2 The Constitution

Key Terms

7/50 amending formula (p. 60) A rule for passing most amendments to the constitution, requiring the consent of Parliament and the of seven provinces representing 50 per cent of Cana- da’s population.

Amending formula (p. 50) A set of rules governing how the constitution can be changed.

Bill of Rights, 1960 (p. 69) A federal law detailing Canadians’ rights and freedoms vis-à-vis the fed- eral government.

Cabinet solidarity (p. 45) The understanding that members of the remain cohesive and jointly responsible for the government’s undertakings.

Charlottetown Accord (p. 64) A failed accord in the early 1990s that proposed to renew the consti- tution, but was defeated in a national referendum.

Charter of Rights and Freedoms (p. 51) A portion of the Constitution Act, 1982, enshrining Cana- dians’ core liberties and entitlements vis-à-vis their governments.

Charterphiles (p. 75) Supporters of the enhanced role of judges in the Canadian rights regime.

Charterphobes (p. 75) Opponents and skeptics of the enhanced role of judges in the Canadian rights regime.

Charter-proof (p. 75) Pre-emptive steps taken by a government to ensure that its proposed legisla- tion withstands .

Colonialism (p. 46) The imposition, practice, policy, or belief in the supremacy of European settler institutions over those of Aboriginal groups.

Constitutional convention (p. 51) An unwritten rule based on custom that binds political actors to adhere to the traditions of the constitutional order.

Inside Canadian Politics © Oxford University Press , 2016

Constitutional monarchy (p. 43) A system in which the sovereignty of the Crown is maintained, but exercised by elected officials according to prescribed rules.

Constitutional order (p. 47) The body of written and unwritten rules that govern all laws in Canada.

Crown (p. 43) The legal concept dictating the supremacy of the monarch over the executive, legisla- tive, and judicial branches of government.

Dialogue model (p. 74) The notion that the definition of rights and freedoms is reached through the interaction of judges, legislatures, and executives.

Direct (p. 41) A system in which citizens make political decisions by voting on individual issues.

Fathers of (p. 48) The colonial leaders who negotiated the terms of union forming the of Canada.

Freedoms (p. 69) The autonomy to live and act without external restraint.

Fusion of powers (p. 44) An intimate connection between the authority of the executive and the authority of the .

Gang of Eight (p. 60) The group of provinces united in opposing the federal government’s plans to patriate and centralize the Canadian constitution.

Liberal democracy (p. 40) A system in which equality, rights, and freedoms are preserved through public debate and free and fair elections.

Meech Lake Accord (p. 63) A failed constitutional amendment package in the late 1980s that would have recognized Quebec as a “distinct society.”

Ministerial responsibility (p. 45) The understanding that ministers remain individually responsible for the activities undertaken by staff in their respective departments.

Night of the Long Knives (p. 60) An incident in November 1981 in which the federal government and 9 of 10 provincial governments reached a deal to patriate the constitution, without the presence of Quebec government officials.

Notwithstanding clause (p. 69) Section 33 of the Constitution Act, 1982, which permits legislatures

Oakes test (p. 71) A model employed by the court to weigh the democratic benefits and assess the constitutionality of a law that breaches certain Charter rights.

Parliamentary democracy (p. 39) A democratic system in which government executives must be supported by a majority of elected representatives in a legislature.

Parliamentary supremacy (p. 69) A doctrine under which legislatures and executives, not courts, define key elements of public policy.

Inside Canadian Politics © Oxford University Press Canada, 2016

Patriation (p. 51) The process through which Canadian governments gained the authority to amend the country’s main constitutional documents.

Reasonable limits clause (p. 70) Section 1 of the Charter, which allows governments to pass laws that would otherwise contravene rights and freedoms but which are deemed necessary to protect other democratic norms.

Reference case (p. 52) A proceeding initiated by a government to seek the court’s opinion on the constitutionality of legislation.

Representative democracy (p. 41) A system in which citizens elect officials to make political deci- sions on their behalf.

Responsible government (p. 43) The constitutional principle whereby the executive (cabinet) must be supported by a majority of elected members of the legislature.

Rights (p. 69) Legal claims or entitlements to have something or to act in a particular manner.

Royal Proclamation of 1763 (p. 46) A British document setting out the terms of European settle- ment in North America following the Seven Years’ War.

Rule of law (p. 40) The principle that no one is above the law, and that any powers granted to elect- ed or nonelected officials must be conferred by legislation.

Self-government (p. 46) The inherent right of a people to sovereignty (or self-determination) over their own affairs.

Sovereignty-association (p. 59) A legal arrangement whereby Quebec would be politically inde- pendent but maintain economic ties with Canada. to pass laws that breach certain rights and freedoms.

Treaties (p. 46) Agreements between the Crown and Aboriginal peoples establishing mutual duties and obligations.

Two-row wampum (p. 46) A ceremonial beaded belt symbolizing the parallel paths and equal-order relationship between the Crown and First Nations people.

White paper (p. 59) A document outlining a policy commitment by government.

Review Questions

Multiple Choice Questions

1. Which parliamentary democracy system does the concept of “rule of law” best apply? a) b)

Inside Canadian Politics © Oxford University Press Canada, 2016 c) d)

2. Who is Canada’s head of state? a) The lieutenant governor b) The prime minister c) The Queen d) The governor general

3. Who makes up the political executive (the “cabinet”)? a) The Crown and two legislative bodies b) The first minister and her or his ministers c) The governor general and three lieutenant governors d) The governor general and all lieutenant governors

4. Which of the following documents was designed to supposedly end the Seven Years’ War be- tween France and Britain and their respective Aboriginal allies? a) The of 1774 b) The Royal Proclamation of 1763 c) Act of the Union of 1840 d) Constitution Act of 1971

5. At the Night of the Long Knives the prime minister and nine premiers reached an agreement to patriate the constitution. Which province was not present? a) Manitoba b) Ontario c) British Columbia d) Quebec

6. Which of the following provinces was not part of the Gang of Eight? a) Ontario b) Saskatchewan c) Alberta d) Manitoba

7. When did the House of Commons pass a symbolic resolution declaring the Québécois “a nation within a united Canada”? a) 1876 b) 1981 c) 2006 d) 2015

8. Which of the following was not part of the “triple-E” Senate reform? a) Eligible: The senators must be eligible to run b) Effective: The Senate’s powers must be effective, not ornamental c) Equal: The Senate seats must be divided equally among provinces d) Elected: The Senators must be elected, not appointed

Inside Canadian Politics © Oxford University Press Canada, 2016 9. Which of the following is employed by the courts to weigh the democratic benefits and assess that constitutionality of a law that breaches certain Charter rights? a) Reasonably limits clause b) Notwithstanding clause c) Oakes test d) Equality rights

10. Which category of the Charter’s rights and freedoms does freedom of religion, thought, and be- lief fall under? a) Democratic freedoms b) Fundamental freedoms c) Equality rights d) Legal rights

Discussion Questions

1. Why is it difficult for Aboriginal Canadians to achieve self-government in Canada?

2. How much influence do the courts have in influencing policy-making and deciding on constitu- tional affairs?

3. What were some of the key challenges faced by both the federal and provincial governments in patriating the constitution?

Further Resources

Websites  Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/const/page-15.html

This link includes the official and fully documented Charter of Rights and Freedoms that out- lines individual sections and its corresponding right and/or freedom.

 Supreme Court of Canada http://www.scc-csc.ca/

This official Supreme Court of Canada website contains full documentation and references to all Supreme Court cases.

 The Canadian Constitution http://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/csj-sjc/just/05.html

This link provides more information on The Canadian Constitution.

 Parliament of Canada http://www.parl.gc.ca/default.aspx?Language=E

Inside Canadian Politics © Oxford University Press Canada, 2016

The official website of the Parliament of Canada, with information on parliamentary business, the House of Commons, Senate, and all its members.

 Your Guide to the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms http://www.pch.gc.ca/eng/1356631760121/1356631904950

A more abbreviated guide to the specific rights and freedoms in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

 The ’s Approach to Implementation of the Inherent Rights and the Ne- gotiation of Aboriginal Self-Government http://www.aadnc-aandc.gc.ca/eng/1100100031843/1100100031844

This website includes a detailed account of the Government of Canada’s approach to inherent rights and Aboriginal self-governing frameworks, including specific policy frameworks and nego- tiations.

 Indian Act http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/i-5/

A detailed overview of the official Indian Act including all regulations made under the Indian Act.

 The British North America Act, 1867 http://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/csj-sjc/constitution/lawreg-loireg/p1t11.html

An overview of the British North American Act of 1867, detailing the specific provisions under each section.

 Canadian of Rights http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-12.3/FullText.html

This website links to the full document of the Canadian Bill of Rights, 1960.

 The Canadian Constitutional Foundation (CCF) http://theccf.ca/

The CCF is a registered, independent charity-based organization that looks into defending a citi- zen’s rights and freedoms through education, articles, publications, conferences, and media.

Articles/Books  Adam Dodek, The Canadian Constitution (Dundurn, 2013).

Inside Canadian Politics © Oxford University Press Canada, 2016 This detailed guidebook to the Canadian Constitution includes a glossary, details on the role of the Supreme Court, a historical account of the Constitution, and complete texts of the 1867 and 1982 constitutions.

 Mary Dawson, “From the Backroom To The Front Line: Making Constitutional History or En- counters with the Constitution: , Meech Lake, and Charlottetown,” McGill Law Journal 57, no. 4 (2012): pp. 955–1000.

Mary Dawson, the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner of Canada, writes on the back- ground, challenges, and process involved with the patriation of the Constitution as well as her own personal experience with the Meech Lake and Charolottetown Accords.

 David Johansen and Phillip Rosen, “The Notwithstanding Clause of the Charter,” Library of Par- liament BP–194-E (2008) http://www.parl.gc.ca/content/lop/researchpublications/bp194-e.pdf

A paper prepared by the Parliamentary Information and Research Service that gives a content overview of Section 33’s notwithstanding clause, and its invocations and arguments for and against the clause.

 David Martin and Chris Adams, “Canadian Public Opinion Regarding Aboriginal Self- Government: Diverging Viewpoints as Found in National Survey Results,” American Review of Canadian Studies 30, no. 1 (2000): pp. 79–88.

A great article that brings together some of the key issues discussed in this chapter, including Aboriginal self-government and the challenges it faces vis-à-vis the constitution.

RSS Feeds  CanLII http://www.canlii.org/en/rss.html

 Department of Justice http://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/news-nouv/rss.html

Answers to Review Questions

Multiple Choice Questions

1. a (p. 40) 6. a (p. 60) 2. c (p. 39) 7. c (p. 67) 3. b (p. 39) 8. a (p. 64) 4. c (p. 48) 9. c (p. 71) 5. d (p. 60) 10. b (p. 72)

Inside Canadian Politics © Oxford University Press Canada, 2016