Heresa Morrow: RTÉ One TV: the Late Late Show: 8Th Jan 2016…………………………….81
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Broadcasting Authority of Ireland Broadcasting Complaint Decisions September 2016 Broadcasting Complaint Decisions Contents BAI Complaints Handling Process Page 4 Upheld by the BAI Compliance Committee 26/16 - Mr. Francis Clauson: TV3: ‘The Power to Power Ourselves’ (Advert): 10th Jan 2016………………5 27/16 - Mr. Francis Clauson: RTÉ One TV: ‘The Power to Power Ourselves’ (Advert): 16th Jan 2016….…9 29/16 - Intro Matchmaking: Sunshine 106.8: Two’s Company (Advert):16th Feb 2016…………….………13 Rejected by the BAI Compliance Committee 7/16 - Mr. Brendan Burgess: RTÉ One TV: Ireland’s Great Wealth Divide: 21st Sept 2015……………….16 13/16 - Mr. Martin Hawkes: RTÉ One TV: Prime Time: 3rd Dec 2015……………………………………….23 15/16 - An Taisce: RTÉ One TV: Prime Time: 3rd Dec 2015………………………………………………….28 30/16 - Mr. Pawel Rydzewski: RTÉ One TV: The Late Late Show: 22nd Jan 2016…………………………38 32/16 - Mr Séamus Enright: TV3: TV3 Leaders’ Debate: 11th Feb 2016………………………………….…41 35/16 - Mr. John Flynn: RTÉ One TV: The Late Late Show: 19th Feb 2016…………………………………45 37/16 - Mr. Enda Fanning: RTÉ One TV: The Late Late Show: 19th Feb 2016……………………………48 Rejected by the Executive Complaints Forum 8-10/16 - Mr. Brendan O’ Regan: Newstalk: The Pat Kenny Show: 2nd – 4th Dec 2015……………………52 19/16 - Ms. Patricia Kearney: RTÉ Radio 1: When Dave Met Bob: 29th Dec 2015…………………………58 21/16 – Ms. Mary Jo Gilligan: RTÉ Radio 1: The Ray D’Arcy Show: 14th Nov 2015………………………61 22/16 - Mr. Brendan O’ Regan: Newstalk: Lunchtime: 30th Nov 2015…………………………………….…64 23/16 - Mr. Brendan O’ Regan: Newstalk: The Pat Kenny Show: 1st Dec 2015………………………….…64 25/16 - Mr. Robert Thompson: RTÉ One TV: The Late Late Show: 30th Oct 2015…………………………69 28/16 - Mr. David Hegarty: RTÉ Radio 1: Today with Seán O’ Rourke: 21st Dec 2015…………………….72 33/16 - Mr. Jason Lee: RTÉ One TV: The Late Late Show: 12th Feb 2016………………………………….75 36/16 - Ms. Margaret Lee: RTÉ Radio 1: News at One: 11th Jan 2016………………………………………78 www.bai.ie 2 Broadcasting Complaint Decisions 42/16 - Ms Theresa Morrow: RTÉ One TV: The Late Late Show: 8th Jan 2016…………………………….81 44/16 - Mr. Gerard O’ Carroll: RTÉ Radio 1: The Ray D’Arcy Show: 8th March 2016………………………85 45/16 - Mrs. Sharon Gardiner: TV3: Tonight with Vincent Browne: 7th April 2016…………………………89 46/16 - Ms. Eithne Murray: RTÉ One TV: Today: 23rd Feb 2016………………………………………….....92 47/16 - Ms June Twomey: RTÉ One TV: The Late Late Show: 8th Jan 2016………………………………96 www.bai.ie 3 Broadcasting Complaint Decisions BAI Complaints Handling Process Under the Broadcasting Act 2009, viewers and listeners to Irish radio and television services can complain about broadcasting content which they believe is not in keeping with broadcasting codes and rules. When making a complaint, the relevant programme or commercial communication should be identified, including the date of broadcast and time. The complainant should explain what it is about the broadcast that has led them to make a complaint. It is important to set out clearly the grounds of the complaint and why the programme material or commercial content does not comply with the BAI’s Broadcasting Codes. A copy of the codes may be found on the BAI’s website: www.bai.ie, by emailing [email protected] or by phoning the BAI on 01 644 1200. In line with the complaint process, the viewer or listener should direct their complaint to the broadcaster in the first instance and in the manner detailed in the broadcaster’s Code of Practice for Handling Complaints, a document which each broadcaster has available on its website. If a viewer or listener is not satisfied with the response from the broadcaster or if the broadcaster does not respond within the timeframe provided for in their Code of Practice (usually 21 days), then the viewer or listener can refer the complaint to the BAI for consideration. In assessing complaint referrals, the BAI will have regard to the relevant codes and rules, the written material submitted by the relevant parties, together with the broadcast material. Complaints are assessed at Executive level by the Executive Complaints Forum and/or by the Compliance Committee of the Authority. Further information may be found on the complaints handling section of the BAI’s website: www.bai.ie. The details of the broadcasting complaints decisions reached by the BAI are set out in this document. The decisions deal with the issue of whether a programme or a commercial communication did or did not comply with the relevant legal requirements and the relevant broadcasting codes or rules. The decisions do not constitute endorsement or support for the views of either parties to the complaint nor will they address every aspect of a complaint submission. The BAI will not carry out a separate or independent assessment outside of the matters raised in the complaint. In total, 10 complaints were considered by the Compliance Committee of the BAI. Of these, 3 have been upheld and 7 rejected. The Executive Complaints Forum considered and rejected 16 complaints. The decisions of the Compliance Committee were reached at meetings held in May and June 2016. The decisions of the Executive Complaints Forum were reached at meetings held in April, May and July 2016. www.bai.ie 4 Broadcasting Complaint Decisions Upheld/Upheld in Part by the BAI Compliance Committee Complaint made by: Mr. Francis Clauson Ref. No. 26/16 Station: Advertisement: Date: TV3 The Power to Power Ourselves 10th January 2016 1. Advertisement The complaint concerns an advertising campaign entitled ‘The Power to Power Ourselves’, which featured on TV3 in January 2016. The campaign was coordinated by the Irish Wind Energy Association (IWEA). 2. Complaint Category The complaint is submitted under the Broadcasting Act 2009, Section 48(1)(d); the BAI General Commercial Communications Code (Section 9: Prohibited Communications). 3. Complaint Summary The complainant states that this campaign has been coordinated by the Irish Wind Energy Association (IWEA). He states that it is clear that the IWEA are a special interest lobby group: IWEA is the national body representing the wind energy sector in Ireland. The complainant states that the IWEA is committed to promoting the use of wind energy in Ireland and beyond as an economically viable and environmentally sound alternative to conventional generation and promotes awareness and understanding of wind power as the primary renewable energy resource. The complainant further states that wind energy is currently a matter of significant political dispute and that campaigns are underway to oppose the further development of wind energy within the country. The complainant states that the IWEA are now targeting what their CEO describes as "a concerning escalation in false and misleading information about wind energy from some quarters". The complainant states that this dispute is also linked to the ongoing review of the wind energy guidelines being undertaken by Government; the review and proposed revision to the wind energy guidelines has at its heart a battle to set safe setback distances/noise limits between homes and wind farms, something which the IWEA has vehemently opposed. The complainant also states that, taking into account the content of the advert, the context in which the advert is broadcast, the aims and objectives of IWEA and of The Power to Power Ourselves advertising campaign, this advertisement is in contravention of the ban on political advertising. www.bai.ie 5 Broadcasting Complaint Decisions In this regard, the complainant highlights the current political context, in particular the ongoing lobbying and campaigning in relation to the review of the wind energy guidelines and the high volume of political and planning disputes, relating to wind farms, which in many instances have created political activity. The complainant states that, finally, it should be noted that the IWEA, who are running this campaign, are supported by State and Semi-state organisations. 4. Broadcaster’s Response 4.1 Broadcaster’s Response to Complainant TV3 states that, having carefully reviewed the complaint and considered the application of the Broadcasting Authority of Ireland's guidelines for commercial advertising, it does not accept that this is a political message or advertisement. The broadcaster states that the Irish Wind Energy Association (IWEA) is a limited liability company. The broadcaster states that political advertising is restricted for political parties, trade unions and charities which they believe the IWEA is not. The broadcaster states that, separately, Section 41(3) of the Broadcasting Act 2009 states that a "broadcaster shall not broadcast an advertisement which is directed towards a political end”. Again, having regard to the content, TV3 does not believe that the advertisement in question is one directed towards a political end. 4.2 Broadcaster’s Response to BAI TV3 states that having reviewed the BAI’s Code, they do not believe the advertisement was a political one. They state that the advertisement called "The Power to Power Ourselves" was not a call to action in any way. There were no misleading factual claims. The broadcaster states that the only text that accompanies the advertisement is as follows: "Why do we import 85% of Ireland's energy needs, producing only 15% domestically, when we're surrounded by a resource that could move us towards energy independence.” The broadcaster states that the public records indicate that the IWEA is a limited liability company with a registered office in Co. Kildare. Its aim is a commercial one - to promote wind as an energy source from which its members profit. The broadcaster states that the advertisement merely promotes wind energy in general terms, a commercial enterprise not prohibited under the BAI General Commercial Communications Code. www.bai.ie 6 Broadcasting Complaint Decisions The broadcaster states that the complainant refers to the fact that there are ongoing campaigns to oppose wind energy and an ongoing review of wind energy guidelines is being undertaken by the Government.