Control of Flagellum Number in Naegleria Temperature Shock Induction of Multiflagellate Cells
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
jf. Cell Sci. 7) 463-481 (1970) 463 Printed in Great Britain CONTROL OF FLAGELLUM NUMBER IN NAEGLERIA TEMPERATURE SHOCK INDUCTION OF MULTIFLAGELLATE CELLS A. D. DINGLE Department of Biology, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada SUMMARY This paper describes the production of supernumerary flagella by flagellates of Naegleria gniberi exposed to sublethal temperature shocks during the amoeba-to-flagellate transforma- tion. When transformed at any constant temperature below 34 CC, cells of N. gniberi strain NB-i may develop from 1 to 4 flagella, but biflagellate cells predominate and the average number of flagella per cell in these populations is approximately 22. Populations exposed to a 38 °C temperature shock during transformation develop about twice as many flagella as controls (average number of flagella per cell is approximately 4's). The individual response of cells is extremely heterogeneous: some develop no more than the normal 2 flagella, whereas others develop as many as 18. At least half the cells produce 5 or more flagella, as opposed to fewer than 1 % with 5 or more flagella in control populations. Multiflagellate cells and popula- tions are normal in appearance, apart from the excess flagella and resulting disorientation of the normal swimming pattern. The supernumerary flagella, their basal bodies and the rhizoplast (which is also occasionally doubled) are indistinguishable from those of normal cells. Maximal production of flagella occurs over the narrow temperature range from 37-5 to 385 °C and is related to the duration of exposure to a given temperature: optimal flagellum induction is ob- tained following a 45-50 min exposure to a 38-2 °C temperature shock. After approximately 1 h the flagellates revert to amoebae, losing both normal and supernumerary flagella. Populations of these amoebae followed through 2 more cycles of retransformation and reversion developed the normal number of flagella (22). Clones isolated from multiflagellate populations were identical to normal populations, developing approximately 2-1 flagella per flagellate at normal temper- atures and 45 flagella per flagellate when temperature shocked again. INTRODUCTION Both the number and the distribution of cilia and flagella on eucaryotic cells are subject to enormous variation. For example, flagella are often found singly as on many protistan cells, on virtually all sperm cells and on the retinal rods of photoreceptors. They are frequently paired, as on other protistan cells, on epithelio-muscular cells of coelenterate gastroderm, and on cells of the rat adenohypophysis. Several or even thousands of flagella may be present on a single cell, as in the case of polymastigote flagellates, ciliates, sperms of ferns and cycads, and in the ciliated epithelia of both vertebrates and invertebrates. This extreme variability in the number and distribution of flagella raises intriguing questions about cellular differentiation and regulation at the organelle level. One such question concerns the nature of the controls which direct the development 464 A. D. Dingle of precisely one flagellum on mammalian spermatozoa (Fawcett, 1958), two flagella on cells of mammalian adenohypophysis (Wheatley, 1967), and hundreds of cilia on the ciliated epithelium of mammalian trachea (Dirksen & Crocker, 1966) or lung (Sorokin, 1968). In multicellular organisms these are developmental controls in which each different length, function and distribution is expressed against a constant genetic background. In the case of many unicellular organisms, so precise is the genetic control of flagellum number and distribution that these parameters often constitute important criteria for taxonomic characterization. Many examples come to mind, such as Monas and Polytoma with 1 flagellum, Chlamydomonas and Bodo with 2 and Tetramitus, Hexamitus and Octamitus with 4, 6 and 8 flagella respectively. Consider also the following comment on the classification of chrysomonad flagellates (Hall, 1953): 'on the basis of flagellar equipment, four families have been created: Chromulinidae, with one flagellum; Syncriptidae, with two equal flagella; Ochromonididae, with one long and one short flagellum; and Prymnesiidae, with three flagella.' Despite many such examples of rigorous controls over flagellum number, there have been repeated observations of cells with unusual numbers of flagella, for example mammalian sperm tails with double axonemes (Fawcett, 1961), and the atypical multiflagellated sperms of the snail Viviparus (Gall, 1961). Furthermore, the cells of many species routinely have variable numbers of flagella: newly flagellated swarm cells of the myxomycete Didymium nigripes possess only one flagellum but after several hours may develop a second (Kerr, i960). More impressive is the transition in which virtually all cells of mammalian foetal lung—whether fibroblast, chondrocyte, myo- cyte, mesothelial cell or epithelial cell—initially develop single 'primary' or (9 + 0) cilia. Later, only those cells of the maturing lung which differentiate into the epithelial border develop 250-300 basal bodies and cilia (9 + 2) apiece (Sorokin, 1968). The flagellates of Naegleriagniberi have been described as possessing predominantly 2 (Alexieff, 1912; Wilson, 1916) or predominantly 4 flagella (Willmer, 1956). Normal flagellate populations of the NB-i strain are composed of cells bearing from 1 to 4 flagella and, very rarely, exceptional cells are seen with 5 or more (Fulton & Dingle, 1967; reviewed in Fulton, 1969). During an investigation of temperature effects on the rate of Naegleria transformation it was noticed that among the reduced numbers of cells which developed flagella at sublethal temperatures (approximately 40 °C), there was a significant increase in the proportion of cells which produced 3, 4 or more flagella. At that time it was realized that the amoeba-to-flagellate transformation of Naegleria presented a near unique system with which to study the development of the centriole-like basal bodies in cells which have no visible centriole precursor. This is a particularly intriguing possibility in the light of the commonly accepted generaliza- tion that centrioles and basal bodies develop only in association with pre-existing centriole-like templates. However, because of their small size and limited number, centrioles are not easily visualized in cells, either by light or electron microscopy. Some means of either enhancing the resolution or increasing the number of centrioles and basal bodies is therefore a prerequisite for the elucidation of the developmental sequence by which these organelles arise. This paper presents such a method, based on a sublethal temperature shock, which Control of flagellum number in Naegleria 465 induces the development of approximately double the normal complement of basal bodies and flagella in transforming populations of Naegleria. The appearance and behaviour of the multiflagellate cells and their flagellar apparatuses are compared with those of normal biflagellate cells, and the longevity and heredity of the excess flagella and basal bodies are discussed in the light of the supposed continuity of centrioles and basal bodies from one cell generation to the next. Subsequent reports (A. D. Dingle, in preparation; C. Fulton & A. D. Dingle, in preparation) will describe the effects of environmental variables on the induction of excess flagella, and the use of these 'hairy' populations in studies of the development and continuity of basal bodies in Naegleria. A preliminary report of this work has been published (Dingle, 1967). MATERIALS AND METHODS Petri-dish cultures of Naegleria gruberi strain NB-i were grown at 34 °C on nutrient agar (NM) in association with the bacterium Aerobacter aerogenes, as described by Fulton & Dingle (1967). Cells from early stationary-phase cultures were suspended in 0-002 M tris (hydroxy- methyl) aminomethane (tris) buffer, pH 74, washed free of bacteria by differential centrifuga- tion using the method C described by Fulton (1969), and resuspended in tris at final cell densities of 5-10 x io5/ml. Aliquots of 15-20 ml of these suspensions were dispensed into unstoppered 125-ml Erlenmeyer flasks and shaken at 100 2-5-cm strokes per min under various temperature regimens as described in the Results section. Particular care was taken to control water baths to within ±o-i °C of any reported experimental temperature. Cell densities were determined by diluting aliquots of the suspension into a large volume of electrolyte (04% NaCl), agitating vigorously and counting in a Model F Coulter counter at threshold 20 (attenuation 2; aperture current 64). Mean cell volumes were likewise determined by threshold sizing with the Coulter counter which had been previously calibrated in cubic micrometres per threshold division (Sheldon & Parsons, 1967) against direct measurements made on 1000 NB-l cyst diameters using a Nikon filar micrometer eyepiece. At intervals, samples of transforming cells were fixed and stained in Lugol's iodine at a ratio of 4 drops cell suspension to 1 drop fixative. Using phase-contrast optics at 500 x magnification, the percentage of flagellated cells (%F) was determined for samples of 100 cells, and counts of the average number of flagella per cell (f/F) were made on samples of at least 300 flagellates. Light-microscope photomicrographs of iodine-fixed flagellates were taken using phase- contrast optics and Ilford FP-4 film in a Nikon EFM semi-automatic camera attachment. For electron microscopy, cell suspensions