#366 14 - 20 September 2007 16 pages Rs 30
Weekly Internet Poll # 366 Q. Who is most against elections happening? Total votes: 4,650 No accident
Weekly Internet Poll # 367. To vote go to: www.nepalitimes.com Q. How should we settle the fate of monarchy?
FLOOD OF TEARS: The ill-fated microbus is pulled out of the flooded Dhansar river in Rautahat the morning after five people perished.
UPENDRA LAMICHHANE/KANTIPUR Accidents don’t just happen, they are a result of corruption and war
he microbus carrying a microbus got stuck mid-river. artery, was knocked out by a Whenever the water receded, newly-wed couple and their As the bus headlamps flood three years ago. Makeshift passengers would make the T relatives left Dhankuta on illuminated the swollen river, the repairs allowed it to keep perilous crossing on foot to catch Saturday afternoon for the passengers got out to push. Just functioning while wheeling a bus on the other side. overnight journey to Kathmandu. then a flashflood engulfed the dealing on the contract delayed The microbus arrived at the It was important to cross the vehicle. The newlyweds, Raju and construction of a new bridge. broken bridge and seeing a bus troubled eastern tarai at night, Kimila Shrestha, and two other The work had just begun at making it safely across, took the despite the danger of highway passengers held on to the roof, the height of the Maoist war in fateful decision to cross. robberies, because of road but five others were washed away 2004 when guerrillas demanded This isn’t the first time a bus blockades and disruptions in the with logs and other debris that Rs 1.5 million from the has been washed away by daytime. There was a banda call the river brought down. Their contractor. He said he couldn’t flooded rivers, and it won’t be for Sunday, and the wedding bodies were found up to 10km pay, and work stopped after the last. Sometimes it is a group was in a hurry to cross the downstream the next day. three of the pillars were casualty of war as in last plains by midnight. This would have been just completed. After the ceasefire weekend’s tragedy in Rautahat, at By the time the bus reached another tragedy on Nepal’s last year construction resumed others it is because disagreement Chandranighapur in Rautahat, it accident prone highways had it but the contractor faced extortion over kickbacks has delayed was 10PM and raining heavily. A not been for the circumstances again, this time by the Jwala repairs. Interestingly, the Road little ahead, hundreds of vehicles that lead to the deaths. This faction of the JTMM. Work was Department rushed equipment were queued up by the side of the wasn’t an accident: it was the halted once more. and repaired the bridge the day highway in the dark because the result of corruption, war and On the night of 5 September after the tragedy, just to prove bridge over the Dhansar river had government negligence. Also, the there was a massive storm how quickly it could act if it been washed away three days microbus probably wouldn’t have upstream in the Chure hills, and wanted to. previously. been travelling at night if the tarai the flood washed away the same This tragedy was proof that Trucks were fording the river unrest hadn’t made daytime section of the Dhansar bridge corruption kills. Negligence can even though the water came up to journeys so unpredictable. once more. For four days, there be fatal. And the sorrow of war tyre height. Driver Anil Tamang A 50m section of the bridge on was no effort to repair the lingers long after the fighting saw a passenger bus go across and the Dhansar on the East-West damage or warn buses on the stops. decided to give it a try. But the Highway, Nepal’s main road highway of the broken bridge. Kunda Dixit in Rautahat 2 EDITORIAL 14 - 20 SEPTEMBER 2007 #366
Published by Himalmedia Pvt Ltd, Editor: Kunda Dixit Design: Kiran Maharjan Director Sales and Marketing: Sunaina Shah [email protected] Circulation Manager: Samir Maharjan [email protected] Subscription: [email protected],5542525/535 Hatiban, Godavari Road, Lalitpur GPO Box 7251, Kathmandu 5543333-6, Fax: 5521013 [email protected] Printed at Jagadamba Press, Hatiban: 5547018 Caste mongering www.nepalitimes.com Identity politics is compartmentalizing GLASS HOUSES Nepalis without their consent It’s hard even for die-hard democrats to see a silver lining in the hanks to the past few constantly change as individuals banega na musalmana banega’ went way the current interim executive is conducting itself.The country decades of democracy and adapt to new circumstances. Any on to become the theme songs of has been steered back on to the path of freedom and peace, but it rebellion, the ghost of the discussion on cultural identity the 1950s. looks like governance and development are not on the agenda. T Not even during the worst days of dictatorship have we seen Panchayati daura suruwal must be qualified by a further For newspaper-reading such a paralysis in decision-making. Never have we had such a identity is finally fading away. discussion on counterculture that intellectuals across the world, severe fuel shortage. Although it is due to past mismanagement, Sadly, however, a new monster our societies have undergone over India is often closely associated not much has been done to avert a 14-hour power cut each week fast raising its head is one that the past centuries. with recurring communal riots this winter. At the start of what could be a record tourist season, mechanically forces each Nepali To deny Nepal’s cultural and ethnic strife between Hindus no one can get seats in and out of Kathmandu because the into compartments of castes and identities in political debate is to and Muslims, Christians and national airline is in a shambles. ethnicities. This new caste ignore the elephant in the room. Sikhs. However, in the minds of We may be free, but only to complain about how much more politics is taking us away from Equally, to disregard the dynamic ordinary people, most of whom miserable things are. And all we seem to be interested in are the social inclusion and changes cultural identities have happened to be the Bollywood trappings of democracy, not in actually using it to get results. multicultural coexistence. already undergone is to imprison movie-goers, India is a place where Case in point is the Parliamentary Special Hearing a twenty-first century human an incredibly large spectrum of Committee which is unnecessarily adding more delays to important appointments by staging a constitutional charade. Chief GUEST COLUMN being into a medieval iron cage. diverse cultures coexist, bonded Justice designate Kedar Prasad Giri was “interrogated” by the Mallika Shakya India offers an excellent by a deep affection and making a committee, and a similar fate awaits all the judges of the example in clarifying how culture respectful space for each other’s Supreme Court, ambassadors and heads of constitutional organs. is not static but a dynamic unique cultural and religious These hearings hinge on the assumption that lawmakers are The mono identity of daura concept. It is true that the idea identities. Film after film has best suited to prevent the elevation of unworthy characters to suruwal was the invisible wall of Indian independence started obsessively emphasized the positions of authority and responsibility. But let he who has not that kept Nepalis blissfully out with resistance to the English quintessential oneness of people sinned cast the first stone. unaware of each other’s cultural culture, which initially entailed of diverse faiths. Everyone knows the ambassadorial candidates are political histories. The problem about digging deeper roots of Hinduism. Somewhat belatedly in the appointees who did not emerge from a talent search among being assigned a certain caste But as early as in 1828, the winding road to democracy and career diplomats but from a process of wheeling-dealing. Some ethnicity and bluntly being told Kolkata elites had already pluralism, Nepal has finally come of these names are ill-suited for their new posts, but why are nominated members of a transitional parliament going through the not to venture outside its launched the Brahmo movement, to realise that any political change whole rigmarole all over again after the parent parties of the perimeters is that these are not as or the worship of one universal must have deeper social and honourable members have already done so? Perhaps the best we static as the mongers of caste god, aiming to do away with cultural roots for the common could get was what we have got. Let’s not make an unseemly politics would want them to be. sectarian divisions and caste people to be able to relate to it. fuss over it all. Assigned identities and values hierarchies within Hinduism Thanks to the Maoist rebellion and Reportedly, leftwing members of the legislative parliament while keeping the ancient the popular uprisings that have been most vocal in quizzing Giri and other nominees and spirituality intact. followed in Kathmandu and in holding forth as if they were as pure as virgin snow. While the elite Brahmo the tarai, Nepal has finally set out For all their democratic pretensions, let us not forget that the movement has gained wide to open the old portmanteau of UML was a direct participant in King Gyanendra’s dictatorial attention, one that remains little culture. This is an incredible experiments. The Maoists have yet to prove their commitment to acknowledged to date is the achievement in itself. pluralism and democracy. The kangresis all have skeletons in their closets. cultural movement of the non- Without addressing the Almost everybody at the top of Nepal’s professional pyramid elites, which is best captured in centuries-old institutions, both has reached there the Bollywood expression. It is good and bad, nurtured by our by making some all too easy to make fun of culture and our history, one unprofessional Bollywood, but it has uniquely cannot lay foundations of a New compromises with touched the lives of many Nepal. But this won’t be a panacea. past regimes. ordinary Indians. Unlike film Resolving the deep-seated There is no way to industries elsewhere, Bollywood prejudices of castes and ethnicities invent squeaky has never been funded by the is undoubtedly a priority but clean personalities state. Raj Kapoor’s ‘mera juta hai making sure that the treatments that match the high japani’ was a snub to the ‘be truly echo people’s spirits and not expectations of our peerless Indian, buy Indian’ variety of those engaged in identity politics parliamentarians. nationalism promoted by the is no less daunting. People in glass houses government in the 1950s. As the shouldn’t throw stones. country reeled under the Mallika Shakya is a PhD fanaticism of Hindu-Muslim candidate at the London School of violence, songs like ‘na tu hindu Economics. The coming potato riots The fuel crisis masks a coming food crisis he Kathmandu high society is cars will be cheaper after 2009 when Some taxi-drivers claim that they income earners in this country consumed preoccupied with preparations for import duties will have to be reduced to make more money by driving in line to the 9.4 times more than the poorest 20 percent. T constituent assembly elections. A suit WTO guidelines. petrol pump than they would by driving Disturbing as they are, even these parliamentary committee is investigating The petrol lines are an admissible around town carrying passengers: the statistics of inequality fail to capture the nominees for influential positions. Fund- conversation piece. The high society lady premium on a five-litre jerrycan of petrol frustrations of the bottom rung. An average raising for Prime Minister’s Relief Fund has may complain that her chauffer is often more than Rs 200. In a way, the day-labourer in agriculture earns at most turned into a fashion parade. Paras’ disappeared for the day on the pretext of scarcity of petrol has come as a blessing Rs 10,000 per year, calculated on the basis procuring petrol. An upwardly mobile in disguise for cabbies who don’t own of Rs 50 per day for 200 days of work. It journalist can admit without their vehicles. But for the rest, owning costs at least Rs 200,000 per year to be STATE OF THE STATE embarrassment that he pushed his and driving ageing Marutis bought with able to lead a lifestyle that includes entry- C K Lal motorcycle through the queue for four bank-loans has become a frustrating level motorised vehicle-a scooter or a hours only to be told at the end of his occupation. motorcycle. ordeal that the petrol was finished. But the fuel crisis masks the food In a classic class society, rewards are coronary artery has been unblocked. The However, nobody likes to raise the crisis. The price of dal has shot up to Rs related to power rather than need or Maoists are threatening an imminent urban point that we never see politicians, 80 per kg. Onions have hit the Rs 40 per contribution. With extremely limited uprising. Extension of UNMIN contracts is a bankers, media moghuls or other hoity- kg mark, the line beyond which they opportunities for advancement in life, the foregone conclusion. But no one is toity waiting in the fuel queues. A become unaffordable to the poor. But the privileged are perhaps correct in assessing concerned about everyday matters like the passenger on the Lagankhel bus the other most astonishing is the price of potatoes: that Nepal is ripe for endless cycles of shortages and the cost of living. Because day pointed out another very visible it is now Rs 30 a kg. Apparently, those revolution. They have managed to get a law these things don’t affect the rich. The more incongruity: other than two-wheelers, most who worry about unavailability of petrol that will allow them to take their money high-rise apartments are built, higher goes of the vehicles queuing up for petrol are and those disturbed by the runaway price elsewhere. Worse times are in store for the rent for the poor. This improbable taxis. This adds one more mystery to the of potatoes belong to two different societies oblivious to structural injustices. relationship between burgeoning supply and as yet unexposed fuel supply universes despite sharing the same city. The Maoists are planning an urban uprising, escalating cost is never discussed by arrangements of vehicles belonging to The Asian Development Bank but can they control it from descending into economists. Speculation is rife instead that international agencies. calculates that the top 20 percent of nationwide potato riots? 14 - 20 SEPTEMBER 2007 #366 3
LLL ETTERS
JOGIMARA It is such a sad and terrible thing to hear about the bereaved people of Jogimara ‘I weep at night’ (#364). I felt so moved after going through the column and hearing that the government, instead of compensating the bereaved families, have tagged them as terrorists. Don’t they feel sorry for the families of the dead? Are those who were killed not Nepali citizens? Can’t the dead rest in peace? Thanks to Mohan Mainali and Nepali Times for a great job in covering the plight of these innocents. Ravi Lama, email
YOGI IS RIGHT Yogi Adityanath is right (‘Nepal should be a Hindu rastra again’, #365). Only then will there be peace there. Hindus are naturally secular, and as long as there was King Birendra there was peace in the Himalayan kingdom. Secularism is unsuitable, because we know the kind of sham secularism being practised in India for vested interests. G V, email
MADHES The articles and interviews by Prashant Jha (‘The Gorakhpur Connection’, #365) are brilliant, with well weaved-in analysis and insights. Great work. Ruhit Tewari, email
JAI NEPAL I am in total agreement with Maura Moynihan (‘Jai Nepal’, #365). Compulsive optimism like this is in short supply. We need more reminders like this to infuse ourselves with well-deserved pride that our history, heritage, and uniqueness rightfully affords us. In contrast to nations around the world, patience and tolerance is still plentiful in our Nepalese society. And these characters will ultimately help us through the process of re-inventing Nepal. Let the bouts of dysentery only cripple those Kathmandu cocktail circuiters who dampen our optimism. Arun Neupane