thunder usually comes with hail sunshine lightning snow

4. Cheese comes from milk nuts vegetables eggs

5. A radiator is a part of a chest desk roof automobile

6. Thanksgiving comes in April February November December

7. The number of inches in a foot is 9 12 36 too

8. Bears live in dens dugouts houses kennels

9. The sun rises in the north south west east

10. Leather is obtained from birds animals fishes trees

1 1 . Chicago is in Illinois California Ohio Vermont

12. A swan is like a pigeon pheasant goose quail

13. Paris is a city in Germany France Italy Russia

14. A... wolf is a kind of a cat cow lynx dog

15- The iris is a part of the foot eye hand nose

16- Jerusalem is in Austria India Kamchatka Palestine

17. Copperhead is a kind of a bird coin *snake turtle

18. Bricks are made of clay stone tar wood

Primaries are connected with baseball elections farming glasswork

20* Pasteur is the name of a merchant musician priest scientist

21. Gunpowder was invented by Americans Europeans Chinese Indians

22. Chess is played on a court board gridiron links

23. "The Merchant of Venice" was written by Shakespeare Scott Spenser Schiller

24. When it is summer here it is winter in China Turkey Australia Siberia

25. The law of gravitation was discovered by Ari s to tl e Newton Coperni cus Bacon „, £age 20 Draw a l^e under the word that makes the sentence true. Mark just one word in erch line- Sample: Quiet means most lik noisy quite still talkative

1 . Y-Iptu means most like bak e ho t nice en ow 2. Afraid means most like courage defray emotion fearful 3. Sickness means most like doctor health illness kindness 4. Begin means nost like commence desist erase stop 5. Sleep means most like awake bed lull s lumber 6. Old means most like beard gray ancient youth 7. Often means most like after frequent never times 8. Polite means most like courteous elite gentleman sulky 9. Wisdom means most like ages knowledge ignorance kingdom tO 1 Alert means most like desert drowsy eyesight keen It. Frank means nost like candid cranky ta c i turn zea 1 ous 12.. Sly means most like slip spy stealthy straight

13. Eminent means nost like cellar illustrious imminent unknown

14. Recline Deans nost like decline hermit move rest

15. Contend means nost like content straggle peace tender

16. Help means most like hinder house problem assist

17. Pretty means most like face ugly handsome lady

18. Sharp means nost like edged cut dull razor

1; 9. Stiff neans most like pliable unyielding stand tiff

20. Failure means most like attempt life success defeat

21. Gentle means most like dental rough mild right

22. Broad means most like short narrow heavy wide

3. Cruel means nost like ruthless duel humane true

4. Surly means most like curly genial crusty sure

5. Nomad means most like monad wand erer non i na 1 s e 1 1 1 ed

6. Connand means most like order of fi cer commend obey . Page 21 Draw a line under the word that makes the sentence true. Mark Just one word in each line.

Sample A man always has food glasses head shoes

A river always has boats fishes logs water

A cat always has ball fur kittens ribbon

A house always has roof fireplace paint porch

A sled always has bells horses runners ropes

5, A dog always has kennel master license nose

A tree always has leaves roots fruit nuts

7. A kitchen always has cupboard mi rror table floor

0. An auto always has cushions speedometer wheels windows

9. A library always has books chairs magazines tables

10- A shoe always has buttons sole lacee lining

t. A fire always has coal wood heat paper

2. A snake always has legs poison rattles skin

3. A hill always has birds brooks height grass

%, A box always has cover sides hinges nails

5. A school always has pupils blackboards desks maps

6. A chimney always has bricks opening ivy smoke

7. A door always has hinges knocker lock top

8. A garden always has plants flowers vegetables weeds

9. A chip always has sail engine stern anchor

(0. A reservoir always has fi shes cont ents sand fence spines stomach Il . A fish always has scales speckles

A rowboat always has oars keel bottom rudder

3. Wood always has knots grain pitch bark

A leopard always has cubs prey spots darkness 5. A grotto always has cavity fissures pools A trunk always has lock handles weight strap . .

Mark 1ust one word in each line. t carrot peach pear Samples : apple bitter sour sweet white

supper 1 breakfast dinner grapefruit parlor stage 2 . bedroom kitchen

3- geography reading school spelling

4. camera flute piano violin

5- cow dog sheep tiger

6. box drawer field room Wilson 7. Lincoln Pershing Washington 8- beer grape Juice lemonade orangeade potatoes 9- bread candy meat stockings 10. boots shoes slippers lake river sea 1 1 island

12. hop jump skip walk tall 13- long loud short worm 14. mouse rabbit rat magazine newspaper 15- book letter shingles 16. bricks concrete whisper yell 17. cry shout sofa table 18. bepoh chair handle valise 19. bag basket sleep work 20. recline Fe st goose hen swan |.| > duck stovepipe fire smokestack 22 . chimney

• oriole robin 23- canary lark steel wood 24. coal paper Florida Maine Ohio 25. Boston tree woods 26. forest grove Copyright, 1931, by C. H. Stoeltii .E-Arith-K-S 3l ppge £5

Name

Find the answers as quickly as you can, and write them on the dotted lines.

miles does it 5" 1. If a car travels 30 miles in an hour, how many i travel in one-half hour?

2. If you buy 4 notebooks at 5 cents each and give the clerk a half-dollar, how much change do you get?

miles, many gallons would 3. If a gallon of gas lasts for 10 how ^ be used on a 200-mile trip?

and pay 2 dollars for the use of a 4. If 8 boys club together ^ room, how much should each pay?

each having 2 berths. If 80 berths 5. A boat has 50 staterooms, ^ are taken, how many berths are left unused? much 6 If a single trip cost $1.50 and a round trip $2.50, how of two singles? is saved by taking a round trip ticket instead

visitors and a teacher. 7. In a class of 32 members, there are 2 If 5 students are absent, how many persons in the room?

6 oranges at 50 cents per 8. A girl had 75 cents. If she bought dozen, how much money did she have left?

you are to feed 4 9. If there are 4 sausages to a pound, and people who can eat 3 sausages apiece, how many pounds would you buy?

pencils cost? 10. If 2 pencils cost 5 cents, how much will 10

will it take him to 11. If a man walks 4 miles an hour, how long walk 7 miles?

much will he save 12. If a boy saves 10 dollars each month, how in 2 years?

morning until 11 at 13 A movie theatre is open from 11 in the are night. If each performance lasts 2 hours, how many given in a day?

will 5 yards cost? 14. If 2 yards of cloth cost 50 cents, how much

are cut out. How 15. In a 150-page magazine, pages 31 to 40 many pages remain? keg weighs 10 16 If there are 50 nails to a pound and the empty pounds, how many nails in a keg weighing 110 pounds I Copyright. 1931. by C. H. Stoelting Co. U-F—Sen-K-S ^age 24

ame Only one word in each space,

trees. 1 Apples grow t A squash larger a potato.

and the cat up a ; The dog chased the ,

them. 4. Hens lay ,and we

freezes m winter. | ice in summer, and

of Stoves made iron, tables are

and are made of glass.

the floor. A broom is for

Automobile are of rubber, filled air,

in the Most of us to bed at and get

at night ; but people who

have to in the daytime,

If we downstairs rapidly in the » we

likely to

A cube has sides and eight

begins It a sultry day July. Suddenly the

woman to blow, a burst of is heard. A

as is wheeling a carriage walks as

she can, so as to get before it begins to i.uxMro&irEo nsf i*t arms mjmsfts, ^ age m Addition Time 4 Min. Dlreotlottfi am ojpylng atianaver 3oasit>l© by .laoing /our v .'.!* t > • ^ ,i ol3.-i f,hi MMplea

i. 3. a. Q

13 Q 29 325 2371 9509 21 137 983 5433 3794 00 ©50 76* 1627 669 34 709 459 e 8206 8034 -JflB SBfl Jtta

6.

3153 7, Copy and addl 3770, 9386, 334, 1002, 156 90S

'4.9 8. Copy

'art f« Subtraction (Tlao: 4 Kin.)

1. % 3. 4, 3.

64369 33928 109300 60929 8 55402 24U6 3.501,9 75344 13762 8Q437

6, ?. 8. 10,

34626 330368 31707 4196C4 50348 703*5 93857

11, I 8/ I |fa 3 13. and aubtiMoi: - 1 11 6504 215431 561*77 14.)fi26346 695; 747 39 19694 U579Q 15«)1<*13>0 - 39996

7. 1. 2. 3* 4, 3, 6. 554 10* 453 43*5 6979 l J967 3796. 810 789 463 1M ~ 231 654 2031

Part 4. CiTialon (Tlaes 6 mi*,) 38)17379" (1) 34)9093 (2) 46)S5355" (8) 297) (4) 105) UU& (3) 18FOT (6) *

II. Diagnostic ?ast la fractions* P&£ e 26

Directions, Oopy only «hen necessary* Answers must be teduoe whan possible*

Part 1, Edition (Tina all >wed 5 rain;) * U 8. »• 7/8 1/2 78 8/3 11 4/9 7 11/16 3/4 1/4 66 4/5 3 l/S 4 7/16 1/8 1/3 » 3/8 5/6 13 8/3 18 1/8 7

6* 6 7/18 pitta 3 1/6 plus 8 8/8 plus 1/8 pltt» 8 8/3 Answers mist ba reduced when oaaible

Part a« subtraction (flae alloead 8 lain.)

1. 8* 3, 4# G. 6*

7/12 79 5/9 23 39 3/8 32 1/4 100 1/3 1/4 13 IS 8/8 ili/L ^ 8/6

7* 98 1/8 * 89 2/3 8« 90 1/8 - 68 1/6 Answers oust ba re used whan possible*

Part 3* multiplication (Tlaat 8 min.)

1. 5/3 X 7/6 8* 3/9 X 13/85 3, 4 X 3/8 X 1/3 4* 7 1/8 X 8/15 5. 5 1/3 X 13/84 6. 11 2/3 13

Answers wet ba reduced when possible* ,

Pert 4* Division (Time: 4 min.) 3/4 1. 3/4 - 1/8 *• «A6 + 8 3. 8 +5 2/8 4. 8 1/3a 1/3 8. 3 1/6 + 1 1/6 6. 18 1/8 ) III. Diagnostic ras* m "aoi ou>». , Page 27 Par* 1, Addition (Tint 2 aln.) anewar oor-eotly. 14 recti ono; ooyy, add and point off aaoh 5.67 ?lua 4 1) ,08 plua 1.001 plua .065 plua ?lua 37.6 plua 16.005 2) 29,65 plua 80 plua 32.01 plua .5 3) 18.125 plua 8.5 plua 6*04 plua 3

?art 2. Suotraotlon (Tlmti Sain. OlrooUonai point off aaah anaaar oorractly. - 7.033 3) 834 - 196.04 1) 6.388 * 4*16 «) 10.7 aln.) Part 3. Multiplication { ?1*»; 3

Dlraotlonai point off aaoh w oi»«p correctly 102.90 1) 138 8) 8.90 3) 10.50 4) ^Oflafi .05 •008

air.) Part 4. Blvlalon ( Tlmat 4

Dlraotlona: point off ©aah answer Correctly. '^ a) 368) W 1) 3.41) W

3) 45)7W 3) ,08857120.0 /ft t-age 28 IV. iii&gnostie rail In Denominate Numbers,

-art 1. Changing forma of Denominate Numbers, Directions: ffrlte on your paper only *hat should be on the blanks. (Tine allowed 4 min.)

*• *• a. ft. in. n 2. 9 . gal. at. 3. 131 min. tt hr. rain, 4. 7 pt. n qt. pt. 5. 16 ft. m yd. ft. 6* 1 ou. yd. M eu. ft. 7. l£ lb. t? 03. 8, bu« pk. , 9. 27 mo. it Jtr. mo. 10. 11 qt. it pk. qt. 11.57 Cu. Ft," Cu, Yd. ou. ft. 12. 43 ou. in. * yd. in. 13. 41&0 lb. " if, lb. 14. 1 ou. ft. " ou. in. 13. 157 sq, in, " 8q, ft, aq. in, 16, 640 " aq, mi. 17, 320 Sq, rd. " Acre 18, 3 sq, mi, " ootlon

Part II, Clmputation with denominate numbers. (Time 4 min.)

Directions: Answers must be in eorreot form.

1. 6ft. 7 in. -ilua 5ft. Sin. plus 1ft, 2in. 2. 21b, lOoz, plus 71b. 6oz. plus 91b, 5oz, 3. 5 pal, 2qt. plus 3qt, plus 2gal« 8yd, plus 3yd. 2ft. plus lly . 1ft. 5. 3br. lOmin. * 2hr, 25-.in. 6. 51b. - 31b. 802. 7. 9yd. Sin. - 8yd. 71n. 3. 3gal. 2qt. - lgnl. 8qt.

Multiply: (Time 2 min.) (9) (10) (11) 2 gal. 1 qt. 4 ft. 7 In, 3 lb, 5 oz. (12) 3 2 8 6 yd, 2 ft. 3

Divide: (Time 2 min,)

13, 3) 6 hr. 21 min. 14, 4) 9 hr, 24 r.'n.

15, 3) 5 lb. Id oz. 16. 3) 3 yd. 2 ft. . .

Percentage Diagnostic teat

Time allowance 30 iain. for entire teat, part I. Praotion-Dacimal-Per Cent Equivalents Directions : Write aa your answer what should be on each blank. "Frao". means common fraction. "Deo." meana decimal.

16 of H (free) of N. 1) 3/4 of * * of N 11) 2/3 * of N '% Of N . 2) It % or R '(dec.) of N 12) 1.32 ' of TTrac) of N 3} k 2/3% oF¥ (frao) of N 13) I '* of H. 4) 1/8 of M £of N. 14) li of N 4535 Of IT "(free) of N. 5) 7% of H (dec) of K 15) of "(free) of N. 6) .0425 of N 0 of 16) 110% F" of N "55 of N. 7) 25* Of H —TTrao) Of N.17) 2/5 "* of N. 8) 130£ of W~~~ Toee) of N • 18) .0* of N~ 4i* of N (dec) of N. 19) 4.5* of fT "(dec) of K. 9) * "8 " of S of N» 0) 3/10 Of R * Of K« 20) 5/6 art II. Chooaing Correct Solutiona in Percentage. Directions: Five waya are shown below for working each example. Only one of the method a shown is correct. Do not work the examples simply check (X) the correct aolution.

) Find 4* of 368 388 26827756" .0775^ 1/7 x 368 368 x7 .07

) 43 is what * Of 179? 43 or 179743.00 179 .43)179.00 179 T7¥ x.43 179-43

5) If 64 Is 8% of 100$ of H equals what? 64 x 100 64 64T3350 .08TS4 .00 ,O8TO5oT0ir~ x.C8

4) What number equale N, if 6i* of N - 94?

94 .65784.00 .94785.00 .06575OT0" 94 X6S x.065

cent of 421? 5) 756 is what per 756 X421 786 756 or 4217736" 756-421 421 or 75674151 x421 32T TBI? of 384? 6) What is 11211* Add: 384 1.1857583 H/8 x 384 38471.125 384 1 1/8 118 &

Part III. Computation of Percentage. Directions: Work the examplea and problems tie low. I) Find 5* of 976. 875? 8 ) 140 ia what per cent of 5) What is K, if 83* Of N - $143.08? 4) What is 100^ of an amount if 140* of it - £467.50? Page 50

5) Find 7k% of 508. 6) 142 is what per cent of 497? /) The let. year pupils in a certain school were asked tide questions "suppose you had one hour for review work on the arithmetic topio bout which you feel most uncertain.. On what topic would you vote to spend the hour of drill?" The votes of the pupils are given, below. Express the votes or each topio in per oent:i of the total vote (93ft) writing these per enta in a column. (Garry answers to 2 decimal places.) Topic Number Votes Per Cent

Fractions 1?0

Areas & Volumes 102

Dec ima Is 136 m Percentage 289 Interest 238 — Total 935

1500 minutes a week in sohool, Ijelow ) A first year class spends

is shown how some of this tia* is spent. How many minutes are

used each week for each subject shown? Per Cent ofo Time Number of Minutes Subject Qiven to Subject Qlven to Subject

Science 8 1/3* Arithmetic 12*

English Agriculture 180 they the pupils in a certain school 85%, or 529, reported that ) Of pupils had already started an account at some savinga bank. How many were in the school?

school 93 pupils reported that they did not visit a ) In another the dentist at least once a year. Theae pupils were only 15* of entire school. How many pupils were there in that school?

example was given: 46fi£ of an amount of ) In a percentage test this money « «301.£2. What is the amount of money? ; Wge 31 VI. Interest Diagnostic Tost

(Time allowance 30 minutes)

Part I. Im ortant faots about interest. Directions: underline the one word or phrase whioh makes the true statement in eaoh of the following: Interest ia usually reckoned by the: day; weak; month) three; months; year. Interest is: the amount borrowed; the tjmount paid back; the balanoe; money ©aid for use of money; profit. In the formula i 8 p r t, i means: the interest in money; the interest in per cent; the total amount to pay; the amount loaned; the time. In whioh one of the five problems below would you use the formula r » 1 to find the answer? P a) tfind the interest on ^400 8% to earn ?64? b) If $400 earns 324 interest a year, at what per oent is It invested! o) How long will it take v400 c 8% to earn $64? (d) $400 invested at 7% for 3 years w ill earn how muoh Interest? i») In one year how mush more will 9400 j 6% earn than 3400 at 5%? ;.5nny savins banks pay interest at the rate: 5.'>; l.V£; 3fci; 10 i ka interest table is used to determins: the safety of an investment; the worth of the security; the rate per cent; the interest in money; the principal* The largest rate of interest which you should expect on a "safe" in- vestment is: 8%, 6%. 10%, 18&$, 10$. In examples 8to 12, "prin," means prinoipal. 4& for 8 mo. equals: 8$ of prin,; 4j of prln.; 10% of prin. 24% of prin,; 4/6 or 2/3 of prin,;. 6% for 9 mo. equalst 3% of prin.; 4|r% of prin.; lot of prin.; 54$ of prin. 1% of prln,; ^ , of prin.; Gh of prin.; , 5% for 1 yr. equals: 4$ •* priiM P 15% of prin.; 51% of prin. _ _ , ^ of prin.i 6;> of prln.: . 3^ of 2 yr. 4 mo. equals: 3$ of prin.; •% of prln.; ft* of prin. _ _ H , 0 4 w , of prln,; 3?% of prin.; 23% if prin.i^ , n for 30 day. means: 210;* ?*, of prin.; 7/12 i of prin. Solutions. rt II. Choeaing Correct mmmmmm Directions: do not work the examples below. As your answer, check the solution you would use. Find the interest on $500 «* 6% for 1 yr.

*2 !3L »500 X.06 «X8 MtfS* mo. Find the interest on #800 : 5&% for 1 yr, 6 X .055 x 3/8 :055 $300 X .055 X 1/8 $300 X 3* X 3/2 $300

,055)355

investe if it earns ^>60 a year? » At what rate is $900

00)1535- *To Hfil "Jfe or 90OTO5T- *SL tape 62

4« |800 earned ^70 In a years. Find average rate of interest* 800 x .7 X 8 70 Or a0O)"9000 300 300 35 355" 70 X.7 Wor 300)35 1

yr. mo, fc, find the Interest on 11500 % 5£#for 3 8 1800 X ,0525 X 44 |1S00 x ,0528 x Addt 1500 ^o 32/3

years, .That was the average rate of , |2500 earned $900 interest in 5 interest?

Addt 2500 $8500 x 9 x 5 .3 too 25OT or 32500)130.00 5 900 "~—' ~ 8*500 or asoo)*^ Subtract; 2500 800

art III. Computing Interest. Directions} Work the examples below. Give your answers to the nearest oent or nearest tenth of one per cent.

Find the interest on 0750 • 8* for 6 no, * Find the rate per cent on an investment of ^2000 /toloh earned ?60 in a year. find the int«l»•§«, on $2400 00 4 1/4S for 1 year 3 t.n. Pss |900j»r •» 7% t ^ 3 yr, Find i. p - *1500 « i «. # 127.50 per year, Find r. Find the totef amount to be paid on a loan of #800 7% for 30 da. I* fhioh investment is earning the higher rate? (a) £700 earns 42 yearly (b) §800 earns 149.50 per annum. 6. Find the interest on $8000 0 8 l/<# for 90 Da, VII. Mensuration Diagnostic Test Time Allowance » *iu*i.

Part X*. Vocabulary of llensuration Directions t Write on your papers only the facts which, should he on the blanks*

B

Fig. 1 Pig. 2

1« In Pig. 1 angles M and IT are angles. t h j im 2. Pig. 1 is called a . ._ " 3. 4" and 2» are the ^ ~ " of" Fig. 1, 4. The surface covered by Fig, 1 is called its * _ _ ^ 5. In Pig. 1 # lines A B and C 3> are not only straight Tines'? they are also lines t o each other. Area of Pig. 1 "would "be "expressed in units. 6. . , ., t 7„ Pig* 2 is a triangle.

"2 T>"y - 8, Area of Pig. "is^ound taking 1/2 #f ,, A „ 9 e To find the area cf Pig. 3 we must know the" length of its

10. Angle B A G in Fig. 3 is called a 111) _ angle. a 11. Angle A B C in Fig* 3 is called a (N) . ngle*

12, The volume iff Pig. 4 would be expressed An^ unite. 13, Pig, 4 is #alled a s olid. > 14, Formula for finding r volume "of Fig. 4 is w y 3 ,, , , „ , 43* Line X in Pig. 3 is called a ( n) _ ~

16, Line Y in Pig. 5 is called a " WZZZ I . I 17. Line Z in Pig. 5 is balled the _ » , = s Fac;e 34

Part II* Mensuration Fasts Direetions! Write as your answers the numbers or Words that should he en the blanks 1* 4 in« = f t. 7» 288 sq* in#- t 2, 1 sq, ft,- _sq,, in, 8« 1 eu, ft, - 3. 9 yd. - ~?t, 9# 5i ft, -- ^ -, 4. 1 au, yd, - 9U» ft, 1C, 4 2/3 yd. 5, 17 in, - _ "ft, 11. 2 3/4 ft, mi, 6* 4*5 ft*, - "in, 12, 1 - r 13, DiraensionsDerore being multiplied must be expressed in the unit, Scale "oh a map is 5 ml; 6" representa » 14. V\ L

the , 9 15, The formula A » ab would be used to find \

15, The formula A a ab would be used to find the . . ^ t _ ^ 2 used find the, 17, The formula V er 1 w h would be to

Part JII, Mensuration Problems, J Directions: Solve the following seven problems

1. Area of Pig, 1 « ? 2, Find area of Pig. 2

w 3* Perimeter of Pig, 3» t 4, Area of Pig, 4 7

7 i 5, In Pig, ! «, Pind th« In Pig, sq, yd. base 4 1 sq, in, volume of A af base q 14 ft, V 1 h f 6 in, V « ¥ Pig. * h * 15 »

4CT

I

it

'i {-4

7 Pig. 5 Pig* 4 Pig. = = -£age 35

Diagnostic Teat

answers must be reduced Directions i Copy only when necessary, when possible.

Part I Addition Tlme 9 Mln » 1. 263 2. 23 5/8 3. 6 7/12 4- 3 l/6^fi 5/842 2/3 367 19 1/3 548 62 1/5 4, 29 .65 +• .02 +.065+ 4 + . 5 = 192 87 1/2

5* 6 7/l2ft.+ 5ft5in, + lyd.lOin. =

6. 5i gal.+ 1 gal. 3 qts.+3 qts 1 pint +3$ qts.*

7. 2i hrs.+ 35min-M hr;20min<. +55 seconds

8,, 2 acres +-240 sq* rds^+f acre -j- 40 sq„ rds.=

4- . + pks . ^ 9 . 2i bu. 3 pks . + 3 qts 2i

10. 4.5 rtL.+ 5 yd+3 rd. 2 ft.+- 5,25rd. Part II Subtraction Tiiae-6 Uin - 14 2/3^ 1» 21,000 2„ $138.42 3. 20 3/5 .18,729 - 11.79 4, M - 8i = 5. 24/005 - 11.146 s.

6. 6i gal. - 1 gal 3 qts.

7* 4i hrs. - 1 hr. 20 min.^ 2 acres 40 sq. rds - 120 sq. rds.^.

9* 3.5. bu. - 3 pks, 5 qts* ss - ML 3.75 rd. 3 yd. - 2 rds. 6 ft.

1 = £age 36

Diagnostic Test

Directions* Copy only when necessary. Answers must be reduced when possible.

Part III Multiplication Tlme-lOMin

1. 996 2» 37,06 3. 1.05 4. 5 5/8 x 1/3 = 625 3g.2 .005 5. 2/3 of 4i -

6. 2 gal. 1 ct. 7. 5 ft.9in. 8* $396.00 4 3 7-2/Qw

9. 40 rds. x 16"£ yds. —

10. 20 ft. x 16 ft. x 8 ft.

Time 8 .. Part IV Division Label ans . correetly 2.25"*" 1. 56) 183,172 2. 450). 1080 3 « w075]

9 4. 7 2/3* A = 5. 3 6. 3 ) I9k+ g/jj _ 9 hrs.l5min ?

7, 4 lbs. 6 Ofc -r' 7 = 8. 5 rd. 4 yd. 6 ft ._

9, 8 ft*t 96 sq. ft. 10. 25 sq. yd. 1 125. §tt. yd. « = Page

Diagnostic Test

Directions; Write on your paper only what should be on the blanks

Part V Denominate Numbers

1. 35 in = ft. in. B. 53 in a* yd. in. 2* 11 qt. * gal. qt, 9* 37501bs. - T. lb. 3. 141 min. m hr. min. 10. 1 cu.ft* - cu. in

4. 9 pt. * qt. pt. 11. 167 sq.in. sq.ft. sq.in c 5. 17 ft. m yd. ft* 12. 320 sq % rd* «s Acre 6. 1 ou.yd. cu.f t. 13. 640 acres = Sq. Mi. 7. 9 pk. m bu# pk. 14. 6000 ft. = mi. f.t. 15. 36 oz* = lb. oz

Part VI Fractional-Decimal Time-3 L!in. Percent Equivalents

1. f of H = # of N.

2. 6£ % of N = (dee.) of N,

3, Z5% of N m (frac.) of I»

4. 130 ^ of IT ss (dec, ) of N.

5. 2/3 of N = (#) of

6. 4,5^ of K =7 (dec.) of W.

7. 3^ of N *s (frac.) of N.

3« 30 of N of N.

9, # 06 of N « ^ of N

10, li of N *c % of N Rage 38

Diagnostic Test

Part VII Interest *4nt 10 Will

Directions: Compute the following problems,

1. Find the interest on (,750 @ 6% for 6 months, 2. Find the average rate per cent on an investment of $2000 which earned $180 in 3 years. 3. T $900 r 1% t 3 yr. Find i 4. P £1500 % $127. 50 per yr. Find r. 5. I $175per year r 3~^. Find P

Part VIII tt^m 0 Utn

Mensuration Facts and Formulas

la. The area of a plane surface is expressed in units.

2* The volume of a solid is expressed in units.

3* Dimensions "before "being multiplied must be expressed in units

4a The formula V.r= 1 w h is used to find the .

5. The formula for finding the area of a right triangle is_ 6» The formula for finding the area of a trapezoid is _

7 # V = is the formula for finding the

8a> The formula for finding the area of a circle is

9a V m 4/3 TTR 3 is the formula for finding the

10. The formula for finding the area of a ring is i 1 .

\\ | Jilll !|| i !!:« 1 | ! f f I IS] %

1 1! i P i i ii s 8 I* P il ft isa 2

p HK»ojo Gj o»w cj o cHoiho <4tfttp 0100 cd wcd omcihi^^oj n Addition

tt***Mti I M jf^ d y M MM I :*-r* lift***. HHJfH * HHH W W

* - 4 jjj£-{3 f ] I I I i j H r- jWttltlnli- ; uu h» M H HH H H H M H H H H HM p*»**^"bati ->n Htf*o H-a jricn a c* aa qOftj «a t&o qH*| a CM* of <* *p dp q tf» pj to

• *4 «sm -4 1* «j a «#o «a o> c*ivj n; <» m o j mica cfa 0 ap

- 1 1 j j j I \ f \ i-v^-- ponofli^ f 1 — -0 --^ f Numbers ?i ! ^ Ssi P gb^oid si siwG^- «

j* aw* • ^ 1 ^-«»-| ? 1 1 j ! f €-hooetng f \ f H f

f I ] \ ] I j I f I I a

j ] | iB%»re«-t in 4»\ I t t I I I f I Hi U HjO vitA ri* wj H Hh cajw *jtt> ciiH*

! t.«r-H| I I { f j I I j j j \ t i f "'^'•S't'nt'l'IW'"

j j j { i I j I !-0ho99lng ^ w f I i ^ t !w d* dto h!w witR H^Ho> w!* wi^ wki> Htn «i<* Hat. -olu #

j j W^j j I :Cfy«iputtnp f f { f c*^ ?do-: o^c»' hU ojw *«;to frtowpi o^#»juicitei*;(& iln tor oats I

I j $ ) ) Natation i k«i ) I I 1 I j ) ^°«l>tilary a *> b» oo> Siw «lto sika o^ub« «bi cjoc o^wN

1 1 \ { 1 j j j fesnau-ration \ faw I i h

st Hj*fc I i° h c*^ oib h jH riWO cba wbo nii o»iw »l> »|w whhm! Uonsurat i on

te t minor I k fe b b !g t b b b b b t ig _ * £uab*r W in W in in !h Sh Ih h W W ^ in I i I I K' s i I n p i ^ I n f^*^

I j I I tr f I i I i H I IHfli m r L if L * r l» i L « if I? L isotion ** ;oB i<- ! 1 h w m 6 F P p P p P p Izzl ?« 1 j- i isanJc ^ 1 1 i H i i I i i j r f In kass 0 I i L . L in h \to w0 mm ^ j H H f» p » |C |C ^ p jS |M » I J J

.i 1... ; Page 40 TlBLS Kg It SO^SSNTS OH 3RH0R3 OF DIA0N03TIC TB3TS (see next page for keyj

Bachalder ^eak on Ils.d; IIIa,b*o; IVb.a; 7; VTa,b t c f di Vlla.d^ej VIIIb,oj IXbjOj S and XX

Bellsood ?eak on Ia,d; Ha,b t c f d} IIIb,d; I7a,b,o,d; V, 7Ia,b,o,d; 7IIa,b,o,d,e; Villa, b, o,d,e; IXa,b,o; X and XI

Bin^iam -feak on IIa,dtIIIdj ITa,b,oj VIb,o,d; 7IIo,d| 7IIIa,b,o,f; IXa,b,o; X and XI

Cameron Careless on II; Illand I7a v b f c,d} eak on 7IIIa,b,o,f; 7, Yla,b,o,d; IXa,b,o| X and XI

Chambers C. Slow on IIoj weak on IIIa,b; IVb,d; V, VIa,b,o,d; VIIa,b,o,e; VTIIb,o,oj lXb,aj X and XI

Chambers M. /oak on I7a,bj Via; 7IIb,o,d,e,f j 7IIIa,b,o,e,' £ia,b,o; t and XI

^stwood .Vsak on IIa t dj Illa.d; Careless I7d; V, 7Ia,b,o,d; 7IIb t o,d,e,f j VIII ,,0} IXa,b,oj X and XI

i>, Ford teak on Ia f o t d{ IIb,d| IHa f o,d; I7b.d| Vl"a,b,o,d; VIIb t o,d,e,f; VIIIa,b,e t et TXa,b,ot * an* ST

Kurd

7IIb,o,d,e,f j VIIIb,e,f } IXa,b,oi X and XI

Jones eak on la) IXa,b; IIIa»b,a,d; Ivb,o,d; 7 # VIa,b,o,d; VIIa,b,o,d,e,f; VIllb,o,d,e; TXa,b,of X and XI

Marshall tfeak on IIa,o,dj lHa,dj IVb,o,d| V, VIa,b,e,d; , Xanci XI 7IIa # b,o,d,e f l | 7111b,e 9 a»f i lXb 9 o;

quina Very weak on I, II, III. one IVa,b,o,d; V, 7Ia,b,o,d; X VIIa,b,o,d,e,f % VIIIb,ft,d,f; IXa,b,c; and XI

Robinson Slow IIIc,d| teak on IVej V, 71 a,b,e,d} 7IIb,o,d ,e,f 7IIIb 9 o; IXa,b,oj X and XI Sorlbner -lo. in Ia,b,d;

Tataronis Carelwss on lb; »«ak on IIo; I7b,d; 7, 7Ia,b,o,d; Vila, 'o,o, d,e,f; Vlllb,o,e; IXa,b,o; X and XI

tfni taker Careless on Ib,o; teak on Ho; IVb,d; V, 71 a,b,c,d; and XI 7IIa 9 b 9 o,d,o,f | 7IIIb,ej IXa,b,o| X Page 41

TABLE NO. Ill | S J Key to 'rrors of Dia^oetlo Toats

I.. .ADDITION A— .Thole Numbera B—tfr-iotione C--De«3i> >als D—Denominate Numbers

II # *3ttBT1UrriON AjHjCjI'J (sane as I)

III *MOLTirLIC \TI0N A,B,C,r> (aamo as I)

AjBjG^D (same ae I)

V*. FRACTION ZiOQUUO* pS 3QUIVAI. 5TK>

YI* .PP.RC:^X RciCOrn? i-> 0lutir>n» B—Finding 1 of a Given Number C—Pindirr % one vimber is of Another Girei D—Finding a unbar men ti Certain $ is

TII.IT/TJl .^T A—Facts B—leoogniziag Hatea 9* for 2 yrs,-6j for 1 yr. C—Finding Intorast D—Recognizing ^olutiona E—Finding Rates F—Finding Principle vmsMffim KWaum: etc. A—Linear 'tenure B—Squire * C —Cubic " ii—Liquid B—Dry " F—Wal^ita « 0—Time rt

ix..i.iiiNoUiuri&N A—Faots B—Formulas 0--*' In ding Aran and Volumes

X.., Reducing Answer*

;u . djtittL&ro ui TOW 1 42

.30 w n ,9 Ml iff a' f f | H 8 § »1 s H 1 0 IN I 10 ^ P CJ 9 w Hi ; ! 1 w-J CO o c+

c& i o p» 3 1 o d U1 co I o • I i 3 1 i m "j •« i 4 llJl jtHMftt

> O - ! l ; \ 1 ft j { ft } j Addition r : i f i- « 1 i ••• • I> » .)>»• pi....£<

j f^i y H jw -#tf >^o oil* c-i h o>M c*p

' h o«wq» cm o Divl si o*iw oicn o*H sjH siiw hiw oio) ^»i»wH f o hh ^ c - Hi M M HI M H Hi N I Hi Hi h[ K Hi | ^ t h $o coin wi#» bit* Mis* Ctf* hw o^a siPicp* hh * so o»Hup 0*1 o a>*"*T ^ K umber b

iHiMiH^ Lfc* ? L** j 1st; i^rao« Dec. M -*jH 'Op OiO -*jO Oj rffc WP Oto GiO OOO ^ Up Ojlt W N ° % Bauiv.

0, u*o l^i»olv*lo c,i 9 Interoet in »nio oio Hoi [<& a! w c^o cnn i^iw b w H ^ b | NiMH*

?* ! 0* 1 aen to o Total a | *** IP iOi ° Rl i is !• I b o ..; 10 *> p — * a ...||.4jaL \m |Wurob*r In Hi 9 b jo 1* i# j A H 1 ... LJL~:tfl&utt4 I' 4tn. . ^ ..f.Cto.... m j in !h Ih i wanking |cc i Ih pH W M H H in in n | 3#etlon O MB | 1 —r—*N ! i | Ih :H !H \ Wank In a ;H : H m ] n [CiWjUll 1 i ....ha p .Q.... .|jEA...... j j -j £ i

i

...i .....

4....- i I- 7 i • t

!. L Fage 43

« it j u S IS

i a i en

in I u tt \m il a

: O e »! j T

i*> LiS Ft] A Shi- • 01 h

jiubtraotion j

ft** O < < Uf Cj» * Ul H i cation o mii \ |DirtiIoa ?H t* a I a H

! r { *4 *4 m I Denominate i pa «ioo tfurabers 2 • » • H j ai 31. Krao» Deo* < . f '

• t H GJM ^ H W l_. i ° : ;• jUlOf |

™i i luttreet ir |

o

9 TOtll' Store IS H \ OCD .Kuab«r. c to «*• ittemotod m 1

CO -cottons

i in lOK il Kink Cli

si

i i

i i I i i ««•

i

i 4 f . j..

I I

.i j. J •I ifatei Page 44 T4.RX3 no. 7

GQMMBKT3 ON 0? HSVI312 DIAGNOSTIC T8ST3 (see next page for key)

Bowley veak on I, II, III and IVb,o,dj Vb,o; VI. VIIa,b,o; VIIIa,b; 12 and X

Christensen Very weak on I, II and IIIo,d; I7b,o,d; Vb,o; 71, VIIb,oj Villa, 5; IX and X

Conti Vary #eak on I, II, III and IVb,o,d; Vb.oj VI, VIIa,b o| VIIIa,bj IX and X

Foster Weak on I, II, III and IVo.dj Vb,c,e; 7IIb| VHIa.bj IX and X

Preaman 'freak on I, II, III and i'Vbj VI lib; also IX and X

Jfullington Teak on Ibi 7, Land Measure Vlllbj IX and X

Oral'tam Weak on I, II, III and IVe,d; Vb,o,dj 71, Vllb,o; VITIa,b; IX and X

Hayes Slow and 7erv weak on I, II, III and IVo,d; 7a,b,c| VI, Vila, b,oj VIlla,b; IX and X

Lydon Careless and weak on I, II, 1I X »o,d; na,b,c,f; 7lo; 7IIb,e; Villa, b; Jr. &iA r.

Hi coll Week on I, II, I.Hc,d; I7b,c,dj Vb,o; VI, Vllb.o; VI lib j IX and X

Kimmo Careless of work on I end Ildj III and IVb,d; Vo; VI, Vlllbj IX anfl X

Sennia feak on I, II, III and IVb,o,d; Vb,o,ej VI, Vllb.oj Vlllbj IX and X

Sactln • oak on Icj lid; Hid; IVo,d; Vb.oj VIIa,b,oj

VII lb j IX nd X

Sheely /eak on I and IIb,d; III and lVb,dj Vb,o,d; VI, VIIb,o Vlllbj IX and X

3raUh S. Careleaa or week on Ie,dj Hd; II and IVd; VIIa#b,oj VII lb; IX and X

Saolak Careless on I, II, III and IVd; Vlllb; IX

Thompson *eak on II, III and IVb,o,d; Va.oj VI; Careless Vile; VIIIoj IX and* VI, VIIa,b, '.Vhita Very waak on I, II, III and IVo.d; Va,b,oi 0} 7111a, b| IX anrt X

Volfsen Jcak on I, II, III and IVdj 3g,.Miles VI, VHo; Vlllbj IX and X •

TJLBLh. SO. VI

Key to "Srrora of Seviiofi Dldgncmtlo Toots

I ADDITIOW A*-**/holo Numbers B»»?ractions 0— DeoinmlB D~L'cnominate Nurabaro

II . ...SUBTHACTIOS A?B § C t D (»9rao as I)

III. , .ITJLTIPLIG ATIOR A,B,C t D (socio as I)

IV. ...DIVISION A,S,Q,D (same x I)

V. in # TABLE'S l4?>A3tJFtS8 ?C A»-Llxie«r Ueamir E*-3 que.ro " 0 •-Cubic " r—Uquia • S»-Dry H FW?elshto 0—Tlrao yi....FRACTIOH DSOSUL raQSKT ISqUIVALSHTS

VII#..0OM?OTI!IO IHTS3SST A—Finding Interest B~- • T?ato C— Principal

IIX ##K3B3UHATXCff A**?aota Formulas

IX, . • .LABELING AflSffCTS

X. ....Rf- r*tWPTO AHOJfT.aS TO LOfSflT T3TM3 Page 46

CHAPTER IV

PH33 STATION 0? DAT'. OBTAINED

The following table abows the number of puolle tested each year durlne the course of tills study.

TABLE ro. VII jj. g ^ w ^ g

1935 1 9 3 6 Total, 8 1933 1954 , , Arithmetic IA — 16 —- 16 Arithmetic IB 17 — 17

\rlthraetic 10 17 17

Arithmetic IU 14 19 15 16 64

.rithmetio I ID 14 19 ,15, A3 , -Jl "lilT Q3 30 29 175

Diagnostic tests were not given to the freshmen classes teach In 1933, 1935, and 1936 because the author did not

freshman arithmetic classes during these years,

from this point on, data will be presented rirst for the year 1934- 35, work done in the year 1933- '34, seeond for •

year 1936- * 37. third for the year 1935-' 36, and finally ror the dur- Tables VIII, IX, X and XI show all the data obtained with the quarter ing the first year»s testing program, together

marks of the students. interpret the It should be remembered in endeavoring to were excluded quarter marks, that the diagnostic teat scores the fundamental pro- from all marks, furthermore, drill on the year 1934-'3o cesses was not riven to the freshmen except In 0 Pap;e 47 ^ O o HI m S 3 3 £ »3 ^ H lit* ! ffi I i 4 I Pi CD CD CO 3 \l >1 » fli j 3 M 8 3 3 1 o ftif If o o *

! s 5 3 3 3 » i I M H i .^S^*. 0 M H M Score |!g IH 0a [ath Test i • • i 3 § IS 1 to 03 I tH oi i r N IN H Relative K \# IS \m Benlc Anay \ H H j ! * H O [».„. 0> iS I to m W j 8 4$ m ;

j H jRela tlve O © O to o oi m \ « i s |* iRerik

0 H ! Math & ! CD H • H H i H [g(Alpha) • • ii : 1 1 i# ! H ^ O O ^ O ilk jC* C* HI ;fi «0 03 Relative 6 | H Ok o» o> 0» 3 Is » Ofe o o I Rank § H wKent s 3 O g P 2 i© 1 0» Oi 11! o» 8 tO Oi wTest W m ] m t 9 id Relative m in S IK |B 40 iS * Rank B (Matfce) O 55 3 0* j « i *9 i 0* OI £ o g ii !8 I m mm m i it • • Kent i..M.... CD ! i w L jRelatlve I* m S 1 g § i i I Rank Korm o \» L L j Iff m h M K i life o Sk i * j* k * i* P « Kent :: e the [1. tfc i** I 8

.i i a o

i 1 i 3

0) 4k

I- -r

-] 1 i

r

:

: r I : ; : : i

i...... L .i U 1 Pace 48

»-3 3 *8 o i? 2 £ 2 sr i i t a o i o If 8 I f o « M w i

Score {3 M« the 3 s o 8 3 IB S wTeat 3 £ S 3 Relative Rank o s s s 2 w Alpha Relative 2 8 ft Rank wMathe o :a> B ^ Alpha) Relative o Rank

s 3 3 jJKe; 3 1 s s s 8 8 St Relative I to Rank a 8 8 8 8 II aw o jM Relative 8 °> Rank All Kofm O n Kent :.!athe .t 1

I H to CP f o i i d H Pare 49

8-

9 - 0> M Ml > CO M Ml CD c t a an CD t-; <33 a! £ < 0 CD H o O a. « s t* *=5 O 3 5 1 die |to rf CO ^ a (0 OS ^ CO 2! p: HflKB C p O CD 0 o 0) 3 CD O mi 3 3 O C* iC CD O* (0 ct B to I ! o I t3

o* to H H H H* H H Noi SvJ OO S»03 0>lfr t&CR U O rf^O HHWHU> HC-J 01 **-

— ' " — ' ii|*"" yw'o »fr on i»4 h» ! ^ wj"" ^'r^sub t | h> i • 03 aicn *i ci oi «o of OJ tiba doa ^ato to a wqoSj^lotion B iifr iN j* -[ h* I'H i -f pi J H & H V* ! 9 h q w too ifro <»ta 0O> 0 Mui#fw «ifrHw?oc^ m mwfi\ cooation A • tO ^7 >J2 i - Muitipii^

iifr ! i d d I d ^ g h H i I g w r if oo c* ^>3 0»sj a)rd «oo »^ «fr oioi 0C4 ox«frOf09Q> to oooa

•H 1 f H t i W Hi ^""""Dl'Vt'Sl'Bil offlifr^^woiowc^«^c^Qcnaia)(»ifr^toQ»froj

H H- fr4 H i !>iv-'lel-on M j CO •fr U> M W HO» **ifr HO <0 *fr Hifr^l-aH^ H^H __H _ H M o*fr HC>»*frwai o> wo> J 0) h- ill i •-3 Htfrfl^HcM'iw ^ Totals to on 1 Hftw toio» 0*0 O 04 Ho A 01 6 j INS WW o» 8'm Ul W MH DH Off 0* Sir 01 09 id Total© 00 tvpo O 03 03O O C *fr«£ O H -aw to o :« * i oi

I HI to

\ n H i Jh&wt&Vt i 5 04 s CO O ! Hank k

i.. I Relative ^ H jH CO Hank B J ^3 P

i 1st ^3 03 [si i0> m CN Quarter I CD 8 IO O O j 2nd 03 S3 la 03 :uartor H Ol Q H o O i ID

I* i hi 1 - 3rd %\i&t S3 i to a hi a Quarter i to :0 i o p I la o

i lit 8 NX i%3 !Oi SI IS id id 3 i o o o o icn Quarter

! i i -Sad -^ua 10) - Teg a wK IO ?,uartor i

i j

I L •jar w 3rd 5 o o lot 1 iO i* i P quarter iw l 4 x i •I

L ...i. .1 L«, Pane 50 1 t Page 5\m i r 0

5fr I i i ! 2 o I 1 ! f li if • I i Mi If 5 » i » O M 1 i g 18 HP PC i»*3 , 1

•! : 3 i « 14- 141414 j+i4ii- » 1 + i HM +;i + 1 + \ $ en i Addition*

1 H H ; M -4 • 0»Q» CP MOB M A

To i Ad4i%ion : OI to p p p |j HH i it * • M*i -a Hto ooitiao) o&to tooi to w 6h %i ro B SI 4* T H Su bti^c 1 1 oi l4 to 'fi"p|!|»' ji-pf""! f|y ]gpp'*4 'P j-pnt-p- too WH^pwH-H *5m«6m oi* $w03 too© oa?o*toto ciao tdM a> o tion B o> oi oi j ; MttXtlpli- fe- 9 ! lt* i rw H H toe cn en si nsOetion A

! O* in M i ! " | I Uult Ipli- pri t t I ! | ! f i

i • B • i QE)09 Ot 0>0 HOWH rbtHO CA^MCTl rfjk'Nj ^ to oation O to SI ! | P j; i i : i | ; tp | L ..[ . ^Wlaion i • • I 0> HO>^05> t^O) OtO Cli^. cbotM 0>tvjAN>CD

fl» I I I j j""* £jj ^ i ^ivision to j^ii* **"f • !©CD05 t$tO (jfyfr Q*fr 0rf> *H «H ^OJOi ^MJ)A0D si*^ o oi eft o b SI 01 j 3 Total 9 •aw tlnra Oito Olto O U oe>oo h?S too « A Total OS o> H Oih ^ w taw 8 03 030 to w no 6 to iok Ok i .j i. ftelativo it '''lit to ito to CD O St OI i to to Rank A i *> l 8 t 4 Pel at ire 3 ; H CO H to i to i to to M a to oi m -a OI ;M Hank B i i CO i • { i lat i en if m s <0 SI flarter • ! | 3 OI o O O o o 3 i i : .j i- 4- 8nd H i „ 3 m Qua rtcr fi tO • iO !o O j o § 13 3 3 o S g, g B I 8 I 1 3rd & H 00 si 0> ^ m ftuarter tO • o» w to sis o ;o OI o Oi iOl o o>

! 1 1*1 OI i r- SI oi 1 Ot to i si i ; oo Quarter i tn

i OI o is i oi OI IO en o o o OI •§ ! find m SI i o g} IS 18 S 5 ioi io o o o CxUe rter

i. -4 3rd ! SI CD j • OI oi o ! iO 5 o o o o o • Quarter * i v 4. ..j.... f r-

.i. 7 j? f

S TT : irs: : i i I I ..1—L I J !

.j 2

to

i CD CD- CD CD IN cM<;cb HI (I Pip 1

! ct |3 c+ in- iO aa P3 <5 O 113 IB H

...... j t i J h jA'dditlon 01 w I

til i Addition O i«l to • B jsmtotrea t ion

1 «o H • i H A | 1 V) w [pi f...*. H Bttbtre c- i 1 O V* 1 • • iTion B

j .}.... cn c | ifaltipll-

i *> H 3 • O CPtion A

1 a* Kultipli- i \ eati on b o

H HP"' Dlvieion * B | ^ tot ale OS ^ o» ! Total! B £ I Relative

ijtank A Relative Rank B

i

i

-i .... «3 SI : o Quarter I fjj f End ^ Qnerter

i..

I

! 5 Quarter

j let oi f

H ! H I* Quarter !

E •

.1... .UCu j -3rd i

! o Quarter

-j

4 tests f

j i. 1 \m Page t>3

fables -UI, XIV and XV on the pages 1 -.mediately

following show the comparisons worked out Tor the two arith- metic groups between—

! the scores of Intelligence teats;

2. the avera e and median score Increase or the diagnostic

tests;

3. the average and median error decrease of the dlamostio

tests; and

4. the quarter marks. ; — 1 p

t \ OO o o c—^.

t , 1 - i — . I H

n> >

:>

*

a. : CO

a- C3

— — u- Q—

Q*

^3

1 Co o

i c

7" i L1 u

1 i i 1 1 Hi ( 11 111 11 1 1 CP r> -s Hi A. Q_ —J o r ^5 c- ( > O Co CO n o O- o rr s i 1 Co

a- Pare 55

4 R

Hi

<

c_0 on

q

rb

m o n DQ ^>

,i II II \\ II 11 ts> > ^ r> - : r cr- o

Ft ^ ^ o n n> o oP

60 3 — ei 1 i

!

1 i i V o

< H Hi a jC c F a -\

» LA t/-t O 3

i rtr o 1 it T

i

(-A n tcp a) o

i >>

ri ii n n il n )l n ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ n J3 > b -S £s: °- 3 < s m a- ~- o ° o a* o c5^ OO c3 o 1 4 1 1 ^ H Hi 1

•< 5

.

— vN LJ^

K* VJ\ ~S r-

1

3 n -O

Dj T

Co

— > no" 11 M M 11 Ijl § 11 II III 2 0 ^

T 2' 3- ^ 2_ r: -V T *S $ a Page 58

TABL?. NO. XVI

Tabulation of Comparison Kesulta — 1933-1934 Drilled Station Oheok section

Score "it or core "rror

: Incr i • e • acre ise I no rease u^or^asQ Percent 'eroent ^eroent ^eroant

A. 16.7 -3.4 0 B 15,8 1,4 A 11,7 9 11,6 10 inha tiPArttsi on B 14. 4,7 5 4,3 A 20,5 11*4 9 2,3 Multiplication B 17,8 6.8 13,6 7,8 k 12.5 3 7.5 7.5 Division B 13 5,5 11.5 2

15,3 6*5 6,4 4,0 Combined Test 15,1 5.5 3,3 3,9

A» Medium .werage

Interpretation of rtesulte:

In addition, there is a marked increase of score and a marked decrease of errors In the drilled section. The results show that properly dlreoted drill Increases both speed and aocuraoy in addition. or both In subtraction, there is on indicated 'noroase In the speed and aoourioy. This increase Is more pronounced not averages than In the n»dlans. !!owever, the increase Is

gre^t enough to show any marked results. multiplication The increase of both speed and accuracy In result* Is high enough to indicate a positive division The increase of both speed and accuracy In has made better progress. also indicates that the drilled group Page 59

The results of the combined tests show thst the drilled group has doubled the score increase of the oheok group, while

the or -or decrease of this group has increased about thirty percent above the check group*

The comparison of the intelligence teat scores found in

table XII on page 54 indicates that the diagnostic teats ere closely correlated with the Amy Alpha and the Army Alpha

Ma the tests. However, the correlation of the rient-Lhakow

tests indicates that the latter are too eaay Tor tne mental age of this group of atudents. The scores of all tests were

from one to seven percent higher for the drilled group.

These scores indicate that the intelligence of the drilled

group was slightly higher than that of the oheok group.

The comparison of the quarter marka of the two groups during the freshman and spoho *ore yeara is found in table

XV on page 87. this comparison indicates that the marks

were higher during the freshman yesr than during the aophonore

year. However, it must be remembered that the freshman year

marks were given by different instructors and the time allotted

for arithmetic waa also greater in the freshman year than in

the sopno ore year.

The comparison of the first and third quarter marks for

the sophomore year shows that the drilled group had an average

increase of 13. and a median inorease of 20J*. The check

group had an average increase of 10^ and a median increase of

12.5% for the same period. • Page 60

The drilled group had a yearly average mark of 6?£ and a median yearly average mark of 71*7% for the soohomore year#

The oheok group had a yearly average mark of 64*9$ and a median yearly averape mark of 63*3$ for the same period

The comparison of the mean and rasdlan deviations of

the first and third quarter marks for the soohoroore year

found in tables X and XI * shows that the drilled group had

a mean deviation deorease of 1*4 and a median deviation de«

ors^se of 4*?# The oheok section had a mean deviation de-

crease of 1*2 ant!! a median deviation decrease of 1*4 for the

same period.

These faots indicate that the drilled group has made

better progress than the oheok group* 1 Ir i Pare 61 Hi

CO o> to 53 at a £D f £ 9 o cd CO H HI 1 : Oh O >< 6 O O 1 I H Pg P H* j » I i CD W r •1 # 00 COM 11 i tl lifll 33 ° O O i i i t 8 V CO if ^3 ill is Ill 0: 3)lagno8tl

i 00 W ICS H h fe5 to ! 03 p ^ C9 H II Rank I |

i 01

«o in 51 O H H M to w E 0 CD j<0 to CD army o to B lpha

H j 1 HelatiVe !• 0) ito o 8 O 8 j Rank 1 a, i IJlatha CD H j O AO 00 i oi B(Alpha( o H CO to to Tola cl ve pp IP \ *> CD fi at «o 10 100 ;H jo icn 1 !» I Rank o m ! bp flit' to O f i 1^ P !3 IS CO P :^ J. | V j u .1 1 t"'HaIativa r1 H" H ito i t* to o j si at p M ;a> ! Hank M H 10 j M- ftf I b if «i c(Kent o I I* F |* j» T) » Co ice W r H SO d H H Relatlre $o h ^3 S3 H H | Rank

so ill i to H to i^en t No H CO tO H 0) o O D O 0) V s. .i 4 •'Kol'at'lva H H Id H to 0k o» i c^ Hank p j* O I

I j i i to ieo to H tO n k B ^3 CD to i i 0 Time : i I Relative !£0 to pi to in to jo> to 5 14 Rank o

i ...... j

i i til " SI *4 \t it ha 03 ii | ME P fO & iOi p 0^ w ^ k vuarta - w 5< 2nd If S3 C> i-xJ U) O <0 s |> o p l I P 1 OI O O 03 P 8 luart •» a h

w tl (I If 3rd' ! 4a h tr) fc> en oi o f v» P O p tfl Quarter » h Is + -r- « *« to i 0* & M| ic o i: * p a 1 o> I i o y» p p a o o quarter 9 c« 53 S3 IP ©> cn S3 io -*j -4 0> Quarter | s fiji w di % i o 4 3rd i> o tb 8 g I $ I • 8 o P> w O 4aarter 3

••«•'••- • Hi- f»M ««•< •! ~ i-

PC w 1 4. -L „L u 1— | 5 CD CD ct 1 Oi I Hi H- " i P 5T $ r ! W 3 ft 3 | CO I p ib O «V ko 0 a CO a ! CJ w o i CD o U o O 1 i

i o -SLiJLi * S itnntu o Relative Hank

j |> i O o H en

S • El** .4 1» 1 ..a. Helative at Hank 1 a the * H Alpha) 1..CJI 01

| Relative

I Rank ^ant to j H i g?i ia r to U1 M

! Relative Rank .1 | I... M

i hMathe • ^Kent T) Relative i

| Rank to .'8 jj£ent No to j c I -Tl ne 40 i-O- to I i-w

! Relative CD \ Rank

L. i to Math Kent r- I lo P M if i£ i o Time ..[... CO Relative Rank aJ;

...j... i 1st !W qua rter,^ ni |C i O •i »~ 3H i to M Quarter 5 p if • — W7 «j 3ro ^ to U3 ^uerter^g* ut & o fcl 1st • CD I

CO if |"oo" 2nd o I .Quarters* .] par s 3rd I \iu ^rtero - **• CP

i u I i I. CO £ 3 — 1 ^1 Pap,e 63 a tr

O t3J to 2 p p OH i a I cr co r Hi ill in | n 8- (5 1 O * I ct \ t : V I f f B 1 B f o 2 O o i J

£*» \ i» .4 H 10 if If hi ito H H s a H E S 4v hi m jP s- ;

N 1 i i g (SUP P V io ^3 IO t .>,...... "i--- i c iH 3 H H H io riauk 1 H id H S3 H i I a to 10 b h B (Upha) ^ io

| nelatlya IN Hank o ko H [09 If ! iO s H —i -i- si *+ O H H H o o si iui iO* tat to O O o 91m W ut o B at I" 6 I 5 to ^ J Hela-tive ,. , ; I — CO |0 CO to Hank io i IS a H H © GO tit G CD It [B to P 9 i

]V o j IS » (Tant T # ) co

.j;..;;...^n. ... i let - & RalatlYa Iff iH N "6 0 if Hank ;« M CO 05 CO Vi irr tO o m O sj j Kant No « (• H CD to Ti:ne !*> 2 2"j|a 1 11 0 to CO t1 % ^* Halati va CO IN IN w H j H Hank ^ N N m 3 8 S3 ^^ s* H M -a |H 10 h w <0 I J U«th Xtn£ CD \& ico IN if N IH N 1 S3 O O 1 o let :03 IP Hel*tiv«3 iO. m ° in m oi ico CO i 63 H Kank co CO io s O 0 O iu> ICD H IH CO O 1st cn M ioi 'H ;H 04 is) M lot Quarter CSI H H to ;«o o w io i a ^..:....-4 4— - tai I t si sa uj oi ioi |0> S3 jO ftuarter^^ ;oc lot \m at id O H en i IO? iO H ia> lot 4 | ! 9r<\ I f iO» Ni is» !0» icu a a) ice CO Ul iO Id o ^uartor" m o c» ten Ol jO jc |§ p 1st «»

iC ! ., 04 iO* Q.ua teK H si S3 !SI SJ ! o iO i o o lf'if'6 18 o io 3 4 Quarter^ io> { s» oi g» i -a si it* hi !a ;g jO iff |o o Id io W jO ! o a ' i 3pa -i 4 i i f '?^J f Ih Oi Sen ico !

i

i i •ti.f liinui.n.iiMHi i.. (

CD < 1 o Mean ct tr H« 10 p CD h3 SL o if to in 1 1 ! g | CD o o. LlJ

CD IK io i C0 1 Deviation I b I 1 cr fa c+ CD - 1 i 1 §

8 g oDiftcn r>6 tlo Relative St Rank SI : • • 1 Alpha Jo .H! Relative Bank ,Mathe -a g -a h • • o ( Alpha Relative 8 Rank +* 1*-- o m Kent I 8 grime .SI Relative Rank h Math* •j F to P (KentT) Relati ve i Rank

k> Kant No • • I L 4 ! _*« B Tina i SI JH g b Relative W o Rank - Klathe Kant -J H >-* • to • 5 TTo Time ;H SB Relative i Rank 1st S r Quarter H| ana | Ok • Quarter

» ct CJi 3rd a • Quarter "IT CD let • • * CJi 01 Quarter H H C O s 2nd M • • • M a Quarter ...03 o>. 3rd to s • •g g • Quarter # # i \ n ! Page 65 Mt? ^oilV|k oiHI CO sr * * f HI O o o *$r # n^» ow o p o CD Qi 3 & f Cft P Si 1 g s cfr ** M» N £ i io *U D 6 P s r a a fa* m to o 13' • I i I co > i o o

! 3 cf w h «fr K * S3 « o o ^ I 0 .a.. 1

] \ ! [ I I i \ 1 1 I Addition j f I b to w iM*iw woioa i^coHrf* W wi^ wwh ui*» jw *w pv* :H*>tow iwo H 4

t*jui*!ww joi* ^jw a> iiil^iHwi^ &c* ci woioj Iw^iiD* *>WokUoi p Ljy^ %% M jo fi

lO A C K. ; Subtrao- I p w;p«a btnatd •slwoiji^c* how^M cfr|i^o>iMw 10 o woi tnH jH^ on B

j I t t t I I t I I feultipiu : H^H c ^i#p*+> *>vip> +pl9*mm( u^pci^ G»jwoi<*oi oi $oa> ;h<» wo* iwco gontlon A

t ^rapii- I I I I ! I ! I I I \ I J ! t «4jutdjipfcCt 03 to cd o>to^*>o to a>H ot^^M^ ckp jooatlon B til p>e>ifi a 90 o

-a

j o A o iw en jtw HWwai pio ahaH *itacj«jci»tn btoaH^H ^foatoH- caw ]g q

-.* 4 j. i 1 1 j. i ] ] ^4 t**'-. jjflinoiriliifttJo »3 |wo^ ojtoo HCii^i iwccjto ajbec^o !*©jwo|* oj^-aMo i^^p^^ A «

Hi h denominate S iw « |oo> oca to ub co h^H ^>blo)b jtob^Miw bfasiuib ^ M» H» !iumbets B ^ 0

i.,..

t

H I 0» H

: I : I ; : .... Interest A ^oj^UHi^H Hj&aHjWH HwH^lw tobjH|t»«0 jC0C4 CO tob W^ICAHjW- j^O

I ! j j | ; I { j j \ j [ j j j I Interest iwo

J i L wiooboo jwoi w oj^4-» woicfiH ifl oi^wicow^ H^toi^oi bHi^w^ j^^jRffy -i <4 -»..•!' ^njwei w|»oi|w^ inftiiwmiui whh^h H « |qh |Ooj»o ^sjf^g* -! h -4 Totals uj b U ^ ta w H 1*^ b 0» ait P c w iwlo C! k-c ID H i to^sop HO P A ' Totals g B C-4 to Wo> W OH! Em r Relative in 1^ !o "ank A I I II I It icu H P L loi ¥ (UJ.""11' !h S !m ;m a Rank {ci |o MK • & |h \t»w k U b P j* p 1 K B I - I : i r i *- ....J • 1 * are 66

J1* « «t 00 0i I (D Q Q s Of E swff.s & 1*1*2 o hi cd a o o u 1E tQ jf a o o 3 I co * 0) CD CO gas ; a g »3 0 9 o cr o f i 3 3 I • 8 1 3 id ; u

•i /Addition 03 oi i 0> A,_ NE ; O. „

H i OB Addition H CO W on • I • it £

I w *t Subtree t- : i M i # too j ; j i Ol 1 4- .i « i j to h | Subtrac- O \ H M 1 ai . tion j

on MultlplU M Hoa-ion A o • Lmn o CO CO Multlpll-^j O CI 01 j

CO ! 00 goat Ion B lll{||IM>*JMtl>litlU to Dlvl si on 03

* i » O

H I Division M g it m HOD H B

| w -j f o

• ! Jpenomlnat*"

i. j 0»O

H ut to • Renominate „.l, [~t* otJu^bers B m CO

I • F WW

I 4 i * — H o | !4 W CD

CO to Interest tn A CO Interest Oft tn b

to 03 r Mensuration P •si g A CO Mensuration r i 0» «U> b b if Totals : • A

I I

; H iH Totals Ok ;0> ;$ « ] M m O I CD ] K i 0* I I* !.oj- I relative nflmk A

t r- Relative Bl Lis .IsbJIla B Pare G-7M If

• v =0) / S K JC it* £» :0 X3 p 59 ft rsi •:: I 2 g ,h IS. §. h a t s & i 5 I fesa V id

: a !? ! l n \ r 1 5 o M n w m ct» o p o ; * a i H 's<; & I &£ # I & I, 9 if 2 ^

+ i +!' i -f [/ -tl +h +1 1 i-h -t! ' +\\ i-h + h +h -v +JI : -—« ... - .- ; — « 1 «J ; -..,[,,...,.. L u - ——-

1 I ! Addition |OiM:^« W jtOM^ 05 jUlfca caifc TOCO ^l^WWpWWOJ 64W{WM j*M p^CO jH pHfd ^ Addition IfeHitot wiiKoiwoi •-'-a iho ^ c* bn^oi Hcoiwo i*t© ww H ^oHdb jO I i, I I ! JS I j ^ [ .[ i

; i i I I j i ! I = ; j 1 ! \ ! • i

[I L L i Subtrao- , |ee» wto*o<*o*oat** WW **wto 10 aooaso w> oaufoocooi oavi^ea jg ^ Qn ^ - i ftm

; \ f p r. I pill i f i i

I I'ultipli*

Multlpll-2 | , saw |h kw iwo> oaou* *> o>&K* pi*>*>&iNh jw c»Uoi>#>*t*j- CD mo oat ion

L Division P'

• * Division °

' « ' i i7. S : :.i i .•(. i -A — i i

c» jw-a to-aj»ojco«o to a ho toco wo^ce H a^Oi ^bo^mtoowo . ^numberuxnj>e^ 8a A

j £ i*a 15©c jo £ 1 - Fra« Dec.S

• : : : i • : ; ; ; : | ;

F : i : j : ; : ; | 111 Interest j^OfACO O \tm pG *m jUlH jEOH t»t» WO^HWO^OtlHflH M* WW. X r m Internet B

o 4. j 1 Mm 1 Mensura- O Totals b to K CO o-. t4co QO 0 ^4 m Hto II s o> k f f a \ j I Totals 4c H«dc« to to to Co CO W . B iH p si Relative Hank A

Rela ive Ran k CD 63 . i o CD Q a. a* CD h§ 9 g a H M Q m © a o CD o 0) 3 w o CD P 0) w w h 1

Addition 02 CO I * to to

Ot i tO • » i to JUJfe jjD

i 3ubtrao~ to 09 tlon A to

to 01 j J tion B h m w i# it QM .( ^© .. CO-- • 4 h 03 I isuitipii*^ « <*m cation k**

! J CO ;. : t < ! : I : H f if ! cation Bg 3; H jN [# Si to u- - *5

i to I Division 8 to [#k ||| I sa I <£ H "T Diviilon ° H O CP W • * to If W H <4>H » g ^benominatpj »« lumbers A I** o i 0» ^

I t -• '• %«M»im«t« H CO

03 CO to i

j O ! *4 -a g

! fra« i>eo«<£ 60 | 01 h \h to oa ;« M-iit ilttiwiii to I" g

i CO H A H a I

I Interest

to to ! H B H * to cj><* i -i ilensura-

to O i 03 tion A O* !M + CD "1 Benlura- • i to H tl0n B h ;o ico w 0> OH £ 03 '7'^o'fali to 5 i Sen A

B 8 £p§ Relative Rank A •Reitttlve 1 It* Rank b wi is •—1*—*• j. i i- I Pace 69 O O o QOO -i— -I—

cr > rtT

<3e»

D3 C-0 & o «; ^ Pa

0>

0-> Q

TO o Ul

Co o o

CD m o> ft u a: a i u' a o Co C-o to Co Co n O T — 05 ex. O

5 5 r-5 Pas

I

H a is rn o o> US a_

X.

Co' Co o a O Co o o 4^ ri

n

Co

II II 11 11 Q H il if Co > n Cp CP N a- ? <; n o -V tn a. Co TH Co o CO ro O Hr 0 a. 0 ^ rs Cx T In a> 3 ^3

05 Page 71

On ^ <0 —1 O r-r

X 3 n rn o <-0

o

—- rn us ^ Oj 2

C_n| nj

Hi

Co

era :> z 11 II H a is H to ^ * _ (T\ ' c— < Hi ^ _ o n> o rr ^ 2 o Co Co to o ° —H 3> O as ^5 n Q ro — Pap 3 72 oo O O 3V> o -4 —1_ t

3> X

cv — o

CM

0> Q— J3 O

a*

Hi

n 0 u u ri ii n ii H H ^ n ^ o o a Co pi

so 5=: a. cu o- O r» -S

T ^ ^ ^

s 5^ Q_ 3 n ?a , 73

TAB13 NO XXV

Tabulation of Comparison faults - 1934-1935 Drilled Seotion Check Section

Score Error ..oore Increase Decrease Increase Decrease ^oroent Perocnt Pereent ? or cent

A 30 10 w A Addition 2 (9 A 10 0 10 10 Subtraction B 10 e 7 l A 30 -10 10 10 Multiplication B 23 8 12 a A 19 0 0 10 Division B 11 3 z 4

6,7 Denominate A ao 6.7 13.3 Numbers B 14.7 7.4 8,7 4.7 A 10 10 10 10 6 i 3qulv« B 9 10 6 A 20 ao 0 20 Interest B 14 13 4 8 A xo 10 0 10 Mensuration B • 6 4 6 A 16*3 7.5 6.8 8 Combined Tests B 13,3 7 8 3.4

A- Median B» Averagi

Interpretation of Results: those in table The results shown in the above table and are, in many respects, ;.VI which show the first year's work speed nnd accuracy in Suite similar. The increase of both division is even addition, subtraction, multiplication and There is a great* more apparent than in last year's rsaults. as shown by the score er increase of speed than of aocuraoy, Page 74

Increase and the error decrease. In subtraction the speed again and aocuraoy of tooth the drilled and oheok groups Is very similar*

In tooth denominate numbers and interest, the drilled group has doutoled the score increase of the oheok group while the error doorcase is only slightly in favor of the drilled group in tooth oases*

The soore lnorease and the error decrease of the drill* section in ed section is also higher than that of the oheok and mensuration. tooth fraction decimal peroent equivalents great However, the increase of speed and accuracy is not as

as in denominate numtoers and interest. more The results of the oombined eight tests show, even drilled conclusively than those of last year's tests, that the the oheok group has more than doubled the score lnorease of

d rilled group is group. Likewise, the error deoroase of the oheok group. more than fifty pero nt greater than that of the soores found The comparison of the intelligence test results to those in table XXI on page 69 shows very similar olosely correlated of last year. The diagnostic tests are tests. However, with the Army Alpha and the Army Alpha Kathe again indioates that the correlation of the Xent-Shakow tests age of this group of the latter are too eay for the mental eight to twenty students. The soores of all tests are from scores indicate peroent higher for the drllle' group. These was oonside-atoly that the intelligence of the drilled group higher than that of the oheok group. Page 75

The comparison of the quarter marks of the two groups found In table during the f reahman and sophomore years are marks than the XXIV on page 72. The drilled group aho*a higher specialised check group during both years. As there was no the drill drill given In the freshman year, the effeot of quarter of the sophomore would not be apparent until the second year* marks for The comparison of the first and thlr<5 quarter and XVIII, shows that the freshman year, found In tables XVII sophomore year, had an the group, which was drilled In the of 15*. The average Increase of 1**10 and a median increase and a median ln- Check had an average inorease of 27.1*

orcase of 874 for the same period. quarter marks for The comparison of the first and third drilled croup had an average the sophomore year chocc that the The cheek Increase of 8.3* and a median increase of 7*. a median increase group had an aware increase of 1.6* and

of 3.8* for the same period. mark of W3.7* The drilled group had a yearly average of 77.7* for the sophomore and a median yearly average mark average mark of 66.3* end year. The check group had a yearly for the same period. a median yearly av*racs mark of 70.3* deviations of the The caparison of the mean and median the sophomore year, found first and third garter mark* for that the drilled group had a in tables XVII and XVIII, shows median deviation decrease mean deviation decrease of 3.1 and a Page 76

or 2.9. The cheok group had a mean deviation lnorrcaae of

2 and a median deviation increase of #5 for the same period.

These faota indioate that the drilled group has made muoh better pro -res- tlian the oheok rroup. ] ; Pape 77

" ;o L lep 1*1; 1 I ft 3 i§ F E ~ ;> i» r S? , » » j .g o o o> to < © o o & A 9 3 j» 6 8 § | =

CD £0 H .1 CP -*> 4 4- -I i*

pi i !

i I •[• j» 4 1 I I £ I.: i- i i j * F"V ""'"l I f-

13 [jo Krtt * P ? I 8 !fl 3 |J 2 8 !« !« ?

o» p» ;h ;0 j*t ttaftk [5 fta j 1 Uph ! 8 1. 1« 1 f 3 8 3 I IS '8 S I I" « is » j niauv* "wvwr L Li b u k< i< S 5 8 S S g S S | 5 H»nk 1

I * ° i B • II I * • £ I- fSj... I

:: u I** it* S I !h ! iJJ Relative L t» o. £ f| S ;S |& h 5 \+ Rank g

i j-

i

iSS P. IT 8 !6 B Hank. B frthe » » !« - »!? :0»• • - r SaT*t« S ftelativ« [• m %\ H i* f S 1* S it* ii 1 t! t; 2 to P iX * 5 «3 TIM™ if * ;0» IM| isS us LZli.jl1 p Helatlve ; 01 S i 1 Rfftk to ;CC ! to & i I"*- ro T a] j«isjajs $;ent 8j?| j 8 $ ]g lsI ! s j '.el' ' iv | 1

i H ig «» bk*Hack 15 • If I ,5i O | » 5 - E s™ i • J .i !; »i ' ..1 a a \--- v I jo* -a 1st Of IS uart^r S |8 i 3 1 I 3 St Is! IS IS !& |8 |3 I |8 ;5

• i ! v | | I I j l-u P K 4 1 t i . f tte »i« r . _ »r

2k ifsb a «{« a a a!«lJUlili.2f!?f i 8'8'a Pi SI !g i^S 8 :3'5 3,8 8 SUr J»

Ot i i £ Pa^e 78f

S3 O 55! HI ® Oo 2 O 5 i* «+ 9 S> P h ,D iCiH 8 p* j 1 W ft B W ST iO H WW I i r Q O O' p o IO & <* w 0*1 i H * 1 ;m Q*l ^ -(DO O

i t» * * r t i ; I S 8 •4 | i 4* I #

3 jTjrji 1 0 1 1 % £ s t s a S s a $ S ^??;" 1

h *> *a £ IS S^dwcowUiooHfe «* iRelative

I R*Q.fc P »rmy m © H -SO 0» t.n 4» 0> W C O O |-» «0 0» #» O So 5 S S & t» h» to o^pfww p»c»© © Mpha

J i i j.. : L [MM j | } [ | I g tn«o xi b o *• #» «c bathe I t* 0 few Oi 4a * 4 B * * .Alphi...

cs o» ki o> w W cl c-! K p oa a» o> o> o w o» © : {©JLatj^v©

t i |g h to H H M I W Relative V.

i *.lmt.....l iHolatire I § i I 1 to 8 ?S m % k 9 m Hank ^

B fc £ "t'8 Kaot jg 1 £ S g 8 M *P 8 6

j • 1 S i * * I is 8 8 k L t I I 1 *J*J*^ J f t £ g 1 3 * |j s i§ s i s e « ji :i |** I I ro t 12 $ I t 8 k k S b I ? * flat ly*' I H i $ f 5 ; 1 . 1 ; * [ ;

s & $ 2nd 1 1 1 ? i 1 1 $ 1 1 ll 1 1 1 aji.w.t^. k I i 2 i i I i i is * I f T Mil F ! luartar 8 I 8 I s I i I | $ t I |3 MM

! ! I I 1 t I I i I Quarter j j ^ J I I i || I it a 14 | k 1 1 * j M !• m**«ll i

i a- » * fiip«-iwi , i... i_ i i «4 4-. — £s o o pr B 5. 5 o. q, • g g> H o H a L'i « h- » w> h- g & E * 0 f S * • • fel £ f o Q u O •

I, I i | I »-* b A m ** a •} M * ef • 0 *-* s tit 0 hi Ma 0 at j"; M

Jf I U » S 3 & Tests

1 Hark

„.L.... S £ ov jp* i-ftmy ^ oi m H P Alpha

r r \ Hank

2 S £ ? f r b^** 1 jr * 1 tj>MH» *ank f * i g £ @ g 5 8 I * p *a ;h 1*4^ Oft *

K«t T J | t £ T ! i i& : i : I m Relative

0 * i Rank i g * | & C f p r f i

it •

i03 tO

H , 0» p !• >3 •

C i -j*- *o « !• • 3 % si m « 3 H i pi

• r *Si" 1 r :cp 1 ! c \6 ill! I r Sion 1 p h c

1 • i * -a id

-Ua i [- m. » m

?°ti i

! ' i 1 \ r a.t' c JVFi uj ^ r— w O O I 1 & 123 O O W co cp m o o p> p a> oi H r* CD O 5 5 6 S O $ 5 5 P O M * in c+ g o v O H- H» O O HIP w g P P i P ; CD 3 c n 0 C3 OS :0Q H- co • ; CO o> 03 CD CD O o t3 CO 0 « 0*5 i 1M O o >-jo O ^ O I M CO a* MM ! *3 i O ; Co CI 11 O ^ o H , H» *s fl> MCD CD *-# CD o ; O ; f jj

"

05 r : 1 H""1 i_t 1 h 1 Addition -4 : CD h H m h

I * • i • • Ul CD I ;- t * ..1*2

w i w Addition O*

H to i h Subtrac* 04 ^ mnhh m hI* hhm h hhh o rf^^H « w i**h atrf* h gtion A

to \ oi

H-^£>tf4 ho> oj ch nop w oa o*4c* il*03 cnt* rf^ ^^Q^g"

co^iro to <^**3 a> o^^ o> rf^aio»0)03WCDCo w S j^cati on A CO

^ui^wwoicjifr-jqioo oww oi wen oi Ration B s Divi sion w KwH wojo^^oo*

1 ; j J.M. z 1 j L

! Division M 5 i ! i- ! i I I I I f-5 L.. hh h h , ^ ^ tA Denominate od wwo©^H^H^Q>aoxo«CQ^^^ g H?yo^ A •-3 COKWOOlp^HO^O WtOHCD WHHW ^ g HNog ^3

i 4 4 1 I r f IT"' H r. J H ! Frao. Dec* CO

i *i. » * ..' .5 A* ^tU« If a l» fV . il . ?. 1. I Frac. Dec* H 8 Interest f Hoi wcflHH'wcij owfoijii to own H 00 * to J 03

[ Interest 1 L^l CO O O i^OltOi HMHOaOlHf OC*KC3Ht^ 0>»^ ^ g

i4 hHh Mensura- h^SS wS^tP^^oitffcxDO w ^t010 ^ tion A

' r ' ! f i . Men sura-

O* tf» ^3 d 4 c o>w 01 <2 cn A o: W «C a h ^ aiRH tolo ^ tf* U to tals oi oj oa fc wco rf4 03 ^ O.CGH 03 *D C\

I i L w ^ ! Relative a L k 8 S IBIS ISP I S 8|HMk

i M j Relative E0 Hank B CO o ! w 1 i |H | im 03 O ; W r « ox

O

Multlpll-

oati on A.

O

o Renominate r a>? os. A 1

1

M j ? 0j i I CI. «^

^ H) Oi a* *v Q 9 SB E ft 2 ft 3 5 I o 5 6 1 3 - W H H ^ ft o g o cr i c » B ® *> p P

(D . « ! O H 0» • ! 3 » E a 5 § 1 » i ** \, 6 n T ft ! p I a ! © O ff5 D H O ** «D 0; • ft £ 1 ii P

S M ; 4- 1 + -HJ i i -f- / i i i 4- +;/ -fii -Ki 4- i +; + [j +|) + j + + -H +i + |

Ufi ^ Addition yhwi M: H H H M H L M jj j -Hi cab oi»H &s op c*«0 © 0 c»o» h jo** o si w o>jo «©a> oj h*°H ^coo>w wito ^

| j ! I h r i ri*£Liiii «oto H HQ o o» hu» Hp o go o»hwoj^ co** oa *f*coo h w d d|_

4 $*-

i I •»: Hi Hi if] '. Ul 0*4 LUtOOl H CD Hi CO, hhhhI h! h hhh! Motion too^H o»*a

| " TJubst rao- | [ J j j t j on 53 t* -*h tnUo ^ c»6 co h sk* ca <^eo^ woaokO** j ruitiDii-

*

| i | (THultipIl- | | | | • j L sitoo h o>*<*i* *» c*

; ; 4 i [ *d « j : H H H H H H A ivlaidn 2

W o>H «orasa o c» ^ w o H cn w o v Danouinate 6

! ; s y. ui m I HHi H ; H H HHH H: •* *• ^onoMhat a « Noa. B ; H

"!Trao • Cao • i i b« \ yii I H H 9 ^ 5to ccgib si s>« o h cotoi^-o w tooi tn o ot c «w to

: ; ! i I \ r f i j I;: ! i riao* Pact h t# * o ob ococ& h o»0 oi 0 tob tof* ^ kM^ ^ oi to w cn ic^«ia c* M oiH o|C f j I "interest H1 a •^erest h b « hIw h|I » Sw» f^i^ Hi^ hh w w oi ^ b M an aura-

.1* * |who* h o jw cn u\ mjMfc lw nip wfc^opo^^juw^wfaoib^io p Htl on B H H Totals

(J)

i to H to H B stela*" c B B e B to to O 5D

* I a i» jp h m m M i I i ^ p p f p j Mk 6 i i i i $ t i s Ralatlva » i i p Rack B a i- 35 HI H 'HI CD w W a. 5. * 0) H» £ (?j oj

*03 ! b ; T B O ^1 ; O Q (Fl P U o a 8 fe^ to a i » io PI 0 a o 9 ci a o N I cr jt »1 O ^ 1 w 3 3 8 3 I—* ---- CD , i m m

! 1 -a !* O p ** o • L Addition 1 I PI • to cn *» to - - i » i i Co i i o Q en 4 H to &> o» Vdc! i tl on <^ • r b Vi P> f - £ -I.... ^> B is H i"" &•* I tc cflto oiubstrao- * i 4 1^ |l .fil- j — in ^

i 1 I <* 14 ft 4 ls I f w » ICD P ^bion B "f 1= CO H 9 to O In p • f ^fttlon 4 j. I to : f>t* # * it ji • ; * Ration B a lib 01^ 1 -• t o & U :C& Oi ^

Fill <*m- ~ — -i J & 0» O I If Htf^w u» 1)1 vision s 9 4 '1 .iWi k i r SI 9 nominate 4 • & ^tft In 4 * r* ,...{£..IlO«f JO |0 .. . ( ... I CO oDenomlnate # h co r |5 It S ! |jJtoft* iu 1 1SI

0 ! h coo cn-^ ra<3 * ^00* 4 to • a> I ! £*• C* A !"i iJ|-3 -i, H * to cn 9 o is0 m 4 ^iji.*....JI.W.--^ ^ p n 00: «o|nt«rest * \** I E p 01 p p » i*

i i N 6* CO S3 •a V» O tcn i>a % 1 ui B I f is - i ....l — i-. i< H ^H«oiTensurft- 9 is p H in [. F a. C 0. J ! 2.Mm .40 P*.. r i 61 M «0 E tCI to B £5 i 4 6 INN It*? h^ ti on B 4. o 03 ta-c 1 I I fe#HC totals i I fo » 8 •* I 4 4O" .A. j I I tOr t i i i i E 4 ?• <0 i<0 4 4 4 iO 44 10 ^ Relative f J Hank A ^ ^ B«latlve „ L. in Vare 34 o 3» I —I u 5 3.

7=S.

< 3 o Co O a

O C/i O CO rti Ox C-M Co on s D (a

Hi ^ O 03 2> O z \\ M " )l (1

^ ^ V, ^ Co Co a. O - ^ ^ a. cu —I r;-

ex 2 & 3 o 35 i o U1 O O O __u -4- -4- 9—

0- on 3 -S3

o <0 Cr> rri

a to

3

t u H c^? CD

a. £; O S § 2 «J o o g 3

ST On

In -

I i I o o o —i _L_ -4- n > 3- ^

TO

L ™

o

Co

O

ON O Hi a.

c> hx(^"n m o 0\s i> ;

)i ii n ii " 'i i II ^ ^» O 2 n> *— 3. * — — o — o ri". ro <-Q A) Hi o o Co , » = 2 o a- O o o 3 <* CA ?3 ^5 3 5=; it 3

<=C> C3 5 — — o O4^ —I —u- _1 L_ —i Hi

| < s <-0 TO o a ida

O

rn t? UP) 03 ^> ~n Q ^ !i M 11 II II

o ^ ¥1 O ts*

o> Co

a- ^ a. c$ T » a. ^ rape ee

T*\BLS NO XEXXV

Tabulation of Comparison Results 1935-1936

Drilled eotion Check -ieotl m

Soore 3rror score T :rror Inorease Decrease Increase decrease g or pent Percent Per oent ^erceri 14*1*1 on — Elo* 2:1 =88:9 -:2 A 6.7 -1.7 -8,3 -6.7 Subtraction B 4.7 2,3 -5.3 -4,7 A 15.9 -15.5 -2.7 Multiplication B 9,5 -12,6 5 -9,9

A 2,5 -2,5 5 5 Division B 10 -3,5 6.3 5,5

Denominate k 22*3 13,3 9,5 -1.1 Numbers B 20,6 12.1 16 2.1 FracDeo, A 42,5 -5 20 2,5 24,3 -4 $> Squir» B 29 1 A 12,5 1.2 35 17.5 Interest B 17,5 -2,8 27,8 •2.5 A -11,2 4.1 -19,1 .9 Mensuration B -12.4 -1,4 -23,9 -2 A 10,6 4,1 3,4 -8 Combined Tests B 9*9 .3 2,9 -.9

Median D- \vera£.e

Interpretation of Hesfclts* tables The rosults shown in the above table and those in results, are in Ttl and XXTj whioh show the last two years:' is apparent many respects quite similar. The score lnorease mensuration. There is a in all tests except addition and e*d de» noticeable error deorease in addition, subtraction nominate numbers. Page 39

The drilled section has again shown the greatest seore increase In all tests except Interest, Thie fact seems to In- dicate that the cheek group had more or better training in interest than the drilled group,

The results of the combined tests Bhow, even more strlk- ingly than In previous yenrs, that the drilled group has made better progress than the eheok group* the score increase and the error decrease of the drilled group are both about three times that of the check group*

It should be remembered, ^vhen interpreting the results of this year*s ^ork, that the ending tests were given one year after the beginning tests. In other words, the students were tested at the close of a six month's project season and not during the school year as was the case in previous years.

This accounts in part for the increase of errors in some tests.

The comparison of the intelligence test scores, found those In table XXX on page 84, shows very similar results to Mathe of previous years. The Tent-Shako* te:-5ts, except the the time test, again lndloate that the latter are too easy for mental age of this group of students. The Army Aloha and the

Kent-Shakow time test indicate that theproups were of about the equal Intelligence, The diagnostlo tests Indicate that remaining check group was of higher intelligence, while the intelligence. tests indicate that the drilled group was of higher groups round The eomparison of the quarter marks of the t»o drilled group made in table XXXIII on page 37. s ows that the Pare 90

batter grogi'ess than the ohook group during tha freshman year*

It should be remembered that this sroup was drilled during the freshman year instead of the sophomore year. The marks of the drilled group were higher In all oases except the rirst quarter of the freshman year*

The comparison of the first and third quarter marks of the freshman year* founrf In tables XXVI and XXVII, shows that the drilled group had an aver are increase of 15. 9£ and a median increase of 13$. The ehecV- group had an average increase of

6.8% and a radian increase of t$ for the same period*

The drilled group had a yearly av>raf?e mark of 72.3^ and a median yearly average mark of 74. 2£ for the freshman year*

The check group had a yearly averaop mark of 71 • 6$ and a median yearly average mark of 73. 3& for the same period.

The comparison of the mean and median deviations of the first and third quarter marks for the freshman year are found

in tables XXVI and XXVII on pages 77 to 79. The drilled group had a mean deviation decree © of 3.3 an<5 a median deviation de-

crease of 2.8. The check group had a saean deviation decrease of 3.2 and a meet an deviation decrease of 2.4 for the same per-

iod. These deviations are not great enough to be of any elgnifl anoe.

The effect of the drill is also carried over to the

sophomore year as is shown by the following:

(1) The comparison of the first and third quarter marks of

the sophomore year shows that the drilled section had

an average increase of 11«SA and a median increase of Page OX

53# The check section had an average Increase o* 5«3£

and a median Increase of 4$> for tha same oeriod.

(a) Tha drilled group ted a yearly average mark of 74«2S

and a median yearly average mark of 7B # 3* for tha

sophomore year. The oheok group had a yearly average

mark of 75. 3£ and a median yearly average mark of 77#*£ for the same period*

(3) The comparison of the mnxx and median deviations or the

first and third quarter marks for the sopViomore year

ahoff 6 that the drilled group had a mean deviation de«

create of 3*1 and a median deviation decrease, of 3«6 #

The oheok group had a mean deviation decrease of 5«6

and a median deviation decrease of 4*7. for the same

period*

Tha results of this yea/s work indicate that the drilled group has made a definite increase in progress above the check

K*9U»| as indicated by the marks as well as the diagnostic test scores* i

o 3 o o h c: o a £ h» » o 6 h o P &• » n * to h- m to

i = i : 7 j j jl j f 1 [ » i P* O O

I i I ' I B

- j j M I M *> j x 1 c tt" Hstfli Iitfit tsfi illi ft "to ft hrt*t*t si W&™

ui 6» h; lark [ <* | ! ! IS o» i o o CD m [•!• fi I'l iV i m

- ij»4 i I i Anay ,

- ! 1** I fa W I hp hrl mi r1 fel Hi® o M ^ 0)O » M CP tfl ^ i^ « a) en Hank

' ' 1 ! £ I ! I

; * 4 ; j 5 A ; i M 4- M i...f*.-J. Relativev^iH UVO ^ <* «* 0> 1 <» C* P <» * H 0» M ; * M Rank

ln* H II* S§ 1 1 I S it 8 $ § £ * 8 8 S| * Hank I i ** j ca co I i j • | P*

f

j ^•4-^--i i I | Matfce i I I I:

* f «...j...- ...| i 4 4-|«» "i •^l:ft-ti-V8 #• I 1 ar j-, -p M m c* ( «• ; \M i ; « I sank ;m|» [ ||!^i

i-g-i g fir iylel ttl 5 •4#l-d5 -s-j-'S'is- gTlmaIB*** ! * ? ; 2 ! % \ 3 ! to a w § o £ S K £

i i .1 ! • i i i L#..l i I I "alative i | 1

i ! Hank 'iHiKiH:H!H \W LP i Mi «J

? .(«> ! j L.JttS! 1 j m g 3 11 - fill fiipii'itiji ii iiiiil.riJif -

i i i I I Rela tive Hank M a* m ^ tf m K « H S £2 1st [ S f S 4 If I f ! W! 1 8 1 1 o l¥ iH « 8 tarter

I ; i - c j i i ^4 -3&a

I ltlTl"!¥tTfl rill S o S ? g ?' o S garter

«i o| 0-; w [ I i Oi io » : quarter io w i Tl Si S o 5 !o i Sio % : gag g g [ifitii S: OMtMi I

! 1 rt9r Tllsl'»1i!a if 1318 IS It IS !S|3|3| Si ^

i.™. L -....i— i j .i. ? Pape 93

a OjO (St q a. a. ft '8f:f ° I II

: 3

elntiva Hank F E5DM lolatlve Kank

- i Maths g( Alpha)

i ! i HolattT* Rank

S lisffim Halativa Hank

-a

at

[ : Relative Hank A g'itaa a V i Halatlva Hank

...j ; § 3 Ifetha (K) IT** F ; • *o Time Hal ail ra Hank

f uartsr

r 03 uart 3T

3rd t£5 unrter j

% Quarter Q S 2nd -a Quarter

• ^Quarter 1 I 'age 94

(» ta x # *0 * M HI «55 i n o 5 P S & I I 5 8 I 3 i I i M m 4 1 <; H H i G» ft

i a M & o O

; § inn i B 8 | i B t w j iH \m ^ i 1 w • -a cn |H 1 p I to | to Relative Rank to H to | fer* tt Im. B to tt j to O* IS I B I oa o* r» IH •a in 01 O CD io i H • ?. tt H h iloha ** a [ft \M 1 .^s... 1 m tt ? tt |f| Relative to to H H o» O* ;0I Rank fi ii o 8 | \ . CD a m «• i...... S

= 0* O* O i r-.athe Itt oi o < cn tt !• 10 © | m g(Uph§) o « .... { r x i*.;* i- H Relative to H H I 0 tt 'tt H H O tt iW Rank

I Jfent o* H ©Time t-1 CP O © j tD H 03 l^j <3 O B i*-"*-® JO -•^a O l^^' i_ tt JlJI 2 19 Relative to a 10 to to H I- OI ^ Rank o \ I j tt H o 8 ! tt $» M i ] id! \ Mathe (K) *> M ;« o» i to j H ...W..

- Cm Relative 10 H H H to H Rank h h 11; •fi cs I a i o i a o o o ! [ c ft o* O O I.3.... j

i : to ^4 i « a *•

»— t t i i •a 8 si s tt si g) a 8} 3 j Quarter £ o i ri d »l 2nd 6 I tt tt H 03 •si j t»! O e ft on oi O <^rtar <& a j i * -f

: : i :

CD I pi ^ tt ! ^3 of ,j a wj o o -.uartor ui m i • H a> : i * fcLJj S 1 ! P^ge 95

GO * ^ 1 H3 o o o CD I s a I B o H o ct 5 K iH w O I iS 7 O m I I 1 O 0

53

I I 4- I I I j -V: ( \ +: I I h -H +i 4; +[ I 4 + i + \ + I +j I +| + ( 4 +

P :i>l I Oi|W»lH*| ^l^OIHWlHMOIOiUlHOOJCO Oil W Oiro to* HC* COtO HoiH» A ES 1

oioa U*H 0)^ cat* co|o c*w a>j*c*&& oi wsiS. pn d* * C* o B i ... ..

j OtfU+jC* Substrain- t 61 OK) * * *M 0i* 0) W OitO CflH 0» 04 MO €»> tftjo -4W £00*0 .0 •j | 1 -j } | i h i A i * 0* to OJO O CA -4 H -«fM 03 H «io O* 0) 0 COM H»H to: * iM* <* W W H<0; ion B C sio *C*<* ^lltlpll~ i 04 iNO *» 19 CJCA 01 CO #» * G*W 0*UI Otj* OlOl * ^ jo elation A * * ' >"i ' j»f M w 1*1 Multipll* i ££*tlon B I ! •i I jJLv 1st m O A.

0» ^vision £ ° » V... Dpnomlnate i 4«» H»S •* CM S«IO«W#rt0|O » 0O» « *» HtO WW CB C» do ® Ui.N0S A f. - ! j- j- ' i ** J | ) if I i© |^nominat« «0 HOW O) W H OH W65 W «3 ^tOW HUMHVlSuMOQ>>OW«0 ..Mliij £

i • i : : i : A ^rac» Mil if B g5 H o Interest Oi d A f Interest S m B H Mensuration i h A

! ! I j a I j j [ ; J j I I M Ileneuratlon f Vi^^^^w^od^ciiwc^ Ij a Totals CO H 63! 0J tO H» ip^M ^ 1^(0 O H 003 -s4 0»iP^ j k Qftft-i »IC0 a o b S H ltd in in in j m «3 !H iO» 10* ;U3 :rf^ Hank A IH Hi tH !H ; lalative co m* m lo» Hank B Pare 96 ttf WW* Of 1 <0 m 9 ft 9 a a 3 0 w i»0 0 HI r

r

m i aubstrao-

H j Si on A

°> * ! <%lon 1

Is I on

l fir. j

«

<* b

...

Relative {ank 4 lolotlve Hank B 1 Pace 97 •0 t4 B M

I I I I + 4-1 ' I #1+1 +; 4 I +| +lf "+h +1 +1 4 I + Vddition

r * if

i i u St&etrfte* -a co u»*a k o> ho q>&a #4 #> to on A

* In d. Htton B

! O I'll' ]JK Multipli- 01 6»W Ol 03 &ic* 05 On UH CF»« 0)1 ^ OO ^^WHC^WU So H cation k

f fir-it*' t& i • • # -a wen u» too cn toco &*> o>h ww 0? w pn ot«4 H a Hultipii* o H -a to q Ration B

"] rM'^'ion H a fg k j

i i I - : \W ? rMviBian O » c iH 05 c* I

' ' 3

j "t? TDfnominate B <0 1 <* <>H 1*^ W^ * ! 0) w •( w & 9 I j Q^V ^ H B I.. ..

• •

oi Jito

•1 1 1 1 1 h -m D*0# to <* I H CP T|lff j • qui cito cd h wo a o> to^ h o i okn i oi 4^ h oiHHo B 1 ^ • • CD ft* i i ; ; ; i : :

10 IjN h*{o H w w *• W A ^ i± c dp* b ho H 9° M 9^ f*" P gi Inttreai K die H c dto M O OO rfHO WH co qp 0< CO oo WH o wt CO Mensuration r o H o A.

i ! \ \ \ j. . ,. i |, j j I I I h I Sen surat i on

W j i mh ^^O0HCi^dOHHHWHWiK«0WHW toco cb s 8 it* I tin d HH^ Totals • : I « A j j co o 1 -T6«als" n 38 ie 4^ cn CD a: i cc is 119 il KB B * j

t0 j$* ! -a j nelitive ! CO it* ! to to L Rank k

- •i- V 'Relative |S [SI |» |S U |8 |8 |S|8 Hank B P p p | p •y**- *• , v L page y#

I

'£dltl on

yiditt on 05 * ob * ubstrac* glon A

- ! bstrao- I to €0 01 loa B

« « gallon k 1 1 Sat Ion B vision

IDivisfton O H » * g B 4 5 i nounlnate

Trae* Dffi JS

!

! J a h h Interest ? "A &

•si

i* ! suratlon

Menaurat i n

teas

tale IfB Relative Hank A Hel atlvo *ank B ' Page 99

Q r .iti \%Ce Ot !•(!) P (SO 0) CP <* » OO ;& id CS P O *$ O- O Q\ * M» HO O ^iO Hf tf S 3 D 1 1*3 10 1 O O^O**** * oioiHioii o H» p © P

> tj ' 3 p » «0 J>;0 f»fj *J » ^ » 2 * ^1 ^IPO P »1 Pj c*H» 0»m

; r\ ii 0 o do 3 * d *i TO • W * h- i i ,9 :P 9 CD 0 cp !« O a> *$ 0 on o im '&w fc&i io ! »* i o>* o o c& • 8

* ! * I ft m i *4 ig * 1 ii n i

: o» I I i 1 Addition m H L L r i° P

I ! I 1 1 life i - I II J U j i» Jk H w J 0

i L r r f ! tp <* f ;r | If l Addition ia -a _<» ci i I 1 w ; jj I ] 4 ^5

! »• Wan. A ft ! I B P I I P H I C : b ^ h » p r o | M « r if 1 i ^ 1 WSfiT 01 w » jH ,, m. Hi. . .!*«!>...I.

o» in - • iw .» h i 1..;.: .Jf*.!• ! mt.l.on....A j SL

9 . ^* ^ , L I I r >- w if r V ^ Muitipuo- i ^ P* ! w atlon B §

i 1 i * In Division ft .1...... j \ ....H... .£ A 1 j § w*A D| vie ion 0 * r 'A ^ 0 <*» -a P | in i B v j j A) P ii j Denominate • <* k 1 -a o M.. 1 ^ ...... ^Ii-^n.., 1 Koa. A P dD » Ih fj ! '» • Denominate b at iU io f O 0 In I j u —4 ...p.. ..jfc JP...... mm- in w Deo., ^ j » ?rao. i 0 j Ih « id) 1 # P.O. Sqt# A S j t : > A •[: i 0 -2 t r • : 1 Frao. Tea, 01 g r j w B P # ...I jn.. JfcJU Sift* I h j ! Interest i ? ^ t* iP \ r: A 1 1 1 \ y - F £» t r t i -i j

1- . h : w h h H pw interest to ^ L B ! i j P I I f. r gM S ! J°1 1 Mensuration^ p ^ j r I b II r w S3 i I 1 A, 1 P ] j ;.„g j± j j] j j Jg Mensuration i L L Jl if b ji * ! m H pa in h 4

0 ! - 0 Aft 1 1 m 1'at. A

B I p p p..Li I v ! i b I S p C r 1

' i of ! Average j (* £ ± # P , w ** 7 ! I C T* Combined Test S If !•*•»• i i 1 IH La i i L.aa W 4 M v iv T

2« ^fi « « h ^ m 53jt?i« £ g o o w » o*< © <& P o o g* $9

p tr <& * » a a 2 50 >i r * I I H I t ;0 ;» ) V g P H M

r ! ; I W M i i, . . * ] . I Addition in h V* H m E 1 if Ik h i ^ fit * *» P . c» 1* 4 »- P # c» Ml" I* *t in iH p ~_ o r 1 i i Fiji Bir10 o» *> m 01 K o *o c* if o * « M j*. ©> o m , Co ! tion

i i i Cj i i i 1 i ! ...I i 1 i : ; j 1 j ]

fa S C h P Si 81 * IS ;5 ^ H ^ h If |« §* h h » iH ;h 1h h Im m Divisionw # |H " fl 1^4 ;<0 Hi. ; 9 |l Mk f P P p J» |H i* * ^ ^ M Denominate E K a » oe I { k % I I M |l I » B g

.... Dec* H H H H H M H H H U ! m o o» © o O M m ;h pg ;* p I I 9 ^ « » ^ ISquiy^

" P : '» r !— — f h''"1h i -H fi5 -w iR" I in !U aO oCfi cu03 Hh >0)o Cm04 Oicm 05a wW o»O m mwonInterest

c J T H H KensarHtion" p a 1° P a P ill o M H m r si

i - MA Inn iiiii - if h Combined p P po ;» 9 S + U P !p

...... j.,. ...^ I i

"J ! M .j « !N 'pT" ' H ^ m to [It w 1 » ** • w \d^itl on Ob

jjjjjji™ -^abstrac- [ In w •a |H to p P 00 IIP tion 1 i

1 t Mttitiplic- I* H "6 m h o !* 6 |v IP H ;° H i 1 at ion :jS

CO in bf in - 1 IB U Division ^,1 ! -a \m id Hi I* i : CO O

i ...j j 03 "lii hr 03 | ^ 'm 0 ! r f j« I I P |p 3 ; | lumbers i : \- £ i 9wm* 9m$

H* ! !<• a m Mi | ;# |h m |t i| i [I 2quiv# B i i : |*

i J .; ! i : H i T» Tin ! If iO 1"* O o 8 IS 8 \m \ !® Interest I j " 1 j " H 1 fe- w ;4H CI \m m N c ut ion iw Mensuration j rn in j : If i i I j "|- — ! f i -I

H in !h co h i i Combined s IS Hi % jH * |s (h w to =oi j» 8 [s i j Teats \ 1 s i - 1 •4 •!•"" (- o -4— 4 i i i i i i 1 : : i i i | f i : : i i 1 ! i i ! i i i ..i . ... JL i -4 •4 4, S i1 age 101

.-n B ' : °» ; I I & I1 1 1K I IH ! p ! M s 0» *J I ff f f ' s o

fe- i : 1 i

...... at

; ' Addition k H to k U fei] co ! P ...,], i : : & It 4* P JB il P p P P P ttoi .. ... 3 fiT i £ i § i k !e teniae. at Ion him s ;H H H H H Division

k j H Denominate 9 1 h P 1 C* P jj P I I P Numbers C M J M 8 0> c* to # Squlv, [ 4 IS £ g * 8 5= £ » f i Mensuration - Ob I II I I I I • I •

I I i nl | j l v iM H H * H ddlti on a - H oi »

t 1 bo m L Is is ^ub.tmo.« 1 *> :** fen £ S p «c P H tion

: : : :

I b I P m o> P F F btlon J?S

! [ j ; j t i I co m m to ^ to h i h Division h • m P P || P p - Id P m~ PMjP j g ^ c.> m iDonominats i H H to .c pt, P f p # - IP !• Nimbera £ S K ^not Dec* > p j| Squiv, tnterest H O O U a S |§ ^ i# j*

H H H itw ««»^^lon jg U [a. | P ^ p V i * i- i I-

L w i L» u i» u L ! fisTestsi"** - p I h I 1' I 1 4 fl f i I f ^ i ! ! I ! [ I I I J j_

i 1 I . I I 1 ] : i ! ? i ; 1 i ' I I l I i ! : : ! ! j | ;

»-•*• I. -^.-„...... -it- i...... a- ».i ^. . . — Par e 102 o s c 1 —1- __1 s 1 r- \

\ O

Cr-

> o >< r- < H Hi

03 Co ft o < TO

Co cu' o n ^ o -v ~Tn

to °i o

**<

Co

i -;> n to 1 f 1 n •c 11 1] 1 / M i II 1 il tl i 1 > at c ——

I 1 -4*1- o n> rs < o> Co -> — — V is- a- 1 * O 5 t3 e O O 3 o <

1

1 > i H- 2 to — 1 t> ^ s — •

r a.

Tv \ ( K> —i 1 1 1 o si

nT

«•

r- H Se 2 m n> r\ A* o

rr- o>

Co Cl Co

Q*

Co -> > o \ Lki H * o

I*

Co

* r— < 1 r m ^ r j 1 \ tl

to ^ Hi co fC: < 4 — Hi OV

Co ^ p o Co Hi Co O a. ^3 n

^3 rrt 5 - Pa^e 104

o o SH

rf <

CO m ^ QJ o 0_ 3 -aa

o m o Ui o

—3

r>5

Z5' (

ji n it n li It K /i :> ^ ^3: H i t < Hi Hi Hi n o Co Co a. PI XX 2 o a) T n o o Co Co 0> a Co — q o o rv a o' ^ rS o Pi o 5 m i — . .05 2^ >0 N > L C o > o o — i —1— — -»— — -'"so Pi — > P

_ <

cJO m m o a

CL.

m ---—^ ^5 r*>

1 a- p\ o

a,

m -tj rn ^

ii II n n u ii II K II -Tl fcj fc} ^ ~^ k* H — o

^ ^ r r- r> o

a.

Co c-o ^ s? to 3 S S 3 o x 5 ^5- ^ ^ * l> ape 106

T4BI/S WO.

Table of Comparison Hesults 1936-1937 Drills* section Check Jeotl m

aoore :irror Score ;rror Inor«*ase Peoreare Increase Decrease Percent °qrcsnt Percent Peroral t

Addition A 1 30 -5 2 10 10 B 27 -2 19 4 Jubtracti on 20 0 35 10 A 2 1 B 16 7 24 5 teulti plication 30 10 20 -10 A 1 2 B 26 14 7 -10

Division 40 0 10 0 A 1 2 B 32 6 11 0

Denominate 0 0 0 A 2 1 3.4 Fumbers B 1*3 2.6 2.6 4.7

*rac» Deo. 30 -10 20 5 A 2 1 % TSouiv. B 17 -1 6 7

20 10 20 0 Interest A 1 2 B 20 12 6 24

30 -10 -10 "'enauratlon A 1 2 0 B 29 -5 5 -13

Combined Testa A 23.9 -1.2 15 • 6 B 19.9 3.6 9.9 1.9

A- Median B- Average 1- IIA Section 3- IIB lection

Interpretation of ttasults:

It should be remembered that the groups were rotated this year to offset the differences of group ability*

i'he results shown in the table above and in tables XVI $

XXV and JQtXXTg which show the results of the previous three

1 years work are in many rospect3 t quite similar* In the units in Pftff 107

which the Ilk section was used as the drilled group, It showed the greatest increase in both speed and accuracy In all oases.

In the units In which the 113 section was used as the drilled group, it showed the highest score increase In fraction deol al percent equivalents hut was lowest in both speed and accuracy in subtraction and denominate numbers*

The results of the combined tests aho* that the drilled group has doubled the score Increase and the error decrease of the cheek group* These rajults ara similar to tfao^e of pre- vious ye*\rs,

the comparison of the intelligence teat scores found in table XLI on page 108 shows very similar results to ti.ose of previous years, the ease of the Eenfc»3hakow tests In comparison with the other tests Is again apparent* There was also a wider difference of intelligence between the ts»o groaps or students.

The IIA group had from ten to sixteen percent nl^her scores

than the I IB group on all tests.

The comparison of the quarter marks, found in table 7X17

both have mad-' good progress. on pa#e 105 # tfo^s that groups

It should be remembered that both groups were rotated as th© the drill and check sections, fc noticeable leveling off of

series Is a** own in the second and thir^ quarters of the spphomore

year* This fact indicates thnt the effect of drill on both

groups is showinp up as in previous years.

The comparison of the first and third quarter marks of the

sophomore year, found in tables XXXV and XXXYI, sho*a that the Pa^e 103

IIA section bad an a vera re Increase of 7% and a median increase of The IIB section had an average Increase of 15 # 5*> and a median inoreaae of 10£ for the same period*

The IIA group had a yearly overage nark of 77*9* and a median yearly average mark or 79*£*» for the sopnonore year*

The IIB group had a yearly average marie of 69#4*j and a modi an yearly average mark of 75* for the same period*

i'he oonparison of the mean and median deviations of the first and third quarters of the sophomore year, found in tables

XXXV and HOOD!* ah owe that the IIA group had a mean deviation decrease of 2«7 and median deviation decrease of 3* The IIB group had a mean deflation decrease of 6.3 and a n»dlan deviation decrease of 5,8 for the same period*

All of the above faota indicate that the effects of drill are showing up as in previous years, as indicated by the quarter marks a" Mil as the diagnostic test scores. Par© 109

SHAFTS V

Summary and Conclusions

The summary of the four years •work to determine whether or not diagnostic tests, followed by drill in the fundamental processes, should be ua^d in the teaching ngrioulturnl

arithmetic ie found on th* followinp pa?;es #

The author realizes that the nuiribar of oases Meted una not great enough to establish noma. Likewise, the selection of the groups by intelligence quotient ratings, if it had been possible, would have eliminated the variation of group ability* H 110 1 to Ol 2 O J at 8 O >1 r * I? i | | 04 C£ i S id i o i « i* gM I' A

O O D to 03 to i o is I" to plagnoatlo * • ft i loo to tc ill

1^ #> O Ml i • I Moha 0> .*> CD «o o t Alpha 5 2 to I 0u £ Matha i m -a | to * { to Kent * • Tirao sj 'c* u : 1" ; M -a

m 55' ilk o finl No * pi © < § O H SI s -4 No Time # * M S) •"4 *»! 0:

oa i a m •- S3

CP O \ m Fumow of IN 8 Sasee

•!« » «- i- -J-" I Diagnoetlo H W Alpha ar to I 5 alfehe 7S- i Tent ' :> *-« Time o H TlBO HI Tina

-> fr- 5 i Iritha ' Kant No ?lma

? O .1 ,1 4 ] }

I Pare 111 H H4 ^ i -a B I se si; « 8 I I cn hi a> I* ago ft 6 ft | 0 k i 4 i 2

i-

I : m m dumber of : ! o a 04 0XJ j <° * j jCaaos

1 | 1 I-

i io o ; i frill S « I ^Addition £to to I A

• ^ : C : AddltlOIX | i : L B o Subatrao- <« tl on A

i j» i i 3u atraa- j f

• i tl on B i . i

: : *. iMultlpll- •* cation A "] --If* 1 j Multlpll- : p, i ! 1* ; ; i — i j datlon B : : : : j»

i DWisi on A r;w

\ \ \ jk w o =« ! ! Division

im : g J Denominate CI as tfa*. 4_ :> Denominate a Noa* B

...f,

ifrao. Deo* f iM.

A

Int or est 04 a Mensuration A •^ensurati on B Totals » Wi A Totals i B > i. : s Pare 112 o MBS -J fcrf o o 5 » 0) 5 o

! I- H |S^baor of £S8 to - 1** CO Hp c*

i jl

:« p Addition H it B

j 01 •Mi CO 3 t i on A • 8

01 ; no if i i tion B !^«.

:

t :& i Kultipliea-

: • ^ m j u ti on A c h§ to • • i i tton B 00 M ISS DlvlBion CD H A i liTiB'ibn I

9 4t to D«Bomi'nat«

o = »•*• A si : & ^> v- s Denominate No*. B Q ("Hi! -f-«a a Frao* Doe.

* ! i O 3 % Sq. A r frao. Dae. ! r • j O O j

i Sep 1 Int oroct A • 0) f -h ! i CO 1 |H CP * tp o M i fl Interest en I i • B H I Fl 1 u> if 01 : ensurati -m O I [ • i I H A H * • c* H Memurfttion O Ol I * i f O i B

: n •i Total s i • ^ • r r m I A •11..... cni

to Tot al P] • CO; B SI C ! ..-#! I tO • r 4 1 «...f

.i» l.« j. 8 9 Page 113

to to ^0 0 tO t* «* a cue « ST® I § 0OH 3 ? 1 V i L-j p : 1 H* H* CD f o 05 1 9 o si ^3 S 5s O ST I ft X aI

•I I. Iffumber of I™" » : H

oi oi c i to jOasas W 01 to to <3 C r o ^ J ^ Co « ! «3 05 A H vdditi on

: » • it ; • 1 B 1 1. CD Jt. : ; * If H H jSubstrae* cn tl on A r ** u

! : H Wit I M F iBulbstrab* I O j itlon B to ; i »* } I'M i W nil (Muitipiio- * * * eft i atton K si i l-m- H MuitipTio- « • ; # to iation B • m NH «o

i o* :t)iT'iai'bh o i • is CO C) if 03 A | s r* ""tilvlei'on" if 8*8 Ig B -rim-

t tro* <0 ! to ! CO W CO 9 - en:) .In at HI

tO * ; ^ S-l • Noa, A fl5-i->3-

SI H : cn H p i renominate O Nos, B on *J ! i -m-t * ft to o*h ifrao, Uao« j O icn I H ftQ* Sq, A to yH I ! 03 ! a ! tiii J* W H Frac • D«o« a a O • H f.C# Sq. B H l£ «0 W 1 01 etfito Intar^at si | j i w o A

i- £0 ^05 H J « H ''Inter ea't' O jO is SI l» p to B

to ...4. to J A r 'ilansur at 1 on • f

i • • i o ! i H A j.K. to 1...0J

H ! 'Sifan'au'rati'on a O ! £v r* Cv

sa I j B O j o to B to f 3 • • • i • i t I !

CJ> ! A "4 ! 0& j H ... |. 1 «o if Totals ? CP ! -a ill* a; B LL

i, E. Page 114

r

o

o Q

3 t1

K

*< O

1

8

HI 9

Man su rati on A Mensuration 1 o Pa^e IIS

i H M o o ct

to Oases snr

Quarter >i 3 _ 0 tj fcuartar I o

Quarter g J -* Yearly ^ F iraraga pT tno. Of »at » Quarter to

Quarter MJ? Quarter 3rd a #t* Quarter 5 1 t Yearly V Vfl; e

1st uartor

2nd Puarter £ 3rd tuartar g tearly * ATarage T; ino# of 1st

|? £

o «• — 2nd ..uartor g 3rd h< Quarter I H -a Yearly * jyanti * j — Inc. of 1st 0v* 3rd *,ua rter * A » j p (3 1 6 i \, co- c— i > — ,. ] -4 n |

i

a J> < rr- «•

:> < r ) *< 1— o

1 3 3 HO a r v f <: .— Co' 5 o 3 r r-i Ci— Co

)

'—

Co r>

«-j—

t c

c

rn

CP m o ^> c k \i n ii w 111 ^> O a o a. <^ r 1 o~ I o <^ is Co & o . o n Hh Ci p- o $ ;s i Co K

3 | ~1 Pago 117

6^ O 0\ ^ ^ _t 1 ) j 1 _X_

Hi O 2

Co o

s

z II 11 11 Co ^> ^ 0 ^ Hi O- CL. n -1- — - Hi

s s r> o ^ nP C^i o n n> o is

Q ^ (n

2 PS Page 118

Sri

3 o

DO [- < o 2 o Hi u o O

Hi O

U II If n il II il II n i\ Co ^ ^ n ^4 t> ^ ^ a n a ^ i Ob Q3 Co O O Co Co Hi n 0 a -in -i- o Co

.5 St ST*

Co — Pare 119 OO

1 v o - k !

1 1

t

<

n o CO3

CL

o.

) ^ o

11 m w n ii n ii ii ^ n ^

~ a c^i °- ^ Co Co £Z K ± ^ & a. £a. a ^ 0> Hi a O Co 8 S 5 5 sitQ> -2£ ^ X 2s * ^ ? S5 ^ ^age 130

TABLS NO. LVI

Comparison of Four Years Results 1933-1937 Drilled -action Check Jection

Score 3rror -ioore ^rror Increase Decrease Increase Decrease 'oroent Percent Percent Pepoon^

A 17.5 3.5 -3.3 -.7 Addition B 14,3 1.6 -1.1 1.3

A 12 .2 .9 10.9 iub tract ion 5.2 B 11.4 5.9 6.9 -.5

A 25.3 -.5 1.3 .6 yultl all ant 1 an B 30 5. 6 9.2 -1.8

A 17.4 • 7 3.6 6 B 17.2 4.9 7 3.4

A 14.5 6.2 9 Denominate 1.9 B 12 7 9.6 Numbers 3.8 A 23.9 .2 16.5 5.3 *rao. Dec. B 16,3 .1 1 .7 2.7 1 ISquiv.

A 13.3 1 2 • 3 1-1.5 14 Interest B 16.9 11.2 13.6 7.8

A 12.4 1.6 -7.3 1.5 Mensuration B 11.3 .4 -6.3 -1.8

A 17.7 3.1 6.1 4.2 Combined Tests B 15 4*8 6,5 1.9

A-» Median •ft Average

Interpretation of Keaults:

The results of the oonbinea four yearsH eating program shown in the table above are very sioilar to those of the individual years. The drilled groups show a very marked increase of both speed and accuracy above the o^ee-c groups in all oases. Although the jseora increase shows up greater than th« error decrease in all tests, both are T.ore than double t^osg of the check groups. Page 131

The oombined summary of the lntelllgsnee test scores is found in table X71 on pa^e 110, The eoorea are alnllar in many respects for all four years, Saoh year's results ahow that the dlagnoatlo test eoorea ere closely correlated with the Army Alpha and the Army Alpha Ma the test aoorea. The Kent-ohakow Mathe time teat has scores similar to the above tasta during two of the four years. However, the other three rent-ohakow teat scoria ahow that they are too eaay for tha mental nga of this group of students.

The comparison of the oombined scores of the intelli^noe testa for the first three years is^ found in table LII on page

116, It seems-: best not to include the scores of the 1936«*37 groups beoausa they sere both used as drille: and check groupa,

"i'he scores of the Army Alpha, the Army Alpha Maths and tbe

Diagnostic tests s ow that the drilled groups have made an average score of from 4& to 6% higher than the oheok groups. The median scores of the drilled groups are from S$ to Tfrt higher than ths oheov groups for these three tests. The average aoorea o" the Kent-Shakos tests are from 7 3/4 to 14$ higher for the drilled groups, while the nwdlan aoorea of these testa are from Zh to 13$ higher for the drilled groups.

Thus the scores of all Intelligence testa indicate that the drilled groups had ths highest intelligence.

The comparison of the oombined quarter marks for the first three years are found in table LT on page 119. It again seemed Page las

beat not to Include the marks of the l936-»37 groups beoausy they were both rotated as drilled and oheok groups. The ojmperlson of the first and third quarter marks or the freshman year, found In table LI, shows that tho groups which were drilled in the eophoaore year haTe made en average increase of 12,4% and a median lnoroaee of 11,7%, The oheok groups have made an average inoraise of 13.3$ and a median Increase or 12. 5i for the same period.

» The drilled groups have a yearly average nark of 74.2$ and a median yearly average mark of 77,l£ for the freshsian year. The oheok groups have a yearly average lark of 68.9$ and a median yearly avarage mark of 69.8*) for the same period.

It must be remembered that the effeot of drill on the marks

Is not apparent until the aeoond quarter of the sophomore year*

It should also be noticed that the effect of drill during the year 1934- '35 la Included In the above ave-ages. This fact tends to show higher marks and a greater increase In progres for the drilled groups during the freshman year, than Is actually true.

The comparison of the first and third quarter marks in the sopaomore year shows that the drlllei grouse nave made an average inorease of 10. M% and a median inorease of 10,? 6. The oheo\- groups have made an average inorease of 6,7% and a median inorease of 3,3$ for the same period,

The drilled groups have a yearly average mark of 74,4% and a median yearly average mark of 77,4* for the sophomore year. The check groups have a yearly ^verape mark of 69,3$ and a median yearly average mark o** 71. "$% for the same cerlod. * Paeo xm

Conclusions:

Tho results of t"e combined four fears 1 work seem to warrant the ftQ.lowtnc conclusions:

1* That the drilled croups have made a definite Increase in progress above the oheek ftrouT>s, as indicated by the marks as well as the diagnostic tent scores.

2* That the drill had more Influence mon aoore incr^se than upon error decrease, whloh seams to Indicate that drill increases speed more than accuracy.

3. That diagnostic teste reveal pur>lld weaknesses which are not detected by the teacher when oorreotlnr their papers*

4# That carefully planned drill is effective in correcting the #eaknes;:es of the pupils

5* *hat drill is effective in securing a more homogeneous

grouping 9 as is shown by the decrease in the mean and median deviations of the marks*

6 f finally, that the teacher cannot teach efficiently with- out flrat diagnosing the weaknesses of the pupils and then care* fully planning corrective exercise.

Suggestions!

! The author advises the use of a master sheet, similar to the one found in table XL on pa#es 100 and 101, on the olass bulletin board, to show the relative ranks of the students in e^oh test* Such a plan as this one helps to stimulate Interest and enthusiasm on the part of the pupils, by oreating a spirit of rivalry. £• though the correcting and soorine of the diagnostic tests t^ke^ a cons id arable part of the teachers ti re, the author believes that this is the only wa; in *hioh the teioher oan really discover the *eakne&&ea of the pupils* After all, there is no preater eatis^.oti m in teaching than to watch the puoils 1 progress* Anything that the teacher enn do to Increase thie p r©pr ea s will pay dividends to the tencher t the pupil and society, by helping to equip the individual for his llftfts work* . .

Page 125

BIBLIOGRAPHY

1. Bagley, mil am •« and MaoDonald, Marlon 2, Standard

EttjUiai ia Teaching . The MabMlllan Co., New York, 1933.

2. Brown, Joseph C§ and Ooffmat;, Lotus D« The Teaching of /irlthmetlc . How, Peterson and Co., Ken York, 1924.

3. Buawell, Q. T. and John, Lenore, DlaCTOatlo studies In Arithmetic . Sduoational Monograph Wo. 30,, University of Chicago, 1930.

4. Knight, F, B», Ruoh, G. M., and Studcbaker, J, f M

Standard Service \rlthmetlo . Joott Foreman and Co., Chloago, 1929.

Llde, T 5. 3dwin 3., Instruction In Kathematlcm . Bulletin > o.

17 Ponograph 33 Unit ad States Department of Interior,

Office of Education, 1933

f 6. ^robst , Slla, \n Investigation of the astknes -.es In the

Fundamental Operations in Arithmetic The Third

Yearbook of the Elementary School of Principals, 1922.

7. Regan, 0. f. Fundamentals of Teaching. :oott, Foreman and Company, New York, 1933

9. Tiegs, Srneat 7. Test a and ate-u-mr^nant s for Teachers .

Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston, 1931,

9. Vllson, Guy M. Corrective Load in the fundamentals of

Arl thmet lo in Grades olx . .>qven , and Urht in lj:

Representative Town3 and Cities in the Metropolitan

Boston Area, Boston Tally Globe, February 25, 1937. I'age 126

I am very glad at this time to have the oppor- tunity to express publicly ray appreciation for the advice and encouragement given to me during the prooeas of developing this theais. Many persona have been helpful, but I would irention espeoially

Pro feasors V* 3. Velles, W # ff # Chenoweth, K« D. Boutelle, and Mr* Arthur L, Daoy* Graduate Coamlttao

r.mtf