Documenting Maori History

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Documenting Maori History Documenting Maori History: THE ARREST OF TE KOOTI RIKIRANGI TE TURUKI, 1889* TRUTH is ever a casualty of war and of the aftermath of war and so it is of the conflicts between Maori and Pakeha in New Zealand. A bare hun- dred years is too short a time for both peoples, still somewhat uncertainly working out their relationships in New Zealand, to view the nineteenth- century conflicts with much objectivity. Indeed, partly due to the con- fidence and articulateness of the younger generations of Maoris and to their dissatisfaction with the Pakeha descriptions of what is and what happened, the covers have only in the last decade or so really begun to be ripped off the struggles of a century before. Some truth is emerging, in the sense of reasonably accurate statements about who did what and why, but so inevitably is a great deal of myth-making, of the casting of villains and the erection of culture-heroes by Maoris to match the villains and culture-heroes which were created earlier by the Pakeha—and which many Pakeha of a post-imperial generation now themselves find very inadequate. In all of this academics are going to become involved, partly because they are going to be dragged into it by the public, by their students and by the media, and partly because it is going to be difficult for some of them to resist the heady attractions of playing to the gallery of one set or another of protagonists or polemicists, frequently eager to have the presumed authority of an academic imprimatur on their particular ver- sion of what is supposed to have happened. At this rather crucial stage of the unfolding of New Zealand national life one cannot but regret how late qualified, professional historians began seriously to explore Anglo-Maori relations in this country. Keith Sinclair really opened a new era with the Origins of the Maori Wars in * The man known as Te Kooti Rikirangi took the name Te Kooti at his Christian baptism, almost certainly after Dandeson Coates, Lay Secretary of the Church Missionary Society. After his imprisonment and escape from the Chatham Islands he preferred to use one of his father's names, Te Turuki. Of a dozen or more letters signed by him and still surviving in the National Archives most are signed 'Te Turuki', one is signed 'Te Kooti te Turuki', and one is signed 'Te Turuki te Kooti'. He was apparantly still (in the 1870s and 1880s) trying to accommodate Pakeha readers (to whom the two letters were addressed) by sometimes re- taining the baptisimal name by which they knew him. I have also retained it for the most part in this article because he is still generally known by most Pakeha and Maoris as 'Te Kooti', though in his own family and district the preferred name is Te Turuki, a name in turn taken by descendants and co-religionists. 25 26 ALAN WARD 1957; and there are still comparatively few historians publishing in this general area. Still more must one regret, though one may understand the reasons, the lack of trained publishing Maori historians. Most Maori students of modern Maori history appear to be forming their evaluations in the context of anthropology or 'Maori studies', where the reading of detailed scholarly history is perhaps encouraged but not always required. Anthropological research itself has paid very little attention to the evolution of Maori society under contact. There has been much strenuous endeavour to recreate the classical Maori past (often in a form as sterile as it is static) and some thorough studies of modern Maori in urban or rural locations—often excellent in their descriptions of material life and relationships but still rather barren as regards the life of the mind. As more recent anthropology has moved increasingly from func- tionalist approaches to the study of culture in change and cultures inter- acting with other cultures so modern 'Maori studies' specialists have also begun to present their versions of what happened between 1769 and, say, 1945. Thus, in her revised edition of The Maoris of New Zealand, between twenty-eight pages on the Maori before 1800 and 300 pages on the Maori today, Professor Joan Metge inserts ten pages on 'The years between'. One must commend Joan Metge for the richness of her con- temporary material, and the accuracy of her short historical statement, and probably also her restraint at not attempting more of what she is not trained to do. But my fear is that many students of 'Maori studies' will never read more history than these ten pages. And ten pages are not enough to show what powerful historical influences, what complex social action and cultural influences have made Joe Hawke and Ben Couch and Brigadier Poananga, Pat Hohepa or Sidney Mead what they are and why they are so different from one another! There are whole dimensions missing here. Another recent (1977) work which shows some signs of becoming a classic in the 'Maori studies' field is Professor Hugh Kawharu's Maori Land Tenure, published by the prestigious Clarendon Press and priced at over $30. This too contains a historical survey compounded from 'a limited range of published sources long familiar to students of the sub- ject'.1 'Long familiar' is right: given the reliance on Cowan (1922), Kee- sing (1928), Belshaw (1940) and Smith (1948), and nothing later than Ian Wards (1968)! The book stops short with the notorious 1967 legislation, and does not note even in an addendum to the author's preface, itself written in 1976, the amending legislation which followed under a Labour government. A subject of such fundamental importance and present political dynamite as land tenure surely deserves to be supported by the most up-to-date available historical (and other) researches on the subject. 1 Hugh Kawharu, Maori Land Tenure, Oxford, 1977. DOCUMENTING MAORI HISTORY 27 In the modern intellectual confrontation that urbanization and educa- tion have produced, much will depend upon the frankness and the industry of the historians of cultural interaction—including the anthro- pologists and 'Maori studies' professors turned historians. Potted histories, rehashed old histories, are not much use in this. The intellec- tual leaders of both races, and the media which publicize some of their statements, should surely drink deep, not sip at this most sensitive area of New Zealand history. In doing so, they should have regard to the documentary record, and its still largely unexplored riches. The recent vogue for oral history has of course proved valuable. Michael King, in his biography of Te Puea, has shown what it can reveal. But Dr King has himself noted the limitations of oral history, notably the warping effects of recounting over time, and the cultural purposes of the recounting—namely to support important values and myths rather than to strive for objectivity.2 Not that the quest for the Holy Grail of a single objective truth is the proper preoccupation of the documentary historian either, since docu- ments too are created by the protagonists in events, and reflect their various standpoints about events or issues as they see them or reflect on them. But it remains the professional historian's task to unravel these various 'truths'—the events, the interpretations of events and myths about events—usually in relation to larger issues or questions, and to help readers make more informed judgments about them. In this context the stock-in-trade questions of who first said what, and why, put the documentary historian at an advantage. For documents—primary, con- temporary documents—do have the virtue of a certain stability, of cap- turing and freezing the thoughts and utterances of contemporary participants and defying subsequent interpretation and retelling. The other important point to appreciate regarding documents about modern New Zealand history is their abundance. This includes documents written by Maori. It is perhaps not fully appreciated how much the Maori, being a literate people by the mid-nineteenth century, used their new-found talent and wrote letters, frequently, to each other and to government officials. Indeed, because of factionalism and conten- tion among leaders, there was usually a veritable flow of intelligence about almost any important development. A great many letters have sur- vived in the files of the various government officers and are now located in the National Archives. The records of local courts, and journals and letter books kept by magistrates contain very full revelations over time, of the people and events of a local community. The minutes and evidence compiled by the Native Affairs Committee of Parliament contain voluminous records about particular issues such as land claims, and the 2 Michael King, 'New Zealand Oral History: some cultural and methodological con- siderations', New Zealand Journal of History, XII, 2 (October 1978), 104-23. 28 ALAN WARD people concerned about them. So of course do the records of the Native Land Court. Much of this has not yet been used by historians. Political and religious gatherings by Maoris were frequently reported quite exten- sively and verbatim speeches often recorded. With the necessary allowance for bias, misreporting and mistranslation with which all documents must be treated, it is nevertheless possible to get rich insights from these.' Putting all this together, along with missionary archives and published material such as local newspapers, it is often possible to build up a very full picture of Maori history in the nineteenth century—a great wealth of detail about the Maori people of the area, their social condition, the pressures upon them, their activities, their leaders, their belief systems. Oliver and Thompson's history of the East Coast," particularly the detailed study of how the Poverty Bay Maori came to be involved in their terrible and unnecessary military confrontation with government forces, is an illustration of what is possible, and before the nineteenth-century history of the Maori can become very full I believe there need to be more such local studies, based on the documentary material.
Recommended publications
  • The Native Land Court, Land Titles and Crown Land Purchasing in the Rohe Potae District, 1866 ‐ 1907
    Wai 898 #A79 The Native Land Court, land titles and Crown land purchasing in the Rohe Potae district, 1866 ‐ 1907 A report for the Te Rohe Potae district inquiry (Wai 898) Paul Husbands James Stuart Mitchell November 2011 ii Contents Introduction ........................................................................................................................................... 1 Report summary .................................................................................................................................. 1 The Statements of Claim ..................................................................................................................... 3 The report and the Te Rohe Potae district inquiry .............................................................................. 5 The research questions ........................................................................................................................ 6 Relationship to other reports in the casebook ..................................................................................... 8 The Native Land Court and previous Tribunal inquiries .................................................................. 10 Sources .............................................................................................................................................. 10 The report’s chapters ......................................................................................................................... 20 Terminology .....................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • New Zealand Wars Sources at the Hocken Collections Part 2 – 1860S and 1870S
    Reference Guide New Zealand Wars Sources at the Hocken Collections Part 2 – 1860s and 1870s Henry Jame Warre. Camp at Poutoko (1863). Watercolour on paper: 254 x 353mm. Accession no.: 8,610. Hocken Collections/Te Uare Taoka o Hākena, University of Otago Library Nau Mai Haere Mai ki Te Uare Taoka o Hākena: Welcome to the Hocken Collections He mihi nui tēnei ki a koutou kā uri o kā hau e whā arā, kā mātāwaka o te motu, o te ao whānui hoki. Nau mai, haere mai ki te taumata. As you arrive We seek to preserve all the taoka we hold for future generations. So that all taoka are properly protected, we ask that you: place your bags (including computer bags and sleeves) in the lockers provided leave all food and drink including water bottles in the lockers (we have a researcher lounge off the foyer which everyone is welcome to use) bring any materials you need for research and some ID in with you sign the Readers’ Register each day enquire at the reference desk first if you wish to take digital photographs Beginning your research This guide gives examples of the types of material relating to the New Zealand Wars in the 1860s and 1870s held at the Hocken. All items must be used within the library. As the collection is large and constantly growing not every item is listed here, but you can search for other material on our Online Public Access Catalogues: for books, theses, journals, magazines, newspapers, maps, and audiovisual material, use Library Search|Ketu.
    [Show full text]
  • Wednesday, October 14, 2020 Home-Delivered $1.90, Retail $2.20 Kaiti Hill Crawl for Cancer Page 2
    TE NUPEPA O TE TAIRAWHITI WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 14, 2020 HOME-DELIVERED $1.90, RETAIL $2.20 KAITI HILL CRAWL FOR CANCER PAGE 2 LOOKING BACK AT OUR ELECTORATE PAGE 5 ‘I’LL JUST GIVE YA A BIG FAT KISS’ WHERE THERE’S A WOOL, THERE’S A WEIGH: Gizzy Shrek goes to the “hairdresser” on Saturday morning at the Poverty Bay Spring Show and a special competition has been created for people to guess the weight of her fleece for cash prizes. Rob Faulkner is pictured with the woolly girl after she was found on Wairakaia Station last month. Gizzy Shrek is to be shorn with hand blades by legendary shearer Peter Casserly. STORY ON PAGE 3 Picture by Liam Clayton PAGE 14 by Andrew Ashton volumes remained flat year- that obtaining finance is not on-year in Gisborne, the an easy process and banks are GISBORNE house prices only region nationally not to taking up to four or five weeks last month hit an all-time increase from the same time for an appointment.” high median of $560,000 and last year. A total of 39 sales were realtors warn even higher However, listings increased completed last month — the RECORD prices are on the way if they 18.5 percent from the same same as September last year. cannot get more stock. time last year, with 64 new The top sale was $1 million Latest data from the Real properties listed in September. for 85 Hamilton Drive — a four- Estate Institute data shows “This is hopefully the first bedroom house in Sponge Bay.
    [Show full text]
  • East Coast Inquiry District: an Overview of Crown-Maori Relations 1840-1986
    OFFICIAL Wai 900, A14 WAI 900 East Coast Inquiry District: An Overview of Crown- Maori Relations 1840-1986 A Scoping Report Commissioned by the Waitangi Tribunal Wendy Hart November 2007 Contents Tables...................................................................................................................................................................5 Maps ....................................................................................................................................................................5 Images..................................................................................................................................................................5 Preface.................................................................................................................................................................6 The Author.......................................................................................................................................................... 6 Acknowledgements............................................................................................................................................ 6 Note regarding style........................................................................................................................................... 6 Abbreviations...................................................................................................................................................... 7 Chapter One: Introduction ......................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Whanganui Ki Maniapoto
    '. " Wai 903, #A 11 OFFICIAL WAI48 Preliminary Historical Report Wai 48 and related claims Whanganui ki Maniapoto \ Alan Ward March 1992 "./-- · TABLE OF CONTENTS Page No. I THE NA TURE OF THE CLAIMS AND GENERAL HISTORICAL BA CKGROUND ...................... 9 1. The claims . .. 9 2. The oreliminarv report . .. 10 3. The iwi mainlv affected . .. 10 4. Early contacts with Europeans ................. 12 5. The Treaty of Waitangi ...................... 13 6. Early Land Acquisitions: .................. , . .. 15 7. Underlving Settler Attitudes . .. 16 8. Government land ourchase policy after 1865 ....... 18 fl. WHANGANUI AND THE MURIMOTU ................ 20 1. Divisions over land and attempts to contain them ... 20 2. Sales proceed . ........................... 22 /------, 3. Murimotu .. .................•............ 23 -1< ____)' 4. Strong trading in land? ...................... 25 5. Dealings over Murimotu-Rangipo ............... 26 6. Further attempts to limit land selling ............ 27 7. Kemp's Trust . 29 Iff THE KING COUNTRY ........... .. 30 1. Increasing contacts with government. .. 30 2. The Rotorua model ......................... 33 3. Whatiwhatihoe, May 1882: origins of the Rohe Potae concep t . , . .. , , , . , , . , , . 33 4. Government policy ., ....................... 36 5. Legislative preparations ........ , . , ...... , , , . 36 6. The Murimotu legislation .......... , .. ,....... 37 7. The Mokau-Mohakatino .. , ............. , , ... , 38 - 2 - 8. Maungatautari. • . • . • . • • . • . • • . 39 ) 9. Native Committees, 1883
    [Show full text]
  • THE CULT of RUA During the First Third of The
    Allan Hanson CHRISTIAN BRANCHES, MAORI ROOTS: THE CULT OF RUA During the first third of the twentieth century a New Zealand Maori named Rua Kenana, proclaiming himself to be a Messiah and the brother of Jesus, or even Jesus himself, headed a millenarian move- ment that attracted many adherents among Maoris of the Tuhoe and Whakatohea tribes.' The movement included the express intention to eradicate all traces of the old Maori religion. Nevertheless, the cult contained much that derived from indigenous Maori culture. This essay attempts to sort out the Judeo-Christian and Maori sources of Thanks are due to Judith Binney and Peter Webster, without whose careful scholar- ship this paper could not have been written. I am also grateful to Louise Hanson and Fransje Knops for critical comments. I Rua's cult had received very little scholarly attention prior to the appearance of two books, researched independently but both published in 1979. Judith Binney, Gillian Chaplin, and Craig Wallace, Mihaia: The Prophet Rua Kenana and His Community at Maungapohatu (Wellington: Oxford University Press, 1979), tell the story of the move- ment by means of a wealth of contemporaneous photographs conjoined with a carefully researched narrative by Binney. Peter Webster, Rua and the Maori Millennium (Welling- ton: Prince Milburn for Victoria University Press, 1979), perceptively analyzes the cult in terms of a general, cross-cultural theory of millenarian movements. Binney has pub- lished two further essays on Rua's cult, "Maungapohatu Revisited: or, How the Govern- ment Underdeveloped a Maori Community," Journal of the Polynesian Society 92 (1983): 353-92, and "Myth and Explanation in the Ringatu Tradition: Some Aspects of the Leadership of Te Kooti Arikirangi Te Turuku and Rua Kenana Hepetipa," Journal of the Polynesian Society 93 (1984): 345-98.
    [Show full text]
  • Ngā Ariki Kaipūtahi and the Mangatū Lands
    Wai 814, #P21 Wai 1489, #A22 Ngā Ariki Kaipūtahi and the Mangatū Lands 28 May 2018 Anthony Pātete A report commissioned by the Crown Forestry Rental Trust for the Waitangi Tribunal Mangatū Remedies district inquiry Ngā Ariki Kaipūtahi and the Mangatū Lands, May 2018 Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 4 Summary of the findings of the Mangatū Remedies Inquiry ................................................. 5 The identity of Ngā Ariki Kaipūtahi .......................................................................................... 6 Whakapapa ............................................................................................................................. 6 Protest ..................................................................................................................................... 8 Organisation ........................................................................................................................... 9 The rohe of Ngā Ariki Kaipūtahi ............................................................................................. 13 Customary interests of Ngā Ariki Kaipūtahi ........................................................................... 17 Comment on land block interests ......................................................................................... 20 Impact on Ngā Ariki Kaipūtahi...............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Wednesday, April 28, 2021 Home-Delivered $1.90, Retail $2.20 Tuhoe Protest: ‘It’S Confiscation All Over Again’ Page 3
    TE NUPEPA O TE TAIRAWHITI WEDNESDAY, APRIL 28, 2021 HOME-DELIVERED $1.90, RETAIL $2.20 TUHOE PROTEST: ‘IT’S CONFISCATION ALL OVER AGAIN’ PAGE 3 TEAM COVID-19 PAGES 6-7, 12-13, 16 SPIRIT • Western Australia travel bubble reopened • Kiwis in India face more hurdles to get home Team Gisborne had every reason to smile after being named winners of the Team Spirit Award at the Halberg Games in Auckland • World rallies to help devastated India at the weekend. Back row (from left) are Team Gisborne members Oren Tibble and Tama Wirepa, team manager and Parafed • United States eases mask guidelines Gisborne-Tairawhiti regional development coordinator Lou Ellery and Raymond Braybrook. Front are Lezae Te Reo and former New Zealand Paralympics swimmer Rebecca Dubber, who presented the award. The Halberg Games is a three-day sports competition • British PM denies making open to athletes aged eight to 21 with a physical or visual impairment. Ms Ellery said anyone with a disability, of any age, was ‘bodies-piled-high’ comment welcome to join Parafed Gisborne-Tairawhiti via Facebook or by ringing her on 020 4080 9069. STORY ON PAGE 4 Picture supplied A GISBORNE woman’s of perjury had simply not He criticised her for plight through the court occurred, she said. confiding in three close friends system has been highlighted “(The woman) should have (those she called as witnesses) in national media reports as been free to leave her marriage. about the alleged abuse. a rare insight into existing She should have been able to The judge accused the concerns about the treatment secure a fair and reasonable woman as lying in an of women and children within matrimonial settlement and it “unreasonable pursuit” of more Family the Family Court system.
    [Show full text]
  • 7. Poverty Bay and East Coast
    7. Poverty Bay and East Coast The first fighting in the Poverty Bay and East Coast regions took place in 1865 at Tokomaru Bay, Waiapu and Hicks Bay, mostly between sections of the Ngāti Porou tribe (Cowan 1983 II: 117–123; Soutar 2000). On one side were Pai Marire (‘Hau Hau’) or ‘Kingite’ forces and on the other ‘Queenite’ Māori forces and allied Pākehā. There followed a six-day siege of the Pai Marire pā Waerenga-a-Hika in Poverty Bay in November 1865, resulting in surrender of the pā and the deaths of 11 men on the government side and more than 100 Pai Marire (Cowan 1983 II: 124–128) . On 10 July 1868, Te Kooti Arikirangi and 300 followers landed at Whareongaonga, south of Poverty Bay, having escaped from imprisonment on the Chatham Islands. This led to fighting in the next four years over much of the central and eastern North Island, with fortifications involved at Ngatapa (7.5), inland of Poverty Bay in December 1868 and January 1869, at Whakatane in March 1869 (5.31, 5.34), Mohaka in April 1869 (8.1, 8.6), and in October 1869 at Te Porere (6.15– 16), south of Lake Taupo (Cowan 1983: II ; Binney 1995: 87–208). Fortifications in this section are listed under: • Poverty Bay • East Coast POVERTY BAY 7.1 Crow’s Nest X17/32 (2908600E 6288600N); recorded 1991, update 1999. Ngatapa; 800 m east of Ngatapa Trig, on the crest of prominent ridge forming the right flank of the approach to Ngatapa pā (7.5).
    [Show full text]
  • Processes of Pakeha Change in Response To
    http://waikato.researchgateway.ac.nz/ Research Commons at the University of Waikato Copyright Statement: The digital copy of this thesis is protected by the Copyright Act 1994 (New Zealand). The thesis may be consulted by you, provided you comply with the provisions of the Act and the following conditions of use: Any use you make of these documents or images must be for research or private study purposes only, and you may not make them available to any other person. Authors control the copyright of their thesis. You will recognise the author’s right to be identified as the author of the thesis, and due acknowledgement will be made to the author where appropriate. You will obtain the author’s permission before publishing any material from the thesis. PROCESSES OF PAKEHA CHANGE IN RESPONSE TO THE TREATY OF WAITANGI A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Waikato by Ingrid Huygens 2007 DEDICATION To my father the labourer‐philosopher who pondered these things as he drove his tractor i ACKNOWLEDGMENTS My most respectful and loving acknowledgments to my peer study group of Mitzi and Ray Nairn, Rose Black and Tim McCreanor. Their combined experience spanned a depth and breadth of Pakeha Treaty work that framed my research project. Their academic, emotional and practical support during times of ill-health and scant resources made this thesis possible. To my colleagues, the Treaty and decolonisation educators who shared with me their reflections, their dreams and their ways of working. It was a privilege to visit each group in their home area, and my year of travelling around the country will always stand out as one of warmth, colour and generosity.
    [Show full text]
  • Crown Forestry Rental Trust Report to Appointors 2007 – 2008
    CROWN FORESTRY RENTAL TRUST REPORT TO APPOINTORS 2007 – 2008 Crown Forestry rental trust trustees sir Graham latimer MS Janet mason mr GreGory Fortuin mr paul morGan ms anGela Foulkes mr kinGi smiler The Trust has a fundamental duty to prov ide funding and support to claimants. It is an obligation that w e regard as an integral ingredient in settling Treaty claims. Cover image: © mychillybin.co.nz/Brent Carville Contents 2 | Message from the Chair 6 | Message from the Chief executive 12 | Income statement 12 | Statement of Changes in equity – retained earnings 13 | Balance sheet 14 | Statement of Cash Flows 15 | Notes to the Financial statements 41 | Auditor’s report 43 | Map of Crown Forest licensed land 45 | Directory The Trust has a fundamental duty to prov ide funding and support to claimants. It is an obligation that w e regard as an integral ingredient in settling Treaty claims. Message from the Chair Kia hiwa ra, kia kiwa ra. We are pleased to present the Annual Report of Crown Forest Rental Trust to our Appointors: the New Zealand Maori Council, the Federation of Maori Author­ ities, and the Minister of Finance. This Report covers the financial statements and activities of Crown Forestry Rental Trust (‘the Trust’) for the period 1 April 2007 to 31 March 2008. Over the last 12 months the Trust has worked very hard to meet the expectations of the claimant community. It has taken a robust approach in balancing the needs of the claimant community with the powers granted to the Trust under the Trust Deed.
    [Show full text]
  • Local Government on the East Coast
    Local Government on the East Coast August 2009 Jane Luiten A Report Commissioned by HistoryWorks for the Crown Forestry Rental Trust 1 Table of Contents Introduction................................................................................................................................ 5 Local Government.................................................................................................................. 5 Project Brief ........................................................................................................................... 7 Statements of Claim ............................................................................................................... 9 The Author ........................................................................................................................... 11 Executive Summary ................................................................................................................. 13 Part One: The Historical Development of Local Government................................................. 27 1. Local Government in the Colonial Context: 1840-1876................................................... 28 1.1 Introduction.............................................................................................................. 28 1.2 Local Government in the Crown Colony, 1840-1852.............................................. 29 1.3 Constitution Act 1852 .............................................................................................. 35 1.4 Financing
    [Show full text]