Local Government on the East Coast

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Local Government on the East Coast Local Government on the East Coast August 2009 Jane Luiten A Report Commissioned by HistoryWorks for the Crown Forestry Rental Trust 1 Table of Contents Introduction................................................................................................................................ 5 Local Government.................................................................................................................. 5 Project Brief ........................................................................................................................... 7 Statements of Claim ............................................................................................................... 9 The Author ........................................................................................................................... 11 Executive Summary ................................................................................................................. 13 Part One: The Historical Development of Local Government................................................. 27 1. Local Government in the Colonial Context: 1840-1876................................................... 28 1.1 Introduction.............................................................................................................. 28 1.2 Local Government in the Crown Colony, 1840-1852.............................................. 29 1.3 Constitution Act 1852 .............................................................................................. 35 1.4 Financing Public Works........................................................................................... 37 1.5 Local Government in the Provinces......................................................................... 40 1.6 The End of Provincialism......................................................................................... 42 1.7 The Provision for Maori Local Government, 1840-1876 ........................................ 45 1.8 General Government on the East Coast, 1840-1876................................................ 49 1.9 The Auckland Provincial Government on the East Coast........................................ 54 1.10 Local Government in the Provincial Era.................................................................. 57 2. County Government 1876-1989 ....................................................................................... 59 2.1 The Constitution of Counties ................................................................................... 59 2.2 Franchise .................................................................................................................. 60 2.3 The Impact of Franchise on Maori Participation ..................................................... 64 2.4 County Functions ..................................................................................................... 70 2.5 Funding .................................................................................................................... 73 2.6 Ad hoc Bodies.......................................................................................................... 77 2.7 Attempts at Reform.................................................................................................. 78 3. The Southern Counties: Cook, Waikohu, Uawa............................................................... 82 3.1 Cook County, 1876-1890......................................................................................... 82 3.2 Te Tino Rangatiratanga, 1876-1890 ........................................................................ 89 3.3 Waikohu County ...................................................................................................... 99 3.4 Uawa County.......................................................................................................... 104 3.5 Specific Local Government Treaty Claims............................................................ 113 3.6 Cook County, 1965-1989....................................................................................... 117 2 4. Waiapu County, 1890-1920............................................................................................ 120 4.1 The Composition of the Waiapu County Council.................................................. 121 4.2 The Work of the County Council........................................................................... 126 4.3 Te Tino Rangatiratanga 1890-1920 ....................................................................... 150 5. Waiapu County 1920-1980s ........................................................................................... 157 5.1 Local Government and Rates................................................................................. 158 5.2 Representation........................................................................................................ 162 5.3 Provision of Services.............................................................................................. 177 5.4 The Jerusalem–Whareponga Road......................................................................... 183 5.5 Roads in Northern Waiapu..................................................................................... 186 5.6 Te Tino Rangatiratanga 1920–1960....................................................................... 200 5.7 Waiapu County 1960s–1980s ................................................................................ 211 5.8 Amalgamation........................................................................................................ 213 6. Matakaoa County............................................................................................................ 216 6.1 Matakaoa County, 1919-1933................................................................................ 217 6.2 Government Intervention ....................................................................................... 233 6.3 Matakaoa County Commissioner 1933–36............................................................ 240 6.4 Challenge................................................................................................................ 246 6.5 Commissioner Rule 1939–1963............................................................................. 261 6.6 Economic Decline .................................................................................................. 292 6.7 Conclusions............................................................................................................ 296 7. Town and Country Planning........................................................................................... 298 7.1 County Planning Beginnings.................................................................................. 298 7.2 Waiapu County District Planning .......................................................................... 300 7.3 The District Scheme Review 1981......................................................................... 308 7.4 Waiapu County District Scheme Proposed Review No. 2 1989............................ 312 7.5 Planning Under the Gisborne District Council and the RMA................................ 314 7.6 Conclusions............................................................................................................ 319 Part Two: Contemporary Developments in Local Government ............................................ 321 8. Local Government Reform ............................................................................................. 322 8.1 Local Government Reform .................................................................................... 322 8.2 Local Government Reform and Maori................................................................... 324 9. Tangata Whenua Standing Committee ........................................................................... 329 9.1 The Maori Liaison Group 1993–1995.................................................................... 330 9.2 Towards 2000: The Treaty Debate......................................................................... 336 9.3 The End of the Tangata Whenua Committee......................................................... 350 9.4 Conclusions............................................................................................................ 357 10. Potaka Marae Hatchery.............................................................................................. 363 10.1 Background ............................................................................................................ 364 10.2 Events at Potaka ..................................................................................................... 374 10.3 Issues...................................................................................................................... 399 3 List of Appendices ................................................................................................................. 412 Appendix 1: List of Landholders, Waiapu County 1910- .................................................. 413 Appendix 2: Table of Waiapu County Landholders @ 1910 showing relative Maori/Pakeha tenure by riding .................................................................................................................. 416 Appendix 3: List of Maori Ratepayers in Waiapu County, 1913-1914 ............................. 417 Appendix 4: Waiapu County Council List of Ratepayers, 1926-27..................................
Recommended publications
  • Thursday, March 11, 2021 Home-Delivered $1.90, Retail $2.20
    TE NUPEPA O TE TAIRAWHITI THURSDAY, MARCH 11, 2021 HOME-DELIVERED $1.90, RETAIL $2.20 PAGE 3 ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT PAGES 23-26 POLICE GISBORNE ACCUSED OF GALLERY ‘RACIALLY CLOSING PROFILING’ ITS DOORS PAGE 10 KIDS INSIDE TODAY CRUISING BACK TO GISBORNE: Eastland Port has 23 cruise ship visits scheduled for next summer, depending on the reopening of New Zealand borders. The Oosterdam (pictured) was a regular visitor to Gisborne in the early years of cruise ship visits here and she will be back twice in early December and early February next summer if the borders reopen. STORY ON PAGE 3 File picture A WOMAN who blew the whistle on Enterprises Limited (BEL) by his Matawai farmer John Bracken’s alleged Gisborne accountant, who unwittingly $17.4 million tax scam has given evidence prepared them using bank transactions in his High Court trial at Gisborne. manipulated by Bracken and false GST Ex-lover a She claimed Bracken was her lover, invoices he submitted. that they lived together in Auckland Bracken’s pleas to the charges have when he was regularly there for been deemed not guilty because he his export business and that she refuses to enter any. He says the charges unknowingly helped him with his scam are not his to answer — that as a by surreptitiously producing false beneficiary of a Maori Incorporation, he is invoices. protected under Te Ture Whenua Maori Bracken did not dispute their Act 1993. woman involvement but in cross-examination of Bracken is representing himself but her conveyed a situation in which she has literacy problems, so is being assisted was a woman scorned who squealed to by his wife and a McKenzie Friend the Serious Fraud Office (SFO) because of (someone who attends court in support her unfulfilled romantic designs on him.
    [Show full text]
  • And Taewa Māori (Solanum Tuberosum) to Aotearoa/New Zealand
    Copyright is owned by the Author of the thesis. Permission is given for a copy to be downloaded by an individual for the purpose of research and private study only. The thesis may not be reproduced elsewhere without the permission of the Author. Traditional Knowledge Systems and Crops: Case Studies on the Introduction of Kūmara (Ipomoea batatas) and Taewa Māori (Solanum tuberosum) to Aotearoa/New Zealand A thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirement for the degree of Master of AgriScience in Horticultural Science at Massey University, Manawatū, New Zealand Rodrigo Estrada de la Cerda 2015 Kūmara and Taewa Māori, Ōhakea, New Zealand i Abstract Kūmara (Ipomoea batatas) and taewa Māori, or Māori potato (Solanum tuberosum), are arguably the most important Māori traditional crops. Over many centuries, Māori have developed a very intimate relationship to kūmara, and later with taewa, in order to ensure the survival of their people. There are extensive examples of traditional knowledge aligned to kūmara and taewa that strengthen the relationship to the people and acknowledge that relationship as central to the human and crop dispersal from different locations, eventually to Aotearoa / New Zealand. This project looked at the diverse knowledge systems that exist relative to the relationship of Māori to these two food crops; kūmara and taewa. A mixed methodology was applied and information gained from diverse sources including scientific publications, literature in Spanish and English, and Andean, Pacific and Māori traditional knowledge. The evidence on the introduction of kūmara to Aotearoa/New Zealand by Māori is indisputable. Mātauranga Māori confirms the association of kūmara as important cargo for the tribes involved, even detailing the purpose for some of the voyages.
    [Show full text]
  • Of the Trust Lands. the Longer the Prob
    200 THE CONTEMPORARY PACIFIC. SPRING 1991 of the trust lands. The longer the prob­ to promote a series of events that lem is framed in terms ofmoney, the would make the sesquicentennial "our harder it becomes to frame it in terms year." The commission promoted the ofland. In typically American fashion, theme of unity and racial harmony money has come more and more to extensively on television and made replace the Hawaiian birthright. grants to community projects that Meanwhile, Hawaiians continue to would enhance the sense ofnational leave Hawai'i, the intended result of unity. dispossession. This was not an easy task in view of The only hopeful sign is public dis­ the history of colonial despoliation of approval of the agreement by a host of the Maori. For twenty years Maori sovereignty groups. One in particular, activists had targeted the government­ Ka Lahui Hawai'i, dogged OHA at each sponsored treaty celebrations at of its community presentations, forcing Waitangi, revealing the contradictions the question of land dispossession into between Maori and Pakeha in New open debate. Apart from critical educa­ Zealand society. In 1971 Nga Tamatoa, tion, however, these forums did not the young warriors, protested at succeed in overturning the settlement. Waitangi, proclaiming Waitangi Day a In the year ahead, Hawaiians will day of mourning for the loss of 63 mil­ need to consider strategies aimed at the lion acres ofMaori land and calling on US Congress, the Justice and Interior the government to ratify the treaty. departments, and the broader interna­ The government responded in 1976 by tional human rights community.
    [Show full text]
  • Unsettling Recovery: Natural Disaster Response and the Politics of Contemporary Settler Colonialism
    UNSETTLING RECOVERY: NATURAL DISASTER RESPONSE AND THE POLITICS OF CONTEMPORARY SETTLER COLONIALISM A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA BY STEVEN ANDREW KENSINGER IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY DR. DAVID LIPSET, ADVISER JULY 2019 Steven Andrew Kensinger, 2019 © Acknowledgements The fieldwork on which this dissertation is based was funded by a Doctoral Dissertation Fieldwork Grant No. 8955 awarded by the Wenner-Gren Foundation for Anthropological Research. I also want to thank Dr. Robert Berdahl and the Berdahl family for endowing the Daphne Berdahl Memorial Fellowship which provided funds for two preliminary fieldtrips to New Zealand in preparation for the longer fieldwork period. I also received funding while in the field from the University of Minnesota Graduate School through a Thesis Research Travel Grant. I want to thank my advisor, Dr. David Lipset, and the members of my dissertation committee, Dr. Hoon Song, Dr. David Valentine, and Dr. Margaret Werry for their help and guidance in preparing the dissertation. In the Department of Anthropology at the University of Minnesota, Dr. William Beeman, Dr. Karen Ho, and Dr. Karen-Sue Taussig offered personal and professional support. I am grateful to Dr. Kieran McNulty for offering me a much-needed funding opportunity in the final stages of dissertation writing. A special thanks to my colleagues Dr. Meryl Puetz-Lauer and Dr. Timothy Gitzen for their support and encouragement. Dr. Carol Lauer graciously offered to read and comment on several of the chapters. My fellow graduate students and writing-accountability partners Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Proposed Gisborne Regional Freshwater Plan
    Contents Part A: Introduction and Definitions Schedule 9: Aquifers in the Gisborne Region 161 Section 1: Introduction and How the Plan Works 3 Schedule 10: Culvert Construction Guidelines for Council Administered Drainage Areas 162 Section 2: Definitions 5 Schedule 11: Requirements of Farm Environment Plans 164 Part B: Regional Policy Statement for Freshwater Schedule 12: Bore Construction Requirements 166 Section 3: Regional Policy Statement For Freshwater 31 Schedule 13: Irrigation Management Plan Requirements 174 Part C: Regional Freshwater Plan Schedule 14: Clearances, Setbacks and Maximum Slope Gradients for Installation Section 4: Water Quantity and Allocation 42 of Disposal Systems 175 Section 5: Water Quality and Discharges to Water and Land 48 Schedule 15: Wastewater Flow Allowances 177 Section 6: Activities in the Beds of Rivers and Lakes 83 Schedule 16: Unreticulated Wasterwater Treatment, Storage and Disposal Systems 181 Section 7: Riparian Margins, Wetlands 100 Schedule 17: Wetland Management Plans 182 Part D: Regional Schedules Schedule 18: Requirements for AEE for Emergency Wastewater Overflows 183 Schedule 1: Aquatic Ecosystem Waterbodies 109 Schedule 19: Guidance for Resource Consent Applications 185 1 Schedule 2: Migrating and Spawning Habitats of Native Fish 124 Part E: Catchment Plans Proposed Schedule 3: Regionally Significant Wetlands 126 General Catchment Plans 190 Schedule 4: Outstanding Waterbodies 128 Waipaoa Catchment Plan 192 Gisborne Schedule 5: Significant Recreation Areas 130 Appendix - Maps for the Regional Freshwater Plan Schedule 6: Watercourses in Land Drainage Areas with Ecological Values 133 Regional Appendix - Maps for the Regional Freshwater Plan 218 Schedule 7: Protected Watercourses 134 Freshwater Schedule 8: Marine Areas of Coastal Significance as Defined in the Coastal Environment Plan 160 Plan Part A: Introduction and Definitions 2 Section 1: Introduction and How the Plan Works 1.0 Introduction and How the Plan Works Part A is comprised of the introduction, how the plan works and definitions.
    [Show full text]
  • Tairawhiti Iwi COVID-19 Response
    9 April 2020 Tairawhiti Iwi COVID-19 Response Tena tatou Ngati Porou whanui whanau at home and our health and emergency services. As we countdown to Easter, this weekend being Easter weekend, it is important that we maintain Instead, Facetime your whanau, give them call, vigilance in; ZOOM them to tell them that you love and miss them. Tell them you can have a great catch-up • Staying at home NOHO Ki te KAINGA when we all come out of lock-down • Refrain if not cease all together Tell them to do the right thing for them and the right unnecessary travel including numerous trips to thing by us and that is to stay put. the shops, when one trip should be sufficient Invite them to Join us and 1000 other households • Delegate one person from your bubble to go do in their bubbles for Karakia on Easter Sunday the shop and purchase the household supplies. morning from 11.00am via the link which is on the Te Pihopatanga o Aotearoa FB page We can not stress enough the importance of NOHO https://www.facebook.com/TairawhitiAmorangi KI TE KAINGA WHANAU. Remember whanau, The imposed national Lockdown, which for some of us might have been better as a “LOCKED-IN’ is STAY IN YOUR BUBBLE AND KEEP OUT OF showing promising results, with daily numbers of TROUBLE people testing positive for COVID 19 declining, or at the very leas not rising. While this is still early days, BE KIND TO EACH OTHER, LOOK AFTER ONE it is the right trend and we want to see that ANOTHER continue.
    [Show full text]
  • East Coast Inquiry District: an Overview of Crown-Maori Relations 1840-1986
    OFFICIAL Wai 900, A14 WAI 900 East Coast Inquiry District: An Overview of Crown- Maori Relations 1840-1986 A Scoping Report Commissioned by the Waitangi Tribunal Wendy Hart November 2007 Contents Tables...................................................................................................................................................................5 Maps ....................................................................................................................................................................5 Images..................................................................................................................................................................5 Preface.................................................................................................................................................................6 The Author.......................................................................................................................................................... 6 Acknowledgements............................................................................................................................................ 6 Note regarding style........................................................................................................................................... 6 Abbreviations...................................................................................................................................................... 7 Chapter One: Introduction ......................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Historic and Notable Trees of New Zealand : Poverty Bay, Hawkes
    , ! ,PRODUCTION FORESTRY DIVISION FOREST MENSURATION REPORT NO. 18 (revision) ,,-- ODC 174(931 )--090.2 ~· .soIL BUREAU I . UBRARY I U\NDCARE RESEARCH N?. J P.O. BOX 69, LINCOLN, f<.L NEW ZEALAND FOREST SERVICE f ORE ST RESEARCH INSTITUTE HISTORIC AND NOTABLE TREES OF NEW ZEALAND: EAST COAST - POVERTY BAY, HAWKES BAY i1 'i." S. W. Burstall Forest mensuration report leo (rev) ADDENDUM The following entry should be with Notable Exotic Trees of National Interest in the Rawkes Bay section of this revision. It appeared in that section of the 1970 report. Populus deltoides 'Virginiana', Necklace Poplar. Frimley Park, Hastings. Dbh 262 cm, height 44.3 m, with a clear trunk to 9 m, in 1974. Planted c.1874. This is the largest known deciduous tree in New Zealand and one of the largest poplars in the world. Growth appears to be declining as since 1969 diameter has increased by only 4 cm and there has been little if any·height growth. SOIL BUREAU HISTORIC AND NOTABLE TREES OF NEW ZEALAND: POVERTY BAY, HAWKES BAY S.W. Burstall Date: September 1974 ODC 174(931)~090.2 Forest Mensuration Report No. 18 (revised) Production Forestry Division Forest Research Institute Private Bag Rotorua NEW ZEALAND NOTE: This is an unpublished report, and it must be cited as such, e.g. "New Zealand Forest Service, Forest Research Institute, Forest Mensuration Report No. 18 (revised) 1974 (unpublished)". Permission to use any of its contents in print must first be obtained from the Director of the Production Forestry Division. INTRODUCTION Comments on the early establishment and in New Zealandmostly appeared in letters and journals of military personnel.
    [Show full text]
  • Auckland Regional Office of Archives New Zealand
    A supplementary finding-aid to the archives relating to Maori Schools held in the Auckland Regional Office of Archives New Zealand MAORI SCHOOL RECORDS, 1879-1969 Archives New Zealand Auckland holds records relating to approximately 449 Maori Schools, which were transferred by the Department of Education. These schools cover the whole of New Zealand. In 1969 the Maori Schools were integrated into the State System. Since then some of the former Maori schools have transferred their records to Archives New Zealand Auckland. Building and Site Files (series 1001) For most schools we hold a Building and Site file. These usually give information on: • the acquisition of land, specifications for the school or teacher’s residence, sometimes a plan. • letters and petitions to the Education Department requesting a school, providing lists of families’ names and ages of children in the local community who would attend a school. (Sometimes the school was never built, or it was some years before the Department agreed to the establishment of a school in the area). The files may also contain other information such as: • initial Inspector’s reports on the pupils and the teacher, and standard of buildings and grounds; • correspondence from the teachers, Education Department and members of the school committee or community; • pre-1920 lists of students’ names may be included. There are no Building and Site files for Church/private Maori schools as those organisations usually erected, paid for and maintained the buildings themselves. Admission Registers (series 1004) provide details such as: - Name of pupil - Date enrolled - Date of birth - Name of parent or guardian - Address - Previous school attended - Years/classes attended - Last date of attendance - Next school or destination Attendance Returns (series 1001 and 1006) provide: - Name of pupil - Age in years and months - Sometimes number of days attended at time of Return Log Books (series 1003) Written by the Head Teacher/Sole Teacher this daily diary includes important events and various activities held at the school.
    [Show full text]
  • Monday, September 14, 2020 Home-Delivered $1.90, Retail $2.20 Tears Flow
    Nupepa o Te Tairawhiti THE GISBORNE HERALD RĀHINA, MAHURU 9, 2019 I MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2019 HOME-DELIVERED $1.70, RETAIL $2.00 TE NUPEPA O TE TAIRAWHITI RAHINA, MAHURU 14, 2020 I MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 14, 2020 HOME-DELIVERED $1.90, RETAIL $2.20 TEARS FLOW AT C COMPANY HOUSE PAGE 3 PUKANA: Kereru class students at Te TOLAGA BAY CIVIL DEFENCE PAGE 4 ‘All day, every day, te reo is our way’ Hapara School practise their te reo Maori every day. Te Wiki o te reo Maori VOLUNTEERS RECOGNISED is another week where the students UNHEARDOFSAVINGS! IT is Te Wiki o te reo Maori Ms Neilson said. what they teach us every embrace te ao Maori. The children are (Maori Language Week) but “Singing connects us morning so we will become pictured with teacher Tanya Neilson. te reo Maori is used at Te and brings us together better performers, therefore Picture by Liam Clayton. Hapara School every school and creates memories and incorporating the intrinsic day. memory space in our brains. link to culture and identity PAGES Each day the kereru “We know our students and the essential element 5-8,11, whanau class have the enjoy our morning sessions of whanaungatanga (the 12, 13, 16 same routine of performing and they could independently importance of people and a waiata (song), karakia run it on their own. connectedness),” said Ms (prayer) and haka and “We are a culturally diverse Neilson. HEARING• Mask refusal halts Fullers ferry trip practise use of te reo Maori whanau and celebrate and “The school’s focus this •NEW Political party leader’s Covid theories kupu (words) and commands respect all people.” year has been about creating raising fears for Maori health because that is a part of who Te Hapara has two kapa a sense of belonging and PBL they are as a class, says haka tutors — Papa Pura and we feel that through culture, • Expecting ugly GDP figures for quarter teacher Tanya Neilson.
    [Show full text]
  • New Zealand 16 East Coast Chapter
    ©Lonely Planet Publications Pty Ltd The East Coast Why Go? East Cape .....................334 New Zealand is known for its mix of wildly divergent land- Pacifi c Coast Hwy ........334 scapes, but in this region it’s the sociological contours that Gisborne .......................338 are most pronounced. From the earthy settlements of the Te Urewera East Cape to Havelock North’s wine-soaked streets, there’s a National Park................344 full spectrum of NZ life. Hawke’s Bay ................. 347 Maori culture is never more visible than on the East Coast. Exquisitely carved marae (meeting house complexes) Napier ...........................348 dot the landscape, and while the locals may not be wearing Hastings & Around .......356 fl ax skirts and swinging poii (fl ax balls on strings) like they Cape Kidnappers ......... 361 do for the tourists in Rotorua, you can be assured that te reo Central Hawke’s Bay ......362 and tikangaa (the language and customs) are alive and well. Kaweka & Intrepid types will have no trouble losing the tourist Ruahine Ranges ...........363 hordes – along the Pacifi c Coast Hwy, through rural back roads, on remote beaches, or in the mystical wilderness of Te Urewera National Park. When the call of the wild gives way to caff eine with- Best Outdoors drawal, a fi x will quickly be found in the urban centres of » Cape Kidnappers (p 361 ) Gisborne and Napier. You’ll also fi nd plenty of wine, as the » Cooks Cove Walkway region strains under the weight of grapes. From kaimoana (p 338 ) (seafood) to berry fruit and beyond, there are riches here for everyone.
    [Show full text]
  • Whale Rider: the Re-Enactment of Myth and the Empowerment of Women Kevin V
    Journal of Religion & Film Volume 16 Article 9 Issue 2 October 2012 10-1-2012 Whale Rider: The Re-enactment of Myth and the Empowerment of Women Kevin V. Dodd Watkins College of Art, Design, and Film, [email protected] Recommended Citation Dodd, Kevin V. (2012) "Whale Rider: The Re-enactment of Myth and the Empowerment of Women," Journal of Religion & Film: Vol. 16 : Iss. 2 , Article 9. Available at: https://digitalcommons.unomaha.edu/jrf/vol16/iss2/9 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by DigitalCommons@UNO. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Religion & Film by an authorized editor of DigitalCommons@UNO. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Whale Rider: The Re-enactment of Myth and the Empowerment of Women Abstract Whale Rider represents a particular type of mythic film that includes within it references to an ancient sacred story and is itself a contemporary recapitulation of it. The movie also belongs to a further subcategory of mythic cinema, using the double citation of the myth—in its original form and its re-enactment—to critique the subordinate position of women to men in the narrated world. To do this, the myth is extended beyond its traditional scope and context. After looking at how the movie embeds the story and recapitulates it, this paper examines the film’s reception. To consider the variety of positions taken by critics, it then analyses the traditional myth as well as how the book first worked with it. The onclusionc is, in distinction to the book, that the film drives a wedge between the myth’s original sacred function to provide meaning in the world for the Maori people and its extended intention to empower women, favoring the latter at the former’s expense.
    [Show full text]