Haryana Vidhan Sabha 1 Session Bulletin No. 1

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Haryana Vidhan Sabha 1 Session Bulletin No. 1 HARYANA VIDHAN SABHA 1st SESSION BULLETIN NO. 1 Monday, the 4th November, 2019 (Brief record of the proceedings of the meeting of the Haryana Vidhan Sabha held on Monday, the 4th November, 2019 from 2.00 P.M. to 3.57 P.M.) I. ANNOUNCEMENTS BY THE SECRETARY The Secretary informed the House that the Governor:- (i) In exercise of the powers vested in him by Article 180 (1) of the Constitution of India has appointed Dr. Raghuvir Singh Kadian, M.L.A. as Acting Speaker of the Haryana Vidhan Sabha; and (ii) In exercise of the powers conferred on him by Article 188 of the Constitution of India, has appointed the Acting Speaker, Haryana Legislative Assembly, to be the person before whom every Member of the Haryana Legislative Assembly shall, before taking his/her seat, make and subscribe oath/affirmation. II. OATH/AFFIRMATION BY THE MEMBERS The Acting Speaker congratulated all the Members on their being elected as Members of the Haryana Vidhan Sabha and also welcomed them to the august House. He announced that the oath/affirmation would be made and subscribed by the Members in the following order as per the call of the Secretary:- (i) Chief Minister; (ii) Deputy Chief Minister: (iii) Lady Members; and (iv) Other Hon'ble Members districts-wise alphabetically in alphabetical order. Thereafter, 89 Members of the Sabha present in the House, were sworn in, one by one. 2 III. WELCOME TO THE PRESIDENT OF INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS PARTY, HARYANA STATE/ FORMER MINISTERS OF HARYANA AND FORMER MEMBER OF HARYANA VIDHAN SABHA. During the course of oath/affirmation by the Members:- (i) the Acting Speaker, on behalf of the House, welcomed Kumari Selja, President of Indian National Congress Party, Haryana State, Capt. Ajay Singh Yadav and Shri Ram Kishan Gurjar, former Ministers of Haryana and Shri Nishan Singh, former Member of Haryana Vidhan Sabha, who were sitting in the VIPs’ Gallery to witness the proceedings of the House. (ii) the Acting Speaker, on behalf of the House, welcomed Shri Ajay Singh Chautala, Former Member of Parliament and former Member of Haryana Vidhan Sabha, who was sitting in the VIPs’ Gallery to witness the proceedings of the House. IV. ELECTION OF SPEAKER At 3.24 P.M, The Chief Minister moved- That Shri Gian Chand Gupta, a Member of the Haryana Legislative Assembly, who is present in the House, do take the Chair as Speaker of the Assembly. The motion was seconded by the Deputy Chief Minister. There being no other proposal, the Acting Speaker declared Shri Gian Chand Gupta unanimously elected as Speaker at 3.26 P.M. and requested him to take the Chair. (Shri Gian Chand Gupta, escorted by the Chief Minister, the Deputy Chief Minister, Leader of the Opposition, Shri Anil Vij and Shri Kanwar Pal, Members from the Treasury Benches, occupied the Chair). V. CONGRATULATORY SPEECHES The Chief Minister, Shri Bhupinder Singh Hooda, Leader of the Opposition, Shri Abhay Singh Chautala, Member from the Indian National Lok Dal, Smt. Kiran Choudhry and Shri Varun Chaudhary, Members from the Indian National Congress Party and Shri Randhir Singh Gollen, an Independent Member, made congratulatory speeches. The Speaker, while thanking the members, made some observations. 3 VI. ANNOUNCEMENT REGARDING THE RECOGNITION OF LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION During the course of congratulatory speeches, the Speaker announced that Shri Bhupinder Singh Hooda, Leader of the Indian National Congress Legislature Party, recognized as the Leader of the Opposition in the Haryana Vidhan Sabha. VII. ANNOUNCEMENT REGARDING ELECTION OF DEPUTY SPEAKER Under Rule 10 (i) of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Haryana Legislative Assembly, the Speaker announced that he would declare the date in connection with the election of the Deputy Speaker later on. The Speaker further announced that as the Governor is to address the House at 10.30 A.M. tomorrow i.e. 5th November, 2019 and the House is adjourned till immediately half an hour after the conclusion of the Governor‘s Address. The Sabha then adjourned till 10.30 A.M. on Tuesday the 5th November, 2019. CHANDIGARH SECRETARY. the 4th November, 2019. .
Recommended publications
  • India Postpoll NES 2019-Survey Findings
    All India Postpoll NES 2019-Survey Findings Q1: In whatever financial condition you are placed today, on the whole are you satisfied or dissatisfied with it? N (%) 1: Fully satisfied 4937 20.4 2: Somewhat satisfied 11253 46.4 3: Somewhat dissatisfied 3777 15.6 4: Fully dissatisfied 3615 14.9 7: Can't say 428 1.8 8: No response 225 .9 Total 24235 100.0 Q2: As compared to five years ago, how is the economic condition of your household today – would you say it has become much better, better, remained same, become worse or much worse? N (%) 1: Much better 2280 9.4 2: Better 7827 32.3 3: Remained Same 10339 42.7 4: Worse 2446 10.1 5: Much worse 978 4.0 7: Can't say 205 .8 8: No response 159 .7 Total 24235 100.0 Q3: Many people talk about class nowadays, and use terms such as lower class, middle class or upper class. In your opinion, compared to other households, the household you live in currently belongs to which class? N (%) 1: Lower class 5933 24.5 2: Middle class 13459 55.5 3: Upper Class 1147 4.7 6: Poor class 1741 7.2 CSDS, LOKNITI, DELHI Page 1 All India Postpoll NES 2019-Survey Findings 7: Can't say 254 1.0 8: No response 1701 7.0 Total 24235 100.0 Q4: From where or which medium do you mostly get news on politics? N (%) 01: Television/TV news channel 11841 48.9 02: Newspapers 2365 9.8 03: Radio 247 1.0 04: Internet/Online news websites 361 1.5 05: Social media (in general) 400 1.7 06: Facebook 78 .3 07: Twitter 59 .2 08: Whatsapp 99 .4 09: Instagram 19 .1 10: Youtube 55 .2 11: Mobile phone 453 1.9 12: Friends/neighbours 695 2.9 13:
    [Show full text]
  • MP Deepender Singh Hooda MP Arjun Ram Meghwal
    INDIAN LEADERS PROGRAM, FOURTH EDITION ‐ MEMBERS OF PARLIAMENT May 31st to June 5th 2015, Madrid and Barcelona SPAIN‐INDIA COUNCIL FOUNDATION MP Deepender Singh Hooda Deepender Singh Hooda is a third term Member of Parliament for Rohtak in Haryana State constituency, whip of Indian National Congress in Lok Sabha (Lower House of Parliament), National Spokesperson of Indian National Congress. He actively serves as Member of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Energy; and Member of the Ad hoc Committee on Absenteeism of Members in the Parliament. He also leads INC’s Social Media Communications Team. Deepender was first elected to the thirteenth Lok Sabha (in 2005) as an MP from Rohtak (Haryana) at the young age of 27. His unwavering commitment earned him a victory by a record margin (of about 4 and a half Lakh votes) when he sought re‐election to Lok‐ Sabha for the second term in 2009. He continued his winning streak for the third time in 2014 even when his party faced strong anti‐incumbency. Areas of agriculture, energy, India’s economic growth and employment potentials find Deepender's passionate involvement, both in his constituency and at a broader national level. Hooda is a third‐generation Parliamentarian from a family with a rich political heritage extending over four generations. His father, Bhupinder Singh Hooda, was the Chief Minister of Haryana for two terms from Mar 2005 ‐ Oct 2014. Deepender's grandfather, Ranbir Singh was a noted freedom fighter, an eminent parliamentarian and one of the founding fathers of India (by virtue of him being a member of the Constituent Assembly of India (1946‐1950) which was responsible for drafting the Constitution of India).
    [Show full text]
  • Unions Reject Govt Offer to Setup Committee
    Page-1- 2_Layout 1 01-12-2020 22:57 Page 1 TOPDELHI, UP www.topstory.online STORYwww.topstorypaper.com www.facebook.com/topstorypaper DELHI, WEDNESDAY 02 DECEMBER 2020 VOL-07, ISSUE - 235, PAGES - 8, PRICE RS 2.00 Jacqueline Fernandez Joins China says Delhi SCO BCCI secy Jay Shah The Cast Of Akshay Kumar­ Heads of Govt meet sent visits PCA's new Starrer Bachchan Pandey many 'positive signals' stadium at Mullanpur FILM PAGE­8 WORLD PAGE-7 SPORTS PAGE­6 FARMERS' PROTESTS AGAINST FARM LAW 3 DELHI Govt will reach a Delhi's air Unions reject Govt offer to setup solution after discussing quality their issues, Tomar says remains committee; talks remain inconclusive before meeting farmers New Delhi 'very poor' he government on n The meeting remained inconclusive and the government has called for another Tuesday expressed confidence that it UP­STATE round of discussions on Thursday, December 3, union leaders said 5 Twould reach a solu- New Delhi the issues and wanted the tion after discussing issues Rawat releases he government on farmer representatives to raised by protesting farm- dash board Tuesday offered to further consider the pro- ers, as a meeting got under prepared for set up a committee posal way between union minis- Tto look into issues Sources said the minis- ters and representatives of monitoring SDG raised by farmers protesting ters were of the view that it over 30 farmer organisa- against new farm laws, but was difficult to reach a deci- tions. it was rejected by represen- sion while interacting with For the meeting at Vi- tatives
    [Show full text]
  • RMG 9 November 2013: Chandigarh
    RMG 9 November 2013: Chandigarh Invest North 2018- 7th in series A unique Conclave - one of its kind showcasing investment opportunities in Northern States of India Key Objectives of Invest North To define and Northern Region’s developmental priorities discuss Competitive & Cooperative Compete for investments and learn from each others good practices Federalism To showcase Northern States of India as a investment destination Leaders from all sectors to closely examine the synergies that spark the To create common next phase of growth and build new bridges for shared and equitable platform for growth Transmission of the right message goes to the right audience with the To ensure right impact and produces the right results To improve Policy dialogue on Ease of Doing Business in Northern States of India Investment Climate All Northern States on a single platform with other stakeholders to To bring together facilitate policy dialogue Engaging Leadership– Over the years Nirmala Sitharaman Ramesh Abhishek Minister of State (I/C) for C&I, GoI Secretary – DIPP, GoI Capt Amarinder Singh Manohar Lal Chief Minister, Government of Punjab Chief Minister, Government of Haryana Prakash Pant Satish Mahana FM, Government of Uttarakhand IM, Government of Uttar Pradesh Rajpal Singh Shekhawat Manpreet Singh Badal IM, Government of Rajasthan FM, Government of Punjab Bhupinder Singh Hooda the then CM, Government of Haryana Sheila Dikshit The then CM, Government of NCT of Delhi Arvind Kejriwal Chief Minister, Government of NCT of Delhi Harish Rawat Sukhbir Singh Badal The then CM, Government of Uttarakhand The then Dy CM, Government of Punjab Mukesh Agnihotri Indiraa Hridayesh The then IM, Government of HP The then IM, Government of Uttarakhand EngagingEngaging Leadership Leadership– –Over Over the the Years years Madan Mohan Mittal Manish Sisodia The then IM, Government of Punjab Dy.
    [Show full text]
  • Abhay Singh Chautala … Appellant Versus
    1 Reportable IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1257 OF 2011 (Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 7384 of 2010) Abhay Singh Chautala … Appellant Versus C.B.I. … Respondent WITH CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1258 OF 2011 (Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 7428 of 2010) Ajay Singh Chautala … Appellant Versus C.B.I. … Respondent J U D G M E N T V.S. SIRPURKAR, J. 1. This judgment will dispose of two Special Leave Petitions, they being SLP (Crl.) No. 7384 of 2010 and SLP (Crl.) No. 7428 of 2010. While Abhay Singh Chautala is the petitioner in the first Special Leave Petition, the second one has been filed by Shri Ajay Singh Chautala. The question involved is identical in both the SLPs and hence they are being disposed of by a common judgment. 2. Leave granted in both the Special Leave Petitions. 3. Whether the sanction under Section 19 of The Prevention of Corruption Act (hereinafter called “the Act” for short) was necessary against both the appellants and, therefore, whether the trial which is in progress against both of them, a valid trial, is common question. This question was raised before the 2 Special Judge, CBI before whom the appellants are being tried for the offences under Sections 13(1) (e) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act read with Section 109 of Indian Penal Code in separate trials. 4. Separate charge sheets were filed against both the appellants for the aforementioned offences by the CBI. It was alleged that both the accused while working as the Members of Legislative Assembly had accumulated wealth disproportionate to their known sources of income.
    [Show full text]
  • Haryana Vidhan Sbha
    HARYANA VIDHAN SBHA RESUME OF BUSINESS TRANSACTED BY THE TWELFTH HARYANA VIDHAN SABHA DURING THE SEVENTH (AUGUST) SESSION, 2012 WITH APPENDIX CONTAINING DAILY BULLETINS HARYANA VIDHAN SABHA SECRETRARIAT CHANDIGARH AUGUST, 2012 TABLE OF CONTENTS Sr. Subject Page 1 Statement regarding Council of Minister 1 etc. 2 Statement regarding party position 3 3 Summoning, Sitting and Prorogation of 4 the Haryana Vidhan Sabha 4 Leave of Absence 5 5 Programme observed 6 6 Panel of Chairpersons 12 7 Committees 13 8 References 26 9 Financial Business 34 10 Legislation 36 11 Synopsis of the Bills 40 12 Resolution 43 Non-official - 13 Report presented/Laid 44 14 Paper presented/Laid/Re-laid 45 15 Adjournment Motion 47 16 Calling Attention Notices Under Rule 73 49 17 Short Duration Discussion Notice Under 54 Rule 73-A 18 Statement made by the Ministers 56 19 Comparative statement of speeches made 57 and time taken thereon 20 Figures relating to Questions 58 21 Question statement 59 22 Statement Showing the Date-wise Number 60 of Starred Questions Answered/not put/Postponed 23 Statement showing the date-wise number 61 of Starred Question deemed to have been answered Under Rule 45(1) 24 Statement showing the number of Starred 62 question in the name of Different Ministers date-wise. 25 Walk-outs 63 26 Ruling of the Speaker Regarding the issue 64 of castist remarks made against Sh. Jaiveer Balmiki, Chief Parliamentary Secretary by Sh. Abhey Singh Chautala, M.L.A. 27 Appendix 65 Bulletins Seventh (August) Session, 2012 - PERFACE The following pages contain Resume of Business transacted by the Twelfth Vidhan Sabha during its Seventh Session held from 24 August, 2012 to 28th August, 2012, togetherwith the Bulletins issued daily after the adjournment of each sitting of the Sabha.
    [Show full text]
  • The Great Communicator
    THE LAST WORD ON THE NEWS WEEKLY: SAT/NOVEMBER 17/2018 NETWORK18 MEDIA AND INVESTMENTS LIMITED PAGES 20 SAMPLE COPY 12 RBI versus Residential Centre is evil of Yogi’s about 2019 hometown ENCEPHALITIS CASES IN GORAKHPUR The reason elections UNABATED DESPITE GOVT’S TALL CLAIMS why I wrote MODI GOVT WANTS CENTRAL BANK OF VACCINATION TO RELAX LENDING TO BOOST my story GROWTH, WHICH IS SHOWING SIGNS 10 was be- OF SLOWING DOWN, BEFORE POLLS cause I felt that this was the moment Who calls of ‘now or the shots? never’ WHY KATRINA’S TWO GIG VINTA NANDA ROLES MATTER MORE THAN TV PRODUCER HER DIRECTORS WRITER 14 6 COVER STORY inside Wrong target BLAMING NAIDU, ANDHRA FOR TELANGANA PROBLEMS WON’T IMPRESS VOTERS AS TDP IS NOT THE MAIN Phugat RIVAL OF KCR & TRS high on 8 politics BJP DELHI MEMBER AND MRS UNIVERSE 2015 WEST ASIA SAYS IN POLITICS IT IS EASY TO LET POWER GO TO YOUR HEAD BUT ONE HAS TO BE PROFESSIONAL 4 Rebel With a Cause DALIT LEADER CHANDRASHEKHAR AZAD’S REBELLIOUS STREAK HAS ATTRACTED SUPPORTERS THE BIG PICTURE 9 The Great REMEMBRANCE OR RAGE DIFFERENT BALLGAME Role of Indian Batting for 3 soldiers in WW I diff erent balls triggers debate of cricket Communicator While 74,000 Indians died Cricketing giants prefer balls NAMO APP: How Narendra Modi is using technology, data, and serving the Raj overseas, does of di erent makes due to valorising their sacrifi ces insult lack of standardisation of targeted comms strategy to stay ahead of the political pack memories of those who did balls globally and di culty in resist the empire and exonerate adjusting to them in di erent 2 those who sent soldiers to fi ght? conditions SHATAKSHI 7 18 FIRSTPOST.
    [Show full text]
  • Haryana Vidhan Sabha WHO's WHO 2005
    Haryana Vidhan Sabha WHO’S WHO 2005 Research Branch Haryana Vidhan Sabha Secretariat, Chandigarh Preface This publication of WHO’S WHO contains the biographical sketches of Members of the 90 seated 11th Haryana Legislative Assembly the election for which were held on 3rd February, 2005 and the Assembly was sonstituted on 21st March, 2005. A tragic incident took place on 31st March, 2005. A tragic incident took place on 31st march, 2005 when Shri O.P. Jindal, Power Minister and Shri Surender Singh, Agriculture Minister died in the chopper crash at Gurgaon, near Saharanpur (U.P.). The Bye-election on 3 vacant seats i.e. hisar, Tosham and Kiloi (Shri Krishan Hooda resigned on 05.04.2005) was held on 2nd June, 2005 in which Smt. Savitri Jindal (wife of Shri O.P. Jindal), Smt. Kiran Choudhari (wife of Shri Surender Singh) and Ch. Bhupinder Singh Hooda were elected from Hisar, Tosham and Kiloi constituencies, respectively, Sardar Harmonhinder Singh Chatha was elected Speaker of the Assembly unanimously on 21st March, 2005 and resigned from the office of Speaker on 12th January, 2006. On 13th January, 2006, Dr. raghuvir Singh Kadian was elected as Speaker of the Assembly, unanimously. These bio-sketches have been prepared on the basis of information furnished by the Members themselves and every effort has been made to ensure the factual accuracy. The party position of the Members included in this publication is as it stood on the date of election. The names of the Members have been arranged in English alphabetical order. Any suggestion regarding improvement in this publication will be gratefully received by this Secretariat.
    [Show full text]
  • Thetribunechd /Thetribunechd
    13 chandigarh | gurugram | jalandhar | bathinda | jammu | srinagar | vol.3 no.273 | 16 pages | ~4.50 | regd.no.chd/0006/2018-2020 established in 1881 | thursday, october 3,2019 /thetribunechd /thetribunechd www.tribuneindia.com THE TRIBUNE NATION JALANDHAR | THURSDAY | 3 OCTOBER 2019 QUOTEUNQUOTE KILLERS CLAIMING Mahatma Gandhi pioneered successive non-violent movements that changed history. 150 years since his birth, Gandhi’s GANDHI’S LEGACY philosophy is at the core of our work at the UN. May his courage and conviction continue to inspire us. Antonio Guterres, UN CHIEF Those who assassinated Mahatma Gandhi are now ❝ trying to make him their own. They are trying to Tributes & political jostling to claim Bapu’s legacy interpret Gandhi’s statements in their favour. NewDelhi, October 2 remembrances of the Mahatma Pinarayi Vijayan, KERALA CM His writings, his spoken words and efforts to understand his pro- HOUSE REMEMBERS HIM and vignettes from his life — found contribution to society. ■ Parliament paid tributes to cele- HIS INDIA UNDER Mahatma Gandhi was the President Ram Nath Kovind, brate the 150th birth anniversary SEVERE ATTACK refrain in the farthest corners of Vice President Venkaiah Naidu of Mahatma Gandhi. Lok Sabha India on his 150th birth anniver- and Modi led the nation in paying Speaker Om Birla said not just Today, as we inaugurate sary on Wednesday as tributes rich tributes to the Father of the India, the entire world was cele- #SurjeetBhawan, it is poured in and parties jostled to Nation at his memorial in Rajghat. brating the birth anniversary Gandhi's 150th birth stake claim to his legacy.
    [Show full text]
  • Grucr Raavrcd W`C 65 Bfvczvd
    $ % <6 ' = = = 6.$7%,6+"839: '*+,+',- &'() *'(./ %4%$5:4%5 >5$$;?5:;55: $%#&#%5% 84"?5:5 @;"484";4%:#7 "46"%"43-A # 4%53B66" 2C D% (5 % ' !;<=3> 3< Q 4565$7" last 15 years, out of 30 districts in Odisha, 14 with high den- 4565$7" who is an SPG protectee, went riven by hunger and cul- sity of tribal population, have back in her white Toyota Land Dtural practices, tribals in witnessed outbreaks of anthrax ongress leader Sonia Cruiser with a convoy of vehi- many pockets of Odisha are affecting at least 1208 people CGandhi’s son-in-law cles carrying the elite com- taking to butchering and de- and killing 436. Robert Vadra on Wednesday mandos. skinning of dead animals Koraput was worst affect- appeared before the Vadra was directed by a and consuming them, ed with total 354 human Enforcement Directorate (ED) Delhi court to cooperate with exposing themselves to anthrax cases and 9 deaths in connection with a money the ED investigation after he anthrax, a deadly infectious reported in last seven years. laundering case for the alleged approached the court seeking zoonotic disease. During the survey, the sci- possession of illegal foreign anticipatory bail in the money Ringing alarm bells, scien- entists observed that tribals assets. The Congress tried to laundering case. The court had tists from the Indian Medical also dig out the buried animal tactically turned the focus away asked him to appear before the Council of Research (IMCR)- at night and consume the from him by having Priyanka ED on Wednesday on his Regional Medical Research meat.
    [Show full text]
  • Maharshi Dayanand University Rohtak Alumni
    MAHARSHI DAYANAND UNIVERSITY ROHTAK ALUMNI DIRECTORY missing your old friends.. meet them here... MAHARSHI DAYANAND UNIVERSITY ALUMNI OFFICE M. D. UNIVERSITY, Rohtak - 124001 (Haryana) www.mdurohtak.ac.in MDU ALUMNI ASSOCIATION OFFICE BEARERS President (Ex-officio) Prof. R.P. Hooda, Vice – Chancellor, M.D. University, Rohtak Vice President Secretary Joint Secrtary-cum-Treasurer Director, MDU Alumni (Ex-officio) Prof. S.P.S. Dahiya, Prof. K.P.S. Mahalwar, Prof. (Mrs.) Asha Kadiyan, Prof. Nasib Singh Gill, Head, Dept. of English & Foreign Languages, Dept. of Law, Dept. of Eng. & Foreign Languages, Dept. of Comp. Sci. & Applications, M.D.University, Rohtak M.D.University, Rohtak M.D.University, Rohtak M.D. University, Rohtak EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE Prof. Narender Kumar Garg Dr. H.J. Ghosh Roy Dr. M.S. Chaudhary Dr. (Mrs.) Sanju Nanda Dr.(Mrs.) Shalini Singh Head, Dept. of Commerce, Professor, IMSAR, Ex-Director, Maharaja Associate Professor, Associate Professor, M.D.University, Rohtak M.D.University, Rohtak Suraj Mal Institute Dept. of Pharmaceutical Science, Dept. of Psychology, M.D.University, Rohtak M.D.University, Rohtak M.D.University, Rohtak Dr. Surinder Sharma Mr. Jagbir Singh Rathee Dr. Dinesh Gabba Mr. Atul Jain Associate Professor in History, Director, Youth Welfare, Associate Prof. in Commerce, Director, Malabar Vaish College, Rohtak M.D.University, Rohtak Govt. College, Bhiwani Healthcare Centre, Rohtak MAHARSHI DAYANAND UNIVERSITY 2 l HARYANA RAJ BHAVAN, CHANDIGARH. MESSAGE I am happy to know that Maharshi Dyanand University, Rohtak is organizing its 2nd Alumni Meet on February 12, 2012 and a Alumni Directory is being published on the occasion. The Educational Institutions are the temples of knowledge which make a nation healthy, wealthy and wise.
    [Show full text]
  • SUPREME COURT of INDIA Abhay Singh Chautala Vs. C.B.I. Crl.A.No
    SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Abhay Singh Chautala Vs. C.B.I. Crl.A.No.1257 of 2011 (V.S. Sirpurkar and T.S.Thakur,JJ.,) 04.07.2011 JUDGMENT V.S. Sirpurkar,J., SLP(Crl.)No.7384 of 2010 1. This judgment will dispose of two Special Leave Petitions, they being SLP (Crl.) No. 7384 of 2010 and SLP (Crl.) No. 7428 of 2010. While Abhay Singh Chautala is the petitioner in the first Special Leave Petition, the second one has been filed by Shri Ajay Singh Chautala. The question involved is identical in both the SLPs and hence they are being disposed of by a common judgment. 2. Leave granted in both the Special Leave Petitions. 3. Whether the sanction under Section 19 of The Prevention of Corruption Act (hereinafter called "the Act" for short) was necessary against both the appellants and, therefore, whether the trial which is in progress against both of them, a valid trial, is common question. This question was raised before the Special Judge, CBI before whom the appellants are being tried for the offences under Sections 13(1) (e) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act read with Section 109 of Indian Penal Code in separate trials. 4. Separate charge sheets were filed against both the appellants for the aforementioned offences by the CBI. It was alleged that both the accused while working as the Members of Legislative Assembly had accumulated wealth disproportionate to their known sources of income. The charges were filed on the basis of the investigations conducted by the CBI.
    [Show full text]