WSTS 2013, San Jose’
The Smart and Connected Vehicle and the Internet of Things
Flavio Bonomi Cisco Fellow, Vice President
and Many Others
Advanced Architecture and Research Cisco Systems • An Introduction to the Internet of Things • The Future Infrastructure for the Internet of Things • The Connected Vehicle and Intelligent Transportation • Enabling Technologies • Conclusions
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 2 • An Introduction to the Internet of Things • The Future Infrastructure for the Internet of Things • The Connected Vehicle and Intelligent Transportation • Enabling Technologies • Conclusions
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 3 People
Home Mobile
White Paper at: Things Data http://www.cisco.com/web/about/ ac79/docs/innov/IoE_Economy.p df Business
A good way to go beyond the “naming” confusion: (IoT, M2M, Cyber-Physical Systems, Intelligent Systems, Industrial Internet, Connected Devices, etc., etc.)
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 4 The Evolution of IP Networks Trillion The Evolution of Mobile Networks End Points
Billion From RFID to Billion IP Device Smart Sensors to Mobile Voice, Office & Home Machines to More Internet, SMS Complex Objects Million (e.g., a car) Million PC / Voice Laptop
One TheCommon Evolution (Computing, of Storage and Networking) Infrastructure: IP NetworksThe Ultimate Convergence of Enterprise, Service Provider, and Data Center Technologies “The IoT Computer”
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 5 Source: Cisco ([email protected]) Energy Saving (I2E) Defense
Predictive maintenance
Industrial Automation Intelligent Buildings Enable New Knowledge
Enhance Safety & Security Transportation and Connected Vehicles Agriculture Healthcare
Smart Home
Smart Grid © 2010 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Smart City Cisco Confidential 6 • An Introduction to the Internet of Things • The Future Infrastructure for the Internet of Things • The Connected Vehicle and Intelligent Transportation • Enabling Technologies • Conclusions
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 7 Data Center Cloud Centralized Intelligence: CLOUD Application Hosting, Computing Management Core IP/MPLS Core IP/MPLS, QoS, Multicast, Security, Network Services, Mobile Packet Core
Multi-Service Dumb Network Field Area Network Fabric Edge 3G/4G/LTE/WiFi/ Ethernet/PLC
Embedded Systems Smart Things Network and Sensors smart and less smart The “Swarm” things, vehicles, machines End-Point Intelligence Wired or Wireless
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 8 Data Center Cloud Centralized Application Hosting, Intelligence: CLOUD Management Computing Core IP/MPLS Core IP/MPLS, QoS, Multicast, DiDistributed t ib t d Security, Network Services, Intelligence: Mobile Packet Core CLOUD/FOG Computing
Multi-Service Field Area Network Edge Distributed 3G/4G/LTE/WiFi/ … Intelligence: FOG Ethernet/PLC Computing … …
Embedded Systems Smart Things Network and Sensors smart and less smart The “Swarm” things, vehicles, machines … End-Point … Intelligence
Wired or Wireless … …
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 9 Mine in-depth Data Center Cloud Centralized Intelligence: CLOUD ApplicationHealthCare Hosting, Computing ManagementSecurity Surveillance CoreEnvironmental IP/MPLS Core IP/MPLS,studies QoS, Multicast, DiDistributed t ib t d Intelligence: Security, Network Services, Analyze/act on the Fly Mobile Packet Core CLOUD/FOG Computing User experience Network Performance Intrusion Detection Fraud Detection Sensor Monitoring Multi-ServiceStore FieldEnvironmental Area Network monitoring Surveillance EdgeNetwork Management Distributed Logs Contact Center 3G/4G/LTE/WiFi/ … Security Logs Intelligence: FOG Ethernet/PLC Computing Smart Cities Data … Traffic Information … Ingest Environmental data Network Data Security on Data Embedded Systems Smart Things Network and Sensors Sensor networks smart and less smart Smart grid things, vehicles, machines … End-Point … Smart cities Intelligence SCV & Transportation
Wired or Wireless … …
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 10 DataCloud-Based Center Cloud Centralized (Slowest) Control Intelligence: CLOUD Application Hosting, Computing Management Core IP/MPLS Core IP/MPLS, QoS, Multicast, DiDistributed t ib t d Security, Network Services, Intelligence: Mobile Packet Core CLOUD/FOG Computing Core-Based Control
Multi-Service Field Area Network Edge Distributed 3G/4G/LTE/WiFi/ … Intelligence: FOG Ethernet/PLC Computing … Fog-Based Control …
Embedded Systems SmartEdge-Point, Things Network Swarm, and Sensors Fastest Control smart and less smart things, vehicles, machines … End-Point … Intelligence
Wired or Wireless … …
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 11 FCldFrom Cloud Data Center Cloud Centralized towards Intelligence: CLOUD Application Hosting, Computing ManagementFog/Endpoints
Core Video/Content IP/MPLS Core IP/MPLS, QoS,Software Multicast, Updates DiDistributed t ib t d Security, NetworkControl Services, Policies Intelligence: Mobile PacketVMs/Context/Application Core CLOUD/FOG s Computing
Multi-Service Field Area Network Edge Distributed 3G/4G/LTE/WiFi/ … Intelligence: FOG Ethernet/PLC Computing … Peer-to-Peer … From Endpoints towards (Fog, Endpoints) Fog/Cloud Embedded Systems Smart Things Network Content Measurements and Sensors Status Telematics smart and less smartMobile Data … End-Point … Events things, vehicles, VMs/Contextmachines Intelligence Video Surveillance Applications Wired or Wireless … VMs/Context/Apps …
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 12 Data Center/Cloud Hosting IoT analytics Network Management Applications Core IP/MPLS Core IP/MPLS, Security, QoS, Multicast, Network Services, Mobile Packet Core
Multi-Service Field Area Network Edge Distributed 3G/4G/LTE/WiFi/802.11p Intelligence: FOG Wired Computing
Embedded Systems Smart Things Network and Sensors Low power & bandwidth, smart things, vehicles, machines Millions © 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 13 • An Introduction to the Internet of Things • The Future Infrastructure for the Internet of Things • Intelligent Transportation and the Connected Vehicle • Enabling Technologies • Conclusions
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 14 Intelligent Transportation
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 15 Public Cloud Private (OEM) Cloud Enterprise Cloud
Subscription-based Data Center/Virtual Enterprise Video, Voice, Services Servers Data Services
VNO Policy Enforcement, Flow-based Energy Service Management, DPI Providers (Smart Grid) MobileMobile SP 1 SP 1 Operation
CommunicationsMobileMobile SP 1 SPService 1 Providers, “Fog”
Mobile WiFi Offload DSRC Roadside Consumer Network Electrical Charging Network Wi-Fi Hotspots, Infrastructure Home/Dealership Wi-Fi Charging Stations, 802.11u, 3G/4G 802.11p (V2I) Hotspots, Femtocells Other Services (802.11p ?) Infrastructure
V2I/Upstream Communication (Wi-Fi, 3G/4G, 802.11p, etc.)
Software
V2V Communication (802.11p) End Points
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 16 Home Enterprise WirelessWeb car-to-XOEM network Roadside Grid DSRC 802.11p, WiFi, Low Speed Network WiMAX, Multiple 3G/LTE LIN, Lo-speed CAN Entertainment network X-by-Wire/ MOST, internal WiFi Safety Network Flexray
Wireless in-car network, Smart Phone Bluetooth, Low Power WiFi, RFID IOS Collision Radar
High-speed network Hi-speed CAN
Audio/ VideoElectronic ControlTelematics Unit (ECU) DiagnosticsCentral GatewayADASWheel-Sensor ….
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 17 Multiple buses Automotive specific
Vehicle Control Low speed SW/GW Multiple separate ECUs Difficult to communicate with CAN Flex Ray MOST CAN
Main Engine Chassis Assistance Infotainment Main Body Controller Module Coordinator Controller Controller
Reversing Body Transmission DSC HMI Satellite Camera Satellite 1.2
Chassis Park Assistant Body Energy Telephone Satellite 2 Camera Satellite 2
Chassis Infotainment Body MOST CAN Satellite 3.3 MOST Satellite 1 Satellite 3 Flex Ray Body Satellite 4 LIN
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 18 Instrument Cluster WiFi/Cell/DSRC
Tethered Smartphone BT GPS Sat CAN
Central Gateway Powertrain CAN Bridge
Chassis/Safety CAN Video Cam
LIN
CAN
Body/Control CAN
OBD DLC Connector
• All ECUs networked directly or indirectly via gateways / DLC Connector • Unsecure access into in-vehicle network via DLC • Network security implemented in IVI Headunit
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 19 Instrument Cluster Rear View Mirror Telemetry Module WiFi//BT/Cell/GPS/ Tethered Smartphone / DSRC Owner connectivity
Powertrain GPS Sat
Ethernet Body Control SCV Gateway USB/ WiFi/ BT
Ethernet IVI / Chassis/ Headunit Safety Ethernet
CAN Powertrain Front Rear Video Cams Video Cams
Body Control OBD DLC Connector Ethernet Body Control
Chassis/ Safety • Ethernet-based Central Vehicle Gateway • Mini-switches/hubs aggregate ECUs/Sensors depending on location within vehicle • Potential reduction in wiring harness density and bus splices
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 20 Instrument Cluster Rear View Mirror Telemetry Module WiFi//BT/Cell/GPS/ Tethered Smartphone / DSRC Owner connectivity
Powertrain GPS Sat
Ethernet Body Control SCV Gateway and Central USB/ WiFi/ BT ECU
Ethernet IVI / Chassis/ Headunit Safety Ethernet
CAN Powertrain Front Rear Video Cams Video Cams
Body Control OBD DLC Connector Ethernet Body Control
Chassis/ Safety • Ethernet-based Central Vehicle Gateway • Mini-switches/hubs aggregate ECUs/Sensors depending on location within vehicle • Potential reduction in wiring harness density and bus splices
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 21 Instrument Cluster Rear View Mirror Telemetry Module WiFi//BT/Cell/GPS/ Tethered Smartphone / DSRC Owner connectivity
Powertrain GPS Sat SCV Gateway and Central Deteraministic SCV GatewayData Centerand Central Body Control Ethernet Data Center USB/ WiFi/ BT
Deterministic IVI / Chassis/ Ethernet Headunit Safety Detaerministic Ethernet
CAN Powertrain Front Rear Video Cams Video Cams
Body Control OBD DLC Connector Body Control
Chassis/ Safety
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 22 • An Introduction to the Internet of Things • The Future Infrastructure for the Internet of Things • The Connected Vehicle and Intelligent Transportation • Enabling Technologies • Conclusions
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 23 • Security • Fog computing • Seamless, optimized connectivity, mobility, LISP • Ad hoc networking for mobility • Deterministic networking (wired and wireless) • ….....
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 24 • Security • Fog computing • Seamless, optimized connectivity, mobility, LISP • Ad hoc networking for mobility • Deterministic networking (wired and wireless) • ….....
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 25 Highly secure communication from car to wider network Encryption Identity Management Wide range of VPN technologies Private Cloud Secure tunnels to OEM, partners, 3rd Party App third party applications providers Provider Partner Cloud Operation Smart Center Smart Center Comprehensive secure In-vehicle VPN Aggregation protection Strong firewall VPN Tunnels Intrusion Prevention Anti-virus/malware protection V2I/Road-side V2V On-demand secure connectivity vehicle-to-vehicle, vehicle-to- infrastructure
Infrastructure 802.11p 802.11p Easy to deploy and manage
Firewall Centralized identity & policy management Authentication, authorization,
Vehicle accounting
© 2010 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Cisco Confidential 26 • Security • Fog computing • Seamless, optimized connectivity, mobility, LISP • Ad hoc networking for mobility • Deterministic networking (wired and wireless) • ….....
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 27 . Maybe just another funny name for “Edge of the Network Computing” …..
• Systematic, highly virtualized, secure, and network-integrated computing and storage located between End-points and Clouds, supporting many of the same techniques/approaches applied to Cloud Computing: Virtualization, multi-tenancy, IaaS, PaaS, SaaS, automation, ….
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 28 Video Servers
IP Network
Wireless Fog Edge Device Mobile Server Clients
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 29 • Roadside multi-purpose equipment based on convergence of routing, computing and wireless technologies • Distributed, multi-tenancy computing model
• Supporting multiple wireless technologies • Located with other traffic control equipment • Purpose - Managed Service Regulate traffic (Traffic Router – cars, IP packets, same) Collect tolls taxes (per transaction fee collection) E-Commerce support Content delivery Traffic sensor management (e.g., Sensys)
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 30 • Security • Fog computing • Seamless, optimized connectivity, mobility, LISP • Ad hoc networking for mobility • Deterministic networking (wired and wireless) • ….....
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 31 Multiple Wireless WAN interfaces 3G/4G(LTE), WiFi Highly Scalable Secure Mobility Public/Private Cloud Industry leading architectures: LISP, PFR
Operation Home Agent Mobile IPv6, NEtwork MObility (NEMO)
Single-IP reachability Carrier Network Public Network Home Network Seamless User Experience Wireless SP Dealers / Antenna Parking / SA,PA Non-stop 99.99% reliable • Cellular 3G/4G / Energy Station In-Home • Wi-Fi: HotSpot 2.0 Devices connection management • Wi-Fi: HotSpot 2.0 Application-aware, flow-based Infrastructure connectivity Seamless Handover: 3G -> wifi
3G/4G Session persistency Vehicle Optimized Communications
© 2010 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Over 3G/4G, WiFi, …Cisco Confidential 32 • LISP (Location Identity Separation Protocol with IP-in-IP) was originally designed as a scalable routing architecture for the Internet • It turns out that LISP offers native support for: Mobility with route optimization, Multi-homing, Dual Stack (IPv4, IPv6) Network Mobility • Clear separation between control and data plane is well suited for over-the-top deployments Enabling an ecosystem of LISP Service providers to deploy global mobility applications such as the Connected Vehicle
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 33 LISPmob.org
Map‐ Map‐ Server Resolver
LISP Mapping Service Providers
Data LISP Center Data Path LISP Unaware Infrastructure Services
3G I’m I’m @ WiFi @ 3G WiFi
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 34 LISP Mapping Data Center System (Cloud) + L3 Fabric Fog Controller Move App
App App to Fog
OS OS IP Network
Fog
Update GeoLocation
Data Path Control Path © 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 35 LISP Mapping Data Center System (Cloud) + L3 Fabric FogVideoApp Controller Access Policy: Go to Use vWAAS Viideo App App vWAAS first, Service on Fog OS OS then VideoApp IP Network
VideoApp Location?Fog
VideoApp Location? vWAAS
Data Path Control Path © 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 36 • Security • Fog computing • Seamless, optimized connectivity, mobility, LISP • Ad hoc networking for mobility • Deterministic networking (wired and wireless) • ….....
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 37 • Enabling more “natural” ways of collaborating and socializing • Communications for highly mobile exchanges • Critical for a large set of real life applications • Fundamental for transportation • Enabling collaboration when not core connectivity is available • Exploiting “opportunities” to communicate (Delay Tolerance) • Tolerating high loss situations (Disruption Tolerance)
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 38 • Key technology to provide non-line-of-sight communication in next generation advanced driver assist systems
• DSRC is the global industry standard for latency critical V2V/ V2I communication • eCall + DSRC are key triggers for broader CV deployment • Cisco is investing in DSRC Communications Joint Projects with Cohda Wireless Working with University of Porto on Taxi Deployment
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 39 • Need to Support Multiple Modes
End-to-end
Proxy-ed
Multi-Hop
Delay Tolerant
Disruption Tolerant
• Working with:
U. Porto and Veniam
ITTC/UPC Barcelona
UCLA
WiFi Rail/McLaren
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 40 . Take Advantage of Node Mobility: e.g., Store-Carry-and-Forward (DTN) – Store a message, carry it until an appropriate communication opportunity arises, forward it to a new node 1 12 13 D S 14
2 16 11 15 3 7 . Work and Cisco Collaboration with UCLA (Prof. Mario Gerla, Kevin 8 Lee, Giovanni Pau) 5 10 – VANET Research, Hybrid Routing 4 Models with Navigation Assistance . Work and Cisco Collaboration with 9 USC (Prof. Costas Psounis) 6 © 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 41 41 UAVs Manned Aircraft Video Cameras
SATCOM
Mobile Devices
The Internet
Biometric Scanners Unmanned Ground Radio Over IP Robots Sensor Network Gateways
Copyright 2011 Persistent Systems, LLC Proprietary All Rights Reserved
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 42 Disaster Response Network Large WRoIP Network with nodes in: o NYC & at FDNY Fire Department Operation Center in Brooklyn o State of Connecticut Governors Office and Emergency Operations Center Multiple mobile vehicle nodes with 4G Backhaul o Boston at USCG Stations and Logan International Airport Backhaul via 4G
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 43 • Security • Fog computing • Seamless, optimized connectivity, mobility, LISP • Ad hoc networking for mobility • Deterministic networking (wired and wireless) • ….....
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 44 • Required in Industrial Automation, System Control, Automotive, Smart Grid, Robotics, Building Automation, etc. • Key Elements: (Both wired and wireless) Network Ingress shaping Network synchronization Timely transmission Centralized scheduling (NP-complete optimization problem) • Wired: Time Triggered Ethernet • Wireless: Over 802.15.4 for low power low rate (4Hz), over WIFI (802.11ac) for higher rate (100Hz)
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 45 Future Relevant Innovations to Standard Networks Safety-Critical TIME-SYNCHRONIZED Closed-Loop 10 Gb/s, Low Jitter, Precise Scheduling, Control, Wired Loss-less Convergence, Multi-path switching
Motion REAL TIME Wireless Gb/s, IEEE 1588 PTP, 802.11n, Low-latency, CleanAir, Very Fast Convergence (ms) Input/Output
MANAGED 10/100Mbs, 802.11 a/b/g, QoS,
INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS INDUSTRIAL RSTP Fast Convergence (s), IGMP, Information Full-Duplex, Wirelss Mesh
UNMANAGED 10Mb/s, Half-Duplex, slow convergence
DETERMINISM
“Non-Deterministic” “More Deterministic” “Very Deterministic” “Strictly Deterministic”
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 46 TTEthernet
40 msec 40 msec 40 msec
TT1 TT2 RC RC BE TT1 BE RC TT2 BE TT1 RC BE RC TT2 TT1 BE BE RC RC TT1
30 msec 30 msec 30 msec 30 msec TIME
Longest Communication Cycle in this Example: LCM(30,40) = 120msec
Source: TTTech
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 47 • Value Prop IPv6 for mission-critical Applications Industrial, Avionics, Telematics, spatial C&C Cisco business in wired and wireless backbone Converged Campus / Enterprise (adding IoE) • Objectives IETF standards Trigger open source implementation Build Ecosystem • Status: IETF WG creation starting • ¼ people initially
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 48 Plant Control Network Enterprise
Deterministic Wi-Fi or Ethernet (RPL Domain or IPv6 ND) 6TSCH
6TSCH
- Wi-Fi Border Router
- WiFi/6LoWPAN RPL -WiFiHost Backbone Router - 6LoWPAN Host • Plant Firewall - WiHart Backbone - WiHart Host • Wireless Lan Router Controller - ISA100 Host • Integrated Plant Security - ISA100 Backbone © 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 49 & Identity services Router • An Introduction to the Internet of Things • The Future Infrastructure and the Huge Role for Wireless Communications!! • Enabling Technologies and Relevant Case Studies • Conclusions
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 50 • A time of exciting developments in Networking and beyond • We need strong Research Collaborations: WE NEED YOU!!! • Profound impact at human, social, and environmental levels • Virtuous cycle between new applications, services, and innovative platforms
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 51 • More Traditional Industry-University Focused Research Initiatives • Multi-Way Research Partnerships are Key Networking Industry-Car OEMs-Universities Networking Industry-Silicon Providers-Service Providers Content Providers-OEMs University-Industry (e.g., GSRC, Clean Slate, RadLab) • Government Involvement NSF – GENI DOT - DOE Leveraging of Defense Technologies
© 2011 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Attorney-Client Privileged Cisco Confidential 52 Thank you.