SPATIAL and TEMPORAL PATTERNING of OBSIDIAN MATERIALS in the GEYSERS REGION David A. Fredrickson
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SPATIAL AND TEMPORAL PATTERNING OF OBSIDIAN MATERIALS IN THE GEYSERS REGION David A. Fredrickson LTRODUCTION square miles in the Mayacmas Mountains within TIhis paper focuses upon the archaeology of the northeastern Sonoma and adjoining portions ofLake geothermal region of northeastern Sonoma and adjoin- and Mendocino counties (Map 1). The approximate ing portions of Lake and Mendocino counties, Califor- center of the area is about 75 air miles north of San nia, referred to here as the Geysers region, and draws Francisco, with Clear Lake located an additional 15 from information and materials obtained over a period miles to the north. The study area trends roughly 20 of 14 years during more than 100 separate archaeologi- miles in a northwesterly direction, with its widest cal field investigations implemented as a result of portion of about 12 miles trending northeasterly environmental protection regulations that helped guide through a central point formed at thejoined corners of the development of geothermal resources in the region the three counties. The regions is comprised for the (see Fredrickson 1985). While field work was an most part of the Mayacmas uplands, contrasting with activity of cultural resource management, the integra- the surrounding lowlands ofKelsey and Putah creeks, tive and synthetic work is an academic endeavor (cf. and the Russian River. Terrain is usually rugged, Lipe 1974). The present study further illustrates the lacking broad valleys, with numerous slopes greater contributions that small, often ephemeral, archaeologi- than 60 percent. Although slopes often rise steeply cal sites (in this example, ones located in a hinterland from stream bottoms, occasional narrow valleys and locality) can provide to the understanding of a region's low rolling hills offer more gentle terrain. prehistory (see Whalen 1986; Glassow 1985). Obsidian For purposes of the present work, the study area sourcing and hydration studies offer an indispensible has been straified with respect to major stream key to such understanding when employed not only to drainages. To the north, wholly within Lake County, obtain temporal control but also to gain estimates of are the drainages of High Valley and Kelsey creeks, interrelatedness, or relative social distance, between together referred to as the Kelsey Creek locality; in the adjacent localities (Kay 1975; Wilmsen 1973). central area totally in Sonoma County are Squaw Creek and the lower portion ofBig Sulphur Creek, whose THE STUDY AREA drainages are referred to here as the Squaw Creek locality; to the south, also totally in Sonoma County, is Although the geothermal resource area within the upper portion of Big Sulphur Creek, referred to as which the Geysers region is located is much larger, the the Big Sulphur Creek locality; to the west, in Lake area under study here consists ofabout 100 contiguous County, is Putah Creek, whose lands are referred to as 96 Conftrbutions ofthe Archaeological Research Faciliy Number 48, December 1989 MAP 1 MAP OF GEOTHERMAL STUDY AREA SHOWING MAJOR DRAINAGES AND ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITES Boggs 4 Lake Miles 0 .5 1 2 3 I I I 1 Patterning ofObsidian in the Geysers Region 97 the Putah Creek locality. subsurface investigations, the actual numbers for each The region is marked by a complex floral mosaic, category are subject to change as subsurface data consisting of various combinations of chaparral, become available. cypress forest, grassland, oak woodland, Douglas fir- It was recognized during initial work in the oak woodland, and yellow pine forest (Simons 1985). geothermal region that obsidian flakes occurred at Although all these vegetation communities are present virtually all of the identified archaeological sites. within each of the four localities, different localities are Indeed, a significant majority of sites was marked by dominated by different plant associations, a circum- obsidian flakes alone, with even bifacially worked tools stance that affects the relative frequency of different apparently absent (Fredrickson 1974: 3ff.). Limited site types. Chparl and cypress forest associations subsurface investigation did little to change this dominate much of the Kelsey Creek locality, while perception (Fredrickson 1985: 29). Because geother- grassland and oak woodland cover a great deal of the mal development is land intensive, it was also recog- Squaw Creek locality. Flake scatters, assumed to be nized that impacts to archaeological resources, both associated with hunting, dominate Kelsey Creek, while anticipated and locationally unanticipated, could occur sites with more extensive cultural deposits, assumed to as a result of implementation of any one of the many be indicative of upland camps, are most common at different projects under development (Fredrickson Squaw Creek. In short, the study area forms a rugged 1974: 16ff.). Although each power plant utilizes only a upland backcountry, usually dominated by chaparral few acres, it draws upon steam from wells contained and yellow pine forest, as contrasted with the more within a leasehold averaging about 800 to 1000 acres in gentle and generous terrain which surrounds the area. size. Considering that about 30 power plants are now As already mentioned, the study area also contains operating, under construction, or in the permitting geothermal resources, the development of which has stages, a significantly large ground surface area is prompted the archaeological work reported here. affected. Within each leasehold are about 10 to 15 Territories of four ethnographic Native American steam wells required to furnish steam to operate the communities converge within the region, with Geysers power plant, a complex network of pipelines to trans- Rock at the head of Squaw Creek forming the approxi- port the steam, support roads, and power transmission mate point of convergence. An Eastern Pomo commu- lines. Add to this service centers, disposal areas, and nity with its major villages along the lower reaches of other geothermal features, and the potential threat to Kelsey Creek controlled the Kelsey Creek locality. A archaeological resources through land disturbance Southern Pomo community with its major village activities becomes acute. located on the Russian River near Cloverdale controlled In view of these circumstances, an explicit plan the Squaw Creek portion. The upper Big Sulphur Creek that focused upon analysis ofarchaeological obsidian portion was controlled by a Western Wappo community was initiated in 1973 to complement the archaeological whose major village is believed to have been at the surveys required by law (Fredrickson 1974: 29). Geysers proper. The Putah Creek locality was con- Although preliminary analyses of obsidian data have trolled by the community at Middletown, consisting of been reported previously (e.g., Eisenman and Fre- either Lake Miwok or Northern Wappo, or both drickson 1980; Jackson 1974), a more thorough (Kroeber 1932: 366ff.; Merriam 1955: 43ff.). analysis was made possible during the preparation of an archaeological management plan for the geothermal THE DATA BASE area by Sonoma State University's Anthropological Studies center (Fredrickson 1985) under contract to the Systematic and intensive archaeological survey U.S. Bureau of Land Management (see acknowledge- associated with geothermal resources development ments). began in 1973 (e.g., Fredrickson 1973; Peak 1973). Since then, numerous surveys have generated more than ASSUMPTIONS 200 reports, letters, and environmental documents pertaining to archaeological resources. As a result of Our studies have attempted to control for two this work, more than 100 contiguous square miles have major variables, space and time. The spatial dimension been surveyed and more than 340 prehistoric archaeo- has been controlled as described above through logical sites have been recorded. Of these, about 63 stratifying by major drainage. The temporal dimension percent are flake scatters while about 37 percent are has been controlled, though only to a limited extent believed to have subsurface deposits. Because these because of cost constraints, through source-specific evaluations are based primarily upon observable surface obsidian hydration studies. Because no satisfactory attributes and have only occasionally been tested by hydration rates have been developed for the obsidian 98 Contributions ofthe Archaeological Research Facility Number 48, December 1989 sources under consideration, we have resisted the ties are more or less equally distributed within two temptation to convert obsidian hydration readings into communities, then fall-off is low by definition and calendric dates. However, at this point in the research, interrelatedness is assumed to be high. source-specific hydration data reported in microns Several simple assumptions, none of which is provide a satisfactory framework for relative dating. necessarily true, have been made in drawing inferences The spatial stratification of the study area by major from the distributional data. First, the principle of least drainages (rather tanm vegetation or geomorphology) is effort is assumed. For example Borax Lake obsidian is not an arbitrary procedure. Territorial boundaries in assumed to have entered the region from the northeast, ethnographic Califomia were frequently at divides where its parent source is located, rather than by a more between watersheds. This was certainly the case within round about route from the south. Second, it is assumed the present study area. To place this geomorphological