The Passion of St. Domnius: the Tradition of Apostolic Succession in Dalmatia

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Passion of St. Domnius: the Tradition of Apostolic Succession in Dalmatia Vadim B. Prozorov Moscow THE PASSION OF ST. DOMNIUS: THE TRADITION OF APOSTOLIC SUCCESSION IN DALMATIA St. Domnius (Lat. Domnius, Domnio, Ital. Doimo, Croat Dujam, Duje) was, in fact still is, the holy protector of the metropolis of Salona-Spalato. Late antique Salona, the capital city of the Roman province of Dalmatia was a very important Christian centre in the Mediterranean region without any exaggeration comparable with Ravenna and Aquileia in Italy.1 Spalato (Croat Split) originated very close to ancient Salona and indeed was her successor in respect to ecclesiastical authority when Salona perished in the seventh century. The early history of the Church of Salona is mainly known due two me- dieval Histories — the History of Archbishops of Salona and Spalato written in the mid-thirteenth century by Archdeacon Thomas of Spalato and the anony- mous History of Archbishops of Salona whose earliest manuscript dates back to the early sixteenth century. The latter finishes its narrative in 1185 while the former continues to the middle of the thirteenth century. Both texts are almost identical except some vital interpolations added to the History of Arch- bishops of Salona. Both Histories, the common text as well as supplementary documents, glorified the Church of Spalato and enhanced its apostolic foundation and old metropolitan status. Who else but a bishop-saint, a bishop-martyr could be a more positive proof of the apostolicity of this Church! And indeed the Histories appeal to this figure of a saintly and apostolic founder — St. Dom- 1 See an overview of early Christian antiquities in Salona in E. DYGGVE, History of Salonitan Christianity (Oslo, 1951) (Instituttet for sammenlignende Kulturforskning. Serie A: Forelesninger 21). Besides, there are following useful reports: Forschungen in Salona, veröffentlicht vom Österreichischen Archäologischen Institute. 3 vols. (Vien- na, 1917–1939); Recherches à Salone, publié aux frais de la Fondation Rask-Ørsted. 2 vols. (Copenhague, 1928–33); E. CECI, I Monumenti cristiani di Salona (Milan, 1963); Excavations at Salona, Yugoslavia, 1969–1972 / Conducted for the Depart- ment of Classics, Douglass College, Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, by Ch. W. CLAIRMONT, with the collaboration of S. HANDLER AUTH, V. VON GONZENBACH (Park Ridge, N. J., c1975); Salona Christiana (Arheološki muzej — Split, 25.9– 31.10.1994) / Ed. E. MARIN (Split, 1994); Salona: recherches archéologiques franco- croates à Salone / Conduites par le Centre A. Merlin (C.N.R.S., Paris — Sorbonne) et le Musée archéologique de Split, dirigées par N. Duval et E. Marin. 3 vols. (Rome— Split, 1994–2000). Downloaded from Brill.com09/29/2021 02:33:37AM via free access 220 Scrinium II (2006). Universum Hagiographicum nius. Thomas of Spalato reported only basic facts about Salona’s patron saint.2 His more elaborate Passion was inserted among the supplementary docu- ments in the History of Archbishops of Salona (see appendix).3 According to the Passion, Domnius, a native Syrian from Antioch, was sent to Salona by St. Peter the Apostle immediately after St. Titus had been there. The latter’s mission is mentioned in St. Paul’s Second Letter to Ti- mothy (4.11). At the same time as Domnius Pancratius was dispatched to Sicily, Apollinaris went to Ravenna and Marcus — to Aquileia. Domnius successfully preached in Dalmatia and erected here the first church which he dedicated to genetrix Dei (Mother of God). Disturbed by his progress pagan priests accused Domnius before prefectus urbis Maurilius, lamenting that he was seducing people to overthrow cults of pagan gods. The prefect had him imprisoned and tortured. As all his strict measures failed to make Domnius reject the Christian faith Maurilius tried to bribe him, but the saint was ada- mant and determined to be a martyr. Meanwhile Salonitan Christians support- ing the holy prisoner raised a revolt and many of them were executed by the order of the prefect. At this point the Passion turns to St. Domnius’s miracu- lous power and reports that the prefect along with some prominent citizens of Salona had to approach Domnius asking him to raise from the dead a son of a certain noble widow. Condemning Maurilius’s hypocrisy Domnius worked this miracle. Consequently the number of converts into Christianity increas- ed further. Annoyed pagan priests bribed Maurilius and even threatened him to be punished according to the Roman legislation. Finally, as the Passion goes, Maurilius promulgated the law that sentenced Domnius to death, and the saintly bishop was beheaded. The story of St. Domnius is very simple and recognizable but the back- ground of the Passion is very dim. It caused many questions. First, when did the martyrdom actually take place? Second, when was the Passion compil- ed? And third, when was the cult of St. Domnius tied with St. Peter, i. e. to what time the tradition of apostolic foundation can be ascribed? If the first question can be easily answered, the second and the third ones are more comp- licated since we do not have any positive indication of when the Passion was compiled and when the apostolic legend emerged, and can only suggest some moments in history when the compilation and further development of the legend were most possible. The ancient tradition attributed St. Domnius’s mission to the second half of the first century, and his martyrdom to the time of Emperor Trajan (to be 2 THOMAS ARCHIDIACONUS, Historia Salonitana / Ed. F. RAÈKI (Zagreb, 1894) (Mo- numenta spectantia historiam slavorum meridionalium 26) 89. 3 Historia Salonitana maior / Ed. N. KLAIÆ (Belgrade, 1967) 73–75. In fact, seve- ral later versions of the Passion are extant. In general they demonstrate a close simi- larity. D. FARLATI, Illyricum sacrum (Venice, 1751) Vol. 1. 412–427. Downloaded from Brill.com09/29/2021 02:33:37AM via free access V. B. Prozorov 221 more precise his death was fixed in 107).4 But if all the information available to us is deployed it is obvious that Domnius was martyred sometime under Emperor Diocletian. The grounds for this certainly were found in the text of his Passion. While some names here perhaps have symbolic meanings5 the others can be ascrib- ed to real persons. The strongest argument in favour of the martyrdom of the holy protector of Salona in the fourth century is the fact that so-called Prefect Maurilius of Rome who ordered to execute the saint was found in the list of the governors (presides) of Salona under Emperor Diocletian (between 299– 304). His real name was Ì. Aurelius Iulius and thus he can be easily identi- fied as Domnius’s prosecutor Maurilius.6 4 FARLATI, Illyricum sacrum... Vol. 1. 432. 5 Domnius’s mother’s name is Migdonia which is probably connected with Ma- cedonia, since she is said to be Greek by birth and Mygdonia was a region to the north of modern Thessaloniki (J. ZEILLER, Les origines chrétiénnes dans les provinces romaine de Dalmatie (Paris, 1906) (Bibliothèque de l’École des Hautes Études. Scien- ces historiques et philologiques 155) 28) or with a region around Antioch (Nisibis) which was named after Greek Mygdonia under Alexander the Great (Der Neue Pauly Enzyklopädie der Antike (Stuttgart—Weimar, 2000) Vol. 8. Col. 569). Domnius is said to have been born in Syria and some names of immigrants from Nisibis were discovered on the funeral tombs in Salona (A. CARAMANEO-MATIASSEVICH, Riflessioni sopra l’istoria di S. Dojmo primo vescovo di Salona e martire // Supplemento al Bullettino di arheologia e storia dalmata (hereafter BASD) 23/12 (1900) 5; DYGGVE, History of Salonitan Christianity… 25–30, 81–82, 100, 134; G. ALFÖLDI, Bevölke- rung und Gesellschaft der römischen Provinz Dalmatien. Mit einem Beitrag von Andras Moscy (Budapest, 1965) 83, 113; J. NIKOLAJEVIÆ, O poreklu orijentalnih uticaja u ranokræanskoj umetnosti u Dalmaciji [On Roots of Oriental Influences on Early Christian Art in Dalmatia] // Çáîðíèê ðàäîâà ôèëîñîôñêîã ôàêóëòåòà 12 (1974) 125–126). The name of a pagan philosopher Pyrgus who had disputes with Domnius can be derived from the Greek word ¿ ðýñãïò (a tower, a dice-box). The name of a late Roman patrician Diginanus (Dignatius in a later version) whose child was raised from the dead by Domnius could come from the Latin word dignitas and indicate his noble status, although the family of Dignatii was known in Rome. His widow’s name Febronia can be associated with the Latin word febris (fever) and symbolize the ill- ness and death of her child (I. BABIÆ, Splitske uspomene na salonitanske kršcanske starine [Spalato’s Memories of Christian Salonitan Antiquities] // Vjesnik za arheo- logiju i historiju dalmatinsku (hereafter VAHD) 85 (1992) 50). The name of Theodo- sius, Domnius’s father, can also have a symbolic significance, at the same time it is a real name although almost unknown in the first century. 6 F. BULIÆ, M. Aurelius Julus. Praeses provinciae Dalmatiae // BASD 38 (1914) 118–119. The confusing reading Julus suggested by Bulic was corrected into Julius (see Cambi’s conclusion in F. BULIÆ, Izabrani spisi [Collected Papers] / Ed. N. CAMBI (Split, 1984) 633). A. JAGENTEUFEL, Die Statthalter der römischen Provinz Dalmatia von Augustus bis Diokletian (Vienna, 1958) (Österreichische Akademie der Wissen- schaften. Schriften der Balkankommission. Antiquarische Abteilung 12) 105, 107, Downloaded from Brill.com09/29/2021 02:33:37AM via free access 222 Scrinium II (2006). Universum Hagiographicum Further in the Prologi Paschae ad Vitalem Anni CCCXCV, whose earliest manuscript (Ms. Köln) dates from 798–805, St. Domnius was mentioned as a martyr of the late third century. It says: «In the seventh year of the consul- ship of Diocletian and in the sixth year of the consulship of Maximian (that is 299. — V. P .) Christians suffered the sixth persecution.
Recommended publications
  • Your Cruise the Best of Croatia
    The best of Croatia From 8/26/2022 From Venice Ship: LE JACQUES CARTIER to 9/2/2022 to Venice Discover the beauty of the Adriatic with PONANT on an exceptional 8-day cruise in Croatia and Monténégro. Aboard Le Jacques-Cartier, fall under the spell of the hidden treasures of the Dalmatian coast and its turquoise waters. Your voyage will begin in Italy with an embarkationVenice in . An opportunity to discover or rediscover the sublime city of the Doges, with its many canals, its vaporetti and its mythical gondolas. Le Jacques-Cartier will then call at Korcula, full of olive groves, vineyards and ancient buildings. An island marked by history, the birthplace of the explorer Marco Polo. Split will open its doors to you to discover its historic centre,UNESCO a World Heritage Site, with treasures such as Diocletian's Palace or the Cathedral of Saint Domnius. You will then head to the aptly named “Pearl of the Adriatic”, Dubrovnik, a UNESCO World Heritage site. Surrounded by medieval ramparts, its terracotta-tiled roofs, its palaces, cloisters and fountains are bound to impress you and will plunge you into the heart of Croatian history. Your ship will then set sail towards Montenegro, for an unforgettable cruise in the Bay of Kotor. This impressive gap between two mountain ranges is home to a veritable inland lake with a magical atmosphere; the medieval city of Kotor and its many historical monuments are its jewels. After a stop on the magnificent island of Hvar, the last stage of your trip will take you to Rovinj, giving you an opportunity to discover this city with Venetian influences.
    [Show full text]
  • The University of Split the Catholic Faculty of Theology
    THE UNIVERSITY OF SPLIT THE CATHOLIC FACULTY OF THEOLOGY THE UNIVERSITY OF SPLIT THE CATHOLIC FACULTY OF THEOLOGY ACADEMIC CALENDAR 2015/2016 Split, October 2015. A CIP catalogue record for this leaflet is available at the Split University Library UDC 378.096:271.3>(497.5 Split) The Catholic Faculty of Theology (Split) Academic Calendar 2015/2016/ the University of Split, The Catholic Faculty of Theology/ <editor Jadranka Garmaz>. - Split: The Catholic Faculty of Theology, 2015. ISBN 978-953-256-078-7 1. Garmaz, Jadranka 160106052 Academic Calendar 2015/2016 The Catholic Faculty of Theology of the University of Split, Managing Editor: Associate professor, Jadranka Garmaz, Ph.D. Editor in Chief: Full professor Ante Mateljan, Ph.D. (the dean) Computer Typeset: Paola Jukic English edition: Angelina Gaspar Publisher: Dalmacija papir, Split CONTENTS General information about the Faculty.................................................................................. 6 History ................................................................................................. 7 The University of Split .......................................................................................... 10 Organization of the Catholic Faculty of Theology • Authority, government, offices and services ............................................................11 • Teachers listed according to their title and appointment rank ................................13 • Chairs and head of chairs ................................................................. 15 •
    [Show full text]
  • Split-Riviera-HR-SLO-PL-RU-CZ.Pdf
    HR SLO PL RU CZ Kroz upečatljiv spoj S presenetljivo kombinacijo Przez imponujące połączenie Впечатляющее соединение Díky působivému spojení UNESCO-m zaštićene zaščitene arhitekturne chronionego przez UNESCO строительного наследия под UNESCO-em chráněným graditeljske baštine i raskoši dediščine UNESCA in razkošja dorobku architektonicznego i защитой ЮНЕСКО, роскоши architektonickým dědictvím a tradicije, slikovitih plaža tradicije, slikovitih plaž, uroków tradycji, malowniczych традиции, живописных vznešenosti tradice, malebným uronjenih u bistro plavetnilo potopljenih v jasno modrino plaż zanurzonych w пляжей, погруженных plážím, ponořených do jasné Jadrana i kulturnih poslastica Jadrana, in kulturnih poslastic, przejrzystym błękicie Adriatyku в прозрачную синеву modře Jadranu a kulturním koje su tek točka na »i« ki so pravzaprav pika na »i« oraz kulturowych smakołyków, Адриатики, культурных delikatesám, které jsou jen izvornom i gotovo filmskom izvornemu in skoraj filmskemu będących kropką nad »i« деликатес, являющихся tečkou na »i« na původní ozračju svakodnevice ovoga vzdušju vsakdanjika tega kraja, oryginalnej i niemalże filmowej глазурей для оригинальной a téměř filmové atmosféře kraja, Splitska rivijera nudi ono Splitska riviera ponuja tisto atmosfery życia codziennego и почти фильмовой všedního dne tohoto kraje, najbolje od Mediterana. najboljše od Mediterana. tego regionu, Riwiera Splitska атмосферы повседневной nabízí Splitská riviéra to ma do zaoferowana to co жизни этого края, Ривьера nejlepší ze Středomoří. Pridodamo li nizu
    [Show full text]
  • 2 TIMOTHY 2:1-3 ENSURING a FUTURE for the FAITH “You
    2 TIMOTHY 2:1-3 ENSURING A FUTURE FOR THE FAITH “You then, my child, be strengthened by the grace that is in Christ Jesus, and what you have heard from me in the presence of many witnesses entrust to faithful men who will be able to teach others also. Share in suffering as a good soldier of Christ Jesus.”1 postolic succession is essential to a healthy church. However, whenever we speak of “apostolic succession,” it is important to define what is meant. When I speak of apostolic A succession, I imply adherence to the model provided in Scripture. I do not refer to the aberrations, however popular they may be, that occur in contemporary church life. By “apostolic succession,” I mean that there is a continuation of the Apostles’ doctrine, the apostolic message. Our Catholic friends, Orthodox Christians and numerous Protestant communions as well, hold to what they call “apostolic succession.” By this term these religions infer that they depend upon being able to trace the ordination of priests back to Peter; this is succession of the office. Tragically, we are aware of the scandals that have marked many of the churches holding to this particular aberration. Those who perpetuated and attempted to cover over crimes which were committed by priests were certainly not living as Peter would have lived. It is obvious that God could not approve of their actions. They would argue, however, that because of succession of ordination leading back to Peter, then doctrine and full fellowship are ensured.2 Among some evangelical churches, and especially touted by certain Baptist groups, a form of apostolic succession that has caused great harm to the cause of Christ is promoted.
    [Show full text]
  • Century 1 © 1989 -2011 by Timothy Ministries Contemporary Events the Church
    The Mustard Christian Centuries Time Line Seed Story A BC to AD Course Century 1 © 1989 -2011 By Timothy Ministries Contemporary Events The Church 63 BC to AD 66 Israel ruled by Rome. 14 Augustus dies. 14-37 Tiberius Caesar. 22-220 Later Han Dynasty, China. 33 Death and resurrection of Je- 37-41 Gaius Caligula. sus Christ. 41-54 Claudius Caesar. 34 Conversion of Saul of Tarsus. 43 Rome conquers Southern Brit- 34-37 Paul in Damascus/Arabia. ain, London founded. 44 James son of Zebedee martyred. 47 Paul’s missionary journeys begin. 47 Birth of Plutarch. 48 Jews no longer majority of Chris- 50 Gothic kingdom set up on tian believers. Lower Vistoula. 49 Jews in Rome riot against Jewish 54-68 Nero. believers and are expelled from 64 Burning of city. Rome. 50 Jerusalem Council. 66-73 Jewish-Roman 50-66 Paul’s letters. War. Holy Land 56 Paul’s arrival and arrest in Jeru- Christians refuse salem (Acts 21). to join nationalist 59-60 Paul sailed to Roman imprison- movement. ment. Acts written. 69-79 Vespasian. 60 Matthew martyred. 70 Jerusalem destroyed. 63,64 1 & 2 Peter written. 73 Fall of Masada. 64 Nero persecutes Christians in 79-81 Titus. Rome, martyrdom of Peter. 79 Vesuvius erupts. 67 Paul beheaded in Rome, Linus 81-96 Domitian. becomes bishop of Rome. 90 Birkat ha- 80-90 Christians slandered and perse- Minim: ritual cuted in province of Asia (Rev 2.9; Jewish curse 3.9). against Chris- 88-97 Clement (ˈklĕ-mənt) bishop of tians and other Rome.
    [Show full text]
  • The Cult of Saint Jerome in Dalmatia in The
    Ines Ivić THE CULT OF SAINT JEROME IN DALMATIA IN THE FIFTEENTH AND THE SIXTEENTH CENTURIES MA Thesis in Medieval Studies Central European University CEU eTD Collection Budapest May 2016 THE CULT OF SAINT JEROME IN DALMATIA IN THE FIFTEENTH AND THE SIXTEENTH CENTURIES by Ines Ivić (Croatia) Thesis submitted to the Department of Medieval Studies, Central European University, Budapest, in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the Master of Arts degree in Medieval Studies. Accepted in conformance with the standards of the CEU. ____________________________________________ Chair, Examination Committee ____________________________________________ Thesis Supervisor ____________________________________________ Examiner CEU eTD Collection ____________________________________________ Examiner Budapest May 2016 THE CULT OF SAINT JEROME IN DALMATIA IN THE FIFTEENTH AND THE SIXTEENTH CENTURIES by Ines Ivić (Croatia) Thesis submitted to the Department of Medieval Studies, Central European University, Budapest, in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the Master of Arts degree in Medieval Studies. Accepted in conformance with the standards of the CEU. ____________________________________________ External Reader CEU eTD Collection Budapest May 2016 THE CULT OF SAINT JEROME IN DALMATIA IN THE FIFTEENTH AND THE SIXTEENTH CENTURIES by Ines Ivić (Croatia) Thesis submitted to the Department of Medieval Studies, Central European University, Budapest, in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the Master of Arts degree in Medieval Studies. Accepted in conformance with the standards of the CEU. ____________________________________________ External Supervisor CEU eTD Collection Budapest May 2016 I, the undersigned, Ines Ivić, candidate for the MA degree in Medieval Studies, declare herewith that the present thesis is exclusively my own work, based on my research and only such external information as properly credited in notes and bibliography.
    [Show full text]
  • The Responses of Pope Nicholas I to the Questions of the Bulgars AD
    The Responses of Pope Nicholas I to the Questions of the Bulgars A.D. 866 (Letter 99) Translated by W. L. North from the edition of Ernest Perels, in MGH Epistolae VI, Berlin, 1925, pp.568-600. Introduction Since the sixth century, the Bulgars had known intermittent contact with the Christians of the surrounding nations, whether as merchants or prisoners-of-war or through diplomatic relations. During the later eighth and early ninth century, the Christian population in Bulgar lands increased so much that Christians were rumored to have influence at the court of Khan Krum (802-814); they were also persecuted under Khan Omortag (814-31). The Bulgars continued to remain "officially" pagan until the reign of Khan Boris, who came to power around 852. Several factors may have led Khan Boris to assume a more favorable attitude towards Christianity. First, Christianity offered a belief-system that transcended — at least potentially — cultural or ethnic boundaries and thereby offered a means not only to unify Bulgaria's disparate populations but also to secure legitimacy and respect with Byzantium and the West. The ideology of Christian rulership also enhanced the position of the prince vis-à-vis his subjects including the often contentious boyars. Furthermore, Boris' sister had converted to Christianity while a hostage in Constantinople and may have influenced her brother. Finally, Boris himself seems to have been attracted to Christian beliefs and practices, as evidenced by the seriousness with which he pursued the conversion of his people. Boris' move towards Christianity seems to have begun in earnest with the opening of negotiations in 862 between himself and Louis the German for an alliance against Ratislav of Moravia.
    [Show full text]
  • Papal Primacy Church and Papal Infallibility Apostolic Succession
    The Catholic Faith Papal Primacy Papal Primacy Compare Matthew 16:13-19 with Isaiah 22:19-22. Papacy: The supreme jurisdiction and ministry of the Pope as shepherd of the whole Church. As successor of St. Peter, and therefore Bishop of Rome and Vicar of Christ, the Pope is the perpetual and visible principle of unity in faith and communion in the Church (CCC 882). Primacy (Pope): The successor of St. Peter as Bishop of Rome and Supreme Pontiff of the universal Catholic Church. The Pope exercises a primacy of authority as Vicar of Christ and shepherd of the whole Church; he receives the divine assistance promised by Christ to the Church when he defines infallibly a doctrine of faith or morals (CCC 880-882). Church and Papal Infallibility Infallibility: The gift of the Holy Spirit to the Church whereby the pastors of the Church, the pope and bishops in union with him, can definitively proclaim a doctrine of faith or morals for the belief of the faithful (CCC 891). This gift is related to the inability of the whole body of the faithful to err in matters of faith and morals (CCC 92). Magisterium: The living, teaching office of the Church, whose task it is to give as authentic interpretation of the word of God, whether in its written form (Sacred Scripture), or in the form of Tradition. The Magisterium ensures the Church’s fidelity to the teaching of the Apostles in matters of faith and morals (CCC 85, 890, 2033). Apostolic Succession Apostolic Succession: The handing on of apostolic preaching and authority from the Apostles to their successors the bishops through the laying on of hands, as a permanent office in the Church (CCC 77, 861).
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 13 Protestant Christianity - Teaching Tips
    Sullivan, Religions of the World (Fortress Press, 2013) Chapter 13 Protestant Christianity - Teaching Tips Chapters 11-13 could be taught in a comparative sense, since the Eastern Orthodox, Roman Catholics and Protestants wrestled with some of the same issues. They obviously did not agree on a number of the issues and hence the division. The student however could be best served by looking at the similarities and differences. For this reason the same comparative grid that was used in Chapter 12 is also useful for this chapter. Here is a suggested outline to get your started: Doctrinal or Practical Roman Catholic Eastern Orthodox Protestants Emphasis Apostolic Succession All Popes must have They believe that this Most protestants focus some direct line to doctrine ensures an on continuity with the either Peter or Paul, unbroken line from teachings of the the early apostles Christ to church apostles as opposed to leaders direct succession from the apostles Clergy A very patriarchal Priests and Bishops Most Protestants do system where all must be male, but not require celibacy as clergies are males. deacons can be a condition to become They must also be women. This order a minister. Some celibate. however is dormant. churches practice Priests and deacons female ordination, may marry before including some ordination but not Anglicans. after. Bishops, on the other hand, must be celibate. The Eucharist Catholics believe In the Orthodox For most protestants similar to Orthodox church the Eucharist the Eucharist is seen on the Eucharist. The takes on heightened as an ordinance. This Eucharist is known as mystery.
    [Show full text]
  • One True Church by Holy Scripture by Apostolic Succession by Church
    Simple extensional proof of the Catholic Church claims to be the One True Church One True Church By By By By Common sense Holy Scripture Apostolic Succession Church Fathers and Reason Hundreds of genuine Jesus said in Matt. 16:18 There is a well Jesus Christ said in Matt historical documents the gates of hell shall not documented unbroken 16:18 that the gates of exists today written by prevail against his line of Popes from St. hell shall not prevail many writers from the church. That is his Peter on, down against his church. If hell 1st century and onwards church can never be through every century succeeded and his and are available to all destroyed. to the present 265th church fell away or for reading. Pope. apostatized in century X, then it makes Jesus Christ a liar. Matthew 28:20 "I will Sample writings which be with you always, to mention the Catholic Where were all the the end of the age"-That By the time St. John church: 30,000+ existing man is there will never be a finished the book of made churches before time when the church is revelation in 100AD, St. Ignatius of Antioch the 16th century? not. Implies perpetuity. the Catholic church (35-110AD) wrote of the was already into its Catholic church by name 5th Pope. in 110AD in his letter to All the 30,000+ non- the Smyrneans Catholic sects post 16th John 16:13 "the Holy 1. Peter 30-67AD century, are man made Spirit will teach you all 2.
    [Show full text]
  • A New Theory of Apostolic Succession
    A New Theory of Apostolic Succession R. F. HETTLINGER MONG the few general agreements reached in the course of the long A and continuing debate on apostolic succession has been the conclusion that the earliest doctrine of episcopal succession affirms a continuity of teaching office rather than of sacramental grace. C. H. Turner in a famous essay thus described the idea of succession held by Irenaeus: The bishop of any Christian church is the head and representative of his flock, and has been regularly and openly put into possession of the cathedra or teaching chair, in succession to a predecessor who had in turn been recog­ nized in his time as the one proper possessor of the chair-and so on right back to the foundation of the particular local church.1 It is characteristic of this early period that the bishop traces his succession not ( as in later Western practice) through the bishops who consecrated him but through his predecessors in office. As Dr. A. J. Mason pointed out in the same volume, Irenaeus conceived of truth as abiding in the whole Church, "not in the line of bishops who govern it", although they are "the representatives of their Churches, and the responsible guardians of their traditions".2 In more recent years Dom Gregory Dix acknowledged that "There is in this way of reckoning the matter no emphasis whatever on the sacramental 'succession' of a bishop to those bishops from other Churches who had consecrated him to the episcopate by the laying on of hands" .3 The point at which the later conception of succession, in which the bishop is regarded as the recipient of a special charisma for government or for sacramental validity, replaced the more primitive idea is still a matter of disagreement among scholars, although most authorities agree that some such change took place in the latter years of the second century or in the first quarter of the third.4 The importance of this change of emphasis has also been variously estimated.
    [Show full text]
  • Letters of Gelasius and Nicholas I on Papal Authority
    Manipulating the Message: Letters of Gelasius and Nicholas I on Papal Authority BRONWEN NEIL Macquarie University Abstract: Gelasius I, bishop of Rome during the problematic period of Odoacer’s re- placement as rex Italiae in 493, was greatly concerned with the power of the bishop of Rome. While Gelasius was one of the most significant bishops of the first five hundred years of the Roman church, he is primarily known for his letter to the Byzantine em- peror Anastasius in 494. His Epistula 12 introduced the controversial theory of “two powers” or “two swords.” The idea was taken up in the mid-ninth century by another champion for papal primacy, when Nicholas I embedded a quote from Gelasius in his denunciation of the Byzantine emperor Michael III. I examine the use of political rhet- oric in ecclesiastical contexts in late antiquity and the early Middle Ages, in particular the way that extracts from such letters could go on to have a life of their own in canon law. Finally, I measure the historical impact of each letter as a form of soft diplomacy. hile Gelasius I (492‒96) was one of the most significant bishops of the first five hundred W years of the Roman church, he is primarily known today for one letter. His Epistula 12 introduced the controversial theory of “two powers” or “two swords,” as it came to be known.1 The idea was taken up by another champion for papal primacy, when Nicholas I (858‒67) embedded quotes from it in his excoriation of the Byzantine emperor Michael III.2 In this arti- cle I examine the use of political rhetoric in each case, asking three questions.
    [Show full text]