DOCSLIB.ORG

The Willis Tower Roof Is 442.1 Meters High While One World Trade Center’S Roof Will Be Only 417 Meters High

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Willis Tower Roof Is 442.1 Meters High While One World Trade Center’S Roof Will Be Only 417 Meters High Released 11/19/13 TALLEST SKYSCRAPER DEBATE: A MINUTE WITH U. OF I. ARCHITECTURE PROFESSOR MIR ALI Editor’s note: The 109-story Willis Tower in Chicago recently lost its claim to the “nation’s tallest building” when the Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat (CTBUH) ruled that the new 104-story One World Trade Center in New York City, is taller. The decision hinged on the standards skyscraper experts use to measure buildings – a line of logic that Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel adamantly rebutted. University of Illinois professor emeritus of architecture Mir Ali – a CTBUH Fellow who served on the height committee in 2004 and has written or edited five books on skyscrapers – talked with News Bureau news editor Dusty Rhodes about how the council arrived at that ruling, and why he is not entirely comfortable with it. The Willis Tower roof is 442.1 meters high while One World Trade Center’s roof will be only 417 meters high. So this debate boils down to whether the “mast” of One World Trade Center counts as part of the building’s height. First, describe what a “mast” is. In 1971, about a year after the Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat was established, the question arose: how to define the height of tall buildings. The council adopted the definition by the late Fazlur Khan (a co-founder of CTBUH with Lynn Beedle, who died in 2003) that the height of a tall building is the distance from the ground level at the main entrance to the top of the highest structural element of the building. By this definition, the top of the mast or spire (a vertical and slender tower rising steeply to a point), which is structurally integrated with the building’s main structure, should be considered as the highest point of a tall building. According to this height criterion that continues today, One World Trade Center is the tallest building in the United States. Many skyscrapers around the world have masts. How do experts like you decide whether masts count in height measurement? Any structural mast built integrally with the main structure is considered a part of the structure of a tall building. If it happens to be an antenna (as in Willis Tower) or a nonstructural upright element, it does not count in height measurement. Because of this definition of height, many owners/developers around the world have deliberately added built-in structural spires in their recently constructed tall buildings to achieve greater height for attracting attention and achieving status. How long do you predict that One World Trade Center can hold on to the title of tallest building in North America? I believe One World Trade Center was planned to replace the now-destroyed World Trade Center for economic and, more importantly, socio-political reasons. The city of New York and the Port Authority took an active interest in it. Construction of a super- or mega-tall building is justifiable, amongst other factors, by real estate marketability – that is, a need for commercial space and the profitability from such an enormous financial investment. Because of the currently prevailing economic climate in the United States, I predict we are unlikely to see a taller building built here within the next three to four decades. Let us remember that One World Trade Center is surpassing the height of Willis Tower after about 40 years. You were previously a member of the CTBUH height committee. How would you have voted on this decision? I was a member of CTBUH’s height committee in 2004 when Taipei 101 in Taiwan was built. It was a large committee consisting of many experts from around the world. We had intense discussions, and after considering all factors and opinions, we did stick with Fazlur Khan’s definition of height. Some additional height categories based on roof, highest floor, nonstructural spire, etc. were added, but the overall height definition was upheld as before. How would I vote in the present decision with One World Trade Center if I were a member of the height committee now? I would vote yes. It is like following the constitution of a country whether it is up to your liking or not. CTBUH had a lot of discussions and deliberations on this and cemented the guiding criterion as a done deal. Khan’s definition was upheld by consensus. I believe nobody wants to change Fazlur Khan’s definition out of great respect. He is arguably and generally accepted as the greatest structural engineer in the second half of the 20th century, and he revolutionized tall building design with his innovations of structural systems for tall buildings. Also, if this definition is changed now, the heights of the Chrysler Building, Empire State Building, etc. down to Burj Khalifa have to be revised. That will be a “skyscraper” of a task. I must admit, though, that I feel some degree of discomfort with this classic height definition. First of all, the public does not see a “spire” (structural or nonstructural), an indistinct, thin needle-like element at a great height, when viewed from the ground level, as part of a “building,” and they do not understand why it counts in height measurements since it is totally out of proportion with the main building’s bulk and girth. That explains why Mayor Rahm Emanuel vehemently discredited this height decision. Khan was a structural engineer, so was Lynn Beedle and so is Les Robertson (another CTBUH co-founder). It is no wonder that Khan went by a structure-based definition and others obliged. To me, it would be logical to have the highest usable and walkable floor or the roof at the top of the main structure (that is, excluding the mast or spire), determine the height of the tall building. Even in terms of visual characterization, a spire is simply a spire, whether structural or nonstructural. In my opinion, the present height criterion is 42 years old and thus belongs to the past and should be considered for serious review as times have changed. Because I knew Fazlur Khan personally and professionally and wrote a book about him (“Art of the Skyscraper: The Genius of Fazlur Khan”), I know he had a great deal of respect for truth and logic. This height controversy first came into the limelight in 1996, when the twin Petronas Towers in Kuala Lumpur surpassed the height of Willis Tower (formerly Sears Tower) because of their spires, although their highest occupiable floors were 46 meters below that of the Sears Tower. Khan was already deceased; we have no way of knowing what he would have said. Had he been alive then, I have reason to believe he would rethink his own definition and amend it. Despite what I think, this definition is unlikely to change in the foreseeable future. Clearly, the public does not fully grasp the technicality of this matter and accepts willingly or unwillingly what the experts of CTBUH decide. -dr- Editor’s note: To contact Mir Ali, email [email protected]. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • CTBUH Technical Paper
    CTBUH Technical Paper http://technicalpapers.ctbuh.org Subject: Other Paper Title: Talking Tall: The Global Impact of 9/11 Author(s): Klerks, J. Affiliation(s): CTBUH Publication Date: 2011 Original Publication: CTBUH Journal 2011 Issue III Paper Type: 1. Book chapter/Part chapter 2. Journal paper 3. Conference proceeding 4. Unpublished conference paper 5. Magazine article 6. Unpublished © Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat/Author(s) CTBUH Journal International Journal on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat Tall buildings: design, construction and operation | 2011 Issue III Special Edition World Trade Center: Ten Years On Inside Case Study: One World Trade Center, New York News and Events 36 Challenging Attitudes on 14 “While, in an era of supertall buildings, big of new development. The new World Trade Bridging over the tracks was certainly an Center Transportation Hub alone will occupy engineering challenge. “We used state-of-the- numbers are the norm, the numbers at One 74,300 square meters (800,000 square feet) to art methods of analysis in order to design one Codes and Safety serve 250,000 pedestrians every day. Broad of the primary shear walls that extends all the World Trade are truly staggering. But the real concourses (see Figure 2) will connect Tower way up the tower and is being transferred at One to the hub’s PATH services, 12 subway its base to clear the PATH train lines that are 02 This Issue story of One World Trade Center is the lines, the new Fulton Street Transit Center, the crossing it,” explains Yoram Eilon, vice Kenneth Lewis Nicholas Holt World Financial Center and Winter Garden, a president at WSP Cantor Seinuk, the structural innovative solutions sought for the ferry terminal, underground parking, and retail engineers for the project.
    [Show full text]
  • True to the City's Teeming Nature, a New Breed of Multi-Family High Rises
    BY MEI ANNE FOO MAY 14, 2016 True to the city’s teeming nature, a new breed of multi-family high rises is fast cropping up around New York – changing the face of this famous urban jungle forever. New York will always be known as the land of many towers. From early iconic Art Deco splendours such as the Empire State Building and the Chrysler Building, to the newest symbol of resilience found in the One World Trade Center, there is no other city that can top the Big Apple’s supreme skyline. Except itself. Tall projects have been proposed and built in sizeable numbers over recent years. The unprecedented boom has been mostly marked by a rise in tall luxury residential constructions, where prior to the completion of One57 in 2014, there were less than a handful of super-tall skyscrapers in New York. Now, there are four being developed along the same street as One57 alone. Billionaire.com picks the city’s most outstanding multi-family high rises on the concrete horizon. 111 Murray Street This luxury residential tower developed by Fisher Brothers and Witkoff will soon soar some 800ft above Manhattan’s Tribeca neighborhood. Renderings of the condominium showcase a curved rectangular silhouette that looks almost round, slightly unfolding at the highest floors like a flared glass. The modern design is from Kohn Pedersen Fox. An A-team of visionaries has also been roped in for the project, including David Mann for it residence interiors; David Rockwell for amenities and public spaces and Edmund Hollander for landscape architecture.
    [Show full text]
  • Bringing an Icon Into the Future: Willis Tower
    CTBUH Research Paper ctbuh.org/papers Title: Bringing an Icon into the Future: Willis Tower Author: Stephen Katz, Senior Associate, Gensler Subjects: Architectural/Design Building Case Study Interior Design Keywords: Renovation Supertall Publication Date: 2019 Original Publication: 2019 Chicago 10th World Congress Proceedings - 50 Forward | 50 Back Paper Type: 1. Book chapter/Part chapter 2. Journal paper 3. Conference proceeding 4. Unpublished conference paper 5. Magazine article 6. Unpublished © Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat / Stephen Katz Bringing an Icon into the Future: Willis Tower Abstract Stephen Katz Senior Associate Few buildings are as iconic as Willis Tower. Generations of Chicagoans have a collective memory Gensler of this building playing a role in their entire lives. Chicagoans mark time with Willis Tower, but Chicago, United States time has caught up with this aging supertall. The way the building engages with the city and its occupants needed a fresh approach. Understanding how Willis Tower is being reimagined Based in Gensler’s Chicago office, Stephen is a by new owners is crucial to the success of old and new supertall towers around the globe. This Senior Associate and Technical Director. Stephen paper examines the efforts of the design team as it created a new path forward for Willis Tower. has worked and lectured in the United States, Asia, and Europe and has authored papers about A new city-block-sized podium structure and substantial infrastructure improvements are part façade design and sustainability. Stephen is a of this work (see Figure 1), and the results have a dramatic effect on a piece of civic history while founding member of Gensler Enclosures; a group transforming the building into a destination for tenants and visitors alike.
    [Show full text]
  • Technological Advances and Trends in Modern High-Rise Buildings
    buildings Article Technological Advances and Trends in Modern High-Rise Buildings Jerzy Szolomicki 1,* and Hanna Golasz-Szolomicka 2 1 Faculty of Civil Engineering, Wroclaw University of Science and Technology, 50-370 Wroclaw, Poland 2 Faculty of Architecture, Wroclaw University of Science and Technology, 50-370 Wroclaw, Poland * Correspondence: [email protected]; Tel.: +48-505-995-008 Received: 29 July 2019; Accepted: 22 August 2019; Published: 26 August 2019 Abstract: The purpose of this paper is to provide structural and architectural technological solutions applied in the construction of high-rise buildings, and present the possibilities of technological evolution in this field. Tall buildings always have relied on technological innovations in engineering and scientific progress. New technological developments have been continuously taking place in the world. It is closely linked to the search for efficient construction materials that enable buildings to be constructed higher, faster and safer. This paper presents a survey of the main technological advancements on the example of selected tall buildings erected in the last decade, with an emphasis on geometrical form, the structural system, sophisticated damping systems, sustainability, etc. The famous architectural studios (e.g., for Skidmore, Owings and Merill, Nikhen Sekkei, RMJM, Atkins and WOHA) that specialize, among others, in the designing of skyscrapers have played a major role in the development of technological ideas and architectural forms for such extraordinary engineering structures. Among their completed projects, there are examples of high-rise buildings that set a precedent for future development. Keywords: high-rise buildings; development; geometrical forms; structural system; advanced materials; damping systems; sustainability 1.
    [Show full text]
  • P21 Layout 1
    EU investigates German current account surplus Page 22 Business Risk appetite subdued on US Fed uncertainty THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 14, 2013 Page 24 The Rolls-Royce Arab Spring economies hit by uncertainty Phantom SeriesII Page 23 Page 25 CHICAGO: In this file photo, the 110-storey, 1,450-foot Willis Tower rises above the Chicago skyline. According to the nonprofitCouncil on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat, Willis Tower, formerly known as the Sears Tower, will be the tenth tallest completed building in the world, with a height measured at 1,451 feet, once New York’s 1 World Trade Center, with a height of 1,776 feet, is completed. — AP One World Trade Center named US tallest building 1,451-foot Willis Tower dethroned NEW YORK: They set out to build the tallest skyscraper in the near Central Park. Speaking at his office in New York, council chair- world - a giant that would rise a symbolic 1,776 feet from the ash- man Timothy Johnson, an architect at the global design firm NBBJ, es of ground zero. Those aspirations of global supremacy fell by said the decision by the 25-member height committee had more the wayside long ago, but New York won a consolation prize “tense moments” than usual, given the skyscraper’s importance as Tuesday when an international architectural panel said it would a patriotic symbol. recognize One World Trade Center - at 541 meters high - as the “I was here on 9/11. I saw the buildings come down,” he said. tallest skyscraper in the United States. Over the past few months, the council had hinted that it might be The Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat, considered a open to changing its standards for measuring ultra-tall buildings, world authority on supersized skyscrapers, announced its decision given a trend toward developers adding “vanity height” to towers at simultaneous news conferences in New York and Chicago, with huge, decorative spires.
    [Show full text]
  • Breaking New Ground 2017 Annual Report
    BREAKING NEW GROUND 2017 Annual Report Comprehensive Annual Financial Report for the Year Ended December 31, 2017. Our Mission Meet the critical transportation infrastructure needs of the bi-state region’s people, businesses, and visitors by providing the highest-quality and most efficient transportation and port commerce facilities and services to move people and goods within the region, provide access to the nation and the world, and promote the region’s economic development. Our mission is simple: to keep the region moving. 2 THE PORT AUTHORITY OF NY & NJ TABLE OF CONTENTS I ntroductory Section 2 Origins of The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey 3 Letter of Transmittal to the Governors 4 Board of Commissioners 5 Leadership of the Port Authority Our Core Business Imperatives 9 Investment 10 Safety and Security 11 Integrity 12 Diversity and Inclusion 13 Sustainability and Resiliency Major Milestones By Business Line 15 2017 at a Glance 16 Aviation 20 Tunnels, Bridges & Terminals 24 Port of New York and New Jersey 28 Port Authority Trans-Hudson Corporation (PATH) 30 World Trade Center Financial Section 32 Chief Financial Officer’s Letter of Transmittal to the Board of Commissioners 35 Index to Financial Section Corporate Information Section 126 Selected Statistical, Demographic, and Economic Data 127 Top 20 Salaried Staff as of December 31, 2017 The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey Comprehensive Annual Financial Report for the Year Ended December 31, 2017 Prepared by the Marketing and Comptroller’s departments of The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey 4 World Trade Center, 150 Greenwich Street, 23rd Floor, New York, NY 10007 www.panynj.gov BREAKING NEW GrounD 1 The Port District includes the cities of New York and Yonkers in New York State; the cities of Newark, Jersey City, Bayonne, Hoboken, and Elizabeth in the State of New Jersey; and more than 200 other municipalities, including all or part of 17 counties, in the two states.
    [Show full text]
  • January 2016 the Future of NYC Real Estate
    January 2016 http://therealdeal.com/issues_articles/the-future-of-nyc-real-estate-2/ The Future of NYC real estate Kinetic buildings and 2,000-foot skyscrapers are just around the corner By Kathryn Brenzel The Hudson Yards Culture Shed, a yet-to-be-built arts and performance space at 10 Hudson Yards, just might wind up being the Batmobile of buildings. Dormant, it’s a glassy fortress. Animated, it will be able to extend its wings so-to-speak by sliding out a retractable exterior as a canopy. The design is a window into the future of New York City construction — and the role technology will play. This isn’t to say that a fleet of moving buildings will invade New York anytime soon, but the projects of the future will be smarter, more adaptive and, of course, more awe-inspiring. “I think you’re going to start having more and more facades that are more kinetic, that react to the environment,” said Tom Scarangello, CEO of Thornton Tomasetti, a New York-based engineering firm that’s working on the Culture Shed. For example, Westfield’s Oculus, the World Trade Center’s new bird-like transit hub, features a retractable skylight whose function is more symbolic than practical: It opens only on Sept. 11. As a whole, developers are moving away from the shamelessly reflective glass boxes of the past, instead opting for transparent-yet-textured buildings as well as slender, soaring towers à la Billionaires’ Row. They are already beginning to experiment with different building materials, such as trading steel for wood in the city’s first “plyscraper,” which is being planned at 475 West 18th Street.
    [Show full text]
  • Symbolism and the City: from Towers of Power to 'Ground Zero'
    Prairie Perspectives: Geographical Essays (Vol: 15) Symbolism and the city: From towers of power to ‘Ground Zero’ Robert Patrick University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, SK Canada Amy MacDonald University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB Canada Abstract This paper explores the symbolism of New York City’s World Trade Center (WTC) before and after the devastating attack of September 11, 2001. The many metaphors captured in the built space of the WTC site are interrogated from ‘Ground Zero’ to the symbolic significance of the new ‘Freedom Tower’ now nearing completion (2014). In fulfilling the intended symbolism of American economic power, the WTC towers became pop-culture symbols of New York City, and the Unit- ed States. The WTC towers stood as twin icons of western economic dominance along with ‘Wall Street’ and ‘Dow Jones’ reflecting the American ethos of freedom and opportunity. However, the WTC also imbued negative, albeit unintended, symbolism such as the coldness of modernist architecture, social class disparities across urban America, and global domina- tion. Plans for redeveloping the WTC site predominantly highlight the intended positive symbolic connotations of the for- mer Twin Towers, including freedom and opportunity. This article points to the symbolic significance of urban built form and the potential negative consequences that are associated with iconic structures, including the new Freedom Tower. Keywords: symbolism, iconic architecture, New York City, World Trade Center Introduction tions leading to positive and negative actions of individuals and On September 11, 2001 a terrorist attack of horrific propor- groups. Indeed, there is a long fascination among geographers tions destroyed the New York World Trade Center and surround- and planners to the symbolic functions of ‘architectural gigan- ing structures.
    [Show full text]
  • Burj Khalifa Tower
    Burj Khalifa Tower The tallest structure in the world, standing at 2,722 ft (830 meters), just over 1/2 mile high, Burj Khalifa (Khalifa Tower) opened in 2010 as a centerpiece building in a large-scale, mixed-use development called Downtown Dubai. The building originally referred to as Dubai Tower was renamed in honor of the president of the United Arab Emirates, Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan. Burj Khalifa Dubai, United Arab Emirates Architecture Style Modern Skyscraper | Neo-Futurism Glass, Steel, Aluminum & Reinforced Concrete Prominent Architecture Features Y-Shaped Floor Plan Maximizes Window Perimeter Areas for residential and hotel space Buttressed central core and wing design to support the height of the building 27 setbacks in a spiraling pattern Main Structure 430,000 cubic yards reinforced concrete and 61,000 tons rebar Foundation - 59,000 cubic yards concrete and 192 piles 164 ft (50 m) deep Highly compartmentalized, pressurized refuge floors for life safety Facade Aluminum and textured stainless steel spandrel panels with low-E glass Vertical polished stainless steel fins Observation Deck - 148th Floor PROJECT SUMMARY Project Description Burj Kahlifa, the tallest building in the world, has redefined the possibilities in the design, engineering, and construction of mega-tall buildings. Incorporating periodic setbacks at the ends of each wing, the tower tapers in an upward spiraling pattern that decreases is mass as the height of the tower increases. The building’s design included multiple wind tunnel tests and design adjustments to develop optimum performance relative to wind and natural forces. The building serves as a model for the concept of future, compact, livable, urban centers with direct connections to mass transit systems.
    [Show full text]
  • CASE STUDY WILLIS TOWER (Formerly Known As Sears Tower) Chicago, Illinois
    CASE STUDY WILLIS TOWER (Formerly known as Sears Tower) Chicago, Illinois Situation Constructed in 1973 and named for its largest tenant, the 110-story Sears Tower was the tallest building in the world, a title it held for nearly 25 years. The Sears Tower featured 3,750,000 square feet of premier office, retail and restaurant space in addition to an observation deck and a rooftop antenna farm with over 52 broadcast users. After the 9/11 attack on the World Trade Center in New York, the building’s then owner experienced a marked decrease in the desire for office space in the tallest building in the United States. This resulted in the property reverting to the lender, via a deed in lieu of foreclosure, further stigmatizing the building. Challenge/Opportunity In 2004, the property was purchased for $840 million, with occupancy at its lowest level in decades. American Landmark Properties and its principals were co-managing members of the ownership group and were involved in every aspect of renovating, rebranding, operating and managing this world-class property. The new ownership group saw an opportunity to acquire one of the truly iconic buildings in the world with a unique chance to restore the structure to its original world-famous status through a rebranding of the Tower and a physical and operational make-over, financed by a recapitalization. Results In 2015, the Willis Tower American Landmark Properties Solution sale to Blackstone Group Following the acquisition of the property, the new owners implemented a plan to rebrand the represented the highest price Tower, highlighting its prime location in the CBD and its state-of-the-art systems and security.
    [Show full text]
  • Repairs on the Verizon
    GOTHAM GIGS FROM BOMBS TO BIKES Combat engineer puts the pieces back together CRAIN’S® NEW YORK BUSINESS PAGE 8 VOL. XXIX, NO. 2 WWW.CRAINSNEWYORK.COM JANUARY 14-20, 2013 PRICE: $3.00 Repairs on the CUOMO’S Verizon Telecom’s $1B worth of Sandy damage CASINO could offer silver lining for company FLIP BY MATTHEW FLAMM Nearly three months after Super- storm Sandy knocked out power in lower Manhattan, 160 Water St. is Governor does a ‘180,’ sending its own little ghost town, vacant since seawater filled its basement gambling lobbyists scrambling the night of Oct. 29. But the emptiness of the 24- story building means more than just BY CHRIS BRAGG the absence of tenants like the New York City Health and Hospitals A year ago, Gov. Andrew Cuomo made the centerpiece of his State of Corp. Sliced-off copper cables from the State address an ambitious plan to legalize casino gambling in New the Verizon phone system hang from the telecommunications York. A $4 billion convention center in Queens was to be built next to “frame room” walls, its floor still the Aqueduct racino, which seemed certain to become the city’s first puddled in water. When 160 Water full-fledged casino. In the 2013 iteration of the speech last week, the St. reopens next month, the frame governor reversed himself. He said casinos in the city would under- room will re- mine the goal of drawing Gotham’s 52 million tourists upstate. The main empty. first three gambling venues he eyes for the state now appear destined All the phone 300K for north of the metropolitan area.
    [Show full text]
  • The-Hows-Whats-And-Wows-Of-Willis
    There are enough impressive facts about the When you get back to your school, we hope Willis Tower to make even the most worldly your students will send us photos or write or among us say, “Wow!” So many things at the create artwork about their experiences and Willis Tower can be described by a share them with us (via email or the mailing superlative: biggest, fastest, and longest. But address at the end of this guide). there is more to the building than all these “wows”: 1,450 sky-scraping, cloud-bumping One photo will be selected as the “Photo of feet of glass and steel, 43,000 miles of the Day” and displayed on our Skydeck telephone cable, 25,000 miles of plumbing, monitors for all to see. Artwork and writing 4.56 million square feet of floor space and a will posted on bulletin boards in the view of four states. lunchroom area. We would also love to have you and your students post you Skydeck Behind the “wows” are lots of “hows” and Chicago photos to the Skydeck Chicago pages “whats” for you and your students to on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter. explore. In this guide you will be introduced to the building—its beginnings as the Sears As you get ready for your trip, please call us Tower and its design, construction and place with any questions at (312) 875-9447. We aim in the pantheon of skyscrapers. Its name to make your visit your best school trip ever. was recently changed to the Willis Tower, proudly reflecting the name of the global insurance broker who makes the Tower its Chicago home.
    [Show full text]