Swinhoe's Storm-Petrels at Tynemouth: New to Britain and Ireland Mark G
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Swinhoe's Storm-petrels at Tynemouth: new to Britain and Ireland Mark G. Cubitt The possibility of catching a vagrant species during a ringing session at a site on the Northumberland coast is never far from the back of one's mind during October, particularly when there is an easterly wind blowing. The concept that anything remotely similar could happen when tape-luring small numbers of European Storm-petrels Hydrobates pelagicus would have been considered, at best, fanciful prior to 23rd July 1989. Since that date, there has been an incredible series of captures of what we now know to be Swinhoe's Storm-petrels Oceanodroma monorhis. Three individuals have been involved. The first two were on 23rd and 26th July 1989. The third has, quite amazingly, been caught eight times in five consecutive years: on 6th July 1990, 30th July 1991, 29th July 1992, 21st, 28th and 29th July 1993, and 11th, 23rd and 25th July 1994. Members of our small team take it in turns to watch the nets on the rocky beach at the base of Tynemouth's north pier. Mary Carruthers had noted, with some excitement, a larger bird, stiffer-winged than the familiar European Storm- petrels, circling the nets briefly on 18th July 1989.1 immediately switched the tape to that of the presumed Leach's Storm-petrel O. leucorhoa, but the bird was not seen again, at least not that night. On our next outing, on 23rd July, Adam Hutt and I also saw a larger petrel, but this time it circled the nets once and was then caught. Having rushed over to the net, I was astounded to find that the bird did not have any white on its rump and, even in the darkness of the beach, that its outer wing feathers had white shafts. At our ringing base, in discussion with Les Hall and Keith Regan, it was clear that the bird was of the genus Oceanodroma. We recalled that a Matsudaira's Storm-petrel O. matsudairae had been claimed on a pelagic trip in the Southwest 342 [Brit. Birds 88: 342-348, July 1995] British Birds, vol. 88, no. 7, July 1995 343 Approaches, but we had no documented measurements with which to compare those taken from our bird. All of our captures were of birds attracted to the call of European Storm-petrel rather than that of Leach's. Photographs were taken of all of them (see plates 94- 96 on page 345). They were quite vocal, both prior to being caught and in the hand; we recorded the call (see fig. 1 on page 346). A blood sample was taken from the one captured in 1991. Description The following notes summarise the appearance of all three individuals: General appearance coverts blackish-brown, as remiges. Sooty-brown Oceanodroma storm-petrels. Underparts Upperparts Uniformly sooty-brown, tinged grey. Head and, to a lesser extent, nape, back, rump Underwing-coverts rusty-brown. Axillaries and upperside of tail distinctly smoky-grey. faintly barred buff. Small apparently darker area in front of each Bare parts eye. Bases of outer six primaries with white Bill, legs and feet black. Eye dark. shafts. Pale wing-bar from scapulars and inner Measurements greater coverts through outer median coverts, The measurements taken for each of the birds formed by pale-fringed feathers, to pale caught are shown in table 1. brown carpal covert. Alula and primary Table 1. Measurements (in mm) of the three Swinhoe's Storm-petrels Oceanodroma monorhis caught at Tynemouth in 1989, 1989 and 1990-94, respectively. Feature Bird 1 Bird 2 Bird 3 Wing length 167 166 164 Outer tail length 79 83 78 Inner tail length 61 66 63 Bill length 14.9 14.5 14.5 Bill depth 6.4 - 6.4 Tarsus length - - 24.4 The identification It took over three years to identify these birds positively as Swinhoe's Storm- petrels (Bretagnolle et al. 1991; Cubitt et al. 1992; Dawson 1992). We split the research into three main areas. The first area was plumage and measurements, upon which we based our first published note shortly after the first capture (Carruthers et al. 1989). This stated that they 'were either Swinhoe's Storm- petrels or a close relative'. It was the latter possibility that forced us into looking into vocalisations and DNA sequencing, which have been the other main areas of research. Our birds are very similar in size and structure to the large races of Leach's Storm-petrel, such as the British population. There are some minor size differences, such as tarsus length being greater and bill length and tail length being shorter in proportion to the size of the bird. The two most significant differences are the all-dark rump and the white on the outer six primary-feather shafts. Some races of Leach's do have dark rumps, but these races are much smaller than Swinhoe's. Individuals of the British population can have significant variation in rump coloration, but always exhibit some white. The presence of white primary shafts showing beyond the coverts is 344 Swinhoe's Storm-petrels: new to Britain and Ireland restricted within this family to Swinhoe's and Matsudaira's Storm-petrels. The latter is significantly larger, as are the other Pacific dark-rumped storm-petrels. Our birds' biometrics gave good support to the identification as Swinhoe's, but my measurements of wing length appeared to be at or beyond the extreme of those documented for Swinhoe's, thus causing some concern initially. This, though, appears to be due to differences among recorders in experience and technique of measuring maximum-chord wing lengdis. The second area of research, which took die longest time, was the analysis of cytochrome-b mitochondrial DNA sequences. Through this, we discovered that species within the family, such as Leach's and Swinhoe's, are quite distinct. The analyses also showed that our birds had identical sequences in that part of the gene to those of Swinhoe's from Korea and Russia (Dawson 1992). It is likely that vocalisations provide an important mechanism for storm-petrels to identify the species and sex of another individual in the darkness of a colony. This was the third area of research. We were fortunate that workers in Japan had recently been looking at the vocalisations of both Swinhoe's and Leach's Storm- petrels. This gave us access to recordings that were previously unavailable in the West. More importantiy, they had shown significant differences between the calls of the two species and even between sexes. This enabled them to match a recording that we had made (fig. 1 on page 346) to a sonagram of a female Korean Swinhoe's Storm-petrel. Origins Swinhoe's Storm-petrels are known to breed on islands mainly off Korea and Japan, but also west to China and north to Russia. They migrate westwards, witii the monsoons, into the western Pacific. Some move into the northern Indian Ocean and even into the Red Sea, where die first Western Palearctic record occurred in 1958. This was, perhaps, die route taken by the individual caught on Islote de Benidorm, Spain, in July 1994 (King & Minguez 1994). In order to account for the captures of seven Swinhoe's Storm-petrels in the North Atiantic since 1983, it has been suggested tiiat there may be a small breeding population in die North Atiantic. Our returning bird, however, now certainly of breeding age — but apparently still wandering — may make this theory less likely. Vagrancy is perhaps the more probable source of these birds, although the lack of records in the Western Indian Ocean makes this far from certain. References BRETAGNOLLE, V., CARRUTHERS, M. P., CUBITT, M. G., BIORET, F., & CUILLANDRE, J. P. 1991. Six captures of dark-rumped petrels in the North Eastern Atlantic. Ibis 133: 351-356. CARRUTHERS, M. P., CUBITT, M. G., & HALL, L. 1989. The dark-rumped petrels in Tyne & Wear. Birding World 2: 288-289. CUBITT, M., CARRUTHERS, M. P., & ZINO, F. 1992. Unravelling the mystery of the Tyne petrels. Birding World 5: 438-442. DAWSON, R. 1992. Blood, sweat and petrels. Birding World 5: 443-444. KING, J., & MINGUEZ, E. 1994. Swinhoe's Petrel: the first Mediterranean record. Birding World 7: 271-273. Mark G. Cubitt, 13 Dene Terrace, South Gosforth, Newcastle-upon-Tyne NE3 1QP The inclusion of plates 94- 96 in colour has been subsidised by Carl Zeiss Ltd, sponsor of the British Birds Rarities Committee. Plates 94-96. Female Swinhoe's Storm- petrel Oceanodroma monorhis, Tynemouth: above and right, July 1993 (Mark Cubitt); below, July 1994 (D. Jackson) 346 Swinhoe's Storm-petrels: new to Britain and Ireland Fig. 1. Sonagram of female Swinhoe's Storm-petrel Oceanodroma monorhis captured at Tynemouth in July 1993. EDITORIAL COMMENT Dr David Parkin, Chairman of the British Ornithologists' Union Records Committee, has commented as follows: 'This must be one of the more astonishing developments in Western Palearctic ornithology of recent decades. At several widely separate locations in the northeast Atlantic, and more or less simultaneously, a species was found that appeared to be new to the region. Not only that, but a series of records came from one site in Northumberland, on the shores of what may be the most intensively watched marine habitat in the world. Not a hint of a record in the British literature down the years, and then two in one week, three in 12 months, and a series of recaptures of one bird in successive years! 'The combination of morphology, sonagram analysis and DNA sequencing were sufficient to exclude other species, including the dark-rumped races of Leach's Storm-petrel Oceanodroma leucorhoa, and establish the identity as Swinhoe's Storm-petrel O.