External Resettlement Monitoring and Evaluation Report

# Semiannual Report September 2012

People’s Republic of : Flood Management Sector Project

Prepared by Hunan Water & Electricity Consulting Corporation for the Hunan Provincial Government and the Asian Development Bank.

CURRENCY EQUIVALENTS (as of 18 September 2012) Currency unit – Yuan (CNY) CNY1.00 = $0.1581 $1.00 = CNY6.3245

NOTE (i) In this report, "$" refers to US dollars.

This external resettlement monitoring and evaluation report is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature.

In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area.

The Urban Flood Control Project in the Mountainous Area

in Hunan Province Loaned by the Asian Development Bank

The External Resettlement Monitoring & Assessment Report

（ City, City, , City, County, , , Xintian County, Jianghua County, County, , City, City, City, Zhuzhou County and Youxian County）

No.1, 2012 Total No. 5

Hunan Water & Electricity Consulting Corporation

(HWECC)

Jan, 2012

Approved by: Xiang Hong

Reviewed by: Wang

Checked by: Long Xiachu

Prepared by: Wei Riwen, Zhou Yuanshun

2 Contents

1. Monitoring and Assessment Task and Implementation Progress ...... 5 2. Project Description and Implementation Progress ...... 7 2.1 Project Description...... 7 2.2 Project Implementation Progress ...... 11 3. Establishment and Operation of Resettlement Institutions ...... 15 3.1 Establishment of Resettlement Institutions ...... 15 3.2. Operation of the Resettlement Organizations ...... 16 4. Description of Various Subprojects ...... 17 4.1 Jiangyong County ...... 17 4.1.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 17 4.1.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 18 4.1.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 18 4.2 Chenzhou City...... 19 4.2.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 19 4.2.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 19 4.2.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 20 4.3 Shaoyang City ...... 20 4.3.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 20 4.3.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 20 4.3.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 21 4.4 Qiyang County ...... 21 4.4.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 21 4.4.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 23 4.4.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 23 4.5 Longhui County ...... 23 4.5.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 23 4.5.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 24 4.5.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 24 4.6 Jianghua County ...... 24 4.6.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 24 4.6.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 25 4.6.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 26 4.7 Zhouzhu City...... 26 4.7.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 26 4.7.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 27 4.7.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 27 4.8 Lengshuijiang City ...... 27 4.8.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 27 4.8.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 30 4.8.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 30 4.9 Lianyaun City ...... 30 4.9.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 30

3 4.9.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 31 4.9.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 32 4.10 Shuangfeng County ...... 32 4.10.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 32 4.10.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 34 4.10.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 34 4.11 Shaodong County ...... 34 4.11.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 34 4.11.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 36 4.11.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 37 4.12 Xintian County ...... 37 4.12.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 37 4.12.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 38 4.12.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 38 4.13 Liling City ...... 38 4.13.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 38 4.13.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 39 4.13.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 39 4.14 Youxian County ...... 40 4.14.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation ...... 40 4.14.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions ...... 42 4.14.3 Assessment Conclusion ...... 42 4.15 Attached Tables ...... 43 Attached Table 1 Land acquisition of 16 subprojects...... 43 Attached Table 2 House removal of 16 subprojects ...... 45 Attached Table 3 Investment accomplishment of 16 subprojects ...... 47

4 1. Monitoring and Assessment Task and Implementation

Progress

After signing the external resettlement monitoring and assessment contracts for 16 non-core sub-projects including Lengshuijiang City,

Lianyuan City, Shuangfeng County, Shaoyang City, Shaodong County,

Longhui County, Jiangyong County, Xintian County, Jianghua County,

Qiyang County, Ningyuan County, Chenzhou City, Zhuzhou City,

Liling City, Zhuzhou County and Youxian County, the Hunan Water

& Electricity Consulting Corporation (HWECC) has prepared and delivered No. 1~4 external resettlement monitoring and assessment

(M&A) reports to the Asian Development Bank (ADB) in Sept. of 2008, in Apr. and in Dec. of 2009, and in Jul. of 2010 respectively. This time, external resettlement monitoring and assessment (M&A) have been carried out by HWECC for above 16 sub-projects and the main tasks are as followings: (1). Progress of the main project. (2). Progress of land acquisition and resettlement. (3). Establishment and operation of resettlement institutions. (4). Raising and payment of the resettlement funds.

HWECC’s staffs have made site investigation, collected data, held talks and visited families for above 16 projects since late December, 2011, and prepared the External Resettlement Monitoring & Assessment Report (No.

5 1 in 2011 and No. 5 in total) after comprehensive analysis. According to the M & A results, Zhuzhou County Urban Flood Control Project has not been included in the Report as it is the only project which has not started construction among the 16 sub-projects. As the Ningyuan County sub-project has implemented land acquisition and resettlement while the

RP (Resettlement Plan) has not got ADB’s approval, HWECC has delivered due diligence report of the resettlement to ADB in accordance with the request of ADB. Since ADB did not approve the RP of the

Ningyuan County up to now, it has not been included in the Report. It has been found that because of food control combining urban construction, the land acquisition and resettlement of subprojects including

Lengshuijiang, Youxian, etc., have been enlarged, making land acquisition and resettlement and domestic match fund more difficult. On

Jan. 12, 2011, the State Council issued the Regulation on Acquisition and

Compensation of Houses on the State-owned Land (No.590), land acquisition and resettlement became more difficult. For instance, the southern protection zone in Qiyang County Town has not started because of land acquisition and resettlement difficulties. In addition, the Jianghua

Subproject could not start because of Centianhe Dam Expansion Project.

In Oct. of 2011 the Centianhe Dam Project started construction, review design of the Jianghua Subproject in accordance with the construction of the Centianhe Dam Project has been carried out and got approval of

6 Hunan Water Resources Department, and the Jianghua subproject started construction on Oct. 8, 2011. Above contents will be stated in detail in each subproject. According to the progresses of various subprojects, the key to speed up the project implementation is to strengthen domestic fund raising and work well land acquisition and resettlement according to the laws and regulations. Both project units and departments in charge should pay attention to land acquisition and resettlement.

2. Project Description and Implementation Progress

2.1 Project Description.

The description of 16 subprojects is given in Table 2.1-1.

7 Table 2.1-1

Basic information of 16 non-core sub-projects

No Project name Project Contents Planned Investment Resettlement Schedule X103RMB X103RMB 1 Jiangyong (1). 4 dikes with total length of 6.67km Total 44940 6900.8 County (4.48 km embankment, 2.19km flood construction control wall). (2). 4 culverts and gates. period: 24 (3). Consolidation and improvement of months (20 4 flood discharge channels. months for main project) 2 Chenzhou (1).5.83 km dike (including 2.14 km Total 177850 44889.2 City natural slope cutting). (2).11.19km construction flood control wall. (3).15 culverts and period: 24 gates. (4). 15 flood discharge channels months with total length of 2960m. (5). River dredging. 3 Shaoyang City (1).Including 6 protection zones Total 206530 33041.8 (Baitian, Shentan, Xiwaiwan, construction Shaoshuidonglu, Shaoshuixi, Maoping, period: 48 Hongqihe), 7 dikes with total length of months 12.174 km. (2).9 culverts and gates. (3).1 communication gate. (4).7 drainage stations (4800KW). 4 Qiyang City (1). 13.635 km dike (9.28km for the Total 132830 32378.4 Xiangjiang River and 4.355km for the construction Qishui River). (2).10 culverts and gates period: 48 and 3 drainage stations (880KW). months (44 (3).13.635km surface hardening of months for flood control dike. main project) 5 Longhui County (1).8.219km dike. (2).5 culverts and Total 76430 15423.1 gates, 2 communication gates. (3).3 construction drainage stations with 6 pumps and period: 48 capacity of 784KW. (4).1.8km river months dredging and removal of 3 sand dunes in the riverbed (452,000m3). (5). Flood control commanding system and necessary management facilities. 6 Jianghua (1).3.6 km dike (2.85 km embankment, Total 52130 10748.7 County 0.75km masonry wall). (2). 3.6 km construction grass slope protection and 2.85 km period: 34 masonry slope protection. (3).3 electric months (28

8 drainage stations (660KW). (4).3 months for culverts and gates. (5).3.6 km surface main project) hardening of flood control dike. (6). clearing up obstacles in the river. 7 Zhuzhou (1).33.057 km dike consolidation Total 377900 116692.1 City (13.638km in Qingxiangtian Zone, construction 11.645km in Heming Zone and 7.774 period: 48 km in Qujian Zone). (2).6.723 km months (47 anti-leakage treatment within the dike months for (3km in Qingxiangtian Zone, 1 km in main project) Heming Zone and 2.723 km in Qujian Zone). (3). Renovation of 7 culverts and gates (4 in Qingxiangtian Zone, 1 in Heming Zone and 2 in Qujian Zone). (4).6.678km slope protection (4.878 km in Qingxiangtian Zone, 1.8 km in Heming Zone). (5).5.47 km dike grouting (3.5 km in Qingxiangtian Zone, 0.97 km in Heming Zone and 1 km in Qujian Zone). (6). There are 30 drainage stations with 53 pumps (6218KW), of which 10 drainage stations with 28 pumps (5150KW) are available, and 39 new pumps (12863KW) will be installed. 8 Xintian County (1). Expansion and heightening of 6.514 Total 52420 11869 km existing stone masonry flood control construction wall. (2). 9.789 km earth dike. (3). period: 36 2.033 km flood control wall. (4). Bank months protection 0.61 km. (5). 2 culverts. (6). 2 pumping station with 4 units and 644 KW. 9 Lianyuan City (1).The planned protection area of Total 98758.2 16544.4 Lianyuan Urban Flood Control Project construction is divided into Lantian, Guangmingjie, period: 48 Shimashan and Chengbei zones, 4 dikes months with total length of 15.895km (2.233km earth dike and 13.662km flood control wall) will be built. (2). 10 culverts and gates. (3). Flood control commanding system and necessary management facilities. 10 Shaodong The planned protection area of Total 12790 45625.6 County Shaodong Urban Flood Control Project construction

9 is divided into Liangshitang, Xinglong period: 34 and Meiling zones, 7 dikes with total months (23 length of 11.686 km (11.148 km earth months for dike and 0.538 km earth-rock dike), main project) 3.704 km slope protection, 3.069 bank protection. (2). 7 culverts and gates, 2 traffic sluices. (3). Removal of Caojiaba Dam, 10 deserted pumping stations, 1 deserted bridge pier and 4 deserted spoils. (4). Construction of 1.53 km Majiawan flood discharge channel, harness of 3.22 km Tangjiaba drainage ditch, construction of 2.34 km Jinlong flood diversion channel. (5). 4 drainage pumping stations with total capacity of 1290 KW. (6). Flood control commanding system and necessary management facilities. 11 Ningyuan (1). Construction of flood control dike Total 56530 9858.1 County 8.06 km. (2). 4 culverts and gates. (3). construction Improvement of 4 flood discharge period: 34 channels. months 12 Lengshuijiang (1). 8.27 km flood control dike. (2). 11 Total 97750 23346.6 City culverts and gates. (3). 2 drainage construction pumping stations. (4). Flood control period: 36 commanding system and necessary months (33 management facilities. months for main project) 13 Shuangfeng (1).Construction of 9.8 km urban flood Total 105460 15197.8 County control dike, including 4.97 km eastern construction dike and 4.83 western dike. (2). 12 period: 48 culverts and gates. (3). 2 drainage months stations. (4). 1 discharge channel with length of 1.605 km., 2 underground culverts with length of 1.13 km. 14 Liling City 3.3906km new masonry flood control Total 104780 38524.3 dike, consolidation of 3.6818km old construction dike, 5.1953km new flood control dike, period: 58 5 culverts and gates, removal of barriers months (56 in the river channel, flood control road, months for 4 drainage stations (535 KW), 2 main project) discharge channels (5.7588 km), etc. 15 Youxian County (1). 1.20 km flood control retaining Total 90540 13689 wall. (2). 3.28 km bank protection. (3). construction

10 1 flood discharge channel (1.3 km), period: 35 6.817 km earth dike. (4). 5 culverts and months (24 gates. (5). 4 pumping stations (12 units months for 1035 KW). (6). 2 flood discharge main project) channels (4.5km). (7). Change of Tanzhou River channel (0.9km). (8).3 traffic bridges and 2 culverts. 16 Zhuzhou (1). 3.43 km earth dike. (2). Total 71960 18211.5 County Consolidation of 5.963 km flood control construction dike. (3). Slope protection with precast period: 21 concrete blocks. (4). Concrete works. months (18 months for main project) Total 1854972.9 452260.1

Notes:The data of Jianghua subproject is in accordance with the reviewed data issued by Hunan Water Resources Department (Xiangshuizhong [2011] No.1).

2.2 Project Implementation Progress

The implementation progress of 15 subprojects is shown in Table 2.2-1.

11 Table 2.2-1 Progress of the 16 Sub-projects

No County/ Project Name Contracted Awarded Consulting Started Finished Finished Ended City Price company company date investment ratio date 104 RMB 104 RMB Civil works of the Hunan Kehong Water & Chengbei Protection 918.93 Construction Electricity Consulting Oct, 2007 1021.03 111% Jun.30,2010 Zone Company, Ltd Corporation Jiangyong 1 Civil works of the County Hunan Kehong Yongzhou Water & Chengnan and 938.38 Construction Electricity Consulting Oct, 2007 1042.65 111% Jun.30,2010 Chengdong protection Company, Ltd Corporation zone Civil works of the Hunan Kehong Xiameiqiao, Tongxin 3248.89 Construction HWECC Dec.,2007 3284.89 100% Dec.31,2011 Chenzhou River Company, Ltd 2 City Environmental harness Hunan Laodaohe Hunan Water & of Tongxin River, 5917 Construction Electricity Consulting Jul., 2009 4733.6 80% Dec.31,2011 Chenzhou City Company, Ltd Contracting Company Hunan Xingyu Shaoyang Civil works of the Zi Hydro & Power 3 5219.9195 HWECC Mar.,2009 910.3 17.4% Jun.30,2010 City River dike, Shaoyang Construction Company Hunan Hydro & Chengbei Protection Hunan Yuhui 4685.637 Power Aug.,2008 3045.66 65% Dec.31,2011 Zone, Qiyang Consulting Company Corporation Civil works of Hunan Hydro & Hunan Yuhui Qiyang Chengdong (eastern) 1780 Power Aug., 2011 356 20% Dec.31,2011 4 Consulting Company County protection zone Corporation Hunan Hydro & Not started Civil works of Power Hunan Yuhui because of Chengnan (southern) 1481.5 Mechanization Consulting Company difficult protection zone Company removal

12 Hunan Hydro & Chengbei Protection Shaoyang Kaituo 1800 Power Sept.,2008 Zone, Longhui Consulting Company Longhui Corporation 5 3610.6 110% Dec.31,2011 County Civil works for Hunan Huayu Hunan Yuhui Chengbei Protection 1500 Hydro & Power Dec.,2008 Consulting Company Zone, Longhui Company Civil works of Hunan Hunan Hydro & Jianghua Jianghua County Xiangzhong 6 2208.57 Power Consulting Oct.,2011 685 15.2% Dec.31,2011 County Town Flood Control Hydro & Power Contracting Company Project Ltd Company Civil works of urban Hunan Hunan Hydro & Zhuzhou flood control project, Construction 7 7196 Power Consulting Sept.,2008 4200 58.36% Jun.30,2010 City Zhuzhou (Heming Engineering Contracting Company Protection Zone) Group Xintian Xintian Urban Flood Hydro & 8 210 HWECC Jun.,2009 1648.4 40.65% Dec.31,2011 County Control Project Power Company Bid No.1 of civil Hunan Hydro & Hydro & Power Lianyuan works of Lianyuan 9 5681.28 Power Consulting Company, Apr.,2009 3465.4 61% Dec.31,2011 City City Urban Flood Corporation Ltd Control Project Hunan Hydro & Hunan Water Shaodong County Shaodong Power & Electricity 10 Urban Flood Control 4178.59 Jun., 2011 1143.6 27.37% Dec.31,2011 County Mechanization Consulting Company, Project Company Ltd Hunan Hydro & Jiangbei (northern) Loudi Hydro & Power Power Not Protection Zone, 4844.63 Consulting Company, Mechanization started Lengshuijia Lengshuijiang City Ltd 11 Company ng City Hunan Xinkang Loudi Hydro & Power Buxi Protection Zone, 1089 Construction Consulting Company, Apr.,2009 435.6 40% Dec.31,2011 Lengshuijiang City Company Ltd Shuangfeng Hedong (eastern) Hunan Kehong Loudi Hydro & Power 12 2217 Oct.,2009 443.4 20% Dec.31,2011 County Protection Zone Construction Consulting Company,

13 Company, Ltd Ltd Hunan No.5 Hexi (western) 2430 Construction Dec.31,2011 Jul.,2011 1944 80% Dec.31,2011 Protection Zone Company Hunan Hydro & Civil works of Liling Power 13 Liling City Urban Flood Control 6218 HWECC Nov.,2011 1758 26.5% Dec.31,2011 Mechanization Project Company Northern part of Hunan Hydro & Youxian County Power 2830 HWECC Nov.,2007 2400 Urban Flood Control Mechanization Youxian Project Company 14 84.8% Dec.31,2011 County Southern part of 1575 Hunan Hydro & HWECC Aug.,2010 1336 Youxian County Power Urban Flood Control Mechanization Project Company

14 3. Establishment and Operation of Resettlement Institutions

3.1 Establishment of Resettlement Institutions

Both local governments and owners have attached great importance to land acquisition and resettlement of the Project, have established sound project management institutions and affiliate resettlement institutions, and allocated experienced staffs from departments including government, land resources, water resources, finance, real estates, agriculture, etc., and from the grassroots to be in charge of the resettlement work in order to carry out the work smoothly. All leaders of the resettlement institutions have been trained by Provincial PMO. The arrangement of various resettlement institutions is given in Table 3.1.

Table 3.1

Resettlement Institutions of Various Subprojects

Project name Name of Staff Affiliate to Notes resettlement institution numb . Lengshuijiang Lengshuijiang City 13 Rural Office of City Resettlement Lengshuijiang City Development Bureau Government Liangyuan Land Acquisition and 4 Construction Headquarters City Resettlement Group of Liangyuan City Urban Flood Control Project Shuangfeng Land Acquisition and 4 Urban Dike Management County Resettlement Department Office of Shuangfeng County Shaoyang City Land Acquisition and 6 Headquarters of Urban Flood Resettlement Department Control of Shaoyang City Shaodong Land Acquisition and 6 Headquarters of Urban Flood County Resettlement Department Control of Shaodong County Longhui Mass Work Section 6 Headquarters of Yanjiang County Road & Dike Construction of Longhui County Jiangyong Land Acquisition and 5 Headquarters of Urban Flood County Resettlement Group Control Dike Construction of Jiangyong County Xiantian Project Resettlement 8 Xintian County Project

15 County Office of Xintian County Office Jianghua Contradiction 5 Headquarters of Urban Flood County Coordination Group Control Project Construction of Jianghua County Qiyang City Land Acquisition and 4 Urban Flood Control Project Resettlement Group Construction Management Office of Qiyang City Chenzhou City Land Acquisition and 5 Tongxin River Harness Resettlement Department Urban House Removal & Arrangement Leading Group Zhuzhou City There is no professional The Project institution at the moment Department is responsible Liling City Land Acquisition and 4 Headquarters of Urban Flood Resettlement Department Control Project Construction Youxian Resettlement Office 6 Urban Construction County Investment Company Ningyuan due diligence County report has been delivered Zhuzhou Not County implemented

1-2 leaders in every affected township (town) and village have been assigned to be responsible for their resettlement work.

3.2. Operation of the Resettlement Organizations

After establishment, the resettlement institutions of all subprojects have carried out resettlement work in accordance with the leadership of both Provincial PMO and local headquarters and according to the requirements and procedures of ADB and their main work contents are as followings:

(1). Advertise the importance of the flood control project and resettlement policy and issue Resettlement Information Manuals to the resettled people and local residents in the resettlement arrangement areas.

(2). Check and determine physical indexes in accordance with Resettlement Plan and real situation of the project.

16 (3). Implement land acquisition and resettlement, sign compensation agreements, pay compensation capital and make settlement.

(4). Organize support to vulnerable group.

(5). Handle complaints and claims of the resettled people.

(6). Report land acquisition and resettlement progress to related higher departments.

4. Description of Various Subprojects

4.1 Jiangyong County

4.1.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

According to the Resettlement Plan of the Urban Flood Control Project of the Jiangyong County approved by the Chinese Government and agreed by the Asian Bank, the targets of the resettlement schedule are as followings: the resettlement preparation started in Mar. of 2006 and ended in Jun. of 2007 with total period of 16 months. The resettlement implementation began in Sept. of 2007, the resettlement acceptance was made in Mar. of 2009 and the post evaluation of the resettlement was made in Apr. of 2009. Up to now, land acquisition has completed 45.51 mu (accounting for 86.7%), house removal has finished 2937.89 m2 (including 437.89 m2 auxiliary houses and accounting for 129%). The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

17 4.1.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

(1). The resettlement progress is behind the planned schedule. According to the resettlement plan, the resettlement implementation should finish in the Mar. of 2009. Therefore, the original schedule has lost control function. It is suggested that relevant units should make comprehensive consideration and adjust the plan properly.

(2). The main part of the Project has been completed. Since the issue of No. 3 External Resettlement Monitoring and Assessment Report, the main project and resettlement have no progress. According to local information, the reason is mainly constraint of the capital. It is suggested to pay attention to funding and to speed up project construction.

(3). The progress of resettlement house construction is slow, no house has been begun in addition to house land. It is suggested that local PMO and governments attach importance to resettlement arrangement, to accelerate house construction so that the resettled people can move to new house earlier.

4.1.3 Assessment Conclusion

It is considered by the monitoring and assessment that the Project is basically in accordance with the RP requirements except lagged implementation progress, especially house construction, and higher land acquisition compensation comparing the RP and the planned standards.

18 4.2 Chenzhou City

4.2.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

According to the Resettlement Plan of the Urban Flood Control Project of the Chenzhou City approved by the Chinese Government and agreed by the Asian Bank, the targets of the resettlement schedule are as followings: the resettlement preparation started in Mar. of 2006 and ended in Jun. of 2007 with total period of 15 months. The resettlement implementation began in Sept. of 2007, the resettlement acceptance was made in Mar. of 2009. Up to now, land acquisition has completed 237.64 mu (accounting for 48.18%), house removal has finished 3508.6 m2 (accounting for 6.3% of the planned, including 1986 m2 urban houses and 1522.6 m2 rural houses). The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

4.2.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

(1). The resettlement progress is behind the planned schedule. According to the resettlement plan, the resettlement implementation should finish in the Mar. of 2009. Therefore, the original schedule has lost control function. It is suggested that relevant units should accelerate resettlement implementation, make comprehensive consideration and adjust the plan properly.

(2). Accelerate construction of the resettlement place and reduce the transition period of the resettled people.

(3). Occupation of farmland should be controlled strictly.

19 4.2.3 Assessment Conclusion

It is considered by the monitoring and assessment that the Project is basically in accordance with the RP requirements except lagged implementation progress and higher land acquisition compensation comparing with the RP and the planned standards.

4.3 Shaoyang City

4.3.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

According to the Resettlement Plan of the Urban Flood Control Project of the Shaoyang City approved by the Chinese Government and agreed by the Asian Bank, the targets of the resettlement schedule are as followings: the resettlement preparation started in Mar. of 2006 and ended in Jun. of 2007 with total period of 15 months. The resettlement implementation began in Sept. of 2007 and finished in Mar. of 2009 with total period of 21 months. Up to now, land acquisition has completed 27 mu (accounting for 3.5%), no house has been removed. The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

4.3.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

(1). Since beginning of the construction in Mar. of 2009, the Project’s progress is quite slow and only 0.36 km (accounting for 3%) of the total 12.07 km dike has been finished. The main reasons include inadequate domestic counterpart fund and difficult removal as it is hard to sign resettlement agreements. Up to now no removal has been made. Fund and resettlement have become constraints of the Project. It is suggested that

20 both local PMO and governments raise funds by various channels and speed up resettlement under the conditions of guaranteeing the legal rights of the resettled people.

(2). The PMO should strengthen coordination and management of the Project.

4.3.3 Assessment Conclusion

The implementation is quite slow and both local governments and related departments in charge of the Project should speed up the progress by solving counterpart funds and land acquisition problems.

4.4 Qiyang County

4.4.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

According to the Resettlement Plan of the Urban Flood Control Project of the Qiyang County approved by the Chinese Government and agreed by the Asian Bank, the targets of the resettlement schedule are as followings: the resettlement preparation started in Mar. of 2006 and ended in Jun. of 2007 with total period of 15 months. The resettlement implementation began from Jul. of 2007 and ended in Jan. of 2009 with total period of 19 months. Up to now, land acquisition has completed 372 mu (accounting for 40.32%), and house removal has finished 9247.98 m2 (accounting for 52.55%). The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

21

Arrangement district, Yanhe Road, Qiyang County

Living room of Zhou Feipeng’s home (4 members) in the arrangement district, Yanhe Road, Qiyang County

22 4.4.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

Flood control dike of 13.635 km is planned to build and only 4.5 km of it has been finished (Chengbei (northern) and Chengdong (eastern) zones, accounting for 33%). The Cengnan (southern) Protection Zone has not started because of land acquisition and resettlement difficulties. It is suggested to speed up construction progress of the main project.

4.4.3 Assessment Conclusion

People are satisfied with the finished resettlement arrangement area as it is in proper location and with completed infrastructure. The dike construction should be accelerated as only 33% of it has been constructed.

4.5 Longhui County

4.5.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

According to the Resettlement Plan of the Urban Flood Control Project of the Longhui County approved by the Chinese Government and agreed by the Asian Bank, the targets of the resettlement schedule are as followings: the resettlement preparation started in Mar. of 2006 and ended in Jun. of 2007 with total period of 15 months. The resettlement implementation began in Sept. of 2007 and finished in Mar. of 2009 with total period of 19 months. Up to now, land acquisition has completed 137.7 mu (accounting for 81.4%), 15480.76 m2 houses have been removed (all being auxiliary houses with monetary compensation, accounting for 98% of the planned). The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

23 4.5.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

Most of the land acquisition and resettlement of the Project have been completed with land acquisition, house removal and resettled people finishing 81.4%, 98% and 97% respectively. It is suggested to do the rounding-off work of the resettlement well and the finishing of various resettlement files (physical indexes, land acquisition agreements, payment of compensation funds, pictures, photos and videos) for acceptance and post-evaluation of the resettlement.

4.5.3 Assessment Conclusion

The resettlement work in Longhui County has been done quite well. The arrangement area is suitable, the infrastructure conditions including water, electricity, road, etc., are completed and the houses of the resettled people are big with good quality. Through site visits, the resettled people are satisfied and the whole resettlement work is in accordance with the RP requirements.

4.6 Jianghua County

4.6.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

Being affected by the Centianhe Dam Expansion Project which is 12km in the upstream, the Hunan Nanfang Hydro & Power Design Institute has re-checked the design of the subproject considering the Centianhe Dam factor. Hunan Water Resources Department approved the design (Xiangshuizhong [2011] No.1) on Apr. 8, 2011. Comparing with the original design, the dike top elevation lowered 0.213~2.065m, the Liyujing Middle School was included in the protection zone. The revised

24 design combining with urban development, not only satisfies the flood control requirements, but also meets fewer difficulties in land acquisition, construction conditions, project financing, operation and maintenance. The Subproject was started construction in Oct. of 2011. During implementation, as Jianghua County belongs to minority area and it is difficult to carry out land acquisition and resettlement, the dike sector which needs land acquisition and resettlement in accordance with Xiangshuizhong [2011] No.1 was changed to stone masonry wall, turf revetment in accordance with top width 3.5m, slope ratio 1:2.0 was cancelled. The land acquisition and resettlement will be carried out when implementing the integration of urban and rural areas in future. At the moment land acquisition and resettlement become easy. 2 households 8 persons, 267 m2 were involved and 1 household 3 persons has been finished. The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

The original RP of Jianghua Urban Flood Control Project has become useless.

4.6.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

After completion of the Centianhe Dam Expansion Project located 12km upstream of the Jianghua County Town, combining with planned urban dike project, the flood control standard of the Jianghua County Town will raised to 1-in-50-years. In Aug. of 2009, the Jianghua County Government delivered the Request to Lower the Dike Top Elevation of the Jianghua County Urban Flood Control Project to Hunan Water Resources Department (Jiangzhengfu [2009] No.17), the Hunan Nanfang Hydro & Power Design Institute has re-checked the design of the subproject. Comparing with the original design, the dike top elevations

25 have lowered 0.213~2.065m. During implementation, as Jianghua County belongs to minority area and it is difficult to carry out land acquisition and resettlement, the dike sector which needs land acquisition and resettlement was changed to stone masonry wall, the land acquisition and resettlement will be carried out when implementing the integration of urban and rural areas in future. As above changes belong to the change of the scheme, it has been suggested to report them to related higher department for review and approve. How to combine land acquisition and resettlement with the integration of the urban and rural areas, it should have concrete plan and should approved by related departments.

4.6.3 Assessment Conclusion

Affected by the Centianhe Dam Expansion Project which is located in the upstream (started construction on Oct. 28, 2011), the Jianghua County Urban Flood Control Project has been officially begun in Oct. of 2011, measures should be taken to accelerate the progress. During implementation, because of land acquisition difficulties, the approved design by Xiangshuizhong [2011] No1 has been changed and it should report to department in charge for approval.

4.7 Zhouzhu City

4.7.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

According to the Resettlement Plan of the Urban Flood Control Project of the Zhuzhou City, the targets of the resettlement schedule are as followings: the resettlement preparation ended in Jul. of 2007. The resettlement agreements and implementation began in Aug. of 2007, the resettlement production and living arrangements were finished by the end

26 of Feb., 2009, the resettlement acceptance was made in May of 2009 and post-evaluation began in Jun. of 2009. Up to now, 48.15 mu land has been acquired (3.87 mu collective land and 44.28 mu State-owned land) (accounting for 4.2%). In implementation, land acquisition is reduced to min. extent and the dike without removal has been construction firstly, there is no house removal at the moment. The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

4.7.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

As there is no specialized resettlement organization for the Zhuzhou flood control sub-project presently, it is suggested to establish the resettlement organization and arrange personnel to carry out the corresponding work.

4.7.3 Assessment Conclusion

The major content of the Zhuzhou Sub-project is to thicken and heighten the dikes. The Heming Protection Zone implemented in the 1st stage includes dike consolidation of 11.64 km, up to now 7 km have been finished (accounting for 60.14%). Sector without house removal has been implemented firstly. Up to now no house has been removed and 48.15 mu land has been acquired (accounting for 11.59%).

4.8 Lengshuijiang City

4.8.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

The Lengshuijiang Subproject includes 8.27km flood control dike, 11 culverts and gates, 2 drainage stations. The Buxi Protection Zone, started in Apr. of 2009, has finished 1.5km dike (accounting for 18.1%) and 6

27 culverts and gates. It is planned to resettle 160 households 1738 persons, 25 households 81 persons have been moved and 2114.53 square m houses have been removed (accounting for 7.2%). It is planned to acquire 687.57 mu, including permanent occupation of 325.76 mu, 120 mu land have been finished (accounting for 17.4%). Resettlement capital has finished 7 million RMB, accounting for 30% of the plan (23.34 million RMB). The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

Finished flood control dike in Lengshuijiang City

28

Finished resettlement arrangement district in Lengshuijiang City

New home of resettled Xiao Zhonggui

29 4.8.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

Since beginning construction in Apr. of 2009, the Lengshuijiang Subproject has finished only 1.5 km dike at the moment. The main reason for slow progress is the combination of flood control project with urban road development and BT construction mode is applied, leading to more difficult to resettlement and self-raising fund. In particular, in Jan. of 2011, the State Council issued the Regulation on Acquisition and Compensation of Houses on the State-owned Land (No.590), land acquisition and resettlement became more difficult and the construction speed was affected. It is suggested that related departments should strengthen coordination and cooperation to raise fund and speed up construction.

4.8.3 Assessment Conclusion

Raise match fund actively to solve capital bottleneck, and control the scale of land acquisition and resettlement strictly to reduce the difficulty.

4.9 Lianyaun City

4.9.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

The Lianyuan City Urban Flood Control Project includes 15.895 km flood control dike, 11.869 km dike have been finished since Apr. 15, 2009 (accounting for 74.7%). In addition, 2.5 km river channel needs dredging to lower the flood level. Project investment of 34.65 million RMB has been completed. Permanent land acquisition has finished 220 mu (145 mu collective land and 75 mu other land), 8700 square meter rural houses have been removed, 51 households 138 persons have been arranged with finished resettlement investment of 11.51 million RMB (accounting for

30 69.6% of the total resettlement investment of 16.5444 million RMB). The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

Finished flood control dike in Lianyuan City

4.9.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

Since beginning construction in Apr. of 2009, the progress of the Lianyuan Subproject is quite fast and acceptance has been carried out to finished dike project. In respect to Minzhu Street in , because of dense houses along both river banks, the scheme of dredging river channel to lower flood level to replace flood control dike has been used to reduce house removal. According to the PMO, flood control dike will not be built along 2.5km dredging sector. It is suggested to report the revised scheme and implementation result to related higher department for keeping on record

31 4.9.3 Assessment Conclusion

The subproject has a rapid progress and all finished parts have past acceptance. Other match projects and round-off works should be carried out in order to finish the project at an earlier time.

4.10 Shuangfeng County

4.10.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

The Shuangfeng Urban Flood Control Project includes 9.8 km flood control dike (4.97 km eastern dike and 4.83 km western dike), 12 culverts and gates, 2 drainage stations, 1 flood discharge channel with length of 1.605 km, 2 underground culverts (1.13 km). The eastern dike was started in Dec. of 2010 and has finished 700 m earth dike. The western dike was started in Jul. of 2011. In total 3.5 km dike has been constructed, accounting for 35.7%. According to RP, 16014 m2 houses are removed. Because of optimization of the design, there is no house removal with the constructed dike area. It is planned to acquire land 455.3 mu (362.3 mu permanent land), at the moment 180 mu land has been acquired and all compensation capital have paid. The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

32

Constructed dike in Shuangfeng County（northern area）

Constructed dike in Shuangfeng County（northern area）

33

4.10.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

35.7% of the project has been finished in Shuangfeng County. According to the PMO, the land acquisition and resettlement in unfinished area are very difficult, and the construction has been stopped by local people. It is suggested that related departments should strengthen coordination in land acquisition and resettlement to accelerate the progress of the subproject. In addition, the loan of ADB is based on US dollar, the real loan amount has been reduced because of the appreciation of RMB.

4.10.3 Assessment Conclusion

The eastern dike has finished only 700 m (accounting for 17% of the plan) since beginning in 2010. According to PMO, the main reason of slow progress is difficult land acquisition. Land acquisition and resettlement should be worked well in accordance with the laws and regulations.

4.11 Shaodong County

4.11.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

The Shaodong County Urban Flood Control Project was started on Jun. 2, 2011, 5.13 km earth dike have been finished (accounting for 43.9% of 11.686km dike). The dike line has been adjusted in order to reduce land acquisition during construction, there is no land acquisition in finished dike area. 558 mu land, including 458 mu permanent land (454 mu collective owned and 4 mu state owned) and 100 mu temporary land, have finished formality approval and signed compensation agreements. The compensation is 36745 RMB/mu for paddy field (22517 RMB/mu

34 according to the plan) and 10230 RMB/mu for dry land (15495RMB/mu according to the plan). 20.5 million RMB has been finished in land acquisition. The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

Site investigation of the monitoring personnel in Shaodong County

35

Discussion of monitoring personnel with Shaodong PMO staff

4.11.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

The 5.13 km constructed dike has no land acquisition owing to adjustment of the dike line. Located in the old urban area with dense enterprises and residents, the remaining dike needs to acquire 871 mu permanent land and 444 mu temporary land, and to remove 13666 m2 houses (9151 m2 residential houses). On Jan. 12, 2011, the State Council issued the Regulation on Acquisition and Compensation of Houses on the State-owned Land (No.590), land acquisition and resettlement became more difficult. The PMO suggests to optimize the dike line to reduce land acquisition and to speed up the project.

36 4.11.3 Assessment Conclusion

According to the site investigation, the unfinished dike area has a dense houses and buildings. According to local PMO, the cost for two buildings of the Shaodong County People’s Hospital is about 5 million RMB and there is no suitable place for constructing new building. In order to reduce land acquisition and speed up implementation, the local PMO should make further investigation and report to related higher departments to solve the problem properly.

4.12 Xintian County

4.12.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

Consisted of 5 flood control zones, the Xintian County Urban Flood Control Project includes construction of 9.789 km earth dike and 2.032 km stone masonry wall, consolidation and heightening of 6.514 km stone masonry flood control wall, 0.61 km stone masonry slope protection, and construction of 2 electric drainage stations (4 units, 664 KW) and 2 culverts and gates. Started on Jun. 5, 2009, 2.5 km dike have been finished with investment of 22.814 million RMB (accounting for 43.5% of the total investment of 52.42 million RMB, including main project of 16.484 million RMB, land acquisition and resettlement of 5.23 million, other investment of 1.1 million RMB). According to the RP, 124 mu permanent land (88mu collective land and 36 mu state-owned land) and 57.45 temporary land will be acquired. 193.5 mu land have been finished, including 124 mu permanent land (88mu collective land and 36 mu state-owned land). It is planned to remove 11400 m2 houses, including 11400 m2 permanent houses (4094 m2 urban houses and 7306 m2 rural houses) and to resettle 70 households and 285 persons. 15210 m2 houses

37 have been removed, which exceeded the planned removal. The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

4.12.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

The Subproject has finished only 2.5 km dike (accounting for 25.5%) and investment of 22.814 million RMB (accounting for 43.5%) and it is suggested to take effective measures to control the total investment. In addition, as part dike is located in the old town area with many historic buildings, it is very difficult to acquire land and to resettle, the County PMO suggests to optimize the dike line to avoid removing the dense houses of the enterprises and residents in the old town area.

4.12.3 Assessment Conclusion

Since starting construction in 2009, the Subproject has finished only 2.5 km dike (accounting for 25.5%) and investment of 43.5%, the whole schedule would be affected if no effective measures and optimized design are taken to reduce the removal scale and control the capital gap.

4.13 Liling City

4.13.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

The Liling City Urban Flood Control Project includes construction of 3.39 km stone masonry flood control wall, consolidation and heightening of 3.86 km existed flood control dike, and construction of 5.195 km flood control dike. Started on Nov. 19, 2010, 1200 m flood control dike have been finished till Dec. 31,2011. According to the RP, 46776 m2 houses are removed, including residential houses of 43647 m2 and resettlement of

38 544 households and 1994 persons, 788.3 mu land is acquired permanently, including 735.3 mu collective land (including 39.6 mu farmland) and 53 mu state-owned land, and 120 mu land is acquired temporarily. Up to now 469 mu land have been acquired (all belonging to collective land, accounting for 54.9% of the plan), 4030 m2 houses have been removed (all belonging to urban houses and accounting for 8.6%). The task of land acquisition and resettlement is heavy in future, especially in house removal (finishing less than 10%). The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

4.13.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

According to our site investigation and reports from the County PMO, the tasks of land acquisition and resettlement for unfinished project will be very heavy and the costs will be high, especially after the issuing of the Regulation on Acquisition and Compensation of Houses on the State-owned Land, the work becomes more difficult with the increase of compensation standards. It is suggested that the project unit should implement land acquisition and resettlement in accordance with the laws and regulations in order to accelerate the progress of the project. According to the County PMO, the loan of ADB is based on US dollar, the real loan amount has been reduced because of the appreciation of RMB, making domestic match funding more difficult. This problem has been reported by many project owners and should get the attention of related departments.

4.13.3 Assessment Conclusion

Implement land acquisition and resettlement in accordance with the laws

39 and regulations to solve the bottleneck of the project progress.

4.14 Youxian County

4.14.1 Progress of Resettlement Implementation

Started early, the Chenbei (northern) Flood Control Dike of the Youxian County Urban Flood Control Project began on Nov. 28, 2007 and has finished basically, the Chennan (southern) Flood Control Dike began on Aug. 28, 2010 and has finished 2.7 km earth dike, land acquisition of the project and the resettlement arrangement area.

(1). Progress of land acquisition

331.2 mu land has been finished (accounting for 64.3% of the plan), including 324.8 mu permanent land (292.8 mu collective land and 32 mu state-owned land) and 6.4 mu temporary land. Because of combining with urban construction, the permanent land acquisition exceeded the plan, while the temporary land reduced.

(2).Progress of resettlement & removal

22848 m2 houses have been removed, including 8848 m2 urban houses and 14000 m2 rural houses. 85 households and 384 persons have been arranged. The Chenbei resettlement arrangement area has been finished and the Chennan arrangement area has finished land acquisition and leveling.

The accomplishments of land acquisition, resettlement and capital payment are given in attached Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3.

40

Constructed flood control dike, Youxian County

Finished resettlement arrangement area, Youxian County

41 4.14.2 Existed Problems and Suggestions

Started early, the Chenbei (northern) Flood Control Dike of the subproject has been finished substantially, while the Chennan (southern) Flood Control Dike and some matching projects have not been finished yet and should be speeded up. In addition, both the amount of houses removal and land acquisition exceeded the RP owing to combining with urban construction, it may affect project progress if handled improperly.

4.14.3 Assessment Conclusion

On Jan. 12, 2011, the State Council issued the Regulation on Acquisition and Compensation of Houses on the State-owned Land (No.590), land acquisition and resettlement became more difficult. Both land acquisition and resettlement scales should be controlled strictly.

42 4.15 Attached Tables

Attached Table 1 Land acquisition of 16 subprojects

unit：mu

Permanent Land Sub Collective land Temporary No Finish Total State- Notes project Sum Farm occupat. Sum owned land Jiang- Planned 475.27 52.49 22.49 19.34 30 422.78 1 -yong Finished 45.51 45.51 15.51 15.51 30 County Ratio％ 10 87 69 80 100

Land type Planned 920.21 493.16 83.26 10.3 409.9 427.05 Chen- has changed, 2 -zhou compensated Finished 238.07 237.64 179.84 179.84 57.80 0.136 City accord. to Ratio％ 25.8 48.2 216 1746 14 0.1 farmland

Shao- Planned 1411.11 773.91 642.2 515.4 131.71 637.2 3 -yang Finished 28.5 27 27 27 0 1.5 City Ratio％ 2 3 4 5 Planned 913.61 601.2 528 336 73.2 312.41 Qiyang 4 Finished 372 360 189 35 136 12 County Ratio％ 40.7 59.9 35.8 10.4 185.6 4

Long- Planned 213.4 169.1 114.8 113.6 54.3 44.3 5 -hui Finished 137.7 137.7 82.2 82.2 55.6 County Ratio％ 65 81 72 72 102 0

Jiang- Planned 305.66 127.46 79.86 51.36 47.6 178.2 Design 6 -hua Finished scheme County Ratio％ changed

Shao- Planned 1315.22 871.22 16.2 842 13 444 7 -dong Finished 558 458 Other 8 446 4 100 County Ratio％ 42.4 52.6 49.4 53 30.7 22.5

Xin- Planned 181.45 124 98 98 26 57.45

-tian Finished 78 51 35 35 16 61.5 8 County Ratio％ 43 41.1 32.7 32.7

Lian- Planned 375.8 320.8 0 215 55 9 -yuan Finished 220 220 City Ratio％ 59 69 Shuang- Planned 455.3 362.3 362.3 132.3 0 93 10 -feng Finished 218 180 180 45 38

43 County Ratio％ 47.88 49.69 49.69 34.04

Leng- Planned 687.57 325.76 214.48 137.63 111.28 361.81 -shui- 11 Finished 120 120 37.26 39.73 43.01 0 -jiang

City Ratio％ 17.5 37 17 28.5 38.7 0

Zhu- Planned 1138.81 415.38 300.78 193.9 114.6 723.43 12 -zhou Finished 48.15 48.15 3.87 44.28 City Ratio％ 4.2 12 1 39 Planned 908.3 788.3 735.3 39.6 53 120 Liling 13 Finished 499 469 469 0 30 City Ratio％ 54.9 59.5 63.78 16.7

Planned 514.45 245.86 179.16 71.62 66.7 268.59 Removal area Youxian Finished 331.2 324.8 292.8 32 6.4 increased 14 County because of

Ratio％ 64.3 132 163.4 47.9 2 urban construction

Planned 453.55 241.9 160.41 71.62 84.19 211.65 RP not Ning- approv. 15 -yuan Finished due diligence County report Ratio％ delivered Planned 476 373 362.4 91 10.6 103 Zhu- Not 16 -zhou Finished implemented County Ratio％

44 Attached Table 2 House removal of 16 subprojects

unit：m2，household, person

Build. removal house N Sub index Residential house None Notes o project House- total Resident. person sum urban rural hold house Planned 7278 2276 0 2276 5002 26 80 Urban removal Finished 2937.89 2937.89 2500 437.89 Jiang- (Meat & 1 -yong Fish Company) County Ratio％ 40 129 19 increased compared with RP Chen- Planned 55990 42708 37514 5194 13282 415 1235 2 -zhou Finished 3508.6 3508.6 1986 1522.6 369 City Ratio％ 6 8.2 5.2 29.6 29.8 No house Shao- Planned 22810.4 16746 3869.5 12876.5 6064.4 116 409 removed 3 -yang Finished City Ratio％ Planned 17598 17598 2375 15223 237 1380 Qiyang 4 Finished 9248 8733 33589 5143 514.85 123 716 County Ratio％ 52.6 49.6 151 33.8 51.9 51.9

Long- Planned 15785.76 10306.46 10306.46 0 5479.3 105 318 Increased 5 -hui Finished 15480.76 15480.76 15480.76 101 308 removal by urban County Ratio％ 98 150 150 96 97 construction Jiang- Planned 15193 13441 9747 3694 1751.6 100 475 Design 6 -hua Finished 142 142 142 1 3 scheme County Ratio％ 0.9 0.9 50 37.5 changed

Shao- Planned 13666 9151 0 9151 4515 26 164 Removal not 7 -dong Finished implemented County Ratio％

Xin- Planned 11400 11400 4094 7306 1846 70 285

-tian Finished 15210 13865 5050 8815 1345 59 232 8 County Ratio％ 133.4 121.6 123.3 120.6 72.8 84.3 81.4 Planned 11202 11202 7314.52 3887.48 124 391 Optimized Lian- Finished 8700 8700 5100 3600 51 138 design to 9 -yuan reduce City Ratio％ 78 78 70 93 41 35 removal Shuang- Planned 16014.1 16014.1 15344.1 670 139 461 Optimized 10 -feng Finished design, need

45 County Ratio％ no removal Leng- Planned 29283.64 26887.72 19966.83 6920.89 2395.92 160 596 -shui- Finished 2114.53 2114．53 2114.53 25 81 11 -jiang Ratio％ 7 7 10.5 15.6 13.5 City Zhu- Planned 45198.8 45198.8 19393.8 25805 8780 246 1040 12 -zhou Finished City Ratio％ Planned 46776 43647 43647 3129 544 1944 Liling 13 Finished 4030 4030 4030 City Ratio％ 8.6 9.2 9.2 Planned 12796.6 12796.6 5506.6 7290 170 647 Increased Youxian Finished 22848 22848 8848 14000 85 384 removal by 14 County urban Ratio％ 178 178 160 192 50 59 construction Ning- Planned 7150 7150 1737 5413 95 406 15 -yuan Finished County Ratio％ Planned 10810 10553 4240 6313 1635 46 257 Zhu- Not 16 -zhou Finished implemented County Ratio％

46 Attached Table 3

Investment accomplishment of 16 subprojects

Unit：104RMB，Ratio：% Total investment Resettlement investment N Sub- Ratio Notes o -project Planned Finished Planned Finished Ratio（%） （%）

1 Lengshuijiang 9775 1133.2 11.6 2334.36 700 29.9 City 2 Lianyuan City 9875.82 4616 46.7 1654.44 1151 69.6 3 Shuangfeng 10546 3062 29 1519.78 692 45.5 County 4 Shaoyang 20653 1080 5.23 3304.18 169.7 16.65 City Land 5 Shaodong 12790 3500 27.37 4562.56 2050 44.94 acquisition County costs

6 Longhui 7643 2895.13 37.88 1542.31 494.52 32.6 County 7 Jiangyong 4494 2426.65 54 690.08 362.89 52.17 County 8 Xintian 5242 2281.4 43.52 1186.9 523 44.06 County 9 Jianghua 4499.02 685 15.2 828.33 12 2.4 County 10 Qiyang 13283 5205 39.2 2885.2 1620 56.1 County 11 Cehnzhou 17785 3705.82 20.48 4488.92 2300 51.23 City 12 Zhuzhou 37790 4200 11 11669.21 599.13 5.13 City 13 Liling City 10478 4558 43.5 3852.43 2800 72.7 Resettlem. 14 Youxian 9054 6520 72 1368.9 2784 203 increased County by urban construction Due 15 Ningyuan 5653 1412 25 985.81 492 50 diligence County report delivered 16 Zhuzhou 7196 1821.15 Not County implement. Total 186756.8 47280.2 44694.56 16750.24

47