Drymophila and Hypocnemis)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Auk 116(4):1093-1106, 1999 HIGH LEVELS OF MITOCHONDRIAL DNA DIFFERENTIATION IN TWO LINEAGES OF ANTBIRDS (DRYMOPHILA AND HYPOCNEMIS) JOHN M. BATES?3 SHANNONJ. HACKETT,• AND JAQUELINEM. GOERCK2 •Departmentof Zoology,Field Museum of NaturalHistory, Roosevelt Road at LakeShore Drive, Chicago,Illinois 60605, USA; and 2Departmentof Biology,University of Missouri-St.Louis, 8001 NaturalBridge Road, St. Louis, Missouri 63121, USA ABSTRACT.--Weassessed levels of geneticdifferentiation based on mitochondrialDNA se- quences(portions of the cytochrome-band ND2 genes)at severaltaxonomic levels in tham- nophilidantbirds. Our focuswas to investigategenetic differentiation among populations of two speciesin the genusDrymophila and to identify the sistergenus to Drymophila.In addition,we presentevidence of highlevels of populationsubdivision in Hypocnemiscantator (WarblingAntbird). This widespread Amazonian taxon co-occurs, on a localscale, with D. devillei(Striated Antbird). Sequencedivergences among populations of D. devilleiand D. cau- data(Long-tailed Antbird), two bamboo-specialists,often exceeded 2% between populations. Divergenceswithin H. cantator,a specieswith moregeneralized habitat requirements and a more"continuous" distribution, were even higher, including 5.7% divergence between sam- plesseparated by 350 km of apparentlycontinuous Amazonian forest. At highertaxonomic levels,genetic distances suggest that antbirdgenera and biological species are old. Genetic divergencebetween the two speciesthat comprise the genusHypocnemis was 9.3%, and di- vergencebetween D. devilleiand D. caudataaveraged 7.2%. Weighted parsimony and maxi- mum-likelihoodanalyses supported Hypocnemis asthe sister taxon to Drymophila;the genus Myrmotherulawas not monophyletic,supporting previous allozyme analyses. In additionto the protein-codingsequences, we foundthat spacerregions between genes also provided phylogeneticallyinformative characters from the levelof suboscinefamilies to within the biologicalspecies that we studied.Received 31 March1998, accepted 7 April 1999. WITH SOME266 currentlyrecognized biolog- this study and are thoughtto be restricted ical species(Parker et al. 1996), the antbirds largelyto areasof bambooin the upper-tropi- (formerlyFormicariidae) recently have been di- cal zone of the Andes (D. caudata)and in the videdinto theFormicariidae (ground antbirds, westernand southernparts of the Amazonba- 70 species)and Thamnophilidae(typical ant- sin (D. devillei;Fig. 1). The entiregenus is cur- birds,196 species) based on DNA-DNA hybrid- rently under study by one of us (JMG) to un- izationdata (Sibleyand Ahlquist1990). Mem- derstandits evolutionaryhistory and how this bersof thesespecies-rich families are distrib- history relatesto current ecologyand distri- uted throughoutthe Neotropics.Antbirds in- bution. habit all levels of tropical forest and many Specializationon bambooexhibited by D. de- different insectivorous niches such that as villei and D. caudatais known for a small guild many as 40 speciescan occurat a singlesite. In of Neotropicalbirds (Parker 1982, Kratter 1997, thispaper, we presentdata on geneticstructure Parker et al. 1997). Bamboo-specialistbirds, within and among three biologicalspecies like theirpreferred habitat, tend to havepatchy (sensuMayr 1963) of thamnophilidantbirds: distributions. In the Andean foothills, D. cau- Drymophiladevillei (Striated Antbird), D. caudata data occurs between 1,200 and 2,500 m from (Long-tailedAntbird), and Hypocnemiscantator Venezuelato Bolivia.Three subspecies,with (WarblingAntbird). presumablydisjunct distributions, have been Thegenus Drymophila has been considered to described(Peters 1951), but eventhese subspe- have eight species(Peters 1951), six of which are restricted to the Atlantic forests of eastern ciesprobably are composedof disjunctpopu- South America. The other two are the focus of lations subdividedby deep river valleys and high mountainridges. Based on limited speci- men data, D. devilleishows a similarlypatchy E-mail:[email protected] distribution in the lowlands (Stotz 1990, Rid- 1093 1094 BATES,HACKETT, AND GOERCK [Auk, Vol. 116 10•N oo Attc•zt•,c Ocec• P•c•.f•.c Ocec•'•. 80"W 75 55 F•G.1. Distribution of Drymophilacaudata (circles) and D. devillei(triangles). In severalplaces both spe- ciesare known from the samesector (closed circles). Sites for samplesof Hypocnemiscantator used in this study are also indicated(open squares);in severalinstances these sites correspond with localitieswhere D. devilleioccurs (dark triangles).Numbers depict localitiesin Appendix. The easternmostopen triangle is where the type of D. devilleisubochracea was collected.Locational data compiledand map preparedby M. and P. Isler. gely and Tudor 1994, Stotz et al. 1997). Two villei and two populationsof D. caudatafrom subspecieshave been described, both of which southernPeru. To establish the outgroup for the were consideredto be probablebiological spe- genus,we also obtainedsequences from indi- ciesby Parkeret al. (1996).The nominateform, vidualsrepresenting a numberof other small D. d. devillei, is known from areas of bamboo in thamnophilids.To provideadditional compar- southeastern Peru and northern Bolivia, but ative data on geneticstructure within biologi- severalspecimen records also exist from as far cal species,we alsoincluded multiple samples north as easternColombia (Stotz 1990).Dry- of both biologicalspecies of Hypocnemis.Al- mophilad. subochraceais known from only a few thoughthese samples cover only a smallpor- localities that lie south of the Amazon, from the tion of the geographicdistribution of thesetwo east bank of the Rio Madeira to a western trib- taxa(particularly for H. cantator),they provide utary of the Rio Xingu in Brazil. more divergencedata from anotherlineage We presentsequences from parts of the mi- from this part of Amazonia.Our resultspro- tochondrialcytochrome-b (cyt b) and NADH vide a clearpicture of thehigh levelsof genetic dehydrogenasesubunit 2 (ND2) genesfor mul- structurewe believeare typical of many forest- tiple populationsof both subspeciesof D. de- dwelling Neotropicalspecies. October1999] GeneticDifferentiation in Antbirds 1095 METHODS Biosystems,Inc. [ABI]). Cycle-sequencingreactions were Nh4OAcprecipitated, rinsed in ethanol, dried, DNA sequencing.--Samplesof the 34 individuals resuspendedin a formamide-EDTA solution, and used in this study were obtainedfrom tissuecollec- run on an ABI 377 Automated DNA Sequencer.Se- tions of the LouisianaState UniversityMuseum of quenceswere obtained from both strandsof DNA, NaturalScience (LSUMNS), the Academyof Natural checkedusing the programSequencher 3.0 (Gene Sciencesin Philadelphia(ANSP), and the Bird Di- CodesCorp.), aligned to the chicken(Gallus gallus) vision of the Field Museum of Natural History sequence(Desjardins and Morais 1990) to ensure (FMNH; Appendix).Voucher specimens are housed there were no insertions or deletions of bases in the at these institutions, the Museu Paraense Emilio antbird sequences,and submitted to GenBank Goeldi, Be16m,Brazil (MPEG), and Museu de Zoo- (AFl18154 to AFl18221; Appendix). logia da Universidadede S•o Paulo,Brazil (MZUSP). The followingprotocol was undertakento ensure All DNA work was carried out in the Field Museum's that the smallfragments of DNA weremitochondrial PritzkerLaboratory for the Studyof MolecularSys- in origin (not nuclear copies).(1) Sequencesof se- tematicsand Evolution.Samples were from the two lectedindividuals were verified by amplifying(with speciesof Drymophilaand eight other speciesof L14990 and H16065 for cyt b and L5215 and H6313 thamnophilids(Terenura humeralis [Chestnut-shoul- for ND2; sequencesin Hackett [1996], except for dered Antwren]; Myrmotherulalongipennis [Long- H6313 [CCTTTATTTAAGGCTTTGAAGGC]) and se- winged Antwren]; M. leucophthalma[White-eyed quencinga larger pieceof mtDNA using the primers Antwren]; M. hauxwelli [Plain-throated Antwren]; above.(2) Both DNA strandswere sequencedto en- Formicivorarufa [Rusty-backedAntwren]; E grisea sure accurate sequences.(3) Sequenceswere used [White-fringed Antwren]; Hypocnemishypoxantha only if they gave clean sequence(i.e. little back- [Yellow-browed Antbird]; and H. cantator).We in- ground and no double peaks), and sequenceswere cludedmultiple individuals of speciesin Hypocnemis inspectedfor insertions,deletions, or stop codohs becausethe genushas been hypothesizedto be the that would indicatethat the sequenceswould result closestrelative of Drymophila(Ridgely and Tudor in a nonfunctionalprotein. (4) Partition-homogene- 1994:293).At the genericlevel, the goal of this sam- ity testswere performed to assessif thephylogenetic pling schemewas to confirma suitableoutgroup for contentof thesetwo partial genesequences was sim- geneticand ecologicalresearch on Drymophila,and ilar; nuclearcopies would not necessarilybe expect- not to reconstructa phylogenyof thamnophilidgen- ed to havesimilar phylogenetic content to mitochon- era. As a result, higher-levelrelationships among drial genes.(5) Genetic-distancematrices were gen- thamnophilidsshould be viewed as tentative.We eratedseparately for the two genefragments and in- also included a ground antbird (Formicariuscolma spectedfor differences.(6) Sequencesof individuals [Rufous-capped Antthrush], Formicariidae), a from the samecollecting locality, population, or geo- woodcreeper(Lepidocolaptes angustirostris [Narrow- graphicregion were expected to be geneticallymore billed Woodcreeper],Dendrocolaptidae), an ovenbird similarthan thoseof otherpopulations