University Microfilms, Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan the HISTORICAL GEOGRAPHY of the ERIE TRIANGLE
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
This dissertation has been 64-7049 microfilmed exactly as received SCHMIEDER, Allen Arthur, 1933- THE HISTORICAL GEOGRAPHY OF THE ERIE TRIANGLE. The Ohio State University, Ph. D ., 1963 Geography University Microfilms, Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan THE HISTORICAL GEOGRAPHY OF THE ERIE TRIANGLE DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio S tate U niversity By Allen Arthur Schmieder, B.S., M.A. ***** The Ohio State University 1963 Approved By visei Department of Geography "Geographie without Historie hath life and motion but at randome, and unstable. Historie without Geographie like a dead carkasse hath neither life nor motion at all." Peter Heylyn, 1621 i i ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author is deeply grateful to all who in numerous ways have assisted in the preparation of this dissertation. To Dr. Guy-Harold Smith who gave unstintingly of his time, I am most indebted; for it was under his direction that this study was undertaken and brought to the final phases of completion. I am also appreciative of the many helpful criticisms and sugges tio n s made by P ro fe sso r's Fred A. Carlson, Lawrence A. Hoffman and Alfred J, Wright of the Department of Geography, Ohio State University. Likewise, I wish to express my gratitude to Professor's Frank Ahnert and Jeremy H. Anderson of the Department of Geography, University of Maryland, who read early drafts of the manuscript and made valuable suggestions for its improvement. Many people in various positions of leadership in the Erie region were very helpful in providing advice and data. Mr, Christopher Capotis, Director of the Erie County Planning Commission, and Mr. John Lampe, E rie Harbormaster, were outstanding in th e ir a ssista n c e . Both conducted field excursions for the author to places of particular relevance to the dissertation, and together, supplied more locally published literature than all other sources combined, Mrs. C. F. Wilson, historian of the Erie Public Museum, carefully read and criticized the preliminary outline of the dissertation and contributed greatly to the credence of its historical content. i i i The author also wishes to express his thanks to Professor Joseph Wiedel, University of Maryland cartographer, who helped in the prepara tion of some of the maps. I am especially appreciative of the enduring patience of my wife, Janet, who has lived with this project since its inception. She accompanied me on field trips through the Triangle area, helped in the preparation of many of the illustrations and provided a critical mind against which ideas could be sounded. Because their numbers are many, acknowledgment is made in general to all others who contributed so generously to the development of this dissertation. Any errors of fact or of reasoning are of course solely the responsibility of the author. iv CONTENTS Page PREFACE............................................................................................................................ i i ACKNOWLEDGMENTS......................................................................................................... i i i TABLES.............................................................................................................................. v ii ILLUSTRATIONS........................................................................................................... v i i i INTRODUCTION......................................................................................................................1 Chapter I . DESCRIPTION OF THE AREA............................................................................. 12 The C u ltu ra l S ettin g The P hysical S ettin g I I . PRE-PIONEER PERIOD, TO 1795 .......................................................................68 Introduction Sequent Occupance Prior to 1753 A Frontier land of Contested Rights, 1753-1794 I I I . PIONEER PERIOD, 1795-1828 .................................................................... 102 S e ttin g S a lt Trade S hipbuilding and Lake Commerce P opulation In dustry Agriculture Conclusions IV. CANAL PERIOD, 1828-1860 ......................................................................... 125 S e ttin g Pennsylvania Canal Erie Extension Canal Population Agriculture Industry Summary and Conclusions Page V. RAIIRQAD PERIOD, 1860-1910 ........................................................... 159 S ettin g Principal Triangle Railroads The Impact of the Railroad upon the Triangle's Economy Population Agriculture Industry The Relative Decline of Erie as a Lake Port Recreation and Tourism Summary and Conclusions VI. MODERN PERIOD—AN ERA OF INDUSTRY, 1910-1963 ...................... 192 S ettin g Population Agriculture Industry Port of Erie Recreation and Tourism V II. THE PROSPECT............................................................................................ 236 Introduction Population Agriculture Industry Commerce Recreation and Tourism Summary APPENDIX................................................................................................................. 243 BIBLIOGRAPHY ...................................................................................................... 246 AUTOBIOGRAPHY.........................................................................................................258 v i TABLES Table Page 1. Meteorological Normals, Means and Extremes for Port Erie . 50 2. Coal Tonnage Shipped into the Triangle Region on the Erie Extension Canal between 1845 and 1860 ...........................................134 3. Rank of the Foreign Bom in the Erie Triangle, 1960...................198 4. Companies Which Have Transferred All or Portions of Their Manufacturing Operations from Erie to Suburban Locations since 1950...................................................................................................224 v ii i ILLUSTRATIONS Figure Page 1. Regional Situation of the Erie Triangle...................................14 2. Erie Triangle, 1963 ..............................................................................16 3. Abandoned Clay Q uarry ......................................................................... 27 4. Exposed Rock Strata along Four-Mile Creek.............................. 27 5. Presque Isle ............................................................................................... 30 6. Shorewood Beach.......................................................................................33 7. Elk Creek Beach .......................................................................................33 8. Rock Defended Bluffs, East of the City of Erie......................36 9. Unconsolidated, Regolith Bluffs, West of the City of E rie ............................................................................................................. 36 10. Six-Mile Creek G ulf ..............................................................................40 11. Four-Mile Creek Gulf..............................................................................40 12. Hydrology of the Erie Triangle........................................................ 43 13. Average Annual Precipitation............................................................ 52 14. Number o f Days w ithout K illin g F ro s........................................... t 54 15. Soil Areas of the Erie Triangle.................................................... 60 16. Native Vegetation of the Erie Triangle.......................................64 17. Areal Extent of the Mound Builders in the United States .73 18. Location of Former Mounds in the Erie Triangle......................73 19. Areal Distribution of the Eries Indians ...................................78 v i i i Figure Page 20. Historic Indian Paths of the Erie Triangle ................. 85 21. The Settlement at Presque Isle in 1753 ......................... 92 22. Salinas-Pittsburgh Salt Trade Route ................................... 108 23. Erie Harbor: Shipbuilding and Outfitting Sites of War of 1812 American Great Lakes* Naval Fleet. .115 24. Extent of Primary Road Development, 1795, 1819, 1960 .................................................................................................. 119 25. Regional Canals, 1860.................................................................. 131 26. Erie Harbor and Canal Basin, 1851 ............................................ 131 27. East Canal Basin Marina .............................................................154 28. The Ruberoid Company, a Bayside Industry .........................154 29. Regional Railroads, 1914 ......................................................... 162 30. Relative Positions of Lake Erie Ports...............................187 31. Population Distribution, 1958................................................ 195 32. Principle Transportation Routes, 1960...............................200 33. Agricultural Regions, 1960 .....................................................203 34. The Rise of Sport Fishing......................................................... 222 35. Boat Storage Locker, Erie Lake Shore.....................................222 36. Erie Industrial Park .....................................................................228 37. Truck Stop, Pennsylvania Interstate Route 90 . .228 38. Abandoned Railroad Tracks along the Bay .......................... 230 39. Ships Anchored for the Winter in Presque Isle Bay. .230 40. Presque Isle Recreation Facilities, 1963.........................234