2013 Fall Board Book
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Journal of Architectural Education 2013 Fall Board Meeting PennDesign, Philadelphia, PA Board Book Table of Contents General Information . 1 Meeting Schedule . 2 Meeting Agenda . 3 Reports Executive Editor . 4 Associate Editor, Design . 6 Associate Editor, Reviews . 8 Associate Editor, Theme . 9 Additional Information 01 Theme Proposals 02 “Best of” Contributions 03 Board Guide General Information Welcome to the Journal of Architectural Education 2014 Fall Editorial Board Meeting. We will be meeting at the Fisher Fine Arts Library (aka the Furness Library), Rm 306 and the conference room on the third floor of Myerson Hall. The buildings sit next to one another. The campus is accessible by subway. The closest stop is the 34th St. stop on the Market- Frankford line. Internet access will be available during meetings. If you are unable to attend the meeting, a speakerphone will be provided if you are able to call in to participate. While in Philadelphia, if you need to contact Marc Neveu, my mobile phone number is: 617-899-6965 1 Meeting Schedule Friday, October 04 Location 1:00 – 3:00 Meeting with Taylor & Francis 325 Chestnut St. Suite 800 Crane, Kulper, Mitchell, Monti, Neveu, Sabatino, Tilder, Vonier 4:00 – 6:00 PhD Seminar Penn Design Archives Crane, Kulper, Monti, Neveu, Sabatino, Trubiano Saturday, October 05 9:00 – 12:00 Design Committee Meeting Furness Building, 306 Brown, de Monchaux, Kulper, La, Rupnik, Sprecher, Theodore 1:00 – 4:30 General Board Meeting 3rd Floor Meyerson All members Conference Room Sunday, October 06 9:00 – 12:00 General Board Meeting Furness Building, 306 All members 2 General Board Meeting Agenda Saturday, October 05 Action Call to Order Neveu 1:00 pm Executive Editor Report Neveu 1:10 Associate Editor, Theme Report Crane 1:30 Associate Editor, Design Report Kulper 1:45 Associate Editor, Reviews Report Sabatino 2:00 JAE Re-Design Report, discussion Vonier 2:15 Break 2:45 Best Article (SoD, DaS), discussion 3:00 Best Article vote Theme, discussion 3:45 Theme vote Adjournment 4:30 Sunday, October 06 Action Call to Order Neveu 9:00 am What should the JAE look like in 2018? 9:05 How can the JAE better utilize the web? 10:00 Break 10:45 JAE session at ACSA National 2014, discussion Neveu 11:00 Session decision Board Member nomination, discussion Neveu 11:30 Fall 2014 Editorial Board Meeting, discussion Neveu 11:45 Site decision Adjournment 12:00 3 Executive Editor: Report Marc J Neveu My term as Executive Editor began on 01 July 2013. At that time I appointed Amy Kulper as Associate Editor, Design, Michelangelo Sabatino as Associate Editor, Reviews, and Sheila Crane as Associate Editor for the 68:1 issue. Since that time I have worked with the Associate Editors to develop issue 68:1, familiarized myself with the ScholarOne system, worked with Pascale Vonier to develop the JAE website, attended the August 2013 ACSA Board Meeting in Los Angeles. I am in the process of developing a Board Guide and an Author Guide. JAE 67:2 Graham Livesey and the entire production team delivered the issue on schedule. The issue is printed and its shipment is imminent. Upon completion of production, Graham Livesey stepped down as Interim Executive Editor as well as the Editorial Board. JAE 68:1 We have received a very good response to the 68:1 theme (design+) and over seventy essays have either been reviewed or are in process. Two Design as Scholarship essays were shifted to 68:1 from 67:2 due to page count. Four Opinion pieces have been solicited from Kenny Cupers, Renèe Cheng, Jeremy Till and Mass Design. Fifteen reviews have been commissioned. Manuscripts Received 01 April to 01 October 2013 Manuscript Type Original Revised Total Design as Scholarship 24 1 25 Opinion 2 0 2 Scholarship of Design 45 3 48 Total 71 4 75 Manuscripts Received YTD Manuscript Type Original Revised Total Design as Scholarship 37 1 38 Opinion 3 0 3 Review 1 0 1 Scholarship of Design 69 3 72 Total 110 4 114 Manuscripts Received This Month Manuscript Type Original Revised Total Design as Scholarship 1 0 1 Scholarship of Design 6 0 6 Total 7 0 7 4 Fall Board Meeting Our Fall 2014 Editorial Board meeting will take place from 04-06 October. Franca Trubiano has coordinated the event at PennDesign. This meeting will welcome new board members: Franca Trubiano, Georgeen Theodore, and Ivan Rupnik. Grace La and Michelangelo Sabatino have been appointed for an additional term. A decision regarding the “best-of” articles will be submitted to ACSA following the meeting for both Design as Scholarship and Scholarship of Design submissions. A call for theme proposals was issued in August. The response was robust. Forty proposals were received. The theme for 68:2 will be chosen at the Fall Board Meeting. Project Projects was hired to develop a new design for the JAE to include a new format, cover design, logo, and templates (including, but not limited to, fonts, margins, page numbering, titling, image sizing, etc.). A committee was struck by Graham Livesey in Spring 2013 to include Mason White, Nicholas de Monchaux, and Pascale Vonier to select a designer. I replaced Graham Livesey at the end of August once discussions began with Project Projects. Layouts will be presented to the Editorial Board at the Fall Meeting. Participation in the 2014 ACSA National meeting in Miami will be discussed. Potential new Board Members will be discussed. A list of potential new members will be forwarded to ACSA for nomination prior to he 2014 ACSA National meeting in Miami. Three Committees will be established (Design, Theme, Reviews) to work with the Associate Editors. Taylor & Francis A production meeting will be held with Taylor & Francis to clarify and streamline the production workflow. The new design will be presented to Taylor & Francis. Online Reviews As part of the initiative to develop web content, the first online reviews will go live in October. I anticipate more content in the future. Board Guide An Editorial Board Guide is in process. The intention of the Board Guide is to outline policies and procedures, clearly articulate Board Member expectations, and make participation on the board more accessible. It is intended that the guide will be online by the ACSA National Meeting in Miami in 2014. A working document was sent to the entire Editorial Board. Author Guide An Author Guide is in process. The intention of the Author Guide is to articulate expectations and the process for submission to the JAE. To streamline production, the guide will include a style guide, templates and image permission form. It is intended that the guide will be online prior to the production of issue 68:2. 5 Associate Editor, Design: Report Amy Kulper The provocative call written by the theme editors produced a robust response. Overall, we received twenty-three submissions, and one additional submission (which seemed neither to fit the Scholarship of Design category, nor the Design as Scholarship category). Of the Twenty-three, just three submissions were for the new Pre- Fabrications column, so part of the discussion of the Design Committee in this meeting will be devoted to catalyzing a more fulsome response to this call. On the positive side, numerous inquiries about the Pre-Fabrications call (about ten in all) were received the week after the posted due date, and I am keeping a list of these contacts to whom I will send a reminder when we issue our next call. I will also solicit names of possible future contributors from the board, and write follow-up emails encouraging new submissions. The Design Committee is currently comprised of six members of the board, returning members Grace La, Marshall Brown, Nicholas de Monchaux, and Aaron Sprecher, and new members Georgeen Theodor and Ivan Rupnik whom we are welcoming at this meeting. The Design Committee was divided into two groups, and each group reviewed ten submissions. For the peer review of the Pre-Fabrications submissions, three groups of two Design Committee Members each reviewed one manuscript. Kevin Mitchell created a dropbox folder for us, ensuring that even though the members of the committee were only reviewing ten submissions, they would have an overall view of the quality of the competition. With respect to the Pre-Fabrications submissions, these were reviewed using the Design as Scholarship review form, but I will poll the committee members at this meeting to see whether or not they thought this form was adequate for the review of material that is differently formatted. As the Design Committee deliberations are conducted jury-style at the meetings, there are no statistics available at the time of this report for the number of submissions accepted for the issue. We do, however, have two submissions accepted for publication in issue 67:2 but held over because the issue significantly overran its page count – both of these submissions fit the Design+ theme well. In conversation with Marc and Sheila, it was decided that because the issue is devoted to design, we might feature a larger number of design submissions, if the committee thinks that there are ample submissions of sufficiently high quality. In keeping with the theme of the Design+ call, the committee decided at our last meeting to activate the Design Frameworks most closely aligned with the theme, and so we selected Visible Data: Information Ecologies and Exhibitionists: Curators, Collectors, and Connoisseurs. Nicholas de Moncahux took the lead in the Visible Data category, and invited Sha Hwang of Trulia, and Shawn Allen of Stamen to act as Guest Curators. Aaron Sprecher led the Exhibitionists charge, inviting Hans Ibeling (independent scholar) and Frabrizio Gallanti of the CCA to act as Guest Curators.