Complex Angular and Torsional Deformities (Distal Femoral Malunions)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
416 Clinical Communication Complex angular and torsional deformities (distal femoral malunions) Preoperative planning using stereolithography and surgical correction with locking plate fixation in four dogs Michael D. DeTora; Randy J. Boudrieau Department of Clinical Sciences, Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine at Tufts University, North Grafton, MA, USA Keywords but one had a mild persistent lameness at Introduction Angular limb deformity, corrective osteo - the final in-hospital follow-up examination tomy, stereolithography, preoperative plan- (mean: 54.4 weeks; range: 24–113 weeks A number of methods have been utilized ning after surgery). All femurs healed without in the dog for both pre-surgical planning complications (mean: 34 weeks, median: 12 and surgical correction of angular limb Summary weeks; range: 8–12 weeks for closing osteot- deformities (1–5). Some angular limb de- Objective: To describe the surgical tech- omies, and 26–113 weeks for opening formities are typically challenging to as- nique of complex distal femoral deformity wedge osteotomies). Long-term follow-up sess radiographically due to multi-planar correction with the aid of stereolithography examination (mean: 28.6 months; range: torsional and angular deformities, making apparatus (SLA) biomodels, stabilized with 5–42 months) revealed all but one owner to accurate measurements difficult to obtain locking plate fixation. be highly satisfied with the outcome. Compli- (3, 5, 6). In addition, the femur is particu- Methods: Full-size replica epoxy bone bio- cations were observed in two dogs: prolong- larly difficult to assess as the frontal and models of the affected femurs (4 dogs/ ed tibiotarsal joint decreased flexion that re- sagittal plane orientation can easily be 5 limbs) were used as templates for surgical solved with physical therapy. In one of these masked by the inability to easily locate the planning. A rehearsal procedure was per- dogs, iatrogenic transection of the long digi- hip joint orientation in the presence of formed on the biomodels aided by a guide tal extensor tendon was repaired, and the torsion or multiplanar deformities. As wire technique and stabilized with locking other had a peroneal nerve neurapraxia. such, this combination of factors can rea- plate fixation. Surgery performed in all dogs Clinical significance: Stereolithography ap- sonably define such deformities as com- was guided by the rehearsal procedure. All paratus biomodels and rehearsal surgery plex, although we realize this is a subjec- pre-contoured implants were subsequently simplified the definitive surgical corrections tive definition. Software manipulation of used in the definitive surgical procedure with of complex femoral malunions and resulted computed tomography (CT) data has Downloaded by: Ondokuz Mayis University. Copyrighted material. minimal modification. in good functional outcomes. been described in humans, and also has Results: All dogs had markedly improved, been used to allow more accurate assess- with near normal functional outcomes; all ment in the dog (5, 7-11). However, even with these data and techniques, the surgi- cal planning of such deformities remains Correspondence to: Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol 2016; 29: 416–425 difficult to accurately assess (5, 6). More- Randy J. Boudrieau, DVM, Diplomate ACVS & ECVS http://dx.doi.org/10.3415/VCOT-15-08-0145 over, translating this information from the Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine at Tufts Received: August 26, 2015 radiographs and the CT to the patient at University Accepted: June 21, 2016 Department of Clinical Sciences Epub ahead of print: July 21, 2016 the time of the surgical procedure can be 200 Westboro Road difficult in both dogs and humans (5, 9, N. Grafton, MA 01536 Online supplementary material is available for this 12, 13). United States paper at: http://dx.doi.org/10.3415/VCOT-15-08-0145 Various methods of three-dimen- E-mail: [email protected] sional (3D) printing have been utilized to reproduce anatomical structures for medical use in both human and veterin- ary medicine (14). Stereolithography is a rapid prototyping technology that allows the creation of solid, 3D objects obtained Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol 5/2016 © Schattauer 2016 M. D. DeTora, R. J. Boudrieau: Complex deformity correction aided by 3D biomodels 417 Figure 1 A) Ventrodorsal pelvis radiograph preoperatively in a nine- that shows the right femoral angular and torsional femoral deformity: month-old castrated male mixed breed dog (limb 5) with a biapical deformity proximal procurvatum with distal recurvatum and valgus malalignment; also of the femur; note the malposition of the hip joint. B, C) Craniocaudal and notice the proximal femoral torsion (position of femoral head, neck and lateral three-dimensional reconstruction from computed tomography data greater trochanter); D, E) compare with the opposite normal femur. from CT data with computer aided de- Materials and methods Criteria for case selection sign (CAD) software, and as such the ability to create accurate full-size ana- The study was conducted in a manner con- Medical records of four client owned dogs tomical models of the bone. The use of sistent with the US National Institutes of (5 limbs) with severe distal femoral mal- stereolithography has been reported in Health “Guide for the Care and Use of Lab- union and treated at the Cummings School veterinary medicine to assist correction oratory Animals” and the Animal Welfare of Veterinary Medicine at Tufts University of antebrachial deformities, pelvic limb Acts (US PL 89–544; 91–579; 94–279). using SLA planning and titanium locking deformity, and total knee arthroplasty (3, 5, 6, 15). Accurate pre-planning with 3D biomodels in humans has been reported to translate into a more definite surgical process with increased knowledge of the intricacies of the procedure, improved Downloaded by: Ondokuz Mayis University. Copyrighted material. surgeon confidence, increased surgical efficiency, and reduced anaesthesia time (16). The purpose of this study was to de- scribe the surgical techniques in complex distal femoral deformity corrections with the aid of stereolithography apparatus (SLA) biomodels, and stabilized with multiple titanium locking plate fixation in four dogs (5 limbs). Our aims were to evaluate the use of SLA biomodels to facili- tate the pre- and intra-operative surgical Figure 2 Skyline view (limb 5) three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction from computed tomography (CT) data that demonstrates the inability to assess the femoral torsion of the right femur (A and B), as plan, and as a result, obtain appropriate the anteversion of the femoral head and neck, and position of the femoral condyles cannot be viewed realignment of the affected limb and an simultaneously (upper views are radiographic opacity images, while the lower views are bone opacity improved functional outcome without images so as to more easily interpret the bone conformation); C) compare with opposite normal femur. major complications. A further aim was to Preoperative CT data and further software image manipulation cannot identify the specific areas of evaluate healing after multiple titanium deformity, much less quantify them with any degree of accuracy, as these remain two-dimensional locking plate fixation. images of a 3D structure. © Schattauer 2016 Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol 5/2016 418 M. D. DeTora, R. J. Boudrieau: Complex deformity correction aided by 3D biomodels the opposite normal limb in order to match the mirrored orientation; in the one case with bilateral deformities, a comparison was made to anatomical specimens from a dog of similar size. Guide wires were used to assist in determining the proper spatial orientation and also the corrections to be made (▶ Appendix I: available online at www.vcot-online.com). Corrective osteo- tomy with plate fixation was performed as a rehearsal procedure (▶ Figure 4). The pre-contoured plates were removed and sterilized in preparation for the definitive surgical procedure. Definitive surgical technique Dogs were positioned in dorsal recumben- cy with the affected limb aseptically pre- pared to the dorsal midline. Perioperative cefazolin sodium (22 mg/kg) was adminis- tered intravenously every two hours throughout the duration of the procedure. A standard lateral approach to the femur Figure 3 Stereolithographic epoxy biomodels Figure 4 Stereolithographic epoxy biomodels of was performed combined with a lateral of the right and left (normal) femurs (limb 5). the right and left (normal) femurs after rehearsal parapatellar arthrotomy (and extended surgery on the right femur (limb 5). The torsional craniomedially and distally to approach the deformity has been corrected with a transverse medial aspect of the tibia if necessary). A plates (January 2007 - June 2012) were re- osteo tomy at (a) and spanned with a 5-hole ALPS tibial tuberosity osteotomy was performed viewed. Signalment, orthopaedic examin- (advanced locking plate system) 10 cranially; the dis- using a sagittal saw, and the tuberosity re- ation, assessment of pelvic limb use as a re- tal valgus and recurvatum have been corrected with flected both proximally and medially in a second biplanar cuneiform (medial and caudal) sult of the obvious angular or torsional de- closing wedge osteotomy at (b). Both osteotomies order to gain full bilateral exposure to the formity observed (varus/valgus, pro-/re- were spanned laterally with a 10-hole ALPS 10 (a stifle joint and femoral condyles. curvatum, femoral torsion), patellar stabil-