Legal Observations of the European Audiovisual Observatory
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
•• IRIS LEGAL OBSERVATIONS OF THE EUROPEAN AUDIOVISUAL OBSERVATORY APRIL 1996 - VOL. II - N° 4 CONTENTS 2 NATIONAL NEWS • Editorial CASE LAW Landmark decision on the right of • Germany: Product placement in 12 journalists to protect their sources films - Federal Court sets the rules • European Commission: Broadcasting rights for sports Objections against Cablevision events under discussion 8 agreement of Telefonica and Canal Plus Spain THE GLOBAL INFORMATION • Germany: A princess protected - Federal Court on privacy • Germany: New copyright law SOCIETY raises questions concerning EC • Norway: Defamation and Directive on rental rights 3 jurisdiction without frontiers in broadcasting matters • European Commission: Compilation of a plan of Community 13 action concerning the information 9 • United Kingdom: Government society protects eight sporting events for • Netherlands: Internet-providers LEGISLATION terrestrial television not held responsible for wrongful Czech Republic: • New law on • United Kingdom: Sale of acts of Internet-users the collective management of television sports rights copyright and associated rights WIPO • Slovak Republic: New • Italy: Broadcasting rights for • The February 1996 discussions language law football granted to Cecchi Gori on a possible Berne Protocol and Group and to Europa TV a possible New Instrument LAW RELATED POLICY • France: Canal+ acquires DEVELOPMENTS broadcasting rights of COUNCIL OF EUROPE • Germany: Land presidents agree Ligue Nationale de Football to changes in Broadcasting 5 Agreement 14 • European Court of Human Rights: The journalist’s sources 10 • Austria: Broadcasting rights for protected by Article 10 of the soccer games to be assigned to European Convention on Human • United Kingdom: Department non-domestic private television Rights of National Heritage extends the broadcaster? • Forthcoming meetings of different regulatory and licensing powers of the ITC • Netherlands: Football groups of specialists broadcasting rights sold to new • United Kingdom: Telecom sports channel EUROPEAN UNION regulator issues new consultative document on promoting • Netherlands: RTL5 will not be 6 communication in services over shut down after all telecommunications networks • Sweden: Negotiations on a new • More agreements with non- • Sweden: Government proposal licence term for private commercial member countries on intellectual television property. for a new comprehensive Broadcasting Act • EU Council/European • Sweden: VAT on film exhibitions Parliament: Directive on the legal • Sweden: New guidelines for protection of databases adopted - public service television Part 3: Epilogue? 15 • European Union: The European 11 • U.S.A.: Television networks Parliament looks into children’s agree to rate television programming programmes • Sweden: Report on digital broadcasting • U.S.A.: Publication of a study on violence on television 7 • Switzerland: The Federal Office • Economic and Social of Communication (OFCOM) has Committee: Opinion on a multi- written to distributors of TV 16 annual Community programme on programmes on advertising and the information society sponsoring Agenda - Publications •• IRIS LEGAL OBSERVATIONS OF THE EUROPEAN AUDIOVISUAL OBSERVATORY EDITORIAL Landmark decision on the right of journalists to protect their sources Broadcasting rights for sports events under discussion Member States of the Council of Europe are required to give substantial protection to a journalist’s sources. A disclosure order cannot be compatible with Article 10 of the European Convention for the protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms unless it is justified by an overriding requirement in the public interest. In this issue, IRIS reports on this landmark decision rendered by the European Court of Human Rights during March. The main question that will arise on the basis of this decision will of course relate to the definition of “journalist”. Can anybody be a journalist or will there be a need for an official recognition of a person as a jounalist before he can claim the right to protection of his sources? This raises interesting questions from the point of view of fundamental rights: who will determine who can be regarded as a journalist? In the past few months, the issue of broadcasting rights for sports events, notably in regard to soccer games, has been debated in countries like Austria, France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands and the UK. In this issue we report on these debates and on their outcome in a number of countries. We will continue this report in the next issue of IRIS. Together with this issue you will receive a binder in which you can classify the issues that appeared and will appear in 1996. Ad van Loon IRIS Coordinator Published by the European Audiovisual Observatory • Executive Director: Ismo Silvo • Editorial Board: Ad van Loon, Legal Adviser of the European Audiovisual Observatory, responsible for the legal information area (Coordinator) – Lawrence Early, Head of the Media Section of the Directorate of Human Rights of the Council of Europe – Vincenzo Cardarelli, Directorate General X (Audiovisual Policy) of the European Commission – Wolfgang Cloß, General Manager of the Institut für Europäisches Medienrecht (EMR) in Saarbrücken – Marcel Dellebeke, Institute for Information Law (IViR) at the University of Amsterdam – Prof. Michael Botein, Communications Media Center at the New York Law School – Frédéric Pinard, European Audiovisual Observatory • Contributors to this issue: Alice Bouras, European Court of Humman Rights in Strasbourg (France) – Jens Cavallin, Council for Pluralism in the media (Sweden) – L. Frederic Cederqvist, Communications Media Center at the New York Law School (USA) – Emmanuel Crabit, European Commission, Directorate General XV (Internal Market) in Brussels (Belgium) – Alfonso de Salas, Media Section of the Directorate of Human Rights of the Council of Europe in Strasbourg (France) – Phylis A. Eagle, National Cable Television Association (NCTA) in Washington (USA) – Jamie Gaetz, International Centre of Films for Children and Young People (CIFEJ) in Montreal (Canada) – David Goldberg, School of Law, University of Glasgow (United Kingdom) – Jaap Haeck, Institute for Information Law, Amsterdam (The Netherlands) – Helene Hillerström, TV4 AB (Sweden) – Stéfanie Junker, Institut für Europäisches Medienrecht (EMR) in Saarbrücken (Germany) – Volker Kreutzer, Institut für Europäisches Medienrecht (EMR) in Saarbrücken (Germany) – Roberto Mastroianni, University of Florence, Public Law Department (Italy) – Christophe Poirel, Media Section of the Directorate of Human Rights of the Council of Europe in Strasbourg (France) – Prof. Tony Prosser, School of Law, University of Glasgow (United Kingdom) – Andrea Schneider, Institut für Europäisches Medienrecht (EMR) in Saarbrücken (Germany) – Jacqueline Seignette, Goudsmit & Branbergen, Attorneys at Law in Amsterdam (The Netherlands) – Kristina Stürzbecher, Institut für Europäisches Medienrecht (EMR) in Saarbrücken (Germany) – Connie Tadros, International Centre of Films for Children and Young People (CIFEJ) in Montreal (Canada) – Brigitte Van Dorsselaere, Cabinet Alain Bensoussan, Attorneys at Law in Paris (France) – Stefaan Verhulst, School of Law, University of Glasgow (United Kingdom) – Prof. Dirk Voorhoof, Media Law Section of the Department of Communication Sciences of Ghent University (Belgium). S EUROPEAN COMMISSION Institute for Information Law NYL Documentation: Edwige Seguenny • Translations: Michelle Ganter (Coordination) – Véronique Campillo – Sonya Folca – Brigitte Graf – Katherine Parsons – Claire Pedotti – Stefan Pooth – Mechtild Schreck – Catherine Vacherat • Corrections: Michelle Ganter, European Audiovisual Observatory – John Hunter, European Audiovisual Observatory – Peter Nitsch, Chancellery of the Federal Republic of Germany in Bonn – Christophe Poirel, Media Section of the Directorate of Human Rights of the Council of Europe – Michael Type, European Broadcasting Union • Subscription Service: Anne Boyer, URL http://www.Obs.c-Strasbourg.fr/irissub.htm • Marketing manager: Markus Booms • Contributions, comments and subscriptions to: IRIS, European Audiovisual Observatory, 76 Allée de la Robertsau, F-67000 STRASBOURG, Tel.: +33 88144400, Fax: +33 88144419, E-mail: [email protected] Strasbourg.fr, URL http://www.Obs.c-Strasbourg.fr/irismain.htm • Subscription rates: 1 calendar year (10 issues, a binder + a special issue): FF 2,000/US$ 370/ECU 310 in Member States of the Observatory, FF 2,300/US$ 420/ECU 355 in non-Member States - Subscriptions will be automatically renewed for consecutive calendar years unless cancelled before 1 December by written notice sent to the publisher • Typesetting: Atelier Point à la Ligne • Print: Finkmatt Impression, La Wantzenau (France) • Layout: Thierry Courreau • ISSN 1023-8565 • © 1996, European Audiovisual Observatory, Strasbourg (France). 2 April 1996 - Vol. II - N° 4 •• IRIS LEGAL OBSERVATIONS OF THE EUROPEAN AUDIOVISUAL OBSERVATORY The global Information Society European Commission: compilation of a plan of Community action concerning the information society The Information Society Project Office has recently published a document entitled “Europe’s Way to the Information Society - Update of the Action Plan”, which reports on the various initiatives completed or in hand at 15 December 1995 of Community institutions concerning the information society (Green Books, draft Directives, Directives, communications, reports, workshops, etc). The plan emphasises legislative