COUNTY: FULTON

S A L E S R A T I O S T U D Y

2 0 1 6

DEPARTMENT OF AUDITS AND ACCOUNTS SALES RATIO DIVISION 2016 SALES RATIO STUDY

060 COMPUTATION SHEET - FULTON COUNTY

1. STUDY DATA

NUMBER OF SAMPLES IN STUDY...... 2,230

OVERALL RATIO...... 36.05

2. ADJUSTED 100% DIGEST COMPUTATIONS

PROPERTY CLASS ASSESSMENT RATIO 100% VALUE

REAL PROPERTY = 50,315,381,910 ÷ 36.05 % = 139,563,463,184

PERSONAL PROPERTY = 6,369,583,774 ÷ 36.05 % = 17,667,781,438

CURRENT USE = 168,897,110 ÷ 40.00 % = 422,242,775

MOTOR VEHICLES = 1,036,864,572 ÷ 40.00 % = 2,592,161,430

100% VALUE FOR LOCALLY ASSESSED PROPERTY ...... 160,245,648,827

3. 100% VALUE COMPUTATIONS

LOCALLY ASSESSED PROPERTY ...... 160,245,648,827

PUBLIC UTILITY PROPERTY...... 1,214,361,832

TIMBER ...... 5,000

TOTAL 100% ADJUSTED COUNTY DIGEST...... 161,460,015,659

LESS TAX ALLOCATIONS DISTRICT(S)...... 235,713,150

LESS 100% ADJUSTED DIGEST - ATLANTA (FULTON) - S.D...... 73,177,221,196

NET 100% ADJUSTED DIGEST - FULTON -S.D...... 88,047,081,313

DEPARTMENT OF AUDITS AND ACCOUNTS SALES RATIO DIVISION 2016 SALES RATIO STUDY

201 COMPUTATION SHEET - CITY OF ATLANTA (FULTON)

1. STUDY DATA

NUMBER OF SAMPLES IN STUDY...... 2,230

OVERALL RATIO...... 36.05

2. ADJUSTED 100% DIGEST COMPUTATIONS

PROPERTY CLASS ASSESSMENT RATIO 100% VALUE

REAL PROPERTY = 23,237,836,260 ÷ 36.05 % = 64,456,489,889

PERSONAL PROPERTY = 2,084,834,813 ÷ 36.05 % = 5,782,859,150

CURRENT USE = 156,098,580 ÷ 40.00 % = 390,246,450

MOTOR VEHICLES = 369,592,934 ÷ 40.00 % = 923,982,335

100% VALUE FOR LOCALLY ASSESSED PROPERTY ...... 71,553,577,824

3. 100% VALUE COMPUTATIONS

LOCALLY ASSESSED PROPERTY ...... 71,553,577,824

PUBLIC UTILITY PROPERTY...... 1,623,643,372

TIMBER ...... 0

TOTAL 100% ADJUSTED CITY DIGEST...... 73,177,221,196

LESS TAX ALLOCATIONS DISTRICT(S)...... 5,792,508,440

NET 100% ADJUSTED CITY DIGEST...... 67,384,712,756

DEPARTMENT OF AUDITS AND ACCOUNTS SALES RATIO DIVISION 2016 SALES RATIO STUDY

REVENUE STATISTICS REPORT 060-FULTON COUNTY

2016 DIGEST - RATIO ANALYSIS

CLASS #SAMPLES LCI UCI MEDIAN AGGREGATE COD PRD

RESIDENTIAL 2,170 33.81 34.41 34.10 34.31 14.28 100.78 AGRICULTURAL 2,230 33.89 34.54 34.16 34.41 14.34 100.79 COMMERCIAL 48 36.39 41.82 38.57 37.74 13.05 102.91 INDUSTRIAL 12 31.15 39.34 37.01 34.86 9.91 102.28

PROPERTY CLASS RATIO CALCULATION

CLASS 2016 ASSESSMENTS RATIO M/A PROJECTED DIGEST % OF DIGEST

RESIDENTIAL 29,647,648,584 34.10 M 86,950,100,745 50.97% AGRICULTURAL 100,076,390 34.16 M 292,950,265 0.17% COMMERCIAL 25,288,267,640 38.57 M 65,557,717,989 43.48% INDUSTRIAL 1,999,829,330 37.01 M 5,403,671,351 3.44% PUBLIC UTILITY 1,129,633,716 40.00 2,824,084,290 1.94%

TOTAL 58,165,455,660 36.12 161,028,524,640 100.00%

DEPARTMENT OF AUDITS AND ACCOUNTS SALES RATIO DIVISION 2016 SALES RATIO STUDY

060-FULTON COUNTY

PUBLIC UTILITY EQUALIZATION RATIO CALCULATION

CLASS 2016 ASSESSMENT RATIO M/A PROJECTED DIGEST RESIDENTIAL 29,646,857,600 34.10 M 86,947,780,961 AGRICULTURAL 100,076,390 34.16 M 292,950,265 COMMERCIAL 25,288,267,640 38.57 M 65,557,717,989 INDUSTRIAL 1,999,829,330 37.01 M 5,403,671,351

TOTAL 57,035,030,960 36.05 158,202,120,566

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 1 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 12101 V R INVESTMENTS LLC 5755 POINT PKWY 05/11/16 56161 COM $ 278,801 $ 77,500 27.80 1 ALLIANCE INVESTMENTS LLC 12 286008071243~UN 101 135 IMP 10868 HOUSTON LILLIAN P 215 PIEDMONT AVE 04/20/16 56112 RES $ 76,524 $ 19,080 24.93 1105 LLC 14 005100130954~UN 1105 0.01 686 IMP 09015 HAWKINS KYLE W 1130 PIEDMONT AVE~106~17 04/14/16 56062 RES $ 302,742 $ 102,000 33.69 1207 AATP LLC 17 010600280914~UN 1207 0.03 371 IMP 00174 HEYMAN JOHN HERBERT/ERIN 1281 LANIER PL PL~2~17TH 01/12/16 55772 RES $ 526,161 $ 182,000 34.59 1281 LANIER PL LLC 17 000200110371~L14 BK 8 0.20 352 IMP 10597 BURKS WILLIE 1084 PONCE DE LEON 04/08/16 56130 COM $ 522,847 $ 237,880 45.50 1410 EUCLID AVENUE INC 14 001600090905 0.13 451 IMP 00737 PINKASOVIC BENJAMIN A/COFFMAN ERIN 215 PIEDMONT AVE 01/12/16 55768 RES $ 105,684 $ 28,400 26.87 1809 LLC 14 005100131598~UN 1809 0.02 604 IMP 07004 BIRCHWOOD INVESTMENTS INC 1940 MOORES MILL RD RD~231~17 03/31/16 56008 COM $ 310,265 $ 108,640 35.02 1940 MOORES MILL ROAD LLC 17 023000070090~M&B 0.41 209 IMP 15265 MARTIN RAYBURN EVANS 2616 HARMONY WAY 06/03/16 56254 RES $ 56,611 $ 13,840 24.45 2616 HARMONY LLC 14 019700011167~LT 22 0.43 331 IMP 15257 CITIZENS TRUST BANK 1149 HALL AVE 06/03/16 56254 RES $ 139,281 $ 58,000 41.64 271 GLEN IRIS DRIVE LLC 14 001100070043 0.17 332 IMP 17266 REED LANCE P 2872 STIRLING RIDGE CT 06/23/16 56331 RES $ 765,885 $ 335,240 43.77 2872 STIRLING RIDGE COURT LLC 22 501003920940 1.00 613 IMP 00738 COFFMAN ERIN/ROBERT 215 PIEDMONT AVE 01/12/16 55768 RES $ 91,171 $ 26,600 29.18 303 LLC 14 005100130137~UN 303 0.02 606 IMP 16171 ZELIG NURIT 325 WINDING RIVER DR~367~6TH 06/08/16 56275 RES $ 40,288 $ 18,920 46.96 325B WINDING RIVER LLC 06 036700040984~UN B 0.03 376 IMP 00292 BONSAL AMERICA INC 4765 FREDERICK DR 01/15/16 55785 IND $ 606,989 $ 244,520 40.28 4765 FREDERICK DRIVE LLC 14F0085 LL0061~M&B 2.60 104 IMP 02312 COOPER KYLE A/WILSON TERESA 625 COLONIAL PARK DR DR 02/10/16 55852 COM $ 372,343 $ 138,080 37.08 625 COLONIAL PARK DRIVE LLC 12 209104660719~L10 BK A 0.42 33 IMP 05760 LEON ALEX 268 JOSEPH E. LOWERY BLVD NW 03/15/16 55954 RES $ 38,051 $ 9,840 25.86 A ALI INVESTMENT COMPANY LLC 14 011500070048~21 0.14 28 IMP 05312 COLLINS PATRICK 641 MORELAND AVE 03/07/16 55937 RES $ 172,177 $ 67,000 38.91 A ALI INVESTMENT COMPANY LLC 14 001100030252~L 8 0.17 223 IMP 05876 STEPHENS EUGENE A 698 GRANT TERRACE SE TER~54~14 03/15/16 55974 RES $ 104,640 $ 22,000 21.02 AAI PROPERTIES LLC 14 005400030680 0.21 380 VAC 04391 ADAMS JAN B 1154 HAMPTON WY NE WAY~5~17 02/26/16 55900 RES $ 187,040 $ 50,720 27.12 AARABI-TAFT AZADEH 17 000500011386~UN 1154 0.04 166 IMP 14766 LOGAN JAMES/RUTH GREGORY/S 311 PEACHTREE HILLS AVE~58~17 05/25/16 56241 RES $ 115,778 $ 34,200 29.54 AARON PAMELA L 17 0058 LL1707~UT 16-B 0.02 675 IMP 14453 JAMES GERWE AND ALYSON GERWE 120 QUARRINGTON COURT~902~2ND 05/31/16 56241 RES $ 258,461 $ 100,640 38.94 AARON WHITWORTH 22 541009022895~173 0.18 284 IMP 13633 ANDERSON MARY 9077 COBBLER CT 05/27/16 56227 RES $ 161,582 $ 62,880 38.92 AARONS KATHRYN L/AARONS MARLON G 12 267206750168~94 0.08 432 IMP 14589 SEAN S WANG 400 W. PEACHTREE STREET 05/20/16 56231 RES $ 272,342 $ 106,680 39.17 ABDELGHANI ZERGAOUI 14 007900132453~UNIT 1811 0.02 463 IMP 02461 DABNEY ALLISON D 1429 DUPONT COMMONS CIR~229~17 02/12/16 55857 RES $ 396,229 $ 141,720 35.77 ABDUL-QUDDUS ISA 17 0229 LL2964~LOT 234 0.11 306 IMP 10183 ATLANTA 620 #3 CORP 57 FORSYTH STREET NE UNIT 04/22/16 56098 RES $ 119,300 $ 36,480 30.58 ABEL JENNIFER/ABEL GENE 14 007800121630~UN 10-C 0.02 100 IMP 09608 SCOTT NICHOLAS 870 INMAN VILLAGE PKWY NE PKWY 04/22/16 56098 RES $ 224,151 $ 74,000 33.01 ABEL JESSICA A 14 0019 LL1777~UN 228 0.02 556 IMP 13321 IKWUEZUNMA HENRY 1613 WINGATE WAY~23~17 05/20/16 56204 RES $ 77,163 $ 27,800 36.03 ABELLANOSA FRANCES LOUIE/ABELLANOSA 17 002300031010~UNIT 1613 0.02 641 IMP 14486 BRISSETT ZACHARY T 12570 CORNISH CT 05/24/16 56244 RES $ 228,103 $ 82,480 36.16 ABELMAN HENRY 21 572111640508~132 0.20 181 IMP 08553 COLEMAN BETTY J 854 KINGS CT NE CT 04/12/16 56052 RES $ 291,976 $ 150,560 51.57 ABES LAUREN E 17 005200080292~L3 0.27 679 IMP 14445 HARRISON GLENN W 147 15TH STREET UNIT #16E~105, 05/31/16 56239 RES $ 1,170,731 $ 381,600 32.60 ABES STEPHANIE/ABES MARSHALL 17 010600140720~UT 16E 0.08 680 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 2 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 10604 DOBSON DEREK D 321 GOODSON LN NW LN~147~17 04/20/16 56131 RES $ 394,214 $ 119,240 30.25 ABLETT MARY BROOKS/ABLETT MATTHEW 17 0147 LL2369~L 19 0.02 75 IMP 12731 LACKEY THOMAS J 1023 SOUTHERBY LANE 05/16/16 56184 RES $ 437,011 $ 122,800 28.10 ABOSOUD MOHAMMAD 22 418012770564~6 0.28 408 IMP 02443 RODRIGUES NICOLLETTE 507 GRANVILLE CT 01/29/16 55855 RES $ 83,433 $ 27,360 32.79 ABUSMA HOLDINGS LLC 17 0035 LL2190~UN 507 0.02 113 IMP 08676 JACLYNN A SMITH NKA JACLYNN YOUNG 7315 HIGHLAND BLUFF 03/31/16 56052 RES $ 296,331 $ 85,540 28.87 ACHEE JULI S 17 0032 LL5105~L12 0.02 609 IMP 01626 MELTON VIRGINIA C 836 SAINT CHARLES AVE NE AVE 01/28/16 55813 RES $ 191,533 $ 75,080 39.20 ADAMS TYLER 14 001700140139~L D 0.02 356 IMP 14981 FRANCIS ROHAN 0 DUNNING STREET~55~14TH 05/27/16 56264 RES $ 14,000 $ 5,120 36.57 ADESTE INVESTMENTS LLC 14 005500040266 0.15 86 VAC 19286 NIEMEYER DEARELL 220 EDWARDTON CT 06/27/16 56393 RES $ 397,252 $ 132,080 33.25 ADEWOLE ANTHONIA D/FASORO PHILIP A 12 295008260961 0.48 159 IMP 03320 SMITH ROBERT M 990 LITCHFIELD PL PL 01/15/16 55886 RES $ 267,511 $ 98,160 36.69 ADLER CHAD G 12 206204710303~L11 BK D 0.21 263 IMP 13039 TALSMA GARY 1708 BARFIELD RUN 05/17/16 56180 RES $ 395,755 $ 150,880 38.12 ADZHEMYAN ARMEN/ADZHEMYAN MICHELLE 17 0229 LL0802~LT 26 0.09 498 IMP 05287 WILLIAMS CLAYTON A 629 HANSELL ST SE ST 03/07/16 55935 RES $ 505,721 $ 127,720 25.26 AECK ANTONIN/MOLLY HULL/HULL FRANK 14 002100070041~47.5 X 195' 0.21 418 IMP 07393 MANAS DASGUPTA AND INDRANI DASGUPTA 455 DUNHILL VIEW CT CT 03/28/16 55999 RES $ 338,432 $ 82,600 24.41 AGARWAL PUNEET 11 065102350204~L20 0.33 610 IMP 13689 MARTINEZ JENNIFER M 855 PERENNIAL DR 05/27/16 56224 RES $ 214,961 $ 71,680 33.35 AGHARAHIMI ROYA 17 0035 LL4394~UT 101 0.03 139 IMP 10913 BANKSTON JANNIE 125 ENGLISH OAK CT CT~1192 & 1229~2 04/29/16 56130 RES $ 487,545 $ 170,960 35.07 AGRAWAL MINAL K/MAJUMDER ANIRBAN 21 574011911351~L 32 BLK A 0.34 82 IMP 11568 MCCONAGHIE ANDREW J 305 S SATINWOOD PL 04/29/16 56152 RES $ 373,262 $ 125,520 33.63 AGUILAR KARINA 12 277207630251~L25 BK A 0.27 299 IMP 40564 3102 M L KING JR SW DR COM $ 215,312 $ 81,600 37.90 AHMED ZUBER I 14 023700020210 0.21 IMP 14594 WEBER ROBERT 1105 SUMMIT NORTH DR 06/01/16 56234 RES $ 123,737 $ 36,040 29.13 AIELLO ELIZABETH 17 004800051654~UT 1105 0.02 334 IMP 06100 JENKINS MARCHE D 03/17/16 55965 RES $ 210,889 $ 69,920 33.15 AINLEY LYNNE E/AINLEY LAURA 12 234005972369~L18 BLDG 3 0.03 172 IMP 11669 SPICER DOUGLAS W 798 SAINT CHARLES AVE 05/06/16 56161 RES $ 132,877 $ 62,640 47.14 AINSWORTH ALLISON MCINTYRE 14 001700081226~UT 5 OF 798 ST 0.01 55 IMP 12334 DELOACH CAROL T 2660 PEACHTREE RD 05/13/16 56173 RES $ 766,429 $ 262,000 34.18 AITCHESON III FRANK L/AITCHESON CAROL T 17 011200140326~UT 35-A 0.06 516 IMP 12824 DURHAM ANGELA 5151 ROSWELL RD~92~17TH 05/05/16 56165 RES $ 93,512 $ 28,560 30.54 AKANDE WINIFRED O 17 0092 LL1366~UNIT 5151-2 0.02 474 IMP 14348 HURST MIKE 3445 STRATFORD RD 05/31/16 56244 RES $ 212,533 $ 82,080 38.62 AKARANTA OZIOMA FAITH 17 004500012774~UT 2909 0.02 160 IMP 00308 THOMAS E JOHNS AND LINDA I JOHNS 1650 BAINBRIDGE WY 01/05/16 55753 RES $ 194,486 $ 64,840 33.34 AKIMOV ARTEM 12 219205250047~L8 BK B 0.42 498 IMP 09687 LARIMER ELIZABETH EDEN 907 PIEDMONT AVENUE NE UNIT 04/22/16 56088 RES $ 172,282 $ 68,200 39.59 ALAMILLA JOSE 14 004900031355~UN 13 0.02 639 IMP 14337 BONURA JOSEPH 250 PHARR RD 05/31/16 56237 RES $ 181,914 $ 75,760 41.65 ALEXANDER DANIEL 17 009900072443~UT 1414 0.02 617 IMP 12203 MAY III JOHN S 242 TRIUMPH DR NW DR~17 05/06/16 56152 RES $ 137,462 $ 45,600 33.17 ALEXION CHRISTOPHER 17 018500080557~UN 242 0.03 681 IMP 17652 GRIMES TIFFANY A 6322 DEKEON DR 06/24/16 56344 RES $ 141,561 $ 46,000 32.49 ALEXIS CHAD 09F410001642996 0.18 40 IMP 06895 DANIEL REGINALD B 1225 OLEANDER ST ST 03/22/16 55995 RES $ 31,240 $ 9,160 29.32 ALFORD WILLIE MAE 14 014200170712~50 X 125 0.14 158 IMP 09543 BRENNAN JUSTIN M 3103 COMMONWEALTH WY 04/27/16 56104 RES $ 193,128 $ 63,600 32.93 ALHOMSI MOHAMAD MUHANNAD 22 527010411284~L167 BLDG 31 0.04 191 IMP 00579 SHELTON LISA 01/07/16 55752 RES $ 453,202 $ 145,440 32.09 ALHUSSEIN MERVAT 17 0062 LL2857~UN 2907 0.03 493 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 3 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 10230 ASHTON ATLANTA RESIDENTIAL LLC 12025 CAMERON DR 04/22/16 56091 RES $ 463,030 $ 266,680 57.59 ALI IMRAN N/ALI BIBI SAFFIYA 11 108003970256~L 99 0.16 606 IMP 00173 BTG PROPERTIES LLC 1304 MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. DR SW 01/14/16 55774 RES $ 54,529 $ 14,280 26.19 ALLBRIGHT KELLY 14 014100061284~50 X 125' 0.14 600 IMP 00275 POWERS BERNARD/REBECCA 3263 FERNCLIFF LANE 01/15/16 55773 RES $ 479,538 $ 169,560 35.36 ALLEN HARRY LEE/KATHRYN 17 000800050530~L20 0.03 288 IMP 17394 REAMS RONALD A 120 RALPH MCGILL BLVD 06/17/16 56307 RES $ 133,405 $ 37,920 28.42 ALLEN JR ROBERT J/ALLEN DEBORAH G 14 005000151209 0.03 55 IMP 03341 FAUSETT M DIANE 1065 GRACE HILL DR 02/24/16 55889 RES $ 361,665 $ 122,240 33.80 ALLEN MARGARET S 12 176003551135~L23 0.40 468 IMP 10086 YATES ALAN R 4080 PARAN POINTE DR NW DR~215~17 04/18/16 56076 RES $ 659,225 $ 213,440 32.38 ALLEN NATHAN 17 021500040167~L 16 0.23 236 IMP 02786 MCGEHEE WILLIAM CHRISTOPHER 345 DEERING RD NW RD 02/09/16 55849 RES $ 266,963 $ 85,680 32.09 ALLEN ROGER 17 014700010122~L12 BK B 0.19 28 IMP 00452 TOYZAN CARLY 216 SEMEL DR NW DR~147~17 01/08/16 55776 RES $ 213,909 $ 76,980 35.99 ALLEN SAMANTHA 17 0147 LL2054~UN 374 BLDG 216-C 0.01 154 IMP 13795 FRASER JUDY E 1500 LACKEY RD~1077~2ND 05/18/16 56206 RES $ 803,119 $ 205,760 25.62 ALLEN TODD 22 331010770066 3.30 369 IMP 05052 RANCE JEANNE 7630 ABSINTH DRIVE~46~9C 03/04/16 55925 RES $ 177,325 $ 59,680 33.66 ALLUMS SR MAURY 09C110000464391~L 324 0.25 655 IMP 15033 OWEN EZA D 1460 BELLSMITH DR~598~1ST 05/31/16 56252 RES $ 195,422 $ 69,920 35.78 ALNAJAR AHMED 12 234005972005~42 0.03 261 IMP 15845 AUSTIN TINA MYERS 2233 PEACHTREE RD~111~17TH 06/02/16 56278 RES $ 523,810 $ 184,480 35.22 ALPHARETTA HOLDINGS LLC A DELAWARE 17 011100053777~THE ASTORIA AT THE 0.04 344 IMP 17401 KRINSKY BARBARA L 2660 PEACHTREE RD~112~17TH 06/15/16 56318 RES $ 651,714 $ 205,800 31.58 ALSINA-ROMAN ELSA/DEFERIA WILLIAM 17 011200140185~PARK PLACE ON 0.06 548 IMP 17107 HINES SHERRY J 3113 LENOX RD 06/16/16 56320 RES $ 587,328 $ 226,320 38.53 ALSTON WILLIAM L 17 000800090858 0.03 389 IMP 09384 COX PAUL E/OLIVER RONALD P 239 GLENWOOD AVE SE AVE 04/22/16 56084 RES $ 377,908 $ 114,520 30.30 AMBROSE CHRISTINA C/AMBROSE THOMAS R 14 005300061223~PT LTS 4-6 0.15 109 IMP 01963 KLEIN LINDA A/NEUREN MICHAEL 3435 KINGSBORO RD~45~17 01/29/16 55824 RES $ 368,085 $ 117,320 31.87 AMBURN REBECCA S/AMBURN PAUL F 17 004500060120~UNIT 704 0.04 417 IMP 13069 DARRYL L SCRIVEN AND LATRICIA D SCRIVEN 1100 CREEK RIDGE POINTE~1172~2ND 05/13/16 56175 RES $ 408,306 $ 209,160 51.23 AMICK DEBRA M/AMICK RONALD I 21 558511720081~8 0.36 394 IMP 05381 BOWEN GLEN 2415 WOODWARD WY WAY 03/01/16 55950 RES $ 1,368,696 $ 387,120 28.28 AMICK HANNAH/AMICK JUSTIN 17 011100010066~M&B 0.57 415 IMP 16779 CRISTA YANCEY AKA CHRISTA SHARLYNN 240 LAWRENCE PL 06/14/16 56316 RES $ 184,419 $ 74,040 40.15 AMINIMOGHADAM FARRAH 14F0157 LL0650 0.41 310 IMP 02515 HASAN KHAN AND SHARITA FARHANA 2260 WINTHROPE WAY DR DR 02/05/16 55840 RES $ 232,514 $ 86,640 37.26 AMJADI MICHEL/IVERSEN GITTE R 22 496011240896~L3 0.14 493 IMP 14620 FOWLER RUSSELL 235 LEEWARD LN~581~1ST 06/03/16 56245 RES $ 168,934 $ 74,600 44.16 AMOS CHRISTOPHER 12 242205810925~176 0.09 540 IMP 02864 WELSON CAROLYN W 2212 HUNTINGDON CHASE~23~17 01/28/16 55855 RES $ 86,720 $ 31,200 35.98 AMRANI ASSAF 17 002300021797~UN 2212 0.03 591 IMP 18805 H H MANAGE YOU LLC 2002 CHICAGO AVE~175~14TH 06/24/16 56364 RES $ 18,580 $ 4,730 25.46 ANDERSON AUDREY C 14 017500060129~44 & A 0.17 263 IMP 16694 D R HORTON INC A DELAWARE 7812 OLD THYME RD~36~9F 06/20/16 56313 RES $ 164,167 $ 68,720 41.86 ANDERSON BRANDON PAAK 09F050000365569~1148 0.20 224 IMP 13347 KHAZAMI FARID 1715 COTTON PATCH LN~1193~2 05/20/16 56202 RES $ 121,646 $ 29,560 24.30 ANDERSON KIMBERLY 22 513211931148~UT 1715 BLDG 18 0.03 91 IMP 02571 HIBBERT PAUL R 11099 LINBROOK LN LN~239~1 02/05/16 55850 RES $ 434,743 $ 127,720 29.38 ANDHARE SACHIN P/BAUSKAR VAISHALI 11 067102390115~L 23 BK A 0.75 509 IMP 13713 FRANKLIN JASON 05/23/16 56210 RES $ 120,702 $ 36,880 30.55 ANDREW JON MARK/ANDREW APRIL EMILY 17 011100160176~UT 5 BLDG 100-C 0.02 324 IMP 00979 ROBERT E CLARK AND TRACEY L CLARK 10420 HIGH FALLS CIR CIR 01/25/16 55809 RES $ 615,122 $ 208,480 33.89 ANDREWS NEIL IAN/ANDREWS KELLY MARIE 11 018000750355~L98 0.37 233 IMP 17430 UTSUKI HIROSHI 2479 PEACHTREE RD 06/24/16 56334 RES $ 104,401 $ 59,880 57.36 ANTRY ROBERT D 17 010100132268 0.02 400 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 4 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 12684 GUTERMAN SETH 555 TAUNTON WAY 05/09/16 56185 RES $ 526,154 $ 214,680 40.80 APOSTOLICO HEAVEN JORDANA 17 001400050219~21 0.68 274 IMP 18871 BARBER GLENN K 13830 BETHANY OAKS POINTE 06/30/16 56359 RES $ 493,251 $ 156,560 31.74 ARANT DAVID H 22 492108360044 1.05 190 IMP 15138 LASSITER LORNE E 123 ELYSIAN WAY~184~17TH 06/02/16 56252 RES $ 92,532 $ 28,960 31.30 ARCHER CRAYTON ASHAKI 17 018400061228~UT 123 0.02 88 IMP 17524 EVANS ANDREW ROBERT 5808 WATERS EDGE TRL~248~1 06/23/16 56321 RES $ 251,458 $ 90,760 36.09 ARDAGNA SUSAN P 12 145002483418~2301 0.04 639 IMP 05956 COOK JAMIE JEAN 710 GETTYSBURG PL 03/18/16 55967 RES $ 97,777 $ 32,920 33.67 ARDILA-CLAVIJO LEIDY 06 036400030780~UN 710 0.03 390 IMP 14675 ROTTENBERG FRANCEEN M 602 CHESTNUT OAK CT 06/06/16 56248 RES $ 645,560 $ 202,520 31.37 ARMAND ANNE E/ARMAND PATRICK M 17 013400010309~7 A 0.75 8 IMP 00641 ARMSTRONG ROBERT B/LISA 2802 RUNSON CT CT 01/14/16 55769 RES $ 1,293,828 $ 309,000 23.88 ARNOLD CHRISTINE S/ARNOLD SCOTT J 17 010000020753~BLDG 2 0.09 502 IMP 11980 STEWART FRANK F 2239 HARRY BROOKS DR NW 05/06/16 56138 RES $ 371,395 $ 125,960 33.92 ARNOLD DEVIN PAUL/WEAVER JENNI LEIGH 17 024400060806~LOT 136, ADAMS 0.15 169 IMP 06614 WILLIAMS SHAWN M 4323 SHAMROCK DR DR 03/23/16 55982 RES $ 191,092 $ 67,480 35.31 ARNOLD DWAYLON VERNARD/ARNOLD 09F410501640615~L60 0.22 191 IMP 17301 KRISTI BOWERS HOVINGTON AND RACHEL 2349 THOMAS RD 06/15/16 56305 RES $ 320,646 $ 96,440 30.08 ARNOLD ROBERT 17 025300011310 0.03 385 IMP 11858 WEAVER AVERY B 160 W VILLAGE CT 04/29/16 56143 RES $ 72,809 $ 35,240 48.40 ARNOLD SHERIKA MARIE 13 016400050471~L 47 0.12 521 IMP 02328 MERITAGE HOMES OF GEORGIA INC 3911 KINGFISHER DR DR~178~9F 02/10/16 55854 RES $ 184,978 $ 86,880 46.97 AROMIN MAXINE 14F0038 LL2990~243 0.11 289 IMP 08096 WU LIANG/TONG JIA 2160 GREENCREST CIR CIR 03/11/16 56034 RES $ 274,724 $ 95,480 34.75 ARORA NITIN 22 543010447293~L570 0.08 72 IMP 07110 TIJAL SHAH AND JIGAR A SHAH 2004 STERLING COURT~365~1ST 03/22/16 55981 RES $ 270,744 $ 127,320 47.03 ARTHUR J PARK/JANET ADAIR THOMPSON 12 176003651299~UN 2004 0.05 119 IMP 03924 TANNER TERRY P/ALBA ALMA D 781 CRESTWELL CIRCLE 03/01/16 55900 RES $ 75,879 $ 39,560 52.14 ARV PROPERTIES LLC 14 0245 LL1286~UN 105 BLDG 28 0.01 75 IMP 02513 LEVIN CRAIG SEAN 920 MEMORIAL DR SE DR 02/04/16 55843 RES $ 249,291 $ 88,560 35.52 ASCHOFF EDWARD 14 001300080883~UN 36 BLDG 8 0.05 681 IMP 06642 RIEDMILLER DEBORAH 2285 PEACHTREE RD~111~17TH 03/23/16 55980 RES $ 104,060 $ 29,840 28.68 ASGARI AFSSANEH 17 011100170027~UN 302 0.02 504 IMP 14369 PIE REAL ESTATE PARTNERS LLC 1887 BREWER BLVD~103~14 06/09/16 56244 RES $ 32,547 $ 9,400 28.88 ASPEN ONE PROPERTIES LLC 14 010300040672~12 & 12A, BLOCK 21 0.42 67 IMP 03087 JBJP INVESTMENTS LLC 219 CHADS FORD WY WAY~586 AND 02/10/16 55853 RES $ 107,102 $ 30,320 28.31 ATAR DORIT/ATAR RON 12 229505640128~LT D 0.04 610 IMP 04652 FLYNN WILLIAM J 3638 PEACHTREE RD NE RD 02/29/16 55907 RES $ 259,894 $ 92,980 35.78 ATKINSON CONNIE LEIGH 17 001000200172~UN 204 0.04 668 IMP 03787 THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON AS 1393 BLUEFIELD DR SW DR 02/11/16 55866 RES $ 22,660 $ 6,720 29.66 ATLANTA CITY LIVING LLC 14 013800050613~L27 BK G 0.20 697 IMP 04934 WD REAL ESTATE INVESTMENTS I LLC 1395A VESTA TER 03/14/16 55938 RES $ 56,164 $ 17,960 31.98 ATLANTA METROPOLITAN REALTY ADVISORS 14 013100170350~L22 0.24 99 IMP 10070 COMMUNITY RESTORATION CORPORATION 1083 GRANT WY SE WAY~55~14TH 04/07/16 56086 RES $ 32,296 $ 17,200 53.26 ATLANTA NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT 14 005500090592~L17, BK C 0.11 429 IMP 04231 WILLIAMS TIMOTHY L 200 SHERIDAN POINT LN~39~17TH 02/24/16 55914 RES $ 636,530 $ 225,120 35.37 ATMATZIDIS MARIA/ATMATZIDIS 17 003900040062~LT 6 HIGH POINT 0.41 67 IMP 05586 RETHINGER SARA 336 GLENWOOD AVE SE AVE 03/11/16 55945 RES $ 243,245 $ 72,680 29.88 ATTRUIA JASON/ATTRUIA LEAH 14 004400130079~L336 0.09 148 IMP 18447 TREFZER TIMOTHY 905 JUNIPER ST~49~14TH 06/30/16 56352 RES $ 289,785 $ 108,000 37.27 AUDI EUGENE M 14 004900021208~UNIT 319 0.02 298 IMP 11963 TILLER ELIZABETH H 5652 RIVER OAKS PL~174~17TH 05/10/16 56161 RES $ 371,243 $ 110,440 29.75 AUSTIN DONNA JO R/AUSTIN JOHN B 17 017400020119~UT C-11 0.05 181 IMP 15062 NICKELL AMBER L 1901 WOODLAND HILLS AVE~186~17 05/13/16 56253 RES $ 277,831 $ 82,360 29.64 AVERETT AUDREY G/AVERETT AUSTIN G 17 018600030437~224 0.22 130 IMP 06234 HOEHN JESSICA 1132 WOODLAND AVE SE AVE 03/18/16 55966 RES $ 242,070 $ 58,720 24.26 AVRA KAITLIN 14 001000090604~L 15 BK 10 0.30 114 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 5 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 12119 BAGHERI SHAHRIAR/MAGHADDAM SODABEH 1145 WINTHROPE CHASE DRIVE 05/02/16 56138 RES $ 250,147 $ 89,640 35.83 AVRAMOV EYAL/AVRAMOV AMALIA 22 496011231242~L38 0.19 80 IMP 01478 CLAGGETT RICHARD 1075 PEACHTREE WALK NE 01/28/16 55813 RES $ 240,644 $ 70,000 29.09 AYCOCK HEATHER E 17 010600041779~UN A420 0.03 86 IMP 02462 WESLEY JARMEN 165 N RIVER DR DR~363, 367 & 368~6 02/01/16 55850 RES $ 132,244 $ 40,840 30.88 AZIANGUE KOMLANVI 06 0367 LL1482~UN 165D 0.03 393 IMP 06936 ANGELA W GALLEGO AND DANIEL J GALLEGO 345 SILHOUETTE CT~972~2ND 03/25/16 55987 RES $ 212,554 $ 71,640 33.70 AZIMI-BROOKS ZOHREH 22 542009720637~L361 0.15 43 IMP 18759 KUNIMOTO REBECCA LEE 5308 NORTHLAND DR 06/30/16 56349 RES $ 409,575 $ 177,160 43.25 B M CAPITAL LLC 17 006800030679 0.41 613 IMP 05975 JONES ALUN/GUO LIH SHIEW 3324 PEACHTREE RD 03/15/16 55974 RES $ 185,497 $ 75,880 40.91 BABATUNDE WALE 17 0062 LL4218~UN 1215 0.02 61 IMP 08854 BELL JENNIFER M 670 CORBIN LAKE CT CT 04/07/16 56038 RES $ 201,266 $ 72,440 35.99 BACK AMANDA L/BACK WOOLERY J 06 036700031272~L8 BK A 0.21 456 IMP 14426 MILLER JODY WAYNE 1445 MONROE DRIVE NE UNIT 05/27/16 56232 RES $ 206,832 $ 69,080 33.40 BAER AMELIA E 17 0052 LL1752~UT C22 0.02 245 IMP 03427 BETTY J MARSHALL AND HER SUCCESSORS 10530 STONEFIELD LNDING LNDG 02/10/16 55878 RES $ 353,925 $ 123,640 34.93 BAGHERI MOHSEN 11 080302810162~L25 0.57 214 IMP 17451 R SCOTT PASTOR AND PAIGE PASTOR 1651 MERCER AVE 06/29/16 56343 RES $ 474,228 $ 166,960 35.21 BAGWELL TAMMY LYNN/BAGWELL JOHN 14 015900030023 0.23 41 IMP 01451 DANA MCLAUGHLIN N/K/A DANA 7920 KIVERTON PL PL~77~17 01/21/16 55792 RES $ 241,773 $ 83,840 34.68 BAI YANG 17 0077 LL0904~L 64 0.07 69 IMP 21361 SMITH ALAN C 739 MILLER RUN~156 & 157~14FF 06/10/16 56452 RES $ 187,735 $ 51,880 27.63 BAILEY LAYTON 14F0157 LL1104~199 OF WALDEN PARK 0.39 625 IMP 10275 GREER BENJAMIN M 659 AUBURN AVE NE AVE~19~14TH 04/18/16 56080 RES $ 246,153 $ 72,160 29.32 BAKER EDWIN/BAKER ANNA C 14 001900102301~UNIT 262 0.02 3 IMP 09303 GARY W HALLIBURTON AND SUSAN A 12814 DOE DR DR 04/15/16 56067 RES $ 297,873 $ 106,440 35.73 BALAKRISHNAN SHANKER 22 543011155341~UN 152 BLDG 15 0.03 156 IMP 15955 WHITE LARRY J 921 KIPLING DR 06/07/16 56288 RES $ 439,017 $ 174,840 39.83 BALFOUR JOHN ROBERT 17 015400100287 0.33 170 IMP 15347 GARZA MARCELA S 69080 ROSWELL RD~74~17TH 06/02/16 56259 RES $ 190,640 $ 62,040 32.54 BALICCHIA GIULIA/FEDELI ALBERTO 17 0074 LL3083~UNIT H-4 0.04 544 IMP 16689 MATTHEW C MCCLURE AND MEREDITH F 06/20/16 56309 RES $ 658,799 $ 180,640 27.42 BALOCKI PAIGE/BALOCKI BRIAN 17 015500020138 0.51 295 IMP 14647 DOZIER PAUL C 221 SEMEL CIR 05/27/16 56248 RES $ 242,689 $ 84,000 34.61 BALOGUN ROSEIA 17 0147 LL1668~UT 259 BLDG 221-D 0.01 688 IMP 00435 CARRIE J MURPHY NKA CARRIE J CLEMONS 7006 RICHLAND CT CT~520, 545~1ST 01/08/16 55757 RES $ 184,147 $ 69,280 37.62 BAR-OR RAN/BAR OR PERACH REUT 12 217105450170~L17, BLDG 5, 0.04 625 IMP 14201 MCM CAPITAL PARTNERS LLC AS TRUSTEE 9285 BRUMBELOW CROSSING WAY 05/23/16 56209 RES $ 201,094 $ 88,280 43.90 BARADARAN NAZAR 12 320208910247~24 0.41 579 IMP 04454 BIRD WILLIAM 02/29/16 55899 RES $ 303,434 $ 88,360 29.12 BARAL JODI/BARAL BRIAN 22 373112820407~L40 0.21 171 IMP 01848 DENDY LINDSAY 4295 N STRATFORD RD NE DR 01/29/16 55829 RES $ 1,295,661 $ 346,600 26.75 BARBER LAURA 17 004300020779~95 X 200' 0.44 100 IMP 14429 SIGAL ALEX 7 VALE CLOSE NE~7~17 05/27/16 56232 RES $ 623,205 $ 278,360 44.67 BARCLAY BONNIE/WILLIAMS GUY A 17 000700130085~7 0.28 172 IMP 13434 GLOVER JASON COREY 3180 MATHIESON DRIVE NE, UNIT 506 05/20/16 56200 RES $ 408,513 $ 148,800 36.42 BARDOWELL KARINA J/BARDOWELL LLOYD S 17 006100160051~UT 506 0.03 508 IMP 06827 KESSINGER KAREN R 825 BROOKFIELD PKWY PKWY 03/30/16 56007 RES $ 419,390 $ 141,600 33.76 BARFIELD EMILY MELISSA 22 346212900360~L16 BK D 0.61 229 IMP 16049 CAPITAL DESIGN HOMES LLC 3502 WATERS RUN DR 06/15/16 56279 RES $ 489,876 $ 168,960 34.49 BARI ASIF/BARI MAHWISH 11 005000100285 0.49 579 IMP 19487 BUDDOO DONOVAN A 2828 SUMMIT PKWY 06/27/16 56390 RES $ 157,577 $ 62,440 39.63 BARKER BARBARA 14F0140 LL2201 0.34 9 IMP 18719 ROMAGNOLI SANDRO 2109 DEFOORS RD 06/30/16 56356 RES $ 140,929 $ 34,240 24.30 BARLOW BRANDON C 17 018600110098 0.03 380 IMP 10056 MARK I FELDMAN AND MARSHA P FELDMAN 425 STATE ST ST 04/25/16 56099 RES $ 355,751 $ 134,000 37.67 BARNAS JENNIFER D/BARNAS SCOTT J 12 155202570278~L32 BK C 0.71 579 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 6 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 07289 DEMPSEY CHRISTOPHER GATES 185 SHOAL CREEK DR DR~301~1ST 03/31/16 56006 RES $ 555,032 $ 174,960 31.52 BARNES SCOTT EDWARD/BARNES WENDY 12 170003011166~LOT 9 0.43 30 IMP 09789 MOORE SCOTT J 1706 E TEMPLE AVE AVE 03/30/16 56087 RES $ 189,690 $ 51,160 26.97 BARNES SUSAN A 14 016000020237 0.33 660 IMP 16850 BOWLING DANIEL ADAM 140 SADDLE LAKE DR~1 06/30/16 56343 RES $ 311,805 $ 125,600 40.28 BARNWELL STEWART H/BARNWELL JULIE T 12 194304370345~34, F 0.51 318 IMP 08588 RHINO LAURA P 13 BONNIE LN LN 04/11/16 56046 RES $ 833,054 $ 269,160 32.31 BARON LIOR/BARON RACHEL L 17 012500040497~L2 0.22 700 IMP 16783 MARTIN IV JAMES A 14990 BIRMINGHAM HWY~593~2 06/14/16 56299 RES $ 679,805 $ 187,000 27.51 BARRENTINE JULIE/JOHNSON MICHAEL A 22 393005930105 2.48 284 IMP 14903 GUEVARA OLIMPIO 707 PINE TREE TRL~158 & 163~13 04/29/16 56233 RES $ 23,502 $ 6,480 27.57 BARROW PATRICIA/UGWUDI JUSTINA 13 015800080104~UT 10B 0.03 688 IMP 00054 NAIR ARUN 855 PEACHTREE ST NE ST~49~14 01/06/16 55750 COM $ 262,338 $ 84,080 32.05 BARRY HOLDEN 14 004900023378~UN 2006 0.02 413 IMP 06209 BANK OF AMERICA N A 2677 LANCASTER DR~188~14TH 03/18/16 55977 RES $ 41,674 $ 15,680 37.63 BARSKY FELIPE LUIS 14 018800050232~L 5 BK MM UN 16 0.32 690 IMP 04571 LEDBETTER EVANTHE F NKA EVANTHE F 215 PIEDMONT AVE NE 02/29/16 55901 RES $ 90,161 $ 26,600 29.50 BARTECA RESTAURANTS LLC 14 005100131275~UNIT 1507 0.02 1 IMP 06616 MANTHEY KEITH W 1020 SPENCE ST ST 03/24/16 55982 RES $ 486,851 $ 171,640 35.26 BASARAN RIDVAN 22 418012441083~L6 0.34 69 IMP 17978 ERIC MCCRARY AND RACHELLE MCCRARY 6590 SMOKE RIDGE DR 06/27/16 56332 RES $ 72,388 $ 35,120 48.52 BASS ANWAR 13 015900031049 0.30 243 IMP 08616 WILSON PARKER HOMES OF WILLIAMS BLUFF 4180 MONAGHAN WY WAY~103~9F 03/25/16 56043 RES $ 174,672 $ 52,680 30.16 BASS PEARL L 09F240201032684~L 77 0.17 291 IMP 11656 KEMPH JEFF D 1524 N HIGHLAND AVE AVE~3~17TH 05/04/16 56138 RES $ 615,289 $ 243,440 39.57 BASSETT MARY LOUISE 17 000300100165~LOT 3 0.23 550 IMP 05333 LAWRENCE PAULA JANE 56 DEVONSHIRE DR DR 03/09/16 55934 RES $ 184,357 $ 57,680 31.29 BATTERMAN JYL 12 293008341527~L 56 BLDG J 0.03 123 IMP 14862 5420 OLD NATIONAL HIGHWAY LLC 5420 OLD NATIONAL HWY HWY~93~13 02/05/16 56240 COM $ 633,628 $ 229,320 36.19 BATTLE MONUMENT PARTNERS LLC 13 009300010265~M&B 0.63 455 IMP 06916 CORBIN KRISTIN M 216 SEMEL CIR NW CIR~147~17TH 03/24/16 56009 RES $ 238,699 $ 82,600 34.60 BATTLE SARA GRACE/RICHARDS MAXWELL 17 0147 LL2021~UNIT 371 0.01 3 IMP 04019 DAVITT JEFF 835 GREENPOINT DR DR~318 AND 02/26/16 55898 RES $ 394,880 $ 122,440 31.01 BAUCH AUDREY LEIGH/BAUCH MICHAEL 22 485003181028~LOT 113 1.73 382 IMP 12896 WEBB MARY L 624 JOHN WESLEY DOBBS AVE 05/12/16 56169 RES $ 296,749 $ 97,960 33.01 BAUML MICHAEL T/BAUML CARRIE LYNN 14 001900050955~9 0.03 494 IMP 09753 VANGERPEN BETTY S 2814 PEACHTREE RD~100~17TH 04/25/16 56101 RES $ 277,281 $ 84,600 30.51 BAXTER ROBERT L/BAXTER DIANE L 17 010000160088~UNIT 8 0.02 218 IMP 17573 SCHUEBACH PATRICK 2758 WANDER LN~809~1 ST AND 2 06/01/16 56296 RES $ 243,874 $ 80,120 32.85 BEAL STEPHANIE 12 287008092221~UNIT 30 0.04 586 IMP 14468 KATHERINE LEIGH JACKSON NKA KATHERINE 232 SPRINGDALE DR 06/01/16 56247 RES $ 584,937 $ 180,440 30.85 BEAN NANCY H 17 010100180234~13 B 0.18 249 IMP 01757 CURTIS JAMES DABNEY 1100 HAMPTON WAY 01/28/16 55816 RES $ 194,676 $ 58,760 30.18 BEANE ROBERT 17 000500011113~UN 1100 0.05 658 IMP 15096 FRIERSON AISHA 06/07/16 56269 RES $ 129,913 $ 43,560 33.53 BEARD LAKENDRA 14 0062 LL1336 0.23 138 IMP 09986 FLYNN ASA/GANNON KELLY 1121 ALTA AVE~14~14TH 04/22/16 56104 RES $ 486,278 $ 153,980 31.66 BECKMAN RANDY/BECKMAN SHELLI 14 001400090329~LOT 1 0.14 629 IMP 19680 REYNOLDS SANDRA GAIL 285 ARD PL~123~14TH 06/10/16 56408 RES $ 35,759 $ 11,040 30.87 BELL OCTAVIUS 14 024300090298~12 0.31 684 IMP 14789 WINSHIP DANIEL N 982 MYRTLE ST~106~17TH 05/26/16 56237 RES $ 660,718 $ 289,160 43.76 BELLOWS XAVIER/BELLOWS BRIANA 17 010600120052~UNIT 2 0.09 691 IMP 11608 BRADY M MERRILL 730 COURTENAY DR DR 05/03/16 56140 RES $ 588,161 $ 248,320 42.22 BENEDETTI JAIME A/BENEDETTI CHRISTINE S 17 005200050196~L19 BK C 0.22 476 IMP 14848 MARK A BOARD AND SHERRIE M BOARD 10485 STANYAN ST 05/25/16 56231 RES $ 565,321 $ 178,360 31.55 BENEFIELD ERICA D/BENEFIELD RICHARD W 12 301208450920~62 0.32 571 IMP 14514 BARTOW EARL CLIFFORD 925 SHEPARDS CT 05/31/16 56240 RES $ 1,530,955 $ 611,600 39.95 BENITEZ JORGE DANIEL/BENITEZ CRISTINA 22 330009400461~LT 8 4.34 146 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 7 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 04597 KARSCH RANDY 1676 W SUSSEX RD NE RD~3~17 03/07/16 55919 RES $ 1,339,152 $ 573,360 42.82 BENJAMIN TODD/BROWN BRYAN 17 000300020108~L1 BK 9 0.53 585 IMP 05823 MORRONE MAXIMO A 1350 N MORNINGSIDE DR DR~2~17 03/11/16 55949 RES $ 123,053 $ 47,380 38.50 BENSON BRAEDEN 17 000200150138~UN 13 0.01 143 IMP 01179 SHARP RESIDENTIAL LLC 421 BRIDLE WY WAY~195 & 01/29/16 55815 RES $ 737,254 $ 201,800 27.37 BENTON CARMEL FB/BENTON II GUS 22 419001960463~98, PHASE I 1.33 321 IMP 08232 WOODFORD KATHRYN 4266 ROSWELL RD. NE B3~95~17TH 04/01/16 56053 RES $ 108,108 $ 50,080 46.32 BENZ LEXI L 17 009500110247~UN B3 0.03 204 IMP 16405 FAULWELL SUSAN MARIE 715 DUNSCORE CT 06/29/16 56337 RES $ 359,197 $ 143,920 40.07 BERARDI-QUIROZ NANCY/QUIROZ JR MARIO 22 326110800862 1.04 618 IMP 16947 BRENNER ERIC R 6125 RIVER CHASE CIR~207~17 06/28/16 56338 RES $ 714,520 $ 240,880 33.71 BERGERON CHRISTOPHER A/CHO-BERGERON 17 020600060018~LOT 41, BLOCK C 0.63 296 IMP 05080 SEYEDBAGHERI TAHEREH 211 STREAMSIDE DR 03/08/16 55934 RES $ 123,308 $ 39,440 31.98 BERGSTROM MARILYN 12 215005490726~UN 211 0.03 165 IMP 01893 GRINDSTAFF DAVIN 115 PEACHTREE MEMORIAL DR DR 02/01/16 55829 RES $ 189,795 $ 81,800 43.10 BERKEMEYER LAUREN 17 011100020735~UN E4 0.02 82 IMP 40572 1040 POWERS PL COM $ 131,947 $ 59,200 44.87 BERMIC PROPERTIES LLC 22 482212521169 0.03 IMP 06875 FRAZIER JEANNE P 2575 PEACHTREE RD~101~17TH 03/25/16 55992 RES $ 708,513 $ 272,160 38.41 BERNHARDT KATHERINE S/BERNHARDT 17 010100202038~UNITS 25 A/B 0.07 284 IMP 18173 AMAN SAFAEI AND MANIJEH BEHZADI 711 EAGLES MERE CT~1236~2ND 06/29/16 56347 RES $ 868,243 $ 251,400 28.96 BERNS JESSICA/BERNS NATHAN A 21 563112510238~23 0.91 101 IMP 02566 WILSON PARKER HOMES OF RIVERTOWN 7690 BRAVOS TRL TRL~119~7 01/25/16 55844 RES $ 271,638 $ 106,520 39.21 BERRY DORIS B 07 180001191944~LOT 33 0.35 642 IMP 13717 TUKES GLEN 5065 PATTINGHAM DR~500 & 501~1 05/26/16 56229 RES $ 215,117 $ 82,680 38.43 BERRY LISA MAE 12 220305000076~LOT 7 BLK A CAMDEN 0.14 253 IMP 12905 SOUTHERN STATE INVESTMENTS LLC 750 CASCADE AVE~139~14 05/12/16 56179 RES $ 38,166 $ 9,520 24.94 BEST BUY HOMES LLC 14 013900050323~P/O LTS 1 & 2 0.20 336 IMP 14585 DURANTHON HARRIET 2030 PROVIDENCE OAKS 05/31/16 56236 RES $ 348,517 $ 132,480 38.01 BETA JASON S/BETA ALEXIS A 22 479110540309~48 A 0.27 327 IMP 15145 SEMBLER LORRAINE G 11216 BROOKHAVENCLUB DR 06/08/16 56269 RES $ 402,882 $ 122,840 30.49 BETZ VALERIE P 11 113004061725 0.19 105 IMP 13817 EMERALD GREEN PROPERTIES LLC 502 PRYOR ST 05/25/16 56224 RES $ 61,055 $ 13,600 22.28 BHATLAPENUMARTHI RAMA 14 007600081976~UT 7 0.01 499 IMP 17228 MCGEACHY NICOLE R 06/24/16 56337 RES $ 152,178 $ 65,120 42.79 BIDLACK KAITLYN ELIZABETH 17 010700080115 0.02 184 IMP 17051 JOHNSON EDWARD L 7258 VILLAGE CREEK TRCE~22~17 06/27/16 56337 RES $ 315,506 $ 128,000 40.57 BILBAO SILVIA ELENA 17 0022 LL1775~UNIT C-2 0.03 118 IMP 06978 MCGUIRE JOSEPH S 283 PROVIDENCE OAKS CIR 03/25/16 55986 RES $ 358,980 $ 124,120 34.58 BIRNEY JENNIFER NICOLE/BIRNEY MICHAEL D 22 479010540516~L20 BK A 0.34 102 IMP 07766 GOETSCHALCKX ANDREW T 711 COSMOPOLITAN DR NE DR 04/01/16 56016 RES $ 197,415 $ 65,360 33.11 BISACCO SHAWN G 17 004800032548~UN 512 0.02 1 IMP 14863 PATRICK WALSH AND PAMELA D WALSH 05/17/16 56238 RES $ 234,724 $ 86,240 36.74 BJK GLOBAL LLC 11 090003221676~TWN HM 310 0.02 697 IMP 06349 EISTER CRAIG V 110 DRUID CIR NE CIR~19~14TH 03/21/16 55973 RES $ 961,527 $ 340,840 35.45 BLACHER RACHEL J/MCCOWAN SCOTT 14 001900121087 0.33 495 IMP 00473 O'NEILL RYAN ELIZABETH 410 FORESTGATE CT CT~363~6TH 01/08/16 55771 RES $ 176,184 $ 48,840 27.72 BLACK ALISSA MARIE 06 036300050383~17 0.06 628 IMP 09459 DORMINEY RICHARD JARED 5559 GLENRIDGE DR DR~17 04/15/16 56090 RES $ 170,346 $ 49,520 29.07 BLACKARD SAMANTHA 17 003800010967~UN 2407 CARLYLE 0.03 328 IMP 18671 YATES HARRY P 60 BRANSFORD RD 06/30/16 56356 RES $ 497,655 $ 166,800 33.52 BLACKWELL JASON/BLACKWELL OLIVER PAGE 17 003800020313 0.51 608 IMP 11408 CRAWFORD COLIN 266 11TH ST~106~17TH 04/29/16 56114 RES $ 236,860 $ 103,360 43.64 BLAIR SARAH EVANS 17 010600092483~UN 307 0.02 39 IMP 03462 EAH-LONG ISLAND ASSOCIATES LLC 1040 PRESWYCK WY WAY 02/19/16 55876 RES $ 913,539 $ 283,680 31.05 BLAKE DANIELLE M/BLAKE JASON R 17 012500040554~LOT 5 0.24 1 IMP 12090 BOOTH JESSICA L 289 DEERING RD NW RD 05/06/16 56147 RES $ 325,544 $ 97,960 30.09 BLAS DELGADO CHRISTIAN L 17 010900100051~L24 BK G 0.19 671 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 8 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 04022 MJH HOMES LLC 4489 EAST CONWAY DR RD 02/26/16 55894 RES $ 2,089,777 $ 495,760 23.72 BLAZE CAPITAL LLC 17 013800021195~LT 2 0.49 458 IMP 13577 SATHER ANDREW 2626 PEACHTREE RD 05/26/16 56226 RES $ 149,136 $ 42,200 28.30 BLEWETT BRANDON C 17 011200021435~UT 1402 0.02 159 IMP 12439 VICKNAIR BRENT D 1716 FRIAR TUCK RD~104~17 05/16/16 56189 RES $ 1,634,240 $ 436,160 26.69 BLOUNT KENNETH M 17 010400050111~LT 11, P/O 10,12 0.48 23 IMP 09525 MICHAELS CONSTANCE M 20 CHAUMONT SQ 04/25/16 56101 RES $ 129,398 $ 41,120 31.78 BLUE MARE LLC 17 018400060204~UN 20 0.03 290 IMP 08513 MCKAY BROTHERS MANAGEMENT LLC 713 WOOD BEND CT CT 03/17/16 56053 RES $ 96,895 $ 33,880 34.97 BOADI JOHN 13 0164 LL2846~L52 0.27 647 IMP 05030 SKALLA RUSSELL 3562 ROSWELL RD NW RD 03/04/16 55924 RES $ 536,767 $ 225,980 42.10 BOARDMAN IV CLAYTON PIERCE 17 009800110434~L56 0.02 642 IMP 03767 TOYE FRANK C/SARAH 200 LAUREL FOREST CIRCLE NE~96~17 02/23/16 55885 RES $ 1,196,721 $ 271,600 22.70 BOCANEGRA CARLOS M 17 009600070069~L10,BK C 0.61 62 IMP 08019 RHINEHART BERNICE 12440 CONCORD HALL DR 03/23/16 56009 RES $ 179,740 $ 88,800 49.40 BODEEP THOMAS/BODEEP JOYCE 21 572111641365~L 108 0.29 277 IMP 10307 BERGER DAVID AARON/LIGHTNER JARRED 225 MARSH GLEN PT PT~127~17 04/27/16 56104 RES $ 419,943 $ 95,960 22.85 BOECKL MICHAEL/SUTTON GAIL 17 012600060130~L 22 BK A 0.57 422 IMP 14571 PAPANIA LETITIA 296 DEVONSHIRE DR~822 AND 823~1 06/03/16 56243 RES $ 143,774 $ 51,480 35.81 BOHLMANN CAROL M 12 294008231155~UNIT #296 0.03 294 IMP 05366 MELARA JESUS 3324 PEACHTREE RD NE RD~62~175H 03/11/16 55947 RES $ 232,275 $ 72,960 31.41 BOISSON GREGORY 17 0062 LL6809~UN 2703 0.02 597 IMP 14400 HENDO PROPERTIES LLC 1382 HAWTHORNE WAY~134~14 06/01/16 56251 RES $ 35,996 $ 18,360 51.01 BOLDEN CAPITAL GROUP LLC 14 013400020685~LOT 13 - BLOCK O 0.17 288 IMP 01699 YU ALEXANDER 400 WEST PEACHTREE ST NW 01/19/16 55826 RES $ 159,981 $ 50,720 31.70 BOLHUIS PAUL D 14 007900132255~UNIT 1707 0.02 582 IMP 13696 DANIEL E MILLER AS TRUSTEE OF THE 205 7TH ST 05/27/16 56227 RES $ 464,243 $ 144,400 31.10 BONDOCH ANTHONY MARIO 14 004900031207 0.04 396 IMP 14689 HEWES MARY KATE 3188 VERDUN DR 05/31/16 56230 RES $ 791,594 $ 231,080 29.19 BONEY CONNOR 17 014200020316~31 B 0.43 686 IMP 02237 HILBURN NELL POPE 130 26TH ST NW ST~147~17TH 02/05/16 55847 RES $ 117,136 $ 38,040 32.47 BONILLA DAVID E 17 014700060531~UN 409 0.02 366 IMP 11569 KUMAR SAKET 6085 HAMPTON BLUFF WAY 05/10/16 56156 RES $ 324,609 $ 98,280 30.28 BORGER ADRIEN R/ROBERT KEITH BORGER 12 161002691702~14 0.23 1 IMP 05453 JOHNSTON II GEORGE S/JONES ANNA- 1910 MARIETTA RD 03/08/16 55946 RES $ 315,440 $ 110,360 34.99 BORGHARDT JAMIE CANNON/JULES 17 022900011626~L 38 0.18 559 IMP 10950 NICKEL JUDY N ALDREDGE 6780 TELL RD RD 04/26/16 56129 RES $ 123,579 $ 29,920 24.21 BOSWORTH DANIEL 07 160201700199 4.00 166 IMP 14377 HUBER SARAH 265 GEORGIA AVE 05/27/16 56234 RES $ 320,635 $ 80,400 25.08 BOTHA GARETH F/EDWARDS ERICA ANN 14 005400030607 0.17 297 IMP 05944 HENRY MARSHALL G 510 EDGEWOOD AVE SE AVE 03/17/16 55969 RES $ 291,255 $ 63,480 21.80 BOTHWELL ASHLEY 14 004600122579~UN 5 0.03 355 IMP 03995 GAFFNEY ANDREW B 839 LAKE AVE AVE~19~14 03/04/16 55911 RES $ 610,381 $ 174,960 28.66 BOUCKAERT STANISLAS 14 001900090175 0.11 1 IMP 06853 SIDDIQUE AISHA 640 STREAMSIDE DR DR 03/22/16 55995 RES $ 136,319 $ 49,120 36.03 BOUMAHDI NAIMA 12 215005491518~L2 0.03 585 IMP 01509 DEGOLIAN HELEN RATHBONE 2575 PEACHTREE RD NE RD~101~17 01/19/16 55792 RES $ 355,733 $ 133,320 37.48 BOURGEOIS PAUL LAMBREMONT/BOURGEOIS 17 010100200396~UN 8G 0.04 341 IMP 09532 COFIELD RODERICK S/BARRON 7602 BRAZOS TRAIL~119~7TH 04/19/16 56094 RES $ 204,208 $ 64,000 31.34 BOWENS CARLOS BERNARD/WHITE SHEMEKA 07 180001192264~L 65 0.39 231 IMP 12974 TIMOTHY D WIGGINTON LAURA L LINDAMAN 1054 MERRIVALE CHASE 05/09/16 56183 RES $ 416,348 $ 140,760 33.81 BOWERS VIRGINIA L/BOWERS M DAVID 12 230005370646~9 0.18 359 IMP 03360 LILLEY CRYSTAL 1532 HABERSHAL RD NW 02/23/16 55881 RES $ 328,037 $ 111,920 34.12 BOWMAN-SCOTT KIMBERLY/SCOTT BRAD A 17 0226 LL0334~L268 0.14 697 IMP 09674 ALLEN LAURA/TURNER NICHOLAS 100 WEATHERBURNE DR DR~682~1ST 04/21/16 56092 RES $ 211,334 $ 66,780 31.60 BOYD ELISA B 12 264406820016~L1 BK A 0.36 293 IMP 01999 MILLER MICHAEL CHRIS 132 CRUMLEY ST SE ST 02/01/16 55817 RES $ 250,774 $ 56,080 22.36 BOYD MARK J 14 005300082278~L6 0.08 38 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 9 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 08332 JOHNSON JOY F 801 CASCADE XING SW XING 04/13/16 56058 RES $ 123,047 $ 36,960 30.04 BOYER LORI 14F0090 LL0189~L 96 0.25 60 IMP 06359 SADA ESTHER M 2020 MERRIMONT WY WAY~270~1ST 03/23/16 55976 RES $ 212,850 $ 74,880 35.18 BOYLAN CHARLES B 12 162002331059~L10 BLDG C, THE 0.02 381 IMP 18610 STEPHEN M GILBERT AND COURTNEY B 1485 RICHARDS CIR 06/30/16 56350 RES $ 416,621 $ 164,280 39.43 BOYS ERIN M/BOYS JASON J 22 465012000831 0.46 29 IMP 09956 FAVORS ANITA LANE 503 COHEN ST SW ST~8~14 04/18/16 56073 RES $ 40,406 $ 12,920 31.98 BP2 PROPERTIES LLC 14 008600091585~50 X 100 0.11 183 IMP 07300 JAMES B NUTTER COMPANY 1703 BROWNING STREET SW 03/28/16 55986 RES $ 26,867 $ 12,360 46.00 BP2 PROPERTIES LLC 14 014800010037~L8 BK B 0.20 441 IMP 12646 NEWTON THOMAS 1590 MOZLEY PL 05/12/16 56181 RES $ 36,523 $ 15,960 43.70 BP2 PROPERTIES LLC 14 014800030415~2 B 0.17 587 IMP 17595 LALLEY JENNIFER T 1953 WHITTIER AVENUE NW 06/17/16 56297 RES $ 240,129 $ 65,560 27.30 BRACEWELL BRIA WASHINGTON/BRACEWELL 17 025600010772 0.14 465 IMP 14603 GARGIS TIMOTHY 400 17TH ST 06/03/16 56249 RES $ 216,964 $ 66,880 30.83 BRACHT BEREND/BRINKMANN-BRACHT SILKE 17 0148 LL3390~UT 2219 0.03 264 IMP 11865 ALLEN WILLIAM C 1150 COLLIER RD NW RD 04/29/16 56140 RES $ 129,951 $ 39,160 30.13 BRADFORD NICOLE 17 018600013029~UN P4 0.03 128 IMP 15963 PILSCH JUDITH P 1611 DONCASTER DRIVE NE~104~17 06/13/16 56287 RES $ 780,501 $ 206,680 26.48 BRADLEY ARTHUR/BRADLEY DEBORAH K 17 010400060235 0.55 4 IMP 14556 JAMES P BECK AND KELLY S BECK 235 FRELLIG TRACE~164~1ST 05/26/16 56231 RES $ 206,079 $ 72,600 35.23 BRADLEY BERNARD 11 045301640522~33 A 0.26 485 IMP 07072 ALSHAMMARI REMAL 360 HOUZE WY WAY 03/25/16 55985 RES $ 354,256 $ 87,920 24.82 BRADLEY CASEY QUICK DUNNING/BRADLEY 12 197104450043~L4 BK D 0.74 235 IMP 00770 SKINNER NATHANIEL G 2235 HARRY BROOKS DR NW DR 01/15/16 55772 RES $ 366,589 $ 105,240 28.71 BRAGG JASON CHRISTOPHER/BRAGG MALLIE 17 024400060822~L138 0.11 590 IMP 11353 AMES ANTHONY A 560 DUTCH VALLEY ROAD NE~55~17 05/02/16 56125 RES $ 238,192 $ 78,920 33.13 BRANDAU ROBERT JOE 17 005500061539~UN 2408 0.02 451 IMP 03200 LYONS ROXANNE M 115 WILLOW WY WAY~816~1ST 02/18/16 55871 RES $ 654,632 $ 230,520 35.21 BRANIGAN NICHOLAS/BRANIGAN MELISSA K 12 290508160134~LT 13 BK KK 0.49 164 IMP 00231 EDWARD R MOORE AND ANN Q MOORE 01/15/16 55778 RES $ 386,404 $ 123,760 32.03 BRANNON ROBERT A 22 356010190163 9.92 652 IMP 11928 THE NEW PARADIGM GROUP LLC 214 REINHARDT STREET SE~45~14 05/03/16 56138 RES $ 208,613 $ 59,840 28.68 BRAY VALERIE Y 14 004500100782~L2 0.09 329 IMP 12911 MARLENE I SIFLINGER A/K/A MARLENE IRIS 115 CRANBERRY CONNECTION 05/16/16 56182 RES $ 222,785 $ 69,040 30.99 BREEDLOVE JAMES 12 263707050018~22 S 0.32 70 IMP 19585 JIMROZE CORPORATION 11205 ALPHARETTA HWY HWY 06/30/16 56382 COM $ 104,514 $ 32,000 30.62 BREINER TODD A 12 216105190208~UN 4 BLDG G 0.02 46 IMP 07100 GLAD DIANA 872 EDGEWOOD AVE NE AVE 03/31/16 56005 RES $ 366,886 $ 102,560 27.95 BRENDLE JR GARY DAVID/GUSKE AMANDA 14 001400100185~PT L7 0.07 556 IMP 17268 TURNER BRADLEY 629 CHEROKEE AVE SE 06/24/16 56332 RES $ 384,869 $ 122,040 31.71 BRENNAN-ELLIS KRISTIN L/TAIT MICHAEL T 14 004300020156 0.15 549 IMP 15360 BEAVERS KATHLEEN A 1162 MORNINGSIDE PL~4~17TH 05/20/16 56267 RES $ 276,881 $ 100,000 36.12 BRIAN J LANGLEY AND WILLIAM S STAHL AS 17 000400060566 0.03 305 IMP 13565 HIGHGROVE HOMES LLC 5000 LAZARIAN COURT 05/26/16 56228 RES $ 677,891 $ 338,040 49.87 BRIDGEWATER ALECIA P/BRIDGWATER MARK 06 0312 LL0498~LT 1 0.44 215 IMP 13085 DICKENS STEWART 540 GRANVILLE CT~35~17 05/13/16 56179 RES $ 71,168 $ 25,400 35.69 BRIGHTWELL PETER J/SCHIEFFER VICTORIA M 17 0035 LL2521~UT 540 0.01 313 IMP 13193 MASSANET DAPHNE 7295 HIGHLAND BLF 05/13/16 56201 RES $ 287,411 $ 90,080 31.34 BRINKER EVIN N 17 0032 LL5089~10 0.02 120 IMP 16915 MABRY KENNETH LINDBERGH DR~59~17TH 06/21/16 56325 RES $ 75,372 $ 21,160 28.07 BRISTOL DOUG 17 005900060495 0.02 253 IMP 02855 HARRINGTON INVESTMENTS INC 309 HOLDERNESS ST SW ST~140~14 02/11/16 55854 RES $ 46,218 $ 18,200 39.38 BRITTAIN KEYON 14 014000030389~50' X 150' 0.17 87 IMP 03920 SHARP RESIDENTIAL LLC 273 ROSEBAY TRL TRL~196 & 02/29/16 55897 RES $ 619,844 $ 230,840 37.24 BROADERICK CARYL G/BROADERICK ARTHUR 22 419001960158~L69, PHASE I 1.09 451 IMP 10365 BLUE FISH SUB LLC 320 RIPPLING BROOK TRC TRL 04/25/16 56098 RES $ 69,775 $ 25,200 36.12 BROADTREE HOMES AZEP LLC 07 220100250736 0.23 472 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 10 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 01051 EAHI ETRIS LLLP 1090 ETRIS MANOR DR DR 01/12/16 55806 RES $ 691,913 $ 181,080 26.17 BROCK BRETT/TATUM BRANDY 22 359012360545~L23 0.28 162 IMP 05497 ROTELLO VERONICA J 6851 ROSWELL RD~73~17TH 03/09/16 55948 RES $ 104,310 $ 36,120 34.63 BROOME DORIS 17 007300050092~UN 9 0.03 429 IMP 00188 ELKOUBI RONI/CHARRAS CHISTINE 968 TELFAIR CLOSE 01/05/16 55751 RES $ 301,204 $ 104,000 34.53 BROSAN CHRISTOPHER M 17 002400010690~L40 0.02 450 IMP 17063 HAMILTON VALERIE L 3562 CARRIAGE WAY~194~14TH 06/27/16 56335 RES $ 88,278 $ 20,440 23.15 BROWN ALETHEA C 14 019400010584~L 7 BL A 0.39 506 IMP 14017 FERRELL DWIGHT A 325 EAST PACES 05/26/16 56216 RES $ 185,290 $ 87,680 47.32 BROWN BARBARA M 17 006100090860~UT 410 0.03 189 IMP 10305 ACKERMAN DONALD E 16810 QUAYSIDE DR 04/26/16 56101 RES $ 817,395 $ 265,920 32.53 BROWN BRYAN KAREN REBECCA/BRYAN III 22 436002391035~L65 UN 2C 1.39 157 IMP 17944 GREGORY S SNELL AND KAREN A SNELL 12520 CRABAPPLE CHASE DR 06/21/16 56313 RES $ 338,732 $ 102,160 30.16 BROWN CORNELIUS F/BROWN TIFFANY J 22 401111690057 0.42 570 IMP 06842 BRECHWALD MARC A 2250 CHESHIRE BRIDGE RD NE RD~5~17 03/28/16 55989 RES $ 80,602 $ 34,800 43.18 BROWN JAMES STEVEN 17 000500020882~UN 2250 0.02 17 IMP 04059 FLEMMING PAUL 2900 OLD FARM RD RD 02/22/16 55901 RES $ 57,945 $ 13,720 23.68 BROWN JR MARSHALL E 13 012600040735~L24 0.35 277 IMP 09077 DWIGHT E HOTT AND SANDRA L HOTT 345 SADDLEBROOK DR DR 04/14/16 56067 RES $ 386,578 $ 179,920 46.54 BROWN JULIETTE KATHLEEN/GORELSKI JOHN 12 185203970045~L 25 BK A 0.75 25 IMP 17839 STEELE JR MICHAEL D 1074 PEACHTREE WALK~106 06/20/16 56326 RES $ 222,735 $ 70,000 31.43 BROWN LINDSEY AUSTIN 17 010600042686 0.03 437 IMP 10465 PETER QUECANO/LUZ MARINA QUECANO FKA 211 HARMONY CT~974 05/03/16 56134 RES $ 180,124 $ 55,200 30.65 BROWN PHYLLIS R 22 542009745840~LOT 12 0.03 196 IMP 22161 HORNER LORRAINE J 170 NESBIT RIDGE DR 06/08/16 56467 RES $ 258,740 $ 81,600 31.54 BROWN ROSIMEIRE/BROWN JOHN E 12 278207660082 0.39 606 IMP 06195 PARKER DORIS G 3203 LENOX RD NE RD 03/17/16 55970 RES $ 199,490 $ 66,360 33.26 BROWN YVONNE/BROWN GREG 17 000800160792~UN 19 0.03 649 IMP 14503 KUOH DIKA E 1095 ROME DR~394~1ST 05/31/16 56247 RES $ 279,174 $ 97,080 34.77 BROWNLEE II MICHAEL SCOTT/BROWNLEE 12 186003940741~LOT 10 0.28 189 IMP 00506 VAN EPPS JASON FONDREN 1215 CRABAPPLE LAKE CIR CIR 01/05/16 55755 RES $ 314,170 $ 120,080 38.22 BRUCKER CHAD J/HAWKINS LAUREN L 12 184504000453~L106 0.22 410 IMP 14482 PARKER AMANDA J 32 HOWELL ST~45~14TH 05/31/16 56248 RES $ 244,232 $ 135,680 55.55 BRUNKARD JOAN 14 004500040327 0.13 215 IMP 09669 DUONG KHOA XUAN 2172 MELANTE DR NE DR 04/18/16 56087 RES $ 348,330 $ 115,360 33.12 BRUPBACHER BRENNAN 17 000500070184~L 5 0.26 179 IMP 18599 JENNIFER D REED AND MARK L REED 1525 CHICORY WAY~126~1ST 06/30/16 56355 RES $ 484,443 $ 161,560 33.35 BRYAN JR BENJAMIN S/BRYAN CATRECIA 11 034301260234~70 0.30 204 IMP 13760 HARRIS ANTOINE 11260 VEDRINES DR~228~1 05/13/16 56211 RES $ 351,280 $ 108,320 30.84 BRYYDLI VITALIY 11 056202280268~8 & B 0.48 154 IMP 13110 FISCHER HOMES ATL LLLP 1261 OAKSHAW RUN~1013~2ND 05/09/16 56192 RES $ 704,588 $ 318,320 45.18 BUDNIK MELISSA 22 337010130425~23 1.48 12 IMP 07656 DANIELS PAUL 1084 EDIE AVENUE SE~23~14 04/05/16 56031 RES $ 206,143 $ 54,920 26.64 BUFFINGTON TESSA W 14 002300100382~M&B 0.17 443 IMP 08779 TUCKER JEFFERY S 3180 MATHIESON DR~61 & 99~17 04/04/16 56043 RES $ 382,275 $ 173,320 45.34 BUNNEN JR ROBERT LOUIS 17 006100160648~UN 1010 0.04 592 IMP 17721 SARMIENTO SYLVIA 3143 CHURCH ST 06/20/16 56303 RES $ 26,622 $ 9,040 33.96 BURGOS RAUL 14 015800060120 0.20 109 IMP 01970 CALHOUN CHRISTINA L 245 N HIGHLAND AVE NE AVE 01/29/16 55823 RES $ 210,937 $ 60,760 28.80 BURKE MICHAEL P 14 0019 LL0977~UN 308 0.02 550 IMP 17226 SANTORA NICHOLAS 1080 PEACHTREE ST~106~17TH 06/22/16 56318 RES $ 606,961 $ 202,840 33.42 BURKE ROBERT T 17 010600052065 0.03 691 IMP 02432 WHEELER REBECCA M 1203 MCGILL PARKAVE NE AVE~46~14 02/04/16 55839 RES $ 87,985 $ 18,360 20.87 BURKHOLDER JENNIFER A 14 004600131224~UN 1203 0.02 56 IMP 16456 MILLER ANGELA 800 PEACHTREE ST~49~14 06/14/16 56302 RES $ 144,843 $ 48,600 33.55 BURMAN MALCOLM MONTANA 14 004900341242~UNIT 1402 0.02 259 IMP 14206 DLJ MORTGAGE CAPITAL INC 11057 LORIN WAY~321~1ST 05/24/16 56225 RES $ 217,241 $ 75,240 34.63 BURNETTE SYLVIA 11 090003214085~LOT 12 0.02 591 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 11 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 14474 MENENDEZ JORGE 454 HAMILTON ST~12~14 05/27/16 56232 RES $ 406,438 $ 104,480 25.71 BURRELL RICARDO 14 001200063666~UT 14 0.03 458 IMP 01004 SANTA BARBARA AINSLEY 1161 UNIVERSITY DR NE DR~2~17 01/29/16 55814 RES $ 754,821 $ 204,680 27.12 BURTON JENIFER L 17 000200090169~L16 BK E 0.19 366 IMP 13046 ARANCHELOVICH SUSAN ELENA 3190 SERENADE COURT 05/15/16 56186 RES $ 218,208 $ 67,880 31.11 BUSH GALYE M 22 542009714556~444 0.19 573 IMP 01962 SMITH JR JOHN W 4625 TELL RD EXT RD 02/01/16 55831 RES $ 33,306 $ 12,280 36.87 BUSSEY JR EUGENE/BUSSEY TOSHA 14F006600020962~L6 BK H 0.26 398 IMP 18626 CHESLOCK RONALD P 150 LONGWATER CV~LOT 230 AND 06/27/16 56370 RES $ 413,142 $ 200,400 48.51 BUTLER KEITH S 12 163102300077~LOT 7 BLK H UT 6A 0.84 245 IMP 15867 QUEST IRA INC FKA ENTRUST RETIREMENT 522 WILD CHERRY CT 06/06/16 56280 RES $ 76,122 $ 23,880 31.37 BUTLER NATHAN P/BUTLER JODI L 07 320000371101 0.37 171 IMP 00567 FARRELL CASSIDY M AKA CASSIDY CASH 11780 LEEWARD WALK CIR 01/19/16 55784 RES $ 296,444 $ 112,560 37.97 BUTNER KAREN JOAN/BUTNER 21 574312560576~L20 BK C 0.23 151 IMP 10953 CHAUDHRY MUHAMMAD T 10630 HAYNES VALLEY CT CT~793~7 04/29/16 56117 RES $ 407,363 $ 132,080 32.42 BYRD DAVID LAMAR 12 288007930312~L 2 0.25 111 IMP 06612 LASETER RICHARD A/JILL 111 BROOK LN LN 03/22/16 55978 RES $ 402,330 $ 144,400 35.89 BYRD JOHN 22 372011652168~L 75 0.42 151 IMP 05365 BETTLE AMY D 69 DELMONT DR NE DR 03/14/16 55949 RES $ 253,451 $ 85,760 33.84 BYRNE JOHN CULLEN/GILLEN ALLYSE 17 010000060031~L69 BK A 0.05 272 IMP 02239 CASSIAR LLC 16 LENOX POINTE~6~17TH 02/01/16 55837 COM $ 504,989 $ 202,480 40.10 CABIN 1 LLC 17 000600040111~16 0.06 691 IMP 16095 KELLY ELAINE R 830 GREENWOOD AVE~17~14 05/09/16 56274 RES $ 136,251 $ 44,080 32.35 CABLE ANNA CATHERINE 14 001700051096 0.02 407 IMP 17771 TORRES JASON D 4795 WEATHERVANE DR 06/24/16 56329 RES $ 269,851 $ 96,240 35.66 CACERES RAFAEL/CACERES BIELKA 11 045501920492 0.16 78 IMP 03140 DANNY ADCOCK AND DAWN A TAYLOR 4180 PROVIDENCE SQ SQ~1055~2ND 02/19/16 55876 RES $ 263,383 $ 66,760 25.35 CAFOLLA CHELSEY/AGNELLO MARCUS 22 463110550203~L20 0.49 648 IMP 13748 COSTLEY LEIGHANN 2011 BROOKVIEW DR 05/25/16 56208 RES $ 869,841 $ 380,280 43.72 CAGLE JULIANNA/CAGLE SPENCER 17 015300150275 0.28 25 IMP 14448 BEARS MICHAEL N 1100 VIRGINIA AVENUE NE~1~17 05/31/16 56242 RES $ 1,206,753 $ 518,520 42.97 CAIN SARAH M/CAIN JUSTIN S 17 000100060759 0.21 659 IMP 04700 HILDRETH SUSAN 307 RIVER GLEN DR 02/26/16 55890 RES $ 204,663 $ 66,520 32.50 CALDWELL III EARL D/CALDWELL DORIS 12 193804180147~UN 84 0.04 575 IMP 15869 AUTRY NATHAN S 220 SEMEL CIR~147~17TH 06/10/16 56284 RES $ 236,904 $ 78,400 33.09 CALHOUN STEVEN 17 0147 LL1551 0.01 385 IMP 18129 LGI HOMES-GEORGIA LLC 6479 ST. MARK WAY 06/28/16 56349 RES $ 156,930 $ 73,240 46.67 CALHOUN TERESA MONIQUE 07 150101391041 0.16 21 IMP 14319 CHISHOLM ELIZABETH M 2095 RIVER NORTH PKWY~129~17TH 05/23/16 56225 RES $ 507,718 $ 157,400 31.00 CALNIN CHRIS/CALNIN APRIL 17 012900010165~LOT 49 1.09 593 IMP 02995 PAPADIMITRIOU SPYRIDON K 11025 MORTONSXING XING~203~1ST 02/12/16 55860 RES $ 240,168 $ 71,480 29.76 CAMPBELL NELSON B 11 057202030364~37 0.15 607 IMP 03092 ELKO CHRISTOPER D 4329 CHASTAIN WALK NE RD~95~17 02/16/16 55866 RES $ 101,819 $ 50,360 49.46 CAMY NICOLE R 17 009500100297~UN 29A 0.03 121 IMP 17281 GUIGOU JR JORGE A 06/13/16 56298 RES $ 405,860 $ 153,880 37.91 CANDELIER ROBINSON/CANDELIER LORI R 12 205204801294 0.28 38 IMP 00863 DAVID MORGAN AKA DAVID G MORGAN 3180 MATHIESON DR~61 AND 99~17TH 01/19/16 55787 RES $ 881,921 $ 308,520 34.98 CANNON JR A D 17 006100160861~UNIT 1403 0.06 379 IMP 16712 SIBLEY ANTHONY 400 PEACHTREE ST 06/17/16 56315 RES $ 173,427 $ 53,840 31.04 CANNON SCOTT D 14 007900133519 0.02 610 IMP 04643 TIME COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT LLC 630 ETHERIDGE ST ST~14TH 02/29/16 55897 IND $ 48,514 $ 18,000 37.10 CANOPY DEVELOPMENT GROUP LLC 14 011300060058~122 X 167' 0.48 116 IMP 12795 MITCHELL SHAYKEESHA L 4513 CREEKSIDE CV 02/22/16 56186 RES $ 124,196 $ 59,320 47.76 CANTON III ROY F 09F350001511710 0.15 537 IMP 07461 SPENCER STUART G 1258 AALTO MAIN NW 03/28/16 56029 RES $ 298,838 $ 94,480 31.62 CANTRELL JR MARK E 17 019100071319~L 88 0.05 134 IMP 19445 CASWELL LINDA G 51 FORREST PL~90~17 06/29/16 56394 RES $ 233,588 $ 59,840 25.62 CAO CHUNSHAN/WANG CHANGBAO 17 009000050133 0.04 280 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 12 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 16381 ZHU YUNZHOU 7335 AMBERLEIGH WAY~439~1 06/24/16 56336 RES $ 305,241 $ 139,720 45.77 CAO MING 11 118104390288~AMBERLEIGH / L 280 0.31 571 IMP 08404 US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 8275 EQUINOX LANE 03/29/16 56038 RES $ 267,071 $ 118,080 44.21 CAPPS ANDY 07 130000851246~L19 1.02 100 IMP 07630 WATZMAN RHODA/LIPMAN MERRICK 9095 CLUB RIVER DR DR 03/31/16 56009 RES $ 282,220 $ 89,960 31.88 CARDEN WILLIAM RYAN/CARDEN AMY 12 256106670584~L31 0.17 504 IMP 11638 NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC 6331 RAYMOND TER 05/11/16 56162 RES $ 29,696 $ 16,760 56.44 CARDENAS SERGIO SANTOYO 09F161700760072 0.31 529 IMP 15725 REISMAN PROPERTIES L P 3405 EMPIRE BLVD SW BLVD~66~14TH 06/15/16 56269 IND $ 733,101 $ 232,120 31.66 CAROLYN EMPIRE LLC 14 0066 LL0516 2.55 235 IMP 03960 HAWKINS LESLIE PAIGE 625 ARNCLIFFE CT CT~311~1ST 02/26/16 55898 RES $ 245,596 $ 90,200 36.73 CARONE ALINE VIEIRA 11 077003112567~L512 0.25 496 IMP 15273 GALLOWAY MITCHELL G 5330 CROSS ROADS MNR 06/03/16 56253 RES $ 786,263 $ 341,440 43.43 CARP DAMON H/CAPR CARLY 17 017500060114 0.62 593 IMP 12077 LUMMUS A PORTER 3458 VALLEY RD RD 05/05/16 56142 RES $ 977,333 $ 286,080 29.27 CARPENTER GRAHAM P/CARPENTER JULIA T 17 009800040037~L17 BK A 0.59 575 IMP 19284 PRZYSIECKI PAUL 1435 RICHARDS CIR~1177 & 1200~2 06/15/16 56393 RES $ 449,795 $ 178,520 39.69 CARPENTER JOSHUA/CARPENTER HILLARY 22 465011770889~59 & A 0.43 666 IMP 08344 LAMM RUTH 222 12TH ST NE ST 04/14/16 56057 RES $ 628,771 $ 215,960 34.35 CARR JAMESON/CARR EMILY 17 010600350998~UN 2002 0.04 83 IMP 13818 HAN CONNIE 10838 BOSSIER DR~188~1 05/25/16 56220 RES $ 341,906 $ 130,000 38.02 CARRANO PEGGY 11 047001881380~191 0.11 239 IMP 09993 BROWN JAMES MICHAEL 3221 BUCK WY WAY~1046~2 04/27/16 56103 RES $ 290,730 $ 101,160 34.80 CARRERA TASCON MARIA F 22 543010465469~UN172 BDG. 17 0.03 518 IMP 11024 KATNIK MARCUS JOSEPH 1258 FOWLER ST NW ST 05/02/16 56137 RES $ 636,864 $ 172,560 27.10 CARSON KATIE/DETTMERING BRETT A 17 010800070081 0.11 246 IMP 12254 TIMOTHY M SWOGER AND MARCIA K 1404 LEXINGTON DR 04/29/16 56149 RES $ 294,923 $ 121,560 41.22 CARSTENS DEBRA A 12 176003652206~UN 1404 BLDG 1400 0.04 630 IMP 16829 PATTERSON JANICE KAREN 940 PINE GROVE POINTE DR~194~1ST 06/27/16 56336 RES $ 247,179 $ 90,320 36.54 CARTER II RICHMOND S/CARTER JENNIFER L 12 148201940212~23, BLK D 1.23 241 IMP 16809 BORN WILLIAM 1850 MAYFILED RD 06/20/16 56315 RES $ 250,156 $ 63,880 25.54 CARTER MARCEY R 22 465111780051 0.51 335 IMP 15010 MULLER RICHARD J 2025 DARIEN PARK DR 05/03/16 56260 RES $ 367,600 $ 116,080 31.58 CARTHY AMOUR/CARTHY DUANE A 12 207004700981 0.32 607 IMP 13934 SALKIN JOSHUA 1405 HAMPTON HILL DR~917~1ST 05/27/16 56221 RES $ 550,950 $ 164,640 29.88 CARVER II WILLIAM/WOOD ELIZABETH 12 314109170068~6A 0.69 375 IMP 03921 BREADY JUSTIN S 3127 HEYBRIDGE LN LN 02/29/16 55902 RES $ 677,608 $ 225,480 33.28 CASEY CLAIRE W/CASEY MATTHEW B 22 400010972335~L23 0.38 555 IMP 14025 MARINE JUDITH P 2014 BROOKVIEW DR~153~17 05/25/16 56214 RES $ 511,050 $ 172,400 33.73 CASEY JEREMY C/CASEY ANNE R 17 015300150143~17 BLOCK K 0.34 172 IMP 13020 IRENE SALBO AND KARL SALBO 260 SADDLE CREEK LN~475 05/13/16 56175 RES $ 310,221 $ 124,160 40.02 CASPER WILLIAM THOMAS/CASPER NATALIA 12 204304750337~LOT 32 0.55 342 IMP 12522 MONTGOMERY MICHAEL 311 PEACHTREE HILLS AVE 05/09/16 56166 RES $ 104,727 $ 34,200 32.66 CASSIDY KELLEY M 17 0058 LL1772 0.02 417 IMP 02904 IBARRA VALENTIN RODRIGUEZ 1275 PARKMONT DR DR~562~1ST 02/16/16 55860 RES $ 121,213 $ 52,080 42.97 CASTANEDA IVAN 12 228205620083~L8 0.29 117 IMP 15613 KOCHAN BRANDIE 2700 PINE TREE RD 06/09/16 56264 RES $ 107,356 $ 41,720 38.86 CASTILLO GENNY DENISE 17 004700141084 0.02 433 IMP 10627 BAXTER CHARLES E 2916 NANCY CREEK RD NW RD~232 & 04/29/16 56126 RES $ 1,117,482 $ 379,440 33.95 CATHELL MATTHEW K 17 023300010127~LOT 24 1.44 218 IMP 13463 ELISA ALVAREZ-GARRIDO AND ARMANDO 05/20/16 56203 RES $ 167,944 $ 58,880 35.06 CAVAGGION CHIARA 17 000800100855 0.03 573 IMP 03539 GLENN DAVENPORT AND HOLLYCE R 8637 ELLARD DR~879~1ST 02/18/16 55868 RES $ 1,161,584 $ 295,000 25.40 CAVANAUGH CHRISTINE M/CAVANAUGH 12 309008791675~L 137 0.37 506 IMP 17692 CHILDRESS EVELYN M 1402 VILLAGE LANE CIR~182 & 183~1 06/03/16 56302 RES $ 256,007 $ 95,000 37.11 CEBALLOS LINDA BRYANT/CEBALLOS 12 145001821212~UNIT 1402 0.04 394 IMP 10565 THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON F/K/A THE 4309 BEN HILL RD RD~155~9F 04/21/16 56110 RES $ 105,667 $ 43,720 41.38 CEESAY BARBARA 09F370001551532~L3B, BK A 0.41 233 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 13 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 01956 BASS KATHERINE WHITLEY 1211 OLD HAMMOND CHASE 01/29/16 55823 RES $ 97,911 $ 35,200 35.95 CEKIS REBECCA M/MULLEN MICHAEL P 17 002300020211~UN 1211 0.03 592 IMP 03361 POWERS NANCY M 2 GLENALD WY NW WAY 02/24/16 55881 RES $ 135,022 $ 40,000 29.62 CENTER STEPHEN W/CENTER JOHN L 17 019400050047~UN 2 0.03 662 IMP 07087 MANIKOWSKI KAYE CREWS 325 AMADOR CIR CIR 03/30/16 56006 RES $ 362,435 $ 113,880 31.42 CETINDAG TIMUR/GRIZZARD MEGAN 17 002400020640~L13 BK C 0.61 639 IMP 17315 ROEPKE THADDEUS MARK 2930 WESTMINISTER CIR 06/21/16 56321 RES $ 1,325,666 $ 311,840 23.52 CHA CHARLES WEUNG/GARVEY LAURA C 17 018300020084 0.42 176 IMP 13576 VIRGINIA WARREN FKA VIRGINIA L 6700 ROSWELL ROAD APT. 2B~73 AND 05/27/16 56225 RES $ 107,480 $ 37,880 35.24 CHAKUA WYCLIFF 17 007300030086 0.03 48 IMP 03141 SOMERS MARY ANN 1092 MCLYNN AVE NE AVE~2~17TH 02/19/16 55876 RES $ 795,345 $ 324,040 40.74 CHAMI FERAS/SHAKIBNIA LILLIAN LILY 17 000200120479~LT 7, BLK 7 0.17 346 IMP 04600 ALVERSON WILLIAM DEAN 9585 KINGSTON CROSSING CIRCLE 03/04/16 55919 RES $ 407,368 $ 158,360 38.87 CHANCY SEAN R/CHANCY JENNIFER S 11 062102120414~L60 BK A 0.98 261 IMP 11342 KENNEY RICHARD C 2338 STRATHMORE DR NE DR 05/02/16 56126 RES $ 384,418 $ 130,000 33.82 CHANDLER JILL KELLY/TRUDEAU GREGORY 17 000500050285~L36 BK C 0.22 159 IMP 00526 SUMMERVILLE BOBBY J 199 14TH ST NE ST~106~17 01/07/16 55762 RES $ 268,933 $ 89,960 33.45 CHANDNANI AARTI/SODAH SUNIL 17 010600064029~UN 2405 0.03 400 IMP 17481 HEATHER E MCNAY AND WILLIAM C STAIR II 5855 SUNSET MAPLE DR 06/20/16 56304 RES $ 461,444 $ 160,800 34.85 CHANDRASHEKHAR PEKKY AND SIRISHA 21 575111620594 0.35 157 IMP 14931 MOLEDA JAROSLAW 7705 HIGHLAND BLUFF BLF~32~17 05/27/16 56240 RES $ 419,986 $ 145,480 34.64 CHANG BAOLIN/CAO CHUNMEI 17 0032 LL4512 0.16 477 IMP 09292 WHITE II TIMOTHY/LINDSEY/LOCHBAUM 10694 WEIR WY WAY~169~1 03/30/16 56069 RES $ 240,996 $ 73,200 30.37 CHANG JAE HEE 11 048001691548~L 161 0.06 399 IMP 00535 LINDSEY GLENN GILMER 195 MARSH GLEN POINT~126 & 01/20/16 55784 RES $ 530,281 $ 169,760 32.01 CHARLES OLIVER/KRISTEN OLIVER 17 012600060106~19 A 0.43 404 IMP 19631 KIM SUNG JI 3338 PEACHTREE RD 06/30/16 56377 RES $ 176,161 $ 63,160 35.85 CHARLES ZHANG AND YAN XUAN LI AS JOINT 17 0062 LL0802 0.02 477 IMP 06004 GUADALUPE DAVID 403 RIVER FARM DR~F-16~1ST 02/17/16 55957 RES $ 195,748 $ 89,800 45.88 CHARLISH ANDREW E 11 053200150148~LT 80, BLDG 4, 0.06 374 IMP 08370 GELLING DANIEL/JESSICA/GELLING JESSICA 790 CRAB ORCHARD CT CT~737~1ST 04/11/16 56047 RES $ 284,714 $ 81,360 28.58 CHARRON BRETT D/SCHWARTZ LISA J 12 275507370180~L19 BK K 0.30 111 IMP 17287 CLITES KENNETH A 800 PEACHTREE ST~49~14 06/17/16 56291 RES $ 314,836 $ 82,760 26.29 CHATTERJEE RITWIK 14 004900341838 0.04 390 IMP 17568 MOSHKSARAN SIAVASH 85 CLUB DR~1119 & 1120~2 06/03/16 56302 RES $ 714,376 $ 340,680 47.69 CHAUDHARY BHAVYA/CHAUDHARY JAYANT 21 561111200207~20 0.87 349 IMP 02935 CARPENTER KENNETH S 697 OLD IVY RD 02/09/16 55855 RES $ 686,894 $ 274,200 39.92 CHAUHAN RAKESH 17 004400030488~PT LTS 7,8,38 0.70 36 IMP 17425 DUBE WILLIAM R 862 LENOX OAKS CIR~47~17 06/23/16 56319 RES $ 215,156 $ 85,440 39.71 CHAVARRIA LEO POLDO 17 004700090133~12 0.04 20 IMP 03993 CRAIG L WILLISON LAUREL A WILLISON 4120 FALLS RIDGE DR DR~110 & 03/02/16 55915 RES $ 638,287 $ 257,200 40.30 CHENG EDUARDO/DESOUZA FERNANDA 11 019101000971~L 183 0.67 516 IMP 16118 LANNOM CHANCE 6520 ROSWELL RD 06/09/16 56289 RES $ 101,094 $ 35,980 35.59 CHIA KET VUI/THON CHANPISEY 17 008800060375 0.03 641 IMP 09989 RODTS CONSTANCE E/DENNEY LEAH 891 CARDOVA DR NE DR 04/27/16 56102 RES $ 325,341 $ 116,320 35.75 CHILDS STUART HUNTSMAN/PEMBER 17 000500040534~L7 BK G 0.40 450 IMP 08255 KIM HANKYUL 3324 PEACHTREE ROAD NE, UNIT 1707 04/04/16 56051 RES $ 222,329 $ 82,080 36.92 CHISCOP KATARINA 17 0062 LL5041~UN 1707 0.02 106 IMP 10649 OATMAN MELANIE J 273 12TH ST ST~106~17TH 05/02/16 56133 RES $ 216,120 $ 85,330 39.48 CHO JEAN 17 010600093184~UN 313 0.02 105 IMP 11926 CHOI JASON HOON 10760 BRUNSON DR 04/28/16 56156 RES $ 284,066 $ 104,680 36.85 CHO MYUNGHEE 11 090003453626 0.02 42 IMP 17669 WILLIAM PATTERSON III AND SUZANNE S 7055 AMBERLEIGH WAY 06/28/16 56337 RES $ 377,108 $ 156,680 41.55 CHO SEAN 11 118204310160 1.20 350 IMP 10882 SHAW MICHAEL R 175 PROVIDENCE PLANTATION DR DR 04/27/16 56117 RES $ 447,632 $ 118,360 26.44 CHOICE JESSICA L/CHOICE GAVIN O 22 368109240023~L 2 1.09 234 IMP 04037 AEGIS CAPITAL FUNDING LLC 660 GLEN IRIS DR NE DR 02/29/16 55922 RES $ 240,287 $ 87,200 36.29 CHRISTIAN MELISSA 14 004800340062~UN 303 0.02 3 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 14 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 16240 STEVEN D KNAPP AND JO ANN KNAPP 7625 HOPKINS ROAD~74~8TH 06/10/16 56288 RES $ 49,169 $ 23,000 46.78 CHRISTOPHER R HAYWOOD/SHAWN A 08 170000740963 6.24 76 VAC 09197 JOHNS JULYE M 2540 SIBLEY DR NE DR 04/12/16 56064 RES $ 453,168 $ 180,000 39.72 CHUNARA SHEHZAAN 17 0006 LL4316~L 25 0.02 207 IMP 17340 BONNELL RENEE 815 MILLWORK CIR~346~1 06/15/16 56335 RES $ 258,298 $ 107,840 41.75 CHUNG KYU SOO 11 100003460685~24 B 0.02 115 IMP 12780 WILLIAM H WHITLOCK AND ANNE L 05/13/16 56182 RES $ 129,563 $ 44,200 34.11 CHUNG VICKIE B 14 007800121309 0.02 509 IMP 40549 875 OLD ROSWELL SU 300 B RD COM $ 80,918 $ 31,760 39.25 CLARK ROBERT J/SHIRLEY 12 218505040439 0.02 IMP 08508 BARTON JEFFERSON 823 SAINT CHARLES AVE NE 04/08/16 56046 RES $ 495,796 $ 160,560 32.38 CLARK THOMAS A/CLARK ELIZABETH V 14 001700090920~CONDO LT 1 0.07 235 IMP 02845 BORM ALFRED 3102 W ADDISON DR DR 02/05/16 55842 RES $ 1,233,401 $ 391,320 31.73 CLARKE MAROLYN/CLARKE BRYAN 12 309008301160~L318 0.50 559 IMP 14226 HUGGINS AND NATASHA J HUGGINS 3429 HABERSHAM RD~115~17 05/25/16 56219 RES $ 1,623,601 $ 517,080 31.85 CLAY JONATHAN 17 011500010583~TRACT TWO 0.73 496 IMP 13191 CULPEPPER REES E 1036 WOODLAND AVE 05/13/16 56201 RES $ 249,089 $ 77,920 31.28 CLAY JUSTEN DAVIS/CLAY ANN MARIE 14 001000070382 0.31 141 IMP 07367 GARRY LIGONDE JR AND ODILE LIGONDE 5005 PATTINGHAM DR 03/29/16 56005 RES $ 230,802 $ 85,560 37.07 CLAYTON JENNIFER KATHLEEN 12 220305010018~L1 BK A 0.19 346 IMP 14010 MATTOCKS EMILY 2407 CLAUDE ST~272~17 05/18/16 56216 RES $ 218,189 $ 60,400 27.68 CLEMENT ANDREA 17 025200030196~32 D 0.24 404 IMP 04012 DANIEL JOHN W 5 VISTA SQ~184,185,194,195~17TH 02/26/16 55907 RES $ 151,210 $ 42,400 28.04 CLEMENTS CLAIRE/CLEMENTS ARTHUR STITT 17 018500041542~UN 5 0.03 22 IMP 16346 BONE ALAN G 270 MANSELL CIR 06/24/16 56328 RES $ 225,613 $ 55,280 24.50 CLEVELAND ANDREW J/CLEVELAND HAILEY M 12 209204650818 0.37 691 IMP 08037 SMITH ADRIAN R 2260 BURDETT RIDGE DRIVE~99~13TH 03/31/16 56023 RES $ 90,310 $ 28,240 31.27 CLEVELAND SANDRA 13 0099 LL0436~L 76 0.20 671 IMP 04751 LANGLOIS TIMOTHY/FULLER JESSICA 1040 WOODLAND AVE SE AVE 03/04/16 55922 RES $ 275,093 $ 61,560 22.38 CLEVENGER KATHERINE/TYLER GRAY 14 001000070374~L 4 BK 6 0.28 412 IMP 12256 RODRIGUEZ JOSEPH J 1080 PEACHTREE ST NE ST 05/05/16 56143 RES $ 279,894 $ 93,990 33.58 CLINE ANTHONY/CLINE JASON 17 010600050846~UN 901 0.02 428 IMP 16460 BRENNAN RYAN 3450 MERGANSER LN 06/21/16 56312 RES $ 350,259 $ 149,680 42.73 CLOUTIER LAWRIE C 12 319409260683 0.30 487 IMP 17220 ROBINSON LEANNE K 951 GLENWOOD AVE~12~14 06/15/16 56321 RES $ 174,574 $ 59,600 34.14 CLUBB NATHAN/KEMPTER VICTORIA 14 001200091675 0.03 243 IMP 12129 TARATOOT BRADLY M 230 KINSEY CT NE 05/04/16 56138 RES $ 242,442 $ 114,560 47.25 COATS MARGARET M 17 010200130428~PT L 5 0.09 210 IMP 17131 GORMAN WILLIAM D 1797 MERCER AVE 06/20/16 56338 RES $ 190,789 $ 67,200 35.22 COBB JEFFREY W 14 015900010025 0.23 27 IMP 16448 JONATHAN M PALMER AND JENNIFER K 2060 VILLAGE CREST DRIVE NW 06/13/16 56295 RES $ 316,660 $ 102,840 32.48 COBBS JERMAINE G 17 0256 LL1368 0.11 633 IMP 14522 COBB H HART 6840 LISA LN 06/03/16 56249 RES $ 448,395 $ 163,080 36.37 COBLE WHITNEY H/COBLE BRETT D 17 002000020222 0.38 518 IMP 11559 HANNESTAD PAULETTE NKA DESALVO 5909 WATERS EDGE TRL TRL~248 & 05/05/16 56138 RES $ 234,009 $ 91,240 38.99 COFFEY KAREN F 12 154002483048~UN 5909 0.03 44 IMP 12481 DENG ZHICHOA 5465 HILLGATE XING~269~1 05/13/16 56182 RES $ 280,112 $ 111,400 39.77 COFFIELD JOHN P 11 065202691325~8 0.26 92 IMP 10394 COPLIN CARROLL R 505 TATUM DR DR 04/13/16 56095 RES $ 573,192 $ 246,120 42.94 COFFMAN JUSTIN 12 300008480260~L 1 BK E 0.31 154 IMP 14065 STROUPE JULIAN 372 TEAL CT 05/31/16 56225 RES $ 76,548 $ 27,880 36.42 COHEN ARON/ALEXANBAN-COHEN ASIA 12 242606160623 0.02 3 IMP 01413 DELICATE INC 220 ZEBLIN RD RD~39~17TH 01/22/16 55791 RES $ 1,042,629 $ 440,360 42.24 COHEN SHIRA/COHEN AUSTIN 17 003900020080~L8 BK. A 0.42 302 IMP 17192 CAMPBELL JAMES S 792 BROOKSHADE PKWY 06/16/16 56311 RES $ 542,916 $ 247,080 45.51 COKER AMY C/COKER DENNIS S 22 478009810211 0.64 66 IMP 12176 STYPEREK GEORGIA REAL PROPERTIES LLC 2865 LENOX RD RD 04/29/16 56141 RES $ 286,168 $ 83,960 29.34 COKINOS-CELIO BARBARA 17 0007 LL1584~UN 604 0.04 112 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 15 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 07128 MORENO CONCEPCION 4806 TIMBERCREEK CIR CIR 03/29/16 56005 RES $ 207,251 $ 66,400 32.04 COLE NATALIE J 12 217105200393~L48 BLDG 4800 0.04 196 IMP 08914 SCHAEFER THOMAS 560 TWIN SPRINGS RD RD~137~17 04/12/16 56057 RES $ 734,137 $ 355,600 48.44 COLE SUSAN W/COLE DARGAN S 17 013700040501~LT 10 BK E 0.41 673 IMP 02929 MALONEY-IRWIN KATHLEEN A 1965 NOCTURNE DR 02/08/16 55845 RES $ 149,171 $ 57,440 38.51 COLEMAN ERIC DOUGHLAS 12 260006891266~UN 1208 0.03 421 IMP 06943 PAULSEN BRADLEY S 4822 LAKE FORREST DR DR~120~17TH 03/29/16 56005 RES $ 718,784 $ 235,080 32.71 COLLIE NATASHA/COLLIE EDWARD 17 012000020320~L 4, BK. H 0.63 24 IMP 04711 CHANG WEI CHRISTIE 943 PEACHTREE ST NE ST~106~17 02/26/16 55894 RES $ 176,733 $ 67,840 38.39 COLLINS III OLIVER 17 010600081643~UNIT 1214 0.02 680 IMP 09943 VALKYRIE HOLDINGS LLC 970 SIDNEY MARCUS BLVD NE BLVD 04/04/16 56093 RES $ 111,634 $ 40,920 36.66 COLLINS SABRINA 17 0006 LL2690~UN 1419 0.02 79 IMP 09049 CHASTAIN KENNETH W 106 ROSAIRE PL NW PL 04/14/16 56059 RES $ 153,700 $ 41,120 26.75 COLWELL JOSHUA O 17 019400050963~UN 106 0.03 650 IMP 08908 HEDDEN TRISHA L 600 BRICKWORKS CIR NE CIR 04/08/16 56046 RES $ 336,767 $ 117,480 34.88 COMPARETTO FRANK/COMPARETTO CLAIRE 14 001900080804~UN 6201 0.03 609 IMP 16213 STEGALL GRACE OSHODE 695 BIRCHBERRY TER~77~14FF 06/13/16 56289 RES $ 141,293 $ 53,720 38.02 CONLIFFE JUDITH L 14F007800030413~LOT 22 0.41 477 IMP 13301 WILSON BRYAN 1080 LUNSFORD CIR CIR~1132~2ND 05/02/16 56191 RES $ 616,172 $ 240,000 38.95 CONNOR LEANNA T/CONNOR III FRANCIS V 22 433011310742~LOT 23, BETHANY 0.34 630 IMP 05593 SINGH OMKAR 577 RANKIN ST NE ST 03/11/16 55943 RES $ 562,803 $ 280,560 49.85 CONSTANTIN TINA/EL CHAAR EDGARD S 14 004700060729~190 X 50 0.22 24 IMP 11307 BELAY JEANNIE A 6219 HOLLYFERN LN LN 04/19/16 56137 RES $ 250,619 $ 99,000 39.50 CONTEH-CAMARA MBAKUTU 14F0127 LL0665~L 419 UN 4 0.33 139 IMP 11556 PARKER SANDRA G 12225 MAGNOLIA CRESCENT 05/05/16 56145 RES $ 339,543 $ 112,840 33.23 COOK DYLAN/BARTELS SHERRI 22 359112850940~LT 6, BLK B 0.44 22 IMP 09469 LEVIN ANDREW J 3545 WENNINGTON TRC TRCE~1044~2 04/21/16 56093 RES $ 190,015 $ 65,280 34.36 COON KATHERINE A 22 543010443490~L30 BLDG 6 0.04 304 IMP 17124 TERRY MONIQUE 1082 METROPOLITAN PKWY 06/22/16 56322 RES $ 44,304 $ 10,080 22.75 COOPER INDIA 14 008700071446 0.15 680 IMP 17702 TIFFANY RIDDICK AKA TIFFANY ALEXIS 7088 THOREAU CIR 05/31/16 56314 RES $ 171,107 $ 76,240 44.56 COOPER JANICE/COOPER DAMON 14F0156 LL0818 0.23 183 IMP 15424 HAMILTON KELLY ELIZABETH 1739 ELLEN ST~223~17 06/03/16 56257 RES $ 314,505 $ 104,760 33.31 COOPER JASON P/COPPER KELLY M 17 022300010236~LOT 11 BLOCK 7 0.17 679 IMP 14814 GRETO MICHAEL N 5559 GLENRIDGE DR 05/27/16 56232 RES $ 181,542 $ 49,520 27.28 COOPER JESSICA A 17 003800010553 0.03 56 IMP 14048 TRAUNER MARY C 1067 ALTA AVE 05/25/16 56208 RES $ 140,200 $ 54,360 38.77 COPELAND SHERRY C 14 001400081245 0.02 47 IMP 00415 JOHNSON CEDELL M 5065 FOXBERRY LN 01/11/16 55770 RES $ 263,156 $ 101,840 38.70 CORDERO ELI 12 177003661130~L8 BK B 0.18 577 IMP 17000 DAM MARY L 800 PEACHTREE ST~49~14 06/15/16 56294 RES $ 280,565 $ 84,560 30.14 CORLETT BRITTANY L 14 004900342331 0.03 168 IMP 10166 SHAW ROBERT J 2164 COLLINS DR NW DR 04/21/16 56095 RES $ 264,167 $ 101,880 38.57 CORONA CINDY/CORONA JAMES BENJAMIN 17 024400050419~LTS 10-12 BK I 0.96 41 IMP 18510 DALTON JERAMIE ALLAN 580 SHERINGHAM CT 06/29/16 56344 RES $ 189,515 $ 75,960 40.08 CORTNER JOHN ALEXANDER 12 275607380303 0.29 465 IMP 10631 CITIMORTGAGE INC 2145 HIGH POINT TRL SW TRL 04/25/16 56111 RES $ 129,398 $ 79,640 61.55 COTTON ELLIOT 14F007000010280~L30 0.72 406 IMP 10427 WAGLEY DOROTHY J 5520 CHEMIN DE VIE~93~17TH 04/20/16 56081 RES $ 199,426 $ 64,120 32.15 COUGHLAN MELANIE 17 009300090433~UNIT 5520 0.04 663 IMP 11132 LOPEZ FRANK/LACEY MARK 2545 SIBLEY DR NE DR 05/04/16 56132 RES $ 477,538 $ 180,040 37.70 COUP RAE ANNE 17 0006 LL4431~L 11 0.02 541 IMP 04839 JOHNSON JEFFREY L 6550 WRIGHT RD RD~88~17TH 02/26/16 55910 RES $ 406,919 $ 120,960 29.73 COUVILLION MATTHEW/WHICKER ELIZABETH 17 008800050046~L 4 BK E U 5 0.42 599 IMP 03972 HOLT JR MICHAEL P 340 STONEBRIDGE DRIVE~463,464~1 02/29/16 55895 RES $ 274,888 $ 78,960 28.72 COX MARY K 12 210104640602~L49 0.67 201 IMP 06532 CREATIVE INVESTMENT SOLUTIONS GROUP 23 FORREST PL 03/28/16 56004 RES $ 207,396 $ 59,640 28.76 COX RANDOLPH C/COX ELIZABETH E 17 009000050539~UN 23 0.05 545 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 16 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 13724 WINCHESTER IAN D 2468 RUTHERFORD STREET NW 05/27/16 56227 RES $ 322,893 $ 109,240 33.83 CRADER CAITLIN M/CRADER EDWARD GALEN 17 0253 LL0330 0.24 310 IMP 05292 GRUBBS LYNNE E 1325 PEACHTREE ST 03/10/16 55937 RES $ 482,531 $ 125,360 25.98 CRAWFORD MARIA 17 010500140234~UN 502 0.03 441 IMP 13088 BURNHAM JOY G 215 GABRIEL DR~250 & 253~1ST 05/17/16 56184 RES $ 582,260 $ 193,320 33.20 CREECH ROBIN T/CREECH JAMES A 12 153302530193~67 BLK AA 0.65 422 IMP 08531 VAN HOLM BRIAN R/BERGEAUX EMMA 7501 SAINT CHARLES SQ SQ 04/08/16 56039 RES $ 154,352 $ 42,920 27.81 CRESSLEY CLAYTON 12 200604250366~UN 10 BLDG C 0.04 348 IMP 09841 HAKES CAPITAL LLC 6814 GLENRIDGE DR DR~34~17 04/25/16 56105 RES $ 129,305 $ 32,920 25.46 CREWS SEAN THOMAS 17 0034 LL0872~UN 6814A 0.02 497 IMP 13628 MARELL MARCI D 1369 LOCKHAVEN CIR~152~14 05/20/16 56216 RES $ 27,234 $ 10,160 37.31 CRICHLOW VENA 14 015200120086~43 0.22 402 IMP 12362 BOZEMAN AMELIA 6851 ROSWELL RD 04/18/16 56182 RES $ 92,888 $ 33,080 35.61 CROOK RODNEY L 17 007300062642 0.03 1 IMP 12828 WATSON MAURICE 3067 STONE GATE DR~46~17TH 05/16/16 56180 RES $ 455,220 $ 158,600 34.84 CROSBY CELISSA/CROSBY ANTONIO 17 0046 LL0720~LOT 13 0.03 554 IMP 06436 FRIEDLINE JON PAUL 791 WYLIE ST SE ST 03/21/16 55966 RES $ 175,254 $ 55,040 31.41 CROSE JAMES E 14 002000070836~UN 105 0.02 132 IMP 16166 BITON LIOR 6700 ROSWELL RD~73 & 87~17 06/03/16 56284 RES $ 94,262 $ 34,440 36.54 CROSS BENJAMIN C 17 007300030722~UNIT 32-D RALEIGH 0.02 87 IMP 06155 SUMTER STREET LLC 1845 SUMTER ST NW ST~230~17TH 03/21/16 55969 RES $ 151,571 $ 38,320 25.28 CROSSMAN WILLIAM ANDREW 17 023000060190~L 11 BK B 0.21 654 IMP 05601 LIN ROUNTREE LIN ROUNDTREE AKA 4519 PARKWAY CIR CIR 03/11/16 55949 RES $ 98,252 $ 38,120 38.80 CROWE-HOWARD AMELIA I 09F370001553108~L97 0.16 51 IMP 02588 PATEL DIPESH 170 BOULEVARD SE 02/11/16 55851 RES $ 228,558 $ 73,760 32.27 CROWNOVER CASEY E 14 0045 LL2039~UN E105 0.02 313 IMP 15268 OREN SHACHAR 301 10TH ST~54~17TH 06/02/16 56260 RES $ 238,300 $ 66,480 27.90 CRUSOE DAVID J 17 005400070028~UNIT 2 0.03 233 IMP 11960 WHITMORE GARY LEE 270 ROLLING MIST CT CT 05/10/16 56151 RES $ 370,328 $ 126,240 34.09 CUI YE/WANG ZHIBO 11 016100790198~L19 BK 8 0.31 128 IMP 12640 FOX II ROBERT J 3122 WOOD VALLEY RD 05/16/16 56177 RES $ 769,322 $ 265,160 34.47 CULLENS KATHRYN/CULLENS IV ZACK 17 015700050018 0.76 231 IMP 06431 BRICKSTONE PROPERTIES LLC/FP 1396 BENTEEN PARK DR SE DR~24~14TH 03/18/16 55968 RES $ 284,788 $ 97,760 34.33 CUNNINGHAM SHARISE J/CUNNINGHAM SR 14 002400060650~L48 0.12 313 IMP 11723 MCCART WILLIAM JERRY 10120 KINROSS RD RD 05/06/16 56143 RES $ 398,906 $ 150,160 37.64 CUPPIA ROBERT J/CUPPIA ANDREW R 12 290107900518~L39 BK C 0.16 384 IMP 15906 GABKA MIROSLAW 512 NORTHRIDGE XING 06/10/16 56286 RES $ 58,108 $ 23,600 40.61 CURI ARDIT 17 002500040639 0.05 682 IMP 10384 LIU FEI 7500 BROOKSTEAD XING XING~462~1 04/21/16 56101 RES $ 338,320 $ 127,840 37.79 CURLEY JEREMY P 11 121104620811~L15 BK A 0.33 330 IMP 17831 ESTRELLA JAVIER 7330 VILLAGE CREEK TER 06/16/16 56308 RES $ 382,711 $ 155,760 40.70 CURRIVAN LAUREL S/CURRIVAN STEPHEN M 17 0022 LL1841 0.03 537 IMP 13571 LOWE MARTIN BARRINGTON 248 TARA TRL TRL 05/31/16 56230 RES $ 756,472 $ 221,200 29.24 CURRY EMILY ELIZABETH/CURRY TILDEN 17 0120 LL0778 1.01 115 IMP 14844 BRISTOL CONSULTING GROUP INC 3062 AZLEE PL NW 04/01/16 56238 RES $ 47,004 $ 16,400 34.89 DALTON JOHN 17 026000020213 0.25 40 IMP 04017 BROWN EDDIE LEE/CUTTER NANCY 790 STRATFORDE DR DR 02/29/16 55902 RES $ 421,463 $ 115,080 27.30 DANCEY NICHOLAS JOHN 22 490006190521~L10 1.16 537 IMP 10357 CHAPMAN CLIFFORD W 7690 RYEFIELD DR 04/22/16 56091 RES $ 444,597 $ 144,560 32.51 DANIEL DOUGLAS S/DANIEL JENIFER RENA 06 033800010108~L20 BK A 1.29 116 IMP 07883 SABRA FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP 7212 CARLISLE CT CT~74~17 04/05/16 56030 RES $ 131,242 $ 35,080 26.73 DANIEL MORGAN E/O'GORMAN SIDNEY 17 007400040696~UN 4 BLDG 19 0.04 33 IMP 01442 YING JIE 45 IVAN ALLEN JR. BLVD 01/20/16 55803 RES $ 611,749 $ 157,120 25.68 DANIELS ALLEN B/DANIELS JUDITH ANN 14 007900110772~UN 2107 0.04 559 IMP 06659 WHITE TREE MUNICIPAL CAPITAL 214 LLC 2849 WINDSOR FORREST CT 03/10/16 55986 RES $ 40,092 $ 21,170 52.80 DAPHMAN LLC 13 0062 LL1684~L 41 BK A 0.12 344 IMP 16365 KABBABE GRACIELA 855 PEACHTREE ST 06/17/16 56307 RES $ 224,120 $ 91,960 41.03 DARCY JR JAMES A 14 004900022388 0.02 58 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 17 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 04421 KENNEDY-COOK NICOLE 7529 RUTGERS CIR 03/04/16 55921 RES $ 83,391 $ 31,200 37.41 DARDEN CARLOS D 09F070000336360~UN 10904 0.02 107 IMP 11026 KARLSON LORI LYNN 265 ROSWELL FARMS RD RD 05/02/16 56137 RES $ 209,682 $ 67,960 32.41 DARLING DAVID W/DARLING JENNIFER E 12 181303741006~L3 BK B 0.29 320 IMP 01615 ARP CHARLES R 2511 WEST WESLEY RD RD 01/25/16 55807 RES $ 2,681,932 $ 560,000 20.88 DASHER ERIN K/DASHER KARL F 17 0233 LL1051 3.75 316 IMP 06230 DAVID ROSENBERG AND LEA K ROSENBERG 645 OAKMONT HILL HL 03/18/16 55967 RES $ 362,630 $ 113,480 31.29 DATTA KAUSHIK/DAS SONIA 11 090103210157~L15 2.69 481 IMP 06558 ALFARO CARYL L 16285 LACONIA LANE 03/04/16 55981 RES $ 489,800 $ 217,080 44.32 DAVID NEAL P/DAVID SALLY J 22 452002640362~L4 1.00 374 IMP 08815 CARNAGHI KRISTY FKA HELTZMANN 136 PEACHTREE MEMORIAL DR NW DR 04/07/16 56037 RES $ 181,608 $ 57,040 31.41 DAVIDSON KAITLYN 17 011100110239~#2 0.03 146 IMP 08539 LGI HOMES-GEORGIA LLC 6534 ST. MARK WY WAY~139~7 03/25/16 56054 RES $ 166,170 $ 71,080 42.78 DAVIS ARRE 07 150101390688~L 51 0.15 328 IMP 07606 BRUCE BUCKLAND AND DEBI C BUCKLAND 3334 PEACHTREE RD~62~17TH 04/01/16 56031 RES $ 399,531 $ 112,640 28.19 DAVIS BRENDA L/TOKARCZYK GEORGE 17 006200022342~UNIT 1606 0.04 1 IMP 08516 KEEN DENNIS S 3865 BUFFINGTON PL PL~59~PTH F 03/25/16 56051 RES $ 87,903 $ 21,720 24.71 DAVIS JERMEKA 09F130500590054~L 5 0.23 295 IMP 18600 TEYF YEVGENY P 860 PEACHTREE ST~49~14 06/28/16 56345 RES $ 211,621 $ 61,000 28.83 DAVIS JOSEPH SCOTT 14 004900015705 0.02 653 IMP 14983 JEWETT BARBARA J 335 HIGHLANDS CT~58~1ST 06/06/16 56256 RES $ 406,165 $ 146,520 36.07 DAVIS JR MICHAEL K 11 018000581230~41 0.32 174 IMP 11996 LYNDE GRANT C 775 WILDWOOD RD~51~17 05/10/16 56157 RES $ 959,196 $ 270,000 28.15 DAVIS KELLI M 17 005100020539 0.34 43 IMP 07921 ROZEMA DONALD R 300 WIEUCA RD 04/05/16 56030 COM $ 285,643 $ 91,640 32.08 DAVIS REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS LLC 17 006500130084~UN D-2 0.04 56 IMP 06167 CHOU HSING TE/KIM JENNIFER 1663 N. ROCK SPRINGS RD NE 03/18/16 55972 RES $ 992,011 $ 333,780 33.65 DAVIS WILLIAM/DAVIS SARAH REID 17 005100050643~L2, PT LTS 1,34 BK 7 0.45 149 IMP 12823 BARBER WILLIAM S 5840 HILDERBRAND DR~70~17TH 05/06/16 56165 RES $ 278,317 $ 122,440 43.99 DAVOS DEVELOPMENT LLC 17 007000030154~LOT 12, BLOCK K 0.61 452 IMP 00014 MALDONADO ANTHONY J 2724 ATWOOD RD NE 01/04/16 55735 RES $ 553,904 $ 199,080 35.94 DAVOUDI ROBERT MORGAN/FATEMEH 17 006000060484~L10 BK N 0.24 655 IMP 14529 COX SEAN B 6202 BRICKWORKS CIRCLE NE 06/01/16 56237 RES $ 229,475 $ 73,960 32.23 DAY AUSTIN B 14 001900080812~UNIT 6202 0.02 306 IMP 09692 KEITH III HERBERT BRADFORD 200 SPRING LAKE DR DR~94~7TH 04/21/16 56090 RES $ 104,277 $ 37,800 36.25 DAY DEBORAH/DAY DAVID 07 360400940394~210 X 210 1.00 180 IMP 14269 JOINER JULIE 215 TRUEHEDGE TRC 05/16/16 56205 RES $ 214,864 $ 70,200 32.67 DAYMAN MARK A/DAYMAN RUTH L 12 254406300358 0.23 448 IMP 15903 AROWOLO ODUNOLA 3445 STRATFORD RD~45~17TH 06/13/16 56278 RES $ 330,040 $ 106,960 32.41 DE GUZMAN BENEDICT 17 004500011693~UNIT 1704 0.03 109 IMP 04047 BECK BRIAN T 9240 MACKINAC DR DR~873~1 03/03/16 55918 RES $ 343,863 $ 126,440 36.77 DE OLANO MIRIAM LAURA/NICOLAS REID 12 306608730145~L 14 0.28 227 IMP 09664 BRUMFIELD TRACY J 10325 TWINGATE DR DR~220~1ST 04/15/16 56090 RES $ 502,661 $ 208,520 41.48 DEAHL ERIC THOMAS/DEAHL SCARLET 11 060102200871~L 1238 0.46 160 IMP 17320 MARINHO FERNANDO 5325 DERBY CHASE CT 06/23/16 56323 RES $ 309,896 $ 116,560 37.61 DEBORAH MOBLEY A/K/A DEBORAH ANN 21 573111900124 0.21 77 IMP 14910 MCPARKS ENTERPRISES LLC 28313 PLANTATION DR 05/23/16 56234 RES $ 232,613 $ 79,320 34.10 DECARLO MARY SUSAN 17 000700110970 0.04 201 IMP 13352 GILBERTOS PAUL P 3365 HABERSHAM RD 05/19/16 56196 RES $ 872,126 $ 343,240 39.36 DECKER MARGARET ADDICKS/DECKER JOHN 17 011400010113 0.71 656 IMP 04191 CONDON CURTIS L 3787 IVY LN 02/24/16 55898 RES $ 766,729 $ 213,640 27.86 DEERING THOMAS W/DEERING AMY L 17 004400020687~L9 0.55 479 IMP 13821 KEITH JENNIFER 5222 WELLSLEY BEND~231~1ST 05/26/16 56222 RES $ 220,992 $ 65,080 29.45 DEITER SAMUEL R 11 054002311565~LOT 46 0.05 663 IMP 17970 DUNCAN JR STEVEN WAYNE 950 ORMEWOOD AVE 06/24/16 56330 RES $ 384,869 $ 91,400 23.75 DELELLIS JORDAN/DELELLIS JR THOMAS M 14 001100050268 0.25 103 IMP 09270 SHEPHERD SHIRLEY 125 WOODMERE SQ NW SQ 04/18/16 56068 RES $ 141,190 $ 46,640 33.03 DELEO JESSICA 17 018500051251~UN 125 0.03 697 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 18 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 11543 PLUMMER TIJUANAAKA T OLIVER AKA T SMITH 2595 BONNYBROOK DRIVE SW~219~14 05/04/16 56146 RES $ 43,162 $ 15,720 36.42 DELILLE MYRLANDE/LEEFOON TRISTAN 14 021900031300~L 2319 BK 23 0.31 249 IMP 09031 DENNIS M DONOVAN NOT INDIVIDUALLY BUT 5096 LONG ISLAND DR~120~17, 2 04/15/16 56065 RES $ 2,415,567 $ 1,040,000 43.05 DELMER ROBIN E 17 0120 LL0653~LOT2, UNIT ONE, LONG 119 IMP 05310 CARON CARL P/CATHY S 14490 EIGHTEENTH FAIRWAY~685~2ND 03/07/16 55924 RES $ 626,532 $ 200,400 31.99 DELUCA LAURA C/DELUCA JARED JAMES 22 539106851141~LOT 51 0.42 453 IMP 14450 HOLLAND DARREN 1820 PEACHTREE RD 06/02/16 56249 RES $ 563,827 $ 213,000 37.78 DEMBY BETH L 17 011000021973 0.04 1 IMP 06788 BMI PROPERTIES LLP 3578 OLD MILTON PKY PKWY~2 AND 03/18/16 55978 COM $ 206,660 $ 86,240 41.73 DENG QI 11 001100020309~UN 390 0.05 457 IMP 11293 DUGAUD VINCENT 139 BEREAN AVE~20~14TH 05/02/16 56126 RES $ 206,923 $ 76,560 37.00 DENHAM REBECCA 14 002000041332~LOT 81 0.05 284 IMP 15549 SEAN N STEPHANSSON AND HELEN ANN 4405 PINEHOLLOW CT~133~1ST 06/07/16 56262 RES $ 292,080 $ 95,800 32.80 DENNIS STEPHEN 11 027201170842~35, BLK A 0.22 550 IMP 19246 DAWSON JR HAROLD A 1214 STATE ST 06/30/16 56379 RES $ 587,938 $ 152,920 26.01 DENT JARED ESCHOL/DENT ELIZABETH 17 014800050762 0.02 682 IMP 13555 HAMM LINDA M 1505 RIVER OAK DR 05/27/16 56223 RES $ 234,831 $ 88,520 37.70 DERAMUS SARAH 12 176203540599 0.50 662 IMP 06772 COLLINS II JOEL STEPHEN 285 CENTENNIAL OLYMPIC PARK DR 03/25/16 55989 RES $ 194,605 $ 73,280 37.66 DEROSA SAM/DEROSA NATALIE 14 007800031797~UN 1506 0.03 374 IMP 08782 HANIF NASSER F 9055 SANDORN DR DR 04/11/16 56049 RES $ 331,388 $ 120,280 36.30 DESAI KUNAL/DESAI MAITRI 12 161002691942~L 33 0.60 630 IMP 09793 RIVERA ANGEL 3655 VENETIAN PLACE SW~2~14TH 04/14/16 56077 RES $ 190,960 $ 71,120 37.24 DESAI ROSHNI/DESAI HARISH 14F0002 LL0459~L 25 POD K 0.18 505 IMP 16025 THE BRADFORD MANAGEMENT GROUP INC 2948 JONES ST 05/20/16 56287 RES $ 40,851 $ 15,980 39.12 DESANTOS JAVIER 14 016400080328 0.31 167 IMP 13522 CHILLAG AMY S 864 CHARLES ALLEN DR 05/13/16 56193 RES $ 162,410 $ 49,200 30.29 DEWIT ADAM 14 004800290119 0.02 259 IMP 20102 COE JEREMY S 7206 GOTLAND ST~57~9 06/29/16 56439 RES $ 58,177 $ 26,720 45.93 DIALLO IBRAHIMA 09F120000574153~32 0.02 398 IMP 00426 TAYLOR MORRISON OF GEORGIA LLC 1270 ROSWELL MANOR CIR CIR~611~1 01/04/16 55778 RES $ 447,425 $ 139,240 31.12 DIAZ FRANKIE/DIAZ SUSAN 12 240006110719~27 406 IMP 01782 NAJARIAN CAPITAL LLC 4075 BUTTERNUT PL PL~171~9F 01/29/16 55833 RES $ 191,306 $ 63,640 33.27 DICKSON III LLEWELLYN C 09F410001715412~24 0.19 209 IMP 18906 MARTE PETER H 1901 WALTHALL DR~146~17 06/28/16 56369 RES $ 970,335 $ 435,960 44.93 DIEHL DAVID S/WARSHAW JASON W 17 014600090927 1.23 139 IMP 10223 MCSWAIN MARK 1948 SANDRINGHAM DR 04/15/16 56090 RES $ 41,888 $ 17,480 41.73 DILL REAL ESTATE MANAGEMENT LLC 14 019900031114~PT L2,3 0.26 400 IMP 05712 MATHEWS STARLA 8 BRITTANY WY WAY 03/14/16 55952 RES $ 179,914 $ 67,000 37.24 DIMITROV DANIELA R/DIMITROV DIMITAR N 17 000700071339~UN 8 0.03 23 IMP 17638 ZHU JIE H 361 17TH ST 06/07/16 56302 RES $ 179,190 $ 68,120 38.02 DING BEIRU 17 010800014311 0.02 494 IMP 13031 PHAM ANTHONY D 10515 WORTHINGTON HILLS MNR~541~1 05/10/16 56179 RES $ 171,906 $ 71,560 41.63 DINH CHAU/LE VAN THI THU 12 228105411831~LIBERTY SQUARE LOT 0.18 176 IMP 14293 TERC NEIL 1619 JACKSON WAY~250 & 251~17TH 05/17/16 56211 RES $ 100,076 $ 27,800 27.78 DIONICIO ALISHA 17 0251 LL1207~85 0.04 666 IMP 15376 WALD ALEX S 805 PEACHTREE ST~49~14 06/06/16 56255 RES $ 234,912 $ 90,640 38.58 DISPENZA FRANCO 14 004900290571 0.02 371 IMP 15994 WILLIAMSON WILLIAM H 1067 ALTA AVE~14~14 06/10/16 56281 RES $ 140,801 $ 54,040 38.38 DOMENICO DESIRAE 14 001400081518 0.02 397 IMP 11861 CALHOUN JR SANFORD S 878 PEACHTREE ST 04/29/16 56138 RES $ 196,308 $ 61,560 31.36 DONALDSON SANDY 14 004900010706~UN 402 0.03 78 IMP 01931 DAVIDSON JR JAMES F 3636 HABERSHAM RD NW RD 01/29/16 55828 RES $ 235,575 $ 84,800 36.00 DOPSON STEPHANIE A 17 0097 LL1353~UN 2303 0.03 470 IMP 16577 DAVENPORT JANE R 1 MUSCOGEE WAY 06/21/16 56319 RES $ 545,341 $ 174,560 32.01 DORE GAIL/DORE JEFF 17 011200100023 0.05 439 IMP 09117 CAROLYN WAITS PEARCE A/K/A CAROLYN W 515 MOUNTAIN WY NE WAY 04/15/16 56064 RES $ 269,948 $ 81,240 30.09 DORMAN SCOTT 17 006400030442~M&B 0.50 15 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 19 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 17933 SULLIVAN KATHY L 3040 PEACHTREE ROAD NW UNIT 06/20/16 56311 RES $ 190,789 $ 91,400 47.91 DORSEY CHRISTOPHER S 17 0099 LL2029 0.03 107 IMP 17381 PROTUS RICHARD J 620 PEACHTREE ST~49~14 06/16/16 56301 RES $ 114,813 $ 31,480 27.42 DOWDY ERIK 14 004900081848 0.02 52 IMP 01804 ASHTON ATLANTA RESIDENTIAL LLC 12020 CAMERON DR DR 02/02/16 55833 RES $ 592,302 $ 272,040 45.93 DOWNES MICHAEL R 11 108003970207~L94 0.14 419 IMP 09281 GUELCHER GREGORY M 430 GRANT ST SE ST~44~14TH 04/12/16 56067 RES $ 352,610 $ 120,560 34.19 DRAKEFORD JASON 14 004400040583~M&B 0.18 481 IMP 07664 WEBER KATHY S 619 COLLIER ROAD NW 03/16/16 56022 RES $ 551,449 $ 169,400 30.72 DRIVER ANGELA M/DRIVER KEVIN A 17 015300050095~L3 0.59 152 IMP 14872 VASQUEZ CARMEN 3060 PHARR CT 05/31/16 56238 RES $ 108,067 $ 38,960 36.05 DUANE KELLY 17 009900160719~UN 504 0.02 281 IMP 19609 HOSKINS MICHAEL KEVIN 3071 LENOX RD~8~17 06/30/16 56375 RES $ 255,037 $ 80,800 31.68 DUBOIS MELISSA 17 000800150488 0.04 287 IMP 07709 ROSS BETH 704 WEDGEWOOD WAY 03/14/16 56027 RES $ 123,751 $ 39,480 31.90 DUCAN LISA S 06 036600030416~L70 BK A 0.03 411 IMP 08511 BRIAN STORY AND JOSEPH M MILLS 1142 GRACEWOOD AVE 04/08/16 56038 RES $ 291,912 $ 101,560 34.79 DUDLEY JENNIFER ANNE 14 001100070365~PT LTS 1,2 BK 0.17 525 IMP 00421 CLEVELAND KELLY A 1223 WHITSHIRE WAY 01/08/16 55774 RES $ 89,585 $ 30,240 33.76 DUFFIE ROBERT 22 543010432550~UN 1223 0.02 115 IMP 01468 JONES TIFFANY CHALEN 290 SHELLI LN~391~1ST 01/22/16 55797 RES $ 378,907 $ 143,840 37.96 DUGGAN ZOE MARIE/DUGGAN MICHAEL FEE 12 188403911009~LOT 92 0.15 522 IMP 00112 MYERS SUSAN C/CREASY RICHARD 5008 PARKSIDE DR DR 01/04/16 55746 RES $ 354,299 $ 115,520 32.61 DUKATZ-DEVITIS KAREN A 12 145001890993~L 5008 BLDG 5000 0.05 347 IMP 07247 HALL CLINTON JOEL 12634 ITASKA WALK WALK 03/28/16 55991 RES $ 443,073 $ 171,320 38.67 DULEY DAVID M/DULEY TAMMY 22 400011351463~L93 0.19 539 IMP 00784 OLIVERAS STEPHEN 2049 OLD GEORGIAN TERRACE NW 01/08/16 55774 RES $ 378,248 $ 119,760 31.66 DUMESNIL CHRISTOPHER M 17 0256 LL0931~L52 0.11 422 IMP 09132 ALVAREZ CYNTHIA KARINA 2851 LAUREL RIDGE CIR CIR~225~14 04/08/16 56061 RES $ 74,837 $ 33,680 45.00 DUNCAN STEVEN 14 0225 LL1744~LT 14 LAUREL RIDGE 0.03 652 IMP 03678 BOTTONE TRACY L 275 13TH ST NE ST~106~17 02/22/16 55884 RES $ 199,912 $ 67,800 33.91 DUNN CAITLIN 17 010600340304~UN 307 0.02 314 IMP 15166 CAROL CAMPBELL AND MICHAEL REZNIK 535 CANTON WALK~387~1ST 06/08/16 56261 RES $ 525,537 $ 142,760 27.16 DURA STRESS ACQUISITIONS LLC 12 190103870865~LOT 6C, UNIT 535 0.02 442 IMP 14451 NOVOTNY JON A 2009 MERCER AVENUE~162~14 05/31/16 56242 RES $ 221,538 $ 79,360 35.82 DURANTHON HARRIET J/DURANTHON JEAN- 14 016300070171 0.47 644 IMP 02282 CHARLES R REYNOLDS AND CAROLYN H 2460 CAMDEN GLEN CT CT 02/16/16 55865 RES $ 352,004 $ 107,800 30.62 DUSZYNSKI JON 12 275207600332~L4 BK A 0.14 232 IMP 05062 GALLIUM CAPITAL LLC 209 N MILL RD RD~126~17TH 02/23/16 55934 RES $ 603,090 $ 253,840 42.09 DUVALL JEREMY LYN/DUVALL JUDITH ANNE 17 0126 LL0582~M&B 0.98 368 IMP 05357 HONG DANIEL 9959 INNISFREE DR DR~923~1ST 03/16/16 55954 RES $ 370,738 $ 165,400 44.61 DWORETZ JEFFREY W 12 317009230866~L 23 0.18 633 IMP 17477 BARROWS RAYMOND D 5485 E IDLEWOOD LANE NW 04/08/16 56302 RES $ 648,277 $ 191,480 29.54 DWYER AMY ANNE/DWYER JAMES R 17 013400020233 0.77 623 IMP 18563 WIT MIRJAM JOHANNA 870 INMAN VILLAGE PARKWAY NE UNIT 06/29/16 56353 RES $ 215,959 $ 74,000 34.27 DYMECKI KIMBERLY ALICE 14 0019 LL2338 0.02 550 IMP 00440 SYKES GIOVANNI 425 SPRINGSIDE DR 01/14/16 55788 RES $ 4,957 $ 2,120 42.77 E1 ENTERPRISES LLC 14 003600010230~M&B 321 IMP 11245 MIMMS TERRI ANN 257 BURBANK DR NW DR~142~14TH 04/29/16 56117 RES $ 23,041 $ 6,240 27.08 E320 LLC 14 014200030288~L 7 BK 30 0.29 666 IMP 12517 ROBERT N STARGEL AND JOCELYN M 390 17TH ST~148~17TH 04/28/16 56173 RES $ 215,817 $ 72,640 33.66 EASLEY JEREMY/JONES BRITTNEE 17 0148 LL6039~UNIT 3042 0.03 664 IMP 05051 GRAEBNER II GARY ROBERT 280 WINDRIFT CT 03/07/16 55923 RES $ 425,659 $ 194,440 45.68 EASON JONATHAN D/KOTSOVOS RENEE L 12 289507910259~L15 BK DD 502 IMP 13959 PDOB LLC 1111 CAMBRIDGE SQUARE~600~1 05/20/16 56213 COM $ 241,663 $ 104,000 43.04 EAST GWINNETT PROPERTIES LLC 12 234206000598~UN A- E 0.14 103 IMP 02219 COLE MARY A 222 12TH ST NE ST 01/25/16 55830 RES $ 290,338 $ 129,600 44.64 EASTON DANIEL 17 010600350436~UN 1201 0.02 314 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 20 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 05451 OSURI MICHAEL/GRACE/MANOJ 970 SIDNEY MARCUS BOULEVARD NE 02/23/16 55946 RES $ 154,416 $ 52,400 33.93 EATON BREANNA/EATON THOMAS K 17 0006 LL2278~UN 1217 0.03 324 IMP 17272 BANTA ROBERT E 06/27/16 56332 RES $ 706,225 $ 261,720 37.06 EDGE PHILIP B/HEMPEL HOLLY 17 011000021148 0.24 528 IMP 00767 STALCUP WILLIAM THAD 1164 PINE GROVE DR 01/15/16 55775 RES $ 272,465 $ 81,880 30.05 EDWARDS COLIN 22 497311950663~L33 BK D 0.41 344 IMP 02414 BETTY JANE FOSTER DEADWYLER 630 W. POWDERHORN ROAD 02/12/16 55863 RES $ 422,969 $ 130,880 30.94 EDWARDS COLIN/EDWARDS ANNE-ROSS 17 004100030044~L4 BK A 0.43 214 IMP 07782 CAUSEY JEFFREY D 1403 LANIER PL PL 04/01/16 56016 RES $ 647,711 $ 225,240 34.77 EDWARDS JOSEPH K 17 000200030835~L19 0.23 103 IMP 17151 LEIGH ROTHMAN TRUSTEE OF SWANSTON 9077 SELBORNE LN LN 06/28/16 56337 COM $ 477,659 $ 150,440 31.50 EDWARDS JR GREY HOLT 08 140000450624 0.02 317 IMP 01598 MCCAY JIMMY F 4192 POST OAK GROVE GRV 01/20/16 55798 RES $ 157,998 $ 43,200 27.34 EDWARDS TYNIKA L 09F410001643465~L338 0.25 80 IMP 14022 JOHN TURRENTINE AND MICHELLE 945 AZALEA DR~333 & 341~1 05/27/16 56223 RES $ 472,823 $ 189,280 40.03 EGEA EDUARDO/GUIHUR SILVANA 12 172102970029~LOT 1 BLOCK D 0.55 185 IMP 17144 LGI HOMES-GEORGIA LLC 6514 ST. MARK WAY 06/24/16 56330 RES $ 157,398 $ 69,880 44.40 EGERTON JASMINE NICOLE 07 150101390738 0.15 140 IMP 15165 BENTKJAER MICHAEL U 6060 FOXBERRY LN 06/10/16 56270 RES $ 262,829 $ 110,040 41.87 EHLIDIL SAYGIN 12 177003660926 0.30 493 IMP 17791 RAOOF LUCY RYANS 295 BOULDER DR~202~1 06/15/16 56337 RES $ 553,115 $ 185,600 33.56 EIPT LLC 12 152101690257~LOT 25 0.74 116 IMP 21434 ABDSHARAFAT MAHLEGA 3530 RIVER FERRY DR~21~1 06/27/16 56449 RES $ 295,732 $ 123,440 41.74 EISEMAN JEFFREY 11 011200210221 0.42 181 IMP 08662 LYCKE LAWRENCE/GRUNSCHLAG/DRAYER 71 CHESHIRE DR~822~1ST 04/01/16 56044 RES $ 196,005 $ 58,080 29.63 EISENBERG NANCY L 12 293008220424~UN 71, BLDG N 0.03 434 IMP 11347 BRINKER JAMES H 4225 FALLS RIDGE DRIVE 05/02/16 56122 RES $ 735,727 $ 304,440 41.38 EITLER V MICHAEL III/EITLER CANDICE 11 030001111115~L 217 UN 6 0.55 332 IMP 04933 HARRIS JERVON D 1771 DEFOOR AVE NW AVE~187~17 03/10/16 55939 RES $ 170,866 $ 51,960 30.41 EKEH OGECHUKWU 17 018700090091~UN E BLDG 1771 0.03 291 IMP 02793 COMBS H WAYNE 1323 BATTLEVIEW DRIVE 02/05/16 55842 RES $ 563,310 $ 133,400 23.68 ELEGANT HOMES LLC 17 019500040112~PT L5 0.49 698 IMP 18456 NICHOLS THOMAS E 3080 BELLINGRATH BLVD 06/30/16 56357 RES $ 598,948 $ 188,080 31.40 ELLIOTT JOEL A 12 197004310586 0.75 640 IMP 00972 SEAY LUTHER A 2402 DEERWOOD LANE SW~4~14TH FF 01/22/16 55797 RES $ 79,387 $ 26,680 33.61 ELLIS CHARLENE 14F0003 LL1902~LOT 74 0.02 143 IMP 14813 MCF SFR HOLDINGS 1 LLC 4413 ROCHE ST~112~9F 05/27/16 56242 RES $ 105,674 $ 30,960 29.30 ELLISON JR RICHARD A 09F280001122087~95 0.18 449 IMP 13428 NOLAN MARISSA LEANNE 970 SIDNEY MARCUS BLVD 05/17/16 56200 RES $ 166,399 $ 43,600 26.20 ELLISON-WHITE CHELONY A 17 0006 LL2740 0.03 603 IMP 12417 KIM STEVE 9051 WOODLAND TRL~1264~2ND 05/12/16 56171 RES $ 333,272 $ 132,920 39.88 ELNAAMANI MOHAMAD AK 22 530012642245 0.04 84 IMP 17705 ACS BURTON LLC 2880 DUKE OF GLOUCESTER~223~14TH 06/20/16 56315 RES $ 217,411 $ 72,480 33.34 EMBRY MICHAEL 14 022300040024~31 1.49 1 IMP 11336 WILLIE L PHILLIPS AND GABRIELLE MALLORY 2235 MAIN ST NW ST~253~17 04/29/16 56117 RES $ 306,904 $ 107,720 35.10 EMERSON ELIZABETH 17 025300020279~L 3 0.23 651 IMP 13460 WILLIAM H HOLCOMBE AND CRISTI C 5400 ROSWELL RD # H 7 05/19/16 56202 RES $ 102,656 $ 28,600 27.86 EMMETT JENNIFER P/HALLIDAY EVAN S 17 009200080591 0.02 159 IMP 16923 GADODIA GAURAV 1101 JUNIPER ST~106~17TH 06/21/16 56318 RES $ 255,822 $ 89,040 34.81 ENG RUTH/ENG PAUL 17 010600066958~UNIT 823 0.03 104 IMP 13907 GRANT JAMES 2353 OLD COLONY RD 05/27/16 56228 RES $ 41,547 $ 11,160 26.86 ENGLISH KEITH 14 018800040217 0.28 574 IMP 02805 ROOT DUSTIN 2180 DEFOORS FERRY RD NW 02/12/16 55857 RES $ 418,107 $ 108,520 25.96 ENGLISH MATTHEW T/ENGLISH SARAH T 17 019400060012~LOT 1 PH A 0.10 353 IMP 09879 DON L WAMSLEY JR A/K/A DON L WAMSLEY 245 TRUEHEDGE TRC TRCE 04/18/16 56073 RES $ 238,257 $ 79,720 33.46 EPSTEIN KIMBERLY A/EPSTEIN MARC E 12 254406300325~L32 BK A 0.28 313 IMP 09302 TRICIA D CRUPI TRUSTEE OF THE GWEN 2970 RIVERMEADE DR~232 & 242~17TH 04/15/16 56063 RES $ 977,397 $ 480,120 49.12 EPTING JR JAMES E 17 024100010150~LOT 23, BL. A 639 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 21 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 00775 LEFEBVRE KATHRYN 71 MADDOX DR NE~55~17 01/15/16 55775 RES $ 210,442 $ 53,160 25.26 ESKEW MARTHA IRIS/TISDALE JR CHARLES H 17 005500140085~UN 8 0.02 550 IMP 10513 MARTIN RYAN 330 E. WILLOW RUN 04/29/16 56120 RES $ 184,327 $ 60,320 32.72 ESLAMI AFSANEH/DINDA MAHMOUD/JELEZ 11 029100970918~L 7 BK E 0.23 118 IMP 15558 BENNETT ROGER P 5590 HLLBROOKE TRCE~269~1 06/10/16 56273 RES $ 317,362 $ 134,480 42.37 ESPAILLAT GISSELLE/ESPAILLAT FARAND 11 065202691697~169 A 0.24 526 IMP 11661 CAMELOT PAPER AND PLASTIC INC 10555 BRIDGEMOR DR DR 05/03/16 56142 RES $ 220,560 $ 92,080 41.75 ESPARRAGOZA JACQUELINE E 11 048301860975~L32 0.29 316 IMP 01715 YONGUE ROBERT E 01/29/16 55825 RES $ 148,707 $ 57,280 38.52 ESPOSITO WILLIAM D 14 004900342042~UN 8209 0.02 670 IMP 02247 CARDIN RICK HENRY 3755 JAILETTE RD 02/02/16 55842 RES $ 23,494 $ 8,840 37.63 ESTRADA GUSTAVO RAFAEL GARCIA 09F380401780094~315 X 280 1.90 679 IMP 02226 BOOTHE DALLAS 14775 BIRMINGHAM HWY~631~2ND 02/01/16 55827 RES $ 528,976 $ 123,720 23.39 ETB HOMES LLC A GEORGIA LIMITED 22 393006310232~TR 3 5.16 473 IMP 07786 RABY CLARK D 106 ARDMORE PL NW PL~109 04/06/16 56027 RES $ 123,234 $ 33,240 26.97 EUBANK JAMES 17 010900160519~UN 3 BLDG 106 0.02 321 IMP 17229 GARNER OFFUTT MIRIAM ELISE 790 LORIDANS DR~42~17 06/24/16 56334 RES $ 519,353 $ 240,000 46.21 EVANS CELENA L/EVANS CURTIS I 17 004200050132~LOT 1, BLOCK C 0.48 456 IMP 05020 CARACCILO JONATHAN 2004 COLLIER COMMONS WY NW 03/10/16 55938 RES $ 897,288 $ 366,280 40.82 EVERHART CARL E 17 015300120401~L 3 0.42 153 IMP 03182 BYUN JACK 3645 PEACHTREE RD 02/11/16 55870 RES $ 96,327 $ 32,360 33.59 EWONDERWORKS GROUP LLC 17 001000060485~UN 213 0.02 413 IMP 06464 SKIPPER GINNY S 2675 HOLCOMB SPRINGS DR DR 02/26/16 55965 RES $ 185,401 $ 59,800 32.25 FACCO ZALETE N 12 294407810070~L7 0.05 308 IMP 13964 PIPER JOHN 250 PINE BROOK WAY 05/23/16 56208 RES $ 294,395 $ 71,480 24.28 FAIL MICHAEL K/FAIL PAIGE E 12 195104350221 0.70 427 IMP 18174 SHAW GWENDOLYN 1019 MANIGAULT ST~13~14 06/28/16 56360 RES $ 308,832 $ 79,920 25.88 FAITELSON HYMIE LIONEL/FAITELSON 14 001300070488~LOT 67 0.11 561 IMP 05761 RICE JENNA Y 245 AMAL DR~72~14TH 03/15/16 55952 RES $ 61,832 $ 26,200 42.37 FAKUNLE OYEBODE 14 007200062426~UN 5010 0.03 647 IMP 02228 HOWARD JENNIE S 2685 ASHLEIGH LN LN 01/29/16 55828 RES $ 152,142 $ 55,000 36.15 FAN SHANNA C 22 512011211560~UN 121 BLDG 15-A 0.03 292 IMP 17608 KENT N BANKS AND DALE B BANKS 8015 RICO RD 06/17/16 56305 RES $ 320,172 $ 113,800 35.54 FANELLI BART FRANK/FANELLI ERICA KJAER 08 130000431203 13.10 565 IMP 16207 EDDIE L GRAY AND MICKIE K GRAY 4470 PARK BROOKE TRCE 06/06/16 56287 RES $ 515,551 $ 223,560 43.36 FANG YUAN AND RUI CUI AS JOINT TENANTS 11 015000821004 0.38 682 IMP 17088 D'ERICO ARMAND J 11231 CALYPSO DR~689~1ST 06/16/16 56305 RES $ 354,230 $ 130,040 36.71 FANNING MICHAEL S/FANNING CAROL A 12 260006893007 0.03 638 IMP 08904 GUNDAKER DAN 9195 CHAPELWOOD DR 04/07/16 56043 RES $ 365,088 $ 135,840 37.21 FANNON MALLORY B/FANNON KENNETH E 12 306708730078~L7 BK A 0.31 62 IMP 00507 SINGER FRANK F/SHELLEY/BIDARI RANDEE 906 BRANDWINE CIR 01/06/16 55755 RES $ 179,407 $ 60,800 33.89 FARBMAN TATIANA 06 036600010525~UN 906 0.05 409 IMP 17134 MORGAN JOHN RAYMOND 711 COSMOPOLITAN DR~48~17 06/22/16 56323 RES $ 188,734 $ 66,240 35.10 FARHADI JASON 17 004800031375 0.02 388 IMP 03074 BOWMAN TAMMY Y AKA TAMMY FREEMAN 3708 RAMSEY CIR CIR 01/29/16 55838 RES $ 230,667 $ 70,320 30.49 FARLEY TAURON/ETHERIDGE-FARLEY TASHA 14F0002 LL0707~L50 POD K 0.19 514 IMP 17060 O'DONNELL BRUCE 1075 WILDE RUN CT~1284~2ND/2ND 06/28/16 56332 RES $ 449,883 $ 166,000 36.90 FARRELL ROBERT RYAN/FARRELL NATALE 22 373012371329~319, PHASE V 0.22 50 IMP 15468 SELPH DOUGLAS D 2230 PEACHTREE RD~111~17 06/03/16 56268 RES $ 195,443 $ 82,380 42.15 FAULKNER DONNA B/FAULKNER GREGORY H 17 011100140467 0.04 159 IMP 13666 JAIME COLLAZO AND JENNIFER HOLIHAN NKA 9155 NESBIT FERRY ROAD, UNIT # 98 05/24/16 56215 RES $ 137,586 $ 49,680 36.11 FELDBEIN SVETLANA/FELDBAIN ALEXANDER 12 306408391015 0.02 412 IMP 01510 RIERSON CHANDLER STEVEN 3445 STRATFORD RD NE RD~45~17TH 01/22/16 55791 RES $ 213,013 $ 81,980 38.49 FELDMAN BARBARA/FELDMAN HOWARD 17 004500010455~UNIT 203 0.03 318 IMP 04791 GUEST ALBERT DWIGHT 165 BROADMEADOW CV CV 02/29/16 55914 RES $ 444,530 $ 122,480 27.55 FELKINS SIRLENE/FELKINS JAMES D 12 178203500201~L7 BK A 0.50 679 IMP 11505 BUTLER ROBERTA J 3406 VILLAGE LN 05/06/16 56150 RES $ 256,767 $ 95,000 37.00 FENETY JUDITH L/FENETY SHIRLEY 12 145001821436~UN 3406 0.04 465 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 22 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 09542 DIAMOND GARY J/GUSS NANCY 1121 SHELBY PLACE SE 04/26/16 56106 RES $ 161,632 $ 57,800 35.76 FERGUSON CHRISTOPHER 14 001000100668 0.16 338 IMP 16162 RAYNOR ERIN E 502 DEFOORS 06/14/16 56290 RES $ 188,519 $ 68,400 36.28 FERNANDES CAROLINA H 17 018700100098 0.03 181 IMP 07902 GALLAGHER JR DAVID PAUL 9835 SUMMER OAKS DR DR~788~1 03/30/16 56010 RES $ 313,483 $ 93,200 29.73 FERRARO SCOTT ALLEN 12 291107880635~L129 BK B 0.67 232 IMP 40543 5960 STATE BRIDGE RD COM $ 1,531,195 $ 642,920 41.99 FIDELITY BANK 11 095003310379 1.12 IMP 16823 THOMASON MICHAEL SCOTT 565 PEACHTREE ST 06/20/16 56314 RES $ 204,100 $ 74,840 36.67 FIEGLER ALBERT 14 005000011551 0.02 369 IMP 10583 PAULETTE BAKELY AKA PAULETTE BLAKELY 2330 HACKAMORE DR DR 04/29/16 56122 RES $ 82,947 $ 20,600 24.84 FIELDS II VINCENT A 13 0133 LL3297~L134 0.11 273 IMP 14710 WHITE O L JOE 974 DILL AVE~120~14TH 05/27/16 56245 RES $ 34,773 $ 11,640 33.47 FIELDS MURLINE 14 012000050134~L 28 0.23 695 IMP 17991 MCCAULEY IVAN D 1220 FRANCIS ST 06/28/16 56336 RES $ 246,994 $ 74,760 30.27 FINE ASSET INVESTMENTS 17 010800060900 0.17 347 IMP 02839 FREEMAN MATTHEW CHARLES 567 LINWOOD AVE AVE~15~14TH 02/08/16 55850 RES $ 536,237 $ 196,960 36.73 FINEGOLD GERALD M 14 001500010516~LOT 26 0.20 302 IMP 16325 ALEX K HIRSCHLER AKA ALEXANDER KLAUS 640 GREENVIEW TER~615~2 06/09/16 56293 RES $ 827,538 $ 308,800 37.32 FINGER JR JAMES E 22 521006151160~40 0.34 16 IMP 02541 KURELIC JR JOSEPH P 5535 CHEMIN DE VIE~93~17TH 02/15/16 55857 RES $ 183,399 $ 58,640 31.97 FINKEL PATRICIA/FINKEL STEPHEN 17 009300090748~UN 5535 0.04 512 IMP 17960 PHAM MY PHUONG THI 3060 PHARR COURT NORTH~99 06/24/16 56323 RES $ 121,212 $ 34,600 28.55 FINNIS MICHAEL 17 009900161634 0.02 512 IMP 10118 COFFMAN JUSTIN 7105 THREADSTONE OVERLOOK 04/13/16 56085 RES $ 349,471 $ 135,160 38.68 FINNO PATRICK/FINNO APRIL 11 117104290928~L57 0.38 99 IMP 01045 ADMIRALTY PROPERTIES LLC 6894 SMOKE RIDGE DR DR 01/15/16 55789 RES $ 91,152 $ 29,520 32.39 FIREBIRD SFE I LLC 13 0162 LL1246~L22 0.04 72 IMP 03075 MOORE CASSANDRA 7215 BUCK CREEK DR DR 02/08/16 55853 RES $ 73,123 $ 17,440 23.85 FIREBIRD SFE I LLC 13 016200030434~43D 0.31 164 IMP 09070 KAPLAN THEODORE G 7095 TRADEWATER PKY 04/21/16 56069 IND $ 2,478,217 $ 862,000 34.78 FIRSTCHOICE PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT LLC 14F0136 LL0193 5.77 20 IMP 12882 MEYER TED M 5625 HILLBROOKE TRACE 05/16/16 56186 RES $ 327,758 $ 131,080 39.99 FISH BERNADETTE K/FISH BRIAN T 11 077102690026~120 0.33 596 IMP 08497 SAMBOR CHRISTIN M 1 PLANTATION DR NE DR 04/08/16 56042 RES $ 229,189 $ 77,920 34.00 FISLER JENNIFER 17 000800100699~UN 1B 0.04 429 IMP 15876 MICHAEL K MILLER AND JENNIFER N MILLER 06/10/16 56281 RES $ 326,301 $ 104,800 32.12 FISSHA MERON 17 008600020272 0.46 514 IMP 16932 MAU NANCY L 664 BOULEVARD~22~14 06/20/16 56312 RES $ 386,015 $ 101,600 26.32 FLAIM GRAYSON/FLAIM KATIE 14 002200010467 0.20 97 IMP 13552 BELTRAN CAROLINA 870 INMAN VILLAGE PKWY~19~14TH 05/27/16 56221 RES $ 221,283 $ 91,040 41.14 FLEISCHER LEE/FLEISCHER MARLA 14 0019 LL1678~UNIT 215 0.02 242 IMP 17898 JUNE F RAYMOND TRUSTEE OF THE JUNE F 400 MILLBANK PL~867~1ST 06/01/16 56327 RES $ 359,871 $ 128,920 35.82 FLEMING CHRISTINA/FLEMING WALTER 12 303208670177~LOT 22, BLOCK 1, 0.63 593 IMP 14028 FEIKEN DANIEL R 419 SINCLAIR AVE~15~14 05/27/16 56227 RES $ 532,886 $ 205,680 38.60 FLETCHER BRIAN 14 001500100572 0.18 649 IMP 15522 WILSON LENNIE 6310 HICKORY LANE CIR~41 & 58~9F 05/23/16 56260 RES $ 54,350 $ 15,200 27.97 FLOWERS PATRICIA Y/FLOWERS WALTER C 09F130000415232~G5 0.08 3 IMP 16587 ABA ENTERPRISES INC 185 LAWTON ST 06/17/16 56304 RES $ 51,139 $ 11,720 22.92 FLOWMAX HOLDINGS LLC 14 011600060642 0.19 417 IMP 09920 SEGLER-CRADDOCK ASSOCIATES LLC 2650 HOLCOMB BRIDGE RD RD~783~1 04/25/16 56093 COM $ 263,779 $ 129,800 49.21 FLYNN RIVER PROPERTIES LLC 12 293007832203~UN 510 344 IMP 11019 DANNY F RYAN AND AMY M RYAN 345 SCARBOROUGH WY WAY~15 04/29/16 56113 RES $ 361,281 $ 103,840 28.74 FLYNN STEVEN JAMES/FLYNN KATHERINE 11 008000151118~L 35 0.25 112 IMP 09129 PECK ROBERT R 1101 JUNIPER ST ST 04/20/16 56067 RES $ 167,889 $ 65,000 38.72 FOBARE AMANDA G 17 010600066305~UN 622 0.02 441 IMP 01817 KIM MIHYUN 401 BLACK DIAMOND COURT 01/28/16 55824 RES $ 908,553 $ 365,990 40.28 FOLEY SEAN 11 102103630258~L B528 0.37 29 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 23 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 11550 BYRNE STEPHEN J 297 FOREST VALLEY CT CT 05/04/16 56138 RES $ 762,224 $ 281,640 36.95 FOLLOWILL EMILY J/FOLLOWILL THOMAS C 17 006700010821~L2 0.70 531 IMP 08809 HALE KELLY 3635 E PACES CIR NE CIR~9~17 04/11/16 56051 RES $ 222,637 $ 81,080 36.42 FONG CINDY 17 000900031661~UN 1412 BLDG B 0.02 5 IMP 06940 L DOUGLAS HIGGINS A/K/A LLOYD 14435 MORNING MOUNTAIN WAY 03/24/16 55984 RES $ 619,577 $ 227,360 36.70 FORD BRIAN NELSON/FORD MEKETTE MARIE 22 522006871591~L6 POD A-2 0.47 335 IMP 18331 DYER PATRICK A 250 PHARR RD 06/21/16 56361 RES $ 191,534 $ 74,000 38.64 FORERO ANA M 17 009900072559 0.02 204 IMP 19599 STOELZEL WILLIAM 390 17TH ST~148~17TH 06/30/16 56389 RES $ 145,333 $ 53,360 36.72 FORERO PAUL F 17 0148 LL4703 532 IMP 06688 QUARLES STEPHEN P 03/24/16 55980 RES $ 205,612 $ 79,640 38.73 FORREST PARK PRESERVE HOLDINGS LLC 17 001600010237~#38 0.05 284 IMP 18867 GIP HOLDINGS LLC 840 PINEHURST TER~139~14 06/27/16 56353 RES $ 52,967 $ 13,800 26.05 FORSTATER MAX 14 013900060553~18 0.17 6 IMP 06028 FERREIRA CAROLINE M 5269 GLENRIDGE DR DR 03/22/16 55975 RES $ 269,798 $ 96,320 35.70 FORTE ALEX 17 006800050362~UN 5269 0.06 430 IMP 01181 KEKVIN MARTINEAU AKA JOHN KEVIN 878 PEACHTREE ST NE ST~49~14 01/29/16 55816 RES $ 196,214 $ 65,200 33.23 FORTNER JESSE T 14 004900010458~UN 312 0.02 114 IMP 15164 LEE CHANG HO 10740 ELLICOTT WAY 05/13/16 56252 RES $ 230,841 $ 82,970 35.94 FOWLER JIE GAO 11 048001680608 0.04 171 IMP 06685 ELIZABETH L GRAY AKA ELIZABETH D GRAY 230 THE SOUTH CHACE~36~17TH 03/24/16 55979 RES $ 392,317 $ 89,240 22.75 FOX ANDREA N 17 003600070195~UN 230 0.04 124 IMP 17707 JANS LAWRENCE D 655 HERON RUN CT 06/17/16 56306 RES $ 489,152 $ 215,680 44.09 FOX CHRISTOPHER J/FOX TAMMY J 22 537006140631 0.33 135 IMP 04464 ERIC C LOHR AND CHENYUE MAO 985 RICELAND CT CT~241~1ST 02/24/16 55901 RES $ 463,895 $ 143,200 30.87 FOX DAVID/PEUGH SUSAN M 12 158002410364~L 7 1.26 294 IMP 02347 MOORE MARII J 3334 PEACHTREE RD NE RD 01/22/16 55850 RES $ 187,372 $ 73,240 39.09 FOX GARRETT ARTHUR 17 006200020452~UN 113 0.02 346 IMP 14237 TUOMY BLAKE A 4600 JETTRIDGE DR~137~17TH 05/23/16 56211 RES $ 824,305 $ 215,960 26.20 FOX II ROBERT J/FOX LAURA B 17 013700040469~LOT 25 BK B, UNIT 4 0.42 353 IMP 19171 DALE LAUREN A 06/29/16 56378 RES $ 147,645 $ 47,840 32.40 FOY JOSHUA H 17 011100140178 0.02 80 IMP 08329 POOLE JOSHUA A 90 FAIRLIE ST NE 04/13/16 56057 RES $ 163,130 $ 61,680 37.81 FOY LILLIAN 14 007800160125~UN 503 0.02 42 IMP 04906 PULTE HOME CORPORATION 1020 APPLEGATE DR DR~1281~2ND 03/08/16 55937 RES $ 402,439 $ 155,920 38.74 FRADEJAS LANI LORMA/IVAN NOLI 22 387012812397~L 8 0.22 227 IMP 03922 LYNCH MICHELLE FKA MICHELLE GRANT 120 BISCAYNE DR UN C-8 DR~111~17 02/25/16 55894 RES $ 121,436 $ 36,880 30.37 FRANCESCHI BRITTANY N/FRANCESCHI 17 011100161141~UN 8 BLDG 120-C 0.02 31 IMP 02123 LOCKETT VERONDA L 2265 KILMINGTON SQ SQ~693~1 02/01/16 55822 RES $ 144,979 $ 47,760 32.94 FRANCO CHRISTIAN/FRANCO NORMA 12 258106931982~UN 139 BLDG 21 0.03 246 IMP 14085 HINDERSINN KENNETH R 795 HAMMOND LAKES BLVD 05/23/16 56211 RES $ 140,404 $ 45,320 32.28 FRANKLIN TYRA L 17 0037 LL2735 0.02 263 IMP 05750 PEREZ JUSTIN 250 PHARR RD NE RD~99~17 03/15/16 55953 RES $ 210,706 $ 75,040 35.61 FRANZ MICHAEL 17 009900071726~UN 1012 0.02 560 IMP 10862 VALDEZ VICTOR RENTERIA/PARADA-ORREGO 7620 STONERIDGE DR DR 04/28/16 56112 RES $ 290,522 $ 107,680 37.06 FRASCH DAVID 17 0032 LL5763~L53 0.02 697 IMP 10235 DANZ ERIC E 3045 GREENS CREEK LN. 04/22/16 56091 RES $ 495,541 $ 194,600 39.27 FREDRICK MEGAN ELIZABETH/FREDRICK 22 432011011441~L36 0.34 60 IMP 14035 ZIMMERMAN DARYL J 821 RALPH MCGILL BOULEVARD NE 05/23/16 56212 RES $ 153,855 $ 50,800 33.02 FREELAND SEAN 14 001800102161 0.02 424 IMP 07280 ERIC CARL SEYLER AND TIFFANY H SEYLER 180 ARROWOOD LN LN~599 03/30/16 56003 RES $ 291,831 $ 77,360 26.51 FREEMAN APRIL 12 234105990659~L11, PT L12 BK A 0.51 651 IMP 07693 HENDERSON JAMES 5293 CATTAIL LN LN 03/29/16 56025 RES $ 96,560 $ 23,160 23.99 FREEMAN ERWIN 13 0067 LL1630~L15 0.20 540 IMP 11296 KWON ROSEMARY 3338 PEACHTREE RD NE RD~62~17TH 05/03/16 56133 RES $ 420,902 $ 165,560 39.33 FREEMAN HARVEY J 17 0062 LL3210~UN 3403 0.04 533 IMP 02046 STUMP WILMA DAUGHERTY 640 LAKEMONT CT 01/29/16 55823 RES $ 279,745 $ 82,760 29.58 FREEMAN LAURA M/FREEMAN JAMES A 12 149301970091~L40 BK B 0.90 304 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 24 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 11809 LUTSEY MATTHEW T 395 CENTRAL PARK PL 05/06/16 56141 RES $ 183,405 $ 56,440 30.77 FRENCH JOHN 14 004700112173~UN 640 0.04 89 IMP 06352 NIBBS ROBERT L III/FANEISHA JACKSON 715 NEEL REID DR DR 03/21/16 55966 RES $ 288,932 $ 106,720 36.94 FREUDENBERG STEPHEN TRIEST/NIKA 12 192103830873~L2 0.02 277 IMP 02303 AYCOCK LAND LLC 1843 ROCK SPRINGS LANE NE 02/03/16 55839 RES $ 1,129,900 $ 370,440 32.79 FRIDMAN EMILY B/FRIDMAN PETER D 17 005600031382~L6 0.21 203 IMP 02419 KASTENS WILLIAM H 5410 HAMPSTEAD WY WAY~264~1 02/17/16 55865 RES $ 444,794 $ 140,240 31.53 FRIEDRICHS ROBERT J/WATERMEIER ALLISON 11 067302640236~26/E 0.43 156 IMP 11778 BADRI RAJESH 799 HAMMOND DR DR~37~17 05/05/16 56145 RES $ 211,067 $ 65,880 31.21 FRIERSON JERMAINE 17 0037 LL4210~UNIT 429 0.03 392 IMP 18437 FAZYLOV LEONID 195 14TH ST~106~17TH 06/30/16 56350 RES $ 165,592 $ 62,120 37.51 FROESE BRIAN 17 010600331097~1201 628 IMP 06733 STOUT REBECCA YALE 605 PELHAM DR RD~56~17 03/23/16 55984 RES $ 487,190 $ 138,440 28.42 FRUTH NICOLE 17 005600070208~L 6 0.21 22 IMP 18558 SIMMONS ROBERT L 1037 RALPH D. ABERNATHY BLVD BLVD 06/30/16 56365 COM $ 171,767 $ 72,000 41.92 FTA INTERNATIONAL LLC 14 011700070566 0.24 495 IMP 10401 DASILVA TERRI 825 HIGHLAND LN NE LN 04/20/16 56091 RES $ 255,079 $ 91,160 35.74 FU YUE 14 001700091373~UN 1111 0.02 353 IMP 00669 JEGA INVESTMENTS LLC 887 W MARIETTA ST 01/12/16 55767 COM $ 273,476 $ 97,600 35.69 FUGO STUDIOS LLC 17 0150 LL1050~UN 887-S-108 0.03 293 IMP 08045 HARRISON DENNIS M 3324 PEACHTREE RD NE RD 03/31/16 56017 RES $ 376,199 $ 132,120 35.12 FULLER SUZANNE 17 0062 LL4804~UN 1601 0.03 285 IMP 18446 POTTLE WILLIAM L 612 PACES FERRY RD~46~17TH 06/30/16 56358 RES $ 484,443 $ 161,000 33.23 FULTON FAY A 17 004600040113~LOT 5 0.24 124 IMP 09455 CUPPIA ROBERT J 975 KILMINGTON CT CT~693~1 04/11/16 56074 RES $ 145,157 $ 47,760 32.90 FULTON LISA EILEEN 12 258106933525~UN 97 BLDG 13 0.03 390 IMP 00420 SEGARS LINDA BYARS 6851 ROSWELL RD NE RD~73~17TH 01/07/16 55764 RES $ 92,633 $ 32,200 34.76 FUNG PEGGY PIK-KEI 17 007300050084~UN A BLDG 8 0.03 395 IMP 11381 PHELAN JOSEPH 1120 HUNTCLIFF 04/28/16 56108 RES $ 479,593 $ 140,720 29.34 FURBISH SANDRA D 06 036800040132~L 1 BK A 1.19 555 IMP 12936 DAVIS PARKS C 687 CHEROKEE AVE 05/17/16 56179 RES $ 465,808 $ 115,800 24.86 FURTSCH TRENT/FURTSCH EMILY 14 004300020990 0.09 657 IMP 06052 GOLD PARTNERS LLC 1875 OLD ALABAMA RD RD~660 01/01/16 55958 COM $ 185,000 $ 52,320 28.28 G2W LLC 12 252006601043~UN 1030 546 IMP 15161 LAMBIN CINTHIA M 2700 PINE TREE ROAD 05/20/16 56252 RES $ 112,568 $ 41,720 37.06 GABELMAN JONATHAN 17 004700140847 0.02 128 IMP 15316 CLINTON LINDA 6004 BROOKHAVEN CIR 06/08/16 56262 RES $ 373,337 $ 139,120 37.26 GABRIEL PATRICIA 11 113004073225 0.06 412 IMP 10115 MEREDITH ELIZABETH T 2355 DELLWOOD DR NW DR 04/11/16 56106 RES $ 894,282 $ 348,800 39.00 GAFFNEY ANDREW/GAFFNEY TRISHA 17 014500010249~L13 BK 12 0.28 23 IMP 01399 PENTECOUTEAU JEAN PAUL C 28411 PLANTATION DR~7 & 8~17TH 01/20/16 55792 RES $ 187,524 $ 64,360 34.32 GAIR CELINE PAYNE 17 000700111002~UN 411 BLDG 28 0.03 319 IMP 16483 THOMAS CHARLENE A 12390 PEYTON FARM WAY 06/17/16 56306 RES $ 489,152 $ 138,120 28.24 GALASSO JAMES/GALASSO TUONG VAN 22 449012011360 0.48 243 IMP 15814 KING KENNETH D 5545 SURREY CT 06/06/16 56276 RES $ 309,331 $ 128,880 41.66 GALLAGHER JENNIFER F/GALLAGHER JAMES 22 480311250300 0.46 90 IMP 09833 PAUL KLEINSCHNITZ AND CALLIE A 487 BRYN MAWR LN NW LN 04/25/16 56089 RES $ 762,522 $ 216,840 28.44 GALLAGHER KATHRYN GREER/GALLAGHER 17 013700020073~L5 BK B 0.93 532 IMP 01279 THOMAS R EVANS AND GAIL H EVANS 169 BIRCH RILL DR DR 01/20/16 55789 RES $ 153,061 $ 56,080 36.64 GANGUMALLA HAREESH REDDY 12 302408650047~L314 BLK B 0.21 597 IMP 03631 FLHH ATLANTA LLC 1150 COLLIER ROAD NW UNIT 02/22/16 55881 RES $ 77,188 $ 21,040 27.26 GANTI VIVEK 17 018600013417~UN G-1 0.01 103 IMP 03082 REINGOLD RICHARD 71 LAKELAND DR NW DR~98~17TH 02/05/16 55846 RES $ 669,212 $ 164,920 24.64 GANZ JASON 17 009800030939~27 B 0.22 422 IMP 19380 FRASER LUKE S 821 RALPH MCGILL BLVD~15 & 18~14TH 06/21/16 56379 RES $ 155,178 $ 49,480 31.89 GARCIA FABRIZIO 14 001800101023~UNIT 3249 0.02 3 IMP 40562 3141 AERO CT IND $ 1,084,145 $ 332,160 30.64 GARDEN ESSENTIAL INC 14 015800130139 2.40 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 25 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 04382 RAVINDRA ANNIGERI AND SHUBHA RAO 100 SKYLAND DR DR~342~1ST 02/29/16 55899 RES $ 365,236 $ 121,280 33.21 GARDINER ANAIS/GARDINER ASHLEY 12 182403420475~L 77 0.58 195 IMP 15973 CHRISTOPHER PATRICK MCKEON JR AND 1943 MAIN ST 06/14/16 56283 RES $ 181,032 $ 54,760 30.25 GARDNER ELDON JAMES 17 025200110204 0.23 107 IMP 18240 HARDY GREGORY K 3980 FALLS RIDGE DR 05/31/16 56346 RES $ 624,270 $ 220,600 35.34 GARDY REBECCA/POINDEXTER SCOTT 11 019100730271~L169 0.36 474 IMP 05529 ATWOOD INVESTMENT SERVICES LLC 199 14TH ST NE ST~106~17 03/11/16 55944 RES $ 204,135 $ 70,920 34.74 GARG AMAN 17 010600062122~UN 707 0.02 237 IMP 07491 STAINES MICHAEL 2110 WOODLAND LN LN 04/04/16 56022 RES $ 160,415 $ 57,720 35.98 GARNER JON/SEIBEL EMILY 22 530012641288~UN 2110 0.03 114 IMP 14697 SOUTHERN HERITAGE HOME BUILDERS LLC 16615 FREEMANVILLE RD 05/31/16 56236 RES $ 540,337 $ 213,120 39.44 GARRETT JAMES 22 467001900351 1.43 678 IMP 17765 DAVID M WILCOX AND IN SUK WILCOX 06/27/16 56332 RES $ 463,460 $ 165,640 35.74 GARRETT SENECA MARIE 12 308008780787 0.04 314 IMP 40555 3515 ZIP INDUSTRIAL SE BLVD IND $ 877,747 $ 350,400 39.92 GARVA INVESTMENTS INC 14 0063 LL0956 2.14 IMP 14231 SCHNUGG STEPHEN J 397 CARRIAGE DR~71~17 03/29/16 56208 RES $ 800,742 $ 225,440 28.15 GARZON NATALIA/DOBRZYNSKI RAFAEL 17 007100040269~LOT 13 BLK B 0.56 541 IMP 16188 OVATION 1005 LLC 3040 PEACHTREE RD~99~17 05/26/16 56284 RES $ 149,136 $ 54,760 36.72 GASS TRACY E 17 0099 LL1856 0.01 2 IMP 05192 HOPKINS JACK 1030 S BETHANY CREEK DR 02/26/16 55933 RES $ 313,015 $ 107,400 34.31 GAUL CANDICE F/PENABAD BRIAN 22 541008991884~L 45 BK B 0.26 642 IMP 17391 SULLIVAN CHRISTOPHER 10520 SUMMER CREEK DR 06/17/16 56308 RES $ 242,797 $ 116,600 48.02 GAUT MARY 12 315309190186 0.83 430 IMP 03564 READ PATRICIA G 1010 VILLAGE GREEN CIRCLE~248~1ST 02/25/16 55887 RES $ 397,078 $ 137,560 34.64 GAVIN MARGARET 12 154002483584~L1010 BLDG. 6200 0.04 73 IMP 12953 ATLANTA PROPERTIES GROUP LLC 1304 WINGATE WAY~23~17 05/13/16 56175 RES $ 107,665 $ 23,920 22.22 GEER MARGARET 17 002300030525 0.03 700 IMP 19448 SCHROETER ELISE 125 BAYVALE CT~33~17TH 06/30/16 56381 RES $ 537,292 $ 160,440 29.86 GEETHAKUMAR SARATH 17 003300040498~LOT 1 0.43 234 IMP 05368 PUTNAL ROBERT 1265 OLD WOODBINE RD NE RD~13 AND 03/10/16 55940 RES $ 563,191 $ 179,360 31.85 GELBARD RONDI 17 001400030179~L29 BK C 0.43 412 IMP 02062 FRAYER EVAN 921 BERNE STREET SE 01/29/16 55819 RES $ 149,197 $ 78,400 52.55 GELHAUSEN RICHARD A 14 001100010437~L52 0.18 346 IMP 15454 MICHAEL D SCHWARTZ AND CATHERINE D 275 LACKLAND CT 06/03/16 56255 RES $ 422,336 $ 156,960 37.16 GENNA PETER JAMES/GENNA ISABEL FLORES 06 031100060443 0.50 109 IMP 11196 ATL RESIDENTIAL HOLDINGS LLC 404 BASS ST SW 04/28/16 56137 RES $ 73,322 $ 19,200 26.19 GEORGES MUTEBA LLC 14 008600050037~37 X 78.5 0.07 159 IMP 09936 LYNCO LLC 1255 WESTMONT RD SW RD 04/26/16 56097 RES $ 20,042 $ 5,970 29.79 GEORGIA RENTAL PROPERTIES IX LLC 14 015200040383~L3 BK B 0.17 550 IMP 14601 STIEBEL DAVID J 1005 YORK CV~614 & 683~2 06/01/16 56251 RES $ 418,455 $ 163,280 39.02 GHANNAM LEE 22 522006141235~11 0.25 232 IMP 11577 GRIFFIN WAKITHA 821 RALPH MCGILL BLVD NE 05/09/16 56152 RES $ 215,037 $ 63,760 29.65 GIBBS JEREMY 14 001800102500~UN 2412 0.02 194 IMP 12587 PLANTE RONALD C 196 PEACHTREE WAY NE~101~17 05/16/16 56185 RES $ 741,098 $ 197,960 26.71 GIBBS WALTER BRAD/GIBBS AMY 17 010100020158 0.30 26 IMP 00071 WATSON CHARLES L 3873 ROSWELL RD RD~17 01/06/16 55746 RES $ 388,716 $ 109,960 28.29 GIGANTE PILAR 17 009700100097~L8 0.05 75 IMP 04550 ROSE CHARLES 1004 LOOKOUT AVE AVE 02/18/16 55893 RES $ 6,779 $ 2,970 43.81 GIL PABLO 17 024800060141 0.60 183 IMP 06544 VILLEGAS CHARERA B 1302 SPENCER AVE~133~14 03/07/16 55980 RES $ 174,090 $ 52,320 30.05 GILBERT LAWRENCE 14 013300090036~M&B 0.33 412 IMP 10829 LACKEY SHARON 19 SCOTLAND PL NW 05/02/16 56127 RES $ 183,012 $ 56,920 31.10 GILBERT MADELINE 17 022000081214~UN 145 0.03 227 IMP 18265 SIMMONS CRYSTAL 6950 MISTTOP LOOP~140~9F 06/28/16 56345 RES $ 144,668 $ 46,200 31.94 GILL AUDREY 09F310001405461~LOT 42, JONES 0.29 583 IMP 04977 ANTHONAY A FALOR AS TRUSTEE OF THE 2876 OVERLOOK WAY 03/02/16 55935 RES $ 409,847 $ 155,360 37.91 GILLANI SAIRA S 17 000700012754~L7 371 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 26 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 18674 RONALD LLOYD AND KELLY LLOYD 06/30/16 56356 RES $ 268,646 $ 112,400 41.84 GILLEN RYAN 17 010600051075 324 IMP 17926 CARTWRIGHT THOMAS BENJAMIN 1101 JUNIPER ST~106~17TH 06/20/16 56314 RES $ 162,836 $ 65,480 40.21 GILLIHAN DAVID ASHLEY/GILLIHAN DONNA 17 010600067246~920 0.02 696 IMP 16074 DAVID KATHRYN E 841 FREDERICA ST~16~14 06/14/16 56289 RES $ 127,462 $ 41,170 32.30 GILLMAN DARREN L 14 001600270226 0.01 254 IMP 02656 SHROPSHIRE SEVIS LYNN 616 MEMORIAL DR SE DR~20~14TH 01/20/16 55862 COM $ 183,229 $ 69,280 37.81 GITS GERMAINE 14 002000100385~L 136 295 IMP 09517 SANCHEZ NORMA A/QUIAHUA MARCOS 40 LETHEA ST 04/19/16 56104 RES $ 11,139 $ 6,780 60.87 GKC HOMES GA LLC 14 004000010291~L2 0.23 41 IMP 16144 GEORGE S WHITTLE AND EMILY M WHITTLE 1615 SETTINDOWN DR 06/10/16 56282 RES $ 469,338 $ 153,560 32.72 GLASPEY TARA L/GLASPEY MARK A 22 326110080408 0.67 577 IMP 10233 DAREN MOORE AND DENISE MOORE AS 100 LANSBURGH TURN 04/22/16 56101 RES $ 532,591 $ 153,400 28.80 GLENN RYAN/GLENN KATHARINE BRYAN 11 005400090011~L1 0.37 177 IMP 06962 ROCA MIGUEL 551 BOULEVARD AVE 03/31/16 56005 RES $ 348,071 $ 124,800 35.85 GLOVER II HAROLD KEVIN/JACKSON 14 004400080670~UN D 0.02 486 IMP 01029 THUMANN ALBERT 222 12TH ST 01/22/16 55799 RES $ 302,754 $ 163,640 54.05 GOEBEL JR WILLIAM A 17 010600350311~UN 1005 0.03 247 IMP 08692 GNEPPER AND ANDREA L GNEPPER HEATH J 13245 WARRENSVILLE COVE 04/08/16 56041 RES $ 247,898 $ 71,840 28.98 GOFF MARY CATHERINE T 21 552009751252~UN 33 0.03 315 IMP 16492 RAISSIAN BRANDON HOSAIN 3324 PEACHTREE RD~62~17TH 06/20/16 56343 RES $ 217,855 $ 82,080 37.68 GOH WOO C 17 0062 LL4143~1207 0.02 389 IMP 08788 MARTIN W SMITH AND LYNN C SMITH 580 GLYNN MEADOW LN LN 04/11/16 56054 RES $ 490,175 $ 199,200 40.64 GOLDEN WHITNEY W 22 372012120496~L130 PH 2-A 0.56 392 IMP 12473 WEISER MICHAEL A 6105 BLUE STONE RD~89~17TH 04/28/16 56166 RES $ 368,917 $ 118,520 32.13 GOLDSTEIN CAROLINE BETH 17 008900081594 0.04 678 IMP 12134 O'DELL RICHARD D 1080 PEACHTREE ST NE ST~106~17TH 05/04/16 56149 RES $ 605,922 $ 184,960 30.53 GOLDSTEIN PHILLIP/GOLDSTEIN NANCY 17 010600051505~UN 1303 0.03 32 IMP 12165 PAMELA S MASTERS NKA PAMELA MANCOSKY 115 BISCAYNE DR 05/11/16 56162 RES $ 136,969 $ 41,440 30.26 GOMES KEVIN N 17 011100160812 0.03 219 IMP 09913 WATSON DWIGHT CADELL HARCOURT 65 SLOAN STREET UNIT 3 04/22/16 56091 RES $ 602,059 $ 166,000 27.57 GOMEZ JORGE 12 191404151500~UN 3 0.02 23 IMP 02619 MORRIS ARIEL I 2700 PINE TREE RD NE RD~47~17 02/08/16 55858 RES $ 110,904 $ 38,840 35.02 GONZALEZ JR ARTURO 17 004700141357~UN 4005 0.02 691 IMP 18095 RUBENSTEIN JOEL 505 WILLISTON WAY~314~1ST 06/30/16 56354 RES $ 383,151 $ 170,440 44.48 GONZALEZ MIGUEL/ROMERO-MATEUS MARIA 11 087403140985~LOT 69, BLOCK F 0.29 456 IMP 01808 KHOSRAVI BIJAN 01/29/16 55819 RES $ 1,545,959 $ 583,080 37.72 GONZENBACH ROBERT A 11 021200700378~LL2 POD Y 0.67 482 IMP 12025 OWENS JESSE G 71 CHICAMAUGA AVE 05/03/16 56157 RES $ 38,598 $ 20,280 52.54 GORDON DAMIEN 14 014100060070 0.19 340 IMP 12490 BHC 1891 WINDEMERE LLC 1891 WINDEMERE DRIVE, NE 05/13/16 56169 RES $ 866,795 $ 295,680 34.11 GORDON STEPHANIE N/GORDON THOMAS A 17 005000100027 0.28 49 IMP 17796 ROBINSON PELHAM H 907 GETTYSBURG PL 05/27/16 56296 RES $ 87,610 $ 32,920 37.58 GOSHAY PAMELA M 06 036400030558 0.03 604 IMP 14768 WHITLOW DANA P 7415 MID BROADWELL TRC 05/31/16 56240 RES $ 417,320 $ 154,320 36.98 GOSS JOHN R/LAPPE JILL S 22 417211720040 0.46 236 IMP 09008 OWINGS DOOZ L 10615 COLONY GLEN DR DR 03/30/16 56062 RES $ 164,743 $ 48,680 29.55 GOSWAMI CHINMAY 11 017100770693~L84 BK D 0.07 462 IMP 13704 KOEPSELL STEVEN G 804 ABINGDON WAY 05/20/16 56212 RES $ 130,724 $ 48,080 36.78 GOVINDARAJ SANTOSH 17 002000040501 0.03 26 IMP 12890 FURTSCH TRENT 484 GLEN IRIS DR 05/17/16 56180 RES $ 477,635 $ 111,120 23.26 GRABER LUKAS 14 004700060232 0.13 48 IMP 16558 GODWIN CYNTHIA 208 RIVER MILL CIR 06/15/16 56305 RES $ 89,959 $ 25,440 28.28 GRABOWSKI BARBARA 12 202504210185 0.03 345 IMP 02179 LEDFORD S TRENT 1061 WALKER AVE SE AVE 01/25/16 55819 RES $ 246,049 $ 65,400 26.58 GRACZ HENRY C 14 002300070387~L8 0.16 124 IMP 14078 GRIFFIN PATRICIA D 6520 ROSWELL RD~88~17 05/26/16 56220 RES $ 96,261 $ 37,440 38.89 GRAHAM VERNON WILLIAM 17 008800060839 0.03 306 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 27 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 10832 JEAN HENRY SCHOLTEN AND JENNIFER 145 LAUREL BRANCH CT CT 05/02/16 56137 RES $ 390,855 $ 153,840 39.36 GRAHL STEPHANIE MILLS/GRAHL DIRK 12 136300370217~L21 1.12 272 IMP 12784 THOMAS III JAMES J 1822 NORTH ROCK SPRINGS ROAD NE 05/13/16 56177 RES $ 113,596 $ 31,960 28.13 GRANACHER JULIA E 17 005100090169 0.02 594 IMP 04331 FRENN SUSAN/CREECH JANNE 8825 TATUM RD RD 02/26/16 55901 RES $ 120,390 $ 28,640 23.79 GRANBERRY GREGORY T 07 370001260357~M&B 1.12 578 IMP 00078 RUCKER REGINA 270 17TH ST NE~108,148~17 01/05/16 55744 RES $ 296,018 $ 111,200 37.57 GRAY BETH ANN/GRAY DANIEL ROSS 17 010800018031~UN 1408 0.03 362 IMP 03687 CHIEFTAN ATLANTA LLC 230 AMAL DR SW DR 02/02/16 55890 RES $ 73,420 $ 19,560 26.64 GRAY CHELSEA 14 007200061261~L5 0.07 119 IMP 03467 MAYVILLE D P 650 MONTAUK WY WAY 02/25/16 55889 RES $ 491,528 $ 204,360 41.58 GRAY IV LOUIS PATRICK/GRAY KELLY F 11 017200780196~L619 0.64 506 IMP 13159 MEYER BRUCE M 3588 KINGSBORO RD~9~17TH 05/20/16 56204 RES $ 566,289 $ 185,800 32.81 GRAYSON DAVID J/GRAYSON BARBRA WISE 17 000900020078~11/2 0.80 639 IMP 03459 THOMAS ANNELLE HALL 120 ALDEN AVE AVE~147 & 109~17 02/19/16 55872 RES $ 55,161 $ 31,760 57.58 GRAZIANI JUAN 17 010900150023~UN H-1 0.02 346 IMP 16048 CRESSWELL TRAVIS 3185 WOOD VALLEY RD~157 & 182~17 06/14/16 56286 RES $ 766,555 $ 260,800 34.02 GREEN LEAH/GREEN ANDREW 17 015700060041~7 BLOCK C 0.65 370 IMP 14732 MCKEE CHERRYL A 4790 WEATHERVANE DR 05/31/16 56238 RES $ 243,152 $ 75,840 31.19 GREENE BRADLEY 11 045501920120 0.16 207 IMP 05092 MARTINEZ KEITH LLOYD 700 ARGONNE AVE NE AVE 03/04/16 55934 RES $ 110,229 $ 32,680 29.65 GREENE ERIN 14 004800051453~UN 700-4 0.02 60 IMP 10510 WINE LARRY C 603 GLENOVER DRIVE 04/20/16 56120 RES $ 815,327 $ 403,080 49.44 GREENE RUSSELL W 22 392005590091~L644 UN 6-D 1.15 185 IMP 11161 COLEMAN GINA 285 CENTENNIAL OLYMPIC PARK DR 04/28/16 56133 RES $ 461,147 $ 131,400 28.49 GREENFIELD DEIRDRE A/GREENFIELD 14 007800032555~UN PH2-3 0.04 142 IMP 12043 CAITLIN REESE AKA CAITLIN BETH REESE 380 GRANT CIR~42~14TH 05/05/16 56159 RES $ 224,833 $ 62,920 27.99 GREENLEE JONATHAN/GREENLEE LYDIA 14 0042 LL0523 0.03 604 IMP 01222 BUSCH JOEL 102 BEECH ST 01/19/16 55799 RES $ 242,096 $ 59,360 24.52 GREINER TRACY 22 328212241615~LTS 16,17 BK 5 0.34 377 IMP 15338 CARTER WALTER N 3078 HAYNES TRL~866~1ST 06/03/16 56258 RES $ 767,842 $ 334,160 43.52 GRIFFIN JOSEPH/GRIFFIN MARTHA M 12 302008660925~4 0.18 488 IMP 16655 KIRKMAN NATHAN L 830 DEKALB AVE~19 AND 20~14TH 06/03/16 56295 RES $ 298,331 $ 80,960 27.14 GRIFFITH DONALD 14 001900130617 0.03 473 IMP 15772 MALOY STACEY R 6125 GWENDOLINE DRIVE~64~13TH 06/10/16 56289 RES $ 38,441 $ 19,960 51.92 GRISSOM BENNIE JOE/GRISSOM MARQUIS 13 006400030045~3 & B 0.52 625 IMP 04859 SULLIVAN STEVE 4254 RIVERGREEN DRIVE NW 03/10/16 55932 RES $ 171,821 $ 38,160 22.21 GROSCH ELIZABETH 17 0236 LL1181~UN 605 0.02 380 IMP 08504 UHLIS ELISA 2770 GLENLOCKE WY NW WAY 04/05/16 56038 RES $ 218,423 $ 85,560 39.17 GRUBBS NATALIE/GRUBBS TROY 17 0257 LL0419~L20 0.24 130 IMP 40569 1610 SOUTHLAND NW CIR IND $ 1,011,288 $ 391,880 38.75 GTG PROPERTIES LLC 17 0192 LL0516 1.41 IMP 09463 BELL JAMES G 315 PINE ISLE CT CT~117~1 04/18/16 56093 RES $ 326,036 $ 98,520 30.22 GU ZHIPIN 11 027201170305~L34 BK G 0.52 323 IMP 11050 PILLA LEONARD D 445 THE NORTH CHASE 04/29/16 56117 RES $ 285,707 $ 91,800 32.13 GUDURU SURYA PRAKASH/NAG SHALINI 17 003600060303~# 5 BLDG P 0.05 427 IMP 04225 GORDON GARMAN 3905 PEACHTREE DUNWOODY RD 02/29/16 55905 RES $ 716,054 $ 300,960 42.03 GUILD III GEORGE N/GUILD NORA J 17 001000010316~L22, PT LTS 19,23 0.81 95 IMP 15860 WAKEFIELD MICHAEL 1812 COLLAND DR 06/10/16 56276 RES $ 606,116 $ 221,840 36.60 GUINEE MEGHAN 17 014600070499 0.29 137 IMP 09428 MADEA ALICE NOELLE NKA SALEVSKI ALICE 13153 FASHERSTONE DR DR~1043~2ND 04/15/16 56183 RES $ 167,461 $ 61,200 36.55 GUMBS WILLIAMS WLICKFFER J 22 543010444407~L164 BLDG 25 0.04 615 IMP 10996 PREISSIG JR RANDALL STEPHEN 2875 MARGARET MITCHELL DR NW 04/27/16 56115 RES $ 618,378 $ 174,960 28.29 GUMP LOUIS K/GUMP MARY E 17 0196 LL1445~L 4 0.70 493 IMP 05054 DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPANY 710 GRANBURY WY WAY~282~1ST 02/24/16 55923 RES $ 372,153 $ 166,560 44.76 GUO AOYUE 11 081002820741~L22, UN 8, PHASE 2 0.55 498 IMP 12031 CANECCHIO III ROBERT J 3335 SONATA LN RD~972~2ND 05/05/16 56144 RES $ 234,009 $ 77,560 33.14 GUTTA RAVINDRANATH/VEERAMACHANENI 22 542009720355~L 333 0.30 546 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 28 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 06071 REHAL RASHPAL S 570 GALE CT CT~972~2ND 03/22/16 55969 RES $ 165,665 $ 54,160 32.69 GUZMAN ALVARO ALVAREZ 21 547109720397~L39 BK A WINDCREST 0.03 404 IMP 08407 JAMES ANTHONY HOLDINGS LLC 3445 STRATFORD RD NE RD 04/08/16 56046 RES $ 346,122 $ 106,960 30.90 GUZMAN JOSE C 17 004500012972~UN 3204 0.03 138 IMP 11710 YU YEON SOOK 425 FOX CHASE CIR CIR 04/29/16 56142 RES $ 396,303 $ 138,920 35.05 GUZMAN MAURICIO 11 044001950778~L 48 0.35 277 IMP 17471 CAGLE JARED 1765 PEACHTREE ST 06/17/16 56305 RES $ 151,192 $ 38,000 25.13 H ARMS II LLC 17 010900120133~UN 2C 0.02 289 IMP 00601 WU GRACE 1115 UNIVERSITY DR DR 01/11/16 55762 RES $ 546,378 $ 235,800 43.16 HADDOW STUART 17 000200090037~LTS 3C,3D BK E 0.11 521 IMP 11599 TONGE DEBRA ANN 7430 HALFPENNY PL~22~17 04/15/16 56154 RES $ 316,490 $ 151,400 47.84 HADID JAMAL C 17 002200010353~2 0.41 121 IMP 07316 JORDAN STEVEN A 480 CARRIAGE CT 03/28/16 55997 RES $ 193,255 $ 74,680 38.64 HAFETH MAJDI 11 058302040279~L27 BK C 0.25 11 IMP 12672 MOELLER TRICIA A 630 JARDIN CT~704~1ST 05/12/16 56175 RES $ 281,227 $ 104,480 37.15 HAGLER WILLIAM 12 262007040901~LOT 45-C 0.07 205 IMP 06406 DENNINGTON ROBERT TRAVIS 466 HAMILTON ST~12~14 03/22/16 55975 RES $ 620,062 $ 152,560 24.60 HAID REBECCA DUGGAN 14 001200060456~LT E9 0.08 244 IMP 01284 TIMOTHY S REICHERT AND TARA R BERRY 644 IRWIN PL 01/21/16 55797 RES $ 404,600 $ 93,200 23.04 HAILE LAUREN 14 001900071175~UN 1 0.02 617 IMP 04836 ASHTON ATLANTA RESIDENTIAL LLC 11805 STRATHAM DR DR 02/25/16 55902 RES $ 612,001 $ 230,360 37.64 HAIM KENNETH I 12 284208010533~L2 0.13 500 IMP 05071 GUYER TIMOTHY S 860 PEACHTREE ST NE ST~49~14TH 03/04/16 55932 RES $ 279,406 $ 90,520 32.40 HAIRSTON STEVEN C III 14 004900016257~UN 2804 0.02 490 IMP 08515 ROBERT C THOMAS AND TRINA ANN THOMAS 14260 MORNING MOUNTAIN WY 03/25/16 56047 RES $ 487,929 $ 169,280 34.69 HAIT ALEXANDER GRAY 22 539107540743~L 71 POD A 0.43 84 IMP 07237 GRAUCH EDWARD ROWLAND 825 KINGS CT NE CT~52~17TH 03/25/16 55988 RES $ 604,503 $ 269,160 44.53 HAJDU GABOR 17 005200080474 0.16 625 IMP 18391 NANCY A MUCHA AND LAWRENCE J 1858 ADAGIO DR~689 & 690~1ST 06/30/16 56355 RES $ 325,898 $ 100,880 30.95 HAKIM GINA HIPPS 12 260006893288~49 0.03 244 IMP 20716 SLOCUMB LEON 2485 CAPELLA CIR~54~9-C 06/13/16 56423 RES $ 120,420 $ 54,160 44.98 HALIBURTON ALYSE 09C150000590464 0.10 54 IMP 11282 KNATT JOHNNY J 2010 WESTCROFT LN 04/29/16 56115 RES $ 622,104 $ 265,400 42.66 HALL FRANK JR/HALL AMBER N 12 172003311323~L11 0.77 563 IMP 11375 LOESER MICHAEL 1007 COLONNADE WAY~487~2 04/28/16 56108 RES $ 484,204 $ 179,800 37.13 HALLBERG FRANK R/HALLBERG DANA E 22 407004870870~L 2 1.12 552 IMP 15383 JONATHAN TASSIE AND KEISHA 14003 PORTSIDE BND 06/06/16 56254 RES $ 224,960 $ 69,400 30.85 HAM FREDRIC M 22 540008282195 0.02 664 IMP 10497 MERRELL GAYLE R 10820 WILLOW MEADOW CIR 04/28/16 56108 RES $ 206,824 $ 58,640 28.35 HAMEISTER RICHARD A/HAMEISTER MEGAN R 11 028100960143~L14 BK G 0.21 683 IMP 17029 HAMMOND GWIN F 703 MASONS CRK CIR 06/24/16 56330 RES $ 168,015 $ 62,120 36.97 HAMILTON MATTHEW/GRASSO THERESA 06 0364 LL0784 0.04 296 IMP 11075 JACQUES JAMES 7750 GEORGETOWN CHASE 05/02/16 56122 RES $ 427,182 $ 138,400 32.40 HAMLING JEFF C/HAMLING LAURA E 12 190303861250~L 50 BLDG 5 0.06 669 IMP 11826 TAYLOR ALLEN A 2942 RHODENHAVEN DR~156~17 05/05/16 56158 RES $ 633,202 $ 192,040 30.33 HAMMERTON VALERIE L/JEREMY J 17 015600040317~L 16 BL E 0.65 527 IMP 00104 DEBORAH AZIANE N/K/A DEBORAH A SNYDER 10900 WITTENRIDGE DR DR~915~1ST 01/04/16 55744 RES $ 150,702 $ 48,440 32.14 HANEFIOUI SAID 12 313009152556~UN 6 BK K 0.03 326 IMP 16086 WHITE JONATHAN 2965 PHARR COURT SOUTH 06/09/16 56279 RES $ 96,173 $ 32,840 34.15 HANRY BENJAMIN SCOTT 17 010000121007~UN 610 0.02 422 IMP 08492 MICHAUD CLARE 655 MEAD STREET SE~23~14 04/07/16 56042 RES $ 213,670 $ 63,480 29.71 HANSON BRADLEY 14 002300020721~UN 9 0.03 91 IMP 02692 ZISMAN DAVID A 3463 LATITUDE COVE CV~828~2 02/11/16 55852 RES $ 206,081 $ 80,680 39.15 HANSON CATHERINE MARY 22 540008281866~UN 2704 0.02 5 IMP 18186 GILLESPIE DANIEL L 11325 QUAILBROOK CHASE~441~1 06/28/16 56345 RES $ 310,507 $ 127,040 40.91 HANSON MICHAEL/ANNE MARIE A 11 117104410294~147 0.28 245 IMP 10644 NELSON KATHRYN I 3174 PARC CT SW CT 05/02/16 56117 RES $ 73,573 $ 22,200 30.17 HARDY ROBERT DEVAUGHAN 14 0231 LL3395~L B81 0.02 214 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 29 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 07753 ATCHISON DAVE 1150 COLLIER ROAD NW~186~17 03/31/16 56033 RES $ 70,461 $ 20,440 29.01 HARMON KELLY A 17 018600014217~UN L-9 0.02 294 IMP 14501 HERSAM ROBERT 136 PEACHTREE MEMORIAL DR 06/03/16 56250 RES $ 187,805 $ 47,370 25.22 HARMS MARY LIZ/BARRON 17 011100110601~UN 1 BLDG 10 0.03 587 IMP 10802 WILENSKY MICHAEL S 7970 MAGNOLIA SQUARE 04/29/16 56111 RES $ 467,269 $ 228,720 48.95 HARNEY DIANE N/HARNEY CHRISTOPHER P 17 0024 LL1393~L24 0.04 333 IMP 10567 TURNER DREW 1602 LIBERTY LN~426, 427, 451~1 04/29/16 56120 RES $ 158,521 $ 57,960 36.56 HARNOIS JEREMY 12 200404260599~UN 121 BK C 0.02 161 IMP 03692 HARDY DEMETRIUS 3535 PARC CIR SW CIR~250~14TH 02/16/16 55878 RES $ 72,728 $ 19,680 27.06 HARPER-TAYLOR JENIFFER 14 0231 LL2652~A28 0.02 300 IMP 07686 ISKANDER ROYKE/ROTINSULU MEIDY A 5060 AMBER LEAF DR DR 04/01/16 56015 RES $ 279,202 $ 87,440 31.32 HARRIGAN PATRICK/HARRIGAN JESSICA 12 184504000198~L78 0.21 206 IMP 13625 WILLIAMS JR NEAL L 180 DEVEREUX CT 05/24/16 56220 RES $ 1,284,439 $ 359,560 27.99 HARRIS DEXTER A/HOLLY S 17 017400070098 0.34 332 IMP 13735 MCGOWAN DENNIS J 215 SEMEL DR~147~17 05/27/16 56227 RES $ 239,347 $ 84,520 35.31 HARRIS LATREACE 17 0147 LL3391~UN 449 0.01 568 IMP 17123 MARSHALL BRET A 13614 WEYCROFT CIR 06/10/16 56341 RES $ 200,877 $ 90,680 45.14 HARRIS WENNY L/JOHN F 22 525009020900 0.16 113 IMP 00148 FLOYD II FRANCIS XAVIER 350 PETERS ST ST 01/15/16 55772 RES $ 142,970 $ 40,200 28.12 HARRISON ELIZABETH 14 008500150218~UN 21 0.03 700 IMP 04545 CORCORAN FKA KELLY J HICKEY AND 1025 CALADIUM LN LN~364~1ST 02/26/16 55912 RES $ 890,888 $ 258,880 29.06 HARRISON LAURA CAMERON/HARRISON 12 176003642694~LOT 21 0.74 530 IMP 11667 LOVELL TRACIE L 11840 DANCLIFF TRC TRCE~1266 AND 05/06/16 56144 RES $ 382,858 $ 129,000 33.69 HARRISON SCOTT W/HARRISON SARA J 22 514212661460~LT 11840 0.04 634 IMP 02537 BERMAN SONIA G 730 WOODSCAPE TRL TRL~101~1ST 02/12/16 55853 RES $ 632,022 $ 234,000 37.02 HARSHAW COLLEEN/HARSHAW KEVIN T 11 031001011743~404 0.44 640 IMP 07534 KWASNY KURTIS 174 CHESTER AVE SE AVE~13~14TH 03/31/16 56014 RES $ 178,739 $ 53,640 30.01 HART LAUREN M 14 001300051454~UN 124 0.02 228 IMP 01860 GORE SMITH JASMINE 110 TOWERGATE PL PL 01/29/16 55823 RES $ 177,663 $ 54,840 30.87 HARTMAN CHELSEY/HARTMAN ZACHARY 06 036300050185~L2 0.07 118 IMP 07216 ARTEAGA ARTURO 1710 KILMINGTON CT CT 03/30/16 56004 RES $ 152,505 $ 51,280 33.63 HARTMAN LENA 12 258106931891~UN 22 0.03 328 IMP 10577 ENRIQUEZ MANNY 14155 YACHT TERRACE 04/28/16 56124 RES $ 156,698 $ 58,200 37.14 HARTZELL DEBORAH 22 539007570998~TWNHM 304 0.01 461 IMP 14895 ROSE RICHARD 2277 PAUL AVE 05/24/16 56247 RES $ 294,181 $ 107,280 36.47 HASBARGEN JEREMY/KRISTYN 17 025300011518 0.10 56 IMP 12300 VANG T HUYNH NKAKELLEY 1845 LIBERTY PARKWAY~221~17TH 05/17/16 56185 RES $ 181,956 $ 60,040 33.00 HATCHER PATRICK RYAN 17 0221 LL4133~LOT 3002 0.02 540 IMP 17624 ALDERMAN LAVERNE A 2792 MARGARET MITCHELL DR~219~17 06/24/16 56334 RES $ 774,163 $ 282,280 36.46 HATFIELD BROOKS A 17 021900020017~LOT 2, BLOCK E 0.67 480 IMP 12257 MEEKER ELIZABETH F 57 FORSYTH STREET NW UNIT #3- 05/05/16 56149 RES $ 125,034 $ 30,760 24.60 HAWKENSON DAVID W/JOHNSON 14 007800121085~UN 3-D 0.02 62 IMP 19801 CARROLL GLENN 11180 STATE BRIDGE RD RD 02/24/16 56411 COM $ 142,028 $ 58,400 41.12 HAYES DAVID/HAYES ERIN 11 036001300756~UN 207 BLDG 200 0.03 542 IMP 12048 WALLSOM DOROTHEA VENABLE 1024 SASHA LN 05/06/16 56162 RES $ 170,567 $ 51,920 30.44 HEALY MARY 12 189704100268 0.03 578 IMP 19600 JOHNSON TROY D 8930 TERRACE CLUB DR 06/30/16 56382 RES $ 259,838 $ 95,160 36.62 HEATHER MASHON DUNN AND ERIN ROSE 12 256106670337 0.20 636 IMP 11641 ACUNA JOSE A 943 PEACHTREE ST~106~17 05/11/16 56157 RES $ 342,650 $ 115,440 33.69 HEATHERLY SR JAMES H/HARRIS MARK A 17 010600082534~UN 1708 0.02 142 IMP 12841 STOVIN MARK B 4526 CLUB VALLEY DR 05/16/16 56185 RES $ 564,473 $ 226,040 40.04 HEBEBRAND ANDREW P 17 001300010297 0.73 235 IMP 10251 GAVIN BROCK W 2516 ACORN AVENUE NE 04/28/16 56106 RES $ 581,045 $ 180,240 31.02 HEDGES NATHAN J 17 010100120222~L8 BK 7 0.17 258 IMP 06563 HILL RAYMOND D 400 KING RD NW RD~139 & 140~17TH 03/22/16 55979 RES $ 1,718,186 $ 447,040 26.02 HEISER CRAIG/KOELLA VIRGINIA 17 0140 LL1079~L 11 BK F 2.00 252 IMP 07540 KENNEDY WILLIAM J L 2010 LANCASTER SQ 04/01/16 56017 RES $ 1,250,298 $ 405,800 32.46 HELLER KRISTA/HELLER GREGORY J 12 196004330560~L12 BK A 0.73 672 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 30 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 17480 GREEN ANDREW V 2547 RIDGEWOOD TER 06/17/16 56310 RES $ 395,768 $ 158,680 40.09 HELLER MICHAEL A 17 023100010079 0.36 671 IMP 01772 TANN II WILLIAM DAVID 8165 INNSBRUCK DR DR~356~6TH 01/29/16 55826 RES $ 593,844 $ 165,960 27.95 HELLSTROM MICHAEL 06 035600020146~LT14 BK B 1.01 659 IMP 06884 JESSA FARUK 03/28/16 55994 RES $ 215,880 $ 88,360 40.93 HENDERSON CHARLOTTE KIM 14 004900022081~UN 1104 0.02 233 IMP 11214 RUSSELL STEPHEN P/GIVEN LESLIE 11860 WEXFORD CLUB 04/28/16 56114 RES $ 367,331 $ 123,720 33.68 HENDERSON LYNNE W 12 174303590291~LT 2, BLK A 0.41 158 IMP 06447 ROGER A FISHER AND BETH S FISHER 1727 HAWTHORNE AVE 03/16/16 55961 RES $ 228,146 $ 83,480 36.59 HENDERSON SANKARA A 14 015900130344~70 X 190 0.31 418 IMP 02574 CAMPBELL RICARDO 530 GRACELYN CT SW CT~950 AND 02/03/16 55840 RES $ 303,263 $ 76,240 25.14 HENDRICKS GEORGE 14F0104 LL1959~L 223 0.30 24 IMP 00088 PEACH WALTER 806 VEDADO WY WAY 01/04/16 55742 RES $ 504,002 $ 169,320 33.60 HENRICKSEN DAN/RHINE RICHARD 14 004800070164~PT L11 BK B 0.08 647 IMP 17859 HACKNEY ERIN 5376 BOREAL WAY~95~14F 06/27/16 56329 RES $ 260,421 $ 78,800 30.26 HENRY ALEXI LARKINS 14F0104 LL0696~10 0.35 502 IMP 14952 LEAPHART WILLIAM R 570 ABBEYWOOD DR~238~1 05/26/16 56235 RES $ 442,889 $ 171,760 38.78 HENRY CURLEY/ELLEN 12 150202381222~63 0.76 601 IMP 02195 D R HORTON-CROWN LLC 434 MOSSYCUP DR DR 01/29/16 55834 RES $ 229,046 $ 58,520 25.55 HENRY TAMMI M/HENRY JUAN E 09F310001436631~LT 85 SIERRA 0.28 140 IMP 12967 CHRISTMAN NEIL 5995 WEST ANDECHS SUMMIT 05/16/16 56175 RES $ 547,534 $ 227,960 41.63 HENSON BEVERLY 11 095100340402 0.62 125 IMP 09735 RABIDEAUX SEAN 4253 RICKENBACKER WY NE 04/20/16 56079 RES $ 477,694 $ 152,440 31.91 HENSON CHARLIE C/HENSON ERIN C 17 006500040234~L6 BK C 0.36 304 IMP 18338 YELLOW LOFT LLC 400 VILLAGE PKWY 06/30/16 56350 RES $ 351,442 $ 99,760 28.39 HERB JENNA K 14 001800100454 0.03 286 IMP 08099 U S BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 1727 BARNESDALE WAY NE 03/31/16 56014 RES $ 642,050 $ 167,360 26.07 HERITAGE SELECT HOMES LLC 17 010400030030~L10 BK E 0.61 1 IMP 12320 RIEPE AMANDA M 8750 WILLOWBRAE LANE 05/12/16 56169 RES $ 438,276 $ 130,160 29.70 HERMAN ROBERT I 12 280507700204 0.38 105 IMP 14273 ALDO JR PETER F 246 BUCKLAND DR~822 AND 823~1 05/17/16 56222 RES $ 128,279 $ 50,920 39.69 HERNANDEZ AVILA DANIEL 12 293008222115~UN 246 BLDG F 0.03 160 IMP 07805 HARDIN MARY A 130 26TH ST 03/31/16 56017 RES $ 87,018 $ 38,040 43.72 HERSAM ROBERT 17 014700060937~UN 704 0.02 213 IMP 13754 MAUPIN JOHN E 750 PARK AVE~44~17TH 05/24/16 56226 RES $ 687,025 $ 205,680 29.94 HERSH THEODORE/REBECCA 17 004400040891~UNIT 16S 0.05 138 IMP 14871 LEVEL ONE PROPERTIES LLC 120 RALPH MCGILL BLVD~50~14TH 05/26/16 56231 RES $ 131,059 $ 35,880 27.38 HERSI MOHAMED 14 005000150169~UN 206RENAISSANCE 0.02 552 IMP 08943 1754 MT PARAN ROAD LLC 1754 MOUNT PARAN RD NW 03/29/16 56063 RES $ 3,179,417 $ 819,400 25.77 HEYWARD JASON A/ JR EUGENE/LAURA 17 0200 LL1373~M&B 1.49 303 IMP 09290 AMY L MCNEIL AMY L COOK FKA 997 LONGLEY AVE AVE~189~17 04/15/16 56070 RES $ 331,384 $ 102,280 30.86 HICKMAN ANDREW E 17 018900040862~M&B 0.16 106 IMP 20618 DAVIDSON DARREN T 1965 NOCTURNE DR~690, 651 & 06/24/16 56422 RES $ 150,409 $ 59,120 39.31 HILL NICHOLE MARIE 12 260006891100~UNIT 1102 0.03 2 IMP 06639 MACKEY DAN M 301 TOWNSEND PL NW PL~236~17TH 03/23/16 55981 RES $ 581,790 $ 163,440 28.09 HILL RAYMOND DUNLAP/HILL KATHERINE 17 023600010264~UN 301 0.07 628 IMP 05527 KINGSBORO EQUITIES LLC 3533 ROXBORO RD 03/14/16 55949 RES $ 699,667 $ 249,880 35.71 HILLIARD MICHAEL S/HILLIARD VERNITA H 17 000900010780~UNIT 1 0.07 504 IMP 05155 HAMID SADRUDDING A 11285 SHELTON PL PL~463~1 03/07/16 55924 RES $ 316,614 $ 174,960 55.26 HIMANI NAZLIN/HIMANI FIROZ 11 121004631025~LOT 19 0.21 90 IMP 16752 WEBER KATHERINE A 4301 VILLAGE GREEN DR 06/30/16 56343 RES $ 337,349 $ 120,880 35.83 HIMBURG WILLIAM C/ANITA MARIE 12 145001892809 0.03 447 IMP 09351 BOEHM WALTER E 7135 GREATWOOD TRL TRL~1122~2 04/27/16 56099 RES $ 682,892 $ 274,120 40.14 HINES JAMES MICHAEL 21 569011220894~L 58 0.38 409 IMP 13684 HILBURGER PAUL 914 WOODLAND AVENUE SE~10~14 05/26/16 56228 RES $ 312,282 $ 96,080 30.77 HITRON EMILIE E 14 001000040393 0.16 1 IMP 15284 ARUN CHERVU SAMEER D AND INDIRA 1080 PEACHTREE STREET 06/06/16 56264 RES $ 448,216 $ 167,920 37.46 HIX ANDREA M 17 010600052404~UN 1812 0.03 264 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 31 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 04364 PONCE BARBARO ENRIQUE 1189 ARGONNE WY NE WAY 03/04/16 55920 RES $ 275,572 $ 100,840 36.59 HODGES SARAH C/LANIUS III JOHN S 17 000400010603~L 5 BK 12 0.18 49 IMP 20645 BUTCH WILLIAM G 9770 FARMBROOK LN~210~1 06/30/16 56439 RES $ 484,443 $ 130,040 26.84 HOEHN EDWARD/DOROTHY JANE 11 061002100179~11 & B 1.42 186 IMP 02917 RAVID KOMILIAN AND HALEH S KOMILIAN 235 LEAF CT CT 01/29/16 55843 RES $ 368,085 $ 130,320 35.40 HOF EMMANUEL/HOF CELENNE 11 064302710259~L113 0.28 371 IMP 04604 JERE FLINT AND CAROLE FLINT 5584 BENTON WOODS DR DR 02/17/16 55916 RES $ 402,155 $ 136,880 34.04 HOFFMAN LIESE/BRADLEY/ELISHEVA/ESTRIN 17 006900020109~L10 0.41 184 IMP 11493 DAIGLE RICHARD CHARLES 115 RIDGE RUN AVE 05/03/16 56154 RES $ 330,840 $ 113,080 34.18 HOFFMANN MIRIAM/MICHAEL IAN 11 016100790115 0.32 380 IMP 15646 HOUSTON TYLETHIA LATIA 2030 WINDCREST CT 06/09/16 56267 RES $ 205,766 $ 73,880 35.90 HOFFMIRE ROBERT DAVID 12 308008781140 0.02 629 IMP 17180 CERMAK JENNIFER M 833 INMAN VILLAGE PKWY~19~14TH 06/14/16 56294 RES $ 574,916 $ 188,080 32.71 HOGAN BRIAN 14 0019 LL0373~L 104 0.02 1 IMP 12875 SASZI BRANDON C 110 CABOTS COVE CT~7~1ST 05/13/16 56182 RES $ 347,630 $ 107,320 30.87 HOGAN KATHRYN M/JOHN F JR 11 004000072990~2 0.21 421 IMP 14422 TORRENCE MICHAEL J 1249 BREUER MEWS~191~17TH 05/27/16 56233 RES $ 243,863 $ 91,880 37.68 HOLBROOK JANAE 17 019100071053~LOT 78 0.03 247 IMP 07178 KELLY BONNIE J 108 MOUNT VERNON CIR CIR 03/29/16 56005 RES $ 197,830 $ 68,840 34.80 HOLLAN BRIAN A 17 0020 LL2072~UN 108 0.03 265 IMP 14359 PRAGER ELISA 535 PINE TREE DRIVE NE 06/02/16 56242 RES $ 741,877 $ 268,120 36.14 HOLLAND JASON L/ELIZABETH STUART 17 006000060617 0.37 15 IMP 06324 D R HORTON-CROWN LLC 5661 CASA BLANCA LN LN~107~14FF 03/09/16 55963 RES $ 303,952 $ 106,560 35.06 HOLLAND VIVIAN P/HOLLAND JR FLOYD N 14F0107 LL2533~L 9 0.33 16 IMP 14038 DAVIS LEA ANNE 1362 PEACHTREE BATTLE AVENUE NW 05/23/16 56210 RES $ 381,989 $ 129,760 33.97 HOLLINGSWORTH DESMOND LEE 17 019500030063 0.63 480 IMP 12018 WILSON MICHAEL J 1536 WOODLAND AVE~8~14 05/02/16 56155 RES $ 119,464 $ 28,240 23.64 HOLLOWAY ANTOINETTE 14 000800090384~3 PART OF 2 1.34 205 IMP 15340 EMILY CHIN CHU AND STEPHANIE N CHU 3820 ROSWELL RD~97~17TH 06/07/16 56271 RES $ 203,829 $ 77,840 38.19 HOLMES TOMIC R 17 0097 LL2690~UN 1014 0.02 111 IMP 06305 KENWYN H NICHOLLS AND CHERRY D 3115 ABBEY DRIVE SW~3~14TH 03/17/16 55974 RES $ 232,738 $ 79,560 34.18 HOLT ERNEST G 14F0002 LL6217~L93 POD 1 PH 3 0.28 307 IMP 12210 HUNT TERRY D 2626 PEACHTREE RD 05/09/16 56152 RES $ 311,117 $ 75,960 24.42 HOLT OLIVIA N 17 011200021625~UN 1605 0.03 470 IMP 04740 OJEVAAR OTTO/BRENDA 285 WEMBLEY CIR CIR 03/02/16 55905 RES $ 477,035 $ 166,680 34.94 HOLT SCOTT 17 0022 LL1049~L69 0.12 242 IMP 01881 JOHNSON DAISY 1744 SHIRLEY ST SW ST~171~14 01/28/16 55820 RES $ 50,093 $ 12,440 24.83 HOLZMAN HELENE L/DORFZAUN SANDER S 14 017100060172~L3, BK 8 0.20 267 IMP 07206 BROGDON SR M GINO 174 WALTHALL ST ST~13~14 03/22/16 55997 RES $ 473,330 $ 168,560 35.61 HOMES OF PINECREST LLC 14 001300110235~L4 0.21 398 IMP 20815 SPELLS LAURA 5668 SABLE WAY~95~13 06/15/16 56439 RES $ 102,429 $ 26,680 26.05 HOOKS JR RONALD L 13 0095 LL0604~231 & E 0.13 201 IMP 13447 GASTLEY ANDREW R 1909 SUNBURY PLACE 05/18/16 56192 RES $ 436,379 $ 129,480 29.67 HOOPER MARY KATHERINE/WILLIAM W 17 015300140920~L 3 BL D COLLIER 0.24 543 IMP 14818 MAISANO ANTHONY A 315 HUGHES BRANCH CLOSE~1208~2ND 05/26/16 56240 RES $ 352,503 $ 124,920 35.44 HOOT JOSEPH R/KENT HEATHER A 22 401212080448~LOT 68, BLOCK B 0.42 680 IMP 18613 HOWARD RAVI Y 520 WALDO ST 06/30/16 56353 RES $ 331,183 $ 119,320 36.03 HOPECK JOHN/KINCAID MEREDITH C 14 002100060638 0.10 402 IMP 12754 DEDICATORIA RIC 3005 VANCE CT 05/13/16 56172 RES $ 364,966 $ 150,840 41.33 HOPKINS STEVEN HEATH/FRANCES SCOTT 22 465012000674 0.33 429 IMP 13807 PAGE JENNIFER 1267 MORNINGSIDE DR~2~17 05/20/16 56213 RES $ 639,095 $ 262,240 41.03 HORTON LEAH M/WILLIAM C III 17 000200120198 0.22 254 IMP 07808 GOPICHUND VINESH 390 MEDRIDGE DR DR 03/11/16 56034 RES $ 367,253 $ 128,520 34.99 HOSKOTE SESHAGIRI RAO/KOCHERLAKOTA 11 082103031642~L10 BK F 0.19 25 IMP 16333 POWELL JULIE SADLIER 907 PLYMOUTH RD 06/10/16 56295 RES $ 705,348 $ 255,240 36.19 HOUGH CATHERINE/SEAN 17 000300060427 0.52 631 IMP 02857 BANKS KENNETH A 6507 HIGHPOINT RD RD 02/12/16 55856 RES $ 145,851 $ 48,720 33.40 HOUSTON BREEZY/SADLOWSKI ERIC 09F280000984453~L49 BK A 0.31 605 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 32 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 02120 D R HORTON-CROWN LLC 407 MOSSYCUP DR DR~143~9F 01/29/16 55834 RES $ 248,394 $ 64,120 25.81 HOWARD VICKY LYNN/HOWARD RONNIS M 09F310001436532~25 0.31 158 IMP 01467 KATHERINE STOLL KATHERINE COPELAND 1350 MORNINGSIDE DR 01/21/16 55803 RES $ 122,367 $ 45,000 36.77 HOWDEN III EDWARD THOMAS 17 000200150146~UN 14 0.01 557 IMP 12245 DONOHO MARGARET A 12689 LECOMA TRCE~1136 05/05/16 56145 RES $ 468,019 $ 156,440 33.43 HP GEORGIA I LLC 22 400011360993~LOT 46 0.21 21 IMP 16238 DAVID W KORB AND CYNTHIA A 5415 HAMPSTEAD WAY~264 06/14/16 56286 RES $ 415,366 $ 149,840 36.07 HP GEORGIA I LLC 11 067302640178~LOT 17 0.47 369 IMP 05998 CASTLEBERRY BETH B 230 WESSEX CT~33~17TH 03/21/16 55971 RES $ 423,688 $ 124,920 29.48 HP GEORGIA I LLC 17 003300040340~LOT 15 0.41 185 IMP 16576 SKARPNESS BRADLEY O 730 EIDER DOWN CT~926 06/14/16 56295 RES $ 368,570 $ 125,160 33.96 HP GEORGIA I LLC 12 319409260113~LOT 11 0.30 69 IMP 09050 CADOGAN JANICE M 04/14/16 56067 RES $ 207,727 $ 73,960 35.60 HP GEORGIA I LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED 12 264406820123~L40 BK A 0.32 325 IMP 04729 ROKHLIN VALERIE 960 LAKE HAVEN CT CT 03/03/16 55918 RES $ 218,451 $ 68,880 31.53 HRUSKA STEPHANIE 12 264306810398~L40 BK A 0.33 304 IMP 03390 MCBRAYER MELINDA 11155 BLACKBIRD LN 02/15/16 55871 RES $ 300,814 $ 97,880 32.54 HSU CHUANCHIEH/LIN JINGHWA 12 313009043326~UN 27 BLDG 2 0.05 586 IMP 07799 RICHARD C FARBER TRUSTEE UNDER ITEM V 4091 PEACHTREE DUNWOODY 03/30/16 56013 RES $ 447,161 $ 227,080 50.78 HSU DIANE 17 001100010117~LOT 20 322 IMP 10201 ELLIOTT ROBERT 2 HARPER ST NW ST~186~17TH 04/12/16 56082 RES $ 209,347 $ 71,760 34.28 HSU TERRY 17 018600030551~LOT 270 0.22 71 IMP 12183 BOYLAN SHERRIE K 8626 ELLARD DR~880 04/22/16 56138 RES $ 1,081,854 $ 256,280 23.69 HSU YU-CHING/TSANG ADAM 12 309008801573~L 127 0.22 585 IMP 08471 HALBERT ALSHA 135 OLD ALABAMA PL PL 04/08/16 56042 RES $ 304,026 $ 124,120 40.83 HUANG HUIZHU/WU GANGCHENG 12 264806810146~L14 0.22 459 IMP 17582 DOWDELL DOUG 5605 CLAIRE ROSE LN 06/17/16 56302 RES $ 1,245,114 $ 539,800 43.35 HUANG PAUL/SONG JEAN 17 013400050255 0.88 594 IMP 13026 RAYMOND DAUTHARD GREEN JR TRUSTEE 1160 SAINT LOUIS PL 05/13/16 56180 RES $ 647,815 $ 213,360 32.94 HUEFNER ROBERT JOHN/CHRISTINE DIANA 14 001600060312 0.11 620 IMP 00813 SETH B LONGTIN 345 WOOD TRC DR 01/15/16 55775 RES $ 318,041 $ 93,000 29.24 HUELSEWIESCHE DAWN 11 006700110194~L18 BK A 0.42 241 IMP 14245 O'CONNOR KATHLEEN D 250 RIVERVIEW TRAIL, UNIT 65~418 & 05/20/16 56205 RES $ 181,561 $ 63,560 35.01 HUETTEL GEORGE B 12 193604180313~65 0.04 237 IMP 13196 FOX DAVID A 420 COCHRAN DR~138~17TH 05/16/16 56195 RES $ 1,638,792 $ 503,600 30.73 HUGGINS KENNETH T/NATASHA J 17 013800020411~E.M. BARTON 0.71 207 IMP 05153 DEAN JASON M 970 SIDNEY MARCUS BLVD~6~17 02/29/16 55935 RES $ 153,687 $ 52,400 34.10 HUGGINS VIRLYNNE 17 0006 LL3086~UN 2118 0.03 181 IMP 13667 GRAU JACQUELINE 565 PEACHTREE ST 05/24/16 56211 RES $ 285,129 $ 95,440 33.47 HUGHES JOSEPH LA 14 005000011460 0.03 367 IMP 12163 WILLIAMS CARL J 1561 CAVE ROAD NW~200~17 05/06/16 56157 RES $ 1,398,005 $ 748,680 53.55 HUGHES KENNETH J/HOLLY H 17 0200 LL1183 1.11 59 IMP 18033 CAMPBELL STEVEN T 650 SADDLE RIDGE TRACE 06/27/16 56353 RES $ 343,402 $ 117,880 34.33 HUGHES STEPHEN C/ANNA L 12 194504390135 0.51 71 IMP 19919 FLETCHER RACHEL 2479 PEACHTREE RD 06/07/16 56425 RES $ 111,098 $ 46,680 42.02 HUNTER JACQUELINE V 17 010100130585~UN 105 0.02 379 IMP 15919 MCELDERRY SARAH 2242 EDISON AVE 06/10/16 56274 RES $ 540,856 $ 172,200 31.84 HUSCHKA RYAN J 17 010200070327 0.16 194 IMP 07623 E J HARRIS AS TRUSTEE OR SUCCESSOR 880 S ABBEYWOOD PLACE, UNIT # 3 03/25/16 56027 RES $ 425,108 $ 171,160 40.26 HUSSAIN SAMAD TOSEEF 12 150201980198 643 IMP 09419 GREGG F ORANGIO AND SABRINA M 301 MAGNOLIA GRV GRV~1123~2ND 04/15/16 56073 RES $ 366,757 $ 117,400 32.01 HUSSEY RICHARD 12 303008671458~UN 301 BLDG 300 0.07 387 IMP 15493 HAWKINS JR RUSSELL MORRIS 923 PEACHTREE ST 06/03/16 56265 RES $ 305,519 $ 93,400 30.57 HUTH STEVE/CAROLE 17 010600083706~UN 1030 0.02 639 IMP 11567 HAMILTON JEOFF B 1827 GROVE AVE~166~14TH 05/09/16 56154 RES $ 45,312 $ 12,360 27.28 IC HOLDINGS GA LLC 14 016600020611~LOT 19 BLK 3 0.18 189 IMP 01134 MICHAEL W PRICE AND CATHERINE V PRICE 855 HAMPTON BLUFF DR DR 01/26/16 55803 RES $ 575,369 $ 245,640 42.69 IGENITO JR ALFONSO 22 424104830142~L14 BK A 1.23 628 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 33 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 16220 PERDIDO PARTNERS LLC 6050 CARRIAGE PARK WAY 06/07/16 56289 RES $ 183,670 $ 72,600 39.53 IH6 PROPERTY GEORGIA LP 11 087103520023 0.18 327 IMP 11223 RICHARDSON DANYELLE 3105 S SEMMES ST ST~163~14 04/28/16 56113 RES $ 28,591 $ 8,200 28.68 ILES JENNIFER 14 016300130181 0.25 52 IMP 15796 PITTMAN JANE E 7957 MAGNOLIA SQ 05/31/16 56285 RES $ 468,292 $ 194,360 41.50 ILIOAIA MIHAI VIOREL/VIORICA 17 0024 LL1187 0.04 70 IMP 17167 THE WHATLEY TRUST BETTY CARTER AS 386 MCDONOUGH RD BLVD 06/29/16 56340 COM $ 90,932 $ 42,680 46.94 IMAN DEVELOPMENTS LLC 14 004100080343~103.2 X 89.1 0.21 649 IMP 07208 GUSTAFSON II FRANC EDWARD 10140 HIGH FALLS POINTE PARK~74~1ST 03/24/16 55986 RES $ 683,010 $ 268,480 39.31 IMIG JUSTIN 11 019000740404~L116 UN 4 0.45 64 IMP 10323 LAMB DEBORAH/JEFFREY D 4314 DAVIDSON AVE AVE~12~17 04/18/16 56084 RES $ 1,811,314 $ 655,520 36.19 IMLAY MARY ELLEN 17 001200010801~L3, PT L12 BK 8 0.47 600 IMP 17697 BORENGASSER STEPHEN 873 MONROE DR 06/01/16 56301 RES $ 464,350 $ 215,200 46.34 INGERSKI LISA MARIE/DAHLMAN DAVID IAN 14 004800040332 0.17 388 IMP 06261 HERBERT AYANA 3149 ESPLANADE CIR SW CIR~231~14TH 03/11/16 55975 RES $ 196,409 $ 78,520 39.98 INGRAM COURTNEY/BELL VICTORIA 14 0231 LL1308~L 63 0.20 199 IMP 03969 KLOTZ KATHLEEN LYNNE 3542 OLD MILTON PKWY 02/24/16 55909 COM $ 136,192 $ 65,080 47.79 INICENTRO 61 LLC 11 001100020127~UN 206 0.03 535 IMP 02342 STEPHENS SHERRY SINGER 18 COLLIER RD NW RD 01/22/16 55850 RES $ 147,433 $ 44,480 30.17 INJAYCHOCK MEGHAN/TESTA PATRICK 17 011000130238~UN 5 0.02 324 IMP 13060 DAVENPORT GWENDOLYN 215 PIEDMONT AVE~51~14TH 05/11/16 56168 RES $ 82,236 $ 26,600 32.35 INNOTECH LLC 14 005100130079~UN 207 0.02 83 IMP 01444 ANDRESEN LARS 105 FIELDSBORN CT CT 01/21/16 55789 RES $ 455,915 $ 178,320 39.11 IQBAL ALI GULRAYS 17 0032 LL0759~L1 0.47 643 IMP 12059 FINCH PROPERTIES LLC 3060 PHARR CT NW RD~99~17 04/15/16 56149 RES $ 148,937 $ 54,080 36.31 IRELAND LINDA L 17 009900160370~UN 304 0.02 693 IMP 05603 MROCZKA JOHN 12360 PRESERVE LANE 03/14/16 55949 RES $ 447,406 $ 158,920 35.52 IRWIN NATALIE W/IRWIN ANDEW R 21 578111930989~L118 BK A 0.34 323 IMP 18006 MARTIN BELINDA 10585 WREN RIDGE RD 06/24/16 56347 RES $ 269,851 $ 114,200 42.32 IVANYCHUK IGOR 11 058402420272 0.39 225 IMP 01677 LANGRO DONALD 10800 ARLINGTON PT PT 01/25/16 55816 RES $ 295,259 $ 92,920 31.47 IVCHENKO ALEXEI 11 068002421489~L31 0.06 679 IMP 16616 JARRETT LATRICE R 3637 OAKLEAF PASS~193~13TH 06/21/16 56314 RES $ 119,709 $ 47,040 39.30 IVERSON TYRELL 13 0192 LL2032~31 & E 0.10 458 IMP 17100 CHARLES H CALDWELL AND KIMBERLEY A 330 HIGHOAKS CT~271~1ST 06/16/16 56305 RES $ 382,622 $ 122,960 32.14 IYER KARTIK G 11 064302710556~92 0.28 24 IMP 01237 JONES JANARA 747 BALIWICK DR 01/20/16 55795 RES $ 237,886 $ 71,400 30.01 JABBIE ALPHA U 14 002300030167 0.02 391 IMP 02957 SCOFIELD TONIA M 3367 GALLEON DR 02/12/16 55863 RES $ 194,468 $ 67,520 34.72 JACKSON BRIANNE 22 539008282189 0.02 293 IMP 03363 WRIGHT GREGORY J 1036 DONNELLY AVENUE SW~119~14 02/23/16 55885 RES $ 60,801 $ 15,680 25.79 JACKSON BRYAN 14 011900020122 0.31 44 IMP 14439 TAYLOR TREMAINE N 120 BRADFORD CT~1282~2 05/31/16 56239 RES $ 247,655 $ 91,520 36.95 JACKSON DANIEL/HOCKENBERRY CLAIRE 22 387412820099~LOT 7 0.28 500 IMP 14786 TOMAZ JOHN 5395 LEEWARD RUN DR~1231~2ND 05/27/16 56238 RES $ 316,119 $ 96,440 30.51 JACKSON JACOB L 21 574112310214~LOT 21 0.70 16 IMP 17388 WILKIN HOLLEY A 225 WINDING RIVER DR 06/17/16 56314 RES $ 123,177 $ 40,840 33.16 JACKSON MELANIE 06 0367 LL1797 0.03 680 IMP 11503 CAUDILL SCOTT ~73~14 04/29/16 56152 RES $ 100,872 $ 36,880 36.56 JACKSON MERCURY 14 007300040314~31 0.26 637 IMP 11406 EDWARDS JAMES WILLIAM 770 WILSON RD~154~17 04/29/16 56131 RES $ 480,172 $ 162,720 33.89 JACKSON WADE TERRI L/WADE KEVIN A 17 015400020642~LOT 5 BLOCK 5 0.94 519 IMP 09161 YVETTE GARDINER NKA YVETTE CAMILLE 135 HYDRANGEA CT 04/08/16 56067 RES $ 462,119 $ 156,080 33.77 JACOB JERRY/MATHEW JEMLY 11 054001970932 0.54 586 IMP 10133 SOUDERS KIM 6105 BLUE STONE RD~89~17 04/26/16 56101 RES $ 304,791 $ 113,280 37.17 JACOBS NANCY 17 008900081404 0.03 403 IMP 06806 WILSON TRACY L 305 SPRING CREEK RD 03/24/16 55988 RES $ 309,127 $ 98,320 31.81 JACOUTOT JR MICHAEL 12 155102460323 1.10 231 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 34 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 17176 MANUEL MICHAEL W 165 SPRING RIDGE CT 06/14/16 56293 RES $ 294,054 $ 95,600 32.51 JAFARI ASADULLAH SYED 12 265107090403 0.28 426 IMP 09890 BYERS CARLY 5964 BROOKGREEN RD 04/25/16 56097 RES $ 378,950 $ 111,360 29.39 JAGOR JR MARK RICHARD 17 007000010149 0.41 306 IMP 17444 PEPPER LORD C 120 RALPH MCGILL BLVD 06/28/16 56336 RES $ 122,615 $ 43,960 35.85 JAMES BRIA 14 005000150383~UN 408 0.03 331 IMP 10564 HART JAMES K 0 JOHN RIVERS RD 04/27/16 56137 RES $ 11,998 $ 7,400 61.67 JAMES GWENDOLYN 07 170001520846 1.38 79 VAC 01426 PATRICK J WINDERS AND AMANDA J WINDERS 1101 COLLIER ROAD NW, F1~186~17TH 01/25/16 55808 RES $ 152,550 $ 48,640 31.88 JAMES SNYDER 17 018600011114~UNIT F1 0.02 35 IMP 02003 NDONG-SMITH JENNIFER 401 16TH ST 02/01/16 55829 RES $ 146,840 $ 46,320 31.54 JAMES-ELSTON YOLANDA 17 0148 LL1097 0.02 58 IMP 17775 HAMMONDS HELEN K 3873 ROSWELL RD 06/27/16 56329 RES $ 308,974 $ 113,160 36.62 JAN JUNKO/ERIC 17 009700100147~UN 23 0.05 640 IMP 07111 MARION S BUTTS JR 443 ALDERWOOD STREET~73 & 03/21/16 55981 RES $ 383,664 $ 140,190 36.54 JANANI JULTA/ARAVINDHAN RAVISEKAR 17 0073 LL3928~18 0.02 140 IMP 07487 BLUMBERG ROGER D 3075 BURLINGAME DR~1157 03/28/16 56029 RES $ 392,638 $ 173,320 44.14 JANKOWSKI LEILA T/JANKOWSKI DOUGLAS J 22 339011570567~105 0.50 115 IMP 02531 BROWN WENDY W 309 ALDERWOOD LN~73~17 02/11/16 55857 RES $ 389,200 $ 145,680 37.43 JANN MICHAEL R 17 0073 LL3274 0.02 643 IMP 18808 MASHBURN C J 7027 SOMERSET CIR CT 06/23/16 56347 RES $ 119,531 $ 46,880 39.22 JARAMILLO MARIA/KESKINTEPE OLGA N 22 513411840073 0.03 172 IMP 14433 CATHERINE O BUTLER F/K/A CATHERINE J 3127 LENOX RD 06/01/16 56241 RES $ 458,951 $ 216,200 47.11 JARRELL JULIAN BRANHAM/JARRELL 17 000800080776 0.07 144 IMP 05126 TAYLOR EMILY D 680 GREENWOOD AVE~17~14TH 03/04/16 55939 RES $ 215,569 $ 46,120 21.39 JASANI MADHUBALA V/JASANI VRAJLAL 14 001700020497~UNIT 307 0.02 422 IMP 18483 MICHAEL ANDERSON AND KATHERINE 3336 JAMONT BLVD~925~1ST 06/15/16 56369 RES $ 944,125 $ 289,200 30.63 JASANI SULTAN 12 318009250797~29 0.36 276 IMP 08856 WOODARD ELIZABETH SUZANNE 3311 REGATTA GRV~757~2ND 04/08/16 56050 RES $ 202,060 $ 64,840 32.09 JASPER KARI E 22 539007571426~1003 0.02 583 IMP 07876 SHARMA LEKANATH 209 PEACEHAVEN CT~483~1 03/31/16 56017 RES $ 332,078 $ 118,560 35.70 JAVAID NAJAM 11 125004830487~LOT 14 0.35 192 IMP 15824 GANDOSSI LUCIANO 505 RIPPLING WATER LN 06/10/16 56279 RES $ 473,808 $ 231,760 48.91 JAYANTHI LAKSHMI/NEERU A 11 110203880194 0.45 598 IMP 02826 MCENERY JOHN W 230 BRANDENBURGH CIR 01/29/16 55855 RES $ 39,262 $ 20,440 52.06 JCE INVESTMENTS MANAGEMENT LLC 12 157102600304 0.70 649 VAC 16104 DABIRI AKRAM 2506 QUEEN ANNE CT~366~6 06/08/16 56275 RES $ 107,346 $ 36,640 34.13 JECHURA II ROBERT L 06 036600051081 0.03 39 IMP 18697 FISCHER DANIAL 8910 SOMERSET LN 06/28/16 56349 RES $ 232,881 $ 67,440 28.96 JEFFERSON DANIELLE L/SHAWN W 22 513611830106 0.20 623 IMP 11439 PELEG AT DUNWOODY ROW LLC 964 PERSIMMON PT~18~17TH 05/06/16 56139 RES $ 337,562 $ 94,720 28.06 JEN-JU CHIA JENNY/JYH-CHENG CHIA JERRY 17 0019 LL1853 0.05 109 IMP 17148 JOHN A OBLINGER AND KATHERINE S 301 DEFOORS LANDING~187~17TH 06/23/16 56333 RES $ 176,198 $ 67,640 38.39 JENNIFER R SLATTERY 17 018700100080~UNIT 301 0.03 21 IMP 00688 TURNER KARYNNE 166 WINTHROP ST 01/11/16 55775 RES $ 231,466 $ 74,040 31.99 JENNINGS ORVIN R 14F0009 LL1989 0.25 48 IMP 08241 WILKINSON LUKE W 659 AUBURN AVE 04/11/16 56051 RES $ 253,909 $ 78,240 30.81 JENNISON VALERIE/GWIN ANDREW 14 001900102111 0.02 240 IMP 06890 PATEL YOGESH 10670 BRANHAM FIELDS RD~305~1 03/28/16 55993 RES $ 334,661 $ 119,240 35.63 JENSEN MARK D 11 080403050536~66 0.42 30 IMP 17084 PATRICK J RUSSELL AND THERESA 4010 BRECKENRIDGE CT 06/15/16 56301 RES $ 449,795 $ 175,920 39.11 JENSEN MARTIN A 11 035001580508 0.37 213 IMP 05015 CAPES ADAM 450 LAUREL CHASE CT~136~17TH 03/07/16 55927 RES $ 1,079,930 $ 349,080 32.32 JERKINS NATHAN T/SHAN HSUANY 17 013600020108 0.41 240 IMP 04317 STATON JOHN C 413 MANOR RIDGE DR~144~17TH 02/24/16 55893 RES $ 2,083,189 $ 580,000 27.84 JERNIGAN MELISSA B 17 014400050055~LOT 18 & PART OF 1.52 602 IMP 11241 ANTIONETTE THOMAS N/K/A ANTIONETTE 170 NOWELL DR 04/29/16 56116 RES $ 88,477 $ 28,200 31.87 JIMENEZ RICARDO VAZQUEZ 09F090400511560 0.13 354 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 35 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 08056 JOHN A BOUGHTON AND SUE H BOUGHTON 100 DOVER CLIFF~141~1ST 03/21/16 56018 RES $ 625,230 $ 191,280 30.59 JOAN P POSTELL 11 032301080107~10 0.24 657 IMP 16148 THOMPSON JAMES C 855 PEACHTREE ST 06/06/16 56287 RES $ 250,961 $ 96,240 38.35 JOHN R WILLIAMS AND MEGHAN B 14 004900022222~UN 1208 0.02 656 IMP 07175 THOMPSON JR RONALD G 7422 ABSINTH DR~46~9C 03/30/16 56007 RES $ 178,770 $ 53,920 30.16 JOHNSON DAVID BERNARD 09C110000462338~118 0.21 177 IMP 06183 HAUCK H BRUCE 03/17/16 55964 RES $ 417,979 $ 128,360 30.71 JOHNSON HELEN SMITH 12 280607710053 0.39 422 IMP 02510 SCHECHTER NICOLE 5400 ROSWELL ROAD 02/05/16 55840 RES $ 130,911 $ 33,440 25.54 JOHNSON JENNIFER 17 009200080880 0.02 559 IMP 05599 COLSON GREGORY M 2421 SAGAMORE DR 03/14/16 55951 RES $ 442,646 $ 246,480 55.68 JOHNSON JUAN C/HARVEY JEAN K 17 014400040536 0.37 250 IMP 08541 CENTURY COMMUNITIES OF GEORGIA LLC 7811 WROTHAM CIR~46~9C 03/31/16 56034 RES $ 198,485 $ 65,760 33.13 JOHNSON KARL 09C110000463831~268 0.23 592 IMP 09287 MCDONALD ANDRE JEROME 2953 BLUESTONE DR 04/08/16 56061 RES $ 186,999 $ 73,440 39.27 JOHNSON KRISTI 14F0128 LL0938 0.34 219 IMP 04249 D R HORTON-CROWN LLC 5677 CASA BLANCA LN~107~14FF 02/04/16 55914 RES $ 356,329 $ 99,080 27.81 JOHNSON MARQUS J/YOUNG LATRICHIA R 14F0107 LL2491~LOT 5 0.33 207 IMP 00412 HADEN JANET 520 AUTUMN WOOD CLOSE~109~1 01/07/16 55760 RES $ 423,321 $ 133,360 31.50 JOHNSON MATTHEW C/JOHNSON JENNIFER P 12 141201090112~LOT 21 BLK E 1.25 133 IMP 01892 SPRINGFIELD MICHAEL 400 WEST PEACHTREE ST 01/29/16 55825 RES $ 171,773 $ 60,960 35.49 JOHNSON MICHAEL A 14 007900132321 593 IMP 02132 LUU KEVIN 330 WHITLEY PARK DR~312~6TH 01/21/16 55821 RES $ 387,676 $ 132,720 34.23 JOHNSON PAUL/JOHNSON ALIX 06 0312 LL0357~LOT 4, BLOCK A 0.64 673 IMP 13972 HOWARD HARRIET R 5635 HILLGATE XING 05/25/16 56214 RES $ 310,248 $ 123,800 39.90 JOHNSON STEPHANIE 11 065202682035 0.41 269 IMP 08910 STALVEY N/K/A SARAH STALVEY CANTRELL 245 BUCKLAND DRIVE 04/12/16 56052 RES $ 130,503 $ 50,640 38.80 JOHNSON STEPHANIE 12 293008222107 0.03 307 IMP 08865 HOSTETTER ROBERT PARKER 400 VILLAGE PKWY~15 AND 18~14 04/08/16 56047 RES $ 266,607 $ 85,600 32.11 JOHNSTON RYAN E 14 001800100686 0.03 452 IMP 14289 TAIJERON SABINA 815 MURROW COURT~108~7TH 05/20/16 56205 RES $ 90,781 $ 26,640 29.35 JOINER MONG 07 140001082931~LOT 17 0.08 482 IMP 06559 VEIKKOLAINEN MIA 3546 ROSWELL RD~98~17 02/22/16 55978 RES $ 478,049 $ 158,280 33.11 JOJO INVESTMENTS LLC 17 009800011004 0.03 148 IMP 07167 CRAIG F GREGOZESKI 4306 PINE HEIGHTS DRIVE NE~7 AND 03/17/16 55981 RES $ 166,242 $ 56,040 33.71 JONATHAN CARRUBBA 17 000700012564~UNIT 4306 0.03 157 IMP 13392 JOHNSON SHIRLEY C 0 RIVERTOWN RD~30~8TH 05/23/16 56204 RES $ 23,461 $ 8,280 35.29 JONES CHARLES/JONES HEATHER VICTORINE 08 060000301272 2.40 8 VAC 13126 LATIMER KENNETH 2870 PHARR CT~100~17TH 05/06/16 56202 RES $ 109,860 $ 34,120 31.06 JONES JERICA B 17 010000071426~U 502 0.03 299 IMP 14036 STAMMEN BRENT M 3481 LAKESIDE DR 05/25/16 56208 RES $ 148,792 $ 56,760 38.15 JONES JR DOUGLAS MARSHALL 17 000900042510 0.02 69 IMP 03869 WEATHERLY JODY C 2959 HABERSHAM WAY~113~17TH 03/01/16 55914 RES $ 1,056,537 $ 333,760 31.59 JONES JULIE M/JONES THOMAS T 17 011300040194~13/17 0.78 578 IMP 01934 VENTURE HOMES INC 3983 MARGAUX DR 01/29/16 55824 RES $ 186,398 $ 72,160 38.71 JONES KENDRIC D 14F0156 LL2954 0.28 242 IMP 12475 SHMUEL KATZELNIK AND ANAT KENAN- 14430 WYNDHAM FARMS DR 05/10/16 56170 RES $ 397,760 $ 155,280 39.04 JONES KOREY M 22 507107620393 1.46 95 IMP 15139 CAMPBELL PRICILLA A 7235 MADISON CIR~42~9F 05/27/16 56253 RES $ 191,478 $ 83,440 43.58 JONES LATORRIA 09F120000422031~L 408 BL J POD F PH 2 0.25 531 IMP 11218 SWINT NOAH T 4144 RAVENWOOD CT 04/29/16 56128 RES $ 79,261 $ 27,200 34.32 JONES LAUREN 09F210600981203 0.03 279 IMP 06751 HARPER II RICHARD W 212 MONTAG CIR 03/25/16 55988 RES $ 708,513 $ 255,990 36.13 JONES PATRICK 14 0019 LL2700 0.04 491 IMP 06829 DR HORTON INC 7283 PARKLAND BEND~140~7 03/30/16 55996 RES $ 242,697 $ 103,880 42.80 JONES PHYLLIS/JONES JAMES 07 150001408531~57 0.22 134 IMP 17674 JUSTIN LUBENOW AND VIVIAN SUCHY 1029 PEIDMONT AVE 06/28/16 56335 RES $ 251,405 $ 96,520 38.39 JONES ROBERT B 17 010600091873~UN 302 0.03 450 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 36 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 11044 SOBEL PAUL J 710 QUARTERPATH LN~626~2 04/21/16 56107 RES $ 625,660 $ 231,600 37.02 JONES STEPHEN J/JONES HEATHER R 22 441006260814~LOT 2 1.00 304 IMP 04961 MADDOX BAXTER RAY 2344 ABNER PL 03/03/16 55929 RES $ 17,745 $ 10,640 59.96 JONES WAYNE 17 024600020329 0.18 336 IMP 05795 THE NEW PARADIGM GROUP LLC 212 REINHARDT ST~45~14 03/14/16 55948 RES $ 225,607 $ 59,200 26.24 JORDAN EVA CLAIRE 14 004500100444 0.09 216 IMP 15819 LEE CHERYL SNYDER/SANDRA B/MICHAEL D 955 JUNIPER ST 06/08/16 56286 RES $ 146,828 $ 53,960 36.75 JORDAN TIMOTHY J/CATHERINE M/MICHAEL L 17 010600311461~UN 3318 0.02 542 IMP 14311 ANGELA HOPE STEPHENSON 230 WINDFLOWER TRC 05/13/16 56210 RES $ 232,575 $ 73,080 31.42 JOSEPH AHERN/KRISTINE SOTO 12 180203720540 0.28 689 IMP 16905 GROCHOWSKA BEATA K 580 CALAVERAS DR 06/22/16 56320 RES $ 509,493 $ 204,240 40.09 JOSEPH JOCELYN K 17 002400020202 0.63 349 IMP 07975 ROBERT JACKSON AND DENISE M WILSON 4588 TALL PINES DRIVE NW~119~17TH 04/01/16 56032 RES $ 947,124 $ 281,960 29.77 JOSEPH YEAGER/STACEY YEAGER 17 011900050734~13 Y 0.69 137 IMP 00265 MADISON TODD A 1080 PEACHTREE ST 01/15/16 55787 RES $ 609,330 $ 175,720 28.84 JOY ROBERT 17 010600051083~UN 1009 0.03 45 IMP 17875 HAIM JULIE 06/24/16 56331 RES $ 805,129 $ 397,840 49.41 JOYCE CHRISTOPHER P/MIRIAM W 22 463010330714 1.78 392 IMP 20794 JOHNSON KATHERINE STANLEY 3388 PACES FOREST RD 06/22/16 56396 RES $ 531,645 $ 213,320 40.12 JULY HOMES INC 17 018100010137 0.79 202 IMP 10397 PETERS STEVEN E 3002 STEEPLECHASE 04/15/16 56090 RES $ 120,080 $ 36,520 30.41 JUMANI CHETAN/HELIG AMIRRAMAY 22 450212480058 0.03 443 IMP 06343 HERRING BRADLEY 1735 PEACHTREE ST 03/18/16 55965 RES $ 308,520 $ 99,200 32.15 JUNEAU-VINCENT MOLLY/VINCENT TONY 17 010900180822 0.04 77 IMP 17649 ELLEN M PRENDERGAST AND WILLIAM J 6 OLD PACES PLACE NW~198~17TH 06/22/16 56322 RES $ 983,542 $ 250,400 25.46 JUNG MIN WONG/KOON HON WONG 17 019800020194~6 0.39 391 IMP 09388 AYAL JUDITH IRENE SHAMSKY 2624 FORREST WAY 04/22/16 56084 RES $ 602,059 $ 190,720 31.68 JUNGER MATTHEW EDWARD/JUNGER PATTI 17 010100080525 0.31 148 IMP 11727 LONG PATRICIA A 4014 CARISBROOK DR~83~9F 05/06/16 56147 RES $ 88,034 $ 22,840 25.94 K1 GROUP LLC 09F240100832077~LOT 84, BRENTWOOD 0.16 125 IMP 01720 JAMES L MCFARLANE JR AND MARIA Y 3063 PEACHTREE DR 01/29/16 55828 RES $ 480,965 $ 185,040 38.47 KAELIN L MASON AND WILLIAM A MASON 17 004600110031 0.47 650 IMP 00404 NAMERUMAL RAMESH 2170 NEWPORT LNDG 01/07/16 55759 RES $ 116,040 $ 31,040 26.75 KAHANA ROY 22 514512650031 0.03 26 IMP 01191 SUAREZ HOLLIE 400 PEACHTREE ST 01/19/16 55791 RES $ 316,207 $ 87,080 27.54 KAHN MICHAEL M 14 007900135233 0.03 473 IMP 02681 JEFFREY D HAMMAN AND JOYCE B HAMMAN 115 ENGLISH OAK COURT 02/05/16 55845 RES $ 415,204 $ 158,360 38.14 KALYAN PONNADA AND SUJATHA PONNADA 21 574012291365 0.32 586 IMP 16229 BRUCE BARBARA 8 BASSWOOD CIR 05/26/16 56282 RES $ 230,393 $ 80,960 35.14 KAMAL HODA A 17 001800020309 0.05 662 IMP 09265 ADAMS YOLANDA D 510 GRACELYN CT~104~14FF 04/15/16 56070 RES $ 321,145 $ 82,200 25.60 KAMBON AKO/KAMBON HANIFAH 14F0104 LL1975~225 0.25 621 IMP 07723 BURD JESSICA 14 IRON BOUND PL~220~17 03/31/16 56015 RES $ 192,121 $ 56,920 29.63 KANTOR RYAN A 17 022000081669~UNIT 112 0.03 556 IMP 14883 PATTERSON SCOTT ALLEN 383 RALPH MCGILL BLVD~46 & 47 05/27/16 56235 RES $ 126,447 $ 43,280 34.23 KAO CONNIE 14 004600152030 0.03 39 IMP 05163 KIMBERLY GRAY COMBES F/K/A KIMBERLY 03/08/16 55934 RES $ 197,867 $ 65,920 33.32 KARAMI ARJANG 12 317308970170 0.49 613 IMP 12530 JOHNSON HENRY S 5805 GREENBRIER RD 04/15/16 56168 RES $ 407,249 $ 155,200 38.11 KARASZEWSKI ERIC 17 003700030099 0.45 663 IMP 08637 ROSENBURY ALISON 245 HIGHLAND AVE 03/29/16 56045 RES $ 207,251 $ 60,760 29.32 KARESH MERYL E 14 0019 LL0985 0.02 476 IMP 13358 BROWN PATRICK T 355 PHILLIP LN 05/16/16 56194 RES $ 705,591 $ 237,000 33.59 KARNIK VIKRANT/KARNIK BOJANA 11 015000412549 0.37 473 IMP 18244 VANNBERG FREDRIK 400 WEST PEACHTREE ST 06/29/16 56348 RES $ 273,254 $ 118,960 43.53 KARSLI KEMAL/YILDIRIM OYA 14 007900133188~UN 2304 0.03 601 IMP 00432 HUBBARD ELIZABETH FLEMING 635 JEFFERSON CIRCLE 01/08/16 55759 RES $ 298,617 $ 116,200 38.91 KASL PROPERTY GROUP LLC 17 003300020144 0.06 700 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 37 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 11179 JACKSON C ALAN 845 SPRING ST~80~14 04/28/16 56122 RES $ 290,522 $ 101,400 34.90 KAWAJIRI YOSHIAKI 14 008000031249~315 0.03 251 IMP 15430 FRIDMAN BORIS 935 PIEDMONT AVE~106~17 06/06/16 56268 RES $ 290,502 $ 82,880 28.53 KAZMIER MATTHEW P 17 010600120862 0.02 190 IMP 00877 KANGISSER STEVEN J 01/19/16 55786 RES $ 464,429 $ 184,000 39.62 KBD DEVELOPMENT LLC 17 000200020018 0.22 672 IMP 15418 WHITFIELD INVESTMENT PARTNERS LP 13973 TREE LOFT ROAD~814, 843~2 06/06/16 56271 RES $ 224,153 $ 73,600 32.83 KEARCE JR JAMES T 22 428008141035~27 1.26 311 VAC 06278 MICHAEL A ROBINSON AND ANNA D 285 FARM TRAK 03/22/16 55976 RES $ 265,065 $ 80,320 30.30 KEATING KEVIN/SULLIVAN KARA 12 171403000049 0.41 287 IMP 18166 SUR IGOR 230 LULLWATER CT~298~1 06/28/16 56350 RES $ 537,213 $ 242,120 45.07 KEITH MICHAEL S/SHANA L 12 172002981092~14 0.25 6 IMP 00090 PATIRE JOSEPH B 923 PEACHTREE ST~108~17TH 01/06/16 55744 RES $ 274,095 $ 78,160 28.52 KELLER MICHAEL J 17 010600085230~1835 0.02 307 IMP 09912 YUDICHAK KRISTIN A 870 INMAN VILLAGE PKWY~19~14 04/22/16 56098 RES $ 226,930 $ 71,400 31.46 KELLY BAILEE FRANCES 14 0019 LL2213~415 0.02 329 IMP 01158 JACOBUS OTH J 915 CURLEW CT~164~17TH 01/15/16 55791 RES $ 1,000,688 $ 368,480 36.82 KELLY EDWARD/KELLY BONNIE 17 016400030094~LOT 45, BL. A 0.56 433 IMP 09657 DAVIS ANDREW 3235 ROSWELL RD 04/15/16 56080 RES $ 339,762 $ 107,880 31.75 KEMME SCOTT L/MURPHY ELAINE 17 009900030342 0.03 193 IMP 14969 JASON BRAVERMAN AS TRUSTEE OF THE 400 SEVENTEENTH ST # 2405 05/31/16 56235 RES $ 143,189 $ 44,480 31.06 KEMP KHALIL 17 0148 LL3929 0.02 341 IMP 06136 DAVIS WILLIAM 4055 INVERNESS XING 03/18/16 55961 RES $ 441,421 $ 168,760 38.23 KENCHAPPA MOHAN KUMAR/LOUIS RACHAEL 12 162202710417 0.44 638 IMP 10801 D R HORTON-CROWN LLC 8063 STILLMIST DR~107~7TH 04/27/16 56132 RES $ 262,471 $ 80,360 30.62 KENDALL URSULA/KENDALL KAREN 07 140001078269~669 0.20 352 IMP 15350 GILES GARY D 1050 LAKE SHORE OVERLOOK 05/27/16 56256 RES $ 808,360 $ 307,160 38.00 KENDRICK JOANNE M DION/ROBERT L 21 562011700692 0.45 231 IMP 10689 MAHMOOD NIFAR R 878 PEACHTREE STREET NE #703~49~14 04/27/16 56119 RES $ 207,664 $ 64,120 30.88 KENNEDY PATRICIA/MILLER MELISSA D 14 004900011761~UNIT 703 0.02 179 IMP 18960 MCCURRY JILL P 645 MOUNT VICTORIA PL~29~1 06/17/16 56394 RES $ 297,938 $ 132,880 44.60 KENNEDY WILLIAM NEIL 11 009100290210~22 & C 0.60 43 IMP 07551 BENEDETTO PETER 245 SKULLEY DR 03/28/16 56024 RES $ 311,094 $ 104,760 33.67 KENNELLY SHANNON L/KENNELLY TONI K 22 387012811019 0.12 458 IMP 11824 LONGVIEW PROPERTIES LLC 6510 LONG ISLAND DR 05/03/16 56150 RES $ 953,463 $ 260,160 27.29 KENNETT CHRISTINE MARY/KENNETT PHILIP 17 012500020051 0.91 668 IMP 18421 WYATT JAMES REESE 72 NATHAN CIR~1271~2 06/17/16 56347 RES $ 182,320 $ 55,480 30.43 KERCHER-BURNS DONNA 22 466212710294~12/B 0.65 412 IMP 14643 IZU LLC 1280 WEST PEACHTREE ST 06/02/16 56249 RES $ 179,849 $ 41,760 23.22 KERSHNER MARK R/KERSHNER TERRI D 17 010800084983 0.02 577 IMP 04840 EH CAPITOL LLC 896 SPENCER ST 02/26/16 55917 RES $ 38,043 $ 8,400 22.08 KETERRA INVESTMENTS LLC 14 011000040228 0.10 62 IMP 06547 DONEGAL PROPERTIES LLC 3568 OLD MILTON PKWY PKWY~2/3~1 03/22/16 56007 COM $ 132,369 $ 65,080 49.17 KEW RAY LLC 11 001100020259~UN 340 0.03 626 IMP 14849 VANDERVEN JOSEPH E 565 SHIREROKES CT 05/24/16 56241 RES $ 520,474 $ 179,200 34.43 KEY JASON L/KEY EMILIA A 12 168403230030 0.69 92 IMP 05724 HORSTMEYER NEAL 11057 GREY OWL RD~903~1 03/10/16 55943 RES $ 272,050 $ 83,160 30.57 KEY JUSTIN 12 313009033087 0.03 1 IMP 09451 CAMPBELL SCOTT T 105 STANMORE CT 04/20/16 56083 RES $ 347,372 $ 140,040 40.31 KEY KARA/TARTER DANIEL F 22 329412950799 0.61 627 IMP 10873 IMMEL JEFFREY W 375 CHAMPIONS VIEW DR~609~2 04/29/16 56132 RES $ 654,361 $ 257,560 39.36 KHAN ALI SHAHZAD/TOOR IJAZ UL HAQ 22 521006090582~25 1.13 292 IMP 01695 EDGE KATHLEEN E 6980 ROSWELL RD~74~17TH 01/27/16 55826 RES $ 164,141 $ 62,040 37.80 KHAN KASHFIA 17 0074 LL3505~UNIT 3, BLDG M 0.04 604 IMP 15214 BIBLE CHARLES M 1150 COLLIER RD 06/01/16 56254 RES $ 71,992 $ 21,040 29.23 KHATH DAVY 17 018600013409 0.01 85 IMP 10992 TRACY CANDACE 04/28/16 56116 RES $ 344,938 $ 118,120 34.24 KILGORE REBECCA 22 480411070285 0.46 1 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 38 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 14423 MILLER BLAISE M 820 STONEHAVEN LN~1253, 1254~2 05/31/16 56240 RES $ 425,966 $ 181,400 42.59 KILPATRICK LAUREN C/KILPATRICK MANION S 21 567412530622~19 0.36 331 IMP 11968 SIVAN YARIV 225 CREEK RUN CT~1231~2ND 04/15/16 56141 RES $ 335,014 $ 94,200 28.12 KIM ANNE S 21 574112310149~14 0.37 3 IMP 11166 BUTLER JOHN MARK 860 PEACHTREE ST 04/27/16 56114 RES $ 341,492 $ 120,320 35.23 KIM HANKYUL 14 004900013346 0.03 244 IMP 20640 AN HYOK KYU 6180 IMES WAY 06/17/16 56406 RES $ 266,810 $ 106,000 39.73 KIM JUNG HWA 11 091003442155 0.04 524 IMP 16581 POSADA PATRICIA J 765 HEDGEWICK TRL~115~1 06/17/16 56307 RES $ 249,912 $ 84,360 33.76 KIM MINKIL 11 038001151569~LOT 16 0.21 278 IMP 07431 DODRILL ROBERT M 58 BASSWOOD CIR 03/18/16 56014 RES $ 280,041 $ 86,680 30.95 KIM SOLOMON/KIM MEREIDTH 17 001800020416 0.06 129 IMP 00216 KENNETH A BOMAR OR FRANCES S BOMAR 3520 LAKEWIND WAY 01/15/16 55774 RES $ 429,008 $ 141,720 33.03 KIM TAEJIN 21 567412530309 0.38 117 IMP 05002 CALLIE SCHLOSSER 872 BOULEVARD SE~22~14TH 02/29/16 55924 RES $ 304,150 $ 81,160 26.68 KIMBERLY WHITE 14 002200100664~65 0.12 529 IMP 19388 PETER R GREENE AND THERESA B 110 PINE RISE CT 06/30/16 56378 RES $ 254,553 $ 83,320 32.73 KIMOTO CHRYSTELLE N/CARMICHAEL L 11 027101180693 0.23 55 IMP 16990 JOHN R GIMSON AND NANCY P GIMSON 205 PARK BRIDGE LN~389~1 06/15/16 56298 RES $ 282,347 $ 88,960 31.51 KINCAID WILLIAM 12 189603890258~25, BLK A 0.28 321 IMP 16812 PHILBRICK KEVIN 360 ORMOND ST~43~14 06/23/16 56328 RES $ 442,619 $ 112,800 25.48 KING LINDSAY S/TIMOTHY G 14 004300060301~LOT 10 0.18 290 IMP 16968 PALUMBO GEORGE J 1200 RICHMOND GLEN CIR 06/14/16 56298 RES $ 704,161 $ 205,120 29.13 KING MARY I/CHOJNACKI KEVIN P 22 410007020451,0659 2.91 522 IMP 04438 DIXON BARBIE A 4471 RAVENWOOD DR~98~9F 02/24/16 55900 RES $ 84,871 $ 31,000 36.53 KINLOCH PARTNERS II LLC 09F210000972844~254 270 IMP 00923 HARVEY LOLITA 5704 ROCKAWAY DR 01/05/16 55806 RES $ 104,723 $ 38,680 36.94 KINLOCH PARTNERS II LLC 09F160200652169 444 IMP 06330 BRUNNER MARK 1110 RIVER VISTA DR 03/15/16 55958 RES $ 499,416 $ 147,640 29.56 KIRBY AMY F/KIRBY DALE A 17 0211 LL1727 0.02 414 IMP 01233 LANGEVIN MICHELE P 3018 WINGATE WAY 01/19/16 55792 RES $ 88,439 $ 23,920 27.05 KIRTAN J P HOSPITALITY LLC 17 002300031663 0.03 410 IMP 12617 BERRY HELEEN BECKER 906 VIRGINIA CIR 05/02/16 56165 RES $ 597,779 $ 197,400 33.02 KITCHEN JODY F 17 000100070337 0.17 176 IMP 05170 MAHESH C PANDE AND PREMA PANDE 12105 GREENMONT WALK~1274~2ND 03/11/16 55940 RES $ 269,955 $ 74,160 27.47 KITCHENS JACOB D 22 450312740112~11 BLK A 0.56 11 IMP 09207 THE BENEVOLENT EMPIRE LLC 455 GLEN IRIS DR~18~14 04/15/16 56066 RES $ 255,985 $ 72,760 28.42 KITCHENS NATHAN P 14 001800050980 0.03 230 IMP 07633 RHW GEORGIA INVESTMENTS LLC 3151 AERO CT~158~14 04/01/16 56016 IND $ 338,726 $ 141,320 41.72 KJGB PROPERTIES LLC 14 015800130147~6 1.81 486 IMP 10982 JAMES C GUELLER LINDA FRANCES GUELLER 2043 VILLAGE CREST DR~256~17TH 04/18/16 56133 RES $ 326,036 $ 99,440 30.50 KLAREICH RICHARD J/NIKELLE ALAYNE 17 0256 LL1137~72 0.14 514 IMP 07759 RASMUSSEN COURTNEY M 830 CRAB ORCHARD DR 03/31/16 56017 RES $ 261,994 $ 87,720 33.48 KLECZKA SHANNON/KLECZKA JR MICHAEL 12 263406840370~3 0.39 4 IMP 11919 KARP REGINA K 3340 MERGANSER LN~926~1ST 05/03/16 56138 RES $ 397,008 $ 149,800 37.73 KLEIN MARTHA/KLEIN ROBERT 12 319409260550~LOT 4, BLK B, 0.40 185 IMP 08615 SAVELL KEVEN D 250 PHARR RD~99~17TH 04/04/16 56040 RES $ 207,320 $ 75,040 36.20 KLOPP ANNIE 17 009900072096 0.02 1 IMP 09750 KESTERTON WILLIAM L 135 TRAIL POINT 04/22/16 56091 RES $ 622,992 $ 172,280 27.65 KNIPLE SHERI L/KNIPLE JOSEPH L 17 002800010316~13A 1.34 81 IMP 01972 MASON JAMES G 175 15TH ST NE #202 01/29/16 55819 RES $ 299,376 $ 97,960 32.72 KNOESPEL AMY A 17 010600020658 0.03 225 IMP 04646 LOWE SARAH N 2375 PINE GROVE DR~230~17 02/29/16 55899 RES $ 213,855 $ 107,720 50.37 KNOX BOBBY RANDALL/PATEL-KNOX PRIYA 17 023000010732 0.65 452 IMP 14602 ALPER ELAINE J 7301 SAINT CHARLES SQ~425~1 06/03/16 56243 RES $ 158,151 $ 44,000 27.82 KOCHHAR RAHUL 12 200604250150 0.04 41 IMP 02367 LIM AAN B 4645 VALAIS CT 02/04/16 55860 RES $ 154,462 $ 52,760 34.16 KODELA SRINIVASA 11 037001530517 0.03 539 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 39 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 16151 TURNER JR PAUL A 1030 JORDAN LN 06/15/16 56287 RES $ 407,043 $ 146,360 35.96 KODIGINAHALLI PRABHAKAR K/GUPTHA 22 387012402108 0.25 584 IMP 04632 RYAN J ROLANDO AND DEBRA L ROLANDO 115 PEACHTREE PL~79~14 02/29/16 55908 RES $ 228,272 $ 64,680 28.33 KOENIG STEFAN 14 007900121563 0.03 468 IMP 06638 BELL ELIZABETH 136 PEACHTREE MEMORIAL DR 03/22/16 55990 RES $ 168,505 $ 57,040 33.85 KOEPFLE COURTNEY 17 011100110072 0.03 272 IMP 02000 MCCRACKEN JACQUELINE Y 3245 WOLF WILLOW CLOSE~755~2ND 02/02/16 55821 RES $ 531,068 $ 200,040 37.67 KOETTER DONNA/KOETTER STEPHEN 22 539107550247~LOT 10 0.40 497 IMP 06697 BOWLING ASHLEY E 1125 BRIARCLIFF PL~16~14 03/23/16 55979 RES $ 226,946 $ 70,840 31.21 KOHLER ROBERT THOMAS/KOHLER RACHEL 14 001600140122 0.02 677 IMP 11004 FRICKS FRANK M 14663 TIMBER PT~689~2ND 04/29/16 56127 RES $ 705,051 $ 324,520 46.03 KOHRMAN KRISTEN/KOHRMAN BRIAN 22 506006890875~LOT 34, 2.06 698 IMP 07173 MARSHALL STEVE 03/25/16 55994 RES $ 266,401 $ 90,320 33.90 KONEN DAVID A 12 154002493260 0.02 213 IMP 04040 WILSON JOHN B 03/02/16 55915 RES $ 211,163 $ 86,780 41.10 KOOISTRA KEVIN/KOOISTRA JENNA 22 326110090514 1.10 577 IMP 09888 GARFINKEL MARC 3820 ROSWELL RD~97~17 04/19/16 56073 RES $ 301,672 $ 107,800 35.73 KOONIN STEVEN R/KOONIN AMY B 17 0097 LL2310 0.03 631 IMP 06634 CREEK M A 820 KENLEY WALK 03/23/16 55980 RES $ 245,014 $ 95,440 38.95 KOPPEN SUSAN L 12 206204710048 0.41 505 IMP 07961 MONDRAGON ADRIENNE 1101 JUNIPER ST~106~17 03/31/16 56014 RES $ 221,072 $ 65,840 29.78 KORNDOERFER JENS 17 010600067006 0.02 250 IMP 06720 HOBBS TERRY 215 PIEDMONT AVE 03/11/16 55989 RES $ 97,298 $ 28,280 29.07 KOSMA EDA/TSANG-KOSMA WINNIE/KOSMA 14 005100132281 0.02 588 IMP 03542 LAKSHMINARAYANAN KRISHNARJ 02/22/16 55884 RES $ 310,877 $ 99,760 32.09 KOTHAPALLI PURUSHOTHAM/KOSANA 22 541008991538 0.21 1 IMP 01986 DAYAN SCOTT M 4100 PARAN POINTE DR 02/01/16 55829 RES $ 652,404 $ 204,400 31.33 KOTKIN ROSS 17 021500040183 0.21 53 IMP 10324 HOWARD PHILIP A 10670 BUICE RD 04/15/16 56075 RES $ 283,911 $ 95,240 33.55 KOU YUNFENG/CHEN HUAIYU 11 027201170974 0.35 219 IMP 10661 SMITH III WILLIAM BERTRAM 2085 HOWELL MILL RD 04/27/16 56133 RES $ 452,246 $ 164,720 36.42 KRAUSE THOMAS W/KRAUSE RACHEL R 17 015300010164 0.49 144 IMP 18184 KAUFMAN DANIEL R 1969 SPRING CIR 06/30/16 56357 RES $ 440,403 $ 167,960 38.14 KREAFLE KENNETH CHARLES 17 025600011234 0.35 441 IMP 08205 HOVORKA JEROME W 878 PEACHTREE ST~49~14TH 04/12/16 56054 RES $ 221,081 $ 75,200 34.01 KREGLOSKI KIM RENE 14 004900011068 0.02 63 IMP 07171 DABIERO BRIANNE MARIE 325 PACES FERRY RD 03/28/16 56004 RES $ 181,943 $ 63,240 34.76 KRUEGER JOHN 17 006100091561 0.02 506 IMP 03001 BURCH BARRY W 7540 STONERIDGE DR 02/16/16 55863 RES $ 305,458 $ 98,430 32.22 KUMAR AMIT 17 0032 LL5683 0.02 272 IMP 06542 CHISHOLM SANDRA M 3424 ARCHGATE CT~757~2 03/10/16 55987 RES $ 257,732 $ 88,720 34.42 KUMAR SURESH/KUMAR SHOBA 22 539007573281~2 0.10 542 IMP 17178 FISHER WILLIAM HAMILTON 9040 RIVERBEND MNR~878~1ST 06/15/16 56304 RES $ 476,516 $ 166,160 34.87 KUNEMUND GREGG/LORI-ANN 12 308008780654~14A 0.03 137 IMP 05414 FERRELL ROBERT M 1708 THOMS DR 03/04/16 55945 RES $ 11,981 $ 4,680 39.06 KUTZ INC 14 014600050522 0.18 341 IMP 04893 GRANATH LINDA G 3160 HARTRIDGE DR 02/12/16 55933 RES $ 364,628 $ 148,160 40.63 LACHAPELLE SAMANTHA 12 319308930337 0.37 696 IMP 08282 JOHNSON MICHAEL D 1150 COLLIER ROAD~186~17TH 03/31/16 56055 RES $ 68,391 $ 21,280 31.12 LACKS JONATHAN MACAULEY 17 018600014225~CONDO UNIT # L-18 0.01 344 IMP 04725 VOSS MICHAEL P 410 PRINCE CHARKES PL~871~1 02/26/16 55904 RES $ 398,733 $ 150,200 37.67 LAJOE ANTHONY M/LAJOE NICOLE M 12 305608710263~26 & S 0.59 220 IMP 01226 NEWPORT ATLANTIC LLC 4765 KENT ROAD 01/20/16 55808 RES $ 39,993 $ 21,600 54.01 LAKES GEORGIA PROPERTIES LLC 13 003500050130 0.91 537 IMP 17449 JEFFERIES LAURA A 2898 ROCKINGHAM DR 06/29/16 56338 RES $ 856,828 $ 306,080 35.72 LAMBERT ELISE/STEPHEN 17 0156 LL0528 0.80 198 IMP 00833 MORRIS ARUTHUR J 3344 PEACHTREE RD 01/15/16 55774 RES $ 1,674,419 $ 621,960 37.14 LAMENTATIONS 32224 LLC 17 0062 LL9415 0.07 287 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 40 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 00727 GURIS MICHAEL P 1089 LIBERTY PKWY~221~17 01/07/16 55765 RES $ 188,253 $ 53,240 28.28 LAN GUANGHUI/TONG ZHAOHUI 17 0221 LL0982 0.02 454 IMP 10966 BROWN IAN 924 GARRETT ST~12~14 05/02/16 56119 RES $ 153,583 $ 47,970 31.23 LANDAZABAL DAVID SAENZ 14 001200062510 0.02 688 IMP 18252 EAH-LONG ISLAND ASSOCIATES LLC 1015 PRESWYCK WAY 06/28/16 56349 RES $ 776,180 $ 237,000 30.53 LANDES BARRY 17 012500040588~LOT 8 0.21 500 IMP 05217 RISHER DIANA 10900 WITTENRIDGE DR~915 & 916 & 03/10/16 55938 RES $ 148,912 $ 46,000 30.89 LANDON JENIFER CHRISTINE 12 313009151277 0.03 689 IMP 17075 KANE JEFFREY MARK 12051 ORCHID LN 06/15/16 56312 RES $ 382,994 $ 120,840 31.55 LANDRY KEVIN/KETAILY RICHARD 22 482412701223 0.05 568 IMP 06565 GEORGIA REAL ESTATE WHOLESALER LLC 3777 CROSBY DR 03/09/16 55993 RES $ 21,970 $ 6,390 29.09 LANG MATHEW 14F001600020781 0.27 77 IMP 17026 WHITE JR AND CHERYL W JAMES G 363 MILLEDGE AVE~44~14TH 06/24/16 56323 RES $ 376,022 $ 90,840 24.16 LANGAN CHRISTOPHER 14 004400071232 0.23 145 IMP 06094 LINMAN JEREMY 136 PEACHTREE MEMORIAL DR~111~17 03/16/16 55959 RES $ 194,875 $ 71,840 36.86 LANGFORD MARY ANN 17 011100120352~UNIT 8 BUILDING I 0.03 526 IMP 13100 LORD MICHAEL G 2660 PEACHTREE RD 05/20/16 56204 RES $ 730,784 $ 290,840 39.80 LANIER ELIZABETH G/LANIER DAVID P 17 011200141530 0.07 422 IMP 07735 CAMPE LEE R 2537 PAUL AVE~253~17TH 03/31/16 56017 RES $ 153,339 $ 62,040 40.46 LARK JAMES D 17 025300011294~LOT 1 0.23 439 IMP 02993 PELLEGRIN JOCELYN G 71 MADDOX DR~55~17TH 02/08/16 55847 RES $ 186,220 $ 53,160 28.55 LASKER TERRENCE 17 005500140028~LOT 2, BL. A, UNIT 2 0.02 193 IMP 11688 WALKER ZACHARY 706 CHARLES ALLEN DR 05/06/16 56158 RES $ 129,301 $ 38,600 29.85 LASSITER LARRY M 14 004800100912 0.01 205 IMP 10287 HODGE-DOLPHIN TYRENE F 1655 ABBOT LN 04/21/16 56084 RES $ 273,436 $ 91,120 33.32 LATZKO STEFAN ANDREW 17 022400031199 0.10 87 IMP 10129 BENJAMIN MARK WOOTEN AND EMILY 12610 CONCORD HALL DR 04/25/16 56099 RES $ 244,931 $ 85,680 34.98 LAUER TESSIE A/LAUER MICHAEL A 21 572111250241 0.21 534 IMP 01137 AREA 14 REAL ESTATE MGT INC A DOMESTIC 1085 BEACON HILL XING~1053~2ND 01/20/16 55804 RES $ 469,057 $ 145,640 31.05 LAVI ASAF 21 564010531631~LOT 62 0.28 410 IMP 16511 PHELPS TERRELL 6516 RAYMOND DR 06/27/16 56339 RES $ 75,036 $ 20,440 27.24 LAWAL MOHAMMED 09F161500760256 0.55 407 IMP 14189 FREEMAN FREDERICK CHARLES 325 LUM CROWE RD 05/25/16 56218 RES $ 651,249 $ 250,760 38.50 LAWRENCE SCOTT/LAWRENCE KIMBERLY R 22 325010070220 1.44 323 IMP 02183 CREER MARK 110 SADDLEBROOK CT~397~1 02/01/16 55821 RES $ 337,957 $ 134,970 39.94 LAWSON SARA ANDREWS/LAWSON JOEL 12 185203970300~LOT 2 BLK B 0.74 1 IMP 03910 ABRAMS EILEEN L 7012 RICHLAND CT 02/29/16 55906 RES $ 192,229 $ 61,560 32.02 LAWWILL MICHAEL/LAWWILL JOYCE 12 217105450204 0.03 632 IMP 14491 BARRINGTON NIKKI J 1101 COLLIER RD 05/31/16 56246 RES $ 143,640 $ 48,640 33.86 LAYER KELSEY DIANE 17 018600010819 0.02 397 IMP 17768 MORNINGSIDE ROAD PROPERTY LLC 1158 VIRGINIA AVE NE 06/24/16 56332 RES $ 1,150,184 $ 366,760 31.89 LAYSON III HOMER FRANKLIN/PATRICIA 17 000100110166 0.19 97 IMP 03401 CHANDLER-WYANT PROPERTIES LP ET AL 100 LUCKIE ST ST~78~14 02/26/16 55888 COM $ 937,777 $ 349,470 37.27 LAZ/LA III ATLANTA LLC 14 007800120921 0.17 327 IMP 10366 JEFFREY C TUCKER AND THERESA A 4755 HUNTLEY DRIVE NE 04/26/16 56096 RES $ 592,034 $ 218,440 36.90 LAZARUS JOANNA/ROTHSTEIN JOSHUA D 17 006600050711 0.44 209 IMP 12851 FERGUSON PEARL W 724 SUMMIT NORTH DR~47 AND 48~17 05/06/16 56178 RES $ 88,493 $ 32,640 36.88 LE TRACEY TRAN 17 004800051209~UNIT 724 PIEDMONT 0.02 147 IMP 14791 JAMES DEBBIE Y 350 STONECASTLE PASS 05/18/16 56239 RES $ 227,190 $ 86,400 38.03 LEACH ROBERT/LEACH TIFFANY 14F0092 LL1268~L 9 0.42 391 IMP 08769 STEVENS JAMES M 4810 REBEL TRL 04/08/16 56044 RES $ 764,742 $ 233,880 30.58 LEAL RAYMOND L/LEAL ANN S 17 0163 LL0701 1.43 130 IMP 06677 STEPHEN KLEIN AS TRUSTEE OF THE 2007 700 PARK REGENCY PL 03/16/16 55992 RES $ 570,366 $ 180,960 31.73 LEBOW JEFFREY ALBERT 17 0044 LL1860 0.04 334 IMP 04628 KATERGARIS GEORGE A 11530 CROSSINGTON RD~313~1ST 02/25/16 55893 RES $ 303,591 $ 109,180 35.96 LECKWOLD DAVID J 11 076003131031~LOT 158 0.24 578 IMP 03971 FOSTER SAMUEL L 600 BRICKWORKS CIR 02/29/16 55899 RES $ 230,579 $ 91,880 39.85 LEE BONNIE R 14 001900080895 0.02 517 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 41 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 00139 ANDREW MARONEK AND KRISTIN BRAU N/K/A 14350 CREEK CLUB DR 01/14/16 55774 RES $ 545,292 $ 178,960 32.82 LEE COURTNEY HITE/LEE GEORGE P 22 539107540099 0.57 371 IMP 01405 MERLIN ADAM G 2277 PEACHTREE RD 01/15/16 55808 RES $ 247,596 $ 68,000 27.46 LEE DAIVD CHIAN 17 011100070367 0.03 148 IMP 11260 NOONAN MARK F 960 LANCASTER WALK 04/26/16 56119 RES $ 572,639 $ 152,560 26.64 LEE DANIEL JIN 17 0123 LL1823 0.30 335 IMP 13663 MICHAELS MARILYN J 370 CARYBELL LN 05/24/16 56219 RES $ 330,388 $ 113,000 34.20 LEE EDWARD ROBERT 22 386112090581 0.22 388 IMP 17574 CHEN JING 2921 LENOX RD # 408 06/01/16 56343 RES $ 148,484 $ 47,400 31.92 LEE HYUN SIL 17 0007 LL2152~UN 408 0.02 203 IMP 19382 CRESPO GABRIELA I 3670 RIVER TRACE DR 06/29/16 56377 RES $ 237,995 $ 95,960 40.32 LEE JUNGAE 11 008100310010 0.19 414 IMP 12778 KOO MIN 3324 PEACHTREE RD~62~17TH 05/13/16 56184 RES $ 173,359 $ 75,880 43.77 LEE KIHUN 17 0062 LL3954 0.02 296 IMP 14301 CHANG BOK SOO 11110 SKYWAY DR~360~1ST 05/11/16 56222 RES $ 237,570 $ 89,920 37.85 LEE KYUNG LIM/LEE JU KYUNG 11 090003604459 0.02 571 IMP 06190 HUNTER KENDALL 03/11/16 55968 RES $ 60,096 $ 13,360 22.23 LEEFOON TRISTAN/DELILLE MYLANDE 14F002500020426 0.25 368 IMP 09758 BALL DAN L 6711 SUNNY BROOK LN~87~17 04/22/16 56102 RES $ 245,455 $ 83,680 34.09 LEFKO PROPERTIES LLC 17 008700010165~LOT 2 SUNNY BROOK 0.50 580 IMP 03615 EDGE JEFFERSON 6220 ABERDEEN DR~36~17TH 02/11/16 55867 RES $ 437,850 $ 129,560 29.59 LEGACY CUSTOM HOMES LLC 17 003600010258~LOT 14, BLOCK E, 0.62 55 IMP 08496 HARRISON JEFFREY M 390 17TH ST 04/08/16 56042 RES $ 240,414 $ 79,040 32.88 LEHMAN JOHN/LEHMAN CHARLES 17 0148 LL5312 0.03 485 IMP 18571 BALLARD NATHAN 11580 WINDBROOKE WAY 06/30/16 56356 RES $ 314,448 $ 116,800 37.14 LEHNERTZ ELIZABETH/DIAMOND JUSTIN R 11 064202741172 0.28 408 IMP 00778 PRIEBE MATTHEW 01/15/16 55782 RES $ 277,419 $ 90,160 32.50 LEIBOVITZ ADAM 11 045501920468 0.16 21 IMP 06213 PIERCE CARLA L 4906 THE LAKES DR 03/10/16 55957 RES $ 181,367 $ 65,920 36.35 LEMIEUX III NELSON R 07 140001076735 0.31 351 IMP 18935 SMITH ANTHONY F 15230 SANDPOINT TRCE~540~2 06/24/16 56393 RES $ 346,825 $ 144,520 41.67 LEONCIO LISANDRA 22 536105400201~20 0.70 646 IMP 06492 CONNELLY RYAN J 390 17TH ST~148~17TH 03/22/16 55978 RES $ 239,505 $ 74,720 31.20 LEU TUNG LIN 17 0148 LL7086 0.03 505 IMP 18392 OLLEY CAROL R 7155 ROSWELL RD~74~17TH 06/23/16 56347 RES $ 281,562 $ 106,640 37.87 LEVENSON ALIZA 17 007400060389~THE WYNGATE AT 0.05 651 IMP 15271 WOODLEY ARTHUR T 1735 PEACHTREE ST 03/31/16 56252 RES $ 251,176 $ 99,200 39.49 LEVERETTE CASSANDRA TURNER/TURNER 17 010900181010 0.04 42 IMP 05355 FLORES MARCOS 75 WESLEY RD 03/15/16 55956 RES $ 274,917 $ 103,560 37.67 LEVIT JEFFREY 17 010100010258 0.02 354 IMP 10450 WORTHAN LISA J 6802 GLENRIDGE D DR 04/12/16 56095 RES $ 86,287 $ 24,120 27.95 LEVY ALISARA 17 0034 LL1136 0.02 535 IMP 03945 E-CHUN HUSSEIN AKA E-CHUN TAI HUSSEIN 3475 OAK VALLEY RD~45~17TH 03/04/16 55923 RES $ 301,308 $ 106,520 35.35 LEVY AVIKAM 17 004500051624 0.03 40 IMP 19326 LYNCH JINJURA J 5464 JAMERSON DR 06/01/16 56394 RES $ 206,978 $ 87,000 42.03 LEWIS GENO G 09F400001616454 0.33 403 IMP 09444 GEORGE SHARON 5035 LARKSPUR LN 04/22/16 56097 RES $ 87,993 $ 29,440 33.46 LHF 4 ASSETS LLC 09F340001504427 0.16 67 IMP 03550 WELLS TARA ANNE 11175 ABBOTTS STATION DR~320~1ST 02/22/16 55887 RES $ 197,014 $ 76,040 38.60 LI SHUAI 11 089103200085 0.24 347 IMP 07261 STUART P CONRAD AND MARGARET K 1220 TROON CT~1186 & 1235~2ND 03/31/16 55995 RES $ 3,005,640 $ 1,047,680 34.86 LIANG KAJHOU 21 566111860389~97 1.43 106 IMP 14133 O'SHAUGHNESSY SEAN D 3020 GADSDEN ST 05/24/16 56210 RES $ 515,948 $ 213,520 41.38 LIBBY BUDD O/LIBBY RENEE L 12 287008101329 0.12 497 IMP 01145 PAUL DAVID M 821 RALPH MCGILL BLVD~18~14 01/22/16 55803 RES $ 145,953 $ 43,400 29.74 LIEVANO LUIS NUNEZ 14 001800101395~3204 0.01 68 IMP 04981 CAMPBELL ALISHA B 11770 LEEWARD WALK CIRCLE 03/10/16 55935 RES $ 278,732 $ 92,120 33.05 LILES JASON/LILES KERI W 21 574312560584 0.23 24 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 42 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 04846 ADEOYA AKINWUMI 835 CLIFTON SPRINGS CLOSE 02/26/16 55895 RES $ 264,859 $ 101,240 38.22 LILLEY ALYCE/CHAMBERS JR MARK 14F0124 LL1732 0.22 184 IMP 15206 COOK JENNIFER A 659 AUBURN AVENUE 06/02/16 56253 RES $ 246,393 $ 75,280 30.55 LIN JAMES/LINVILLE LESLIE A 14 001900101873 0.02 488 IMP 15071 WADDELL ASHLEY S 1505 LIBERTY PKWY 06/07/16 56268 RES $ 180,086 $ 57,800 32.10 LIN LIU QIANG 17 0221 LL3481 0.02 13 IMP 10786 HYE KYUNG OH AND BYUNG HO AHN 5280 TAYLOR RD 04/20/16 56110 RES $ 222,615 $ 73,000 32.79 LIN MING QIANG/LIN MEI QIN 11 057502400622 0.22 33 IMP 05817 HAWKINS JAMES W 658 PARK VILLAGE DR~16~14TH 03/11/16 55945 RES $ 209,859 $ 63,000 30.02 LINDBERG MIKKO/WELLS LAUREN 14 001600210180~UNIT 658 0.02 125 IMP 16858 KALVAPALLE RAVI 12973 DARTMORE CIR 06/15/16 56295 RES $ 329,464 $ 130,440 39.59 LINGAREDDY DHANUNJAYA 21 568010541201~34 0.16 218 IMP 10580 PERICH BRENT 709 CARRIAGE DRIVE 05/03/16 56122 RES $ 379,547 $ 118,120 31.12 LINUS JAMES C 17 007200030228 0.75 315 IMP 04657 ESPINOSA SANDRA 180 WING MILL RD 02/25/16 55907 RES $ 534,898 $ 166,680 31.16 LIPMAN MERRICK/TOURIAL ROBERT 17 002900020280 0.54 647 IMP 01938 CAPLAN JANICE 905 JUNIPER ST~49~14TH 01/29/16 55825 RES $ 1,393,817 $ 388,440 27.87 LIPTON RICHARD J/FARLEY KATHRYN T 14 004900021364 0.07 130 IMP 15952 RHYS THOMAS 05/12/16 56278 RES $ 547,844 $ 142,480 26.01 LISA MCCLESKEY/CHARLES MCCLESKEY 06 036800010275 0.74 359 IMP 10617 KUEHNERT NANCY A 211 APPLE LANE 04/29/16 56127 RES $ 442,016 $ 173,480 39.25 LISSO MARK 11 024201220222 0.28 550 IMP 04267 SALADNA BETTY I 336 QUAIL RUN~615, 616 AND 617 02/29/16 55901 RES $ 69,683 $ 23,600 33.87 LITOW MICHAEL R 12 242606160334 0.02 629 IMP 05286 SALOMON ANA 1150 COLLIER RD 03/07/16 55927 RES $ 58,349 $ 20,440 35.03 LITSEY JEAN R 17 018600012849 0.01 345 IMP 00489 MILLMAN ELLIOT 230 TAWNEYWOOD WAY 01/06/16 55752 RES $ 323,930 $ 115,600 35.69 LITZELL BRUCE H/LITZELL ROBIN H 12 316109200597 0.69 568 IMP 12709 BRYANT DAVID T 4885 CAMBERBRIDGE DR~186~1ST 05/09/16 56168 RES $ 228,762 $ 84,200 36.81 LIU ANNA 11 048301860405 0.21 82 IMP 09533 CHATURVEDI PERRY 860 CROFT COURT 04/08/16 56095 RES $ 385,411 $ 129,560 33.62 LIU ZHIQIANG/ZHANG MENGYAO 11 031001090481 0.79 133 IMP 00109 MEIER JEFFREY W 01/06/16 55750 RES $ 1,192,560 $ 466,320 39.10 LIZARDI IGNACIO 22 391104480162 4.28 360 IMP 18651 REIF WILLIAM C 330 SHADY RIVER TRCE~626~1ST 06/30/16 56350 RES $ 264,242 $ 97,360 36.85 LOGA-JAEHNIG VICTORIA 12 256406260045~504A 0.28 561 IMP 17909 GRISWOLD JR JOEL F 1053 FAITH AVE 06/07/16 56295 RES $ 209,205 $ 68,760 32.87 LONG JOHN MARTIN 14 001200070083 0.16 534 IMP 16869 BYERS NEDRA 540 KENDEMERE POINTE 06/15/16 56295 RES $ 407,933 $ 173,240 42.47 LONG JR RICHARD W/BRENDA 12 187004073250 0.06 47 IMP 08414 HALLMAX HOLDINGS LLC 923 PEACHTREE STREET~106~17 04/12/16 56052 RES $ 250,931 $ 67,280 26.81 LONG KEVIN J 17 010600084118 0.02 575 IMP 05675 JOANNE OLSON COLE 3208 LONG INDIAN CREEK CT 03/14/16 55952 RES $ 188,958 $ 65,920 34.89 LOPEZ ROSARIO YANEZ/LOPEZ EMILIANO 12 315209000097 0.32 64 IMP 11001 SCHOMMER MARY ELIZABETH 208 WELLWOOD CT 04/28/16 56113 RES $ 322,803 $ 105,240 32.60 LOPIANO LINDA M 12 188004080329 0.05 446 IMP 17201 HAMBY DANIEL PAUL 45 MOUNT VERNON CIR 06/17/16 56309 RES $ 196,550 $ 68,840 35.02 LORET DE MOLA DENNISE E 17 0020 LL1447 0.03 258 IMP 18870 EVANS III ALFRED L 1810 GREYSTONE RD~146 & 147~17 06/24/16 56360 RES $ 504,312 $ 164,320 32.58 LORINC AMANDA M/JOHN S 17 014600070200~L 20 BL K 0.37 666 IMP 16877 ALEMOZAFFAR MEHRDAD 1080 PEACHTREE ST~106~17TH 06/14/16 56294 RES $ 289,597 $ 111,990 38.67 LOTT JR MARCUS BLAKE 17 010600052446~UN 1816 0.02 120 IMP 13789 KIM JOSEPH W 18 ARPEGE WAY 05/20/16 56216 RES $ 158,866 $ 43,800 27.57 LOUDERMILK GRANT HARRIS 17 018500060187 0.03 253 IMP 16949 MEKELBURG PHILIP J 3874 STRATFORD PARK DRIVE 06/24/16 56334 RES $ 1,110,370 $ 562,520 50.66 LOUIE MICHAEL/ALISON G 17 004400021115 0.42 650 IMP 21243 KAPIOLANI EAST PROPERTY MGT 510 VALLEY ROAD NW 06/20/16 56460 RES $ 1,308,902 $ 440,000 33.62 LOUIS SCHWARTZ 17 0140 LL1657 2.24 118 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 43 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 16935 PERCHIK SHERRY M 20 ASHEWORTH CT~181~17 06/24/16 56331 RES $ 1,074,980 $ 394,200 36.67 LOVE IV JAMES S 17 018100070123~LOT 12 0.55 158 IMP 03657 SCHMITT TODD D 3127 LENOX RD 02/17/16 55874 RES $ 499,060 $ 186,600 37.39 LOVELY PERRY L/HURST CHRISTOPHER 17 000800080420 0.06 689 IMP 13078 REID KENNETH B 684 PELHAM RD 05/13/16 56173 RES $ 967,160 $ 352,000 36.40 LOWE MICHAEL C/BLANCHARD KAREN A 17 005100010126 0.37 617 IMP 10811 BLAND WILLIAM R 230 THOMPSON SPRINGS DR 04/29/16 56108 RES $ 498,604 $ 175,560 35.21 LOWERY JOHN 22 504105360155 1.00 382 IMP 01026 KIM WONSUCK 77 PEACHTREE PL 01/22/16 55799 RES $ 796,333 $ 197,040 24.74 LOWLEY MICHAEL STEVEN/MARTINEZ RODEA 17 010600100948 0.06 246 IMP 04081 CAMPBELL RICHARD 28 PLANTATION DR 02/26/16 55917 RES $ 244,442 $ 79,960 32.71 LUBARSKY ANATOLY/EUGENE/LILIA 17 000800120069 0.04 126 IMP 09643 U S BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS 7535 THOREAU CIR 03/08/16 56087 RES $ 259,998 $ 100,960 38.83 LUMA KELSON 14F0162 LL0349 0.77 75 IMP 12166 HALE ROBERT 3338 PEACHTREE ROAD NE, UNIT 3204 05/11/16 56156 RES $ 267,815 $ 118,080 44.09 LUND JEFFREY 17 0062 LL3061 0.03 24 IMP 11846 LAFOUNTAINE JENNIFER LEE 03/25/16 56148 RES $ 266,401 $ 87,200 32.73 LUPO ANGELO/LUPO VILMA 17 0211 LL4192 0.03 261 IMP 13924 GRAFF MICHAEL A 1022 EULALIA RD 05/24/16 56208 RES $ 1,221,982 $ 346,840 28.38 LUSK CHRISTOPHER/LUSK SARAH 17 000900010178 0.41 106 IMP 12213 KWAN LEE AND SEONG LEE 12500 PRESERVE LN 05/09/16 56155 RES $ 393,471 $ 143,440 36.46 LUTHRA SANJAY 21 578111620556 0.39 577 IMP 18768 JONES RENEE S 200 RIVER VISTA DR 06/30/16 56348 RES $ 268,646 $ 87,200 32.46 LUTZ LJ PAUL 17 0211 LL4788~UN 733 0.03 554 IMP 03970 PATTERSON SHAUN M 878 PEACHTREE ST~49~14 02/24/16 55894 RES $ 221,821 $ 68,080 30.69 LYBBERT RANDY JOSEPH/CASEY BLACK 14 004900010367 0.02 401 IMP 12651 FARRIS MICHAEL ANTHONY 1242 WOODLAND AVE~9~14TH 05/16/16 56185 RES $ 341,415 $ 97,760 28.63 LYLE CAROL ANN 14 000900010092 0.20 38 IMP 00385 JARVIS GEORGE D 12355 EDENWILDE DR 01/04/16 55754 RES $ 484,042 $ 181,240 37.44 LYNCH JEFFREY WAYNE/WENDY SUE MILLER 22 373012120775 0.35 424 IMP 15195 ODUMEGWU-OJUKWU EBELE 6520 ROSWELL RD~88~17 06/03/16 56265 RES $ 91,656 $ 32,560 35.52 LYNN AMANDA M 17 008800060565 0.03 682 IMP 40546 425 CROSSVILLE SU 103 RD COM $ 93,001 $ 30,600 32.90 M C N ENTERPRISES INC 12 198504480051 0.02 IMP 02068 BROE THOMAS M 3430 AUBUSSON TRCE~18 01/29/16 55827 RES $ 431,887 $ 152,120 35.22 MA SANSAN A/MAUNG AUNG T 11 009300180153~L 18 GLASTONBERRY 0.43 574 IMP 12665 WHITE GRACE M 2630 ROXBURGH DR~759~1 05/06/16 56172 RES $ 408,076 $ 152,680 37.41 MACHENHEIMER CHARLES 12 275107590229~34 0.96 193 IMP 00132 NAVARRO DANIEL A 2076 OLD GEORGIAN TER~256~17 01/13/16 55771 RES $ 345,746 $ 126,600 36.62 MADNANI ARCHANA 17 0256 LL1475 0.22 227 IMP 06288 BENNETT JR RICHARD B 250 PHARR RD 03/11/16 55958 RES $ 208,809 $ 76,200 36.49 MADURA ERIN DINNEGAN/MADURA RYAN C 17 009900072468 0.02 203 IMP 17819 TOTTEN ERIC 563 MEMORIAL DR~44~14TH 06/20/16 56303 RES $ 141,983 $ 54,880 38.65 MAESTRE RUBEN D 14 004400031202~OAKLAND PARK 0.02 60 IMP 06015 BERKSHIRE ENTERPRISES LLC 732 HILLPINE DR 03/17/16 55959 RES $ 712,464 $ 235,440 33.05 MAESTRI ANAYI Z/KACZOR JR JOSEPH F 17 005200050436 0.22 157 IMP 06397 PATTERSON ALICE E 878 PEACHTREE STREET NE UNIT 03/18/16 55965 RES $ 142,869 $ 45,970 32.18 MAGISTRO CALEB C 14 004900010490 0.01 614 IMP 17221 LIPSCOMB AUBREY C 1006 DREWRY ST 06/24/16 56335 RES $ 890,862 $ 274,280 30.79 MAHER CILLIAN M/LYONS AOIFE 14 001600010333 0.21 191 IMP 14492 CHRISTOPHER KIM 1240 TUSCANY COURT~1131~2ND 06/01/16 56241 RES $ 309,567 $ 91,920 29.69 MAI-LI DONG 22 432013110860~6 0.42 326 IMP 17855 RUFFIN RANDALL R 9525 KINGSTON CROSSING 06/24/16 56326 RES $ 373,368 $ 145,840 39.06 MAITRA APARAJITA/MAITRA KINSUK KUMAR 11 062102120356~18, B, PHASE ONE 0.45 375 IMP 12712 CRUMBLEY REBECCA EULA 05/11/16 56169 RES $ 193,711 $ 70,760 36.53 MAKORI ALBERT/OLEMUSA WINNIE 07 140001075570 0.19 463 IMP 00296 CALDAS JOSE M 971 PROSPECT AVENUE SE~10~14 01/14/16 55777 RES $ 327,175 $ 101,000 30.87 MALCOLM JR ANDREW LAW/MALCOLM 14 001000060474 0.22 210 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 44 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 04085 METZ SUKENICK CLAUDETTE L METZ NKA 1284 PIEDMONT AVE~55~17 02/29/16 55904 RES $ 115,338 $ 39,440 34.20 MALESEVIC ALEKSANDRA 17 005500090033~UNIT 3 0.01 669 IMP 18545 ELKHOURY USAMA 06/27/16 56347 RES $ 339,871 $ 103,280 30.39 MALHOTRA AMOL 11 062002130323 1.16 153 IMP 07239 HAUGEN KATHLEEN 115 ROSE PETAL LN 03/25/16 55987 RES $ 285,294 $ 104,400 36.59 MALIK MOBASHAR/HAYAT QANITA 11 008400320214 0.18 442 IMP 06013 STATHAM ZACHARY SUTTON 136 PEACHTREE MEMORIA DR 03/16/16 55961 RES $ 178,715 $ 57,040 31.92 MALING VINCENT 17 011100110437 0.03 433 IMP 07307 HOPE MARY ANN W 1480 NORTHCLIFF TRCE~619~FIRST 03/28/16 55989 RES $ 386,510 $ 153,440 39.70 MALLOY SHANEY/MALLOY PETE 12 244406190438~166 0.59 281 IMP 05727 FULLER JANE 6105 BLUE STONE RD 03/15/16 55953 RES $ 243,525 $ 94,320 38.73 MALONE BARBARA 17 008900081396 0.03 685 IMP 12694 GROFF CATHY R 10650 NELLIE BROOKE CT 05/18/16 56189 RES $ 890,940 $ 257,440 28.90 MALONEY MATTHEW C 11 127104760028 3.16 569 IMP 15794 STEVENS LAUREN M 195 14TH ST~106~17TH 06/08/16 56275 RES $ 183,535 $ 68,360 37.25 MANDAWAT ADITYA 17 010600330180~406 0.02 82 IMP 12858 RACHEL L DRISKELL AKA RACHEL L 810 DEVENISH LN 05/11/16 56164 RES $ 401,129 $ 145,120 36.18 MANN THOMAS M/MANN TAMMY M 22 359112860345 0.30 670 IMP 14005 BEAVER MARK A 400 SEVENTEENTH ST 05/23/16 56206 RES $ 140,404 $ 44,480 31.68 MANNING MICHAEL J/MANNING LINDA G 17 0148 LL1857 0.02 541 IMP 07361 LANGDON ADRIENNE SYDNEY 1354 DUPONT PARK~229~17 03/28/16 55989 RES $ 348,708 $ 114,400 32.81 MARCANTONIO GWEN E 17 0229 LL4176 0.08 1 IMP 11219 HARRISON JOSEPH N 3614 FAIRBURN PL~16~14TH FF 04/28/16 56113 RES $ 27,669 $ 10,040 36.29 MARCHEL JOHN EDWARD 14F001600060084~10-D 0.23 51 IMP 06035 PELTON DONALD 11855 HARDSCRABBLE TRL 03/22/16 55976 RES $ 298,198 $ 123,520 41.42 MARCHMAN MARCIA 12 174103600035 0.73 378 IMP 17717 COX ANDREW T 694 CHANNING DR~153~17 06/17/16 56311 RES $ 381,983 $ 138,360 36.22 MAREK DONALD C/MAREK LESLIE L 17 015300140433 0.27 129 IMP 05003 LEAH A REED AND JASON REED 1125 OLIVINE DRIVE~201~1ST 03/01/16 55924 RES $ 294,870 $ 99,880 33.87 MARGARET AMY QUICK/DAVID JOHN QUICK 11 056402010457~95 A 0.21 564 IMP 06336 WATSON CODY ALAN 855 PEACHTREE ST 03/17/16 55965 RES $ 273,586 $ 95,980 35.08 MARK NATHANIEL 14 004900024475 0.02 42 IMP 20705 TATGENHORST RICHARD T 215 DAPPLEGATE WAY 06/29/16 56432 RES $ 475,991 $ 186,280 39.14 MARKOTT TARA/MARKOTT DOUGLAS 11 071302470362 0.56 692 IMP 14428 CARPENTIERI NICK C 1008 GLENWOOD AVENUE SE~12~14 05/27/16 56232 RES $ 320,635 $ 105,640 32.95 MARQUEZ JENNIFER 14 001200070356 0.14 216 IMP 07764 CELECIA MARGARET B 720 LORIDANS DR~42~17TH 03/25/16 56010 RES $ 387,320 $ 189,960 49.04 MARSH RANDY D/MARSH ASHLEY L 17 004200050074~LORIDANS CHASE 0.43 693 IMP 08942 GANDHI CHHAYA J 390 EAGLES PASS 03/25/16 56069 RES $ 422,746 $ 160,520 37.97 MARSHALL DWAYNE A/ONLEY KIMBERLY D 22 537006121219 0.60 89 IMP 15627 DRAA JEREMY BRYAN 1965 NOCTURNE DR 06/09/16 56266 RES $ 147,615 $ 42,390 28.72 MARSHALL LINDSEY 12 260006891332 0.03 12 IMP 18951 LINKAS GROUP LLC 610 SABLE VIEW LN~97~13 06/17/16 56394 RES $ 98,720 $ 31,040 31.44 MARSHALL NICHOLE/MARSHALL PATRICK 13 0096 LL2070~376 0.18 60 IMP 15194 FORD KURT A 1761 MOORES MILL RD~220~17TH 06/09/16 56265 RES $ 390,956 $ 126,640 32.39 MARTELLO AZUMI/MARTELLO MICHAEL 17 022000010072~LOT 10, BL. B 0.31 321 IMP 10937 HAROLD WILLMAN AND SHARI K WILLMAN 155 RIDGE POINT CLOSE~570~12 04/28/16 56116 RES $ 312,657 $ 94,400 30.19 MARTIN DARYL L/TILLI KATHARINE D 12 232205700523 0.41 70 IMP 08281 GRIFFIN E ERIN 657 HANSELL ST 04/14/16 56058 RES $ 417,784 $ 114,720 27.46 MARTIN GUNNAR-WILLIS BRISTOL/MARTIN 14 002100070223 0.16 96 IMP 02405 CHAMBERS SARAH 410 THORNWYCK TRL 02/12/16 55862 RES $ 646,607 $ 147,980 22.89 MARTIN PATRICIA/MARTIN TRAVIS 12 268207161009 0.72 367 IMP 14431 KINKAID DARRELL R 505 CLUBFIELD DR~315~1 05/31/16 56246 RES $ 472,705 $ 219,120 46.35 MARTIN STEPHANIE L/MARTIN CHRISTOPHER 12 164203150437~3, J 0.51 437 IMP 06530 WIRT LILLIAN BROWN 1130 PIEDMONT AVE~106~17TH 03/24/16 55984 RES $ 282,657 $ 99,960 35.36 MARTIN SUSAN W/MARTIN II MICHAEL S 17 010600280302 0.03 530 IMP 08371 DYE ROBERT H 420 CHIMNEY BLF 04/13/16 56055 RES $ 170,587 $ 79,160 46.40 MARTIN TRAVIS 12 308108770886 0.25 119 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 45 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 00616 LI FUXIN 3530 PIEDMONT RD 01/08/16 55759 RES $ 152,295 $ 50,000 32.83 MARTIN-CARTER VINCENT 17 009800060191 0.03 382 IMP 16375 KATZ BYRON 964 WOODLAND AVE~10~14 06/21/16 56338 RES $ 311,687 $ 101,520 32.57 MARTS LUCIAN/FOLEY MARTS MEGAN 14 001000040278 0.20 550 IMP 18205 CARMEN M BENOIT AKA CARMEN BENOIT 751 PIEDMONT AVENUE NE UNIT 06/16/16 56357 RES $ 291,038 $ 72,800 25.01 MASON ROBERT WESLEY/MASON JOANNA 14 004900280168 0.01 96 IMP 10119 CRADER EDWARD GALEN 2170 MAIN ST~253~17TH 04/25/16 56106 RES $ 210,271 $ 78,720 37.44 MASSAR TODD A/MASSAR JANET M 17 025300050060~LOT 2 0.14 313 IMP 07311 ZAMOR HELGA 35 LA RUE PLACE PL 03/28/16 56006 RES $ 173,458 $ 46,280 26.68 MASSEY CATHERINE A/MASSEY ANDREW J 17 018500040353 0.03 458 IMP 05377 SUN TRUST BANK 361 17TH ST~108/148~17TH 03/10/16 55948 RES $ 228,140 $ 57,280 25.11 MASTROGIOVANNI ANDREI 17 010800013818 0.02 424 IMP 15606 STANFORD AARON L 2817 ELKMONT RDG 06/07/16 56266 RES $ 155,000 $ 65,760 42.43 MASUKIDI MATONDO G/KAGARABI 09C130000541071 0.27 198 IMP 16908 LEVINE ABRAHAM R 3265 MATHIESON DR~61~17 06/22/16 56323 RES $ 385,442 $ 167,800 43.53 MATHEWS GREGORY/KOCHENSPARGER 17 006100010298 0.34 26 IMP 15029 MERLEY MAGIC LLC A GEORGIA LIMITED 5564 FESTIVAL AVE 06/03/16 56264 RES $ 81,771 $ 24,760 30.28 MATHIS ANTHONY L 09F070000265213 0.03 215 IMP 06673 STEADHAM GLENDA 4985 BUTNER RD~144~14FF 03/15/16 56007 RES $ 66,589 $ 39,840 59.83 MATHIS ROBERT N 14F0144 LL1076 1.16 130 IMP 01605 ARAGUEL PATRICK J JR 31 PLANTATION DR~7 & 8~17 01/19/16 55794 RES $ 217,392 $ 77,480 35.64 MATINFAR MAJID 17 000800120119~UNIT 31 B 0.04 675 IMP 03279 GEORGIA PROPERTY MANAGEMENT GROUP 1393 KNOB HILL CT 02/16/16 55874 RES $ 244,851 $ 58,280 23.80 MATOL DANA E 14 0009 LL1316 0.14 699 IMP 01901 AUGSBURGER RUDOLPH 1080 PEACHTREE ST 01/29/16 55827 RES $ 809,788 $ 222,240 27.44 MATTEI JORGE L/MATTEI STACY 17 010600053691 0.04 403 IMP 18583 JAY DOUG 06/29/16 56367 RES $ 154,256 $ 47,480 30.78 MATTHEWS REBEKAH A 14 001700080970 0.01 437 IMP 10724 WEDDERBURN TANISHA 2884 CHILHOWEE DR 04/25/16 56116 RES $ 143,262 $ 63,200 44.12 MATTHEWS SHANNON D 14F0152 LL0317 0.22 146 IMP 17403 GUICHARD JR LAWRENCE J 12290 LEEWARD WALK 06/23/16 56324 RES $ 323,177 $ 114,160 35.32 MATTOX LEIGH/MATTOX DANIEL 21 574212310395~31, C 0.90 62 IMP 06169 KIRKLEY-SHANKS VIVIA 824 MCWILLIAMS ROAD~27~14TH 03/23/16 55974 RES $ 17,974 $ 6,880 38.28 MAX INNOVATIONS LLC 14 002700020347~2 0.25 334 IMP 00678 DAYANI RABIN 5324 NORTHLAND DR 01/14/16 55772 RES $ 1,427,672 $ 517,720 36.26 MAXWELL JOSEPH/MAXWELL MARGARITA 17 006800030133 1.00 139 IMP 17129 OWENS JERROD L 125 GARDINIA CT CT 06/15/16 56338 RES $ 158,453 $ 65,640 41.43 MAXWELL SUSAN G 09F120000421272 0.28 60 IMP 15939 HSBC BANK USA NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS 7275 MADISON CIR 06/14/16 56287 RES $ 133,612 $ 73,480 54.99 MAYES-MORELAND ANITA 09F120000371998 0.21 265 IMP 08962 ROBERT M HAYS TRUSTEE OF THE HAYS 1575 HARVEST LN~1246~2 04/15/16 56069 RES $ 470,081 $ 150,120 31.93 MAYUGA ONOFRE L 22 434012460908~68 0.32 130 IMP 11552 TRENT RYAN SHEETS AND HEATHER R 1751 SPRINGER ST~152~17 05/04/16 56152 RES $ 390,295 $ 106,880 27.38 MAZEROLLE II ALLEN PATRICK/POOLE SARAH 17 015200010751~57 0.11 211 IMP 04521 TUNSTALL CHARLES L 2163 BUTNER RD 02/26/16 55912 RES $ 18,396 $ 9,400 51.10 MC2 PROPERTIES PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 14F003200030178 0.22 521 IMP 18356 ALLEYNE EDWIN/CARMEN COREY/L 14103 VOYAGE TRL~828~2 06/27/16 56372 RES $ 220,695 $ 84,360 38.22 MCCAIN DENNIS D 22 540008282203 0.02 296 IMP 17616 ROLISON JOHN C 6101 PARK AVE 06/14/16 56296 RES $ 118,103 $ 40,280 34.11 MCCALL JESSE C 17 009300080806 0.03 358 IMP 11653 DENNY STEVE A 878 PEACHTREE ST~49~14 04/25/16 56153 RES $ 131,246 $ 44,680 34.04 MCCARNEY DANIEL A 14 004900011175 0.01 492 IMP 09866 HELLER GREGORY J 2035 NORTHWICK PASS WAY 04/15/16 56101 RES $ 851,732 $ 242,680 28.49 MCCARTHY BRIAN J/MCCARTHY ERIN W 11 021400640069 0.50 518 IMP 03675 SCHAEFFER WILLIAM D 708 LONGLEAF DR 02/22/16 55882 RES $ 724,317 $ 289,680 39.99 MCCARTY TODD C 17 004400030751 0.08 408 IMP 08550 TOTH ANDREW G 1032 SASHA LN~410~1 04/06/16 56039 RES $ 172,368 $ 51,920 30.12 MCCLAIN EMMETT W/MCCLAIN PATRICIA D 12 189704100300~1032 0.03 599 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 46 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 09140 WLODAR F/K/A ANGELA JONES ANGELA 115 PEACHTREE MEMORIAL DR~111~17 04/15/16 56068 RES $ 191,756 $ 81,800 42.66 MCCLAIN REBECCA JEAN 17 011100020644 0.02 357 IMP 09263 MILLER GARY J 4915 WEXFORD TRL TRL~109~9F 04/15/16 56069 RES $ 129,389 $ 33,880 26.18 MCCLOUD BRENT 09F270101091753~LOT 101 0.23 574 IMP 10901 HOLCOMBE ROBERT R 04/29/16 56125 RES $ 179,719 $ 69,040 38.42 MCCLURE KAREN D/MCCLURE JR JAMES G 22 375003750262 3.24 312 IMP 07324 HINNER CRAIG LEE 1420 KINGFIELD DR~1164~2ND 03/31/16 56005 RES $ 235,183 $ 85,600 36.40 MCCREADIE DINA E/MCCREADIE JR ROBERT L 21 572111640433~43 0.29 697 IMP 16660 MCLARRY JASON D 826 WILSON RD~154~17TH 06/14/16 56291 RES $ 720,205 $ 184,920 25.68 MCCUTCHEON ROY BATES/MCCUTCHEON 17 015400020725~LOT 2, BL. 1 0.25 631 IMP 07166 POPHLI SUSHANT 2904 COMMONWEALTH CIR 03/25/16 55989 RES $ 203,367 $ 66,720 32.81 MCDEARMON BRIAN/MCDEARMON KATE 22 527010411565 0.04 506 IMP 12734 KIRKPATRICK GEORGE G 3180 WESTON PL~182~17TH 05/16/16 56183 RES $ 650,965 $ 206,120 31.66 MCDONALD JOANNA B/MCDONALD JOE H 17 018200070395~LOT 20 0.15 306 IMP 14738 KOSSMAN MATTHEW 1101 JUNIPER ST 723 05/27/16 56232 RES $ 240,137 $ 88,840 37.00 MCDOWELL MICHAEL/MCDOWELL MARGIE 17 010600066636~UN 723 0.03 372 IMP 13587 DAVIS F/K/A RACHEL BARRON-SIMPSON 821 RALPH MCGILL BLVD~18~14TH 05/25/16 56213 RES $ 208,943 $ 63,760 30.52 MCDOWELL REBECCA DAWN/SCHOONMAKER 14 001800101247 0.02 591 IMP 07442 CONLEY LARISSA J 200 SOFTWOOD CIR 04/04/16 56031 RES $ 225,144 $ 66,760 29.65 MCELROY RYAN M 12 242406150188 0.27 135 IMP 09418 FLOODY JAMES H 12900 OLD COURSE DR 04/16/16 56081 RES $ 331,150 $ 134,360 40.57 MCELYEA BROOKS/MCELYEA BRANDI 22 326110800706 0.95 394 IMP 14794 LOCKHARD LOUIS LANARK 926 DREWRY ST 05/31/16 56236 RES $ 616,885 $ 180,000 29.18 MCGLYNN ALEXANDER B/MCGLYNN TINA 14 001600010499 0.19 412 IMP 00714 PROVIDENCE LUXURY HOMES LLC 305 GARDEN TER~181~1 01/11/16 55758 RES $ 764,929 $ 188,320 24.62 MCGOWAN DENNIS DAVID P/KIMBERLY MARIE 11 051001810613 0.62 487 IMP 06006 JASON L BRINKMAN AND KRISTINA G 508 SHADOW HAWK 03/16/16 55958 RES $ 579,872 $ 205,120 35.37 MCGRATH MEGAN/MCGRATH SEAN 22 451001930709 1.58 645 IMP 18466 JENKINS DONNA G 908 MARGARET ST~98~14 06/17/16 56365 RES $ 173,427 $ 52,440 30.24 MCGUIRE RICHARD/MCGUIRE DODI D 14 012700020528~10 0.09 211 IMP 16844 SCHROEDER BARBARA J 5415 HILLGATE XING 06/15/16 56334 RES $ 293,035 $ 98,360 33.57 MCGUIRE-SNELSON STACEY/SNELSON 11 065202700852 0.24 256 IMP 20550 TI GEORGIA HOLDINGS LLC 1467 WESTRIDGE RD 06/06/16 56430 RES $ 41,244 $ 10,280 24.92 MCKENZIE HASONE 14 016900080463 0.30 460 IMP 03914 MORTON BRAD A 1035 CHELSEY WAY 02/29/16 55917 RES $ 422,808 $ 126,720 29.97 MCKINNEY MICHAEL D/VANDENBERG SHELLY 12 221005290751 0.42 106 IMP 17064 TREFFERS-HERRERA TAMIRA S 633 LONGWOOD DR~154~17 06/28/16 56338 RES $ 961,514 $ 288,000 29.95 MCLARRY JASON D 17 015400060200~LOT 35 0.37 181 IMP 15857 MORROW JAMES P 120 SAINT DEVON CT 06/10/16 56279 RES $ 379,493 $ 115,360 30.40 MCLAUGHLIN JOHN/MCLAUGHLIN ALECIA 11 117204400450 0.29 444 IMP 18043 LAWRENCE ASHLEY N 912 LENOX HILL CT 06/30/16 56352 RES $ 275,692 $ 104,120 37.77 MCLENDON ROBERT E/NANCY R 17 000700090073 0.06 629 IMP 04436 FITTS JR SAMUEL P 730 BIRCH RIDGE DR 02/26/16 55902 RES $ 303,384 $ 107,400 35.40 MCLEOD THOMAS S/MCLEOD BROOKE J 12 223105510609 0.35 597 IMP 12236 BURNETT GERALD 2006 VILLAGE GREEN CIR 04/29/16 56139 RES $ 423,952 $ 144,480 34.08 MCLOUGHLIN DAVID M 12 154002483618 0.04 333 IMP 04076 RHYS LYNNE S 395 PHARR RD~60~17TH 02/24/16 55891 RES $ 84,388 $ 27,360 32.42 MCMILLAN IV JOHN LUCIUS 17 006000090069 0.02 691 IMP 00630 PERFORMANCE VIEW LLC 2023 WELLS DR 01/08/16 55765 RES $ 34,839 $ 17,280 49.60 MCMILLAN RAMONA 14 019900040255 0.25 375 IMP 00824 BRIZENDINE MICHELLE 8001 WOODLAND LN 01/15/16 55784 RES $ 155,553 $ 51,320 32.99 MCMILLIAN JANICE/MCMILLIAN WILLIAM 22 530012640785 0.03 578 IMP 17166 YEAGER RUSSELL R 640 BRANTLEY RD~24~17TH 06/28/16 56339 RES $ 149,551 $ 48,720 32.58 MCMINN DON 17 002400050266~26 0.06 478 IMP 16344 SCHMIDT CALLY 923 PEACHTREE ST 06/20/16 56313 RES $ 215,636 $ 73,320 34.00 MCMINN JR PAUL JAVIS 17 010600085420 0.02 527 IMP 06124 PULTE HOME CORPORATION 125 AUSTIN DR~36~17 03/17/16 55963 RES $ 594,200 $ 217,560 36.61 MCQUARY MARY GERALYN 17 003600020745~27 0.17 52 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 47 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 13324 HOOKS BETTYE N 2388 CREEL RD~156~13TH 05/20/16 56197 RES $ 126,185 $ 40,560 32.14 MCSHED ROSALIND G 13 0156 LL1285~43 0.15 152 IMP 15199 DUNCAN JOHN C 5320 MOUNT VERNON PKWY 05/10/16 56267 RES $ 562,351 $ 237,160 42.17 MEAD GAVIN 17 016400010088 0.76 1 IMP 07834 HINKLE MELANI 6980 ROSWELL RD~74~17 04/05/16 56031 RES $ 161,240 $ 37,240 23.10 MEADOWS HALEY A 17 0074 LL3240 0.03 424 IMP 16081 FRANCOIS JR PETRUS P 125 NORTH RIVER DR 06/14/16 56288 RES $ 125,679 $ 40,840 32.50 MEDRANO BRIANDA CABRERA 06 0367 LL1193 0.03 541 IMP 16018 AJOKU CHUKWUMA 8806 SENECA RD~163~7TH 06/14/16 56287 RES $ 84,678 $ 24,560 29.00 MEGLIANI FABIO/RUIZ SARAI QUESADA 07 400001632055~147 0.09 551 IMP 16972 ENGLISH MICHAEL EVERETT 2425 COGBURN RIDGE RD~1110~2ND 06/15/16 56290 RES $ 285,019 $ 99,920 35.06 MEHRPARVAR MAZIAR/POURKHOSROW 22 496111100149~14 0.17 388 IMP 15422 MARTHA MESSINA AND ANTHONY MESSINA 11770 RED MAPLE FOREST DR 06/07/16 56264 RES $ 219,508 $ 88,720 40.42 MEJIA RAJINI/MEJIA MICHAEL 11 064102340620 0.24 220 IMP 15233 HOPKINS WALTER H 4024 SHELDON DR 05/12/16 56273 RES $ 410,883 $ 202,080 49.18 MEKNOJIA KOMAL 17 009600050541 0.65 272 IMP 06505 REYES LUZ 3100 FORREST PARK RD 03/24/16 55978 RES $ 61,447 $ 16,600 27.02 MELCHOR MARIA D 14 000300020188 0.54 575 IMP 00838 CARRASQUERO-ANZOLA CARLOS 3075 BERKSHIRE MANOR DR 01/15/16 55780 RES $ 188,248 $ 67,400 35.80 MENDEZ JAVIER 12 302308660187~2 A 0.24 570 IMP 13792 CHANG IRIS 3481 LAKESIDE DR 05/20/16 56223 RES $ 152,057 $ 51,760 34.04 MENG YANZI 17 000900041926 0.02 439 IMP 04912 DAVID BARRETT RITTER AND YING-JU HUANG 8930 CARROLL MANOR DR~367 03/09/16 55931 RES $ 176,238 $ 69,160 39.24 MENN BRYANT Y 06 036700031769 0.12 1 IMP 40563 2091 CAMPBELLTON SW RD COM $ 271,368 $ 99,280 36.59 MERRITT WILLIAM 14 0168 LL1719 0.61 IMP 12591 BROUSTEIN ALEXANDER 293 PROSPECT PLACE NE 05/17/16 56178 RES $ 523,124 $ 130,680 24.98 MEYER TIMOTHY 14 004600030608 0.18 358 IMP 10170 MUSOLF GRANT 2575 FORREST AVENUE NW~253~17 04/20/16 56088 RES $ 174,845 $ 60,960 34.87 MEZQUITA JARED 17 025300070381 0.23 599 IMP 05804 GRAY BRUCE DOUGLAS 652 HOBART AVE~23~14TH 03/16/16 55955 RES $ 167,307 $ 60,240 36.01 MICHAUD BOBBY/NEALE A/K/A TRACY SOO- 14 002300090740 0.22 436 IMP 13655 BOBBITT II JOHN A AND EMILY C 145 HIGHLAND GLEN CT 05/17/16 56212 RES $ 277,483 $ 94,960 34.22 MICHELLE ILYSSA WEINBLATT AND ARCH 21 574312560196 0.28 69 IMP 13664 NORRIS PATRICK 220 SEMEL CIRCLE 05/23/16 56225 RES $ 241,857 $ 83,800 34.65 MIDIDODDI ANIRUDHA 17 0147 LL1312 0.01 533 IMP 15372 CHOWDHURY ROLAN 1598 OLYMPIAN CIRCLE SW~150~14TH 06/03/16 56261 RES $ 44,929 $ 14,040 31.25 MIGHTY GAIN LLC 14 015000090265 0.28 37 IMP 10027 ASA HOME MANAGEMENT LLC 211 OLLIE STREET 04/04/16 56071 RES $ 29,269 $ 15,480 52.89 MIKAEL PROPERTIES LLC 14 011500060494 0.11 448 IMP 07419 FERNANDEZ HENRY A 211 COLONIAL HOMES DR 04/01/16 56020 RES $ 305,524 $ 107,280 35.11 MILIOS SARADOS 17 011100051649 0.04 496 IMP 01974 MATTEY MARK K 2309 MELANTE DRIVE 01/29/16 55819 RES $ 297,413 $ 103,320 34.74 MILLER JASON 17 000500020304 0.23 269 IMP 17641 SCHAEFFER KEVIN C 195 14TH STREET NE~106~17TH 06/24/16 56330 RES $ 283,034 $ 96,720 34.17 MILLER JOHNNIE R 17 010600330446~UNIT 608 0.03 272 IMP 06372 MUCKLOW NEAL M 220 RENAISSANCE PKWY~50~14 03/15/16 55972 RES $ 133,178 $ 45,000 33.79 MILLER KEVIN 14 005000140012 0.02 578 IMP 17066 QUIGLEY CAROL PUTNAM 4995 BETHLEHEM RD~112~7 06/27/16 56335 RES $ 225,109 $ 53,080 23.58 MILLER MARISA S 07 040001110528 4.04 133 IMP 06803 TRUITT AKA MARGARET M BENNETT 10250 BRIER MILL CT~113~1ST 03/25/16 55986 RES $ 546,027 $ 173,120 31.71 MILLER SARAH RENEE/MILLER MICHAEL J 11 029201130172~17/B 0.40 43 IMP 04318 GLENN III ROBERT B 787 MARTINA DR 02/26/16 55897 RES $ 575,080 $ 195,000 33.91 MILLS JEAN FRASER 17 004600060079 0.16 663 IMP 10356 LINCOLN BROWN AND KATHIA BROWN AND 633 PROVIDENCE PL 04/22/16 56082 RES $ 81,185 $ 46,360 57.10 MILLS JOYCE WHITE 14 0245 LL0619 0.01 510 IMP 01725 D R HORTON-CROWN LLC 5685 CASA BLANCA LN~107~14FF 01/22/16 55834 RES $ 394,727 $ 141,080 35.74 MINES-CARLTON JOHANNA 14F0107 LL2475~3 0.55 121 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 48 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 04925 BAHAR SHIRAZI NKA SARA SHIRAZI HARPER 855 PEACHTREE ST 03/07/16 55927 RES $ 286,005 $ 99,040 34.63 MINHAS HUDA 14 004900022826 0.02 264 IMP 01891 KITCHENS JAMES R 361 17TH ST~108 & 148~17TH 01/29/16 55825 RES $ 166,865 $ 80,000 47.94 MINICORP ATLANTA LLC 17 010800012836 0.02 150 IMP 00249 KIM EDWARD M 10890 CARRISSA TRL 01/15/16 55784 RES $ 527,591 $ 185,840 35.22 MINNATH SHAHAR AL/ALI HAFEES 11 004000393644 0.21 112 IMP 16357 BERGER KATHY S 356 AUGUSTA AVE~43~14 06/20/16 56313 RES $ 372,704 $ 88,240 23.68 MINTON PATRICIA KING/MATTHEW KEVIN 14 004300040188 0.20 111 IMP 17824 STRICKLAND MARK 215 MASTERS VIEW CT~350 06/13/16 56300 RES $ 423,701 $ 130,480 30.80 MISRA AKHILESH 11 088103500247~LOT 24 BLOCK A 0.35 35 IMP 13000 ISAACS GLEN 2481 BAXTER RD 05/02/16 56255 RES $ 19,313 $ 7,600 39.35 MITCHELL ATLANTA PROPERTIES LLC 14 010100090901 0.21 507 IMP 10274 BUSH BRANDON J 455 GLEN IRIS DR~18~14 04/20/16 56084 RES $ 243,949 $ 72,760 29.83 MITCHELL MATTHEW W 14 001800051004 0.03 458 IMP 12026 PARAG ASHIL 2161 PEACHTREE RD~111~17TH 04/29/16 56142 RES $ 157,784 $ 61,080 38.71 MITRA SRIPARNA/MITRA BHASKAR 17 011100200154~UNIT 207, BRADFORD 0.03 124 IMP 01224 LATIMORE ROBIN 4415 GRANADA DRIVE~156~9TH 01/15/16 55789 RES $ 93,133 $ 35,640 38.27 MNSF ACQUSITIONS LLC 09F370501560108~LOT 10, BLK D, BON 0.75 272 IMP 01503 PAZTAL ATLANTA HOUSING LLC 01/20/16 55801 RES $ 72,087 $ 25,360 35.18 MNSF II ACQUISITIONS LLC 09F160000770229 0.41 96 IMP 04299 DISCOVERY ENTERPRISES LLC 401 FENNEL WAY SW 02/23/16 55923 RES $ 31,173 $ 13,600 43.63 MOHAMMED ISAAC 14F002500040457 0.21 121 IMP 06125 BORDERS NATHALIE 03/04/16 55960 RES $ 129,399 $ 41,880 32.36 MOLINA CINTHIA E 07 360400941111 0.39 509 IMP 10181 VAIL KATHY H 540 SADDLE CREEK DR 04/22/16 56092 RES $ 313,071 $ 113,880 36.38 MOMENI REBECCA/MOMENI KAMIAR 12 205104740204 1.00 73 IMP 07104 HENSON JAMES PATRICK 400 17TH STREET NW, UNIT 1411 03/25/16 55984 RES $ 288,128 $ 107,880 37.44 MOMIN RAZA I/MOMIN SAHEELRAZA S 17 0148 LL1659 0.03 272 IMP 11663 MOFO MANAGEMENT LLC 12220 CHARLOTTE DR 04/29/16 56142 RES $ 299,531 $ 169,840 56.70 MONDOK KRISTY K 22 418012440226 1.12 295 IMP 13652 WHINERY LUCY TARALYNN 210 MOSS STONE WAY 05/23/16 56211 RES $ 405,812 $ 174,720 43.05 MONTICUP KRISTYN 12 135500410260 0.45 308 IMP 01928 LAWLEY VIRGINIA RUIZ 1286 DANNER ST~9~14TH 01/29/16 55819 RES $ 245,390 $ 65,360 26.64 MOORE DAVID L/MOORE PAIGE H 14 000900030157~14 BL C 0.17 325 IMP 08765 HOUSER BARBARA R 5480 HUNTERS FOREST LN 03/31/16 56046 RES $ 91,157 $ 23,240 25.49 MOORE JORRION 13 009200060261 0.34 481 IMP 03482 ATLANTA HOMES 4 RENT INC 1055 MAPLE VALLEY CT 02/16/16 55877 RES $ 69,334 $ 23,480 33.87 MOORE KELSEY E/ADAMS STEVE H 09F110100541392 0.07 449 IMP 05701 ERIC C SIMONTIS AND KATHLEEN SIMONTIS 3335 SUGAR VALLEY TRL 03/14/16 55948 RES $ 571,061 $ 162,480 28.45 MOORE MARK N/MOORE LISA A 11 005400090623 0.34 658 IMP 02905 DAVID E KAPLAN AND MARCIA P KAPLAN 253 ALBERTA DRIVE NE 02/16/16 55865 RES $ 543,036 $ 155,840 28.70 MOORE ROBERT B H 17 009800020351 0.59 517 IMP 13963 MOBLEY JR WILLIAM R 3471 LENARDO DR 05/23/16 56218 RES $ 89,224 $ 19,920 22.33 MOORE SR COREY BOUVIER 14 025000020550 0.30 19 IMP 15228 NATALIE CHRISTINE LAMBERT 3212 PEMBROKE CIRCLE, UNIT #3212 06/06/16 56264 RES $ 120,370 $ 36,760 30.54 MORAWSKI DEBRA/WALTER 22 543010432717 0.02 217 IMP 18451 LOY JAMES E 280 BENT GRASS DR~446~1 06/30/16 56359 RES $ 280,977 $ 67,840 24.14 MOREAU SHELLEY/MOREAU JOHN 12 197304460560 0.43 559 IMP 02701 FENSTER JEFFREY H 1150 HAMPTON WAY 02/11/16 55857 RES $ 201,411 $ 50,720 25.18 MORGAN BRIAN RUSSELL 17 000500011360 0.04 308 IMP 01836 SARAH HALE N/K/A SARAH BRADY 2 COLLIER RD~110~17 02/04/16 55835 RES $ 198,455 $ 62,680 31.58 MORGAN CHRISTOPHER 17 011000021254~UNIT 3 EXETER 0.02 402 IMP 00659 SIDDIQUI IMRAN A 422 HIGH CREEK TRCE 01/11/16 55762 RES $ 114,243 $ 38,280 33.51 MORGAN THAYS 12 228305630131 0.08 227 IMP 10084 RUBY Y EVANS AKA RUBY EVANS NKA RUBY 7446 SPOLETO LOOP~118~7TH 04/15/16 56080 RES $ 142,979 $ 39,560 27.67 MORLEY SABRINA/BREWINGTON NATASHA 07 150001184025~48 0.15 401 IMP 02475 AKHTAR ZAMEER 12030 LEEWARD WALK CIRCLE~1255~2 02/12/16 55856 RES $ 262,532 $ 102,480 39.04 MORRIS APRIL LATRICE 21 574312550056 0.21 477 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 49 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 14562 HERNANDEZ CANDIDA 958 OPELOUSAS WAY 05/31/16 56247 RES $ 362,476 $ 141,760 39.11 MORRIS HARRY W/MORRIS CHAUNTEL R 17 0022 LL2252 0.06 571 IMP 16851 DEFOOR CLAYTON E 191 MYSTIC CRSE~94~17TH 06/30/16 56343 RES $ 422,787 $ 181,720 42.98 MORRIS KENNETH R 17 009400020751~3 0.06 431 IMP 11881 PALM LORI 1055 PIEDMONT AVE 05/06/16 56162 RES $ 202,663 $ 82,040 40.48 MORRIS MATTHEW LEE 17 010600094026 0.02 451 IMP 06049 CHAUDHARI NEILAM ~221~17TH 03/14/16 55971 RES $ 186,578 $ 50,680 27.16 MORSE JASON 17 0221 LL1345 0.02 677 IMP 00217 TROTTA CYNTHIA 1735 SPRING AVE~156~14TH 01/12/16 55779 RES $ 52,219 $ 13,040 24.97 MORTON GEORGE A 14 015600040215 0.21 336 IMP 07062 KIM CHRIS 2728 WANDER LN~809~1ST 03/23/16 55985 RES $ 188,254 $ 65,920 35.02 MOSES KRISTIN 12 287008092072 0.03 383 IMP 10971 TOLAND JOSEPH J 2030 INDIAN RIDGE CT 05/02/16 56129 RES $ 170,137 $ 52,840 31.06 MOSHEFI HASSAN 12 315209000337 0.26 529 IMP 01278 TUNSTALL CHARLES L 154 LAWTON STREET SW~116~14TH 01/15/16 55805 RES $ 17,834 $ 8,000 44.86 MOSS AMBER/BAZEMORE JANAY 14 011600040644~LOT 6, BLOCK A 0.10 318 IMP 08009 MARYLAND ASSOCIATES LIMITED II 880 RENAISSANCE PKWY~50~14TH 03/28/16 56030 RES $ 164,974 $ 52,400 31.76 MOSS JOSHUA W/MOSS CAROLYN J 14 005000140517 0.02 541 IMP 14417 NOBELUS LLC 620 GLEN IRIS DR NE~48~14TH 06/07/16 56247 COM $ 835,007 $ 258,480 30.96 MR GLEN IRIS LLC 14 004800121736~UN C-1 0.07 594 IMP 01739 NORTHERN HOLDINGS LLC 11539 PARK WOODS CIR 01/29/16 55819 COM $ 165,630 $ 65,840 39.75 MSYS TECHNOLOGIES LLC 11 025000900906~UN 702 0.03 565 IMP 01103 WALDMAN BRUCE L 225 MEADOWLAND TRCE~897~1ST 01/29/16 55814 RES $ 193,368 $ 64,280 33.24 MUHOVIC MEVLUDIN/MUHOVIC SAMRA 12 317308970477~11 0.22 100 IMP 16762 CLEVELAND PAMELA J 755 BARSHAM WAY~351~1ST 06/17/16 56299 RES $ 240,129 $ 78,080 32.52 MUJUMDAR KISHAN/KISHAN PURNIMA 11 087103510461~46 CARRIAGE PARK 0.17 328 IMP 12321 SINCLAIR DEVIN S 805 PEACHTREE ST~49~14TH 05/12/16 56166 RES $ 205,442 $ 78,760 38.34 MULLANE PATRICK 14 004900290753~214 0.02 71 IMP 07792 SEGLER STEPHEN O 2720 WANDER LANE, UNIT # 11 04/06/16 56030 RES $ 201,408 $ 65,920 32.73 MULLINS JEREMY A 12 287008092031~. 0.03 433 IMP 00543 BURKE JOSEPH S 5655 CROSS GATE DR 01/06/16 55752 RES $ 1,689,419 $ 406,240 24.05 MUNNINGS VALERIE RENEE/MUNNINGS 17 012200050069 0.65 542 IMP 07676 GREENFIELD JASON T 3548 ARCHGATE CT 03/31/16 56022 RES $ 311,382 $ 96,800 31.09 MUNOZ JAIME SOLIS/DE SOLIS YADIRA 22 539007574248 0.09 475 IMP 01496 GREEN ARVELIA L 4648 RAVENWOOD LOOP~98~9F 01/26/16 55810 RES $ 83,266 $ 29,200 35.07 MUPR 3 ASSETS LLC 09F210000982413~211 0.09 68 IMP 10589 WARD JOSEPH R 3155 FERNCLIFF COMMONS 05/04/16 56130 RES $ 1,033,135 $ 369,520 35.77 MURNAHAN WILLIAM SHAWN/MURNAHAN 17 000800050449 0.42 638 IMP 02634 LOPEZ CARLOS 2479 PEACHTREE RD 02/11/16 55860 RES $ 112,868 $ 50,280 44.55 MURPHY MARGARET M 17 010100130932 0.02 188 IMP 08342 TAYLOR BRIAN 04/11/16 56047 RES $ 163,360 $ 65,040 39.81 MURRANS ELIZABETH 17 001800040414 0.04 233 IMP 03063 FARMER ANDREW 1080 PEACHTREE ST~106~17TH 02/05/16 55842 RES $ 282,339 $ 106,760 37.81 MURRAY KYLE T 17 010600050754~UNIT 806 0.02 66 IMP 13462 BAKER BRUCE A 14008 PORTSIDE BND~828~2ND 05/20/16 56200 RES $ 229,584 $ 68,600 29.88 MURTHY VIJAY SHRIRAM 22 540008282062 0.02 357 IMP 17036 BONILLA VICTOR L 400 17TH ST 06/22/16 56313 RES $ 157,721 $ 56,760 35.99 MUSIN ILDAR R 17 0148 LL2822 0.02 249 IMP 01707 DEININGER MARK A 675 SPRINGVIEW CT~709~1 01/29/16 55817 RES $ 261,095 $ 109,120 41.79 MYERS NICOLE L/ADELSBERGER KRISTEN 12 265107090585~72/A 0.33 343 IMP 12414 HARVEST ASSETS LLC 711 HUTCHENS ROAD~30~14TH 05/06/16 56183 RES $ 38,514 $ 15,120 39.26 MYLANDE DELILLE/TRISTAN LEEFOON 14 003000020110~2 0.23 580 IMP 12023 CROFUT STEVEN R 850 PIEDMONT AVENUE NE UNIT 1205 05/06/16 56144 RES $ 365,893 $ 94,480 25.82 MYRONIUK DARRELL 14 004900330088 0.04 192 IMP 08939 BRADLEY K WILLIAMS AND LAUREE L 355 DERBY RIDGE TRCE 03/18/16 56061 RES $ 327,506 $ 116,960 35.71 NAFE LAURA S 12 136200420088 0.51 384 IMP 18016 LAWSON RAISEAN 898 OAK ST 06/27/16 56364 RES $ 74,595 $ 32,600 43.70 NAGUIB FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP LLLP 14 0108 LL1522 0.02 507 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 50 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 04026 CARRINGTON MORTGAGE SERVICES LLC 6517 SNOWDEN DR 02/22/16 55918 RES $ 129,781 $ 66,040 50.89 NAJARIAN CAPITAL LLC 09F410001714241 0.20 106 IMP 12401 BANK OF AMERICA N A 3012 WASHINGTON RD 04/15/16 56165 RES $ 37,234 $ 9,000 24.17 NAJARIAN HOLDINGS LLC 14 016300160691 0.25 361 IMP 09396 ANDERSON PAUL L 240 RENAISSANCE PKWY~50~14 04/22/16 56095 RES $ 219,520 $ 66,240 30.17 NALLUSWAMI SRIDHAR 14 005000130518 0.03 319 IMP 13337 JENNINGS SARA 10900 WITTENRIDGFE DR 05/16/16 56199 RES $ 142,939 $ 46,000 32.18 NARAYANAMOORTHY BALASUBRAMANIAM 12 313009151327 0.03 669 IMP 12773 FISCHER GEORGE V 440 PARK CREEKQ WAY 05/16/16 56179 RES $ 482,533 $ 165,960 34.39 NARULA ANU C/NARULA CHAITANYA K 11 026200920884 0.38 443 IMP 05280 HON'S U S INVESTMENT INC 12175 LEEWARD WALK CIR 02/25/16 55933 RES $ 258,293 $ 107,160 41.49 NATASHA KULAGIN AND MAXIM KULAGIN 21 574212310122 0.25 317 IMP 40558 711 LEE SW ST COM $ 1,284,118 $ 505,720 39.38 NATIONS BANK OF GA 14 0107 LL0046 1.00 IMP 17987 MCAVOY JAMES 285 CENTENNIAL OLYMPIC PARK DR 06/23/16 56340 RES $ 389,583 $ 108,280 27.79 NAVEJA JUAN MARIA 14 007800031821 0.04 398 IMP 06844 AMERICAN IRA LLC FBO THOMAS ANDERSON 2215 BAKER RD 03/22/16 55990 RES $ 11,833 $ 7,040 59.49 NAXA HOME GROUP LLC 14 017800040250 0.21 689 IMP 04471 FOXDALE PROPERTIES LLC 987 BOLTON ROAD~268~17TH 02/26/16 55904 RES $ 22,152 $ 11,800 53.27 NAXA HOME GROUP LLC 17 026800010034~3 0.76 351 IMP 04418 WHITE TREE MUNICIPAL CAPITAL 214 LLC ~78 & 79~9 02/26/16 55911 RES $ 23,115 $ 5,580 24.14 NAZZ INVESTMENT GROUP USA LLC 09F150500780380~WINDHAM CREEK 3 IMP 12400 INNOVATE APPS INC 2002 WINGATE WY 04/22/16 56169 RES $ 60,206 $ 17,520 29.10 NEDLOUF YOUSSEF 17 002300031309 0.02 391 IMP 01307 JOHNSON KATHLEEN B 361 17TH ST~108 & 148~17TH 01/27/16 55806 RES $ 272,159 $ 108,920 40.02 NELSON ANN H 17 010800011978~UN 902 0.02 616 IMP 15600 THE HENRY HUDSON COMPANY 05/26/16 56265 RES $ 12,654 $ 7,080 55.95 NELSON JOEL LEE 14 017900060208 0.20 221 IMP 11361 GARDELLA MICHAEL 101 RIVER MILL CIR~417, 420 & 421~1ST 05/05/16 56135 RES $ 75,250 $ 21,920 29.13 NELSON LISINDA 12 202504210011~UNIT 101, BLDG 1 0.02 562 IMP 11687 DORDE DAVIDOV AND MARIJANA DAVIDOV 3095 COMMONWEALTH WAY~1041~2 05/12/16 56160 RES $ 194,485 $ 63,600 32.70 NELSON LORI D 22 527010411243~163, BLDG 31 0.04 454 IMP 08632 GERALD MASSEY AND KATHRYN GOODYEAR 615 LINWOOD AVE NE 04/08/16 56053 COM $ 558,021 $ 163,720 29.34 NEMETH WHITNEY A/NEMETH STEPHAN P 14 001600110729~L22 BK 31 0.22 46 IMP 09574 YANDLE CHRISTOPHER 2005 BROOKSTEAD CHASE~451~1ST 04/15/16 56078 RES $ 391,890 $ 145,360 37.09 NEU APRIL M/NEU JASON G 11 121104510269~55/A 0.29 439 IMP 17636 JORGE BERGALLO AND MARIA VICTORIA 606 PEMBER PT~30~17TH 05/20/16 56321 RES $ 231,490 $ 83,800 36.20 NEWBERRY SAMPHAO/GEUSS DANIEL 17 0077 LL0870~LOT 61 0.05 58 IMP 16917 FLAHERTY DANIEL J 1181 LAVISTA CIR 06/22/16 56323 RES $ 363,290 $ 123,880 34.10 NEWMAN KELLY ANNA 17 0005 LL2139 0.04 170 IMP 07228 TIMOTHY J REEDY AND LAURA A REEDY 110 WHITE COLUMNS DRIVE 03/31/16 56004 RES $ 682,972 $ 324,720 47.55 NEWTON HANS O/NEWTON STACY K 22 424105270744 1.02 295 IMP 07690 SMITH LARRY D 3111 ARBORWOODS DRIVE 04/04/16 56020 RES $ 323,644 $ 105,400 32.57 NICOLAS GREG/PRIDGEN ERIN 12 305508710512 0.41 257 IMP 05455 HOUSE BEVERLY R 84 POLO DR~56~17 03/07/16 55949 RES $ 1,597,417 $ 338,880 21.21 NICOSIA DARLENE J 17 005600090123 0.18 121 IMP 07576 NAVARRO KATIE H 03/31/16 56012 RES $ 122,295 $ 27,720 22.67 NICULAU CRISTINA 22 514612650220 0.21 411 IMP 01474 AHMAD JUAN CARLOS 4485 MARIENERS RDG~1118~2ND 01/21/16 55792 RES $ 370,061 $ 118,200 31.94 NIELSEN TIMOTHY/NIELSEN CHRISTINA 21 561011181242~30 0.21 684 IMP 06420 BRINSON JAMES DAVID 10 JOHNSON RD~226~17 03/11/16 55957 RES $ 19,078 $ 6,000 31.45 NIER MICHAEL 17 022600080053~LOTS 3&4 BLOCK A 0.14 605 IMP 14425 ELROD JAMES H 705 HUNTERHILL WAY 05/31/16 56236 RES $ 306,191 $ 99,880 32.62 NIMNICHT SHAWN/NIMNICHT SAMANTHA 12 170303020156 0.74 277 IMP 10110 MOOREHEAD MARK JOHN 751 GREENWWOD AVE 04/21/16 56078 RES $ 597,853 $ 241,320 40.36 NIST GREGORY STERLING 14 001700080061 0.17 621 IMP 09314 DOWDA BETTY W 404 BRIGHTON POINT 03/30/16 56071 RES $ 105,436 $ 48,800 46.28 NIXON JAMES/NIXON ANGEANETTE 17 0032 LL1278 0.03 212 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 51 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 15331 ELEVON PROPERTIES LLC 1050 LINAM AVENUE SE 05/20/16 56258 RES $ 90,781 $ 30,280 33.36 NNAYERE OKWANDU 14 005500070404 0.11 598 IMP 18569 ASIRIFI BERNARD 1100 HOWELL MILL RD 06/30/16 56352 RES $ 400,767 $ 141,400 35.28 NOGUERAS CORALI 17 0150 LL2561 0.03 352 IMP 17905 3700 PEACHTREE ROAD LLC FKA PEACHTREE 3722 PAIGE WAY~10~17TH 06/07/16 56311 RES $ 730,201 $ 302,960 41.49 NOLAN CHRISTOPHER P/NOLAN TRACY A 17 001000041832 0.02 450 IMP 09075 OLLMAN ROGER 2479 PEACHTREE RD 04/15/16 56068 RES $ 194,549 $ 71,120 36.56 NORMANN NATHALIE 17 010100132193 0.02 469 IMP 11645 ROSENBLATT MICHAELA M 7325 CARDIGAN CIR 05/16/16 56162 RES $ 118,357 $ 33,560 28.35 NORTAB LLC 17 007400040209 0.03 254 IMP 05579 TARATOOT BRADLY M 232 KINSEY CT~102~17 02/19/16 55951 RES $ 212,901 $ 128,200 60.22 NORTON EMILIE L 17 010200130436~PART OF LOT 5, E. L. 0.17 53 IMP 08140 BLACKMAN REBECCA 7008 RICHLAND CT~520 AND 545~1ST 03/30/16 56031 RES $ 207,012 $ 66,400 32.08 NUCE MICHAEL J/CHRISTINE 12 217105450188~UNIT 18 0.04 576 IMP 13762 VOLL ROBERT J 560 KEARNY STREET 05/20/16 56210 RES $ 590,074 $ 213,400 36.16 NUCOMPASS MOBILITY SERVICES INC 12 301208450178 0.46 518 IMP 04392 DIPIETRO LUCY 8270 HIGH HAMPTON CHASE~901~1ST 02/29/16 55900 RES $ 501,719 $ 156,360 31.16 NUNNELLEY DALE 12 314109010801~157C 0.41 76 IMP 14757 HAYES ALEXANDRA RICCHI 978 NORTH AVE~16~14 05/31/16 56235 RES $ 229,643 $ 57,600 25.08 NUTTALL SCOTT A 14 001600111214~UNIT 304 HIGHLAND 0.02 19 IMP 14985 ATKINSON E ANN 575 ORME CIR 06/03/16 56261 RES $ 673,940 $ 234,800 34.84 O'BANION JACQUELYN/O'BANION JR DENNIS 17 005400010404 0.18 131 IMP 05043 ROBERTSON JULIANA R 122 OLD IVY RD~97~17TH 03/08/16 55935 RES $ 1,218,745 $ 309,560 25.40 O'BRIEN JENNIFER C/O'BRIEN JR DUNCAN M 17 009700012961~UNIT 16 0.03 458 IMP 04021 SKELLY DANIEL F 1080 PEACHTREE ST 02/29/16 55899 RES $ 255,665 $ 110,240 43.12 O'BRIEN TIMOTHY 17 010600051786~UN 1414 0.02 539 IMP 19378 ABERNATHY MARK 613 RIVERLAWN CT 06/27/16 56373 RES $ 500,979 $ 187,980 37.52 O'CONNOR JOHN 17 0211 LL1297 0.03 146 IMP 13220 CAMPBELL CHRISTOPHER P 2051 FAIRHAVEN CIR~111~17 05/17/16 56197 RES $ 438,515 $ 156,400 35.67 O'MEARA JR GERARD J/O'MEARA III GERARD J 17 011100090050~LOT 5, BLOCK 10 0.35 408 IMP 01329 KNAPP STACY L 12629 LECOMA TRCE~1137~2 01/25/16 55803 RES $ 482,256 $ 181,040 37.54 O'NEAL CHANDLER BROOKE/MILLER 22 400011370638~10 0.20 168 IMP 17157 JORDAN ELMARIE 2594 WOODHAVEN CIR 06/27/16 56340 RES $ 74,154 $ 18,360 24.76 O'NEAL WILLIAM JOVAN 14 019700030936 0.31 290 IMP 15375 SOIFER LAWRENCE J 2108 MCFARLIN LN 05/31/16 56256 RES $ 399,850 $ 149,200 37.31 O'SHEA JOHN/O'SHEA ALICE F/SCOTT 22 400111350480 0.04 269 IMP 02679 ALLEN R KOLB AND JOANN Q KOLB 895 STARLIGHT DR 02/08/16 55854 RES $ 344,166 $ 164,360 47.76 OAK LANE HOLDINGS INC 17 004100040126 0.43 220 IMP 17596 DELUCA KARYN E 783 INMAN MEWS DR~19~14TH 06/14/16 56295 RES $ 320,883 $ 112,480 35.05 OCKERS SANDRA B 14 001900131060 0.03 683 IMP 12683 LEBLANC DANYLLE M 14007 POARTSIDE BND~828~2ND 05/12/16 56171 RES $ 210,007 $ 71,560 34.08 OFFEM WOFAI OJU 22 540008282187~WYNDHAM, LOT 3403, 0.02 549 IMP 01812 PHAM LILLY ANN 795 HAMMOND DR~37~17TH 01/29/16 55829 RES $ 80,979 $ 28,200 34.82 OG LLC 17 0037 LL1224~UNIT 611 0.01 57 IMP 08338 DIAZ JUDY E 5994 HORSESHOE LN~11 04/14/16 56058 RES $ 130,412 $ 28,400 21.78 OGHAEKOR EMMANUEL 09F010000113039~13 0.24 343 IMP 08800 GERALD M FURR AND JODI P FURR 3187 SAINT IVES COUNTRY CLUB PKWY 04/01/16 56051 RES $ 747,359 $ 232,560 31.12 OH SAE JAE 11 103203640619 0.53 183 IMP 10014 WILLIAMS NICOLE 1105 NORTHSHORE DR 04/18/16 56078 RES $ 311,174 $ 80,800 25.97 OHME MERETE A/JOHNSON CHAD A 12 232205700259 0.36 172 IMP 03566 GHG092 LLC 2200 SURREY TRL~92~13 02/09/16 55874 RES $ 97,432 $ 27,520 28.25 OKEKE BENJAMIN 13 009200021040~3408 0.28 345 IMP 09734 AMERICAN IRA LLC FBO THOMAS ANDERSON 6040 CARRIAGE CT~126~13 04/20/16 56084 RES $ 29,218 $ 16,000 54.76 OLAYIWOLA MITZI 13 012600010902~22 0.23 444 IMP 08745 TAYLOR KENNETH J 04/11/16 56047 RES $ 138,156 $ 54,720 39.61 OLDEN ALESSANDRA B 14 001600041478~UN 3 0.03 210 IMP 07612 STEPANOVA TATYANA 500 RIDGEMONT DR~709 & 710~1 03/21/16 56015 RES $ 312,615 $ 97,440 31.17 OLEYNICHENKO MAXYM 12 265107090569~12 BL C 0.33 535 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 52 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 07254 HILWAY GEORGE 03/30/16 56006 RES $ 89,432 $ 27,360 30.59 OLIVE MISTY VICTORIA 17 000600012474~UN 88 0.01 571 IMP 01141 MATTEI JORGE L 1080 PEACHTREE ST 01/25/16 55809 RES $ 526,544 $ 174,200 33.08 OLIVEIRA MARCELO J 17 010600050796~UN 810 0.03 216 IMP 08052 BANK OF AMERICA N A 952 PARSONS ST~116~14TH 03/30/16 56018 RES $ 14,121 $ 8,240 58.35 OLIVER YVONNE 14 011600050874~115 C 0.06 494 IMP 07868 TEAFORD JAMES H 280 STEEPLE POINT DR 04/01/16 56026 RES $ 817,864 $ 308,400 37.71 OLSON CHRISTINE M/BRIAN J 12 281707170099 0.86 633 IMP 10944 DENMON JASON M 500 FOURTH FAIRWAY DR 04/28/16 56115 RES $ 345,860 $ 114,120 33.00 OMLIE JR ROGER C 12 296207770156 0.39 28 IMP 17658 SELENE FINANCE LP 1101 CORDOVA ST~119~14TH 06/22/16 56314 RES $ 22,515 $ 9,880 43.88 ONEFATER MIKHAIL 14 011900031137~LOT 5 0.29 3 IMP 10227 MCCART WES 2104 ARLINGTON RD~4 & 5~17 04/22/16 56093 RES $ 370,498 $ 111,760 30.16 ONORATO SUZANNE 17 000500010727~7 0.30 66 IMP 16944 DEBRA PERRY SMSF LLC 06/24/16 56337 RES $ 66,268 $ 24,800 37.42 ORANGE ANNETTE M 13 0133 LL5441 0.05 226 IMP 13661 MCNEILL CALVIN R 1715 SPINNAKER DR~1183 & 1238~2ND 05/24/16 56207 RES $ 706,034 $ 258,360 36.59 OREN GIL/OREN MIRIAM COHEN 21 559212380233~PART OF LOT 10, 0.28 661 IMP 15465 ANNA LYNN HUGHES AND STEPHEN 410 BROOKHOLLOW LN 06/06/16 56263 RES $ 304,848 $ 112,080 36.77 ORLICK JOSHUA T/ORLICK JESSICA MELITO 11 036201560910 0.31 145 IMP 10674 GENSLER RICHARD A 445 PARK CREEK DR~89, 122~1 04/29/16 56137 RES $ 396,303 $ 135,400 34.17 ORMAN ROXANNE N/PORCH JR JAMES C 11 025100890387~38 0.27 291 IMP 09615 SHARI B MARTIN FKA SHARI B HARVEY 300 MORNING MIST WAY 04/27/16 56101 RES $ 358,798 $ 143,040 39.87 ORTEGA JONATHAN JAY/ORTEGA KRISTY JO 11 014400480552 0.29 520 IMP 00901 SATTLER MARY T 1040 WILLIAMS MILL RD 01/22/16 55798 RES $ 433,915 $ 117,520 27.08 ORVOLD THEODORE 14 001500020234 0.11 57 IMP 13609 HOGAN HOLDINGS LLC 3338 PEACHTREE RD~62~17 05/23/16 56213 RES $ 361,426 $ 115,080 31.84 OURAIKAT ALIENA 17 0062 LL1479 0.03 272 IMP 21428 TAYLOR TYRA 5156 ROSEWOOD PL 06/20/16 56447 RES $ 166,386 $ 61,440 36.93 OVERSTREET ROMEL 09F290001190737 0.21 462 IMP 18614 CURRIE ROBERT A 845 SPRING STREET NW 06/30/16 56350 RES $ 206,989 $ 86,200 41.64 OWENS SHAWN C/OWENS DAVID L/OWENS 14 008000031504 0.02 537 IMP 04459 GARRETT DAVID W 1130 MUIRFIELD CT 02/29/16 55908 RES $ 884,255 $ 324,760 36.73 OWENSBY JESSICA R/BEAL TRUMAN 21 566111850455 0.74 165 IMP 09109 FORD EDDIE 969 PARSONS ST 04/14/16 56067 RES $ 34,466 $ 17,080 49.56 PADABLA ASSETS LLC 14 011600050429 0.11 683 IMP 16730 THE ROSA B MILLER RESTATED REVOCABLE 490 HOUZE WAY~470~1ST 06/28/16 56334 RES $ 242,584 $ 73,920 30.47 PADGETT CAROLEANN 12 207004700361~LOT 4, EARL 0.76 554 IMP 16031 YU BRICE K 950 WEST PEACHTREE ST # 714 06/08/16 56282 RES $ 329,468 $ 112,400 34.12 PAETZHOLD MATTHEW G 17 010700061008 0.03 205 IMP 14091 MARTIN THOMAS S 115 MORNING PINE CT~1163~2ND 05/26/16 56221 RES $ 334,336 $ 112,600 33.68 PAGANI ALEJANDRO MIGUEL 21 575211630998~77 0.28 204 IMP 02768 SIAS TYRA 200 RIVER VISTA DR 02/12/16 55858 RES $ 227,625 $ 77,760 34.16 PAGE SARA M 17 0211 LL4705~UN 725 0.03 667 IMP 13469 HARDEN OTIS DOUGLAS 05/17/16 56199 RES $ 179,227 $ 54,760 30.55 PAI HUI LING 21 547009723004 0.03 619 IMP 11533 BRANCO ANDREA 1445 MONROE DR 04/28/16 56144 RES $ 213,050 $ 69,080 32.42 PALANI DINA/PALANI SEAN 17 0052 LL1661 0.02 215 IMP 19201 RAJAGOPALAN GOVINDARAJAN WESTWIND LN~1240~2 06/17/16 56394 RES $ 489,152 $ 199,880 40.86 PALLAMREDDY KRISHNAIAH 21 555012400312 0.29 310 IMP 15467 JONES JUDSON M 225 TRAILMORE CT 06/07/16 56267 RES $ 201,589 $ 62,480 30.99 PALMER DAVID 12 231305680312 0.24 327 IMP 08543 CHUNG YOUNG JIN 10497 HOLLIWELL CT 04/01/16 56035 RES $ 272,621 $ 103,080 37.81 PANJWANI RAZIA/PANJWANI RAFIQ R 11 091003441983 0.02 576 IMP 06581 KIM JEONG HOON 1228 LIBERTY PKWY~221~17 03/21/16 55980 RES $ 184,727 $ 50,680 27.44 PANKOW CHRISTOPHER M 17 0221 LL1881~UN 903 0.02 167 IMP 01738 CHAMPLIN ERIC P 1241 LAFAYETTE DR 01/29/16 55829 RES $ 336,430 $ 118,400 35.19 PANN ELIZABETH G 17 010500150027 0.03 34 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 53 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 02745 BACHTLE MICHELE 12155 LIMERIDGE CT~1240~2ND 02/09/16 55849 RES $ 399,470 $ 165,980 41.55 PARAJULI ARUNA/MUDVARI ANKIT 22 387012401811~25 0.24 528 IMP 00122 LAWSON DAVID 20 10TH ST 01/04/16 55748 RES $ 406,695 $ 147,280 36.21 PARIS MICHAEL W/GIBSON DAVID B 17 010700065090~UN 1101 0.03 575 IMP 08218 JONES EVAN GREGORY 645 STONESTILE TRCE~510~1 04/11/16 56050 RES $ 386,931 $ 144,360 37.31 PARK AROM J/PARK HANNA 11 132005100969~94 0.40 535 IMP 16133 MCMILLON ROBERT MICHAEL 135 PRO TER~350~1 05/06/16 56289 RES $ 337,007 $ 117,520 34.87 PARK SHEENA A/PARK JINHYUN 11 088103500122~LOT 12 / BLK A 0.35 119 IMP 07018 STUNTEBECK KATHERINE 284 LAKEMOORE DR~64/96~17TH 03/25/16 55985 RES $ 138,868 $ 47,640 34.31 PARKER KATHERINE E 17 009600080233 0.03 365 IMP 17851 LABATOS ANTHONY D 2220 WHITESTONE PL 06/17/16 56325 RES $ 136,073 $ 41,960 30.84 PARKER STEPHEN L 11 014000480556 0.03 386 IMP 06538 ROLLINS A/K/A STEPHANIE NORWOOD 290 HORSEMAN RUN~163~7TH 03/24/16 55983 RES $ 102,570 $ 24,880 24.26 PARKS MICHAEL 07 400001631842~LOT 126 0.16 388 IMP 06760 BOWERS M DAVID 7746 GEORGETOWN CHASE 03/28/16 55994 RES $ 589,192 $ 125,560 21.31 PARROTT LYNDA M/PARROTT JR BLAIR S 12 190303861235 0.06 259 IMP 00504 MARK H ZANG AND AMY W ZANG 120 MARSH GLEN PT~126~17TH 01/04/16 55763 RES $ 548,913 $ 147,040 26.79 PARSONS EBBIE/PARSONS AYANA 17 012600060247~LOT 33/PT OF LOT 0.45 475 IMP 04150 ANDREA C MILLER NKA ANDREA JAYARAMAN 02/29/16 55907 RES $ 134,464 $ 46,040 34.24 PARSONS MELISANDE 17 003200050209~UN 20 0.03 122 IMP 06416 PULTE HOME CORPORATION 2002 BLOSSOM HILL DR~1281~2ND 03/08/16 55959 RES $ 464,122 $ 188,960 40.71 PARSONS MICHAEL B 22 387012812272~30 0.33 321 IMP 07543 STIEMKE EDWARD G 256 UNDERWOOD DR~125~17TH 04/01/16 56020 RES $ 343,127 $ 88,000 25.65 PARTNER INVESTMENTS KA LLC 17 012500060107~LOT 11, BLOCK B 0.46 302 IMP 19424 WILSON PARKER HOMES OF RIVERTOWN 7599 BRAZOS TRL~119~7 06/28/16 56377 RES $ 221,413 $ 85,640 38.68 PASCHAL LATASHA 07 180001192199~58 0.38 41 IMP 07798 LGI HOMES-GEORGIA LLC 6522 SAINT MARK WAY~139~7 03/17/16 56022 RES $ 164,247 $ 71,080 43.28 PASCOE GARTH/BROWN PSYLANE TRUDI-ANN 07 150101390712~LOT 54 OF ST. 0.15 645 IMP 13091 GUPTA ASHIS S 5325 CHELSEN WOOD DR 05/16/16 56181 RES $ 819,396 $ 275,120 33.58 PASHA OMAR 11 073200190241~25 A 1.16 396 IMP 09756 BHARTI NEERGA 04/25/16 56095 RES $ 822,599 $ 323,720 39.35 PASSALACQUA NICHOLAS/PASSALACQUA 22 501003291151 0.38 448 IMP 12149 WHELCHEL MARY ELLEN 1270 EAMES GREEN~191~17TH 05/06/16 56151 RES $ 274,191 $ 90,880 33.14 PATE MICHAEL 17 019100071368~100 0.03 495 IMP 04845 ELLINGSON COLLIN 288 SAMPSON ST 02/26/16 55898 RES $ 613,990 $ 176,800 28.80 PATEL HEENA K/PATEL RONAK J 14 001900011031 0.11 209 IMP 10409 WU QINGXIN 11254 GATES TER 04/15/16 56081 RES $ 321,145 $ 102,360 31.87 PATEL HERMANT/PATEL HEJALKUMAR 11 113004060800 0.14 605 IMP 21389 BURGESS BRIG A 10530 HIGHGATE MANOR CT 06/20/16 56456 RES $ 550,183 $ 187,640 34.11 PATEL MANUSHI S/PATEL PRAFULCHANDRA 11 080003061289 0.31 441 IMP 17173 HILLSIDE AVENUE LLC 3032-4 STONE HOGAN RD SW RD 05/11/16 56296 COM $ 168,121 $ 72,000 42.83 PATEL PROPERTY VENTURES LLC 14 0227 LL0413~M&B 0.45 127 IMP 07647 LEVISON MICHAEL 855 PEACHTREE ST 03/29/16 56022 RES $ 221,382 $ 88,360 39.91 PATEL RAJESH 14 004900022909~UN 1704 0.02 597 IMP 10060 ABH REALTY LLC 45 IVAN ALLEN BLVD~79~14 04/26/16 56100 RES $ 406,389 $ 169,160 41.63 PATEL SANTOSH 14 007900110996 0.03 268 IMP 01177 HAAS KENNETH 270 BRUTON WAY~39~17TH 01/29/16 55814 RES $ 572,250 $ 175,160 30.61 PATEL SHALINI 17 003900020130~LOT 19, BLOCK B 1.19 19 IMP 15077 LEBOVITZ BRAD S 9605 AUTRY FALLS DR 06/02/16 56263 RES $ 740,528 $ 233,440 31.52 PATEL URVI/PATEL NIRAJ 11 031001092131 0.34 108 IMP 02764 JAMES S FERGUSON AND PAMELA J 211 BROOKE DRIVE~1251~2NF 02/08/16 55851 RES $ 201,820 $ 54,720 27.11 PATRICK B MORGAN/HEATHER M WEILER 22 482112510304~8 B 0.37 157 IMP 16124 MCDONALD KATHRYN REEVES 4382 SKYLAND DR~65~17TH 06/10/16 56288 RES $ 479,172 $ 179,360 37.43 PATRICK JENNIFER/PATRICK JOHN 17 006500080115~LOT 10, BLOCK D 0.66 412 IMP 14137 RICKS ROBERT S 1095 CHURCHILL LN 05/24/16 56208 RES $ 393,750 $ 148,640 37.75 PATRICK ROBERT A 12 137400350158 1.00 480 IMP 09291 COURVILLE LOUISE 5520 GLENRIDGE PARK~15 AND 04/18/16 56070 RES $ 334,396 $ 108,720 32.51 PATRONIS KRISA 17 0016 LL2557 0.02 582 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 54 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 20886 GONCALVES JOHN D 617 SPRING ST~95~14 06/03/16 56427 RES $ 51,444 $ 17,320 33.67 PATWARY MASUDUR 14 009500050051~6 0.24 156 IMP 02763 BEASLEY JOHN 15 HOLLY DOWNS CT 02/11/16 55859 RES $ 155,680 $ 65,120 41.83 PAUL BRIAN 17 010700080222 0.02 264 IMP 14802 SUSAN L ROECK F/K/A SUSAN L SEARLES 909 NATCHEZ TRCE~364~6 05/31/16 56251 RES $ 98,341 $ 25,640 26.07 PAUL MARGARET L 06 036400021367 0.03 210 IMP 11532 HOPKINS BELLE ANN 3187 BUCK WAY~1115~2 04/21/16 56147 RES $ 245,629 $ 84,560 34.43 PAVLUK TANYA M 22 544011150936~93 0.04 226 IMP 06399 HORTSMAN JOHN R 1024 PINE GROVE DR~1196~2 03/18/16 55972 RES $ 227,830 $ 80,720 35.43 PAXTON ALBERT S/O'GRADY JULIE 22 497511960413~8 & B 0.37 614 IMP 03596 ENGLISH BERNADETTE 5640 NORTH HILLBROOKE TRACE 02/19/16 55875 RES $ 303,868 $ 122,400 40.28 PAYMAN KOUROSH SABET 11 077102690463 0.36 385 IMP 17849 CLAY RUTTI A/K/A CLAYTON D RUTTI 250 PHARR ROAD NE, UNIT 1302 06/17/16 56312 RES $ 186,678 $ 74,520 39.92 PAYNE JAMES A 17 009900072146 0.02 633 IMP 12512 MCDOWELL ANTONIO 1388 LIBERTY PKWY 04/29/16 56173 RES $ 193,543 $ 57,800 29.86 PAYNE KYLE JAMES 17 0221 LL3390 0.02 264 IMP 18656 BEAMER DAVID J 13196 MARRYWOOD CT 06/30/16 56354 RES $ 196,420 $ 69,720 35.50 PEACOCK BENJAMIN JACOB 22 526009751759 0.04 38 IMP 14537 PLEMMONS GROUP LLC 330 BLAIR CT~398 & 399~2ND 06/02/16 56239 RES $ 821,063 $ 226,600 27.60 PEARSON JACQUELINE T 22 518003990392~LOT 42, PHASE 2A 1.00 208 IMP 06658 MEDLOCK SHARON 2233 PEACHTREE RD 03/14/16 56000 RES $ 594,955 $ 188,320 31.65 PEARSON SCOTT B/PEARSON PAMELA C 17 011100054171~UN 1005 0.04 508 IMP 40545 55 OAK ST COM $ 596,298 $ 215,280 36.10 PEEK COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES INC 12 191304140702 0.78 IMP 16749 BIRD BRYAN A 2254 LAVISTA CT~5~17TH 06/29/16 56343 RES $ 364,045 $ 120,920 33.22 PEELER ALFRED SCOTT 17 0005 LL2063~66 0.03 165 IMP 15344 TROUTT WILLIAM R 375 HIGHLAND AVE~46~14TH 05/31/16 56259 RES $ 140,488 $ 52,680 37.50 PENA CHRISTIAN 14 004600141058~UNIT 1016 0.02 415 IMP 09429 MALHOTRA JIGEESHA 860 PEACHTREE ST 04/15/16 56075 RES $ 212,700 $ 82,680 38.87 PENG YANG 14 004900014328 0.02 220 IMP 05788 FONTAINE NELSON M 570 TAMMANY PT 03/11/16 55943 RES $ 257,554 $ 98,600 38.28 PEPPERS ERICA/CLIFFORD J 22 495210510299 0.37 164 IMP 11269 HAYES THOMAS 3301 RILMAN RD~182~17TH 04/29/16 56124 RES $ 1,368,628 $ 541,840 39.59 PERCHIK JERROLD R 17 0182 LL1086 0.65 631 IMP 04777 BAYKAL DEMIR 3047 LENOX RD NE #2105 02/25/16 55907 RES $ 248,174 $ 88,360 35.60 PERCIVAL MIGNON MILES 17 000800090635 0.03 622 IMP 03885 PERRY LOUISE W 1003 VICKSBURG PL~364~6 02/11/16 55922 RES $ 103,138 $ 25,640 24.86 PEREG HELEN POLLY 06 036400020427 0.03 599 IMP 09976 GREENE PATSY 400 17TH ST~148~17 04/22/16 56088 RES $ 129,674 $ 49,440 38.13 PERILLA AKA MIGUEL DARIO PERILLA GOMEZ 17 0148 LL2103 0.02 613 IMP 12152 NELSON VEGA AND ADA M VEGA 905 SADDLE RIDGE CT 05/09/16 56155 RES $ 388,896 $ 130,840 33.64 PERKINS JENNIFER F/PERKINS BRETT T 12 204404760293 0.55 419 IMP 01793 NAVARRO-CERVANTES LISET E 5610 SABLE BAY PT~95~13TH 01/29/16 55833 RES $ 94,230 $ 28,480 30.22 PERMISON ALEXANDER E 13 0096 LL2682~167 & D 0.15 82 IMP 10496 LESTER N/K/A LEE VANESSA 240 SEA HOLLY CIR 04/20/16 56109 RES $ 215,194 $ 65,120 30.26 PERSELL LUCAS BRYAN/PERSELL LEIGHTON 12 254406300754 0.26 631 IMP 10634 SCHWARTZ BRIAN L 280 BLUFF OAK DR 04/29/16 56116 RES $ 359,438 $ 129,970 36.16 PETERS CHRISTOPHER/PETERS KARA 12 205004730792 0.28 685 IMP 07911 TAYLOR JENNIFER L 1361 STIRLING CIR 04/05/16 56032 RES $ 246,453 $ 87,440 35.48 PETERS SARAH/KRAATZ BRYAN 17 0191 LL0921 0.03 575 IMP 03623 LEWENGRUB STEVEN 9135 BRANCH VALLEY WAY~666~1ST 02/18/16 55867 RES $ 314,727 $ 84,200 26.75 PETERSON JAMES BRENT 12 255306660387~LOT 38, BLOCK A 0.29 592 IMP 04910 ALBERTA LLC 191 ALBERTA DR 03/07/16 55930 RES $ 387,397 $ 147,440 38.06 PETERSON RYAN M 17 009800020419 0.34 631 IMP 14763 TIESLAU RICHARD E 4165 PARK BROOKE DR 05/31/16 56240 RES $ 465,591 $ 169,240 36.35 PETERSON YAYOI/PETERSON ERIC 11 026200920454 0.30 505 IMP 12635 HOPKINS DOROTHY 365 MICHAEL DR~696~1ST 05/16/16 56184 RES $ 152,499 $ 54,920 36.01 PETTAS JENNIFER/PETTAS 12 258206960394~LOT 16, BLOCK B 0.39 95 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 55 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 16387 HILL JEFFREY A 335 DEVEREUX DOWNS~257 AND 309~1 06/21/16 56337 RES $ 508,098 $ 158,640 31.22 PFEIFFER ROBERT/PFEIFFER KARA 12 155203090292~LOT 34 BLOCK C 0.73 14 IMP 12278 FUCHS NATHAN S 80 SKYLAND DR 05/09/16 56159 RES $ 386,151 $ 117,680 30.48 PHEIL FREDERICK STUART/WALTER 12 182303420419 0.41 696 IMP 13920 MCAFEE MICHAEL O 05/19/16 56222 RES $ 499,655 $ 241,320 48.30 PHELPS REGAN/PHELPS ZACHARY 22 424105260364 1.01 338 IMP 01505 BROWN DAVID J 01/22/16 55799 RES $ 281,059 $ 86,560 30.80 PHILIPSON HAROLD M 17 006100091272~UN 701 0.03 142 IMP 02162 REDMOND CARRON G 6117 CITICO RIVER LN~75~9F 01/22/16 55833 RES $ 118,340 $ 27,000 22.82 PHILLIP DAWN 09F210100881036~28 0.15 139 IMP 17410 PRICE RICHARD E 270 WILDE GREEN DR~1212~2 06/17/16 56331 RES $ 421,560 $ 164,400 39.00 PHILLIPS CHESTER BRYANT/PHILLIPS MEGAN 22 372012121387 0.35 69 IMP 12189 D R HORTON INC A DELAWARE 7354 PARKLAND BND~140~7 05/04/16 56147 RES $ 198,353 $ 73,920 37.27 PHILLIPS KARRIEM YUSUF 07 150001408226~26 0.26 601 IMP 11303 CAH 2014-1 TRS BORROWER LLC 5465 TWIN LAKES DRIVE 04/29/16 56131 RES $ 78,247 $ 28,440 36.35 PHILLIPS KORY D/PHILLIPS DEBORAH W 13 009400011403 0.13 486 IMP 13037 THOMPSON KAREN J 205 SPRINGDALE DR 05/17/16 56177 RES $ 453,981 $ 137,560 30.30 PHILLIPS TRIFFANY ANNE 17 010100170227 0.19 345 IMP 16657 WRIGHT KIMBERLY A 980 LANCASTER WALK 06/16/16 56293 RES $ 445,013 $ 146,120 32.84 PHILMON CHRIS/PHILMON MAGDALENA 17 0123 LL1807 0.16 584 IMP 07827 PATEAU GINA 3376 ARCHGATE CT 04/05/16 56026 RES $ 269,983 $ 104,720 38.79 PICKERING DAVID TERRENCE 22 539007573695 0.09 679 IMP 12702 ABARA ANTHONY 5810 HAMPTON CT 05/13/16 56190 RES $ 58,395 $ 15,240 26.10 PIERCY LISA 13 0099 LL0907 0.19 113 IMP 08017 SHANSKY HOWARD S 560 WILLOW OAK WAY~710~1 03/25/16 56034 RES $ 524,299 $ 174,840 33.35 PIGEON JEAN 12 266007111307~LOT 99 0.11 177 IMP 09143 SMITH BEN 170 BOULEVARD 04/15/16 56068 RES $ 216,563 $ 70,480 32.54 PIGNATIELLO DIONNE 14 0045 LL1080 0.02 336 IMP 10849 BADGIO WILLIAM C 870 INMAN VILLAGE PKWY 04/29/16 56132 RES $ 222,114 $ 86,760 39.06 PIKE REBECCA 14 0019 LL1801 0.02 416 IMP 13333 OCWEN FINANCIAL CORPORATION 4701 NORTHSIDE DR~177~17TH 05/26/16 56194 RES $ 3,280,992 $ 1,452,000 44.25 PINECONE PROPERTIES LLC 17 0177 LL1315~METES & BOUNDS 2.00 582 IMP 01700 ROBERTS PETER 300 WEST PEACHTREE STREET 02/01/16 55835 RES $ 98,938 $ 24,680 24.94 PITTS JANE 14 007800140424 0.01 499 IMP 08490 CENTURY COMMUNITIES OF GEORGIA LLC 7502 BOWHEAD CT~193~13TH 03/31/16 56035 RES $ 197,554 $ 69,920 35.39 PITTS JEFFERY B 13 0193 LL1488~LOT 30 0.19 267 IMP 14166 MARSDEN STEPHEN 115 VIEW HILL CT 05/20/16 56208 RES $ 555,577 $ 220,280 39.65 PIXTON MATTHEW R/PIXTON CAROL 17 0026 LL0260 1.73 455 IMP 08181 KING DONALD L 460 VALLEY GREEN DRIVE NE~65~17 04/11/16 56054 RES $ 373,302 $ 183,920 49.27 PLANTZ RYAN J 17 006500090270 1.13 84 IMP 15127 GRACZ HENRY C 930 UDERWOOD AVE SE 06/07/16 56265 RES $ 293,424 $ 77,080 26.27 PLENGE KEVIN 14 001000020072 0.39 556 IMP 00945 MELKONIAN GEOFFREY S 6290 BLACKWATER TRL 01/22/16 55794 RES $ 589,237 $ 137,360 23.31 PLEVAK DANIEL/PLEVAK RACHEL B 17 013000040425 0.46 402 IMP 12015 HANDREN EMILY N 1445 MONROE DR~52~17TH 04/20/16 56150 RES $ 204,064 $ 69,080 33.85 PONDISCIO DEVYN 17 0052 LL1497~B14 0.02 490 IMP 02812 GAGERELL ANDERS 275 13TH ST 02/12/16 55857 RES $ 306,288 $ 84,040 27.44 PONGASI MARK JOSEPH/MINNEMAN KENNETH 17 010600340841~UN 801 0.03 415 IMP 10990 LISS DAVID E 645 SHERINGHAM LN~268~1 04/29/16 56108 RES $ 346,535 $ 113,240 32.68 POOLE KRISTEN R 11 065002680528~27 0.29 437 IMP 15042 SGARBI MARCELO V 845 SPRING ST 06/06/16 56270 RES $ 304,399 $ 96,600 31.73 POPE JR JAMES G/HALL MICAH S 14 008000030951 0.03 143 IMP 15009 DESHE CANDACE 6405 MURETS RD~237~1 05/10/16 56253 RES $ 365,756 $ 120,000 32.81 POPE TRACY M/POPE JEROME DOUGLAS 11 056202371240~36/B 0.53 223 IMP 11893 STAIKOV PAVLIN 10319 MONARCH WAY 04/28/16 56148 RES $ 272,077 $ 96,160 35.34 PORRI DEBRA C/PORRI PETER R 11 059002210824 0.05 219 IMP 11173 RANALLO ANDREW J 250 PHARR RD 04/28/16 56115 RES $ 279,455 $ 94,920 33.97 PORTER PROPERTIES LLC 17 009900071148 0.02 77 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 56 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 07255 DAVID ROBERT SIBILSKY AND CATALINA 670 CUMBERLAND CIR 03/30/16 56005 RES $ 720,164 $ 246,000 34.16 PORTO SILVANA M/MOORE RYAN A 17 005100060436 0.27 219 IMP 11027 SCHEIDWEILER BERNARD T 04/29/16 56129 RES $ 517,959 $ 168,640 32.56 PORTWIG JOHANN HEINRICH 21 572011240813 0.22 207 IMP 17640 GILL LEILA A 3946 ESTER DR~25~14TH 05/31/16 56321 RES $ 55,835 $ 14,640 26.22 POUNDS DANTE 14F002500040655~LOT 69/BLK C 0.27 103 IMP 07384 LEE MARIANNE H 845 MARSEILLES DR~28 03/25/16 55999 RES $ 760,470 $ 370,000 48.65 POURREZA PAYAM/PAGAH 17 016600040190 0.75 637 IMP 07747 WOODS KELLIOE S 3783 HEMPSTEAD WAY~5~14FF 03/22/16 56015 RES $ 107,446 $ 58,120 54.09 POWE STEPHANIE 14F0005 LL1686~A 0.15 503 IMP 09696 GRAHAM CAROLYN M 04/22/16 56098 RES $ 152,830 $ 49,640 32.48 POWELL LYNDA DENISE 12 200404260987 0.02 602 IMP 11384 REEVES SHARRON B 57 FORSYTH ST 04/27/16 56119 RES $ 127,829 $ 31,160 24.38 POWELL MARK ANDREW 14 007800121648 0.02 472 IMP 17109 THOMAS E ALLEN JR AND MARY W ALLEN 9860 AUTRY FALLS DR 06/16/16 56305 RES $ 589,642 $ 208,000 35.28 PRASAD RAJIV/PRASAD KALPANA R 11 020200720238 0.36 362 IMP 07984 PING KIMBERLY 7745 JANANN WAY 03/21/16 56027 RES $ 473,659 $ 198,320 41.87 PRENDERGAST PHILIP 06 031300010065 0.61 428 IMP 00685 SHAH LEENA 1445 MONROE DR 01/11/16 55764 RES $ 298,024 $ 105,600 35.43 PRESCOTT WARREN LYNN 17 0052 LL2032~UN D-2 0.04 324 IMP 17196 FULLER MAXINE 4266 ROSWELL RD~95~17 06/17/16 56300 RES $ 100,054 $ 41,680 41.66 PRESSLER ANDREW P 17 009500110155 0.02 445 IMP 10894 COLE ALAN 740 DREWRY ST 04/29/16 56115 RES $ 1,177,389 $ 459,980 39.07 PRICE KENNETH LELAND 14 001700040727 0.19 177 IMP 11399 ARON DIANE M 1001 BRIGHTON POINT 04/29/16 56107 RES $ 158,521 $ 59,600 37.60 PRICE MARVIN 17 0032 LL1682 0.04 501 IMP 02753 CHRISTLER WORTH R 2798 LAKEWOOD AVE~102~14TH 02/11/16 55848 COM $ 225,250 $ 77,000 34.18 PRIMAS PROPERTIES LLC 14 010200020097~9A 0.17 131 IMP 10601 SHARON ZIRNGIBL AND CHRISTINE C 18106 HARVEST RIDGE LANE 04/20/16 56112 RES $ 219,832 $ 88,120 40.09 PRIMO LUCIE RESSLER 11 038501531310 0.04 691 IMP 09511 DONOSCO LLC 2851 TWO LAKE CIR~94~13TH 04/22/16 56102 RES $ 81,046 $ 32,320 39.88 PRIMUS SHAQUANA 13 0094 LL1694~80 0.09 33 IMP 08335 RES-GA KAP LLC 4841 NEAL RDG~159~9F 04/11/16 56055 RES $ 419,976 $ 147,520 35.13 PRIOLEAU JR OSCAR E 09F390001764596~LOT 53, CHAMPIONS 0.93 90 IMP 16951 SHARON SNOWISS F/K/A SHARON A 06/23/16 56332 RES $ 265,625 $ 112,680 42.42 PRITCHARD PAUL E/PRITCHARD JULIETTE 11 065202691705 0.30 567 IMP 02272 LINDSAY BONNIE M 215 SOUTHWIND CIR~581~1 02/11/16 55861 RES $ 189,249 $ 71,800 37.94 PROVENCAL INVESTMENTS LLC 12 242205810677~LOT 66, LAKEVIEW 0.09 310 IMP 00182 BUCHHOLZ MATTHEW 1100 AUTUMN CLOSE 01/20/16 55787 RES $ 616,192 $ 170,480 27.67 PRUETT JAMES/PRUETT LINDSEY 22 537006841618 0.37 131 IMP 00395 FOWLER MATTHEW B 850 RALPH MCGILL BLVD~18~14TH 01/15/16 55786 RES $ 379,469 $ 91,080 24.00 PRUITT JACK M 14 001800130154~UN 16 0.03 59 IMP 18117 WELCH DELPHINE C 520 MCWILLIAMS RD 06/24/16 56369 RES $ 102,189 $ 29,400 28.77 PRUITT JONTAVIOUS 14 003800010048 0.28 688 IMP 07126 MILLER MELISSA D 878 PEACHTREE ST~LOT 49~14TH 03/24/16 55999 RES $ 203,249 $ 60,280 29.66 PRYOR VICTORIA 14 004900011019~UNIT 433 0.02 529 IMP 16464 PERRY JASON 555 WILLOWBROOK RUN 06/22/16 56312 RES $ 279,999 $ 91,240 32.59 PRZEWODOWSKI DANIEL 11 036201560464 0.26 447 IMP 14343 LOGAN VERNON V 563 MEMORIAL DR 05/31/16 56236 RES $ 207,129 $ 72,440 34.97 PUCHE STEPHEN E/WATKINS AMANDA E 14 004400031244 0.02 427 IMP 18625 GIANNAMORE MELISSA M 3020 BURINGAME DR~1148 AND 1157~2 06/30/16 56370 RES $ 488,847 $ 164,880 33.73 PUGH STEVEN/PUGH SHANNON 22 339011480304~LOT 3 HUNTINGTON 0.66 227 IMP 01939 ANGLADE ONY R 470 KNOLL WOODS DR 01/28/16 55823 RES $ 231,804 $ 93,120 40.17 PUJALS KRISTIN B 12 169403250283 0.45 260 IMP 17631 MUSTARD SEED LAND FUND LLC NORTHSIDE CIR 06/24/16 56301 COM $ 460,480 $ 174,120 37.81 PULTE HOME CORPORATION 17 0147 LL0777 0.92 598 IMP 02580 DELANY RICHARD 02/05/16 55840 RES $ 190,506 $ 46,800 24.57 PUTTNAM MARK D 14 004900101018~UN B-5 0.02 328 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 57 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 18617 WOODHAMS PRISCILLA L 345 ARDMORE CT~147~17 06/28/16 56360 RES $ 419,008 $ 176,560 42.14 PWINT AYE AYE 17 0147 LL2666~LOT 9 BLDG 500 0.02 190 IMP 13292 BRADLEY JOHN W 10900 REGAL FOREST DRIVE~F60 05/20/16 56199 RES $ 364,030 $ 145,760 40.04 QIAN QI/LIU TING 11 132000601151 0.33 204 IMP 12970 VICEVICH ROBERT P 1247 MONROE DR 05/12/16 56180 RES $ 363,860 $ 100,000 27.48 QUARLES RICHARD L 17 005200040049 0.22 222 IMP 11054 CHANG TERENCE 950 PEACHTREE RD 04/29/16 56115 RES $ 345,613 $ 112,400 32.52 QUEZADA RAFAEL S 17 010700062329 0.03 141 IMP 04764 BROOKS BURTON L 2682 RIDGEMORE RD 02/29/16 55903 RES $ 466,156 $ 159,160 34.14 QUINLEY DANIELLE JORDAN/JOHNSON 17 022000050060 1.56 641 IMP 05807 1101 DEFOORS LANDING LLC A GA LIMITED 1101 DEFOORS LNDG~1187~17 03/04/16 55940 RES $ 187,868 $ 67,640 36.00 QUIST TERESA DAWN/QUIST BERT A 17 018700100155~UNIT 1101 BLDG 11 0.03 559 IMP 18429 MOHAMMAD SAEED YAZDANI AND FARANGIS 721 SANDRINGHAM DR~1043~2ND 06/30/16 56355 RES $ 138,727 $ 62,800 45.27 RABAUER SIGRID E/RABAUER FRANZ B 22 543010431651~UNIT 721 0.04 283 IMP 13546 SCHIFTIC RONALD M 9500 DOMINION WAY 05/27/16 56225 RES $ 352,246 $ 121,400 34.46 RADEMACHER JOHN 12 319308930568 0.48 406 IMP 18774 NWOBIKE OLUBUNMI 8740 ROSWELL RD~368~6 06/30/16 56351 RES $ 105,697 $ 41,720 39.47 RADILLA MALDONADO JOSE LUIS 06 0368 LL1291 0.04 649 IMP 17089 KINCHEN STEVEN A 338 GRANT ST~44~14TH 06/15/16 56304 RES $ 345,585 $ 119,360 34.54 RAJASINGHAM ANANGU N 14 004400010438 0.10 85 IMP 04441 RAJESH CHOUHAN AND SHALINI CHOUHAN 13053 DARTMORE AVE 02/26/16 55907 RES $ 376,581 $ 130,080 34.54 RAMA VINAY K/PATEL VANITA V 21 568010540872 0.35 139 IMP 07418 CAPITAL DESIGN HOMES LLC 13468 GARDINER LN 03/31/16 56016 RES $ 225,776 $ 107,000 47.39 RAMASWAMY KARTHIK 22 526009703685 0.04 22 IMP 14934 PULTE HOME CORPORATION 2004 BLOSSOM HILL DR~128~2ND 05/27/16 56236 RES $ 441,988 $ 187,040 42.32 RAMENDA TERESA/RAMENDA BRIAN 22 387012812280~31 0.26 634 IMP 18057 MARKER GLENN 560 DUTCH VALLEY RD 06/30/16 56358 RES $ 356,726 $ 105,040 29.45 RAMESH SHEELA LATHA 17 005500060663 0.03 170 IMP 07252 SUAREZ LARRY A 300 INTREPED CUT 03/31/16 56006 RES $ 545,625 $ 185,040 33.91 RAMPERSAD DARYL 21 571212540252 0.49 697 IMP 05093 TRIM-DORIVAL KERLYN L 715 WHITEHALL WAY 03/04/16 55927 RES $ 249,117 $ 91,840 36.87 RASHAD MOHAMMAD 12 206204710493~12 C 0.18 83 IMP 06715 CALATLANTIC GROUP INC 4100 HOPEWELL SPRINGS DR 01/29/16 55999 RES $ 701,133 $ 221,200 31.55 RASPER JOSEPH DAVID/ADIENE MEDLIN 22 516001821296~53 1.06 490 IMP 16422 GAIN GARY 760 MONROE DRIVE NE 06/08/16 56295 COM $ 676,128 $ 210,000 31.06 RATTINER DENNIS L/RATTINER BERNARD J 14 004800070396~M&B 0.51 511 IMP 04520 MARCUS KLUTTZ AND CHRISTINA J KLUTTZ 1085 PINE BLOOM DR~762 & 763~1ST 03/01/16 55902 RES $ 377,472 $ 117,400 31.10 RAUN SHAYNA/RAUN MATTHEW 12 277307630060~16 G 0.37 132 IMP 15527 DUKES BENJAMIN 1779 MONROE DR~56~17 05/26/16 56252 RES $ 447,408 $ 120,720 26.98 RAVAT FATIMA 17 005600030525 0.20 6 IMP 11602 WEISS DAWN P 4170 PARAN POINTE DR 04/29/16 56151 RES $ 681,088 $ 264,400 38.82 RAVILLA NIRUPAKANTHI/BOTTU KISHORE 17 021500040258 0.35 44 IMP 04314 WATSON PROPERTY HOLDINGS LLC 2808 QUEEN ANNE CT~366~6TH 02/23/16 55908 RES $ 91,684 $ 33,180 36.19 RAVKAIE ODELIA 06 036600051172~UNIT 221, 0.03 661 IMP 09754 DANIELSON THOMAS 200 GRAYSTONE WAY 04/21/16 56095 RES $ 342,027 $ 125,720 36.76 RAWAT NIDHI 21 565111030100 0.23 250 IMP 00660 HARRIS DONNA M 01/11/16 55778 RES $ 248,354 $ 73,680 29.67 RAWSON DOUGLAS V 22 513711830329 0.22 630 IMP 06649 TYLER BRUCE Y 170 BOULEVARD~45~14 03/22/16 55979 RES $ 351,211 $ 119,040 33.89 RAY KATHRYN 14 0045 LL1437~UN H428 0.03 640 IMP 03053 SCHWALLIE CRAIG 5555 TENBURY WAY 02/12/16 55864 RES $ 461,862 $ 155,920 33.76 RAYMOND III JOSEPH LEOPOLD/JULISA 11 081102831424 0.32 260 IMP 17934 ENGLE KEVIN L 4588 STELLA DR 06/17/16 56303 RES $ 1,689,797 $ 551,400 32.63 REARDON SEAN C/REARDON DANIELLE 17 011900020398 0.46 297 IMP 02558 JOOS CHRISTOPHER D 1579 BAYHILL DR~342~1 02/01/16 55865 RES $ 862,035 $ 289,480 33.58 REDDY SUJATHA 11 102103420213~B532 0.37 23 IMP 02137 PINNACLE CREDIT UNIOIN 1723 DORSEY AVE~157~14TH 01/20/16 55817 RES $ 31,600 $ 13,800 43.67 REDWINE PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 14 015700070294~LOT 36 0.21 164 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 58 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 06597 KIM DONG WOOK 3324 PEACHTREE RD~62~17TH 03/24/16 55985 RES $ 189,068 $ 75,880 40.13 REED CHRISTOPHER 17 0062 LL5397~1906 0.02 624 IMP 12004 ZOHAR HOLDINGS LLC 05/02/16 56162 RES $ 125,074 $ 35,400 28.30 REED EMILY/WHEELER ANTHONY 06 0367 LL1045 0.02 536 IMP 06913 WHITING EILEEN E 2012 WATERS EDGE TRL 03/31/16 56006 RES $ 229,539 $ 102,920 44.84 REESE JR JEFFERSON 12 154002481687 0.04 609 IMP 11262 MACLAREN SUSAN 211 ESTORIA ST~20~14TH 04/28/16 56108 RES $ 285,819 $ 73,640 25.76 REESE KATHERINE L/MATTSSON JONAS 14 002000080652 0.06 578 IMP 11494 DEBERRY ERICK P 6925 VIRLYN B. SMITH~151~7TH 05/03/16 56143 RES $ 115,794 $ 38,600 33.34 REESE SHALAMAR/REESE ADRIENNE 07 170001511811 3.24 477 IMP 08325 MARLATT TONYA 600 BRICKWORKS CIR 04/14/16 56057 RES $ 349,224 $ 111,990 32.07 REILLY JAMES D 14 001900080721 0.03 66 IMP 10141 PEEDE CARL 12615 OXFORDSHIRE CT~1125~2 04/12/16 56085 RES $ 321,794 $ 105,040 32.64 REILLY JOHN M/REILLY FELIXBERTA J 21 575311250655~67 0.26 653 IMP 17904 RANDOLPH DAVID R 2215 EDISON AVE~102~17 05/31/16 56301 RES $ 472,795 $ 137,600 29.10 REILLY PATRICIA 17 010200080060~LOT 28 & PART OF 0.17 477 IMP 18843 SCHNEIDER RYAN A 2548 SHARONDALE CT~59~17 06/30/16 56366 RES $ 729,307 $ 290,040 39.77 REILLY TIMOTHY 17 005900040117~LOT 13 BLOCK A 0.67 224 IMP 05862 EDMONDS KAYE M 11160 INDIAN VILLAGE DR~131~1 02/29/16 55963 RES $ 207,608 $ 63,320 30.50 REISS MERRYL DARA 11 037101310075 0.28 133 IMP 01663 BOND JR THOMAS P 149 ELYSIAN WAY 01/15/16 55808 RES $ 159,367 $ 41,120 25.80 REMORENKO SANDRA A 17 018400061475 0.03 403 IMP 14711 HARRIS CHAD I 589 AUBURN AVE # E 05/31/16 56239 RES $ 135,084 $ 44,320 32.81 REPNIKOVA MARIA 14 004600122645 0.01 2 IMP 07360 AMRINE NATHANIEL W 370 GREEN OAK DRIVE~386 AND 03/25/16 55989 RES $ 472,342 $ 161,360 34.16 RESCIGNO TRACY 12 190503860789 0.06 36 IMP 08925 GET PROPERTY GA LLLP 1227 EPWORTH ST~137~14 03/31/16 56067 RES $ 69,614 $ 20,280 29.13 RESI SFR SUB LLC 14 013700020641 0.16 248 IMP 18124 STARWOOD WAYPOINT TRS LLC 06/24/16 56360 RES $ 93,784 $ 22,680 24.18 RESI SFR SUB LLC 09F381101780103 0.54 215 IMP 04264 GOINS TAIG 940 BUCKINGHAM CV 02/26/16 55903 RES $ 168,450 $ 69,680 41.37 REYNOSO JOSE N LOPEZ 07 270001692312 0.17 380 IMP 10279 FIERER ROBERT G 41 GLENALD WAY 04/19/16 56078 RES $ 169,864 $ 48,440 28.52 RHODES CAROLYN 17 019400050310 0.03 438 IMP 17986 HOUSTON ANNIE 6015 AUTUMN GREENE DR 06/28/16 56344 RES $ 122,262 $ 32,800 26.83 RHODES TERESA LASHEL 09F030000140733 0.29 26 IMP 05421 GEORGE N GREAVES AND DENISE E GREAVES 6588 FOGGY OAK DR 03/14/16 55954 RES $ 226,559 $ 77,800 34.34 RICE SHANNON M 07 140001077295 0.19 211 IMP 13028 CARTER PRESTON/NICOLE 26 SPRUELL SPRINGS RD~93~17 05/10/16 56174 RES $ 777,232 $ 289,840 37.29 RICE ZAKIYA/RICE WILLIAM 17 009300021032 0.03 117 IMP 11839 RAINES OLUWA 536 BOULEVARD PL 05/09/16 56157 RES $ 297,391 $ 127,840 42.99 RICH JONATHAN C 14 004700030227 0.23 659 IMP 10731 D R HORTON INC A DELAWARE 349 SAND BAY DR~108~14FF 04/28/16 56121 RES $ 149,402 $ 57,920 38.77 RICHARDS ELIZABETH 14F0108 LL1278~292 0.05 344 IMP 13425 MILES BRITTON KIRKLAND 560 RAMDALE DR~326~1 05/20/16 56198 RES $ 328,626 $ 77,240 23.50 RICHARDS KYLE/KROLL HANNA 12 169103260681~46 0.42 680 IMP 22621 NEWDOW TERRY A 123 LUCKIE ST 06/21/16 56495 RES $ 202,175 $ 70,600 34.92 RICHARDS RAYMOND 14 007800150431 0.03 389 IMP 00998 RUTH B KEITH 834 CLEMONT DR~53~17TH 01/29/16 55816 RES $ 736,171 $ 271,720 36.91 RICHARDSON DOMINIQUE R/CHRISTOPHER J 17 005300100206~4 0.19 163 IMP 17506 SUNG BRYAN M 2370 HOWELL MILL RD~154, 155~17 06/17/16 56325 RES $ 570,974 $ 171,840 30.10 RICHARDSON JAMES IRVIN 17 018400040065~55, B 0.70 700 IMP 14143 SARGENT CAROL SPRINGER 1648 MERCER AVE 05/26/16 56219 RES $ 289,685 $ 82,720 28.56 RICHARDSON TARA R 14 015900030338 0.16 443 IMP 09585 LYNCH MARK E 795 DOCKBRIDGE WAY 04/08/16 56084 RES $ 501,876 $ 166,600 33.20 RICHTER RODNEY A/RICHTER TIFFANY M 22 370110660488 1.12 418 IMP 04004 LENNAR GEORGIA INC 801 STUART DR 02/25/16 55905 RES $ 544,536 $ 210,960 38.74 RIDENHOUR ANESHIA/DENESHIA 22 401012072421~1 0.34 522 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 59 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 16430 GREGORY SANDRA L 6110 HARBOUR OVERLOOK 06/10/16 56296 RES $ 335,241 $ 130,480 38.92 RIGWOOD LOIS 21 558411710273 0.14 474 IMP 15341 C STUART MCCLOSKEY AND SANDRA L 6660 MAID MARION CLOSE 06/06/16 56264 RES $ 291,399 $ 92,280 31.67 RINER SHANNON/RINER JEFFREY 11 044101610116 0.27 314 IMP 05705 PHAIL DIANE M 1071 BELLEVUE DR~1~17 03/14/16 55949 RES $ 547,358 $ 185,920 33.97 RISHEL SALLY/RISHEL GARY 17 000100020613 0.18 97 IMP 16635 VENCIUS BETSY JOE 43 DUNWOODY SPRINGS DR 06/29/16 56340 RES $ 171,886 $ 71,840 41.80 RITTER DUANE/RITTER ROSE 17 001800040323 0.04 334 IMP 14511 FOWLER JENNIFER F 3224 VERDUN DR~142~17TH 05/31/16 56233 RES $ 787,992 $ 319,120 40.50 RIVERWOOD AVIATION LLC A FLORIDA 17 014200020340~LOT 34 OF ARGONNE 0.44 342 IMP 11112 BOOMSTRA TREVOR J 4970 HAYDENS WALK DR~213~1ST 04/29/16 56127 RES $ 375,262 $ 134,240 35.77 RIZZONE NICOLE/CODDINGTON JR RUSSELL 11 052202130355~LOT 35, BLOCK B, 0.22 681 IMP 13874 RAY PROMA 955 JUNIPER ST 05/24/16 56217 RES $ 264,039 $ 78,960 29.90 ROACH DENNIS 17 010600311479 0.03 383 IMP 01479 PRABIR MEHTA AND NILI MEHTA 9455 NESBIT LAKES DR~765~1ST 01/29/16 55812 RES $ 441,703 $ 194,280 43.98 ROBACK NEIL 12 292307651099~66 0.54 601 IMP 12162 SISK AUTUMN RICHARDS 122 LABLANC WAY~48~14 05/10/16 56156 RES $ 82,295 $ 34,040 41.36 ROBERTS JOHN H 17 018500070111 0.02 493 IMP 14635 CONNELLY JR JAMES P 3811 CLUB DR 06/01/16 56240 RES $ 1,691,818 $ 689,980 40.78 ROBERTSON JR EUGENE M 17 001000090136 0.93 170 IMP 19291 STEWART ROBERT L 16725 QUAYSIDE DR~265 & 266~2 06/17/16 56393 RES $ 747,068 $ 334,400 44.76 ROBERTSON SEAN A/ROBERTSON JULIE A 22 436002650968~82 1.40 688 IMP 22391 RICHARDS MELINDA 265 REDDING RDG 06/30/16 56484 RES $ 158,545 $ 50,040 31.56 ROBERTSON SHANEAL S 14F0154 LL0505 0.27 475 IMP 11792 NORMAN ROY E 0 WALLACE ROAD 05/11/16 56162 RES $ 150,766 $ 34,600 22.95 ROBERTSON SHELITHA/WHITE JACQUELYN 14F0106 LL1023 6.40 382 VAC 06353 DAY JANET S 530 PARKBROOK TRCE~899~2ND/2ND 03/18/16 55960 RES $ 284,788 $ 91,480 32.12 ROBINSON KARA L 22 541008991165~57, B 0.21 434 IMP 03959 MARSHALL SUSAN G 4245 GLENGARY CT 02/29/16 55906 RES $ 797,752 $ 212,840 26.68 ROBINSON SHARRIE ANENA/STRATAS JAMES 17 004200050389 0.30 670 IMP 13824 ERGAS JAMES M 920 CONFEDERATE AVE 05/27/16 56227 RES $ 400,116 $ 101,840 25.45 ROBINSON STACY R/ROBINSON 14 001000010669 0.40 593 IMP 09400 SOL JACOBS TRTE FOR THE TRT FOR THE 3685 PEACHTREE RD~10~17 04/22/16 56098 RES $ 484,889 $ 182,360 37.61 ROBINSON TANYA S/ROBINSON EARL G 17 001000210130 0.07 2 IMP 13923 LAWRENCE SCOTT W 335 AUTUMN BREEZE DR 05/24/16 56206 RES $ 520,474 $ 189,000 36.31 ROBISON ROBERT MATTHEW 22 373012841016 0.32 409 IMP 09435 HAUG AKA KIMBERLY D HAUG KIMBERLY 575 ABBEYWOOD DR~199&238~1ST 04/21/16 56079 RES $ 442,596 $ 175,960 39.76 ROBY ELIZABETH J/ROBY SCOTT S 12 150201991070~137 0.42 322 IMP 03358 FRANKHAM-SMITH ROB 810 DOCKBRIDGE WAY~1066 AND 02/19/16 55879 RES $ 536,994 $ 144,360 26.88 ROBY GEORGE/KHAVARIAN LILLIAN NACIM 22 370110230464~41, A 2.05 594 IMP 16778 ROBY ELIZABETH J 1340 TREEBROOK CT 06/15/16 56300 RES $ 474,735 $ 169,200 35.64 ROCCO II RYAN CHARLES/ROCCO LINDSAY 12 139101150010 0.55 641 IMP 11498 HARRIS KALEY J 1903 ANJACO RD 05/06/16 56160 RES $ 250,348 $ 76,800 30.68 RODOPOULOS KELLY 17 011000021502 0.03 669 IMP 11213 CUTMORE LINDA JOYCE 635 BRANCH VALLEY CT~665~1 04/28/16 56112 RES $ 258,242 $ 94,440 36.57 RODRIGUEZ ALEJANDRA M/RODRIGUEZ JUAN 12 255106650331~59 0.34 663 IMP 11841 LRT PROPERTIES LLC 0 GARIBALDI ST 05/09/16 56161 RES $ 10,981 $ 2,840 25.86 RODRIGUEZ CHRISTINA M/RODRIGUEZ JR 14 008700092160 0.11 658 VAC 03916 JRMG ASSOCIATES LLC 2519 STONE RD~195~14 02/26/16 55910 RES $ 67,419 $ 20,560 30.50 RODRIGUEZ MARIA 14 019500020756 0.67 129 IMP 03962 BECKERMAN EDWARD G 401 16TH ST~148~17TH 02/25/16 55890 RES $ 117,099 $ 44,480 37.98 RODRIGUEZ RICHARD GONZALEZ 17 0148 LL0735~ART FOUNDRY AT 0.02 376 IMP 05676 WILLIAMS JANICE M 12990 MARINERS CT 03/14/16 55951 RES $ 300,809 $ 99,720 33.15 ROGER CAITLIN/ROGER MATTHEW J 21 561011181291 0.31 665 IMP 14597 LOWRY JR BURNS M 2616 BROOKWOOD DR 06/01/16 56245 RES $ 1,552,333 $ 443,400 28.56 ROGERS BARBARA J/ROGERS GAMWELL 17 010100070385 0.43 678 IMP 15935 MCNUTT STEVEN 6010 CABOTAGE RD~323 AND 344~1 05/25/16 56283 RES $ 287,635 $ 92,560 32.18 ROMANO PAUL 11 090003221429 0.02 497 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 60 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 06794 BRIDGES BARBARA A 1280 PEACHTREE ST~108~17 03/25/16 55992 RES $ 80,298 $ 27,990 34.86 ROMEUS CHRIS 17 010800084140 0.01 357 IMP 05530 WICKHAM WILLIAM R 560 DUTCH VALLEY RD~55~17TH 03/11/16 56047 RES $ 402,547 $ 144,080 35.79 ROQUERO MARCO GOMEZ 17 005500060598 0.04 601 IMP 10838 ANDREW M SNOOK AND ROXANNE SNOOK 3300 WOLF WILLOW CLOSE~756~2 05/03/16 56137 RES $ 528,425 $ 179,520 33.97 ROSENBAUM PETER H 22 539007560791~40 0.29 363 IMP 03790 WALKER KRISTOPHER G 510 BIRCH FOREST LN 02/19/16 55887 RES $ 270,868 $ 107,160 39.56 ROSKOVS MAKSIMS 11 064102340950 0.22 309 IMP 16863 POTTARD MARIGNY 1273 ALMONT DR~138~14 06/15/16 56300 RES $ 16,032 $ 6,120 38.17 ROSS MICHAEL 14 013800060067~6 C 0.21 219 IMP 13710 CARTER NEUGINE 432 LAKE RIDGE LN~96 & 97~9TH F 05/24/16 56229 RES $ 117,672 $ 51,520 43.78 ROSSER TIMIRA 09F200000962135~123 0.16 685 IMP 40567 5925 ROSWELL RD COM $ 1,414,845 $ 520,000 36.75 ROSWELL ROAD ASSOC LP 17 0090 LL0535 0.60 IMP 15601 LOAR JR KENTON J 2277 PEACHTREE RD~111~17 06/08/16 56271 RES $ 253,368 $ 75,600 29.84 ROUILLIER MATTHEW D 17 011100070607 0.03 481 IMP 17047 BENJELLOUN RAFIH 6073 RED OAK RD~127 06/24/16 56334 RES $ 44,238 $ 26,640 60.22 ROWE LEASING AND INVESTMENTS LLC 13 0127 LL0416 1.00 216 IMP 01862 KALIL WILLIAM F 6005 RIVERWOOD DR~132~17 02/01/16 55829 RES $ 540,731 $ 204,880 37.89 ROWE RONALD SCOTT/ROWE ALLISON W 17 013200020342~12, D 0.61 192 IMP 05001 SANDERS ROBERT M 7725 BRIGHAM COURT~337~6TH 03/08/16 55926 RES $ 475,550 $ 168,320 35.39 RUFFIN DONALD 06 0337 LL0218~LOT 75, BLOCK B 0.54 61 IMP 14614 TIMOTHY R NAVARRO AND DEBORAH A 125 THATCHING LN 05/31/16 56237 RES $ 218,837 $ 74,600 34.09 RUIZ HUMBERTO LEEYVA/BORIAS RUBEN 11 055202290509 0.17 193 IMP 16487 GUILLEN JOSE 426 MARIETTA ST 06/21/16 56307 RES $ 162,272 $ 48,840 30.10 RUIZ MOLINA JOSE IGNACIO 14 007900091410 0.02 94 IMP 15582 1003 DILL AVE LLC 1003 DILL AVE AVE 06/10/16 56274 COM $ 79,484 $ 38,200 48.06 RUMBAUGH CHRISTINA 14 012000020368~50 X 200 0.23 40 IMP 03189 PARKER KEVIN R 540 MATTERHORN WALK 02/19/16 55873 RES $ 324,190 $ 129,800 40.04 RUMMEL LIANA/DINOZZI STEVEN 12 321309310543 0.76 611 IMP 11049 SOSBE DONALD G 135 NOBILITY CT~1234~2 04/28/16 56114 RES $ 433,478 $ 166,960 38.52 RUSSELL ANN M 22 352512340158~15 0.48 477 IMP 01824 LGI HOMES-GEORGIA LLC 355 ST. LUCAS CT 01/29/16 55825 RES $ 169,712 $ 64,440 37.97 RUSSELL JEREMY/MONIQUE MAISHA 07 150101392502 0.15 697 IMP 04064 HERRING JULIAN 3145 HIGHGREEN TRL 02/19/16 55901 RES $ 178,063 $ 53,160 29.85 RUSSELL VANESSA M 14F0158 LL2010 0.25 237 IMP 40548 1185 GRIMES BRIDGE RD COM $ 585,055 $ 238,360 40.74 RUSSIA HOUSE INC 12 209304880588 0.42 IMP 13731 YAMPOLSKY OLGA 110 WINTERBERRY CT 05/26/16 56219 RES $ 255,791 $ 80,320 31.40 RUSSO JUSTIN D/RUSSO LISA L 12 254406300168 0.27 366 IMP 12190 EDMUNDSON JAZZMON 7755 WROTHAM CIR 04/28/16 56138 RES $ 169,702 $ 59,360 34.98 RUSSO SONIA 09C110000463971 0.21 367 IMP 06655 BAHRI YOUSSEF 928 WALKER AVE~10~14TH 03/22/16 55979 RES $ 159,294 $ 47,040 29.53 RUTH VICTORIA 14 001000010164 0.18 663 IMP 03296 HARJUNG THOMAS CARL 10425 FOREST BRIDGE DR 02/22/16 55881 RES $ 395,960 $ 114,080 28.81 RUTHRAUFF CASSANDRA M 11 059202250463~LOT 8 G CAMERON 0.44 31 IMP 05941 TATE EDWARD M 368 REDLAND RD 03/17/16 55963 RES $ 522,473 $ 213,840 40.93 RUTLEDGE ADAM C/ANN MARSH T 17 014600050186 0.21 277 IMP 01618 O'DWYER PROPERTIES LLC 13030 LUM CROWE RD~1079 & 01/21/16 55798 RES $ 677,952 $ 204,880 30.22 RUTLEDGE JOSHUA/RUTLEDGE LAURA 22 326010790627~3 1.00 13 IMP 07964 KAMINER BARRY S 4575 JETT RD~162~17 04/01/16 56014 RES $ 1,008,699 $ 392,600 38.92 RUTTEN JOSPEH PETRUS 17 0162 LL1270 1.10 314 IMP 09048 ABRAY LISA 1200 WING ST~363~6TH 04/15/16 56067 RES $ 252,262 $ 77,400 30.68 RYBIN DANIEL 06 036300011013~LOT 4 0.05 8 IMP 03685 GANESHA PROPERTIES LLC 01/27/16 55873 RES $ 122,860 $ 34,890 28.40 S- NELSON PROPERTIES LLC 14F0077 LL0178 1.95 354 IMP 00860 ROTKOW ERIC 275 THE SOUTH CHACE~36~17 01/21/16 55786 RES $ 291,115 $ 98,520 33.84 SABATES ALEXANDRA/BAILEY RYAN M 17 003600070252 0.05 268 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 61 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 10867 DUTCHER RICHARD 1005 THE 1TH FAIRWAY~368~6 04/27/16 56132 RES $ 563,924 $ 129,440 22.95 SABLE KATHERINE ADELIA/SABLE TIMOTHY J 06 036800040090~7/A 1.03 318 IMP 15237 CUNNINGHAM KENNETH J 2395 TRAYWICK CHASE 05/20/16 56254 RES $ 308,654 $ 101,480 32.88 SADAM VENUGOPAL 22 495210511479 0.22 40 IMP 10891 ELMIRA CAPITAL LLC 1161 LUCILE AVE 04/28/16 56118 RES $ 21,674 $ 9,120 42.08 SAFE HOUSE OUTREACH INC 14 011700040171 0.29 204 IMP 06770 MAIER ELIZABETH ANNE 325 E.PACES FERRY RD NE #811 03/25/16 55989 RES $ 309,384 $ 89,200 28.83 SAGGAU HELEN/FALKNER DUSTIN 17 006100091520~UN 811 0.03 400 IMP 05533 CHHAJWANI NITESH K 3334 PEACHTREE RD 03/15/16 55952 RES $ 195,010 $ 74,640 38.27 SAIA AUDREY USERY/SAIA JOSEPH C 17 006200020353~UN 101 0.02 249 IMP 16816 CHEN HONG 1007 HIGHTOWER RD 06/24/16 56337 RES $ 8,848 $ 3,090 34.92 SALEHA REAL ESTATE LLC 17 024900150057 0.16 403 IMP 05509 HILL BEVERLY S 27101 HARVEST RIDGE LN~152 & 153~1 03/11/16 55950 RES $ 219,398 $ 88,120 40.16 SALERNO RAFAEL/SALERNO YOLANDA 11 038501530452~UN 27101 0.04 630 IMP 14588 MCMORRAN ANDREW G 2741 HILLS DR 06/01/16 56245 RES $ 809,913 $ 213,480 26.36 SALERNO REYNOLDS M 17 006000060575 0.26 647 IMP 10857 GANDY ROSE M 1865 MILLSTONE CT~1184~2 03/30/16 56132 RES $ 213,608 $ 74,560 34.91 SALERNO STEPHEN/SALERNO IRENE 22 513711840435~14 0.15 349 IMP 08453 THOLLENBEEK JENNY 30105 HARVEST RIDGE LN 04/01/16 56035 RES $ 211,517 $ 86,720 41.00 SALKIN MIRIAM J 11 038501520313 0.03 443 IMP 13641 PROVOST AMELIE V 214 SOUTHERN HILL DR~329 330~1ST 05/27/16 56221 RES $ 621,399 $ 238,640 38.40 SALKIN ROBYN/SALKIN JOSHUA 11 094303290662~B417 0.37 320 IMP 17560 JACKSON DON D 12225 STEVENS CREEK DR~1230~2ND 05/23/16 56291 RES $ 282,619 $ 99,080 35.06 SALO JERRY/SALO GINA 21 574012300323~18 BLK A 0.35 92 IMP 10845 JANKOVIC LIDIJA 321 QUAIL RUN 05/03/16 56126 RES $ 99,252 $ 29,000 29.22 SALYERS MICHAEL M/WEAVER CHRISTOPHER 12 242606160409 0.02 513 IMP 04691 THACKER SHEETAL A 02/26/16 55898 RES $ 192,384 $ 52,080 27.07 SALZMAN MATTHEW/PALMER AMANDA 14 002300030811 0.01 511 IMP 05436 THOMAS M MAZZANTI AND MARY MAZZANTI 565 ARNCLIFFE COURT~311~1ST 03/14/16 55952 RES $ 231,318 $ 88,600 38.30 SAM JOYCE DANIEL/JEENA SAM DANIEL 11 077003112625~518 0.19 464 IMP 00021 JERRI G SHARON N/K/A JERRI G SANDIFER 9905 FARMBROOK LANE~209~1ST 01/04/16 55737 RES $ 449,111 $ 152,960 34.06 SAMPLES JAMES/SAMPLES AMY 11 060002090398~LOT 22, BLOCK A 1.06 75 IMP 40547 10761 STATE 9 HWY COM $ 862,044 $ 369,400 42.85 SAMS REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS GEORGIA 12 208004850453 0.51 IMP 03166 RUELAS IRMA 6369 GRESHAM STREET 02/19/16 55871 RES $ 14,516 $ 8,480 58.42 SANCHEZ DAISY 09F160300761266 1.17 412 IMP 17304 RANDALL THOMAS M 12333 SUNSET MAPLE TER 06/17/16 56306 RES $ 468,696 $ 151,400 32.30 SANCHEZ STANLEY/SANCHEZ SUSAN 21 575011920631 0.36 29 IMP 18646 MULLIS MICHAEL 740 AUTUMN CLOSE~614~2 06/24/16 56347 RES $ 614,906 $ 196,840 32.01 SANCHEZ STEPHANIE A/SANCHEZ CHRIS 22 537006140749~15 0.31 391 IMP 16628 KARUN MALHOTRA AND MONICA K 3509 WENNINGTON TRCE 06/27/16 56332 RES $ 197,743 $ 61,200 30.95 SANCHO RACHELLE 22 543010443128 0.04 197 IMP 06665 PEARSON CHARLES MICHAEL 10335 VIRGINIA PINE LN~898~1 03/25/16 56007 RES $ 220,111 $ 61,400 27.89 SANDERS LARRY J 12 316308981112~3 A 0.26 652 IMP 17822 HEE YANG LEE AND MI SOON LEE 715 MALLORY MANOR CT 06/17/16 56313 RES $ 557,633 $ 193,920 34.78 SANJAY SINGHAL AND RAJNI SINGHAL 11 004000391309 0.40 596 IMP 00774 RNTR-3 LLC 1429 BRIDGES AVE~138~14TH 01/08/16 55769 RES $ 31,852 $ 17,440 54.75 SANUSI MOHAMMED TOYIN 14 013800010757 0.35 224 IMP 17814 MARTIN K DUNCAN AND JACKIE W DUNCAN 840 OAKHAVEN DR 06/09/16 56315 RES $ 389,166 $ 121,320 31.17 SARAH HAILEY AND RIDLEY HAILEY 22 345112180222 0.65 355 IMP 16963 MACK JOEL 662 662 KENNEDY ST~111~14TH 06/15/16 56339 RES $ 22,267 $ 10,120 45.45 SARGEANT BEVERLY/SARGEANT LLOYD 14 011100061058 0.10 573 IMP 01734 BANK OF AMERICA NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 6851 ROSWELL RD 02/01/16 55830 RES $ 65,808 $ 32,000 48.63 SARPONG KWAME 17 007300050183~UN 18 BLDG A 0.03 337 IMP 13322 REGINA COLLINS N/K/A REGINA GIVENS 301 WARM SPRINGS CIR 05/20/16 56194 RES $ 68,085 $ 26,000 38.19 SARRAF-MAMOURI SAEIDEH 12 203104200436 0.02 430 IMP 12394 DENNIS M FINK AND DEIDRA K FINK 725 WEYBRIDGE PL~99~1ST 05/16/16 56181 RES $ 531,697 $ 214,520 40.35 SASZI BRANDON 11 029200991905~LOT 527 0.38 271 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 62 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 14259 COLLINS MAURICE D 2907 EDGEWATER ST 05/20/16 56209 RES $ 169,760 $ 63,440 37.37 SAVAGE LATANJA T 14F0140 LL2821~86 0.27 290 IMP 16638 YUNGUI HU AND XIAOFANG LIU 5561 JULIAN PL 06/29/16 56338 RES $ 402,829 $ 142,920 35.48 SAYER LORRAINE 17 006900030900 0.03 452 IMP 04261 GULAS ANTHEA A 3445 STRATFORD RD~45~17 02/26/16 55912 RES $ 206,975 $ 76,800 37.11 SCALES CAROLINE SHELBY 17 004500011628~UNIT 1606 0.02 176 IMP 04688 WALLACE LINDSEY S 763 CONFEDERATE AVE~23~14 02/26/16 55893 RES $ 217,666 $ 68,640 31.53 SCARBROUGH MARK A/ALLISON S 14 002300060214~PORTION OF LOTS 27 0.16 539 IMP 02298 CONNELL JEFFREY S 240 FARM TRAK 01/29/16 55838 RES $ 319,989 $ 98,080 30.65 SCHEEL NANCY P/UTSMAN AMY R 12 171303000354 0.41 382 IMP 14424 BARNETT REBECCA 778 CHARLES ALLEN DRIVE NE UNIT 05/27/16 56232 RES $ 270,869 $ 100,640 37.15 SCHEINBERG KELLY 14 004800260021 0.02 261 IMP 09723 GOLD JEFFREY S 595 BRIDGEWATER DRIVE 04/15/16 56102 RES $ 470,826 $ 148,760 31.60 SCHER JOHATHAN P/SCHER ANDREA 17 013100050134 0.44 209 IMP 02525 YANG OUPEI 7247 RIVERSIDE DR~128~17 02/01/16 55850 RES $ 455,507 $ 142,440 31.27 SCHIEFLEY MICHAEL/CESARE ANDREA 17 012800010067~5 0.72 470 IMP 06020 CALHOUN JR JACK J 495 WYNCOURTNEY DR~75~17TH 03/16/16 55965 RES $ 375,824 $ 121,960 32.45 SCHLEIFER MICHAEL S 17 007500010326~10, BLK B, UNIT SIX 0.41 459 IMP 04090 MIZELL III CHARLES 850 PIEDMONT AVE~49~14TH 02/26/16 55903 RES $ 563,427 $ 134,840 23.93 SCHMID JAY 14 004900331185~UNIT 3105 0.04 537 IMP 08107 FIRST CAPITAL AS TRUSTEE FOR LETURA 14412 CLUB CIR 04/05/16 56030 RES $ 576,525 $ 246,520 42.76 SCHNEIDER BARBARA J/ROBERT S 22 522006820614 0.59 411 IMP 05055 POWELL ALAN D 4207 HARRIS RIDGE CT~552~1ST 03/07/16 55936 RES $ 220,004 $ 58,760 26.71 SCHNEIDER DIANNE 12 223505520323~LOT 32 0.26 74 IMP 18702 BODLOVIC STEPHEN V 208 BRIGHTON PT 06/24/16 56346 RES $ 135,368 $ 48,800 36.05 SCHNEIDER JULIE NAN 17 0032 LL1153 0.03 272 IMP 00954 SMITH DARLENE B 8325 RIVERTOWN RD 01/28/16 55810 RES $ 105,589 $ 35,800 33.91 SCHNEIDER RYAN 07 190200870479 2.70 204 IMP 14238 ARBOUR JR GERARD J 6700 ROSWELL ROAD, #26B 05/19/16 56205 RES $ 118,100 $ 37,360 31.63 SCHOENFELD SAMANTHA J 17 007300030292 0.02 205 IMP 10681 REDMOND RYAN A 04/29/16 56137 RES $ 55,298 $ 22,880 41.38 SCHOTTLAND JOSEPH 14 014500030244 0.44 204 IMP 11146 SANTOS PETER 32 PEACHTREE ST 04/26/16 56106 RES $ 58,372 $ 28,440 48.72 SCHROEDER LINDA/SCHROEDER PAUL 14 007800130763 0.01 589 IMP 05913 477 OVERBROOK LLC 477 OVERBROOK DR~146~17TH 03/18/16 55971 RES $ 758,485 $ 261,560 34.48 SCHUMANN KEITH W/SIMON MATTHEW M 17 014600020387~LOT 25, BL. E 0.17 68 IMP 10112 DUNCAN DANIEL 289 ORMOND ST 04/21/16 56078 RES $ 382,941 $ 98,560 25.74 SCHWARTZ HENRY DAVID/SCHWARTZ 14 004300050260 0.09 636 IMP 03446 IVIE III JOSEPH P 411 10TH ST 02/04/16 55877 RES $ 166,194 $ 68,960 41.49 SCOTT ALANA M 17 005400100098~UN 1 0.02 207 IMP 04752 THOMAS CHESTER 220 RENAISSANCE PKWY 03/04/16 55919 RES $ 172,532 $ 53,640 31.09 SCOTT BLAKE RAMBO JR 14 005000130609~UN 1108 0.02 459 IMP 12340 KING PATTI T 175 SHELLI LN~391~1ST 05/13/16 56184 RES $ 337,594 $ 138,760 41.10 SCOTT EDWARD T 12 188403910100~LOT 10 0.16 127 IMP 11094 PATTERSON BRUCE 4195 WEST STUBBS ROAD~165~9F 03/01/16 56136 RES $ 142,056 $ 37,080 26.10 SCOTT HERMON C 09F420001651426~LOT 22 0.25 527 IMP 04965 ALLEN JUDITH E 385 15TH ST~148~17TH 03/04/16 55932 RES $ 388,198 $ 152,240 39.22 SCOTT SHAWN 17 014800051190~74 0.02 200 IMP 07409 COLBERT ERIN 1995 MILTON TERRACE SE TER~55 & 03/25/16 56009 RES $ 67,356 $ 15,360 22.80 SCOTT STEFANNIE 14 005500140686~UN 3105 HILL STREET 0.02 25 IMP 08554 WOODS BRENNAN 655 MEAD ST~23~14TH 04/08/16 56047 RES $ 208,141 $ 73,640 35.38 SCOUT MATTHEW 14 002300021570~UN 69 0.02 584 IMP 01916 ARNOLD NEAL 10800 ELLICOT WAY~168 AND 188~1ST 01/25/16 55831 RES $ 250,970 $ 64,800 25.82 SCRUGGS DAVID/COLLEEN 11 047001681301~66 0.04 354 IMP 15520 TOMS ROGER T 13653 WEYCROFT CIR~902~2 05/06/16 56253 RES $ 229,256 $ 85,400 37.25 SCUDELLARI ANNAMARIE/SCUDELLARI PAUL 22 525009021056~136 0.17 146 IMP 16320 HARDEMAN DORA M 4230 RICKENBACKER WAY~95~17 06/08/16 56327 RES $ 313,353 $ 140,960 44.98 SCYLLA VENTURES LLC 17 009500040519 0.48 529 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 63 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 02018 PAYROVI KAMBIZ 2010 NORTHWICK PASS WAY 01/07/16 55831 RES $ 523,229 $ 194,760 37.22 SE HOME SOLUTION LLC 11 021400640333 0.28 25 IMP 18110 RYAN W BUSS AND MEGHAN C BUSS 11 SAINT CLAIRE LN~7~17 06/30/16 56359 RES $ 192,016 $ 68,360 35.60 SECK KENDA 17 000700070414~UNIT 2 BLDG E 0.04 67 IMP 00110 PATTON STACY R 1629 ACADEMY SQ~158~14TH 01/06/16 55742 RES $ 324,428 $ 97,560 30.07 SEEB DOUGLAS H/DERDERIAN JEANNE 14 015800110297~18 0.16 386 IMP 11324 ROMM GLEN J 177 TRIPLE CROWN CT~775~2ND 04/29/16 56124 RES $ 875,553 $ 220,400 25.17 SEENEY ERIK/SEENEY ANDREA 22 396007750694~LOT 92 1.07 572 IMP 11373 STEIN TERRY H 1525 BAKERS GLEN DR~384~18 AKA 6 04/15/16 56109 RES $ 488,699 $ 173,920 35.59 SEESINK ARJON/SEESINK ADEKEMI 06 038300040273~LOT 27, BLOCK A 0.92 92 IMP 17967 KARCSH JON 860 PEACHTREE ST~49~14 06/23/16 56321 RES $ 236,406 $ 90,520 38.29 SEFIAN ALEXANDER R/SEFIAN GREGORY 14 004900014278 0.02 291 IMP 09477 LIN HSIAO PING 105 VICARAGE CT~1126 & 1163~2ND 04/26/16 56097 RES $ 330,560 $ 123,160 37.26 SEGUEIROS PAUL ZORILLA 21 575311260340~20 0.21 699 IMP 13229 LINDSAY ANN GRUETER NKA LINDSAY ANN 198 PEACHTREE HOLLOW CT NE 05/19/16 56193 RES $ 199,862 $ 63,960 32.00 SEHGAL ACHINT 17 002000070276 0.10 524 IMP 40571 1177 LOGAN NW CIR IND $ 1,125,485 $ 324,000 28.79 SELIG ENTERPRISES INC 17 0193 LL1133 1.40 IMP 07954 WILTON HINES FORD HOWARD LLC A 130 26TH ST 03/24/16 56009 RES $ 103,042 $ 42,760 41.50 SEPICH OKSANA 17 014700060549~UN 410 0.03 571 IMP 06855 CAPALLEJA LEANDRO 3324 PEACHTREE RD 03/25/16 55995 RES $ 203,107 $ 73,960 36.41 SEPNIESKI JOSHUA 17 0062 LL5454 0.02 607 IMP 16810 GALLA MICHAEL C 400 VILLAGE PKWY 06/23/16 56328 RES $ 354,166 $ 94,280 26.62 SEREDNI ERICA MARIA 14 001800100140 0.03 306 IMP 22333 ANDREA L WEITZMAN AND WILLIAM M 1225 PARKMONT DR~562~1 06/30/16 56475 RES $ 146,654 $ 59,320 40.45 SERGILE DAVID R 12 228205620034 0.21 296 IMP 04732 CLUCK JASON W 235 COLES HILL CT~284~1 03/01/16 55904 RES $ 439,423 $ 158,440 36.06 SERTL ELIZABETH G 11 082102840753~131 & C 0.37 280 IMP 18506 BRIAN F OLASOV AND MARIE TENAGLIA- 7445 STONEYKIRK CLOSE~338~6TH 06/28/16 56347 RES $ 511,631 $ 169,800 33.19 SESHAN SATYANARAYANAN/RAGHAVENDRAN 06 033800040030~16 0.77 57 IMP 13145 WISEMAN CHAD 821 RALPH MCGILL BLVD 05/20/16 56191 RES $ 125,277 $ 49,480 39.50 SESSIONS WENDY MARIE 14 001800101635 0.02 173 IMP 17734 MILLAR SHIRLEY G 10375 MEDRIDGE CIR 06/21/16 56314 RES $ 310,356 $ 94,400 30.42 SEYEDI MOHAMMAD 11 082103031980 0.18 73 IMP 02997 CSFR COLFIN AMERICAN INVESTORS TRS LLC 3537 DEVON CHASE ROAD 02/16/16 55862 RES $ 115,395 $ 39,920 34.59 SHAAKIR ABDUL 13 0097 LL0834~175 0.14 556 IMP 14196 HURST JOHN 735 NETTLEBROOK LN 05/12/16 56207 RES $ 707,632 $ 230,240 32.54 SHAH APURVA/SHAH KIMBERLY L 22 459007450846 1.01 1 IMP 11860 SFUGARAS DREW 04/29/16 56143 RES $ 320,268 $ 105,480 32.93 SHAHEEN FRANK P/SHAHEEN TERESA H 17 014900071189 0.05 494 IMP 08249 ROSE RICHARD C 522 PEACHTREE BATTLE AVE~144~17TH 04/11/16 56052 RES $ 1,045,507 $ 361,670 34.59 SHAILENDRA AMANDA 17 014400040593~10/8 0.57 103 IMP 18334 LENAWAY DENNIS D 4175 FALLS RIDGE DR~111~1ST 06/30/16 56350 RES $ 662,366 $ 210,320 31.75 SHAPIRO EDWARD DEAN/LOGINOVA SHAPIRO 11 030001111149~LOT 292, BLK B, THE 0.53 137 IMP 17288 DE LA CRUZ SILVIA 270 17TH ST 06/17/16 56309 RES $ 354,857 $ 98,000 27.62 SHARMA ARUN/SHARMA ANITA 17 010800017892 0.04 191 IMP 12879 BRANDLEY MELISSA E 1055 PIEDMONT AVE 05/17/16 56182 RES $ 332,070 $ 111,560 33.60 SHARMA MEDHAVI/SARASWAT AVINASH 17 010600093796 0.03 52 IMP 00947 ODESS CAITLIN M 1080 HIDDEN POND LN~394~1ST 01/26/16 55800 RES $ 280,210 $ 92,000 32.83 SHARMA RAJESH 12 186303940276~27 0.21 25 IMP 03847 KELLY BRIAN M 1067 ALTA AVE 02/26/16 55900 RES $ 148,321 $ 54,360 36.65 SHARRARD KATHERINE A 14 001400081286~UN 9 0.02 37 IMP 08722 ESTENSON KENNETH C 985 BUCKINGHAM CIR~180~17TH 03/31/16 56057 RES $ 2,140,166 $ 538,000 25.14 SHASHA DANIEL 17 018000010575 2.10 375 IMP 14827 JACKSON MARGARET DALLAS 4545 WIEUCA RD 05/26/16 56249 RES $ 293,753 $ 99,680 33.93 SHEALY JOSHUA/SHEALY CHRISTINE 17 006500110136 0.05 27 IMP 06981 PEACHTREE RESIDENTIAL MODELS LLC 16350 LACONIA LN~240 & 241~2, SECT. 03/25/16 55988 RES $ 689,619 $ 254,200 36.86 SHEFFIELD ABIGAIL P/ROBERT REID 22 452002400494~32, PHASE II, THE 1.86 498 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 64 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 04802 LYNCH JAMES D 350 WYNLAND TRCE~337~6TH 03/04/16 55915 RES $ 455,293 $ 169,160 37.15 SHELDON WENDY 06 033700020173~LOT 17, BLOCK B 0.57 407 IMP 03597 AYMAN PROPERTIES7680 LLC 2520 ROXBURGH DR 02/19/16 55875 RES $ 355,158 $ 153,960 43.35 SHELKOFF MORRIE S 12 275107590161~LOT 40, BLK D 0.72 99 IMP 09900 KENTON CHARLES 04/21/16 56088 RES $ 298,926 $ 143,840 48.12 SHELLHOUSE JESSICA H/SHELLHOUSE KYLE P 12 205004730933 0.90 250 IMP 00742 JACK A/K/A LOREN J JACK JR LOREN L 199 14TH ST~106~17TH 01/15/16 55788 RES $ 198,156 $ 49,240 24.85 SHEN YAO 17 010600062817~UN 1404 0.02 89 IMP 19603 CAMPINS ELIZABETH 1903 NORTH AVE~175~14 06/29/16 56373 RES $ 25,562 $ 6,600 25.82 SHENOI LLC 14 017500110221~LOT 12 - BLOCK L 0.22 304 IMP 00095 LEVEL TEAM CONTRACTING LLC 1308 MORNINGSIDE DR~2~17TH 01/04/16 55740 RES $ 1,056,658 $ 302,640 28.64 SHEPARD LARRY 17 000200110058~9/9 0.20 523 IMP 04870 BLANC JEAN-CHRISTOPHE 1190 WINTHROPE CHASE DR~1123~2 03/04/16 55936 RES $ 258,703 $ 81,680 31.57 SHEPHERD ANDREW THOMAS 22 496011231531~67 0.12 76 IMP 06246 FLYNN PAUL SPENCER 1101 JUNIPER STREET NE #101 03/22/16 55968 RES $ 236,665 $ 76,560 32.35 SHER ADAM/MAYORAS JENNIFER 17 010600065000 0.02 546 IMP 07159 SCOTT A DAVIES AND CAROL A DAVIES 260 BAYFIELD COURT~969~2ND 03/17/16 55981 RES $ 717,214 $ 217,080 30.27 SHERIF SAMY 22 526009690312~10 1.13 174 IMP 03109 KAYUMOV ARTUR A 3480 PATTERSTONE DR 02/16/16 55863 RES $ 223,033 $ 93,840 42.07 SHERMAN MARIANNA 11 007100130310 0.15 44 IMP 09910 KNEELAND III CHARLES STEVENSON 44 PEACHTREE PL~106 & 107~17 04/22/16 56101 RES $ 347,342 $ 112,400 32.36 SHI YIFU 17 010700064267~1634 0.03 311 IMP 03344 PICKENS EDITH S 2277 PEACHTREE ROAD NE 02/17/16 55874 RES $ 288,777 $ 97,000 33.59 SHIN HYE K/SHIN RACHEL H 17 011100070748~UN 810 0.03 403 IMP 13936 LEE JONG HUN 11930 ASPEN FOREST DR~233~1ST 05/25/16 56222 RES $ 360,901 $ 131,040 36.31 SHIN YOUNG SHOOL 11 064002331141 0.13 572 IMP 13209 LARRY S WEINREB AND LISA R TERRY 225 ROD COURT~870~1ST 05/23/16 56204 RES $ 502,736 $ 190,240 37.84 SHIROISHI ELIZABETH R/SHIROISHI JASON W 12 304008700552~LOT 331 0.34 666 IMP 04192 PARRILLO JAMES ADAM 15 IRON BOUND PL 02/26/16 55898 RES $ 192,624 $ 56,920 29.55 SHOCKLEY DANIKA 17 022000081677 0.03 162 IMP 11346 DRISKELL MARY MARGARET H 747 RALPH MCGILL BLVD~18~14TH 05/02/16 56125 RES $ 168,206 $ 53,200 31.63 SHOEMAKER MATTHEW X 14 001800090721 0.02 411 IMP 14832 CANADY MICHAEL J 22 CANTEY PL 06/01/16 56241 RES $ 150,644 $ 46,640 30.96 SHULER STEPHANIE 17 018500050220 0.03 128 IMP 05594 POWERS PAULA G 13341 MARRYWOOD CT 03/10/16 55947 RES $ 208,094 $ 72,040 34.62 SHYAMALA VIDYA 22 526009752971 0.04 233 IMP 08881 GEIGER CHRISTOPHER E 2921 LENOX ROAD NE, UNIT 403 04/01/16 56041 RES $ 249,120 $ 80,280 32.23 SIE IYENEOMI 17 0007 LL2103 0.04 694 IMP 08144 JENKINS RALPH H 39 WOODCREST AVE 03/31/16 56017 RES $ 1,269,989 $ 394,960 31.10 SILBER JULIE C/SILBER JUSTIN A 17 010900030407 0.27 264 IMP 02439 DAVIS JOSHUA K 998 SEABOARD AVE~186~17 02/05/16 55839 RES $ 400,550 $ 94,600 23.62 SILCOTT ALETHEIA D 17 018600030056 0.25 5 IMP 08149 MUKKATIRA SUNDEEP 2657 LENOX RD 03/31/16 56033 RES $ 131,608 $ 33,900 25.76 SIMBAHAN JUAN DIEGO-ALLAREY 17 000600011377~UN 111 0.02 524 IMP 01993 LS LAND COMPANY 3101 HOPE ST~99~14TH 01/08/16 55821 RES $ 59,723 $ 21,000 35.16 SIMMONS INVESTMENT HOLDINGS LLLP III 14 009900010747 0.21 355 IMP 01991 LS LAND COMPANY 3775 STEPHANIE DR~4~14TH 01/08/16 55821 RES $ 44,793 $ 13,080 29.20 SIMMONS INVESTMENT HOLDINGS LLLP III 14F000400030107~102 0.30 356 IMP 06722 HUTCHENS JOHN MICHAEL 799 BARNETT ST 03/11/16 55989 RES $ 147,855 $ 54,720 37.01 SIMMONS JR DAVID A 14 001600041452~UN 1 0.03 607 IMP 17441 FINLEY J DAVID 874 PENN AVENUE NE~49~14 06/27/16 56338 RES $ 640,017 $ 239,840 37.47 SIMON KELLIE B/SIMON STEVEN D 14 004900030191 0.25 683 IMP 06296 RATNER JILL L 4715 KITTY HAWK DR 03/17/16 55965 RES $ 569,971 $ 171,000 30.00 SIMON PAMELA W/SIMON ROBERT 17 001400050029 0.28 30 IMP 02978 CLENDENIN SUSAN P 3334 PEACHTREE RD 01/29/16 55838 RES $ 176,681 $ 63,600 36.00 SIMONIS ADRIAN 17 006200021971~UN 1211 0.02 337 IMP 03354 MCGAUGHY FALON NOEL 115 PEACHTREE PL~79~14 02/25/16 55886 RES $ 144,471 $ 44,720 30.95 SIMONS JOSHUA COREY 14 007900121498~UN 709 0.20 20 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 65 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 07262 SCOTT JR BOBBY LEE 2161 PEACHTREE RD 03/24/16 55999 RES $ 170,162 $ 53,520 31.45 SIMS JOHNATHAN/SIMS JOHN 17 011100200444~UN 604 0.03 428 IMP 14662 OCTAVIA ROUSE F/K/A OCTAVIA M WARE 250 PHARR ROAD NE UNIT #315~99~17 05/31/16 56239 RES $ 178,311 $ 68,360 38.34 SINCLAIR SIAN F 17 009900070496 0.02 647 IMP 05869 THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON TRUST 5495 MORNING CREEK CIR 03/04/16 55973 RES $ 49,367 $ 22,560 45.70 SINGH ANIL 09F250901050118 0.30 1 IMP 12717 ROBINSON DANIEL PATRICK 1257 LIBERTY PKWY 05/12/16 56173 RES $ 188,093 $ 54,160 28.79 SINGH ARGOYA 17 0221 LL1832 0.02 284 IMP 09029 SCHUTT ANDREW J 125 BRIGHTON CIR 04/18/16 56065 RES $ 413,351 $ 145,240 35.14 SINGH KELSEY M/SINGH MARC A 22 432211740278 0.51 645 IMP 03262 CRP EAH GR II LLC 631 MABRY RD 02/23/16 55883 RES $ 901,993 $ 376,000 41.69 SINGH SACHINDRA 17 0033 LL0451~LOT 11 0.41 175 IMP 19309 DAVID A PRIEM NICOLE L PRIEM 965 SAMPLES LN 06/10/16 56378 RES $ 281,603 $ 101,840 36.16 SINGLETARY PARKER/SINGLETARY TED 17 0227 LL0523 0.12 174 IMP 06564 AMEY JENNIFER S 7714 SYLVANER LN 03/10/16 55993 RES $ 178,980 $ 60,420 33.76 SINGLETON RAICHELLE 09C110000463450 0.21 243 IMP 09358 JOHNSON CANDACE N 2555 FLAT SHOALS RD 04/12/16 56071 RES $ 72,761 $ 28,560 39.25 SINGLETON TALFENA 13 0125 LL4030 0.05 460 IMP 10524 SCOTT M BLALOCK AND BLAKELY G BLALOCK 733 CHEROKEE AVE 04/29/16 56125 RES $ 566,805 $ 131,920 23.27 SIPP NIA 14 004300040410 0.23 243 IMP 10054 BAUM DAVID A 720 STURGES WAY 04/22/16 56089 RES $ 935,507 $ 236,920 25.33 SISK MATTHEW 11 033101060257 0.84 443 IMP 04046 GREVEMBERG H SCOTT 384 PAVILLION ST~43~14TH 03/04/16 55914 RES $ 301,931 $ 107,000 35.44 SIZEMORE EMMA K/ELROD STEVEN A 14 004300020479 0.06 545 IMP 16011 GROOM MICHAEL J 3245 WOLF CLUB LN 06/10/16 56288 RES $ 245,844 $ 89,880 36.56 SKELTON MONIFA P 14F0122 LL2120 0.34 25 IMP 07919 MOSCOVITZ BRIAN J 955 JUNIPER ST 03/25/16 56009 RES $ 173,822 $ 53,080 30.54 SKIPPER LARRY THOMAS 17 010600310208 0.02 547 IMP 06467 USHAKOV AND LILYA USHAKOV VLADIMIR 3035 BAYWOOD WAY 03/23/16 55973 RES $ 310,288 $ 94,120 30.33 SKUMS PAVEL 22 373112830455 0.14 593 IMP 16355 TRAWICK ELIZABETH A 847 SAINT CHARLES AVE 06/17/16 56315 RES $ 164,533 $ 47,880 29.10 SLATER CATHERINE G 14 001700090847 0.02 631 IMP 07389 TODD HOUGHTON AND JASON STEVENS 2049 VILLAGE CREST DR 03/24/16 55988 RES $ 346,941 $ 98,040 28.26 SLOVIN JOSHUA 17 0256 LL1160 0.11 212 IMP 20427 TALLLEY SARAH E 600 BRICKWORKS CIR~LOT 19~14 06/24/16 56431 RES $ 215,881 $ 91,880 42.56 SMIGA NATHAN ALAN 14 001900080994~UNIT 6309 THE 0.02 276 IMP 08302 MADISON ASHLEY 7636 RUTGERS CIR~26 AND 33~9TH 03/25/16 56054 RES $ 82,187 $ 22,400 27.25 SMITH ABDUL-HAKEEM 09F070000262871~UNIT 2103 0.03 197 IMP 16006 SNYDER CHARLES EDWARD 50 BISCAYNE DR~111~17 06/10/16 56276 RES $ 342,304 $ 128,400 37.51 SMITH BARNETT F/SMITH SHERRY 17 011100053231 0.04 159 IMP 03373 KESSLER ADAM H 319 THE CHACE~36~17TH 02/16/16 55884 RES $ 246,306 $ 86,040 34.93 SMITH CHRISTINA E 17 003600040321~TOWNHOUSE #1, 0.04 211 IMP 05671 GUZMAN MANUEL O 300 PEACHTREE ST 03/11/16 55950 RES $ 87,759 $ 26,760 30.49 SMITH JOHN 14 007800141117~UN 8F 0.01 167 IMP 00973 LUANN M DRUCKER AND MARTIN R DRUCKER 130 STRAUSS LN~344~6TH 01/25/16 55804 RES $ 1,181,034 $ 274,160 23.21 SMITH JOHN D 06 0344 LL0193~6 1.29 528 IMP 17735 POWELL (N/K/A GREENE) TIFFANY 3300 REGATTA GRV~757~2ND 06/15/16 56312 RES $ 191,497 $ 64,840 33.86 SMITH JORDAN A 22 539007571277 0.02 61 IMP 09137 PRIDGEN ZACHARY 290 ROLLING MIST 04/15/16 56067 RES $ 329,057 $ 109,040 33.14 SMITH LINDSEY C/SMITH NICK K 11 016100790214 0.35 301 IMP 07144 KEENER BRICE P 11216 SNOWY OWL LN~904~1 03/15/16 56007 RES $ 258,745 $ 90,080 34.81 SMITH NATALIE R 12 313009043003 0.03 108 IMP 02241 FREIDANK ROBERT M 34 GLENALD WAY NW 02/05/16 55842 RES $ 159,243 $ 47,640 29.92 SMITH THOMAS HUNTER/JUDY/HUNTER 17 019400050260 0.03 132 IMP 16090 VAN DER WALT ALETTA CECILIA 1985 BRANCH VALLEY DRIVE 05/26/16 56277 RES $ 237,714 $ 84,000 35.34 SMITH-ALVES BRENDA L 12 255106650752 0.44 311 IMP 12486 HAMILTON IV THOMAS H 05/12/16 56169 RES $ 354,273 $ 134,640 38.00 SNAPP GERALD COREY 12 172102970482 0.42 337 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 66 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 18242 WAN SHIRLEY 9265 MARTIN RD 06/29/16 56348 RES $ 317,327 $ 96,120 30.29 SNELL BUCKY 12 254306290394 0.60 664 IMP 10702 ABSHER MICHAEL TODD 3449 LATHENVIEW CT~973, 1043 (1ST 05/02/16 56132 RES $ 165,447 $ 61,200 36.99 SNIGIREVA ILONA 22 543010444225~146 0.04 162 IMP 10090 BUCHANAN BRIE 258 ESTORIA ST 04/18/16 56076 RES $ 341,827 $ 120,240 35.18 SOBBOTT DANIEL S 14 002000110483 0.06 440 IMP 01519 IH2 PROPERTY TRS 2 LP 1665 ABNER CT 01/18/16 55796 RES $ 19,282 $ 10,000 51.86 SOGBESAN OLANREWAJU C 17 025100050104 0.32 167 IMP 06038 LOBOS PROPERTIES LLC 03/15/16 55964 RES $ 374,800 $ 137,240 36.62 SOMANNA DHANANJAYA 17 018200020739 0.37 478 IMP 03670 DITTRICH SETH 326 NELSON ST 02/17/16 55881 RES $ 184,119 $ 39,320 21.36 SOMMERVILLE JAMAL L 14 008400170233~UN 312 0.02 359 IMP 11812 JONES DAVID MARK 2150 BLACKHEATH TRCE~1167~2ND 05/05/16 56146 RES $ 1,004,864 $ 387,640 38.58 SONG MINGQING 21 570011670419 0.50 576 IMP 04035 MAHINDRAVADA VENKATARAMANA 8555 RIVER WALK LANDING~513~1ST 03/01/16 55909 RES $ 230,517 $ 92,080 39.94 SONG SOOL KEE 11 134005130327~150/A 0.31 419 IMP 03756 YOO WON KEUN 10540 ARLINGTON POINT 02/23/16 55887 RES $ 276,018 $ 90,920 32.94 SONG XUHAN 11 068002421232 0.08 333 IMP 09300 STEWART DANA L 04/12/16 56061 RES $ 319,961 $ 89,680 28.03 SONGER MICAH D 12 161202690157 0.25 300 IMP 12046 MATTHEW ANTHONY GENCO AND PAGE 125 BELMONT TRC 05/10/16 56162 RES $ 493,771 $ 139,960 28.35 SONI TANUSHREE/SONI SAMIT 17 012500100168 0.20 600 IMP 06704 PULTE HOME CORPORATION 108 AUSTIN DR DR~36~17TH 03/28/16 56000 RES $ 622,187 $ 220,080 35.37 SONNENFELDT-GODDARD 17 003600020612~12 0.18 162 IMP 13369 TENENBAUM DAVID V 442 CALTON HILL CT 05/06/16 56199 RES $ 495,194 $ 191,640 38.70 SORCABAL CAROL L/SORCABAL CHARLES J 22 474006750161 1.01 533 IMP 06967 NIMTZ AMY S 200 RIVER VISTA DR 03/31/16 56004 RES $ 227,187 $ 75,920 33.42 SORIANO MORRIS J/LAUREN BETH/SHERRI O 17 0211 LL2907~UN 322 0.03 294 IMP 16640 SHARAPAN LEV 2545 RUNIC WAY~920~1 06/29/16 56343 RES $ 264,439 $ 117,800 44.55 SOTOLA BERNARD C 11 006100110299~32, F 0.46 336 IMP 05719 CALEAST NAT LLC 1095 RIVER INDUSTRIAL BLVD SE 03/11/16 55950 IND $ 1,447,105 $ 421,240 29.11 SOUTHEASTERN FREIGHT LINES INC 14 0005 LL0271, 0304 16.00 439 IMP 12211 PAUL M ADLER AND CYNTHIA P ADLER 185 BRIGHTON CIR 05/09/16 56155 RES $ 409,942 $ 155,880 38.02 SOUZA RENAN Q/SOUZA EDINALDO Q 22 432211740211 0.34 396 IMP 12939 EATON LAURA D 61 BELLE ISLE RD~93~17 05/13/16 56176 RES $ 705,115 $ 266,960 37.86 SOZANSKI DANIELA 17 009300022022~7 0.32 27 IMP 17770 WHITTINGTON SUSAN 951 GLENWOOD AVE 06/24/16 56324 RES $ 170,316 $ 59,600 34.99 SPEARS JENNIFER E 14 001200091840 0.03 371 IMP 00416 BURGOON JEFFREY D 571 GLENWOOD PL 01/11/16 55770 RES $ 211,995 $ 62,320 29.40 SPENCER JEFFREY A/SPENCER KELLY 14 001200090149~L 70 0.18 284 IMP 19861 IH2 PROPERTY TRS 2 LP 488 GREY HAWK WAY 06/24/16 56427 RES $ 188,453 $ 74,600 39.59 SPENCER TYREE L 07 140001171080 0.33 609 IMP 17398 STEPHEN D NELSON MILENA T WOLKA 832 STOVALL BLVD~43~17 06/24/16 56323 RES $ 607,386 $ 214,720 35.35 SPRAIN PATRICIA R/SPRAIN JEFFREY R 17 004300040652 0.42 366 IMP 03780 25 KARLAND DRIVE LLC 25 KARLAND DR~98~17 02/25/16 55886 RES $ 409,607 $ 142,400 34.77 SPRATLING CHARLES GRAY 17 009800030129~LOT 15, BLOCK C 0.22 110 IMP 11305 PRICE KEVIN D 5065 SADDLE BRIDGE LN 05/02/16 56120 RES $ 292,452 $ 79,120 27.05 SRINIVASAN PRASANNA VENKATESH 11 047001670551 0.21 423 IMP 01961 GIBSON DAVID S 3728 CRANFORD CT 01/29/16 55822 RES $ 169,810 $ 57,840 34.06 STAELIN HANNAH R 14 0249 LL1423~91 0.24 192 IMP 04741 SR HOMES LLC 9724 COLEMAN RD 03/03/16 55916 RES $ 853,566 $ 258,560 30.29 STAES MICHELLE SAUNDERS/STEVEN 12 171002990640 1.03 591 IMP 12627 COOPER WAYNE P 1755 AZALEA SPRINGS TRL~41~1ST 05/16/16 56184 RES $ 355,072 $ 155,000 43.65 STAMBAUGH MATTHEW/STAMBAUGH MEGAN 12 135500410211~LOT 20, BLOCK E 0.39 96 IMP 10435 RAY KATIE E 13015 CRABAPPLE LAKE DR~400 04/22/16 56082 RES $ 301,030 $ 100,120 33.26 STAMMEN BRENT/STAMMEN BLAKE 12 184404000678 0.14 333 IMP 12763 WOO JOSEPH CHUNGSOO 677 SOMERSET TER NE, #C3 04/29/16 56166 RES $ 156,678 $ 56,960 36.35 STANLEY MARGARET ANN/STANLEY DAVID 14 001700111122 0.01 224 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 67 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 17466 CHAMNESS HELEN M 570 CARYBELL LN~1168 AND 1209~2 05/25/16 56290 RES $ 332,969 $ 134,240 40.32 STANZIANO DEBORAH ANN 22 386111680796~10, BLK D 0.32 548 IMP 18407 EVERBANK 1961 MARVIN LN 06/24/16 56357 RES $ 23,888 $ 10,040 42.03 STAR INVESTMENTS PARTNERS 14 019900010100 0.35 372 IMP 06315 PAIGE CYNTHIA 270 BUCKINGHAM LN 03/21/16 55970 RES $ 156,307 $ 70,040 44.81 STATEN TITO 07 270001691967 0.19 614 IMP 15806 ANDREW D KALAJIAN AND KAY M KALAJIAN 2085 PARK GLENN DR~126 & 159~1ST 06/10/16 56285 RES $ 353,121 $ 178,960 50.68 STAUBLY CHRISTOPHER M 11 034301590523~48 BLK A 0.70 192 IMP 01199 GOODMAN WHITE ENTERPRISES LLC 350 EPPLINGTON DR 01/27/16 55807 RES $ 1,818,325 $ 500,320 27.52 STAUDE GREGORY P/STAUDE ALISA N 17 013700030510 0.46 175 IMP 11942 ANDERSON TED R 4009 STEEPLECHASE DR~1248~2ND 05/09/16 56157 RES $ 140,918 $ 53,760 38.15 STEELE ANDREW 22 450212480678~201 BLDG 200 0.03 287 IMP 04662 UNDERWOOD GERALD VANN 137 MOBILE AVE~102~17TH 02/26/16 55915 RES $ 505,639 $ 186,120 36.81 STEELE JAMIE DALTON 17 010200080011~PEACHTREE HILLS 0.29 552 IMP 03760 MARSH ASHLEY LAUREN 225 MIDVALE DRIVE NE 02/22/16 55878 RES $ 577,522 $ 166,840 28.89 STEELE THOMAS/STEELE MEREDITH 17 009500040287 0.23 590 IMP 06764 LAKE JR CHARLES E 943 PEACHTREE ST~106~17 02/08/16 56000 RES $ 197,920 $ 73,080 36.92 STEFAN GHEORGHE 17 010600081734~UN 1304 0.02 113 IMP 06029 RACZ ASHLEY 11780 HIGHLAND COLONY DR 03/21/16 55969 RES $ 358,749 $ 145,200 40.47 STEINER MCCARTHY ASHLEE M/JONATHAN D 12 135200380284 0.42 279 IMP 10103 DONOVAN KENNETH 170 BOULEVARD SE 04/15/16 56079 RES $ 214,003 $ 66,480 31.06 STENSLAND DANIEL 14 0045 LL2005 0.02 119 IMP 17750 BALSAM JOHN E 6230 RIVER SHORE PARKWAY 06/24/16 56323 RES $ 568,457 $ 195,600 34.41 STEPENS JACK 17 013200040068 0.66 116 IMP 06134 D R HORTON INC A DELAWARE 7516 TOCCOA CIR~36~9F 03/17/16 55976 RES $ 191,154 $ 73,800 38.61 STEPHENS ELVIA M/STEPHENS FRANCISCO O 09F050000364281~1009 0.21 44 IMP 15210 GRAY LAURENCE O 170 SHELLI LN~391~1 06/03/16 56253 RES $ 286,649 $ 136,720 47.70 STEPHENS ROBERT BRITT 12 188403910035~3 0.18 635 IMP 16327 SPANO ROBERT V 805 PEACHTREE ST~49~14TH 06/10/16 56335 RES $ 495,040 $ 158,520 32.02 STERN SIDNEY H/STERN VALERIE A 14 004900290662~212 0.05 641 IMP 15764 BENJAMIN WORLEY 5615 KAYRON DRIVE~69~17TH 05/31/16 56288 RES $ 366,529 $ 102,400 27.94 STEVE MOLINA 17 006900040065~2 C 0.74 86 IMP 09450 ARRINGTON ASHLEY 2921 LENOX RD~7~17 04/15/16 56074 RES $ 214,096 $ 65,000 30.36 STEVENS ODEH L 17 0007 LL2087 0.03 427 IMP 04455 GAYLE HELENE 411 BEVERLY RD 02/29/16 55909 RES $ 1,047,650 $ 491,200 46.89 STEWART ALEXANDER/AMY FRAZE 17 005600100237 0.29 385 IMP 13862 CARDELLO SALVATORE 850 ARONSON LAKE CT 05/18/16 56215 RES $ 363,649 $ 139,960 38.49 STEWART CHRISTOPHER F/STEWART 22 358011631260 0.58 154 IMP 09589 ROSEBERRY THOMAS D 04/18/16 56074 RES $ 375,132 $ 155,720 41.51 STEWART CURTIS 17 0022 LL2047 0.03 1 IMP 06172 FINCHER RAS 915 MELODY LN~463~1 02/26/16 55963 RES $ 245,596 $ 79,160 32.23 STICKLER STEPHEN RICHARD/ROGERS 12 210304630080 0.45 115 IMP 08226 OWENS II JOHN 3488 AUGUSTA ST.~96~13TH 04/15/16 56058 RES $ 135,905 $ 42,960 31.61 STINSON SERITA MONTINA 13 0096 LL5487~LOT 99 0.10 700 IMP 15789 CAIRNS ROBERT 800 PEACHTREE ST ST~49~14TH 06/10/16 56281 RES $ 135,884 $ 48,600 35.77 STOKAN LOUIS J 14 004900341192~1322 0.02 373 IMP 16871 SAWYER JACYNTH 2665 SHADOW PINE DR~788~1 06/15/16 56338 RES $ 238,525 $ 83,640 35.07 STOKES JENNIFER C/STOKES MATTHEW J 12 291107880460~96B 0.30 570 IMP 10076 BLACK RONALD 5345 STONEWALL TELL RD 04/05/16 56092 RES $ 70,308 $ 24,200 34.42 STONEWALL STATION INC 09F270301230227 2.36 122 IMP 10475 DICKSON JANICE A 799 HAMMOND DR~37~17 04/19/16 56113 RES $ 120,669 $ 33,720 27.94 STOUFFER SARAH R 17 0037 LL3824 0.01 635 IMP 17719 HILL MIRIAM 1213 ALLENE AVE~105~14TH 06/15/16 56315 RES $ 70,809 $ 17,760 25.08 STOVER MARVIN H 14 010500020979 0.03 647 IMP 00235 YOUMANS HOLDINGS LLC 3630 PEACHTREE RD~44~17TH 01/08/16 55788 RES $ 1,443,316 $ 349,120 24.19 STRADIVARIUS LLC 17 0044 LL2926~UN 2004 0.05 97 IMP 05522 NIGEL INVESTMENTS LLC 5654 BRIDGE POINTE DR 03/04/16 55943 RES $ 222,854 $ 75,120 33.71 STRANGE PHILLIP JOSEPH 11 013100480433 0.10 318 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 68 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 09311 DAVIS GARY F 821 RALPH MCGILL BLVD 04/18/16 56064 RES $ 143,976 $ 43,400 30.14 STREET DALE LEIGH 14 001800101353 0.01 33 IMP 18310 GARY JR KENNETH J 9075 BROCKHAM WAY 06/03/16 56353 RES $ 256,097 $ 88,520 34.57 STROOP III JOHN RIDLEY/PEACOCK CONARD 12 317509220482 0.22 91 IMP 40541 6800 LONDONDERRY WY COM $ 213,391 $ 90,120 42.23 STUHRMAN J HENRY/DONNA 09F150800630038 0.23 IMP 04663 AYCOCK KEVIN 645 GREENVIEW AVENUE 03/04/16 55919 RES $ 752,432 $ 226,680 30.13 STUMP JOHN BRADLEY/STUMP NICOLE R 17 004600110460 0.38 7 IMP 09869 CALDWELL KEVIN L 185 HAMILTON WY WAY~1214~2 04/04/16 56085 RES $ 614,454 $ 227,720 37.06 STUNDA JOHN C/STUNDA CATHERINE T 22 358012140816~17 0.44 632 IMP 06016 LINDSEY SHATAVA 221 HOLCOMB FERRY RD 03/18/16 55968 RES $ 104,422 $ 30,560 29.27 STURKIE THOMAS RHOADES 12 229305640682 0.08 40 IMP 13888 MOORE CLINTON ALLEN 14475 EIGHTEENETH FAIRWAY 05/27/16 56225 RES $ 609,657 $ 230,080 37.74 SUCO MICHAEL ANTHONY/ARNOLD SHELLEY 22 539106851331 0.46 474 IMP 16658 MAJOR DAWN 968 SAINT CHARLES AVE~16~14TH 06/02/16 56295 RES $ 112,406 $ 30,400 27.04 SUDEKUM VERONICA LABARGE 14 001600041320 0.01 455 IMP 09895 CAUSEY JEREL L 945 NORTHCLIFFE DR~185~17TH 04/21/16 56093 RES $ 764,695 $ 209,800 27.44 SUGRUE BONNIE GIBSON/SUGRUE RYAN 17 018500010117 0.29 424 IMP 09181 WEINBERG MARK 50 BISCAYNE DR~111~17 04/11/16 56066 RES $ 354,726 $ 128,400 36.20 SUIDAN MUBADDA TAWFIC/EL-KHAZEN 17 011100053397 0.04 81 IMP 18191 KROLL HANNA 06/29/16 56348 RES $ 182,463 $ 72,600 39.79 SUING CAMERON/SUING CLIFFORD 17 0035 LL4931 0.03 691 IMP 16842 LABODA ABBE C H 13825 BRITTLE RD 06/29/16 56339 RES $ 1,754,115 $ 485,120 27.66 SULLIVAN DONNA BLOCKER/SULLIVAN 22 460108170325 5.08 456 IMP 14326 MACE JOYCE 3046 SHINNECOCK HILLS DRIVE 05/23/16 56206 RES $ 489,148 $ 220,280 45.03 SULLIVAN JOANN/SULLIVAN KELLY A 11 094200380624 0.68 474 IMP 17204 RIESER MARY 115 OLD FERRY WY 06/17/16 56308 RES $ 102,277 $ 30,360 29.68 SULLIVAN LAHAMA A 12 229105640213 0.04 518 IMP 14391 PINKSTON ROBERT C 13441 PROVIDENCE RD 05/31/16 56238 RES $ 1,206,753 $ 502,520 41.64 SULLIVAN PATRICK KELLY/SULLIVAN MELISSA 22 462009620754 4.68 228 IMP 14467 BROWN CHRISTINE A 1758 MARIETTA ROAD NW 05/31/16 56235 RES $ 291,782 $ 113,840 39.02 SUMMERLIN LAVELLE/SUMMERLIN TERISA 17 022300010657 0.19 313 IMP 02110 GARMON RONNIE J 391 RALPH MCGILL BLVD 01/29/16 55825 RES $ 125,640 $ 43,280 34.45 SUN XIAOJING 14 004600152477 0.03 313 IMP 20443 PARHO PROPERTIES INC A GEORGIA 4290 NOOR VIEW CT 06/21/16 56406 RES $ 540,907 $ 236,440 43.71 SUNG KIJUNG 11 028001150653 0.28 585 IMP 08743 CARY DANIEL S 2741 ASHLEIGH LN 04/06/16 56040 RES $ 180,705 $ 55,000 30.44 SUNNY SACHDEVA AND AQSA Z FAROOQUI 22 512011212790 0.03 74 IMP 08512 DUPONT EDDIE 360 JOSEPH LOWERY BLVD 04/01/16 56055 RES $ 25,382 $ 8,760 34.51 SUNSHINE INVESTMENTS INTERNATIONAL 14 011400071211 0.07 122 IMP 13878 HUNGRU A SHEEN AND CHINGLUN J CHU 400 PEACHTREE STRA 05/20/16 56212 RES $ 172,392 $ 65,600 38.05 SUPLER JORDAN 14 007900133402 0.02 92 IMP 12713 THE SANTA FE TRAIL LAND COMPANY 462 PACES FERRY RD RD~61~17 05/12/16 56164 COM $ 745,869 $ 230,000 30.84 SURECK PROPERTIES LLC 17 006100140095~M&B 0.05 405 IMP 13257 HOOTS KENT 3844 FAIRHILL PT~975~2ND 05/19/16 56202 RES $ 284,804 $ 145,440 51.07 SUTLIVE MARY K 21 552009750742~UNIT 10 0.04 399 IMP 20788 AGAN CUNEYT 1894 FRANCIS AVE 06/24/16 56414 RES $ 95,111 $ 35,640 37.47 SUTTON DONALD M/SUTTON TIA M 17 022900011543 0.23 203 IMP 10623 RINCON CALDERON ELDER Y 416 TEAL COURT~615 AND 616~1ST 04/27/16 56109 RES $ 96,910 $ 27,880 28.77 SWANSON CRAIG ALAN 12 242606150947 0.02 613 IMP 13404 PARARO STEPHEN W 790 NORTH AVE~17~14TH 05/13/16 56195 RES $ 442,522 $ 103,160 23.31 SWARTZ TRACI R/SWARTZ JEREMY N 14 001700110850 0.04 468 IMP 09781 USA HEALTH PLANS INC 11675 CENTURY DRIVE~1124 02/26/16 56092 COM $ 134,107 $ 59,960 44.71 SYASHVAR LLC 22 496011242280~UN A BLDG 4 0.03 678 IMP 17472 MILLER JOSEPH A 517 MANOR RIDGE DRIVE N.W 06/16/16 56297 RES $ 1,468,542 $ 595,520 40.55 SYMBAS ALICE/SYMBAS NICKOLAS 17 014400030214 0.40 449 IMP 04896 HAYEK JOSEPH M 4105 CHASTAIN PARK CT~95~17TH 03/04/16 55925 RES $ 117,897 $ 35,280 29.92 SYMONS BRITTANY ERIN 17 009500131052~4105 0.02 157 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 69 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 14933 BOLING SUSAN T 3190 ARBORWOODS DR 05/27/16 56232 RES $ 329,667 $ 116,920 35.47 SYMONS SHAYNA L 12 305508710314 0.38 24 IMP 02853 MILTON DEVELOPMENT LLC 554 GABLES RUN 02/11/16 55856 RES $ 796,063 $ 350,760 44.06 SZELL IMRE PAUL/KNAPP STACY 22 380007360308 1.18 187 IMP 10909 BETHKE EDWARD 761 NORTH ELIZABETH PLACE 04/29/16 56131 RES $ 32,257 $ 8,240 25.54 TADAYON RAUMIN 14 017600100064 0.19 74 IMP 04476 KENSPECKLE MULTI-FUNCTIONING FERRELLS' 811 N. ELIZABETH PLACE NW~176~14 03/01/16 55905 RES $ 28,815 $ 7,960 27.62 TADAYON RAUMIN 14 017600090497 0.24 137 IMP 10735 HARVEY JOHN A 375 FARM PATH 04/29/16 56110 RES $ 264,509 $ 86,120 32.56 TAFF JOSHUA 12 171203290030 0.41 514 IMP 04166 TORRES CHARLES 10925 SPOTTED PONY TRL~132~1ST 03/03/16 55915 RES $ 220,513 $ 72,440 32.85 TAGHIPOOR AFSHIN 11 037301530092~LOT 20, BLOCK C 0.28 496 IMP 06268 BRINKMAN KIMBERLY A 8027 WILLOW TREE WAY~1182~2ND 03/18/16 55964 RES $ 427,182 $ 139,320 32.61 TAL GIDON/TAL SHIREL 21 558111820034~3 0.71 41 IMP 13544 ATLANTA 620 #2 CORP A FLORIDA 620 PEACHTREE ST~49~14TH 05/24/16 56212 RES $ 98,664 $ 28,360 28.74 TAM PHEBE 14 004900082812~UN 2016 0.02 447 IMP 10486 BRYANT WILLIAM E 2910 GLENEAGLES POINTE~1122~2ND 04/28/16 56108 RES $ 477,748 $ 177,200 37.09 TAMISIN WINSTON DAVID/BRYAN TRACY M 21 569211220215 0.22 76 IMP 08852 DENT LAUREL A 115 LANSBURGH TURN~9TH~1ST 04/07/16 56056 RES $ 514,867 $ 150,200 29.17 TAN LYE SOON 11 005400090177~LOT 17 0.31 120 IMP 18863 GARCIA BRYAN 3 WALNUT HILL PL NW 06/28/16 56354 RES $ 193,185 $ 55,980 28.98 TANNER MADELINE L 17 022000070316 0.03 561 IMP 04088 DAVID NEAL 4735 WEATHERVANE DR~192~1ST 03/04/16 55921 RES $ 256,402 $ 84,960 33.14 TAO SIJIA/ZHANG XING 11 045501920559 0.16 196 IMP 11869 HEYMAN JOHN H 1275 LANIER PL 05/04/16 56150 RES $ 1,503,326 $ 730,320 48.58 TARDELLI DANA/JENNIFER 17 000200110363 0.40 327 IMP 40540 6285 SHANNON PKY COM $ 294,402 $ 127,400 43.27 TARIK PROPERTIES LLC 09F150400780803 0.73 IMP 06062 VASIREDDY KEERTHI KIRAN 4030 CHIPLEY CT~11 03/16/16 55961 RES $ 404,009 $ 147,640 36.54 TARLTON LAURIE/TARLTON CHARLES 12 160302660417 0.59 468 IMP 05581 F C CHANDLER JR AKA FARISH C CHANDLER 18 WILLOW GLN 02/22/16 55953 RES $ 241,439 $ 62,520 25.89 TARVER CHRISTY W/TARVER III LARRY H 17 006800060247~UN 18 0.06 86 IMP 14086 BEASLEY JOHN 4 HOLLY DOWNS CT 05/20/16 56206 RES $ 145,249 $ 65,120 44.83 TAUTE INGRID/FREDERICK 17 010700080024 0.02 679 IMP 15420 CONNOR JOHN D 7620 BRIGHAM DR 06/01/16 56262 RES $ 520,144 $ 204,640 39.34 TAYLOR ERIC J/JENNIFER LYNN SJOQUIST 06 033800020180 0.52 167 IMP 04481 WOHLERS NANCY 616 BRANYAN TRL 02/26/16 55908 RES $ 327,462 $ 159,200 48.62 TAYLOR JULIE K/TAYLOR RORY M 22 400011351505 0.14 487 IMP 14986 PINKARD RAMONA D 6328 PHEASANT TRL~118~7TH 06/06/16 56257 RES $ 179,322 $ 57,720 32.19 TAYLOR LINDA 07 140001182137~170 0.18 40 IMP 08475 OWEN JEFFERY 530 RAMSDALE DR~326~1 04/08/16 56058 RES $ 369,508 $ 120,960 32.74 TAYLOR MICHAEL A 12 169103260657~43 0.61 562 IMP 05974 BUTLER JOHN C 610 ARBOREAL CT~871~1ST 03/15/16 55962 RES $ 337,700 $ 121,760 36.06 TAYLOR PAUL 12 305508710058~LOT 5, BLK. H 0.41 482 IMP 03453 HOPKINS JR JOHN L 25 GLENALD WAY~184, 185, 195, 02/22/16 55882 RES $ 123,955 $ 30,200 24.36 TEFFT GORDAN RAWLS 17 019400051847 0.02 434 IMP 12426 WODEHOUSE COMPANY LLC 435 DUNHILL VIEW CT 05/13/16 56185 RES $ 291,973 $ 98,360 33.69 TELA FLORENCE 11 065102350220 0.23 429 IMP 12142 MARY JO KIMMEL 05/05/16 56139 RES $ 188,125 $ 56,960 30.28 TEN DEGREES LLC 14 001300110037 0.16 66 IMP 14547 ROBERT H ARNOLD AND CAROLYN W 8950 HUNTCLIFF TRC 06/03/16 56249 RES $ 557,124 $ 153,480 27.55 TENENBAUM DAVID V 06 036800010226 0.83 618 IMP 06338 CHESBROUGH JAMES P 130 COBBLESTONE WAY 03/18/16 55969 RES $ 408,196 $ 138,000 33.81 TERAKEDIS II ROBERT S/KELLY S 22 464311270294 0.31 88 IMP 07536 BYSTROM PATRICIA L 54 STANDISH AVE~109~17TH 04/01/16 56014 RES $ 601,647 $ 212,880 35.38 TERRY ANGELA HENDRIX/TERRY MARVIN L 17 010900060065 0.21 348 IMP 16022 CHENGALPETSELVAKUMAR N 205 SADDLE BRIDGE DR 05/31/16 56277 RES $ 258,461 $ 73,320 28.37 TERRY THERESA 11 047201890546 0.21 392 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 70 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 03300 RHODES DONALD E 11400 BROOKHOLLOW TRL 02/24/16 55885 RES $ 241,110 $ 91,520 37.96 TESSIER STEPHANE A 11 036201560027 0.21 649 IMP 15507 BUCCIERO KIMBERLY 685 ARGONNE AVE 06/10/16 56273 RES $ 161,810 $ 43,980 27.18 THARP ALEXANDRA A 14 004800090535 0.02 605 IMP 11731 MILLER STANLEY 218 MARGARET ST ST~57~14 04/05/16 56151 COM $ 152,343 $ 71,480 46.92 THE RON CLARK ACADEMY INC A GEORGIA 14 005700090301 0.21 149 IMP 18235 WALTON JOEL B 7870 WATERLACE DR 05/27/16 56344 RES $ 214,057 $ 83,560 39.04 THOMAS ALLYSON 07 140001183895 0.29 376 IMP 10787 MONTANA VICTOR D 1669 BARFIELD RUN 04/27/16 56108 RES $ 364,566 $ 115,040 31.56 THOMAS II DAVID B 17 0229 LL1032 0.10 122 IMP 09066 BAEZA DAVID CHRISTOPHER 3210 DIAMOND BLF 04/15/16 56068 RES $ 62,387 $ 28,920 46.36 THOMPSON ELIZABETH M 09F210200980191 0.14 326 IMP 15547 COLONY NANCY B 255 SKULLEY DR 06/07/16 56262 RES $ 290,737 $ 102,440 35.23 THOMPSON KIMBERLY 22 387012811027 0.10 380 IMP 01115 MYER DIANE 135 FLOSS FLOWER CT~616 & 629~1ST 01/15/16 55790 RES $ 227,880 $ 92,000 40.37 THOMPSON LEWIS P 12 254406300887~LOT 47, BLOCK A. 0.24 296 IMP 05936 HARRISON RYAN FRANKLIN 430 BROOK CIR~1165~2ND 03/18/16 55965 RES $ 460,407 $ 176,440 38.32 THOMPSON SEAN/THOMPSON JENNIFER 22 372011652317~LOT 64 0.32 516 IMP 03886 JOHNSON JEFF 550 STONEBRIAR WAY 02/22/16 55896 RES $ 225,987 $ 79,720 35.28 THOMPSON VALERIE 14F0092 LL1607 0.50 165 IMP 08667 CROFT CAROLINE KASSINGER 10448 PARK WALK POINT 04/11/16 56045 RES $ 334,189 $ 116,760 34.94 THOMSEN DEBORAH L 12 302008651494 0.04 646 IMP 15296 TAMMY H CURTIS 5 ARABIAN AVE~1022~2 06/07/16 56262 RES $ 383,916 $ 131,400 34.23 THORNE DAVID/SHELBY 22 370110220010~LOT 1, BLK A 0.87 504 IMP 09797 CAPITAL DESIGN HOMES LLC 3036 BIG SKY LN~970 & 975~2 04/18/16 56081 RES $ 224,324 $ 96,920 43.21 THORNTON BRITTANY LASHAWN 22 526009703792~UN 33 BLDG G 0.04 632 IMP 02100 SALM LAURA A 300 BRICKWORKS CIR 01/13/16 55826 RES $ 282,748 $ 108,480 38.37 THORSON ANDREW P 14 001900080564~UN 301 0.02 416 IMP 01162 CONWAY RICHARD E 6145 OLD HICKORY PT 01/19/16 55791 RES $ 738,639 $ 192,360 26.04 THRASHER MICHAEL LEE/THRASHER MARY 17 017200020079 0.86 457 IMP 15220 JAMES G POPE JR AND MICAH S HALL 653 BONAVENTURE AVENUE NE #2 06/06/16 56270 RES $ 282,881 $ 64,480 22.79 THUERK SARAH/BYRD RYAN 14 001700120875 0.03 126 IMP 15721 THUOT MICHAEL E 19 HILLIARD ST~45~14 06/09/16 56268 RES $ 169,981 $ 51,680 30.40 THURESON KRISTIN L 14 004500010825 0.02 141 IMP 13412 YILMAZ ERTUGRUL 13218 MARRYWOOD DR~975~2ND 02/29/16 56194 RES $ 209,530 $ 73,320 34.99 THYAGARAJAN SANTHANAKRISHNAN 22 526009751635~LOT 21 0.04 496 IMP 00328 CUMMINGS MICHAEL R 3655 HABERSHAM ROAD 01/07/16 55759 RES $ 117,534 $ 34,040 28.96 TINDOL LYNDA/ROBERTS MELISSA/TINDOL 17 009700011252 0.02 551 IMP 06290 WILMINGTON SAVINGS FUND SOCIETY FSB 1973 FORT VALLEY DR DR~167~14TH 03/14/16 55971 COM $ 158,932 $ 79,040 49.73 TMR INVESTMENT GROUP LLC 14 016700030411~LT 15, BK G 333 IMP 01216 TIMOTHY JOSEPH TRANKINA TRUSTEE OF 2994 OAKSIDE CIRCLE~970~2 01/15/16 55805 RES $ 268,997 $ 100,440 37.34 TOBEY LYNN HOLDINGS LLC 22 526009701283 0.04 278 IMP 17759 SPRAGUE PERRY J 510 STONEBROOK FARMS DR~464 AND 06/22/16 56337 RES $ 425,316 $ 151,000 35.50 TODD AMY A/CRAIG L 22 503004730930~LOT 35 1.00 90 IMP 03362 MATTHEW J TABOR AND ILYSSA N ASMAN 11065 ABBOTTS STATION DR 02/25/16 55889 RES $ 424,064 $ 168,960 39.84 TODOROV DIMITRE 11 090003212535 0.38 528 IMP 16709 CRAIG ROBERT 06/17/16 56321 RES $ 211,669 $ 56,200 26.55 TOKICH DEBORAH S 14 001300051306 0.02 613 IMP 11239 KREN ADRIENNE J 3820 ROSWELL ROAD, UNIT 810 04/22/16 56115 RES $ 241,750 $ 92,280 38.17 TOMLINSON SIMON ANDREW 17 0097 LL2393 0.03 600 IMP 01147 HOWARD JR WILLIE R 1510 LIBERTY LN~426, 427, 451~CONDO 01/22/16 55800 RES $ 319,519 $ 109,200 34.18 TONER ANNETTE B 12 200404260540 0.06 150 IMP 16912 MATTHES SCOTT A 5225 LEXINGTON WOODS LN~1257~2ND 06/16/16 56312 RES $ 453,023 $ 156,440 34.53 TORRES JASON D/TORRES LEONOR A 21 574012571014~LOT 72 0.40 223 IMP 13288 CHITTY JOHN W 1664 GILSTRAP LANE NW 05/20/16 56192 RES $ 317,914 $ 132,880 41.80 TORRESANI GIORGIO 17 0229 LL2212 0.07 466 IMP 01217 MAGELUND CORINNA 311 PEACHTREE HILLS AVE 01/19/16 55791 RES $ 116,107 $ 34,240 29.49 TOWNS HUNTER E 17 0058 LL1574~UN 13A 0.02 287 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 71 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 15107 STOFF STEVEN M 1205 JAMESTOWNE TRL~1265~2 06/08/16 56271 RES $ 129,818 $ 32,000 24.65 TOWNSEND BARBARA 22 514512650163~1205 0.04 37 IMP 05626 SALAM ELI 6940 ROSWELL RD 03/11/16 55942 RES $ 78,220 $ 33,160 42.39 TOWNSEND STEPHANIE A 17 0074 LL2176~UN 24C 0.01 693 IMP 03438 MANION SCOTT 170 BOULEVARD SE UNIT #H130~45~14 02/19/16 55875 RES $ 290,223 $ 77,680 26.77 TRAPP MARSHALL B 14 0045 LL0520 75 IMP 16867 COWLING BRIAN 185 CORRAL CT VW 06/15/16 56297 RES $ 356,274 $ 114,080 32.02 TRAYLOR THOMAS H 12 195204410222 1.50 369 IMP 19455 FISAL GHAVAMZADEHRAZAVI AKA ALI RAZAVI 1116 BOULEVARD DR~13~14TH 06/30/16 56389 RES $ 289,785 $ 93,480 32.26 TREFZER TIMOTHY W 14 001400140355 0.24 552 IMP 08801 DENHAM REBECCA 170 BOULEVARD 03/31/16 56051 RES $ 357,008 $ 107,680 30.16 TRETTEL MICHAEL P 14 0045 LL2047~UN 106E 0.04 166 IMP 08326 JENNIFER BUCHACH FKA JENNIFER E STRODE 1136 LIBERTY PARKWAY NW~221~17TH 04/11/16 56054 RES $ 183,897 $ 49,600 26.97 TRIBBLE ERIKA 17 0221 LL1519~UNIT 610 BUILDING 6 0.02 285 IMP 14365 BLISSFUL ENDEAVORS LLC 1005 BALMORAL LN 06/03/16 56250 RES $ 606,546 $ 305,960 50.44 TRIGG DARLENE M/MARK G 22 333012210243 3.21 625 IMP 09030 GREEN II BILLIE 3959 PARHAM WAY~174~9F 04/15/16 56065 RES $ 242,022 $ 78,840 32.58 TROY ARIC 09F400001743464~330 0.30 676 IMP 12153 JAMES WESP AND JILL VAN FOSSEN-WESP 616 CYPRESS POINTE ST~877 & 886 & 05/09/16 56158 RES $ 92,100 $ 32,880 35.70 TRUMBLE JR EDDIE 12 322208871189 0.02 3 IMP 11515 KENNY GEORGE T 515 TANACREST CIRCLE 05/05/16 56152 RES $ 403,781 $ 179,240 44.39 TUCKER LAUREN CROSS 17 013100050290 0.45 281 IMP 18119 KAY SCHLESINGER TRUST LRT UNDERR 2336 BONNER RD 06/24/16 56369 RES $ 34,506 $ 10,520 30.49 TUCKER TRADERS LLC 14 018700060216 0.25 687 IMP 04368 CORBIN SHAMEIKA M 7756 BELLMIST DR 02/04/16 55922 RES $ 126,992 $ 34,080 26.84 TUFT NICHOLAS 07 140101170388 0.12 216 IMP 40551 9655 DOGWOOD RD COM $ 730,242 $ 260,000 35.60 TULL MICHAEL M 12 222105300433 1.00 IMP 11565 WILLIAMS BRANDON 1219 WOODLAND AVE~9~14 05/04/16 56157 RES $ 339,787 $ 126,560 37.25 TUMSUDEN RICHARD 14 000900010464 0.30 104 IMP 12478 CROSBY JERRED 850 PIEDMONT AVE~49~14TH 05/11/16 56182 RES $ 447,729 $ 134,440 30.03 TUOHEY JUSTIN/ATHENA 14 004900331276~3115 0.04 309 IMP 01095 POOLE JANEL A 3501 OAKSHIRE WAY 01/29/16 55814 RES $ 132,511 $ 48,440 36.56 TURNER CHANDRA S 14 0002 LL1115 0.32 67 IMP 13495 JEFFREY GOLDSTEIN AND LAURA G 345 WESTBURY LN 05/19/16 56202 RES $ 345,216 $ 110,600 32.04 TURNER DERELL E/BERNADETTE C 11 065002680957 0.34 41 IMP 16371 HILLIARD JULIA 2828 PEACHTREE RD~100~17 05/31/16 56303 RES $ 274,671 $ 88,880 32.36 TUTT GEORGE 17 010000050529~UN 1103 0.03 361 IMP 09152 BURKS WILLIE J 3800 CLOVIS CT 04/15/16 56067 RES $ 20,479 $ 7,560 36.92 TWIN CRIBS LLC 14F001600021169 0.23 509 IMP 10669 EWING SECTION EIGHT LLC 2308 EWING ST 04/26/16 56134 RES $ 50,799 $ 16,440 32.36 TWIN CRIBS LLC 14F003200050176 0.17 553 IMP 02942 ASV INVESTMENTS LLC 164 HOWARD ST 02/11/16 55861 RES $ 37,704 $ 9,240 24.51 TWIN CRIBS LLC 14 017300081234 0.22 38 IMP 07860 NOWERY ASHLEY 13473 SPRING VIEW DR~972~21 04/01/16 56020 RES $ 197,415 $ 64,680 32.76 UDDIN AMNA/KHAN YOUSUF 21 547009722899~LOT 14 0.03 417 IMP 16889 ADAMS SR JOHN H 3338 PEACHTREE RD 06/14/16 56298 RES $ 159,105 $ 74,040 46.54 UEMATSU YASUYUKI/VERONICA 17 0062 LL1313~UN 1105 0.02 449 IMP 12762 DUNG ROLAND 860 PEACHTREE STREET NE, #1203 04/29/16 56166 RES $ 214,741 $ 78,960 36.77 UITTI DANIEL 14 004900013361~UN 1203 0.02 205 IMP 13806 LAL PRATYUSH 115 BISCAYNE DRIVE NW UNIT 05/23/16 56212 RES $ 113,229 $ 41,440 36.60 ULICNY ELIZABETH J 17 011100160366 0.03 446 IMP 05791 CITIZENS TRUST BANK 4730 KENT RD~35~13 03/10/16 55954 RES $ 57,751 $ 24,960 43.22 VALDOVINOS CONSUELO 13 003500060329 0.42 350 IMP 17493 HINTON DEBRA 13416 GARDINER LN 06/17/16 56305 RES $ 244,576 $ 101,950 41.68 VALENZUELA MARTHA I 22 526009703578 0.04 436 IMP 12094 CLARK JOHN R 901 HALL ST~208~14 05/06/16 56156 RES $ 90,786 $ 20,920 23.04 VALERIO-BUFORD LENORE 14 020800020751 0.17 452 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 72 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 11852 STROUD ROBERT H 100 BROOKHAVEN DR 04/12/16 56138 RES $ 1,072,754 $ 279,840 26.09 VAN HORN DAN BRALY/JENNIFER L 17 001100040411 0.75 469 IMP 17306 PULIDO DANIEL 345 CROSSTREE LN 06/17/16 56304 RES $ 489,152 $ 134,440 27.48 VAN RONZELEN PROVOSTY ZACHARY 17 013000070414 0.89 305 IMP 10932 WALKER SCOTT 200 WENDY HILL DR~1130~2ND 04/29/16 56122 RES $ 313,356 $ 103,560 33.05 VANDIVER JEFFREY L 22 448211290387~L 7 BL E UNIT FOUR 0.69 383 IMP 15222 HOANG DIEN 250 PHARR RD 06/06/16 56263 RES $ 363,127 $ 117,560 32.37 VANNAN MANI 17 009900073565~UN 2018 0.03 290 IMP 08378 ESTES MORRIS C 1060 LAKE SHORE OVERLOOK~1170 AND 04/12/16 56050 RES $ 716,413 $ 324,880 45.35 VARSHINE LISA W/VARSHINE MICHAEL D 21 562011700700~6 0.43 670 IMP 40554 3602 BROWNS MILL SE RD IND $ 1,306,360 $ 498,240 38.14 VBBS LLC 14 0063 LL0634 3.35 IMP 07940 HAMILTON F ELAINE 975 HALL PLACE NW 03/23/16 56026 RES $ 227,040 $ 58,280 25.67 VEAL JR JOSEPH BLAINE/JESSICA BROOKE 17 019000050439 0.17 552 IMP 16372 SETTERBERG COLLIN G 2985 LAYTON AVENUE NW 06/20/16 56302 RES $ 281,303 $ 98,770 35.11 VEATCH JENNIFER/JASON 17 025600010236 0.23 564 IMP 12576 DIAMANT JAY 170 BOULEVARD SHL~45~14 05/13/16 56177 RES $ 396,901 $ 114,360 28.81 VEATES CONNIE 14 0045 LL2914~UN 411E 0.04 543 IMP 17896 PRUDENCIO EDGARDO J 146 ROSWELL COMMONS WAY~505~1ST 06/03/16 56299 RES $ 75,481 $ 28,160 37.31 VELASQUEZ-GOMEZ LUISA E 12 218305050406~LOT 38, BLOCK B 0.21 281 IMP 17553 ROSEN REBECCA 747 RALPH MCGILL BLVD NE, UNIT 302 05/25/16 56342 RES $ 167,244 $ 65,200 38.98 VELEZ HERNAN BELLO 14 001800090705~UN 302 0.02 454 IMP 04784 FREW CHARLES S 1609 N. PELHAM 02/29/16 55909 RES $ 816,975 $ 266,000 32.56 VELEZ JAMES C/EMILY A 17 000300060864 0.22 496 IMP 00528 SMITH KYLE R 11030 CHANDON WAY 01/07/16 55771 RES $ 348,617 $ 121,720 34.92 VELTMAN NIR 11 118304310649 0.31 565 IMP 16454 MICHAEL S HOWARD AND JENNIFER C 1055 LILLIAN DR 06/20/16 56313 RES $ 622,061 $ 179,960 28.93 VEREB DEBRA A/PAUL 22 417012051066 0.53 688 IMP 01976 SUPRIT N PATEL AND JILL FKA JILL B 1722 MOORES MILL ROAD 01/29/16 55820 RES $ 441,703 $ 185,440 41.98 VERONICA C SHUPENKO/GREGORY M 17 022000010197~3 A 0.46 594 IMP 00197 GROSS MICHELE RAE 710 CREEK VIEW LN~416~1ST 01/15/16 55780 RES $ 236,797 $ 77,600 32.77 VERSCHAREN SUSAN MARIE 12 192304160781~UNIT 701 BLDG 700 0.02 465 IMP 11947 MORTON LASONGIA 549 SARABROOK PL~38~17 05/09/16 56150 RES $ 402,622 $ 156,960 38.98 VILLA-GARCIA MARIA ROSARIOPABLO R 17 0038 LL2908 0.02 488 IMP 12345 STANTON THOMAS A 9400 ROBERTS DR 05/17/16 56180 RES $ 68,143 $ 27,200 39.92 VILLAGE GREEN WAY LLC 06 0366 LL1376~UN 7D 0.03 277 IMP 13356 CHAD FITZGERALD TEAT AND STEPHANIE 115 NESBIT RIDGE DR~766~1ST 05/19/16 56190 RES $ 340,674 $ 91,880 26.97 VINAYA LAL SHRESTHA AND ANUVA 12 278207660181~LOT 18 0.21 466 IMP 09488 ARORA RAMNEEK 1701 BRIGHTON PT 04/18/16 56081 RES $ 143,976 $ 54,520 37.87 VINTU ANCA 17 0032 LL2045 0.03 396 IMP 14179 COOPER II AND ERIKA N/MAURICE 910 ACADIANA DR~22~17TH 05/17/16 56205 RES $ 369,826 $ 129,720 35.08 VIRUET JOEL/KIMBERLY 17 0022 LL2401~UNIT 910 / BUILDING 9 0.06 332 IMP 03058 GAD JASON N 1445 MONROE DR 02/02/16 55846 RES $ 130,687 $ 55,440 42.42 VIVAS ROMA CECILIA 17 0052 LL1174~UN 12-G 0.02 386 IMP 08132 CALATLANTIC GROUP INC 4065 HOPEWELL SPRINGS DR 03/28/16 56017 RES $ 676,372 $ 190,000 28.09 VOGT CAROLYNN/VOGT PAUL 22 516001821213~45 1.00 484 IMP 00093 WALL DALE 1310 SUMMIT NORTH DR 01/04/16 55743 RES $ 66,868 $ 24,920 37.27 VON BRINEGAR TOD 17 004800052207 0.01 14 IMP 04728 KUMAR SATYENDER 3397 GALLEON DR~828~2 02/29/16 55904 RES $ 223,947 $ 76,920 34.35 VOSS MICHAEL 22 539008282031~3701 0.02 198 IMP 06106 QUINONES LUIS JOSE 375 RALPH MCGILL BLVD~16 & 47~14 03/17/16 55966 RES $ 90,150 $ 28,720 31.86 VUGDALIC ZINAIDA 14 004600150356~UNIT 502 0.02 216 IMP 12342 MITCHELL JOEY 3995 DEMOONEY ROAD~170~9 05/16/16 56177 RES $ 91,044 $ 22,240 24.43 WACHTEL AMY 09F420001700546 2.00 642 IMP 18188 REINSEL MICHAEL J 12520 PINDELL CIR~1173&1174~2ND 06/27/16 56351 RES $ 712,405 $ 221,720 31.12 WADE CHADWICK L 22 433011730899~6 0.36 107 IMP 40556 3430 EMPIRE SW BLVD IND $ 1,870,801 $ 690,600 36.91 WADSWORTH PARK APARTMENTS 14 0066 LL1092 7.99 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 73 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 17982 KENTER EYTAN N 6039 HARLESTON RD 06/22/16 56327 RES $ 332,288 $ 126,760 38.15 WALDROP JESSICA SCHMITZ/WALDROP 17 007100020410 0.53 334 IMP 13222 BLUME CHRISTOPHER 1562 EZRA CHURCH DR 05/09/16 56203 RES $ 22,876 $ 8,240 36.02 WALKER 918 LLC 14 014700040084 0.18 125 IMP 09741 DELICE WANS 5715 HAMPTON CT.~99~13TH 04/20/16 56073 RES $ 57,509 $ 13,240 23.02 WALKER JR WINSTON 13 009900010772~LOT 96 0.07 556 IMP 06817 MARCUS SMITH AND JEANNINE W F HARNED 4835 BRIDGES DR 03/28/16 55994 RES $ 212,109 $ 47,720 22.50 WALKER PHILIP C/GRUPE LINDSAY 11 046501900385 0.13 354 IMP 17476 MORRISON ROBERT B 55 GLADWYN RIDGE DR~878~2ND 06/15/16 56327 RES $ 423,075 $ 164,320 38.84 WALKER RANDY A/WALKER ANGELA M 22 368208780010~LOT 1, GLADWYNE 1.05 634 IMP 02464 KRUPTA JESSICA M 2657 LENOX RD~6~17 01/29/16 55848 RES $ 142,326 $ 33,240 23.35 WALL PEDRO F/WALL KEVIN PETER 17 000600010924~UN 36 0.02 247 IMP 18312 MCGOWAN ANDREW S 984 EDEN AVE~11~14TH 06/07/16 56344 RES $ 383,468 $ 105,360 27.48 WALLIS BENJAMIN D/WALLIS DELMARIS 14 001100110567~L 1 0.28 613 IMP 13390 COX JOI NITASHE 1146 WINBURN DR 05/20/16 56195 RES $ 99,859 $ 31,980 32.03 WALLS BRITTNEY K 14 012400080186 0.22 188 IMP 03029 NAISBY CLAIRE 44 PEACHTREE PLACE NE UNIT 02/08/16 55845 RES $ 327,592 $ 97,440 29.74 WALLS TOBIN R 17 010700063954 0.02 505 IMP 10482 DUFLOS PENGDETH 555 PENNROYAL LN 04/29/16 56110 RES $ 483,858 $ 199,640 41.26 WALSH CAROLYN/ANTHONY 22 540008290479 0.63 401 IMP 09822 SHAUN P HELMEY AND AMANDA D 495 HEMBREE GROVE OVERLOOK 04/25/16 56095 RES $ 408,804 $ 179,160 43.83 WALSH LISA POLLACK 12 205204801179~108 0.30 427 IMP 18002 PRENTICE JOHN 10637 CAMARILLA COURT 06/27/16 56353 RES $ 277,193 $ 104,680 37.76 WALSH PAMELA D/WALSH PATRICK J 11 090003221973 0.02 10 IMP 10629 REED NANCY M 1445 MONROE DR~52~17TH 04/27/16 56112 RES $ 203,049 $ 67,800 33.39 WALTERS ELIZABETH A 17 0052 LL0895~UNIT F20, CARLYLE 0.02 221 IMP 13063 GAUL MICHELE L 860 PEACHTREE ST 05/13/16 56172 RES $ 228,104 $ 85,040 37.28 WANG ANDREW 14 004900012892 0.02 278 IMP 14944 DABNEY DEAN A 1541 GILSTRAP LN 05/27/16 56236 RES $ 365,794 $ 118,880 32.50 WANG BAOJI 17 0229 LL1677 0.12 653 IMP 02390 LI XIAOYAN 02/10/16 55852 RES $ 246,823 $ 95,240 38.59 WANG JENNIFER 12 279307290242 0.28 187 IMP 05417 WALKER ROSLIN J 8995 OLD SOUTHWICK PASS 03/03/16 55944 RES $ 1,270,902 $ 390,760 30.75 WANG KAI/CHEN XIAOJUN 11 022100660068 3.16 596 IMP 03493 KATZ MORTON H 6061 FARRELL WAY~345~1 02/22/16 55880 RES $ 292,141 $ 106,640 36.50 WANG XINYI 11 090003454277 0.02 595 IMP 04291 GANSEREIT RAYMOND F 390 17TH ST~148~17 02/29/16 55910 RES $ 223,947 $ 98,520 43.99 WANG YUEFEI 17 0148 LL5031~UNIT 6061 0.03 333 IMP 10575 WILSON PARKER HOMES OF WATERFORD 826 RAINSONG WAY~148~14FF 04/29/16 56128 RES $ 279,255 $ 104,000 37.24 WARD ERIC T/WARD ANDREA R 14F0147 LL0620~233 0.38 676 IMP 17289 BROOKS JAMES 870 MAYSON TURNER ROAD NW, 06/17/16 56305 RES $ 73,817 $ 27,990 37.92 WARD JR IVORY 14 011000081693~UNIT #1010 0.02 504 IMP 02352 MARTIN GREGORY 970 SIDNEY MARCUS BLVD 02/05/16 55836 RES $ 116,257 $ 40,920 35.20 WARD STEPHEN 17 0006 LL3433~UN 2315 0.02 492 IMP 11488 TALLANT GREG B 361 17TH ST~108 & 148~17TH 04/29/16 56151 RES $ 165,802 $ 83,640 50.45 WARD TIMOTHY P 17 010800014634 0.02 558 IMP 10934 HEAD JESSICA 789 CELESTE LN~12~14FF 04/22/16 56111 RES $ 87,067 $ 31,400 36.06 WARNER MARY E 14F0012 LL0796 0.04 18 IMP 06577 KYLE JR RONALD KEITH 03/09/16 55991 RES $ 276,918 $ 99,960 36.10 WARREN AMY/WARREN DERRICK T 11 010100200266 0.46 356 IMP 07889 KAILOA GROUP LLC 13270 NEW PROVIDENCE RD~996~2 04/01/16 56034 RES $ 486,958 $ 142,040 29.17 WARREN APRIL INMAN 22 369009960298 4.70 175 IMP 01364 FRANCIS LUKE 2840 IVEY OAKS LN~868~12TH 01/21/16 55791 RES $ 281,246 $ 103,840 36.92 WARREN NATE/WARREN AMY 12 303308680639~LOT 44 0.23 345 IMP 01784 ZUCHEGNO NICHOLAS A 305 ALDERWOOD LANE 01/27/16 55835 RES $ 398,164 $ 145,680 36.59 WASHBURN CHRISTINA D 17 0073 LL3258 0.02 508 IMP 03896 BENGIGI MOSHE 6851 ROSWELL RD~73~17 02/24/16 55892 RES $ 101,266 $ 32,200 31.80 WASHINGTON BILLY T 17 007300061727~UN 6 BLDG F 0.03 670 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 74 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 14885 D R HORTON-CROWN LLC 8050 STILLMIST DR 05/25/16 56244 RES $ 238,339 $ 82,480 34.61 WASHINGTON GWENDOLYN 07 140001078731~724 0.41 529 IMP 12578 DANIEL PRADEL MARIA DEL ROSARIO PRADEL 7 FINCH UN 235 TRL~50~14TH 05/09/16 56167 RES $ 118,956 $ 33,160 27.88 WASHINGTON III BOOKER T 14 005000120030 0.02 664 IMP 02023 ALLISON HAUGLAND F/K/A ALLISON K BROCK 972 BOULEVARD 01/29/16 55817 RES $ 294,468 $ 63,160 21.45 WASHINGTON JENNIFER GREENLEE/COREY A 14 002300010557 0.12 21 IMP 05431 HAMILTON ANDREW 2559 PAUL AVE 03/10/16 55955 RES $ 178,503 $ 72,400 40.56 WASHINGTON MARCUS J 17 025300010809 0.25 294 IMP 03162 ELLIOTT DALE B 535 WOODMAN PL~618~1ST 02/17/16 55882 RES $ 309,127 $ 99,320 32.13 WASHINGTON NATALIYA 12 243406180332~76 & B 0.99 305 IMP 04068 RITGER JOHN A 625 CAMERON ST~22~14TH 02/25/16 55914 RES $ 481,794 $ 117,920 24.48 WASSUM JOHN A/WASSUM JENNIFER 14 002200010228 0.29 511 IMP 06215 STEPHEN CHRISTOPHER JEROME 1621 LIBERTY LN 03/11/16 55972 RES $ 214,628 $ 71,480 33.30 WATERMAN GABRIEL 12 200404260680 0.03 25 IMP 07281 WALKER JOSEPH M 121 ROSAIRE PLACE NW~184, 185, 194, 03/29/16 55997 RES $ 127,177 $ 41,120 32.33 WATHEN JAMES M/WATHEN DEBRA B 17 019400050872 0.03 292 IMP 08606 WALLACE SEAN R 5645 SANDOWN WAY~281~1ST 03/31/16 56039 RES $ 390,404 $ 131,080 33.58 WATSON KRISTEN A 11 080302810220~LOT 32, STONEHAVEN 0.45 163 IMP 07086 BROWN SARAH B 529 ROBINSON AVE~42~14TH 03/30/16 55996 RES $ 200,046 $ 59,120 29.55 WEAVER EMILEE/WEAVER JUSTIN 14 004200040304 0.16 307 IMP 14947 GALLAGHER JAMES F 14775 GLENCREEK WAY 05/23/16 56234 RES $ 584,260 $ 156,000 26.70 WEBB III PAUL A 22 522006810359 2.21 139 IMP 22279 JORDAN JON 250 PHARR RD 06/20/16 56465 RES $ 189,902 $ 74,000 38.97 WEBB TERELL G 17 009900072732 0.02 336 IMP 03098 HONOUR AVENUE LLC 35 HONOUR AVE 02/12/16 55860 RES $ 534,788 $ 190,840 35.69 WEBER JEFF 17 009800011087 0.03 267 IMP 08681 HIGGINS MICHAEL A 3040 PEACHTREE RD 04/08/16 56046 RES $ 159,029 $ 66,200 41.63 WEEKS WALLACE R/WEEKS MADLYN L 17 0099 LL0627~UN 202 0.02 211 IMP 05248 D R HORTON INC 02/29/16 55925 RES $ 461,350 $ 200,680 43.50 WEINICK LINSY E/WEINICK GARY B 12 152002030496 0.61 84 IMP 19955 CENTOFANTI MICHAEL 5445 BENTLEY HALL DR 06/30/16 56404 RES $ 238,698 $ 85,760 35.93 WEISS CHRISTOPHER 21 572111651547 0.32 77 IMP 17748 SCHAEMAN SCOTT L 6515 WRIGHT CIR 06/24/16 56331 RES $ 329,572 $ 133,000 40.36 WEISSMAN SCOTT 17 008800040252 0.41 351 IMP 05818 3710 E STAMPEDE DR LLC 2748 CONNALLY DR~219~14 03/10/16 55940 RES $ 85,911 $ 23,520 27.38 WELCOME TIMMIE L 14 021900030187~1 17 0.29 315 IMP 16485 ERIBAC OGUZ 8740 ROSWELL RD 06/21/16 56310 RES $ 99,314 $ 35,760 36.01 WELLS LISA 06 0368 LL1119 0.03 662 IMP 18821 MICHAELS KATHERINE M 170 BOULEVARD~45~14TH 06/30/16 56350 RES $ 202,585 $ 69,800 34.45 WENDEL JOHN M/WENDEL JOAN C 14 0045 LL0744~H220 0.02 539 IMP 13302 BONNER BETHANY E 3200 ELKINS ST~127~14TH 05/18/16 56197 RES $ 269,100 $ 78,400 29.13 WEST JUSTIN/WEST KACEY 14 012700020437~1 0.09 176 IMP 04340 WHEELUS AMY E 75 PONCE DE LEON AVE 03/01/16 55906 RES $ 302,554 $ 82,880 27.39 WEST STEVEN M 17 018600040162 0.28 314 IMP 07212 IMIG JUSTIN 9486 RED BIRD LN~179~1ST 03/24/16 55986 RES $ 586,377 $ 188,960 32.23 WHEATLY ROGER/WHEATLY DENISE 11 051201800133~13 1.11 84 IMP 02709 LEVIN REBEKAH 2277 PEACHTREE ROAD, UNIT 402 02/11/16 55855 RES $ 269,035 $ 106,760 39.68 WHETSTONE PROPERTIES II LLC 17 011100070227~UN 402 0.03 359 IMP 12954 WREN JEFFREY 4682 DUDLEY LN 05/13/16 56173 RES $ 2,075,837 $ 456,160 21.97 WHIPPLE CARA B/WHIPPLE JOSH J 17 011900020174 0.54 445 IMP 09575 LAKEMOORE LLC 228 CHASTAIN PRESERVE LN 04/15/16 56076 RES $ 510,574 $ 211,360 41.40 WHITE BENJAMIN D 17 009600100205~11 0.02 5 IMP 17532 DAVID GRANT KRUEGER AND AMY B 535 CHAMPION HILLS DR~618~2ND 06/04/16 56340 RES $ 556,715 $ 211,720 38.03 WHITE BRIAN J/WHITE CATHERINE 22 505106180112~LOT 11 CHAMPIONS 1.22 238 IMP 12518 FOYERE RUTH E 7194 CAVENDER DRIVE SW 04/12/16 56166 RES $ 174,439 $ 64,600 37.03 WHITE JANET A 09C130000540461 0.27 260 IMP 08180 JONES COREY V 7362 GOSSAMER ST~37 & 42~9F 04/11/16 56052 RES $ 191,365 $ 76,440 39.94 WHITE JR WALTER/PAULA F 09F050000372235~LOT 288 BLK H POD 0.20 555 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 75 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 14702 BRACEWELL JAMES R 30 PLANTATION DR~7 & 8~17TH 06/02/16 56247 RES $ 217,617 $ 77,480 35.60 WHITE RAQUEL/DAGIT EVAN 17 000800120093~30B 0.04 150 IMP 04560 GORDON MARK P 325 PACES FERRY RD 02/25/16 55920 RES $ 187,937 $ 63,240 33.65 WHITE WILLIAM G 17 006100092130~UN 1609 0.02 549 IMP 14713 CONN EVAN 11565 WINDBROOKE WAY 06/03/16 56251 RES $ 341,463 $ 108,440 31.76 WHITTAKER AMANDA A/WHITTAKER JAMES L 11 064202741131 0.63 345 IMP 10162 CORRIVEAU MICHAEL G 04/20/16 56090 RES $ 483,260 $ 236,040 48.84 WIE JOSHUA JAHYUN 11 060102070282 0.43 23 IMP 19598 PALMER MICHAEL B 405 LOFTON RD~147~17TH 06/30/16 56390 RES $ 308,282 $ 100,120 32.48 WIGGINS MARGARET ANNE 17 014700011179~LORING HEIGHTS 0.25 235 IMP 16608 LOSCH JASON R 16065 HENDERSON RD 06/15/16 56309 RES $ 400,808 $ 90,480 22.57 WIGGINTON THOMAS O 22 469103160165 1.11 472 IMP 11011 OSABUTEY EMMANUEL 7555 OLD CHAPEL~158~14FF 04/29/16 56122 RES $ 127,646 $ 38,400 30.08 WILBURN MARK A/WILBURN STEPHANIE 14F0158 LL0725~107 0.24 423 IMP 14055 BOYD II ROBERT RICHARD 104 MAGNOLIA GRV 05/26/16 56223 RES $ 343,465 $ 131,360 38.25 WILCOX SARA J 12 303008681408 0.06 697 IMP 03501 NUNNALLY MARY H 4426 PACES BATTLE~236~17TH 02/15/16 55872 RES $ 451,220 $ 129,670 28.74 WILGUS SALLIE F 17 023600020420~PACES BATTLE, LOT 0.04 98 IMP 05702 HOMES ON THE HORIZON LLC 4803 ENCLAVE DRIVE 03/14/16 55948 RES $ 79,962 $ 29,080 36.37 WILKINS TINYA 09F210000982033 0.07 101 IMP 03465 DONALD WEDINGTON AND LORI WEDINGTON 02/19/16 55881 RES $ 431,608 $ 130,720 30.29 WILKINSON KATHARINE K 17 005600160116 0.05 336 IMP 13083 JAMES A CREECH AND ROBIN T CREECH 420 ABBEYWOOD DR~198 & 239~1ST 05/17/16 56184 RES $ 508,568 $ 165,960 32.63 WILLIAMS ANDREW 12 150201980099~78 0.49 424 IMP 07990 BLACKMON GARY 11 BASSETT HALL PL~220~17 03/31/16 56014 RES $ 188,146 $ 56,920 30.25 WILLIAMS AUTUMN L/NED A JR 17 022000080273 0.03 48 IMP 07002 LYNAM TERRY 240 LAKEVIEW RDG 03/24/16 56003 RES $ 288,329 $ 80,400 27.88 WILLIAMS BRANDON D 12 242205811196 0.09 26 IMP 14021 AXLEY JAMES E 12080 DANCLIFF TRCE 05/25/16 56223 RES $ 327,434 $ 109,440 33.42 WILLIAMS CAROL A 22 514212660140 0.04 678 IMP 12086 RANDOLPH JR SAMMY D 7199 THOREAU CIR~156~14FF 05/05/16 56162 RES $ 214,738 $ 80,840 37.65 WILLIAMS CHANELLE DEIDRA 14F0156 LL0362~116 0.23 468 IMP 16121 IH2 PROPERTY TRS 2 LP 4701 FLAT SHOALS RD # 55 E 06/06/16 56289 RES $ 16,946 $ 6,640 39.18 WILLIAMS DEVON 09F230500853179~E 55 0.03 334 IMP 02121 SMITH TODD CHRISTOPHER 660 GLEN IRIS DRIVE NE UNIT 02/01/16 55822 RES $ 318,365 $ 95,200 29.90 WILLIAMS ERIC/VANESSA CHARMAINE 14 004800340146~UN 201 0.02 263 IMP 00619 TENNYSON TAKEISHA L 1 BISCAYNE DR 01/15/16 55779 RES $ 123,748 $ 42,920 34.68 WILLIAMS FELICIA L 17 011100052456~UN 607 0.02 486 IMP 17703 VAZQUEZ HERIBERTO 6751 JULES TRCE~163 06/17/16 56302 RES $ 120,065 $ 30,040 25.02 WILLIAMS JOANNE E/COOPER CHARITY E 07 400001631073~LOT 49 0.12 656 IMP 06007 HELTON MICHAEL S 44 PEACHTREE PL 03/17/16 55963 RES $ 246,892 $ 78,560 31.82 WILLIAMS RONALD F 17 010700063699~UN 1233 0.02 338 IMP 13383 THAKOR NITA K 2657 LENOX RD~6~17 05/19/16 56191 RES $ 133,090 $ 35,880 26.96 WILLIAMS TAYLOR 17 000600012417 0.02 251 IMP 05554 VANCE RAYMOND J 2590 BETHANY CREEK COURT 03/08/16 55946 RES $ 504,704 $ 176,200 34.91 WILLIAMS TIA 22 492008360508 1.03 372 IMP 10915 HSBC BANK USA NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS 4112 FLAT TRL~83 05/04/16 56134 RES $ 65,345 $ 21,400 32.75 WILLIAMS VISTA 09F240100833240 0.04 118 IMP 04167 HUGHES PHILLIP 6800 GLENRIDGE DRIVE UNIT 03/02/16 55907 RES $ 141,575 $ 32,920 23.25 WILLIS GLENDA 17 0034 LL1045~UN 6820-I 0.02 419 IMP 10588 VINCENT DELANEY AND CHERYL DELANEY 135 HARNESS TRL 05/03/16 56127 RES $ 275,700 $ 96,760 35.10 WILSON EDWARD M 12 195304360269 0.69 576 IMP 07869 SHAW MARY VARBLE 540 MILLSBEE LN 04/04/16 56022 RES $ 469,049 $ 173,520 36.99 WILSON JUSTIN TAYLOR/CORY LEE 12 144201850048 0.51 92 IMP 13764 PUFALL MATTHEW 601 BERAGIO DR 05/23/16 56208 RES $ 493,677 $ 231,240 46.84 WILSON NICOLLE S/WILSON JEFFREY D 22 401012072363 0.36 405 IMP 16348 PIERCE MATTHEW BLAKE 3296 FERNCLIFF PLACE NE 06/20/16 56306 RES $ 510,250 $ 137,960 27.04 WILSON SAMUEL 17 000800070090 0.59 203 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 76 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 04058 GRISSOM MARQUIS D 4190 GLAD MORNING DR 02/22/16 55922 RES $ 55,048 $ 20,800 37.79 WILSON TERRANCE 09F381201770509 0.41 215 IMP 14745 HABECK JARED M 1075 PEACHTREE WALK~106~17 05/26/16 56231 RES $ 141,905 $ 55,240 38.93 WILSON TRAVIS BRYAN 17 010600041084 0.02 86 IMP 04985 GIAN LABLAK USA LLC 2339 BAGWELL DR 02/24/16 55933 RES $ 35,202 $ 15,480 43.97 WINES JR BOBBY 14 007000040309 0.09 227 IMP 12154 TRAN VICTOR 655 MEAD STREET SE UNIT #60~23~14 05/06/16 56153 RES $ 235,675 $ 74,190 31.48 WISE JR WILLIAM 14 002300021489 0.02 200 IMP 00260 TWO HUNDRED TWENTY-FIVE FAIRWAY 225 FAIRWAY RIDGE DR 01/15/16 55779 RES $ 341,819 $ 98,240 28.74 WISOR MATTHEW R 12 321309310303 0.54 663 IMP 07319 ROCKHILL ERIKA 105 BOXFORD CT~229~1ST 03/29/16 55999 RES $ 232,215 $ 85,800 36.95 WITHERSPOON MATTHEW N/JAIMIE K 11 055202290954~93 0.23 357 IMP 14452 REGUS ROBERT J 2000 WESTCROFT LANE~331~1 05/31/16 56242 RES $ 590,769 $ 223,280 37.79 WITTORF ROBERT/WITTORF ASHLEY 12 172003311331 0.28 611 IMP 11433 SHI HONGWEI 3324 PEACHTREE RD~62~17 05/06/16 56142 RES $ 222,745 $ 82,080 36.85 WMM OF OHIO LLC 17 0062 LL5942 0.02 558 IMP 12244 KIM HEA SUN 3324 PEACHTREE RD~62~17 05/06/16 56142 RES $ 215,501 $ 82,640 38.35 WMM OF OHIO LLC 17 0062 LL4531 0.02 553 IMP 09194 HANDY N/K/A MEGHAN A MERLIN MEGHAN A 943 PEACHTREE STREET~106~17TH 04/08/16 56060 RES $ 208,141 $ 69,160 33.23 WONG WA PING 17 010600082484~UNIT 1703 0.02 228 IMP 14728 JEWETT ROBERT W 230 HOPEWELL CLOSE LN 05/31/16 56237 RES $ 432,270 $ 141,040 32.63 WOOD CHARLENE/WOOD LINCOLN 22 494009800235 0.68 56 IMP 16455 MARTIN CAROL Y 1001 CARDOVA DR 06/20/16 56321 RES $ 374,479 $ 169,120 45.16 WOOD JAMES MCKEAN 17 000500030469 0.42 134 IMP 11440 RICHARDSON SCOTT A 384 RALPH MCGILL BLVD 05/06/16 56156 RES $ 137,462 $ 34,080 24.79 WOOD JR SETH ALAN 14 004700082236 0.02 609 IMP 12878 WELLS FARGO BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 04/27/16 56185 RES $ 26,766 $ 11,680 43.64 WOODALL LARRY 13 012500010473 0.24 22 IMP 17853 BLAND NANCY KAY 12599 ITASKA WALK 06/24/16 56330 RES $ 362,750 $ 166,560 45.92 WOODCOCK STEVEN D 22 401011701707 0.05 187 IMP 14731 HARRIS MONTE 818 GREENWOOD AVE 05/27/16 56249 RES $ 168,898 $ 52,040 30.81 WOODS WILLIAM 14 001700050874 0.02 316 IMP 13384 VISKIL JOHANNES C 13300 MORRIS RD~973~2 05/20/16 56204 RES $ 178,838 $ 60,000 33.55 WOODYARD MADELINE C 21 547009732534~UNIT 136 0.04 617 IMP 09652 MYERS ANGELA D 1075 PEACHTREE WALK 04/15/16 56076 RES $ 228,059 $ 70,000 30.69 WORTHINGTON AMANDA 17 010600041399~UN A303 0.03 419 IMP 07524 D R HORTON INC A DELAWARE 4330 FAVORED WAY~22~9F 03/31/16 56024 RES $ 165,012 $ 54,520 33.04 WORTHY SR MAURICE M/WORTHY VICKIE L 09F050000227413~925 0.15 113 IMP 12921 MICHAEL PASSOFF AND SARAH PASSOFF 140 BEECH LAKE CT 05/18/16 56185 RES $ 363,649 $ 122,960 33.81 WRIGHT ALLAN JAMIESON 12 280207280317 0.57 105 IMP 06840 LEE DARNISE S 1238 EAST FORREST AVE~133~14TH 03/31/16 56006 RES $ 93,038 $ 26,520 28.50 WRIGHT MARTY TODD 14 013300190331 0.25 168 IMP 15080 PRITCHETT JR JAMES 440 ABBEYWOOD DR 06/08/16 56268 RES $ 464,657 $ 159,320 34.29 WROBLEWSKI THOMAS E/WROBLEWSKI 12 150202390074 0.39 645 IMP 12121 DEHDASHTI HEDIEH SHEILA 6140 BRIGGS WAY~345~1ST 05/04/16 56146 RES $ 240,147 $ 86,080 35.84 WU ERMIN 11 090003223037 0.02 575 IMP 11875 NILES LISA A 659 AUBURN AVE~19~14TH 04/27/16 56148 RES $ 246,428 $ 72,160 29.28 WURSCHL DANIEL 14 001900101865~UNIT 218 0.02 409 IMP 20047 CLARK TOMMY CHARLES CARTERS GROVE TRL~281 AND 282~1ST 06/09/16 56401 RES $ 462,526 $ 170,760 36.92 XIA MINGJING/SHU FENGJUE 11 081002811112 0.74 458 IMP 18861 PRALL LAURA R 515 SAINT DEVON WAY~430~1ST 06/27/16 56352 RES $ 300,146 $ 123,120 41.02 XIAO FENGCHUN/YUAN TINGTING/YUAN MING 11 118304300038 0.29 474 IMP 18658 TAYLOR MICHELLE R 10765 MORTON CHASE WAY~187~1ST 06/30/16 56345 RES $ 220,202 $ 59,560 27.05 XIONG KYLE 11 048501870139~1ST SECTION, LOT 13 0.12 139 IMP 02591 CLARK SHUKITA 664 OUTLOOK WAY~150~9 02/10/16 55857 RES $ 62,314 $ 20,920 33.57 YAGER JANIS F/YAGER ROBERT P 09F340001503734~40-A 0.03 59 IMP 15409 O'DELL CAROL 3025 ARBORWOODS DR~837 AND 06/06/16 56267 RES $ 341,609 $ 122,680 35.91 YAN JINGYAO 12 305308370327 0.31 113 IMP

2016 Sales Ratio Study Page 77 of 77 060 - FULTON COUNTY

Sample Seller Street~Land Lot~Land Dist Sale Date Deed Book Type Sales Assessment * Ratio Purchaser / Owner Map/Parcel~SLB Prop Price 14088 JOANNA JUNE WALLACE AND JAMES 11835 WINDBROOKE WAY 05/24/16 56219 RES $ 344,870 $ 111,960 32.46 YANG FAN 11 064202700640 0.26 469 IMP 00295 TRINA LANE MCADAMS DAVIS 5615 KINGSPORT DR 01/15/16 55772 RES $ 71,931 $ 23,160 32.20 YANG RUMING/YE QIUYANG/YANG ZIMU 17 009100010961 0.03 629 IMP 02538 TRUJILLO JAIRO M 215 GOLD VIEW LN~360 & 361~1 02/10/16 55855 RES $ 288,690 $ 104,760 36.29 YANG ZHIYUN 11 101003612440~CONDO UNIT 22 0.05 315 IMP 09472 JACQUELINE GOMEZ FKA JACQUELINE R 1 BISCAYNE DR~111~17TH 04/27/16 56101 RES $ 117,861 $ 45,640 38.72 YAO JIN 17 011100051912~UNIT 201 THE 0.02 367 IMP 10185 WELCHEL BARBARA SCREVEN 5145 VILLAGE GREEN WAY 04/25/16 56102 RES $ 116,920 $ 35,440 30.31 YEHUDAY YOAV/MYRIAM 22 514812660367 0.17 308 IMP 05963 LEESONG MARGARET MINSUN 03/21/16 55977 RES $ 281,827 $ 91,040 32.30 YIN YANNAN/YAN MINGYI/YAN WEIDONG 11 082103031626 0.17 53 IMP 09769 ANNETTE WOOTEN KIM ROSS 691 PAINES AVE NW AVE~112~14 04/26/16 56093 RES $ 26,369 $ 6,520 24.73 YO MAMA LLC 14 011200050712~41 X 125 0.12 369 IMP 09770 ANNETTE WOOTEN KIM ROSS 687 PAINES AVE NW AVE~112~14 04/26/16 56093 RES $ 24,291 $ 6,120 25.19 YO MAMA LLC 14 011200050704~41 X 125 0.12 364 IMP 04419 MASON JUSTIN A 1957 WOODLAND HILLS AVE~186~17 03/04/16 55922 RES $ 354,357 $ 91,480 25.82 YOUNG ASHLEY A/YOUNG DANIEL T 17 018600030239~LOT 169 0.22 458 IMP 03734 BHATIA ROHIT 7615 GLISTEN AVE 02/22/16 55889 RES $ 434,494 $ 133,640 30.76 YOUNG JACLYNN/YOUNG JOSHUA 17 0032 LL5220 0.12 411 IMP 17024 CHRIS ELSESSER AND CECILIA ELSESSER 10005 FAIRWAY VILLAGE DR 06/23/16 56343 RES $ 429,427 $ 170,920 39.80 YOUSTIN JR JOHN J/YOUSTIN KAREN S 12 276607610012 0.57 69 IMP 04944 OKESON LAWRENCE E 03/07/16 55923 RES $ 370,658 $ 147,880 39.90 YU WENCUI 12 321209310809 0.16 500 IMP 17496 MCKAY PATRICIA 383 NINTH ST 06/17/16 56295 RES $ 511,386 $ 166,920 32.64 YUAN JENNIFER 17 005400040591 0.18 451 IMP 17604 KENNETH R CARR AND DONNA L CARR 225 WEST SMOKETREE TER 06/20/16 56309 RES $ 510,250 $ 207,240 40.62 YUN-THAYER KRISTIAN/YUN-THAYER VIVIAN 21 578112600029 0.35 194 IMP 15899 HIRSCHFELD DEVON 8 NORMANDY COURT NE 06/13/16 56276 RES $ 164,128 $ 64,240 39.14 ZAPATA DAVID S 17 000700070083 0.03 579 IMP 06097 DONALDSON SCOTT T 9845 LAUREN HALL CT 03/17/16 55958 RES $ 284,511 $ 95,680 33.63 ZEHR TIMOTHY/ZEHR CORINNE 11 006000350888 0.32 388 IMP 16763 KRALOVICH DAVID T 5581 HIGH POINT RD 06/15/16 56300 RES $ 393,682 $ 158,360 40.23 ZHANG MARIE 17 0038 LL3021 0.02 522 IMP 03245 MCLENDON MATTHEW S 136 PEACHTREE MEMORIAL DR~111 02/18/16 55871 RES $ 164,626 $ 57,040 34.65 ZHANG MENGMENG 17 011100110114 0.03 291 IMP 06217 GELBAR TIMOTHY 10550 HIGHGATE MANOR CT 03/18/16 55972 RES $ 596,156 $ 179,480 30.11 ZHANG YAN/LI BIN 11 080003061263 0.28 520 IMP 20333 LERAKIS STAMATIOS 3445 STRATFORD RD 06/12/16 56433 RES $ 231,199 $ 82,080 35.50 ZHANG YI 17 004500012956 0.02 205 IMP 01869 WILMINGTON SAVINGS FUND SOCIETY FSB 390 17TH ST~148~17 01/27/16 55833 RES $ 286,018 $ 100,800 35.24 ZHANG ZHUZHAO 17 0148 LL6641~UNIT #5051 326 IMP 14627 CATES CYNTHIA L 6642 CHERRY TREE LN 06/01/16 56243 RES $ 247,473 $ 113,200 45.74 ZHAO CUIPING 17 007300010120 0.62 596 IMP 01807 MCCAY THOMAS 7126 BOULDER PASS~58~9F 01/29/16 55828 RES $ 141,836 $ 56,160 39.60 ZHAO YU 09F120200580588~LOT 7, BLOCK A, 0.22 113 IMP 16861 IVAN M DIAZ AND AYCA DIAZ 4645 VALAIS CT # 46 06/10/16 56303 RES $ 139,460 $ 50,920 36.51 ZHAO YU/MA CHUNXIA 11 037001541472 0.03 550 IMP 15916 KIM JUNG HO 250 PHARR RD 417 05/31/16 56277 RES $ 184,525 $ 71,760 38.89 ZHEST ILYA R 17 009900070694 0.02 206 IMP 06555 MAKOVETSKA YULIYA V 136 PEACHTREE MEMORIAL DR~111~17 03/22/16 55979 RES $ 179,865 $ 57,040 31.71 ZYABLETSOVA JULIA 17 011100110247~UN 3 BLD 12 0.03 230 IMP

* Adjusted as necessary for items such as: standing timber, personal property, intangibles, time, etc.