Poles Against the Slander
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SPECIAL SUPLEMENT PART V – CONFERENCE: Poles against the Slander 1st Session: The 2nd Session: The 3rd Session: Dimensions 4th Session: Is law concept of Hecatomb scale of Holocaust of Polonophobia a weapon? Co-financed with resources from the Justice Fund managed by the Minister of Justice Organizer Media patronage TYGODNIK LISICKIEGO HISTORIA POLISH HECATOMB AND FIGHT AGAINST POLONOPHOBIA Cemetery of Poles shot by Germans in Palmiry near Warsaw PHOTOGRAPHER: RAFAŁ DZIOREK/ADOBE STOCK TABLE OF CONTENTS 2–4 BACKGROUND INFORMATION 5–7 1ST SESSION: 8–11 2ND SESSION: 12–14 3RD SESSION: Polish remembrance The concept of Hecatomb The scale of Holocaust Dimensions of Polonophobia Western elites do not per- Sometimes historians need Neither Polish village leaders The Germans see themselves ceive Holocaust as degenera- a great synthesis, a single nor Judenrat chairmen in the as a therapist in relation to a tion of the Christian tradition concept to describe a given ghettos were the volunteers patient. We are to be cured but as its culmination. It phenomenon. The very con- of Shoah. In both cases, they of Polishness. This is a new started at Calvary and ended cept of "hecatomb" has been were forced to cooperate with stage of Polonophobia: fear of in Auschwitz… invented brilliantly Germans the Polishness "disease" 2 WWW . DORZECZY. PL DO RZECZY TYGODNIK LISICKIEGO POLISH HECATOMB AND FIGHT AGAINST POLONOPHOBIA HISTORIA Question of honour n the face of Almighty God and Saint Mary the Queen of the Polish Crown, I put my hands on this holy cross, a sign of passion and Salvation. I swear to remain faithful to my Homeland, the IRepublic of Poland, and promise to steadfastly protect its honor my life …” - these words are the essence of the oath taken since 1942 and fight for its liberation with all my strength, until the sacrifice of life…” – I recalled this phrase on the 29th of October this year, during by the soldiers joining the Home Army. „Until the sacrifice of my abecomes conference darkened devoted by to a sinisterHECATOMB shadow as a of description Polonophobia of the that sacrifice acts by madefair means by our or nation foul. during the Second World War. This sacrifice and later to other gods as well. As the ages went by, it became "a great In ancient Greece, Hecatomb was a great sacrifice offered to Zeus, sacrificeoath? It wasto a causethe „honour” that led and to the „freedom”. death of Not many only people". Polish Whatsoldiers was (is?)but also the othercause Polesworth died the forsacrifice the right of life, to maintainas stated honorin the Homeand for Army’s liberation - the victims also included women and children, killed only because they belonged to the Polish nation. Those considered by the German and Soviet occupants and other enemies to be the Polish elite - people who were the most diligent, idealistic, devoted to both the national and local community, willing to help other members of our society, were particularly persistently persecuted . We wrote about it in the previous four parts of the "Hecatomb of the Poles" series. We also wrote about accusing us as a nation of participation in horrible crimes committed by others - especially in the extermination of Jews against libel published in the foreign historical policy statements. - whichToday's is a reportgreat slander, from the and conference about law "Polish used as Hecatomb a weapon and in the fight Fight against Polonophobia" ends that cycle and sums it up to who opened that meeting of excellent historians and journalists, a certain extent. Paweł Lisicki, editor-in-chief of Do Rzeczy weekly, called the suffering inflicted on Poles a hecatomb. Suffering that waspresent wrongly situation and resultingintentionally from marginalized. the confusion Referring that arose to whenthis, the the Minister of Justice Zbigniew Ziobro compared, among others, the countermeasures against Polonophobia, to the situation in 2006, Lowerwhen a Chamber similar resolution of Polish Parliamentof the Senate attempted was adopted to impose without statutory any problems. Something happened during these years ... - he said, stating that fact. The situation is the more dramatic, the more the passivity towards the Holocaust, which we were accused of earlier, turns into accusation of its accomplishment. The Minister referred speech of Professor Yehuda Bauer from the early '70s. We should 4TH SESSION: REDAKCJA: 15–17 Redaktor: Maciej Rosalak tonotice the wordsthat already of Professor then the Norman Israeli Davies,historian who proposed recently to recalled carry out the Is law a weapon? the Holocaust research based on a division into three elements: 1. Z ZESpołem: the perpetrators, 2. the victims, 3. passive witnesses. The perpetra- Studio graficzne: global image of Poland during Wojciech Niedzielko (grafik prowadzący), Deliberatethe last war deterioration can lead to highly of the Jakub Tański (grafik), passive observers. Jacek Nadratowski (DTP) Fotoedycja: Edyta Bortnowska, Przemysław Traczyk torsWell, were currently Nazis (not Holocaust Germans!), researchers victims werefrom Jews,Poland, and who Poles have were Korekta: Anna Zalewska consequences for our country Okładka: Wojciech Stróżyk/REPORTER dangerous legal and financial creativelyconference. developed It's worth the knowing. Bauer’s ©concept, ℗ and assign... PolesMaciej to Rosalakthe 3 first category, make a career abroad! This was also discussed at the 18–24 XI 2019 4 7/ 2 0 1 9 HISTORIA POLISH HECATOMB AND FIGHT AGAINST POLONOPHOBIA Poland‘s remembrance of the victims robably only few remember perversion or denial of the tradition nationalities - Germans, Ukrainians, of the European Christianity, but as Russians, and Jews, who saved its culmination, almost complete Poles? Why not think about one PAWeł liSICKI theKomorowski, first question the askedthen in by- and necessary. What started at the Polish name for the suffering of our PcumbentAndrzej President Duda of to the Bronisław Republic nation? If the world knows the term of Poland, during the presidential the basic principle of that reaso- Holocaust, why not make effort to debate in 2015. It was quite surpri- Calvaryning. According ended at to Auschwitz that way of– thisthin is- introduce one concept covering all sing. The current President raised king, the Holocaust is a universal crimes against Poles? In June 2015, the question of a harmful statement symbol of human suffering, the sole I suggested such term, namely, the made by the then President Komo- and model crime. Hecatomb. This is the best key term. rowski, who, while addressing the Whoever thinks in this way will When speaking of the Hecatomb, participants of the celebration in not be able to notice the autono- we would mean the fate of those Jedwabne at the beginning of his mous, equally innocent and equally Poles who lost their lives in 1937- important suffering of other na- 1953 for being Poles. Those who the Poles sometimes were "a nation tions. The solidarity of the victims were killed by the Soviets and those termof perpetrators". of office, said that in the past, of totalitarian systems – Hitlerism who were murdered by German Such words were nothing new. and communism - disappears. The infamous apology made by slaughterers. battle for remembrance and for the NazisTwo and of finallythe best-known Ukrainian modern UPA had a similar tone. Politicians' self- Instead, we are dealing with a fierce - Aleksandercondemnation Kwaśniewski is the grist into 2001the and who suffered less. And what is ghern, a mass crime against Arme- mill for Poland's enemies - all those, final decision who suffered more examplesnians committed of genocide by Turks, are Medz and theJe remembrance of the Holocaust is Holocaust, a mass murder of Jews prove that Poles as a nation were worse,highly detrimental such universalization to the remem of the- by the German Third Reich. In both ledaccomplices by Jan Tomasz of the Gross, Holocaust, who tryor, to cases, the perpetrator, the motives, who like Jan Grabowski, hold Poles Thus, crimes against Poles can and the timing can be clearly identi- brancebecome of a othermere nations’postscript suffering. to the Holocaust. Poles are judged on one experience arises from the fact that criterion only: whether they have fied.the executioners The unique natureof Poles of were the Polish both When speaking of the Hecatomb, we would crimes against Jews. Hence, we ideological background was also mean the fate of those Poles who lost their sufficientlyhave this endless counteracted discussion German in Sovietdifferent, and although Nazi criminals. in each Theircase, lives in 1937-1953 for being Poles. which one party claims that Poles their intention was essentially to have done a lot and refers to the destroy the nation. Finally, unlike in liable for mass crimes against Jews. number of Polish trees planted for the case of Armenians or Jews, cri- The special place of the Holo- the Righteous Among the Nations, mes against Poles lasted longer and caust in the memory of Western while the other party accuses and the scale of their severity varied. elites did not come out of nowhere. condemns, claiming that there was Soviets committed them secretly, I wrote about it many times - it is not enough Polish help and too while Germans in public. Poles died the effect of hard work of some many acts of denial and collabo- not as a persecuted minority, but Jewish elites. From their point of ration. Given the distribution of as a group considered, as a rule, view, to which they were able to power in the media, the proponents dangerous, rebellious, striving for convince global public opinion, - sovereignty and independence. the Second World War essentially sition in advance. You could always The creation of such single boils down to the Holocaust. There ofdo the more, first it view is obvious. are put Particularly, in a lost po concept covering all crimes against is only one category of victims, all if you evaluate these attitudes from Poles will not only facilitate the the present, comfortable and safe spreading of knowledge of the the well-known Hungarian intel- perspective.