STM Validation D1.3 Improving Port Operations Using Port Collaborative Decision Making 2019.03.17
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
STM_Validation_D1.3 Improving port operations using Port Collaborative Decision Making 2019.03.17 DOCUMENT STATUS Approval Name Organisation Signature Date Activity 1 active members1 190329 Document History Version Date Status Initials DesCription 1.3 161212 Draft 3.1 181231 Draft 6 190113 Mature draft Ready for review round 1 version 10 190218 Final draft Ready for review round 2 version for review 11 190315 Version for Ready for approval approval 1 CIMNE, Costa Crociere, Cyprus University of Technology, Finnish Transport Agency, HiQ, Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport, Norwegian Coastal Administration, Port of Barcelona, Swedish Maritime Administration, Svitzer Sweden AB, Transas, Valenciaport Authority, Valenciaport Foundation, and Research Institutes of Sweden (RISE). Kvarken ports, Port of Stavanger as active participants STM VALIDATION 1.3 – Improving port operations using PortCDM 2 Authors Name Organisation Lind Mikael, Haraldson Sandra, Ward Robert, Bergmann, RISE Viktoria Michael, Bjørn-Andersen Niels, Karlsson Mathias, Zerem Almir, Olsson Eddie, Watson Richard, Holm Henrik, Löfgren Birger Michaelides Michalis, Evmides Nicos, Gerosavva Cyprus University of Technology Neofytos, Herodotou Herodotos, Voskarides Sotos Andersen Trond, Rygh Terje Port of Stavanger Arjona Arcona Jordi, Ferrus Clari Gabriel, Gimenez Valenciaport Foundation Maldonado José, Marquez Miguel, Gonzales Albert Port of Barcelona DISCLAIMER: THIS INFORMATION REFLECTS THE VIEW OF THE AUTHOR(S) AND THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION IS NOT LIABLE FOR ANY USE THAT MAY BE MADE OF THE INFORMATION CONTAINED THEREIN. STM VALIDATION 1.3 – Improving port operations using PortCDM 3 ExeCutive summary Over the last couple of decades and specifically in the last few years, various initiatives have been launched in the maritime domain to overcome the traditional narrow view of focusing exclusively on optimising individual actor-specific processes. However, since most processes are shared among several actors, it is necessary to share information to support collaborative decision-making, and for efficiency reasons, exchange of information has to be in a standardized format. Secondly, it has become increasingly clear that, as in the aviation sector and more generally across commerce, it is necessary for the maritime sector to go through a digital transformation. Digitalisation will enable collaboration and better-informed decision-making in the maritime industry which, in turn, will substantially improve the overall efficiency, effectiveness and innovation in the international transport and logistic supply chains. Prior initiatives, including BLAST, MONALISA and MONALISA 2.0 promoted digitalisation to enable data sharing to create improved situational awareness thereby enhancing safety and efficiency of the maritime transport sector. The Sea Traffic Management (STM) Validation project was the logical result. The STM validation project aims to validate the envisioned concepts through sea trials and simulation. Activity 1 - PortCDM testbeds, is one of five activities in the STM validation project. It has focussed on Port Collaborative Decision Making (PortCDM), a concept inspired by the aviation sector where Airport CDM (A-CDM) is already well established. The concept is now beginning to be embraced by the rail transport sector. The purpose of PortCDM is to support the port call optimisation process by promoting: • The extension of the planning horizons through intra port collaboration, ship-to-port collaboration, port-to-hinterland collaboration, and inter port collaboration. • The sharing of the timing of future events for the coordination of the port call process • The combination of multiple sources of data for enhanced predictability • Shared situational awareness by sharing data on the progress of a port call among internal and external involved actors For this purpose, PortCDM has been developed to meet the needs of a concept that would: • enable real-time standardised information sharing of time stamps between actors involved in port calls • enable just-in-time approaches by synchronising the ship’s approach to the port with the port’s ability to serve the ship for its purpose of call • provide situational awareness as a basis for actors’ coordination of their actions performed in relation to forthcoming and on-going port calls In this way, PortCDM contributes to the enhancement of integrated operations between actors involved in: • the port call, avoiding unnecessary waiting times • managing inbound and outbound cargo/passengers efficiently • coordinating the ships’ sea voyages and the port approach, reducing unnecessary waiting times (anchoring times) for ship outside the port • securing a smooth and precise transport timetable from port to hinterland of cargo and passengers STM VALIDATION 1.3 – Improving port operations using PortCDM 4 PortCDM is thus an essential part of STM. It develops and utilises standardised data sharing between ships and all relevant ports call operators by providing port-call information, mainly timestamps and related metadata to create a joint situational awareness based on shared time stamps. The Port Call Message Format (PCMF) has been developed to enable the different actors to share standardised and interoperable data to gain better situational awareness and improve their operations to increase the efficiency of the port call. It also allows the optimisation of the sea voyage, as the ships get information on when the port can best serve them and, with this information, allows them to sail “Just-In-Time” to reduce fuel consumption and improve their environmental footprint. The PCMF, to be known as standard S-211, was used extensively during the validation project. S-211 is based upon and fully conformant with the S-100 data exchange baseline format that is internationally recognised and endorsed by the IMO as the baseline format for its e-Navigation concept. The PortCDM concept has now been validated in nine ports clustered into two testbeds - the Mediterranean and the Nordic testbeds. This report describes the result of this validation. During the validation process, port call actors have interacted in continuously arranged living lab workshops, they have run focus months in which software for data sharing has been utilised for data sharing. This software, working as a PortCDM demonstrator by reflecting the design principles of PortCDM, has consisted both of back-end and front-end services. The validation has been captured both in qualitative analysis through interviews, questionnaires and collaborative reflections and quantitative analysis of the captured data that has been shared in the port environment. Over 1.7 million timestamps were shared successfully in the ports utilizing the demonstrator, based on the design principles of the PortCDM concept. The principles of PortCDM were implemented successfully in the participating ports. The qualitative analysis of the results of the PortCDM validation project shows that enhanced situational awareness, provided by the data sharing enabled by PortCDM is of value to participants. The participants pointed out that an increased reliability of ETAs and ETDs for port actions has substantial benefits. Enhanced situational awareness as facilitated by PortCDM provided port call actors with access to more reliable data and a greater awareness of other actors’ intentions. Enhanced situational awareness was shown to provide positive effects for operations, including: • Making better estimates for ETAs and ETDs (100% of respondents agreed ‘to some extent’ or ‘more’ with this conclusion) • Improved work procedures (> 50 % agreed to some extent or more) • Reduced time spent on information gathering (> 80 % agreed to some extent or more) • Reduction of administrative workload (> 80 % agreed to some extent or more) PortCDM is not simply a technical enabler for sharing data based on the standardised PCMF. Importantly, PortCDM is a new and innovative operational concept that suggests and requires a change to the collaboration culture in ports and between port and ship so as to build the necessary operational and cultural foundation for optimal use of the technical concepts to achieve the desired outcomes. This requires attitudinal changes among the actors in the maritime transportation chain. The validation process took significant effort to foster the required changes in attitude and ways of interacting between the various actors. In particular, the use of living labs was most STM VALIDATION 1.3 – Improving port operations using PortCDM 5 successful in getting the actors to appreciate the constraints, perspectives, needs and motivation of others in the chain and the impact of the actions of one on another. This reduced the traditional tendency to restrict the sharing of data resulting in enhanced collaboration and better understanding of the overall situation leading to more effective individual operations. Not unexpectedly, and in line with proposals to introduce other innovative and novel revisions to long standing but inherently uncoordinated processes, such as the implementation of Airport-CDM (ACDM), any quantitative analysis of the results of the validation project proved to be problematic. Here the first full qualitative analysis was done after the first airports had been implemented ACDM. In fact the implementation of ACDM recommends following phases where the validation is done after the implementation: Information Phase - Analysis Phase - Cost-benefit analysis (CBA) - Implementation Phase