On the Conservation of the Cultural Heritage in the Kenyan Coast
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE IMPACT OF TOURISM ON THE CONSERVATION OF THE CULTURAL HERITAGE IN THE KENYAN COAST BY PHILEMON OCHIENG’ NYAMANGA - * • > University ol NAIROBI Library "X0546368 2 A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE INSTITUTE OF ANTHROPOLOGY, GENDER AND AFRICAN STUDIES IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS IN ANTHROPOLOGY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF NAIROBI NOVEMBER 2008 DECLARATION This thesis is my original work. It has not been presented for a Degree in any other University. ;o§ Philemon Ochieng’ Nyamanga This thesis has been submitted with my approval as a university supervisor D ate..... J . l U ■ — • C*- imiyu Wandibba DEDICATION This work is dedicated to all heritage lovers and caregivers in memory of my late parents, whose inspiration, care and love motivated my earnest quest for knowledge and committed service to society. It is also dedicated to my beloved daughter. Leticia Anvango TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Tables----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- v List of Figures----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------v List of P la tes---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- vi Abbreviations/Acronvms----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- vii Acknowledgements-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------viii Abstract------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ix Chapter One: Background to the Study-----------------------------------------------------l 1.1 Introduction--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 1.2 Problem Statement----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3 1.3. Study Objectives--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5 1.3.1 General Objective--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5 1.3.2 Specific Objectives------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 5 1.4 Rationale of the Study-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5 1.5 Scope and Limitations-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------6 C hapter Two: Literature Review---------------------------------------------------------------7 2.1 Introduction--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ” 2.2 Tourism, Cultural Heritage and Conservation--------------------------------------------------------- ~ 2.2.1 Cultural Attractions--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7 2.2.2 General Effects of Tourism on the Heritage--------------------------------------------------------------9 2.2.3 Tourism and Cultural Change----------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10 2.2.4 Intercultural Communication and Commoditization of Culture---------------------------------12 2.2.5 Conservation Approaches to Tourism Induced Impacts on the Heritage-------------------- 15 2.2.6 Theories of Heritage Tourism------------------------------------------------------------------------------ *8 i 2.3 Conceptual Framework and Its relevance-------------------------------------------------------------18 2.4 Study Hypotheses---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------20 2.5 Conceptualisation of Key Variables-------------------------------------------------------------------- 20 C hapter Three: Methodology---------------------------------------------------------------22 3.1 Introduction-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------22 3.2 Research S ite----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------22 3.2.1 Location--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 22 3.2.2 Topography and Drainage----------------------------------------------------------------------------------22 3.2.3 Climate and Economy--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 23 3.2.4 Cultural Heritage---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 24 3.2.5 Infrastructure---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------25 3.3 Study Design-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------26 3.4 Study Population and Unit of Analysis----------------------------------------------------------------- 26 3.5 Sample Population and Sampling Procedure-------------------------------------------------------- 26 3.6 Data Collection Methods------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 27 3.6.1 Secondary Data-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------27 3.6.2 Key Informant Interviews---------------------------------------------------------------------------------27 3.6.3 Direct O bservation-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------27 3.7 Methods of Data Analysis----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 28 3.8 Field Challenges and Solutions--------------------------------------------------------------------------28 3.9 Ethical Considerations-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 28 Chapter Four: Tourism and the Conservation of the Cultural Heritage---------------------------29 4.1 Introduction--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 29 4.2 Informant Demographics--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 29 4.3 Tourism and the Kenya Coastal Heritage---------------------------------------------------------------- n 4.3.1 Tourists, Coastal Attractions and Facilities------------------------------------------------------------- 30 4.3.2 Coastal Communities and Tourism------------------------------------------------------------------------ 32 4.4 Tourism and the Conservation of Coastal Cultural Heritage---------------------------------------36 4.4.1 Tourism and the Built Heritage------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 36 4.4.2 Tourism and the Mijikenda Heritage---------------------------------------------------------------------- 39 4.4.3 Tourism and the Movable Cultural Items-----------------------------------------------------------------43 4.5 The Physical and Socio-Cultural Impacts of Tourism-------------------------------------------------45 4.5.1 .Major Physical Impacts of Tourism----------------------------------------------------------------------- 47 4.5.1.1 Positive Physical Impacts------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 47 4.5.1.2 Negative Physical Impacts------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 47 4.5.2 Major Socio-Cultural Impacts o f Tourism------------------------------------------------------------- 48 4.5.2.1 Positive Socio-Cultural Impacts----------------------------------------------------------------------------48 4.5.2.2 Negative Socio-Cultural Impacts---------------------------------------------------------------------------49 4.6. Tourism, Graffiti and Conservation--------------------------------------------------------------------------50 4.6.1 Meaning and Importance of Graffiti---------------------------------------------------------------------- 50 4.6.2 Graffiti and Conservation-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 51 4.7 Effects of Tourism on Heritage Conservation------------------------------------------------------------ 53 4.7.1 Tourism’s Contributions to Conservation--------------------------------------------------------------53 4.7.2 Responding to Impacts: Boosting Tourism’s Positive Returns----------------------------------54 4.7.3 Responding to Impacts: Deterring Tourism’s Negative Returns-------------------------------54 Chapter Five: Economic Impacts o f Tourism -----------------------------------------------------------------56 5.1 Introduction----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5.2 General Economic Effects---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ^6 5.2.1 Positive Economic Effects------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5.2.2 Negative Economic Effects------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ in 5.3. Tourism and Development------------------------------------------------------------------------------------60 Chapter Six: Summary and Conclusions----------------------------------------------------------------------- 68 6.1 Introduction---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------68