New Late Cretaceous Leaf Locality from Lower Kirtland Shale Member, Bisti
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
NewLate Cretaceous leaf locality from lower Kirtland Shalemember, Bisti area, San Juan Basin, New Mexico byCoteman R. Robison,U.S. Bureau ol LandManagement, Albuquerque,andAdrian Hunf, ResearchAssistant, and Donald L. Wolberg,Paleontologist, New Mexico Bureau of Minesand Mineral Resources This preliminary report represents the first sub- stantial paleobotanic study of new Fruitland or Kirt- plant yrs. land fossils in more than 65 The florule is Rt3W Rl2W Rllw Rlow Rgw the most diverse one ever found in either the Fruir land or Kirtland, and it adds substantially to the list of taxa known from these formations. The Fruitland and Kirtland floras need more paleobotanic study; cooperation from the coal companies in the area will make this possible. More precise stratigraphic delin- eation of floras is needed in differentiatine the two formations. The area in and around Hunter Wash. near the site of the Bisti Trading Post, in west- central San Juan Basin, has been actively in- vestigated by geologists and paleontologists for almost 70 yrs (for example, Bauer, l9l7; Bauer and Reeside, 1921; Gilmore, l9l7; Clemons, 1973; Hutchinson, 1981). Within the immediate region, rocks of the Lewis Shale (Late Cretaceous), Pictured Cliffs Sandstone, Fruitland Formation, and Kirtland Shale are exposed (table l). The Bisti-Fruitland coal field, upon which this area lies, is estimated to contain 1.870 million metric tons of subbitu- minous. low-sulfur coal beneath less than 250 FIGURE 1-Gnorocrcet- MApoF AREArN vrcrNrry oF LEAFLocALITY. Also shown is Fossil Forest, a fossilifer- ft of overburden and is the greatest undevel- ous area currently being studied by the authors and others. Klmv, Lewis Shale; Kpc, Pictured Cliffs Sand- Shale; Kkl, lower shale member of Kirtland Shale; Kkf, oped reserve in the San Juan Basin (Sho- ston€; Kf, Fruitland Formation; Kk, Kirtland Farmington Sandstone Member of Kirtland Shale; TKoa, Ojo.Alamo Sandstone; Tn, Nacimiento Forma- maker, l97l). To better understand the strati- tion; Tsj, San JoseFormation. graphic record and depositional environments of the rocks containing these resources, de- tailed field investigations were made near the two large continentalareas. The San Juan member overlain by the Farmington Sand- old Bisti Trading Post (Fig. l). These involved Basinlay on the westernmargin of the seaway stone Member in turn overlain by the upper stratigraphic sedimentologic and paleontolog- and was intermittently inundated by the ad- shalemember (Bauer, l9l7; Reeside,1924). ical studies (Hunt and others, 1981). During vancesand retreatsof the sea (Fassettand The contact betweenthe lower shale member the course of these investigations a new leaf Hinds,l97l). and the Fruitland Formation is imprecise locality was found in the Fruitland-Kirtland The Pictured Cliffs Sandstonerepresents although many boundaries have been sug- sequence. delta-frontand barrierbeach deposits (Erpen- gested(Fassett and Hinds, 1971,p. l9). Lind- beck, 1979;Cumella, l98l) of the final retreat say and others (1981) suggest,rightly in our TABLE l-Uppen Cnpracrous (CavpaNraN ro of the Campanianseaway from the region. view, the presenceof a transition zone be- MeestntcHtreN)srRATtcRApHtc uNtrs IN AREA oF Coal depositsof varyingthickness and lateral tweenthe uppermostFruitland and lower Kirt- HuNrpnWasn. extent and other organic-rich sedimentswere land Shale. The leaf locality reported here is Iaid down in a variety of delta-plainand back- 8.2 m (27.1ft) abovethe highestcoal contact Stratigraphicunit Thickness barrier environments(Erpenbeck, 1979). The of O'Sullivan and others(1972) and Scott and Ojo Alamo Sandstone 20 rn upper portions of the Fruitland Formation others(1979) and 5.1 m (16.8ft) belowthe top Naashoibito Member 20m and the overlying Kirtland Shale lack well- of a red-browntabular sandstone, the bound- Upper shale member 30m nonmarine developedcoal depositsthat are presentin the ary of Dane (1936) and Hutchison (1981). Kirtland Shale lower Fruitland. Preliminary analyses of Pending more precise delineation of the Farmington Sandstone Fruitland and Kirtland brackish and fresh- boundarythis localityis assignedto the lower Member 120m watermolluscan faunas indicate a progressive shalemember of theKirtland Shale. Lower shale rnember 250m trend toward fresh-waterenvironments. This Locelrrv DEScRrprroN-The locality oc- Fruitland Formation 50m in sec.32, T. 24N., R. l3 Pictured Cliffs Sandstone 25 m final marine trendimplies increasing distance from the Pic- curs theSW%NE% Lewis Shale 20m regressionfrom turedCliffs shoreline(Hartman, l98l). W. (Fig. l) within a measuredsection of 19.37 SanJuan Basin Both the Fruitland and Kirtland shalewere m (63.9 ft) of channelsandstones and over- namedby Max Bauer in 1916for exposures bank depositsconsisting of carbonaceousand along the San Juan River in northwestSan noncarbonaceousmudstones and siltstones Juan County, New Mexico. Lindsay and (appendixA; Fig. 2). The localityis just below Geologic background others(1981) suggested that theKirtland Shale the shoulder of a hill and has been protected The Upper Cretaceousrocks of the Western be renamedthe Kirtland Formation as Kirt- from weathering by an overlying resistant Interior were depositedin or near an epeiric land rocks are predominantly siltstonesand siderite concretion. Although the mudstones seathat extendedfrom the Gull of Mexico to not shales.The Fruitland Formationis domi- are highly weatheredwhere not coveredby the the Arctic Ocean.This seaway,approximately nantly composedof interbeddedcoals, sand- concretion,the deposit seemsto be a lens- 3,000 mi in length and 1,000 mi in width, stones,and shales.Three members of theKirt- shapedpocket that extendslaterally about 3.5 divided the North American landmassinto land Shale are recognized:the lower shale m (l 1.6ft). August1982 New Mexico Geology TABLE 2-CoMpostrroN oF FLoRA. ooo o20 lg Filicophyta (ferns) or9 dq/b Polypodiaceae or8 ogg Asplenium sp. ot7 Woodwardio 2 crenata 50 cm 016 k SANDSTONE Salviniaceae ( 20 inches) 5 gg GRAYGREEN Salvinia sp. Ot ss y YELLOW Coniferophyta (conifers) ol4 lq SHALE,/MUDSTONE or3 q OOO Taxodiaceae K KHAKI Sequoia cuneata COAL/HUMATE c CREAM ot2 99 Anthophyta (fl owering plants) CA CREAMGRAY Monocotyledonae o?9 lg BRECCIA y9 YELLOWGRAY Cyperaceae 028 lg orl l9 gy GREENYELLOW Cyperacties sp. o27 k CARBONACEOUS b BLACK Dicotyledonae SHALE oro lg w WHITE Salicaceae o26 CONCRETION r RED Salix lancensis oo9 l9 S. sp. A o ORANGE oo8 d9/gg s9 br BROWN S. sp. B ooo oo7 s9 SILTSTONE Juglandaceae 99 LEAVES oo6 rg d DARK o05 Caryaantiquorum 9S 9S CLINKER I LIGHT Fagaceae oo4 dg v VERY D ry hy op I lu m subfa I ca t u m 000 coNcRETtoN Moraceae lg oo3 k Ficus baueri? o02 s F. crossii o?l ool F. planicostata FIGURE Platanaceae 2-Dllcnaruvarrc REpRESENTATToNoF MAcRosrRATrcRApHrc sEcrroN rN wHrcH LEAF LocAl-rry LIES. Platanus raynoldsii Menispermaceae Menispermites belli Fruitland and Kirtland floras are inseparable. still to be found in the Fruitland Formation Magnoliaceae The newlocality described below represents by (Tidwell and others, l98l). Three speciesof Magnolia corddolia far the largest sample of a local flora yet figs (Family Moraceae)occur in the florule: Lauraceae described. Ficus vaueri, F. crossii, and F. planicostata. Laurophyllum coloradensis Ficus planicostata (figs.7 and 8) is by far the L. wardiana Floral composition L. salicifolium most frequentlyencountered species in the col- Leguminosae The plant taxa identifiedare listedin table Iection, with specimensranging in size from Leguminosites 2. Only a few ferns occur in Fruitland-Kirt- 1.5x 2.5 cm (.6 x I .0 inches)to 6.2 x 9.3 cm Rhamnaceae land floras(Tidwell and others,l98l), and the (2.5 x 3.7 inches).Menispermites belli (fig. 9) Rhamnus sp. florule discussedhere containsonly three gen- is the only member of the moonseedfamily Zizyphus sp. era: Asplenium, Woodwardia, and Salvinia. (Menispermaceae)in the florule. The laurela Vitaceae Salvinia (plate 1, fig. 1; all further references (Fauraceae)are represented,by Laurophyllum Cissus marginata to plate figures will be made by the notation coloradensis,L. wardiana (fig. Dilleniaceae l0), and L. fig. and the number)is interestingbecause it is (fig. Dillenites cleburni salicifolium l1). Of the family Dilleni- Myrtaceae an aquatic, floating fern that requires open aceae,only Dillenites cleburni (fig. l2) is pre- Myrtophyllum toneyi water. sent.The buckthorn family (Rhamnaceaeltras Taxonomic Position Uncertain The only conifer in the florule is Sequoia one specieseach from the genera(Rhamnus\ Carpites baueri cuneata,which bears short, Iancelike leaves on and Zizyphusin the florule, but the exactspe- C. Iancensis young branchesand scalelikeleaves on older ciesaffinity for the specimensis yet to be de- c. sp. branches.Sequoio cuneata is thoughtto have termined. The remaining dicot families in the Ficus? trineruis been a dominant element of late Cretaceous florule are eachrepresented by a singlespecies Rhamnusminutus peat swampsin the Rocky Mountain region and include: Carya antiquorum unidentifiedinfl uorescence of the Jug- (Parker,1976). This florule is severelyimpov- landaceae (walnut family), Platanus ray- erishedin conifers,which represent only 3.20/o noldsii of the Platanaceae(sycamore family), of the assemblageas opposed to 12.3V0for the Magnolia cordifolia of the Magnoliaceae, Fossil leavesare preservedin light-brown entireFruitland-Kirtland flora (table3). Leguminositessp. of the Leguminosae(pea compressionsthat vary in quality of preserva- The anthophyta(angiosperms