China's Investment in Latin America

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

China's Investment in Latin America China’s Investment in Latin America: Themes, Challenges and Future Trends Thomas Mellor, Partner and Brian Sogol , Associate of Bingham McCutchen LLP 1 INTRODUCTION skyrocketed, and it seems each week Economic growth in China over the last a new blockbuster investment deal is decade has been remarkable. During announced. Latin America has generally the same period, economic growth in welcomed this investment, though it a number of Latin America’s maturing has also presented some challenges. economies (most notably Brazil, but On another level, the increasingly others as well) has also caught the important role China is playing has world’s attention. concerned some U.S. policymakers, who view China as challenging the Both China and Latin America showed historical U.S. hegemony in the region. resilience during the world financial crisis, during which Chinese demand This article outlines the nature of for raw materials from Latin America China’s foreign direct investment in the provided a helpful stimulus to the region to date and what is driving these region. Today, both are sought-after investments from both the Chinese regions for investment. Buoyed by and Latin American perspective. The confidence from their economic article then explores challenges the successes, China and Brazil are playing investment relationship faces and greater roles on the world stage; by the concludes with some predictions for accounts of most experts, both are on future trends. the short list of those countries most likely to shape the 21st century. Recent TRADE AND INVestment Trends Chinese-Latin American trade has 1. The Explosion of Chinese-Latin recently reached historic highs, to American Trade. China’s recent the mutual benefit of China and its investments in Latin America have Latin American trading partners. been preceded by a vibrant and Chinese foreign direct investment in expanding trade relationship with the Latin American region has also many Latin American countries over 60 global infrastructure, winter 2012 the past decade. Understanding the to almost every country in the region. Chinese trading relationship with Latin Third, China competes in the region’s America provides helpful context for export markets for manufactured the investment relationship. goods (particularly Mexico and Central America). Thus, China’s The change in the trade relationship trade relationship with resource-rich has been staggering. Trade between countries in Latin America differs Latin America and China in 1999 totaled considerably from its relationship with approximately $8 billion; by 2010, it those countries that depend primarily had grown 22 times to approximately on the export of manufactured goods. $180 billion. By comparison, trade between Latin America and the United 2. The Chinese Investment Boom States grew by approximately 0.5 times2 Follows Trade Expansion. The over the same period.3 This statistic is Chinese government has encouraged often cited to support the perception of investment in Latin America as a way the ascendancy of Chinese commercial to strengthen trade ties.5 Sources vary influence in Latin America. The inability on the amount of Chinese foreign direct of the United States to implement a investment in Latin America, though free trade agreement with Colombia4 by almost all accounts 2010 was a (with critics citing the divisive American watershed year. The following provides political environment as the cause) has data on Chinese direct investment in further undermined the U.S. trading certain economies of Latin America relationship with Latin America vis- and the Caribbean. (Other figures for à-vis China. During the same period, Chinese direct investment in Brazil China signed a number of free trade alone put the number for 2010 in the agreements with countries in the $12 billion to $20 billion range.)6 region, including Chile, Peru and, most recently, Costa Rica. a. The Investment Recipients. The vast majority of direct investment The trading relationship between China from China, over 90%, has gone to and economies in Latin America has natural resource enterprises, including three principal facets: it is at the same hydrocarbons, copper and iron ore, time a buyer, seller and competitor. and agriculture. Not surprisingly, the First, China is a huge buyer of raw primary recipients of this investment materials from resource-rich countries have been those economies where such as Brazil, Chile, Argentina, natural resources are abundant, Ecuador and Venezuela. Second, namely Brazil, Argentina and Peru. China exports manufactured goods While China has been an important china’s investment in latin america: themes, challenges and future trends 61 China: Foreign Direct Investment in Selected Economies of Latin America and the Caribbean7 (Millions of dollars) Country Confirmed Investments Investments Announced 1990 to 2009 2010 2011 Onwards Argentina 143 5,550 3,530 Brazil 255 9,563 9,870 Colombia 1,677 3 — Costa Rica 13 5 700 Ecuador 1,619 41 — Guyana 1,000 — — Mexico 127 5 — Peru 2,262 84 8,640 Venezuela 240 — — source of investment for certain smaller b. Types of Investments. The form of economies, such as Ecuador and these investments varies widely. They Guyana, Chinese investment has had range from greenfield projects (such very little relevance in Mexico and most as the purchase of exploration and of Central America.8 production concessions—namely in the hydrocarbons sector) to taking One feature of Chinese investments minority or control equity positions. In is the willingness of the Chinese addition to these equity investments, government to make significant Chinese banks have proven to be an investments in a number of economies important source of debt financing, both that have been otherwise shunned in assisting Chinese companies seeking by Western investors. For instance, to finance their overseas investments Ecuador has been shut out of global and, in some cases, lending directly to markets since it defaulted on its bonds companies and sovereigns in the region. in 2006, and Venezuela similarly has had a difficult time attracting foreign c. The Investors. Nearly all of the investors given the nationalization Chinese investors making the headline- program instituted under the Chavez grabbing deals are large state- regime. Both countries have been controlled companies in the natural significant recipients of Chinese resources area.9 As state-controlled investment, as has Cuba. companies, these companies are 62 global infrastructure, winter 2012 obviously useful instruments for the 1. Resource Security: Feeding the Chinese government to implement Dragon. The primary motivation state policy. In addition, the debt associated with Chinese investment financing mentioned previously offered is the need to secure a stable supply to Chinese investors by Chinese state- of raw materials necessary for China’s owned banks for overseas expansion economic growth. As mentioned earlier, projects has been an important tool to state-owned corporations and financing promote expansion abroad. provided by state-owned banks are incredibly useful instruments to effect While large state-owned companies these goals of resource security. have been associated with many of the Chinese investment has not only largest investments in Latin America, supported the companies that supply Chinese private investors, the source these natural resources, but also the of most of the growth in jobs and infrastructure that allows for more wealth in the Chinese economy, are not efficient transportation of these goods far behind.10 The Chinese government to China. For instance, the Chinese and recently indicated that it would more Colombian governments have been in aggressively promote these private discussion regarding the construction investors, who have argued that the of an alternative to the Panama Canal, government had previously focused a rail route that would link the Pacific too heavily on providing overseas and Atlantic coasts of Colombia. expansion opportunities to state- This would provide for more efficient owned companies, to the detriment transportation of goods to and from the of Chinese private companies.11 Atlantic coasts of Latin America to Asia. 2. It’s Good Business. Somewhat less What IS DRIVING Chinese INVestment considered than resource security IN Latin AMERICA? is that even while the Chinese The Chinese government has been government is promoting expansion vocal in its support of investment abroad, such expansion is simply good in Latin America,12 but what is business for many Chinese companies. the underlying rationale? Some As natural resource companies in China considerations are obvious and have grown to feed their economy’s others less so. While motivations demand, investing abroad often makes will vary depending on the particular sense for a company’s own growth and investment, some consistent themes diversification strategies. are listed herein. china’s investment in latin america: themes, challenges and future trends 63 Infrastructure construction in China otherwise be subject if exporting goods is another excellent example. Over directly from China. Also, selling locally the last two decades, China has produced manufactured goods may gone through a “golden age”13 of help reduce trade deficits in those infrastructure development, building up markets where trade imbalances have its transportation, telecommunications been identified as problematic (as and energy infrastructure. A common further described hereafter). estimate puts recent Chinese
Recommended publications
  • Diapositiva 1
    Latina Finance & Co Corporate Finance Advisory in Latin America Latin America 2009 Political, Economical and Financial snapshot January 2010 Latina Finance & Co www.latinafinance.net Table of contents 1. Introduction 2. Latin America political 2009 3. Latin America economical 2009 4. Latin America financial 2009 5. Latam – Europe business 2009 6. Outlook 2010 7. Contact 8. Disclaimer Latina Finance & Co 2 1 . Introduction We are very happy to provide you with a quick overview of what has been the year 2009 in Latin America. It is not an extensive review but much more a snapshot which should hopefully provide you with a helicopter view of what has been a very interesting year. We have now entered 2010 and the prospect for this year is encouraging with continuous political stability in the key countries of the region and confirmation of an increasing democratic environment. Brazil is taking the lead of the region’s economic recovery with Peru, Chile and Colombia following the path. Mexico should follow the footsteps of the US progressive recovery. Argentina still needs to fix its debt restructuring issue which it will hopefully achieve in 2010. After a great 4Q rally, financial markets seem to be pursuing a positive trend in early 2010. Equity and capital markets should keep a strong momentum while the bank market might reopen as banks will have re-adjusted their capital ratios . Given the strong demand for infrastructure financing, project financing should continue to recover with the support of multi and bilateral organizations such as BNDES, IADB, IFC and EIB. One can also see renewed interest from large US private equity funds which could tempt European PEs to enter the region.
    [Show full text]
  • Uruguay Latin America´S #1 Business Gateway
    2 3 Business Platforms for Life Sciences Companies in Uruguay1 Both pharmaceutical and medical device companies, combine different business platforms, taking advantage of Uruguay´s value proposition - stability, no restrictions on foreign exchange and repatriation of profits, outstanding tax exemptions, talent availability and quality of life, cold chain and logistics for access to Brazil and countries in the region minimizing time and costs. 1 R&D: Research & Development RDC: Regional Distribution Centers HQ-SSC: Regional Head Quarters or Shared Services Centers 4 Life Science Success Stories Roche has a Regional Supply Center in Uruguay which coordinates all logistic activities in Latin America. Also, the Center manages goods supply from the production centers to all its affiliates in the region. The main activities of the Regional Supply Center include: orders management, billing, and customer service. Thus, the Center has three different departments: Intercompany Operations, Supply Chain, and Transport. Each department ensures an alignment with regional interests and requirements. Shimadzu Corporation manufactures analytical tools for precision and measurement, medical imaging systems, aircraft equipment and other industrial equipment. Shimadzu Latinoamérica S.A, works as a Regional Distribution Logistics center throughout Latin America for medical equipment, and analytical equipment (precision balances, and laboratory equipment). The company has business offices, a warehouse and their Regional Headquarters in Uruguay, which they moved from Brazil in 2013. HQ, SSC, Trading & Procurement Merck settled in Uruguay in 1996. The company develops logistic and business services lead by regional and global positions. The operation has grown steadily, following Merck’s growth in Latin America, and currently 80 employees work in both platforms.
    [Show full text]
  • Latin Business Chronicle
    Latin Business Chronicle Monday, April 27 2009 Updated at 08:00 AM. Reports Opinion Statistics Technology Countries Companies Topics Sectors You are not logged in | Log in | Create Account Perspectives 12:00 AM Back to Perspectives Home Thursday, April 23, 2009 Premium Subscription Summit of the Americas: Much Ado About Nothing Advertising Info Free Weekly Newsletter Searching for substance in the Jobs at LBC summit's declaration is akin to looking for a polar bear in a Archives snowstorm. Crisis & Latin America BY JERRY HAAR Latin America Outlook Summits of the Americas traditionally Latin Security Index have been vacuous, mind-numbing Leader of the Year conventions of inter-American heads Top 500 Companies of state and their acolytes in which Presidents Barack Obama and Hugo Chavez at the Summit of the Top 100 M&As pompous, sermon-style pontifications Americas. (Photo Alfonso Ocando/Venezuela President's Office) Top 50 Ports and amorphous and anodyne declarations—substance-free and Globalization Index coma-inducing—are delivered to the Latin Business Index press and whoever else has a lot of Latin Technology time on their hands. Index Key Conferences In this regard, the recently concluded People On the Move Fifth Summit of the Americas in Books Trinidad and Tobago did not disappoint. Searching for substance in Glossary Trinidad Prime Minister Patrick the 21-page Declaration is akin to Manning signs the final declaration. (Photo: Fifth Summit of the Americas) About LBC looking for a polar bear in a Media Kit snowstorm. Platitudes, hopes, aspirations, and altruistic pledges Press & News Font Size ..... laden in non-specifics embody the Español Declaration—a document issued Privacy Policy before not after the Summit ended Poll Terms of Use (sort of like going to the theater to Contact Us watch a movie, then returning home Should the US end its Cuba to boot up the computer and watch embargo? the trailer).
    [Show full text]
  • Tuesday, May 08, 2007 Latin Business: Best & Worst BY
    Tuesday, May 08, 2007 Latin Business: Best & Worst Best for doing business: Chile, Mexico and Uruguay. Worst: Haiti, Bolivia and Nicaragua. BY CHRONICLE STAFF Chile cements its position as the best country in Latin America to do business in, according to the second annual Latin Business Index from Latin Business CONGRATULATIONS! Presidents Chronicle. Felipe Calderon of Mexico and Michelle Bachelet of Chile in "Chile is actually a developed developing Mexico City in March. They lead country," says Jerry Haar, a professor of the two best countries in Latin management and international business and associate director of the Knight Ridder Center for America for doing business. (Photo: Excellence in Management in the College of Mexican President's Office) Business Administration at Florida International University. "It's not Belgium, but it's not Bolivia either." Font Size ..... Kathleen Barclay, the Chile-based former executive with JP Morgan Chase who chairs the Association of American Chamber of Commerce in Latin America, also sings the country's praises. "Doing business in Chile is straightforward - there is sustainable economic growth and solid political institutions," she says. "The rules of the game are clear and investors - foreign or domestic - are given the equal treatment. Most importantly, when doing business with Chile you deal with quality people who have high ethical standards, The challenge to be successful in Chile is to be competitive." Mexico, Latin America's second-largest economy, came in second. However, Uruguay replaced Costa Rica as Latin America's third-best country to do business in. The index of 19 countries looks at five key categories and 28 subcategories to measure the recent, current and future business environment in a country.
    [Show full text]
  • Using Social Power to Balance Soft Power: Venezuela's Foreign Policy
    Javier Corrales Using Social Power to Balance Soft Power: Venezuela’s Foreign Policy President Hugo Cha´vez of Venezuela has achieved what no other Latin American leader has since the end of the Cold War: bringing security concerns in the Western Hemisphere back to U.S. foreign policy. Might Venezuela provoke a war against neighboring Colombia, spread weapons among insurgents abroad, disrupt oil sales to the United States, provide financial support to Hezbollah, al Qaeda or other fundamentalist movements, offer safe havens for drug dealers, invite Russia to open a military base on its territory, or even acquire nuclear weapons?1 These security concerns did not exist less than a decade ago, but today they occupy the attention of U.S. officials. Attention to these conventional security issues, however, carries the risk of ignoring what thus far has been Venezuela’s most effective foreign policy tool in challenging the United States: the use of generous handouts abroad, peppered with a pro-poor, distribution-prone discourse. While the U.S. debate revolves around ‘‘hard power’’ and ‘‘soft power,’’2 this other form can be called ‘‘social power diplomacy.’’ Similar to hard power and soft power, social power diplomacy allows the projecting nation to attract allies but through different means. With social power diplomacy, other nations are not necessarily cajoled into bowing to the economic or military might of the projecting nation, as is the case in the realm of traditional hard power politics. Also, nations are not necessarily attracted to the magnetic appeal of the projecting nation’s ideology and values, as is the case with the realm of soft power politics.
    [Show full text]
  • Uruguay | Prime Location for IT Companies
    Uruguay | Prime location for IT companies 1 [email protected] | www.smartservices.uy “My first trip to Uruguay was eye-opening. I had no idea that this small country had so much to offer. From the impressive universities, the entrepreneurial spirit, and magnificent coastline, it is clear that Uruguay is poised to step onto the world stage.” Tina Seelig, Faculty Director of the Stanford Technology Ventures Program (STVP), Stanford University 2 [email protected] | www.smartservices.uy Success Testimonials “Verifone operates in Uruguay since 2006 when Trintech operations were acquired. Since that time up to now the diversity of skills and talented staff found in the country has allowed to consolidate Uruguay as one of the Centers of Excellence from where we provide support and services for our customers around the world.” Rafael Cuenca, VP Engineering, Verifone “Netsuite started business in Uruguay on May 2012 by acquiring two Uruguayan companies. Uruguay was a key component to start a whole new strategy of an eCommerce product called SuiteCommerce. We are creating the product and providing the implementation service from Uruguay to customers in the whole world.” Diego Terra, eCommerce Director, Netsuite “The main problem of our industry is the lack of talents, and in Uruguay there are very competitive human resources. We need a mixture of technically good people for software development and also with English language skills, because they have to work with English speaking clients continuously. Uruguay is one of the places where we found the best mixture of both conditions.” Bernardo Manzella, Uruguay Country Manager, Globant “We decided in favor of Uruguay for three main reasons.
    [Show full text]
  • Iran in Latin America Threat Or ‘Axis of Annoyance’?
    IRAN Wilson Center Reports on the Americas • # 23 Woodrow I N LA TI N A IRAN IN LATIN AMERICA M E R Threat or ‘Axis of Annoyance’? I C A Threat or ‘ A xis of A nnoyance’? EDITED BY Cynthia Arnson Haleh Esfandiari and Adam Stubits Latin American Program Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars 1300 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Washington, DC 20004 Tel. (202) 691-4030 Fax (202) 691-4076 www.wilsoncenter.org/lap Latin American Program Middle East Program IRAN IN LATIN AMERICA: THREAt or ‘AXIS OF ANNOYance’? Latin American Program Middle East Program IRAN IN LATIN AMERICA: THREAt or ‘AXIS OF ANNOYance’? Edited by Cynthia Arnson, Haleh Esfandiari and Adam Stubits Woodrow Wilson Center Reports on the Americas # 23 The Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars is the national, living memorial honoring President Woodrow Wilson. In providing an essential link between the worlds of ideas and public policy, the Center addresses current and emerging challenges confront- ing the United States and the world. The Center promotes policy-rele- vant research and dialogue to increase understanding and enhance the capabilities and knowledge of leaders, citizens, and institutions world- wide. Created by an Act of Congress in 1968, the Center is a nonpartisan institution headquartered in Washington, D.C., and supported by both public and private funds. Lee H. Hamilton, President and Director Available from the Latin American Program Board of Trustees Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars Joseph B. Gildenhorn, Chair One Woodrow Wilson Plaza Sander R. Gerber, Vice Chair 1300 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington, DC 20004-3027 Public members: James H.
    [Show full text]
  • Outside Players in Latin America (I): China
    Outside Players in Latin America (I): China Carlos Malamud 4/12/2007 Working Paper50/2007 (Translated from Spanish) Outside Players in Latin America (I): China Carlos Malamud Summary1 In recent years China’s prolonged and sustained economic growth has fuelled a considerable rise in Latin American exports of raw materials (hydrocarbons, minerals, food, etc) to the Chinese market and, at the same time, an increased growth in the region’s economies. Introduction In recent years China’s prolonged and sustained economic growth has fuelled a considerable rise in Latin American exports of raw materials (hydrocarbons, minerals, food, etc) to the Chinese market and, at the same time, an increased growth in the region’s economies. This was confirmed more recently by the visit of the Chinese President Hu Jintao and other senior officials of the Chinese government to several countries of Latin America.2 At the same time, but in the opposite direction, numerous Latin American leaders, from all over the region and from different ends of the political spectrum, making pilgrimages to China’s capital and its main cities, seeking to consolidate the business opportunities that have arisen in recent years, lure new investment for their respective countries and boost bilateral relations. These many trips in each direction confirm a mutual and relatively new discovery, which speaks of the countries’ interest in each other. The trend will certainly grow and at times move at surprising speed. This mutual interest has spurred high expectations on both sides, some of them viable and others totally disproportionate and exaggerated. And if they are not met to a significant extent, this could lead to acute frustration, especially for Latin America.
    [Show full text]
  • Marcelo Maria Giugale,Phd
    MARCELO MARIA GIUGALE, PHD Marcelo Giugale is the former Director of the World Bank’s Department of Financial Advisory and Banking Services—the team of professionals who help governments in emerging and developing countries manage their assets, their debts, and their risks. A former Director of country, sector, and practice Departments, and an international development leader, his thirty years of experience span the Middle East, Eastern Europe, Central Asia, Latin-America, and Africa, where he led senior-level policy dialogue and over thirty billion dollars in lending and insurance operations across the development spectrum. An Adjunct Professor at Georgetown University and a Fellow of the US National Academy of Public Administration, he has published on macroeconomic policy, finance, subnational fiscal rules, development economics, business, agriculture, and applied econometrics. Notably, he was the chief editor of collections of policy notes published for the presidential transitions in Mexico (2000), Colombia (2002), Ecuador (2003), Bolivia (2006) and Peru (2006). In 2017, he authored the second edition of “Economic Development: What Everyone Needs to Know”, a featured volume by Oxford University Press. His opinion editorials are published in the leading newspapers and blog-sites of the USA, Europe, Latin-America, and Africa. He received decorations from the governments of Bolivia and Peru, and taught at the American University in Cairo, The London School of Economics, and the Universidad Católica Argentina. A citizen of Argentina
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Are Latin America's Corporate Elites
    Are Latin America's corporate elites transnationally interconnected? A network analysis of interlocking directorates Global Networks: A Journal of Transnational Affairs (2014, forthcoming) Author Julian Cardenas Affiliation Research fellow Lateinamerika-Institut Freie Universität Berlin Rüdesheimer Str. 54, 14197 Berlin, Germany Assistant Professor Department of Sociology Universidad de Antioquia Calle 67 nº 53-108, Medellin, Colombia Email: [email protected] Research financed by: Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG), grant number CA1271/1-1 1 Are Latin America’s corporate elites transnationally interconnected? A network analysis of interlocking directorates Abstract Conflicting perspectives appear when thinking about the emergence of a cohesive transnational corporate network in Latin America. On the one hand, regional political integration, foreign investment growth, increased cross-border mergers and acquisitions, cultural and linguistic homogeneity may have fostered transnational networks among Latin America’s corporate elites. On the other hand, domestic-based business groups, family control and trade orientation to the USA may have hindered the emergence of a cohesive transnational corporate network in Latin America. On the basis of a network analysis of interlocking directorates among the 300 largest corporations in Latin America, I inquire whether the region’s corporate elites are interconnected at the transnational level and form a cohesive transnational corporate network. I found few transnational interlocks,
    [Show full text]
  • Colombia in Perspective
    COUNTRY IN PERSPECTIVE COLOMBIA Colorful Colombian Bus Flickr / Pedro Szekely DLIFLC DEFENSE LANGUAGE INSTITUTE FOREIGN LANGUAGE CENTER COUNTRY IN PERSPECTIVE | COLOMBIA TABLE OF CONTENT Geography Introduction ................................................................................................................... 6 Geographic Regions and Topographic Features ................................................... 7 Mountains..............................................................................................................7 Plains .....................................................................................................................8 Climate ........................................................................................................................... 9 Rivers and Lakes ........................................................................................................10 Major Cities ..................................................................................................................11 Bogotá ................................................................................................................. 11 Cali ....................................................................................................................... 12 Medellín ............................................................................................................... 13 Barranquilla ........................................................................................................ 14 Cartagena
    [Show full text]
  • Commercial Biotechnology in Latin America: Current Opportunities And
    Fernando Quezada Commercial biotechnology in is Executive Director of the Biotechnology Center of Excellence Corporation, a Latin America: Current Massachusetts-based organisation advising international public and private opportunities and challenges sector agencies in biotechnology development Fernando Quezada Date received: 11th October 2005 programmes. He served on the Presidential Commission for Biotechnology Development for the Republic of Chile and as Abstract Consultant to the UN The unparalleled growth of commercial biotechnology in the USA and Europe during the past Economic Commission for two decades has also been marked by its steady development in Latin America. Brazil, Cuba, Latin America and the Argentina, Chile, Mexico and others have made significant strides in building their research and Caribbean. production capacity in modern biotechnology. As these countries have pioneered new biotechnology applications in agriculture, mining, biofuels, human and animal healthcare a number have also launched national biotechnology plans with long-term investment commitments. Newly formed biotechnology trade associations in the region are expanding their membership and rapidly gaining international visibility. Along with the growth of commercial biotechnology in Latin America comes the need to address a series of issues associated with public perception, regulatory framework and intellectual property protection, financing mechanisms, workforce development and more. Government agencies and related public institutions are challenged to adjust
    [Show full text]