A Feminist Rhetorical Analysis of Legally Blonde and How to Get Away with Murder Jazmine M
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Abilene Christian University Digital Commons @ ACU Electronic Theses and Dissertations Graduate School Spring 5-2-2017 From Blonde to Brutal: A Feminist Rhetorical Analysis of Legally Blonde and How to Get Away With Murder Jazmine M. Moreno [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.acu.edu/etd Recommended Citation Moreno, Jazmine M., "From Blonde to Brutal: A Feminist Rhetorical Analysis of Legally Blonde and How to Get Away With Murder" (2017). Digital Commons @ ACU, Electronic Theses and Dissertations. Paper 50. This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at Digital Commons @ ACU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ ACU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. ABSTRACT Feminism is a word that strikes up many connotations, but has no set definition. Though it might take on different definitions, its overall goal is equality. Feminism has appeared throughout history in various waves, the third-wave is currently in progress. Two artifacts from this wave of feminism include Legally Blonde and How to Get Away With Murder. This thesis utilizes feminist rhetorical criticism to analyze how third-wave feminism appears in each artifact, and what implications that has for the progression of feminism. The research identified two types of feminism, girlie feminism in Legally Blonde, and intersectional in How to Get Away With Murder, respectively. The different types of feminism in each artifact lead to the finding that each is indicative of what third wave feminism was concerned with at the time. Legally Blonde and girlie feminism were geared towards making femininity acceptable in the workplace and compatible with feminism. How to Get Away With Murder and intersectionality are focused on inclusivity in feminism. Despite these differences, both artifacts work for the benefit of feminism, and advancing its ultimate goal of equality. From Blonde to Brutal: A Feminist Rhetorical Analysis of Legally Blonde and How to Get Away With Murder A Thesis Presented to The Faculty of the Graduate School Abilene Christian University In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts In Communication By Jazmine Marta Moreno December 2016 5-2-2017 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The first thank you has to go to God for allowing all this to be possible. Thank you to my parents who have always encouraged me and never once doubted me. Thank you to my committee for taking the time to be my committee: Dr. Davis, Dr. Lemley, and Dr. Macaluso. And last, but definitely not least, thank you to my cohort: Faith, Kholo, Audrey, Philip, and Kaylen. Y’all have been incredible to work with and have helped keep me sane the past two years. TABLE OF CONTENTS ! I. INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 1! Media ...................................................................................................................... 6 Feminist Criticism in Media ....................................................................... 9 Feminism ............................................................................................................... 12 Girlie Feminism ........................................................................................ 17 Intersectionality ......................................................................................... 19 Men and Feminism ................................................................................... 21 Double Binds ........................................................................................................ 21 Legally Blonde ...................................................................................................... 23 How to Get Away With Murder ............................................................................ 26 Methodology ......................................................................................................... 28 Feminist Media Criticisms ........................................................................ 30 Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 31 II. LEGALLY BLONDE ............................................................................................. 33 Synopsis of Legally Blonde .................................................................................. 34 The Rhetorical Situation ........................................................................... 36 Double Binds ........................................................................................................ 37 Generational Feminist Differences ....................................................................... 40 Reclamation of Femininity ................................................................................... 44 Sisterhood and Empowerment .............................................................................. 49 Social Ostracizing ................................................................................................. 55 The Men of Legally Blonde .................................................................................. 57 Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 64 III. THE IN-BETWEEN SHOWS .............................................................................. 68 The In-Between Shows ......................................................................................... 69 Womb Versus Brain .................................................................................. 72 Silence Versus Shame ............................................................................... 76 Sameness Versus Difference ..................................................................... 80 Femininity Versus Competence ................................................................ 83 Aging Versus Invisibility .......................................................................... 86 Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 90 IV. HOW TO GET AWAY WITH MURDER ............................................................... 93 Synopsis of Murder ............................................................................................... 94 The Rhetorical Situation ........................................................................... 96 Double Binds ........................................................................................................ 96 Diversity and Intersectionality .............................................................................. 99 Women in Male-Dominated Professions ............................................................ 101 Sexism ................................................................................................................. 106 Slut-Shaming ....................................................................................................... 109 The Men of Murder ............................................................................................ 114 Conclusion .......................................................................................................... 119 V. CONCLUSION ................................................................................................... 123 Illustration of Third Wave Feminism ................................................................. 123 Characterizations ..................................................................................... 124 Settings .................................................................................................... 125 Comparison and Contrasts of Feminism ............................................................. 127 Appearance of Double Binds .............................................................................. 128 Limitations and Future Research ........................................................................ 129 Conclusion .......................................................................................................... 130 BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................... 132! CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION Television and films are prevalent forms of media. It is evident that both have left an indelible effect on audiences. When statistics show that “there are 2.3 televisions in each home” in the United States, escaping their wide influence poses a difficult challenge.1 Television and films are influential because they are “communicating something – ideas, attitudes, values – content with implications and consequences for human action.”2 This statement from communication scholar Gage Chapel also presents an interesting insinuation concerning media; particularly how influential television and films can be for their audiences. Both media forms remain ubiquitous aspects of American culture with the ability to communicate a variety of ideologies and beliefs to a broad range of audiences. Scholars and critics in the field of rhetoric have focused on what particular ideas both forms of media express. This thesis aims to examine how the media portrays female professionals, specifically, the portrayal of female attorneys in the film Legally Blonde and the television series How to Get Away With Murder. In order