Energy Evidence Volume
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EU AGRICULTURE, FISHERIES, ENVIRONMENT AND ENERGY SUB-COMMITTEE EU energy: decarbonisation and economic competitiveness Oral and written evidence Contents ABB Limited—Written evidence ........................................................................................................ 4 Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators (ACER), Office of Gas and Electricity Markets (Ofgem) and National Grid—Oral Evidence (QQ 339-357) ....................................... 8 Peter Atherton and Bloomberg New Energy Finance (BNEF)—Oral evidence (QQ 171- 185) ......................................................................................................................................................... 27 Bloomberg New Energy Finance (BNEF) and Peter Atherton—Oral evidence (QQ 171- 185) ......................................................................................................................................................... 44 Bloomburg New Energy Finance (BNEF)—Supplementary Written Evidence ..................... 45 Professor Peter Cameron—Oral evidence (QQ 81-92) ............................................................ 47 Centre for European Reform (CER)—Written evidence .......................................................... 58 Centre for European Reform (CER) and Dr Karsten Neuhoff—Oral evidence (QQ 1-33) ................................................................................................................................................................. 65 Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers (CIBSE)—Written evidence .............. 79 Confederation of British Industry (CBI) and World Wildlife Fund (WWF)—Oral Evidence (QQ 305-338) ...................................................................................................................................... 82 Confederation of UK Coal Producers (CoalPro) and European Climate Foundation (ECF)—Oral evidence (QQ 104-117) .......................................................................................... 100 Juan Pablo Davico—Written evidence ......................................................................................... 117 Chris Davies MEP and Dan Jorgenson MEP—Oral Evidence (QQ 248-253) ...................... 119 Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC)—Written evidence .......................... 127 Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC)—Oral Evidence (QQ 358-380) ..... 134 EDF Energy—Written evidence ..................................................................................................... 150 EDF Energy, ScottishPower and SSE—Oral evidence (QQ 186-202) ................................... 158 EDF—Supplementary Written Evidence ...................................................................................... 176 Energy Networks Association (ENA)—Written evidence ...................................................... 179 Energy Technologies Institute (ETI)—Written evidence ......................................................... 183 E.ON—Written evidence ................................................................................................................ 190 E.ON—Supplementary Written Evidence ................................................................................... 193 European Network of Transmission System Operators for Electricity (ENTSO-E)—Oral Evidence (QQ 278-304) ................................................................................................................... 197 European Climate Foundation (ECF) and Confederation of UK Coal Producers (CoalPro) —Oral evidence (QQ 104-117) ..................................................................................................... 209 European Climate Foundation—Supplementary Written Evidence ...................................... 210 European Commission—Oral evidence (QQ 60-70) ............................................................... 215 European Commission—Supplementary Written Evidence .................................................... 228 European Commission—Supplementary Oral Evidence (QQ 216-236) .............................. 231 European Commission— Supplementary Oral Evidence (QQ 254-277) ............................. 245 European Economic and Social Committee (EESC)—Written evidence ............................. 267 European Investment Bank (EIB)—Oral evidence (QQ 157-170) ......................................... 272 Fiona Hall MEP and Niki Tzavela MEP—Oral Evidence (QQ 237-247) ................................ 285 Fiona Hall MEP—Written evidence .............................................................................................. 294 The Florence School of Regulation (FSR)—Written evidence ............................................... 298 Antony Froggatt—Oral evidence (QQ 34-59) ........................................................................... 303 Dr Robert Gross and RenewableUK—Oral evidence (QQ 93-103) .................................... 317 Professor Dieter Helm—Oral evidence (QQ 118-140) .......................................................... 330 INEOS—Written evidence ............................................................................................................. 347 Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR)—Written evidence ............................................. 357 Institution of Engineering and Technology (IET)—Written evidence ................................... 365 Dan Jorgenson MEP and Chris Davies MEP—Oral Evidence (QQ 248–253) ..................... 371 Sir Donald Miller F.R Eng, FRSE—Written evidence ................................................................ 372 National Farmers’ Union (NFU)—Written evidence ............................................................... 377 National Grid—Written evidence ................................................................................................. 379 National Grid—Supplementary Written Evidence .................................................................... 388 National Grid, Office of Gas and Electricity Markets (Ofgem) and Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators (ACER)—Oral Evidence (QQ 339-357) ...................... 390 Dr Karsten Neuhoff—Written evidence ..................................................................................... 391 Dr Karsten Neuhoff and Centre for European Reform—Oral evidence (QQ 1-33) ....... 395 Dr Karsten Neuhoff—Supplementary Written Evidence ........................................................ 396 Professor David Newbery Sc.D. (Cantab.) Ph.D. (Cantab.) M.A. (Cantab.)—Written evidence ............................................................................................................................................... 401 Office of Gas and Electricity Markets (Ofgem), Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators (ACER) and National Grid—Oral Evidence (QQ 339-357) ............................... 408 Oil & Gas UK—Written evidence ................................................................................................. 409 Oil & Gas UK—Oral evidence (QQ 71-80) ................................................................................ 417 Poland, Ministry of Environment—Supplementary Written Evidence .................................. 426 RenewableUK—Written evidence ................................................................................................ 430 RenewableUK and Dr Robert Gross—Oral evidence (QQ 93-103) .................................... 439 Scientific Alliance—Written evidence .......................................................................................... 440 ScottishPower, EDF Energy and SSE—Oral evidence (QQ 186-202) ................................... 444 ScottishPower—Supplementary Written Evidence ................................................................... 445 2 SmartestEnergy Ltd—Written evidence ...................................................................................... 451 SSE—Written evidence .................................................................................................................... 454 SSE, EDF Energy and ScottishPower—Oral evidence (QQ 186-202) ................................... 458 SSE—Supplementary Written Evidence ....................................................................................... 459 Professor Jonathan Stern—Oral evidence (QQ 141-156) ....................................................... 461 Professor Jonathan Stern—Supplementary Written Evidence ................................................ 475 Niki Tzavela MEP and Fiona Hall MEP—Oral Evidence (QQ 237-247) ................................ 476 Vestas—Written evidence .............................................................................................................. 477 Dr Joseph Wheatley PhD—Written evidence ........................................................................... 481 Martin Wolf and Dimitri Zenghelis—Oral evidence (QQ 203-215) ..................................... 483 World Wildlife Fund (WWF)—Written evidence .................................................................... 498 World Wildlife Fund (WWF) and Confederation of British Industry (CBI)—Oral Evidence (QQ 305-338) .................................................................................................................................... 511 World Wildlife Fund (WWF)—Supplementary Written Evidence ........................................ 512 Dimitri Zenghelis—Written evidence .........................................................................................