ONTARIO PLACE | The Value of ’s Public Space January 2020 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Ontario Place has more sustainable long-term value as a high-quality, public space that will create diverse benefits for the regional community.

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 2 Since 2005, new public spaces and community venues have expanded along Toronto’s central waterfront edge.

Sherbourne Common (2009) (2012) (2009) Corktown Commons (2013) Park (2007)

Marilyn Bell (2006) Aitken Place (2019)

Cherry Beach Sport Fields (2006)

Waters Edge Promenade (2010) York Quay (2012) (2010) HTO Park(2007) Harbourfront Promenade (2005) In Progress • Rees Street Park Spadina Quay Wetlands (2007) • York Street Park • Park Bentway (2018) • Promenade & Davis Trail (2017) • Don Greenway

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 3 The success of the city during this time is the direct result of this strategic investment in waterfront open spaces that are public- focused, well-maintained, and thoughtfully programmed.

Toronto’s waterfront….

✓Prioritizes essential public nature of a region’s natural amenities and assets

✓Accommodates a wide mix of activities and promote new ways for people to use the waterfront

✓Forges connections between dispersed destinations and surrounding communities

✓Promotes continuous and intuitive mobility throughout the city’s urban fabric

✓Integrates with existing economic activity and orients future growth

✓Serves all spectrums of a community’s diverse population

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 4 Toronto’s waterfronts are economic engines that are inextricably linked to the identity and vitality of the city.

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 5 Forward-thinking cities across are actively investing in public space and reclaiming their waterfront assets for public use.

New York City | $1.5B+ invested in Dallas | 200-acre redevelopment Seattle | $0.7B invested to San Diego | 40-acre makeover of the new public spaces, community plan underway to create the transform 26 blocks of shoreline Embarcadero to expand public destinations, and waterfront largest urban park in the U.S. into a seamless, connective tissue access and create a central parks over the last 20 years along the Trinity River between Downtown destinations waterfront attraction for the city

Washington D.C. | 5+ new signature Houston | $1.0B invested to Philadelphia | 3+ new waterfront Boston | $25B invested in cleanup waterfront parks created over the diversify its public spaces and parks and trails created over the and launched Boston Waterfront last decade along both the transform the bayou network into last decade to transform both Initiative to build a new network Potomac and Anacostia Rivers active public destinations sides of the Delaware River of public spaces along the harbor

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 6 This trend is also occurring in international cities that are trying to maintain or reinvent their image as vibrant waterfront communities.

Sydney | $6B invested to | Expansive public plans Madrid | 6-km linear park Seoul | $0.9B invested to expand the vibrant harbor are targeted at expanding created along a sunken create a network of linear district to include 54-acres of public access along the Seine motorway to reconnect the parks and public spaces new development and public River to increase year-round city center and adjacent along a daylighted urban spaces use and activity neighborhoods to the river stream

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 7 These investments in high-quality public waterfront assets are driven by two primary motivations.

LONGEVITY OF BENEFITS DIVERSITY OF BENEFITS

The long-term, The diverse variety enduring nature of of community benefits that stem benefits generated from high-quality by high-quality public spaces. public spaces.

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 8 High quality public spaces are unique because their investment horizon is much longer than any commercial use.

Central Park | 1960s Central Park | Today (60 years later)

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 9 The evaluation of costs and benefits of investment decisions must incorporate multiple criteria.

Commercial Use (w/ limited public access) Investment Decision Evaluation Criteria ▪ Upfront Investment Cost ▪ Ongoing Investment Cost Investment Decision ▪ Associated Community Benefits ▪ Benefits Lifespan

Public Space Use ▪ Public Risk

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 10 When compared to public space uses, commercial uses will typically create short-term improvements but at the expense of long-term, enduring benefits.

▪ Risk of decline and public subsidy

Commercial Use ▪ Risk of commercial failure (w/ limited public access) ▪ 20-30 year investment life span ▪ Recurring need for significant reinvestment

Investment Decision

▪ Lower public risk Public Space Use ▪ 50-100 year investment life span ▪ Ongoing maintenance and moderate upgrades

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 11 Another motivation for investing in high quality public spaces is their ability to create significant and measurable benefits for their respective regions.

REAL ESTATE TOURISM SOCIAL & CULTURAL TALENT ATTRACTION BENEFITS BENEFITS BENEFITS BENEFITS

The ability of public The additional The improvements The influence spaces to increase tourism public public spaces public spaces have development value spaces attract, and create in healthy on attracting and and serve as the associated lifestyles, social retaining residents, orienting anchors spending cohesion, and workers, and for new growth generated in the quality of life employers economy.

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 12 REAL ESTATE BENEFITS TOURISM BENEFITS SOCIAL & CULTURAL BENEFITS TALENT ATTRACTION BENEFITS Public spaces increase the value of adjacent properties, accelerate the volume of development, and serve as orienting anchors for new growth.

Since the has more than Across the U.S. public revitalization began, To-date, Toronto’s 400 high-rise projects spaces have increased the has waterfront public spaces in the pipeline, the average pace of adjacent become one of the have attracted more than majority of which are development by as much fastest growing real $21.5B in private real concentrated along the as 1.4X - 3.0X estate markets in North estate investment waterfront America

Intentional investment in New development along Across twelve signature 63% of future space under public space along the Toronto’s waterfront, public spaces, properties construction near waterfront has anchored includes more than 1.5M within a .8km radius Toronto’s waterfront is new neighborhoods SF of new commercial experienced an average preleased and vacancy including , development and 5K real estate premium of has dropped to , and housing units 17% over citywide values historic lows Quayside

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 13 REAL ESTATE BENEFITS TOURISM BENEFITS SOCIAL & CULTURAL BENEFITS TALENT ATTRACTION BENEFITS Given its location, Ontario Place will have significant real estate implications on and diminished public space will impact its value creation potential.

• 192 acres of prominent real estate at Exhibition Place will be more valuable if public open space at Ontario Place is preserved Exhibition Place

• Proximity to Ontario Place is a value driver for any potential future Ontario Place development on Exhibition Place or nearby neighborhoods

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 14 REAL ESTATE BENEFITS TOURISM BENEFITS SOCIAL & CULTURAL BENEFITS TALENT ATTRACTION BENEFITS Well-designed public spaces become regional destinations that catalyze tourism and create incremental spending in the local economy.

More than 4,000 annual 50% of visitors to programs and events 2% increase in leisure Toronto’s waterfront parks Toronto’s waterfront parks at Toronto’s waterfront tourism associated with attract more than 17M are from international parks serve the city’s every 10% increase in visitors every year destinations outside diverse residents and public space investment visitors

Public spaces contribute Shoppers are willing to Surveyed shoppers to the “cumulative Public spaces encourage pay an average 9-12% reported a 30% higher attraction principle” both day and overnight “amenity margin” for satisfaction with the and the greater diversity visitors to stay longer goods in areas with quality of goods in areas of amenities broadens a in a region greater public space with greater public space city’s tourism appeal

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 15 REAL ESTATE BENEFITS TOURISM BENEFITS SOCIAL & CULTURAL BENEFITS TALENT ATTRACTION BENEFITS A rich portfolio of public spaces can enhance a community’s population health, public safety, social cohesion, and overall quality of life.

Public spaces create Toronto has embraced its To-date, the revitalization stable neighborhoods by 5% decrease in stress and identity as a waterfront of Toronto’s waterfront increasing social anxiety reported by city and preserving has created more than interaction between regular users of public uninterrupted public 750 acres of new open different groups and spaces access is critical to space and cultural venues increasing residents’ fulfilling this vision sense of belonging

99% of cities experienced Public space is associated Many kilometers of trails 15% decrease in the odds lower crime risk following with a 41% increase in the and cycling of being overweight for investment in public green odds of residents within a connections have begun residents living in areas space that averaged 1.5 – half mile engaging in to link Toronto’s with adequate parkland 3.8 fewer felonies per 1K regular light physical neighborhoods to the density residents activity waterfront public spaces

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 16 REAL ESTATE BENEFITS TOURISM BENEFITS SOCIAL & CULTURAL BENEFITS TALENT ATTRACTION BENEFITS Workers are flocking to cities that offer amenity rich lifestyles and employers are locating in areas where they can attract and retain this talent.

Public spaces create New public spaces have momentum for Public space investment is led to adjacent Local amenities are commercial associated with a 10-20% employment growth that particularly important to investment and tenants increase in regional outpaced their respective employees in knowledge relocate to benefit from retention of knowledge regions by an average of economy industries proximity to new economy workers 2-3% amenities

Young workers place 3X 20% of leaders of growing Public open space was A city’s quality of life more value on public companies named quality identified as the #5 site amenities increase the space and quality of life of life as a key factor for selection driver for attractiveness of a job by amenities compared to business location commercial tenants and more than 33% older workers decisions investors

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 17 REAL ESTATE BENEFITS TOURISM BENEFITS SOCIAL & CULTURAL BENEFITS TALENT ATTRACTION BENEFITS Since Toronto’s waterfront revitalization began, the region has become an increasingly competitive economic market and entered the upper echelon of global tech capitals.

International firms such as Last year, for the first time An annual index by the Uber, Sidewalk Labs, Since 2007, jobs in Toronto was named one Economist Intelligence Samsung, LG, and Toronto’s knowledge of the top five tech Unit ranked Toronto as General Motors have all economy industries have talent markets in the the #1 place to live in invested in new facilities increased by 32% world the world in 2015 near Toronto’s waterfront public spaces

Toronto has also experienced a growing In 2019, Toronto created The Toronto region is U.S. firms announced influx of millennials, more tech jobs than home to 40% of all more than $1 billion in the majority of which are San Francisco or any Canadian headquarters investment in Toronto in choosing to settle in other leading market in and generates 18.5% of September 2018 alone waterfront adjacent the U.S. combined the country’s GDP neighborhoods

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 18 Preserving public space at Ontario Place, a critical link in Toronto’s waterfront network, is a strategic investment in the city, its economy, and its communities that will last for generations to come.

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 19 Sources

“9 Steps for Creating a Great Waterfront”. Projects for Public Spaces. 2008. “Investing in Open Space.” Gensler. 2012. “A Review of Waterfront Toronto’s Tri-Government Approach to Revitalization”. . 2013. Ontario Place for All. 2019 “Beautiful City: Leisure Amenities and Urban Growth”. Journal of Regional Science. 2019. “Let’s Turn Ontario Place into a 21st Century Park”. Ontario Place for All. 2019. “Business District Streetscapes, Trees, and Consumer Response,” Journal of Forestry. 2005. “Levels of Nature and Stress Response.” Behavioral Sciences. 2018. “Canadian Tech Companies are Attracting More Overseas Talent”. Financial Post. 2018. “LG Opens New AI Lab with University of Toronto”. TI World Canada. 2018. City Parks Alliance. 2019. “Mayors Get It: Parks are Problem-Solvers”. Next City. 2014. City of Toronto. 2019 “Measuring the Economic Value of a City Park System”. Trust for Public Land. 2009. “Destination TO: Why Toronoto is Attracting Top Tech Talent”. Mars. 2018. “Millennials are Flocking to Toronto but We’re Not Sure Why”. Better Dwelling. 2019. “Environment and Crime in the Inner City: Does Vegetation Reduce Crime?” Environment and Behavior. 2001. “Parks Plan.” City of Toronto. 2017. Exhibition Place. 2019. “Plans Finalized for Phase One of Ontario Place Revitalization”. Urban Toronto. 2015. Financial Times. 2019. “Shored Up: How Toronto’s Waterfront Redevelopment is Going Right”. . 2014. “Five Ways Parks Provide a Return on Investment”. National League of Cities. 2016. Statistics Canada. 2019. “Gateway Cities Continue to Top Global Real Estate Investment Led By London”. JLL. 2019. “The Beauty Premium: How Urban Beauty Affects Cities’ Economic Growth”. City Lab. 2019. “GM Canada breaks ground for new 7-acres Mobility Campus”. CBC. 2018. “The Benefits of Parks: Why America Needs More city Parks and Open Space”. 2006. Google Earth. 2019. “The Future of Public Space is Now Arriving – Beneath a Busy Highway”. Sidewalk Labs. 2018. “Great Waterfronts of the World”. Projects for Public Spaces. 2007. “The U.S. Cities Winning the Battle Against Brain Drain. City Lab. 2016. Greater Boston Convention & Visitors Bureau. 2019. “The Waterfront Renaissance”. Projects for Public Spaces. 2007. “Growth to Watch for 2018: Toronto’s Central Waterfront”. Urban Toronto. 2018. “Toronto: Canada’s Tech Hub is Literally Booming” IPE Real Estate Assets. 2019. Happiness and Health Across the Lifespan in Five Major Cities.” Journal of Social Science & Medicine. 2016. “Toronto Ranked Best Place to Live in the World by The Economist”. Global News CA. 2015. . 2019. “Toronto Rises to No. 3 in CBRE North American Tech Talent Ranking”. CBRE. 2019. “How Cities Use Parks for Economic Development.” American Planning Association. 2002. “ Revitalization”. Urban Strategies. 2019. “How Cities Use Parks to Promote Tourism”. American Planning Association, 2005. “Toronto’s New Wave of Development Looks for Community, Not Just Condos”. Curbed. 2018. “How Smart Parks Investment Pays Its Way”. Ernst & Young. 2003. “Toronto’s Tech Boom Attracting Millennials Creating Condo Trends”. REMI Condo Business. 2019. HR&A Economic Impact Analysis Update for Friends of The High Line. 2018. “Uber to Open Engineering Hub in Toronto”. CNN Money. 2018. HR&A Waterfront Seattle Value Study. 2018 Urban Metrics Economic Impact Analysis for Waterfront Toronto. 2013. HR&A Park Impact Assessment for the Trustees of the Reservations. 2017. Waterfront Toronto. 2019. “Human Capital, Quality of Place, and Location”. 2000. “What Do the Best Entrepreneurs Want in a City?” Insight Endeavors. 2014.

HR&A Advisors, Inc. 20 ONTARIO PLACE | The Value of Toronto’s Public Space January 2020