DOCSLIB.ORG

Failure to Replicate Results of Bem Parapsychology Experiments

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Failure to Replicate Results of Bem Parapsychology Experiments March April 13 *_SI new design masters 1/31/13 9:52 AM Page 5 [ NEWS AND COMMENT Failure to Replicate Results of Bem Parapsychology “Correcting the Past: Failures to Repli- Experiments Published by Same Journal cate Psi.” The article is lengthy, but the central KENDRICK FRAZIER conclusion is succinctly stated: “Across seven experiments (N= 3,289), we replicate the procedure of Experiments Two years ago the prepublication re lease 8 and 9 from Bem (2011), which had orig- of a research paper by psychologist inally demonstrated retro active facilitation Daryl Bem claiming experimental evi- of recall. We failed to replicate that find- dence for precognition created a world- ing.” They further conducted a meta- wide media stir and intense controversy analysis of all replication attempts of the within the scientific and skeptical com- Bem experiments “and find that the aver- munities. age effect size (d = 0.04) is not different Bem, of Cornell University, claimed from 0.” that through nine experiments he had To put it even more directly (from the demonstrated the existence of precogni- beginning of their conclusions section): tion, specifically the existence of “con- “We conducted seven experiments test- scious cognitive awareness ...of a future ing for precognition and found no evi- event that could not otherwise be antic- dence supporting its existence.” ipated through any known inferential How can their results be reconciled process.” Essentially, he had claimed to Journal of Personality and Social Psychology © 2012 American Psychological Association 2012, Vol. 103, No. 6, 933–948 0022-3514/12/$12.00 DOI: 10.1037/a0029709 with Bem’s? “It is unclear how Bem have produced evidence that psychic Correcting the Past: Failures to Replicate Psi could find significant support for a hy- abilities not only exist but can transcend Jeff Galak Robyn A. LeBoeuf Carnegie Mellon University University of Florida pothesis that appears to be untrue,” the time and allow the future to reach back- Leif D. Nelson Joseph P. Simmons University of California, Berkeley University of Pennsylvania authors say. They suggest such possibil- Across 7 experiments (N ϭ 3,289), we replicate the procedure of Experiments 8 and 9 from Bem (2011), ward to change the past. which had originally demonstrated retroactive facilitation of recall. We failed to replicate that finding. We further conduct a meta-analysis of all replication attempts of these experiments and find that the ities as what psychologists call Type I average effect size (d ϭ 0.04) is no different from 0. We discuss some reasons for differences between Informed critics of parapsychology the results in this article and those presented in Bem (2011). Keywords: psi, precognition, ESP, researcher degrees of freedom, meta-analysis error—a false rejection of the null hy- were almost uniformly incredulous. Al- Recently, Bem (2011) published an extremely thought- provide the necessary tightly controlled experiments, the purpose provoking article demonstrating the existence of precognition, a of the current article is to conduct and to synthesize replications by pothesis. They also point to concerns “conscious cognitive awareness . of a future event that could not independent investigators. otherwise be anticipated through any known inferential process” though Bem is a respected psychologist, (p. 407). Through nine experiments, Bem found consistent support Psi Phenomena for the idea that people have such precognitive abilities. He sug- about researcher degrees of freedom, gested that these findings present examples of retroactive influ- The precognitive abilities reported by Bem (2011) emerged ence, through which future events influence people’s current re- across a range of tasks. As one example, in Experiment 1, Bem they found so many flaws in the research sponses and that more broadly these findings are instances of psi (2011) asked participants to select whether a picture would appear phenomena, or “anomalous processes of information or energy on the left side of the screen or the right side of the screen. which also raise the likelihood of falsely transfer that are currently unexplained in terms of known physical Participants’ selections were accurate more often than chance protocols and methods that in their view or biological mechanisms” (Bem, 2011, p. 407). would predict when the picture in question was an erotic one (but In his article, Bem (2011) acknowledged that psi is a contro- not a neutral, positive, or negative one), suggesting that people versial topic. He reported data suggesting that many, if not most, rejecting the null hy pothesis. While have precognitive abilities to detect where erotic stimuli will academic psychologists do not believe that psi phenomena exist. appear. the conclusions had no validity. One of Indeed, the publication of Bem’s research met with a wide variety Precognitive abilities also manifested on more complicated of reactions in the academic and popular media alike, and although tasks. For example, in Experiment 5, participants were asked to many experimental decisions are defen- some reactions were supportive, many were skeptical (Carey, choose which of two negatively arousing pictures they liked better. 2011a; Carey, 2011b; Wagenmakers, Wetzels, Borsboom, & van After this choice, the computer randomly selected one of the the most stinging re bukes came in the der Maas, 2011). In light of the skepticism surrounding psi and in pictures to serve as the target picture, which then flashed sublim- anticipation of the reaction to his article, Bem suggested that psi inally on the screen from 4 to 10 times. Research on the mere- sible, “because their application is at the researchers must conduct tightly controlled experiments that dem- exposure effect suggests that subliminal exposure to a negative onstrate psi and “that can be replicated by independent investiga- target increases liking of that target (i.e., causes habituation; form of an ex tended, in-depth critique of tors” (Bem, 2011, p. 407). Whereas Bem’s article may indeed Kunst-Wilson & Zajonc, 1980). Bem (2011) suggested that if people have precognitive abilities, their current liking of a negative discretion of the researcher examining picture would be enhanced by the fact that they will see that This article was published Online First August 27, 2012. picture several times in the future (even though they have no all nine experiments by York University Jeff Galak, Tepper School of Business, Carnegie Mellon University; known way of knowing that they will see it). Bem’s results Robyn A. LeBoeuf, Department of Marketing, University of Florida; Leif supported this prediction: When participants chose between neg- data after the completion of the exper- D. Nelson, Department of Marketing, University of California, Berkeley; ative picture pairs, they were more likely to prefer the one that Joseph P. Simmons, Operations and Information Management Department, would later be selected to be the subliminally presented target. University of Pennsylvania. Perhaps the most straightforward and impressive demonstration psychologist and CSI Executive Council We would like to thank Eduardo Andrade and Justin Kruger for crucial of precognition emerged in Bem’s (2011) Experiments 8 and 9, assistance with the project and Gia Nardini for her help in collecting data iment, they can make a true effect more for this article. which documented “retroactive facilitation of recall” (p. 419). In KEPTICAL Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Jeff these studies, participants saw 48 words and then were asked to member James Alcock in the S Galak, Tepper School of Business, Carnegie Mellon University, 5000 recall as many of those words as possible. Next, participants were Forbes Avenue, Office 381-D, Pittsburgh, PA 15213. E-mail: jgalak@ given a chance to practice a randomly chosen subset of the 48 difficult to discern. ... Researcher de- cmu.edu words by, for example, retyping them and recategorizing them. In INQUIRER (“Back from the Future: 933 grees of freedom do not make a finding Parapsy chology and the Bem Affair,” SI, false . but they do make it much March/April 2011; see also editorial various universities, but none were ac- harder to distinguish between truth and “Why the Bem Experiments are Not cepted for publication by JPSP. In fact, falseness in reported data.” Parapsychology’s Next Big Thing” in the it said it would not consider publishing They end by quoting philosopher of same issue). replication failures. This fact raised more science Karl Popper: “An effect is not an Alcock also concluded that the jour- controversy and concern. effect unless it is replicable, and a sci- nal that published Bem’s study, the Jour- Now the journal has had an apparent ence is not a science unless it conducts nal of Personality and Social Psy chology change of heart. It has finally published (and values) attempted replications.” (JPSP), had done everyone a disservice a set of experiments that attempted (and They do compliment Bem for encour- by publishing this “badly flawed research failed) to replicate Bem’s results. Seven aging the independent replication of his article.” Parapsy chology and the journal’s experiments conducted by Jeff Galak of experiments. own reputation, he wrote, had been dam- Carnegie Mellon University, Robyn A. Alcock, who wrote SI’s 2011 critique, aged, and the article’s publication dis- LeBoeuf of the University of Florida, has mixed feelings about the Galak et served the public as well, “for it only adds Leif D. Nelson of the Uni versity of Cal- al. paper: to [public] confusion about the existence ifornia at Berkeley, and Joseph P. Sim- While I am happy that they carried of psi.” mons of the University of Pennsylvania out this research and that it was pub- Experiments attempting to replicate have been published in JPSP’s final issue lished, I find it very odd that they fo- Bem’s results were quickly conducted at of 2012 (Vol. 103, No. 6) under the title cused on Bem’s studies as though Skeptical Inquirer | March/April 2013 5 March April 13 *_SI new design masters 1/31/13 9:53 AM Page 6 they had been carefully de signed and Here is his initial comment: al.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Patients with Cancer. Is There a Role for Chiropractic? Maria Tsampika Laoudikou, Mchiro1 Peter William Mccarthy, Phd1
    ISSN 0008-3194 (p)/ISSN 1715-6181 (e)/2020/32–42/$2.00/©JCCA 2020 Patients with cancer. Is there a role for chiropractic? Maria Tsampika Laoudikou, MChiro1 Peter William McCarthy, PhD1 People who have a diagnosis of cancer may develop, Comme tout le monde, les personnes atteintes or already have musculoskeletal conditions, just d’un cancer peuvent développer des troubles like any other person. However, discussion about musculosquelettiques, si elles n’en ont pas déjà. En règle potential benefits of chiropractic treatment to this générale, on évite de discuter des éventuels bienfaits des group has generally been avoided related to the fear traitements chiropratiques pour ce groupe de personnes of misrepresentation. We aimed to derive a consensus de peur de faire de fausses déclarations. Nous avons from a group of experienced chiropractors regarding cherché à obtenir un consensus auprès d’un groupe their perception of what chiropractic care offered to de chiropraticiens d’expérience à qui on a demandé patients with cancer. An anonymous, two stage, on- ce qu’ils pensaient des traitements chiropratiques line, Delphi process was performed using experienced administrés aux patients cancéreux. On a mené une chiropractors (n=23: >10 yrs practice experience, who enquête Delphi anonyme, en deux étapes et en ligne, had treated patients with cancer) purposively selected auprès de chiropraticiens d’expérience (n =23 : >10 ans and recruited independently. One opted out of the study, d’exercice, ayant déjà traité des patients atteints d’un 13 actively engaged in two rounds of questions and cancer) choisis et recrutés de manière indépendante. verification; agreeing such patients gained benefit from L’un d’entre eux a abandonné l’étude, 13 ont répondu chiropractic care but use of spinal manipulation was à deux séries de questions et se sont soumis aux not essential.
    [Show full text]
  • Acupuncture, Chiropractic, Naturopathy, Massage Therapy)
    All plans offered and underwritten by Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the Northwest 500 NE Multnomah St., Suite 100, Portland, OR 97232 ©2019 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the Northwest 337643167_LBG_04-19 Oregon PPO Plus® alternative care benefit (acupuncture, chiropractic, naturopathy, massage therapy) This benefit covers self-referred acupuncture, chiropractic, naturopathic, and massage therapy services. You may choose providers from PPO providers or non-participating providers. Choose your benefit maximum, 3 options: Benefit maximum per year (all services combined, all tiers combined) $1,000 / $1,500 / $2,000 Non-Participating PPO Providers Providers (Tier 1) (Tier 2)2 Services You Pay1 Specialty office visit Specialty office visit Acupuncture services cost share cost share Specialty office visit Specialty office visit Chiropractic services cost share cost share Specialty office visit Specialty office visit Naturopathic medicine cost share cost share Massage therapy (12-visit limit) $25 $25 1If added to an HSA-qualified deductible plan, this benefit is subject to the deductible. 2You may need to file a claim for covered services at non-participating providers. Office visits You do not need a referral to make an appointment. There is no claim form to file for services from Tier 1 providers; you pay your copay or coinsurance directly to the provider when you receive care. Once your benefit limit has been reached, you pay 100% of the cost of services for the remainder of the calendar year. PPO provider You may contact Member Services for additional information or visit kp.org/ppoplus/nw for information on locating a PPO provider. Acupuncture services Acupuncturists influence the health of the body by the insertion of very fine needles.
    [Show full text]
  • The Beginner's Guide to 'Holistic' Wellness
    BOOK REVIEWS in the progression of the disease when The Beginner’s Guide to prayer was used” (p. 98). For such a bold statement, the evidence is pretty weak, ‘Holistic’ Wellness however. There are very few studies on DIMITRY ROTSTEIN personal prayer (none are double-blind, of course), and their results are mixed Mayo Clinic Book of Alternative Medicine. By The Mayo even for treating purely psychological Clinic. Time Inc. Home Entertainment Books, New York, symptoms. More disturbing is the fact 2007. ISBN: 1-933405-92-9. 192 pp. Hardcover, $24.95. that the book doesn’t make a distinc- tion between personal and intercessory prayer, even though the latter is known to have no effect according to well-de- he Mayo Clinic Book of mean that perhaps we skeptics have signed studies (including one by the Alterna tive Medicine is the been unfair to “alternative medicine” Mayo Clinic itself). None of these facts most significant publication of and that there is more to it than just T is ever mentioned. In summary, the evi- the Mayo Clinic Complementary and placebo, self-delusion, quackery, or, at dence of the effectiveness of these “ther- Integrative Medicine Program’s team, best, some outdated healing techniques? apies” against any real disease is either which has been studying various forms Perhaps not. dubious or non-existent. Of course, of complementary and alternative medi- True, of the twenty-five CAM ther- controlling such factors as stress and cine (CAM, for short) since 2001. Here apies, fourteen are recommended as depression is important for your health, you will find nothing but reliable and safe and effective for “treating” various but there is no indication that any of the easy-to-understand information from diseases.
    [Show full text]
  • Learn More About Chiropractic
    The Chiropractic Approach tion of health. Spinal integrity is an important factor in promoting healing through chiropractic and is achieved to Health Care without surgery or drugs. Doctors of Chiropractic (DCs) are licensed health care professionals concerned with the diagnosis, treatment Chiropractic Care and prevention of neuromusculoskeletal disorders, and the effects of these disorders on the nervous system and is Unique general health. Chiropractic care involves manipulation/adjustment of the joints (spine or extremity) and associated therapy DCs use natural and conservative methods of treatment to promote spinal integrity. DCs manipulate/treat the and respect the human body’s ability to heal itself. DCs joint dysfunction (subluxation) by using the hands, or a treat the biomechanics, structure, and function of the handheld instrument. DCs diagnose injuries and neuro- spine, and its effects on the muscle and nerve systems, musculoskeletal disorders, and treat individuals for pain, and take into account the role played by the proper func- such as headaches, joint pain, neck pain, low-back pain tion of these systems in the preservation and restora- and sciatica. DCs also treat osteoarthritis, carpal tunnel syndrome, tendonitis, sprains and strains, and a variety of other non-neuromusculoskeletal conditions. Chiropractic Education Candidates must complete a minimum of three years of college-level courses prior to entering chiropractic school. Completion of a Doctor of Chiropractic degree requires four to five years of professional coursework. The education of a chiropractor is similar in total class- room hours to that of a medical doctor. An average of 4,822 hours is required in chiropractic schools, com- pared with 4,667 hours in medical schools.
    [Show full text]
  • In the Supreme Court of the United States
    NO. 17-_____ In the Supreme Court of the United States EDWARD LEWIS TOBINICK, MD, a Medical Corporation d/b/a INSTITUTE OF NEUROLOGICAL RECOVERY, INR PLLC, d/b/a INSTITUTE OF NEUROLOGICAL RECOVERY, EDWARD TOBINICK, M.D., Petitioners, –v– STEVEN NOVELLA, M.D., Respondent. On Petition for Writ of Certiorari to the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI CULLIN A. O’BRIEN, ESQ. COUNSEL FOR PETITIONERS CULLIN O’BRIEN LAW, P.A. 6541 NE 21ST WAY FT. LAUDERDALE, FL 33308 (561) 676-6370 [email protected] SEPTEMBER 1, 2017 SUPREME COURT PRESS ♦ (888) 958-5705 ♦ BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS i QUESTIONS PRESENTED In our age of the Internet, false disparagement against individuals and businesses can be lucrative. An Internet entrepreneur can funnel web-traffic for profit, through sophisticated uses of disparaging “click baiting,” “Internet trolling,” hyperlinks, hypertext, clickable banner ads, podcasts, Facebook, Instagram, email listservs and other systems. Individuals seeking legal redress from false Internet defamation can confront state court anti-SLAPP procedures that accelerate adjudication of the defendant’s “actual malice.” In contrast, businesses seeking federal court protection from false Internet disparagement under the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(1)(B), are entitled to the summary adjudication safeguards of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56. The questions presented to this Court are: 1. When a defendant is sued for both common law defamation and business disparagement under the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(B), does the application of state civil court anti-SLAPP procedure irreconcilably conflict with Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56? 2.
    [Show full text]
  • On Faith-Healing New Secular Humanist Centers?
    New Secular More on Humanist Faith-Healing Centers? James Randi Paul Kurtz Gerald Larue Vern Bullough Henry Gordon Bob Wisne David Alexander Faith-healer Robert Roberts Also: Is Goldilocks Dangerous? • Pornography • The Supreme Court • Southern Baptists • Protestantism, Catholicism, and Unbelief in France 1n Its Tree _I FALL 1986, VOL. 6, NO. 4 ISSN 0272-0701 Contents 3 LETTERS TO THE EDITOR 17 BIBLICAL SCORECARD 62 CLASSIFIED 12 ON THE BARRICADES 60 IN THE NAME OF GOD 6 EDITORIALS Is Goldilocks Dangerous? Paul Kurtz / Pornography, Censorship, and Freedom, Paul Kurtz I Reagan's Judiciary, Ronald A. Lindsay / Is Secularism Neutral? Richard J. Burke / Southern Baptists Betray Heritage, Robert S. Alley / The Holy-Rolling of America, Frank Johnson 14 HUMANIST CENTERS New Secular Humanist Centers, Paul Kurtz / The Need for Friendship Centers, Vern L. Bullough / Toward New Humanist Organizations, Bob Wisne THE EVIDENCE AGAINST REINCARNATION 18 Are Past-Life Regressions Evidence for Reincarnation? Melvin Harris 24 The Case Against Reincarnation (Part 1) Paul Edwards BELIEF AND UNBELIEF WORLDWIDE 35 Protestantism, Catholicism, and Unbelief in Present-Day France Jean Boussinesq MORE ON FAITH-HEALING 46 CS ER's Investigation Gerald A. Larue 46 An Answer to Peter Popoff James Randi 48 Popoff's TV Empire Declines .. David Alexander 49 Richard Roberts's Healing Crusade Henry Gordon IS SECULAR HUMANISM A RELIGION? 52 A Response to My Critics Paul Beattie 53 Diminishing Returns Joseph Fletcher 54 On Definition-Mongering Paul Kurtz BOOKS 55 The Other World of Shirley MacLaine Ring Lardner, Jr. 57 Saintly Starvation Bonnie Bullough VIEWPOINTS 58 Papal Pronouncements Delos B. McKown 59 Yahweh: A Morally Retarded God William Harwood Editor: Paul Kurtz Associate Editors: Doris Doyle, Steven L.
    [Show full text]
  • CFI-Annual-Report-2018.Pdf
    Message from the President and CEO Last year was another banner year for the Center the interests of people who embrace reason, for Inquiry. We worked our secular magic in a science, and humanism—the principles of the vast variety of ways: from saving lives of secular Enlightenment. activists around the world who are threatened It is no secret that these powerful ideas like with violence and persecution to taking the no others have advanced humankind by nation’s largest drugstore chain, CVS, to court unlocking human potential, promoting goodness, for marketing homeopathic snake oil as if it’s real and exposing the true nature of reality. If you medicine. are looking for humanity’s true salvation, CFI stands up for reason and science in a way no look no further. other organization in the country does, because This past year we sought to export those ideas to we promote secular and humanist values as well places where they have yet to penetrate. as scientific skepticism and critical thinking. The Translations Project has taken the influential But you likely already know that if you are reading evolutionary biology and atheism books of this report, as it is designed with our supporters in Richard Dawkins and translated them into four mind. We want you not only to be informed about languages dominant in the Muslim world: Arabic, where your investment is going; we want you to Urdu, Indonesian, and Farsi. They are available for take pride in what we have achieved together. free download on a special website. It is just one When I meet people who are not familiar with CFI, of many such projects aimed at educating people they often ask what it is we do.
    [Show full text]
  • IMCR an Initiative for Improving AYUSH Health System at Kolli Hills IMCR
    IMCR 43 REPORT An Initiative for Improving AYUSH Health System at Kolli Hills Kalyan Maity1,2, Parul Bali3, Maa Muktika4, J. M. Balamurugan5* 1 Division of Yoga and Life Sciences, Swami Vivekananda Yoga Anusandhana Samsthana (S-VYASA), Bengaluru, Karnataka, India 2 Neuroscience Research Lab, Department of Neurology, PGIMER, Chandigarh, India 3 Department of Biological Sciences, IISER, Mohali, Punjab, India 4 Isha Outreach, Velliangiri Foothills, Ishana Vihar (po), Coimbatore, Tamilnadu, India 5 IAS, Principal Secretory to Governor Punjab & Administrator U.T Chandigarh, India *Corresponding Author: J. M. Balamurugan, IAS Principal Secretory to Governor Punjab & Administrator U.T Chandigarh, India Contact no: +91-9780020243 E-mail: [email protected] Introduction only medicine” [23]. Research has shown that Naturopathy can be an integrative treatment for hypertension [24], meno- Indian system of medicine has been a well-established tradi- pausal symptoms [25], asthma [26], metabolic syndrome tional medical system globally [1]. This system is also called [27], and cancer [28]. AYUSH (Ayurveda, Yoga & Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha, and Along with Ayurveda, Yoga and Naturopathy, India is fol- Homeopathy) system. AYUSH system believes in holistic ap- lowing Unani system of medicine since long back, that was proach and treating a person as a whole. It is re-emerging in introduced by Arabs and Persians during eleventh century. developing countries in order to promote preventive health Several Unani healthcare, research and educational institutes rather than symptomatic management [2, 3]. Especially in In- are present in India [29]. Hippocrates is called the founder of dia AYUSH system is developing day by day as an integrative the Unani system.
    [Show full text]
  • Searching for Security in the Mystical the Function of Paranormal Beliefs
    Searching for Security in the Mystical The Function of Paranormal Beliefs MARTIN R. GRIMMER ver the past two decades, the paranor- mal has enjoyed something of a revival Owithin popular culture. There have been countless books, magazine and newspaper articles, movies, and television programs devoted to topics ranging from UFOs, the Bermuda Triangle, lost continents, Yetis, and Belief in the the Loch Ness monster, to pyramid power, astrology, levitation, telepathy, precognition, paranormal and poltergeists. Sociologist Marcello Truzzi appears to satisfy (1972) suggested that this boom in paranormal interest began around the late sixties, noting some very basic, if that Ouija boards outsold such popular board inconsistent games as Monopoly. human needs. It Lately, the paranormal seems to have mani- fested in the form of the New Age movement— will probably a loose combination of ideas encompassing spir- remain with us itualism, mysticism, alternative healing, and a healthy dose of commercialism. Some may think forever. this is mainly an American phenomenon, but it is estimated that Australians alone now spend $100 million a year on personal-transformation courses that delve deeply into such fringe areas as rebirthing, shamanism, channeling, and crystal healing. To some observers, the New Age movement is seen as a sort of quasi-religious justification for "yuppiedom"—how to make money and feel "really great" about it at the same time. Winter 1992 Research studies worldwide have written on this topic, several themes revealed an extensive belief in and in the human motive to believe can acceptance of the paranormal. In a be identified. survey of the readers of Britain's New First, paranormal beliefs may oper- Scientist magazine, a high proportion ate to reassure the believer that there of whom are reported to hold post- is order and control in what may graduate degrees, Evans (1973) found otherwise appear to be a chaotic that 67 percent believed that ESP was universe (Frank 1977).
    [Show full text]
  • Washington Alternative Care Benefit (Acupuncture, Naturopathy, Massage)
    All plans offered and underwritten by Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the Northwest 500 NE Multnomah St., Suite 100, Portland, OR 97232 ©2019 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the Northwest 338172811_LBG_04-19 Washington alternative care benefit (acupuncture, naturopathy, massage) This benefit covers self-referred acupuncture, naturopathic, and massage therapy services when obtained from participating providers. Benefits are subject to the copays or coinsurance, and visit and/or dollar limits shown below. Choose your benefit maximum, 3 options: Benefit maximum per year (naturopathy and massage combined) $1,000 / $1,500 / $2,000 Services You Pay* Acupuncture services (12-visit limit) Specialty office visit cost share Naturopathic medicine (benefit max applies) Specialty office visit cost share Massage therapy (12-visit limit and benefit max applies) $25 *If added to an HSA-qualified deductible plan, this benefit is subject to the deductible. Office visits You do not need a referral to make an appointment. There is no claim form to file. You pay your copay or coinsurance directly to the provider when you receive care. Once your benefit limit has been reached, you pay 100% of the cost of services for the remainder of the calendar year. As a member, you will receive a discount of up to 20%. Participating providers We contract with the CHP Group, a network of alternative care providers, to provide covered services to members. Visit chpgroup.com for a list of participating providers or contact Member Services. Acupuncture services Acupuncturists influence the health of the body by the insertion of very fine needles. Acupuncture treatment is primarily used to relieve pain, reduce inflammation, and promote healing.
    [Show full text]
  • A Skeptical Look at Overnight
    SI May June 2011_SI JF 10 V1 3/25/11 11:53 AM Page 1 Miracle Oil | UFO Abductology Implodes | Water Memory | Book Review: Emperor of All Maladies Vol. 35 No. 3 | May/June 2011 THE MAGAZINE FOR SCIENCE & REASON A Skeptical Look At Overnight Power Lines and Cancer, Distant Healing and Health Care The Numerology of 23 Slaying the Vampire: Solving the Chupacabra Mystery Gho$tly Book Endeavors Published by The Committee for Skeptical Inquiry SI May June 11 CUT_SI new design masters 3/25/11 10:01 AM Page 2 AT THE CEN TERFOR IN QUIRY /TRANSNATIONAL www.csicop.org Paul Kurtz, Founder Joe Nickell, Senior Research Fellow Richard Schroeder, Chairman Massimo Polidoro, Research Fellow Ronald A. Lindsay, President and CEO Benjamin Radford, Research Fellow Bar ry Karr, Ex ec u tive Di rect or Richard Wiseman, Research Fellow James E. Al cock*, psy chol o gist, York Univ., Tor on to Thom as Gi lov ich, psy chol o gist, Cor nell Univ. Lor en Pan kratz, psy chol o gist, Or e gon Health Mar cia An gell, MD, former ed i tor-in-chief, Wendy M. Grossman, writer; founder and first editor, Sci en ces Univ. New Eng land Jour nal of Med i cine The Skeptic magazine (UK) Robert L. Park,professor of physics, Univ. of Maryland Kimball Atwood IV, MD, physician, author, Sus an Haack, Coop er Sen ior Schol ar in Arts and Jay M. Pasachoff, Field Memorial Professor of Newton, MA Sci en ces, professor of phi los o phy and professor Astronomy and director of the Hopkins Steph en Bar rett, MD, psy chi a trist, au thor, con sum er of Law, Univ.
    [Show full text]
  • Red Internacional Escéptica
    RED INTERNACIONAL ESCÉPTICA EUROPA European Council of Skeptical Organizations pour I’Etude des Phenomenes Paranormaux.Mer- PORTUGAL: CEPO; Contacto: Ludwig Krippahl, Praceta Pero (ECSO). Presidente:Amardeo Sarma.Arheilger Weg 11, lin Gerin. RGE/A2 38050 Grenoble Cedex. Union Ra- Escobar, N 2 R/c Dto 2675-599 Odivelas. Correo-e: 64380 Rossdorf.Alemania. Fax: +49 6154 695022.Tel.: tionaliste. Contacto: Jean-Paul Krivine. 14, Rue de l’E- [email protected] +49 6154 695023. Correo-e: [email protected]. cole Polytechnique. 75005 París. REINO UNIDO: Association for Skeptical Enquiry ALEMANIA: Society for the Scientific Investigation of HUNGRÍA: Hungarian Skeptics.Gyula Bencze.Termes- (ASKE),P.O. Box 5994 Ripley DE5 3XL. Fax.: +44 114 Para-Science (GWUP).Presidente:Amardeo Sarma.Ar- zet Vilaga. PO Box 25. Budapest 8, 1444. Fax: 011- 221 7319. Correo-e.: [email protected]. The Skep- heilger Weg 11, 64380 Rossdorf.Tel.: +49-6154695021. 3611187506. tical Inquirer: Representante: Michael J. Hutchinson. 10 Fax: +49-6154695022. Correo-e.: [email protected]. IRLANDA: Irish Skeptics.Contacto: Peter O’Hara. St. Jose- Crescent View. Loughton. Essex 1G10 4PZ. Correo-e.: BÉLGICA: Committee Para. Presidente: J. Dommanget. ph’s Hospital, Limerick. [email protected]. ‘The Skeptic Magazine’: Editores: Observatoire Royal de Belgique.Avenue Circulaire 3. B- ITALIA: Comitato Italiano per il Controllo delle Toby Howard y Steve Donnelly. PO Box 475. Manchester 1180 Brussels. SKEPP.Secretario:W. Betz. Laarbeeklaan Affermazioni sul Paranormale (CICAP). Contacto: M60 2TH. Correo-e.: [email protected]. 103. B1090 Brussels. Fax: 32-2-4774701. Massimo Polidoro, editor Scienza & Paranormale.PO Box REPÚBLICA CHECA: Czech Club of Skeptics.Contac- ESTONIA: Contacto: Indrek Rohtmets.
    [Show full text]