Lots, the Future and God's Will
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
12|19 No.16 ien in Ostasien und Europa strateg ungs ältig . Bew nose d Prog Schicksal, Freiheit un page 4 Focus: International Society for the Critical Study of Divination, International Journal and Book Series page 16 Conferences / Workshops: Medieval Collections of Laws as Sources for Mantic Practices page 18 Miscellaneous – Letter of Support Editorial (Prof. Dr. Klaus Herbers) Lots, the Future and God’s Will Fate, Freedom and Prognostication. Strategies for Coping with the Future in East Asia and Europe IMPRINT Lots, the Future and God’s Will Dear Readers, Publisher It is with great joy that we present to you the six- teenth issue of our newsletter fate that covers the IKGF’s activities during the summer term 2018. In the end of the ancient period. Popes during the 9th century condemned such the editorial, IKGF Deputy Director Professor Klaus procedures in the form in which they were practiced, for example, in Bretagne: Herbers addresses the question of whether deci- “This is why we decide that the drawing of lots, by which you make all of sion-making by lots was considered an acceptable your judicial decisions, is no different from what the fathers condemned as practice during the European Middle Ages. If you divination and magic.” (Unde ad illorum similitudinem sortes, quibus vos cuncti have not yet heard about the formation of the Inter- national Society for the Critical Study of Divination in vestris discriminatis iudiciis nichil aliud quam quod illi patres dampnarunt, Director e.V., the focus article that informs about its estab- divinationes et maleficium esse decernimus.)1 Prof. Dr. Michael Lackner lishment, the academic journal, and book series may offer exciting news. Editor On the other hand, there were, of course, arguments in favor of the drawing Dr. Rolf Scheuermann of lots: the Bible provided numerous examples. Thomas Aquinas (d. 1274), one Like all previous issues, this one contains also of the most original scholars of the 13th century, invoked the most important The whole newsletter has been proofread by Dr. Sue Casson. summaries of talks presented by our guests, passages in his Summa Theologiae: Editorial assistance: Matthias Schumann and Alanah Marx. visiting fellows, and staff during the IKGF Lecture Prof. Dr. Klaus Herbers, deputy director IKGF Series. This section is followed by a short report on ‘Käte Hamburger Center (KHC) a workshop that focused on medieval collections IIª–IIae q. 95 a. 8 arg. 2 Praeterea, Objection 2. There is, seemingly, – Advanced Study in the Humanities’ of laws as sources for mantic practices. At the end, Should we allocate research funding in the ea quae a sanctis in Scripturis nothing unlawful in the is the official name of the ten ‘International Consortia for Research in the we also present to you a letter that was signed Humanities’ that are funded by the German Ministry of Education and future by drawing lots? How would the IKGF observata leguntur non videntur observances which the Scriptures by more than 60 renowned scholars in support Research. We are therefore sometimes referring to the ‘IKGF’ (Internatio- cope with this? Drawing lots as a means of esse illicita. Sed sancti viri, tam in relate as being practiced by holy of an initiative to establish the Consortium as a nales Kolleg für Geisteswissenschaftliche Forschung) as KHC in our pub- decision-making has a long tradition, one veteri quam in novo testamento, men. Now, both in the Old and lications. permanent institution of the Friedrich-Alexander University Erlangen-Nürnberg. that is still alive today. The most recent pope inveniuntur sortibus usi esse. in the New Testament, we find International Consortium of the Coptic Church was selected by lot. As Legitur enim Iosue VII, quod holy men practicing the casting for Research in the Humanities Last but not least, we hope that you enjoy reading Michael Grünbart (University of Münster) Iosue, ex praecepto domini, of lots. For it is related (Joshua Hartmannstraße 14 about our current activities and look forward to 91052 Erlangen - Germany explained during a recent workshop (https:// iudicio sortium punivit Achar, qui 7:14, sqq.) that Josue, at the Lord’s receiving your feedback. Telefon: +49 (0)9131 85 - 64340 www.ikgf.uni-erlangen.de/events/event- de anathemate surripuerat. Saul command, pronounced sentence Fax: +49 (0)9131 85 - 64360 history/workshops/2019/2019-09-Lot-and- etiam sorte deprehendit filium by lot on Achan who had stolen the Email: [email protected] Dr. Rolf Scheuermann Internet: www.ikgf.fau.de (Research Coordinator) Randomization.shtml), three names were suum Ionatham mel comedisse, anathema. Again, Saul, by drawing placed in an urn and a young boy had to draw the ut habetur I Reg. XIV. Ionas etiam, lots, found that his son Jonathan ISSN (Print) 2364-2580 decisive slip of paper. During the discussion of a facie domini fugiens, sorte had eaten honey (1 Samuel 14:58, ISSN (Online) 2364-2661 the workshop, it became apparent how similar deprehensus, est in mare deiectus, sqq.): Jonas, when fleeing from the Design and Layout the issues related to the drawing of lots are if ut legitur Ionae I. Zacharias etiam face of the Lord, was discovered Masami Hirohata we compare East Asia with Western Europe. sorte exiit ut incensum poneret, ut and thrown into the sea (Jonah 1:7, Circulation and Print Decision-making and pursuing happiness by legitur Luc. I. Matthias etiam est sqq.): Zacharias was chosen by lot This newsletter is published in English and printed in 750 copies. To receive regular information about ongoing events at the consortium, lot? Even today, some lotteries are still called sorte ab apostolis in apostolatum to offer incense (Luke 1:9): and the please subscribe to (ikgf-info). To receive the electronic version of this “Glückshafen” (pot of luck), as Matthias Heiduk electus, ut legitur Act. I. Ergo apostles by drawing lots elected newsletter, please subscribe to (ikgf-news). Both actions are possible pointed out during the same workshop. videtur quod divinatio sortium non Matthias to the apostleship (Acts via our website www.ikgf.de. If you prefer to receive the printed ver- sion of this newsletter, please notify the editor. sit illicita. 1:26). Therefore it would seem that Still, decision-making by lot, or sortes, was divination by lots is not unlawful. We have endeavored to obtain all rights of use for the publication of a contested practice in the Latin West during materials of third parties. In case rights of use have not been clarified, please contact the IKGF. Title page: Dosso Dossi: Allegoria della Fortuna (ca.1536) (J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles) 1 Klaus Herbers and Veronika Unger, eds., Papstbriefe des 9. Jahrhunderts (Freiherr vom Stein-Gedächtnisausgabe 51, Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 2018), 70–73. 2 3 Fate, Freedom and Prognostication. Strategies for Coping with the Future in East Asia and Europe What Thomas deduced from these examples seemed clear If we consider the different legal sentences during the Since the founding of the International Consortium for Research conceived as a network for scholars doing research on the wide enough: “Therefore it would seem that divination by lots is not Middle Ages (which are at our disposal in our database of in the Humanities “Fate, Freedom, and Prognostication” in range of topics connected with arts and techniques connected unlawful.” (Ergo videtur quod divinatio sortium non sit illicita.) medieval legislative texts: http://www.ikgf.uni-erlangen.de/ 2009, it has hosted 155 international visiting scholars by mid- with the desire to cope with the future. Divination, however, publications/databases/), we can find many cases in which 2019. Over these years, it became clear that an organization was can also be applied to the search for ‘hidden’ phenomena in In late Antiquity, Augustine of Hippo (d. 430) had already lots were either permitted or not. The practice of casting lots needed that could serve “as a sustainable platform for scientific the past.” Due to the connection between both the Society and acknowledged in his Confessions how the Bible could offer was criticized by the ecclesiastical authorities and, above all, exchange in our field of research,” as Michael Lackner, president the Consortium, with its considerable international outreach, advice, especially in cases of doubt or ambiguity. Accordingly, in papal Responsa, canonical collections, and the decisions of of the society, pointed out. This is why the International Society there are various opportunities for scientific exchange. The his conversion to Christianity is described in the following Councils as a pagan tradition that failed to respect the will of for the Critical Study of Divination e.V. was established in 2016. Consortium organizes workshops and conferences on a regular manner: Almighty God as the only one knowing the future. On the other Starting with 33 founding members, it has grown steadily over the basis, and, Lackner adds, “several of our visiting scholars have hand, stressing the possibility of wanting to know God’s will past year, so that it now encompasses more than 90 registered been encouraged to coordinate workshops in their special field, “Eagerly then I returned to the place where Alypius was was one way to Christianize. The Sortes Sanctorum, a collection members. According to Professor Lackner, the society “is which makes our network ever more extensive.” sitting; for there had I laid the volume of the Apostle when I of oracles, integrated lots into a liturgical framework by placing arose thence. I seized, opened, and in silence read that section them onto an altar or combining them with orations, missae on which my eyes first fell: Not in rioting and drunkenness, not and benedictions. An International Journal and a Book Series in chambering and wantonness, not in strife and envying; but put ye on the Lord Jesus Christ, and make not provision for the Hence, not only did Thomas Aquinas eventually adopt a The immediate focus of the Society is the publication of the International Journal flesh, in concupiscence.