Should the EU Limit the Juncker Plan Interventions Aiming at Promoting Growth? the Vote of the Meps
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Should the EU limit the Juncker Plan interventions aiming at promoting growth? The vote of the MEPs The European Fund for Strategic Investments was set up by the European Commission to implement the Juncker’s Plan, one of the main flagships project of the current President. Despite the innovative nature of the instrument, some MEPs criticized it, raising concerns about the financing of projects whose economic, social and environmental sustainability is questionable. However, most MEPs rallied behind President Juncker in defending the instrument and a critical amendment tabled by EFDD was rejected by more than 70% of MEPs. Centrist groups ALDE, S&D, the EPP and ECR strongly defended Juncker’s initiative, whereas, EFDD and ENF both voted against the European Fund for Strategic Investments. Interestingly, the majority of MEPs from Greens/EFA and a substantial amount of representatives from GUE-NGL decided to abstain. As for French MEPs specifically, they DISTRIBUTION OF FRENCH POLITICAL PARTIES IN THE EUROPEAN tended to follow the general trend of the PARLIAMENT IN 2016 Non-Inscrits : Front national, List "Les Français political groups in the plenary, with all European United Left-Nordic Green libres" Socialists, Centrists, and Republicans Left: Front de gauche, List "union rallying behind Juncker’s Plan. Likewise, pour les Outre-Mer" Europe of Freedom and Direct all members of the French Ecology Democracy: one non-affiliated The Greens - member Europe Party followed their group’s line European Free and abstained on the instrument. Alliance: Europe Europe des nations et Ecologie des libertés : Front Interestingly, the fund was also supported national, Progressive Alliance by some MEPs of the National Front: Rassemblement bleu of Socialists and Gilles Lebreton and Bernard Monot Marine Democrats: Parti voted against the critical amendment, socialiste, Parti radical de gauche whereas Nicolas Bay did not vote. Apart from the National Front, only far-left European People's Party: MEPs joined the criticism against the Les Républicains, one non- Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe: European Fund for Strategic Investments, affiliated member Union des Démocrates et Indépendants, List "Génération citoyens", Modem, Parti radical with the exception of Patrick Le Hyaric who did not vote. Should the EU limit the Juncker Plan interventions aiming at promoting growth? The vote of MEPs elected in France* For Marie-Christine Marie-Christine Mireille Edouard Jean-Francois Joëlle BERGERON Louis ALIOT ARNAUTU Dominique BILDE BOUTONNET Steeve BRIOIS D'ORNANO FERRAND Sylvie GODDYN JALKH National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front EFDD ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF Jean-Luc Younous Dominique Florian Mylène Jean-Luc Marine LE PEN Philippe LOISEAU Joëlle MÉLIN Sophie MONTEL SCHAFFHAUSER OMARJEE MARTIN PHILIPPOT Bleu Marine TROSZCZYNSKI MÉLENCHON The Union for National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front Mouvement National Front Left Front Overseas Territories ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF GUE/NGL GUE/NGL Marie-Christine VERGIAT Bruno GOLLNISCH Left Front National Front GUE/NGL NI Against Marielle DE Nathalie Jean ARTHUIS Jean-Marie Sylvie GOULARD Dominique Michèle SARNEZ GRIESBECK Gilles LEBRETON Bernard MONOT Alain CADEC Union of Democrats CAVADA Democratic Democratic Democratic RIQUET ALLIOT-MARIE and Independants Citizens' Generation Movement Movement Movement Radical Party - UDI National Front National Front The Republicans The Republicans ALDE ALDE ALDE ALDE ALDE ALDE ENF ENF EPP EPP Angélique Françoise Alain Jérôme Arnaud DANJEAN Michel DANTIN Rachida DATI DELAHAYE GROSSETÊTE Brice HORTEFEUX Marc JOULAUD Philippe JUVIN LAMASSOURE LAVRILLEUX The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP Constance LE Elisabeth MORIN- Renaud Aymeric GRIP Nadine MORANO CHARTIER MUSELIER Maurice PONGA Franck PROUST Tokia SAIFI Anne SANDER CHAUPRADE Eric ANDRIEU The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Free French Socialist Party EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP NI S&D Christine REVAULT Jean-Paul Louis-Joseph Emmanuel Guillaume BALAS Pervenche BERÈS Sylvie GUILLAUME Edouard MARTIN Gilles PARGNEAUX Vincent PEILLON D'ALLONNES DENANOT MANSCOUR MAUREL BONNEFOY Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party S&D S&D S&D S&D S&D S&D S&D S&D S&D S&D Virginie ROZIÈRE Isabelle THOMAS Left Radical Party Socialist Party S&D S&D Abstain José BOVÉ Karima DELLI Pascal DURAND Yannick JADOT Eva JOLY Michèle RIVASI Europe Ecology -The Europe Ecology -The Europe Ecology -The Europe Ecology -The Europe Ecology -The Europe Ecology -The Greens Greens Greens Greens Greens Greens Greens/EFA Greens/EFA Greens/EFA Greens/EFA Greens/EFA Greens/EFA Didn't vote Nicolas BAY Patrick LE HYARIC National Front Left Front ENF GUE/NGL Documented absence Robert ROCHEFORT Jean-Marie LE Democratic PEN Movement National Front ALDE NI *Source : Jacques Delors Institute / Data : www.votewatch.eu Should Employers to ban specific kinds of symbols that are claimed to be of a religious nature? The vote of the MEPs Two months after the Nice attacks, the MEPs voted on an amendment defending the rights of the employers to ban religious symbols on the workplace whenever these symbols violate the rights of women or can lead to security problems. This vote is quite important given the French context: France had already banned women to wear headscarves in public schools, as well as the burka and the niqab (the veils that cover women’s faces). In the case of the European Parliament, the vote on this amendment was pretty tight. The amendment was rejected by a slim margin of 5%. The amendment was supported by EPP and ENF, whereas ALDE, S&D, the Greens and GUE-NGL opposed the ban. Interestingly, ECR and EFDD were split, although a majority of their MEPs voted against the proposal. Also in this case, the position of French MEPs is drastically different from the ones of their colleagues from other countries, as a large majority of them supported the ban. The ban on religious symbols at the workplace was opposed by the French Greens, Jean Arthuis from the Union of Democrats and Independents and Younous Omarjee from the Alliance of the Overseas. DISTRIBUTION OF FRENCH POLITICAL PARTIES IN THE EUROPEAN All the other MEPs voted in favor of PARLIAMENT IN 2016 the ban, with some few exception Non-Inscrits : Front national, List "Les Français European United Left-Nordic Green within the political parties: the libres" Left: Front de gauche, List "union Republicans Nadine Morano, Patrick Europe of Freedom and Direct pour les Outre-Mer" Le Hyaric from the Left Front and 3 Democracy: one non-affiliated The Greens - member MEPs from the Socialist Party (Gilles European Free Alliance: Europe Pargneaux, Isabelle Thomas and Europe des nations et Ecologie Vincent Peillon). All these 5 “rebels” des libertés : Front voted against the ban. national, Progressive Alliance Rassemblement bleu of Socialists and Marine Democrats: Parti socialiste, Parti radical de gauche European People's Party: Les Républicains, one non- Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe: affiliated member Union des Démocrates et Indépendants, List "Génération citoyens", Modem, Parti radical The vote of MEPs elected in France* For Marielle DE Nathalie Jean-Marie Dominique Marie-Christine Marie-Christine Mireille SARNEZ GRIESBECK Joëlle BERGERON Nicolas BAY Dominique BILDE CAVADA Democratic Democratic RIQUET ARNAUTU BOUTONNET D'ORNANO Citizens' Generation Movement Movement Radical Party - UDI National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front ALDE ALDE ALDE ALDE EFDD ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF Edouard Jean-Francois Dominique Florian FERRAND Sylvie GODDYN JALKH Gilles LEBRETON Philippe LOISEAU MARTIN Joëlle MÉLIN Bernard MONOT Sophie MONTEL PHILIPPOT National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front National Front ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF ENF Jean-Luc Mylène Michèle Angélique Françoise Alain SCHAFFHAUSER Arnaud DANJEAN Rachida DATI Brice HORTEFEUX Philippe JUVIN Bleu Marine TROSZCZYNSKI ALLIOT-MARIE DELAHAYE GROSSETÊTE LAMASSOURE Mouvement National Front The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans ENF ENF EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP Jérôme Constance LE Elisabeth MORIN- Renaud Jean-Luc Aymeric LAVRILLEUX GRIP CHARTIER MUSELIER Maurice PONGA Franck PROUST Tokia SAIFI Anne SANDER MÉLENCHON CHAUPRADE The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans The Republicans Left Front The Free French EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP EPP GUE/NGL NI Christine REVAULT Jean-Paul Emmanuel Bruno GOLLNISCH Eric ANDRIEU Guillaume BALAS Pervenche BERÈS Sylvie GUILLAUME D'ALLONNES Virginie ROZIÈRE DENANOT MAUREL BONNEFOY Left Radical Party National Front Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party Socialist Party NI S&D S&D S&D S&D S&D S&D S&D S&D Against Younous Jean ARTHUIS Nadine MORANO José BOVÉ Karima DELLI Pascal