EPRI Journal 1988 No. 7
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EPRI JOURNAL is published eight times each year (January/February, March, April/May, June, July/August, September, October/November, and December) by the Electric Power Research Institute. EPRI was founded in 1972 by the nation's electric utilities to develop and manage a technology program for improving electric power production, distribution, and utilization. EPRI JOURNAL Staff and Contributors Brent Barker, Editor in Chief David Dietrich, Managing Editor Ralph Whitaker, Feature Editor Taylor Moore, Senior Feature Writer David Boutacoff, Feature Writer Eugene Robinson, Technical Editor Mary Ann Garneau, Production Editor Jean Smith, Program Secretary Richard G. Claeys, Director Corporate Communications Division Graphics Consultant: Frank A. Rodriquez © 1988 by Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. Permission to reprint is granted by EPRI, provided credit to the EPRI JOURNAL is given. Information on bulk reprints available on request. Electric Power Research Institute, EPRI, and EPRI JOURNAL are registered service marks or trade marks of Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. Address correspondence to: Editor in Chief EPRI JOURNAL Electric Power Research Institute P.O. Box 10412 Palo Alto, California 94303 Please include the code number on your mailing label with correspondence concerning subscriptions. Cover: The incredible number-crunching capabilities of supercomputers have allowed scientists to mathematically model complex systems and processes that eluded them in earlier decades. Researchers hope that new supercomputing concepts will open possibilities for real-time control of the nation's highly interconnected power networks. (Photo: Topographical seismic modeling, courtesy Floating Point Systems.) EDITORIAL The Supercomputer Challenge The emergence of a new generation of supercomputers is challenging some long-held beliefs in the electric power industry concerning the suitability of meeting utility needs with large number-crunching machines. Over the last decade, most attempts to use supercomputers for such numerically intense problems as modeling regional power systems have been neither satisfactory nor economically viable. As described in this month's cover story, there exists a mismatch between the design of traditional supercomputers and the requirements of utility analysis. Now, a variety of new supercomputers are coming to market, offering wider choices in design and price. Of particular interest to utilities are relatively inexpensive array processors that can be attached to conventional computers, enabling them to act like supercomputers for particular kinds of massive numerical calculations. Another promising development is the use of many small concurrent processors, which employ what might be called the piranha approach to super computing-breaking a problem down into numerous parts that can be simultaneously attacked. Even more startling developments in mathematical techniques lie just around the corner. Expert systems, for example, may help utilities model the problem-solving techniques of their fore most experts, while neural networks learn from experience to recognize disturbance patterns in power systems and take remedial action before they lead to catastrophic failure. The computational. complexity of controlling power systems is increasing rapidly as utility networks become more interconnected and as the wheeling of power becomes more commonplace. The need for on-line analysis of voltage and transient stabilities of future power systems has been evident for some time, but only with the advent of affordable new computer technologies can such analysis be considered feasible. Much has already been learned about adapting system analysis codes for use on comput ers with innovative designs. EPRI, working through Wisconsin Electric Power Company and ESCA, Inc., has already made available for control centers the steady-state security monitoring and assess ment of both thermal and voltage conditions in complex power systems. In addition, evolution of pro cessor technology has made it possible to have real-time digital control and protection. The formidable challenge for the next decade is to build on this framework of knowledge and new computer technologies by developing the necessary software and defining the hardware needs for control centers in order to provide on-line analysis and control of dynamic conditions for increasingly complex power systems. Narain G. Hingorani Vice President, Electrical Systems Division RESEARCH UPDATE 38 FREY: A Fuel Rod Evaluation Code Following a mechanistic modeling approach, the FREY fuel rod behavior code is a valuable tool for reload licensing, plant support, and diagnostics. 40 Steam-Injected Gas Turbines Versus Combined Cycles Comparative analysis has shown that although steam � - � � - injected systems appear competitive for small applications, combined cycles are preferable for plants of 150 MW or - .. ---r ·,"'' ,':Wl,t..�i;:---�-t'll"',ll,�: -� .--.... .. ""1 larger. DJ·�f I I•"*'"' ,-. �· . .�I)"• , 16 Exploratory Research 43 New Responses to Transmission System 26 Solid Waste Challenges Increased wheeling, competition, and regulatory constraints have encouraged utilities to develop sophisticated design and analysis tools that help make the most of existing lines. 46 TOXRISK: Computerized Health Risk Assessment The TOXRISK computer program enables utility managers to estimate safe doses of potentially toxic materials and ensures that appropriate calculation procedures are being applied. 48 Decontamination of BWR Fuel Bundles Demonstrated avoidance of corrosion attack during nuclear fuel bundle decontamination has opened the door for tests of full-system decontamination using the LOMI process . DEPARTMENTS 50 Dynamic Benefits of Energy Storage 36 Tech Transfer News 55 Calendar Two new computer models are being designed to help utilities realize the operating flexibility and reliability 53 New Technical Reports 56 Authors and Articles benefits provided by energy storage systems. 55 New Computer Software EPRIJOURNAL Volume 13, Number 7 October/November 1988 EDITORIAL The Supercomputer Challenge COVER STORY 4 Supercomputers for the Utility Future New types of supercomputing machines promise to improve power system modeling and network control at a time when increased capabilities are particularly needed. FEATURES 16 Directions in Exploratory Research EPRl's growing exploratory research program is searching out and developing new areas of science that can make a difference for the future of the utility industry. 26 Energy From Waste: Recovering a Throwaway Resource Crowded landfills have brought a new urgency to the nation's waste disposal problems and new thinking about the incentives for waste-to-energy projects. 4 Supercomputers atmosphere are helping utilities provide ever, supercomputers have not pro A Multiplicity more reliable electricity service to their vided utilities with sufficient com of Machines customers. putational power to analyze highly Still, the direct use of supercomput interconnected power systems in real Once a rare and monolithic tool for only the ers by utilities has remained limited, time (i.e., on-line, as events occur). highest-priority projects, the supercomputer has even though the electric power indus At present, only an analysis of the now evolved into a whole family of powerful but try ranks as a major purchaser of most thermal limitations on power systems is less expensive machines created in a variety of other kinds of computers. Part of the routinely conducted in real time at re shapes and sizes. The addition of parallel pro explanation is that most utility business gional control centers. As power sys cessing options to the standard serial computer operations, such as sorting through tem operations become more complex, architecture has opened up the world of applica meter readings and issuing bills for ser regional control centers also need to do tions and drawn in many new manufacturers, vice, are not arithmetically complex and on-line analyses of voltage conditions who are now competing feverishly for pieces of can be handled adequately by conven and system stability. Such calculations a growing global market. tional computers. In addition, the basic are so complex, however, that today's design of most early supercomputers utility computers may take minutes made them in.efficient at solving those to simulate events that can occur in utility problems that are most computa seconds-thus precluding real-time tionally intense, such as power system analysis. modeling. "Maintaining proper voltage condi This situation may soon change tions and transient stability has become dramatically, as two trends in the com a serious concern for many utilities," puter industry begin to make super says Robert Iveson, technical adviser in computing much more attractive for EPRI's Electrical Systems Division. "Not electric utility applications. First, a vari being able to do the calculations on ety of fundamentally new concepts are these parameters in real time intro being introduced into supercomputer duces unnecessary conservatism in de design, including some that are imme sign and increases margins of safety. diately applicable to power system For today's requirements, we need to modeling. Second, new software tech have both calculations done on-line at niques are providing approaches to control centers." solving utility problems that take better EPRI began exploring ways to im advantage of the new supercomputer prove