<<

THE IMAGE OF THE IDEAL his crown to the people. IN THE TALE The people are the roots and the OF DUODECAGON is the tree And the tree depends on the roots. Kusuma Raksamani1 Do not hurt the people’s heart. If you do, you unroot yourself.” (“Boostan” in Najibullah 1963: 297) Abstract In the anecdote, Anushirawan was the A collection of Thai tales, derived from King of Persia who ruled the Sasanian 2 Persian , narrates how the Empire from 531–579 A.D. Hurmuz or successfully deal with their ministers and Hormizd IV was his son and his successor subjects with their righteousness. In the (reigning 579–590). Anushirawan is narrative, the twelve-sided tomb of a king remembered as a great patron of culture is discovered with the inscription of twelve and a man of a noble character. Because stories, endowed with precepts and wise of his fame, the called him Kisra (in sayings on the art of ruling. This article meaning “great”) and also named discusses the Persian source of the work all the rulers of the by and analyses the content and theme of the this name. The name Kisra later became story that mirrors the image of the ideal which is well known in Western king in Thai culture and that of Persian languages, and Anushirawan was called Muslims as well. Also, the power of the . His reputation for justice as constructive narrative is stressed in well as wisdom is cited in several of wise allowing stories to educate the reader or sayings and stories. The above mentioned the listener. account of his last words to his successor Hurmuz, preaching on the role of a good I heard that in his moment of monarch, is one of them. agony Anushirawan said to Hurmuz: The anecdote is in Boostan, a Persian “Be thoughtful of the poor collection of poems by Saadi of Shiraz, a And concerned not only with your great poet of ethical and humanitarian own well-being. literature. Saadi (1219–1292) lived during No one will be prosperous in your the troubled period of the Mongol rule and 3 kingdom the fall of Baghdad. As early as the last If you are devoted only to your own welfare. 2 Sasanians or Sasanids were a Persian founded in 224 A.D. and dominated by Arabs The wise dislike the shepherd’s during the years 637–651. The Sasanian sleep Empire ruled over , Persia, When the wolf is after the sheep. Western Turkestan and Afghanistan. Take care of the poor and needy 3 After the death of Ghengis in 1227 And remember that the king owes A.D. his vast Mongolian empire was divided up among his four sons. Hulagu, one of his grandsons, conquered Persian territory in 1256. 1 Professor Emeritus of and Thai, He launched the Mongol assault on Baghdad in Silpakorn University, Bangkok, Thailand 1258 and founded the Empire of the Ilkhanids,

Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 03:09:17AM via free access The Image of the Ideal Monarch in the Tale of Duodecagon

decade of the 12th century the literary Saadi tells us of his purpose in writing the works of the Islam culture, mostly in Gulistan: Arabic and Persian, were used to express messages other than simply the illustration I have, in summary form, of a story. Many manuscripts were comprised in this book morals and provided with dedications intended to choice tales, embellished with reflect the glory of ruling . They verses and meritorious deeds of could also be used as lessons in kingship Kings; in collecting materials for and statesmanship and, in many instances, which, I have spent a considerable served as ways of recollecting and part of my life […] my design was interpreting contemporary events through to give advice, and I have spoken references to past heroes. (Hattstein & accordingly. I committed the work Delius 2004: 51–52). Saadi’s is no to god, and departed. exception. Saadi was attached to the (Gladwin 2000: 23) courts of Atabek ben Saad Zangui, the ruler of Fars (southern ), and his His intention probably accords with those descendants, to whom Saadi dedicated his of Muslim thinkers and writers who works. Nevertheless, instead of flattering believe that they have a duty to explain the the important men of his time, as was noble values and present them in an easily- customary among poets, he invited them to understood and attractive fashion so that practise humility, justice and piety. He people will be able to develop the values called the Boostan, which consists of ten and attitudes which God intended for chapters, “the Palace of Wealth, furnished them, thus enabling them to enjoy a decent with ten doors of instruction” (Iran and pleasant life (Al-Hashimi 2003: 20). Chamber Society: 4).The first one concerns Saadi’s works are, we may say, a unique justice, counsel and the administration of combination of canonical and secular government. Also in Gulistan, his collection precepts. His narrative is mostly of stories in eight chapters, Saadi dedicates concerned with worldly activities, but his the first chapter to advice on the morals of resolutions are well grounded in Muslim kings. In his works, historical and thought. In the preface to the Boostan legendary figures such as Anushirawan, (Iran Chamber Society: 3–4), apart from Hurmuz, Faridun, Mahmud, Hatim Tay praise of God, he refers to Prophet and Bahram are characterized in ethical Muhammad as his inspiration for ideal and political parables or tales, interspersed leadership: with those wise sayings attributed to some of those sovereigns. Edwin Arnold, an Think not, O Saadi, That one can English poet and scholar of Eastern walk on the road of purity philosophy, has aptly described the except in the footsteps of Gulistan in culinary terms as “an Muhammad. intellectual pillaw [spiced rice]; a literary He is the patriarch of the prophets, curry; a kebab [grilled meat] of versatile the guide of the path to genius.” (Yohannan 1956: 21) salvation; the mediator of mankind, and the chief of the Court of Judgement. who converted to Islam in 1295. The What of thy praises can Saadi Mongolian dynasty on Persian territory was utter? dissolved in 1335.

60

Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 03:09:17AM via free access MANUSYA: Journal of Humanities, Special Issue No.16, 2008

The mercy of God be upon thee, O I, Khun Kalayabodi, composed Prophet, and peace! these exemplary tales dedicated to the King on Sunday, the fourth Again in the preface of the Gulistan month, the tenth day of New (Gladwin 2000: 10), the qualities of the Moon, 1114 Minor Era, the Year good leader are dedicated to Prophet of Monkey and the Fourth-Ended Muhammad: Year.

There is a tradition of the chief of The date falls in 1752 A.D., in the reign of created beings, the most noble of King Baromakote (reigning 1732–1758) existences, the mercy of the and the title of Khun Kalayabodi belonged universe, the purest of mankind to Muslim court officials, mostly Persian, and completion of the revolution in the late Ayutthaya through to the of ages, Muhammad Mustafa4 Ratanakosin Periods. Accordingly, it (upon whom be blessings and might not be wrong to conclude that the peace!). The intercessor, the Nithan Sip Song Liam was written or, obeyed, the gracious prophet, the more precisely, compiled by a Persian bountiful, the majestic, the affable, Muslim court official in the reign of King the sealed. Baromakote of Ayutthaya. As I have already discussed elsewhere (Raksamani Saadi’s Gulistan and Boostan are 2004: 43–56), the Nithan Sip Song Liam is attractive to readers not only in Muslim not a direct translation of any Persian circles but also in Western ones, through work. It is a compilation of tales, legends their Latin and English translations. Ralph and wise sayings related by Persian Waldo Emerson said that Saadi “speaks to officials in the court of King Narai all nations, and like Homer, Shakespeare, (reigning 1656–1688) and passed down by Cervantes and Montaigne, is perpetually courtiers until written down by Khun modern.” Emerson found in the Gulistan Kalayabodi in the late Ayutthaya period. “the universality of moral law.” (Yohannan 1956: 21) One of the sources of these tales is Saadi’s; at least three tales, (No.1 The The meritorious deeds of Kings, in the Ailing King Who Needs a Child’s Blood disguise of Persian tales, travelled far for Medication; No. 8 The King Who away from home to the land of Siam. A Fosters a Thief’s Son; No. 9 The King court manuscript of a collection of Persian Who Offers His Head for Alms) tales called Nithan Sip Song Liam (Tale of correspond to those in the Gulistan and the Duodecagon) is dated as early as the late Boostan. Also, the analogy of the tree- Ayutthaya Period. roots and the king-people as in King Anushirawan’s words in the Boostan (see On the colophon of the oldest extant above) is recited in the Thai tale on the manuscript is this inscription: inscription of a king named Nowasawan, a Thai version of Nushirawan or Anushirawan. His son Horamuk, a Thai version of Hurmuz, also appears in the 4 In Arabic, al-mustafa means “chosen one”. It Thai tale. is one of the common names of Prophet Muhammad, as chosen by God.

61

Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 03:09:17AM via free access The Image of the Ideal Monarch in the Tale of Duodecagon

Although the Tale may “speak to all mountain in a deserted land. The nations,” according to Emerson, because mausoleum was constructed by of its “universality of moral law”; still, the Nowasawan’s successor, King Horamuk, names of characters, such as Hatim, and inscribed with ethico-political rules, Faridun, Wadinsa, Mansur, and settings, wise sayings and tales on good kingship such as Mada’in, Busra, are unfamiliar to and statesmanship. Before his own death, Thai readers. The words nithan khaek, King Horamuk has the pathway to the given to the Tale by mausoleum covered up in order that no Damrongrachanuphap (1963: a) may refer one can disturb the corpse of his father. to its Persian (or khaek persia in Thai) However, King Mamun finally finds the source. Also, the word khaek implies the way to it. On the gate of the mausoleum, exotic flavour of the narrative and he sees a golden inscription describing Schweisguth (1951: 137) refers to “les five gems of human beings along with a Douze Angles de la Perse” (the Twelve specific form of nourishment and Sides from Persia) as “une littérature de destruction for way of destroying each caractère profane et de provenance gem. The first gem is wisdom for which exotique.” the nourishment is prudence and the destruction is ignorance. The second is The exotic tale5 was set back in the time of knowledge, nourished with study and King Mamun6 of Baghdad. The King is destroyed by negligence. The third is told that the body of the righteous King shame, nourished with self-esteem and Nowasawan has been kept in a destroyed by women.8 The fourth is duodecagonal mausoleum7 on top of a justice, nourished with truth and destroyed by falsehood. The fifth is endurance, nourished with piety and destroyed by 5 The discussion is based on the text published avarice. Metaphorically, gems are virtues by Khurusapha, when faced with lacunae the such as wisdom, shame, and justice that manuscript of Ayutthaya is consulted. are precious for a human being. To 6 Mamun was the king who ruled over Abbasid Empire between 813–833 A.D. He was known maintain them, we need certain qualities as a patron of knowledge who had the House like prudence, self-esteem, truth, and of Wisdom (in Arabic, Baitul Hikmah) piety. Meanwhile we should protect the constructed in his kingdom. His father was virtues from damage such as ignorance, Harun Al-Rashid (reigning 786–809), under negligence, avarice and the like. whom came the political and cultural zenith. Harun is a character in The Thousand and One Having read the inscription, King Mamun Nights or The Arabian Nights. For Thai enters the mausoleum. He sees the corpse readers, he is better known in Lilit Nithra of King Nowasawan sitting upright as if Chakhrit (the Thai version of the Sleeper Awakened) as a king who loves adventures and often disguises himself to observe what The styles of mausoleums are varied: tower- irregularities are committed in his country. shaped, domed or polygonal. In the Thai Tale, 7 Mausoleums (elaborate and monumental King Nowasawan’s mausoleum is tombs), that thrived in Central in the 11th duodecagonal or twelve-sided. Thus the book and 12th centuries, were the preserve of the is called Nithan Sip Song Liam (Tale of , his wives, the highest officers of the Duodecagon). empire, the , and certain important “men 8 As in a patriarchy, women are always blamed of faith”, while “common mortals” were buried for being the cause of men’s failure or in cemeteries (Hattstein and Delius 2004: 374). misbehaviour.

62

Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 03:09:17AM via free access MANUSYA: Journal of Humanities, Special Issue No.16, 2008

alive. He salutes the great King and righteousness.” The story is a somewhat changes the attire of the corpse. Then he elaborated and illustrated version of some sees, on the ruby veil over the corpse’s rules or sayings in the prologue. For face, the inscription of five rules: to example, the advice of how not to oppress eliminate sin, to assist dependents, to the subjects is the theme of at least two provide merit, to do good and to support stories. people. Each of the right four fingers wears a ring, inscribed with the rules of The first one narrates the story of King governing: to be considerate in Faridun who suffers from a terrible punishment, to concentrate on the well- disease. The court physicians advise him being of people, to be conscious of to take a child’s blood for medication; transiency and to relieve people of their otherwise he will die in three months. The misery. The rings on the left four fingers King issues an order to search for a child read as follows: to be virtuous, to appoint whose parents are willing to trade him for intelligent people as the king’s eyes and a big piece of gold. A twelve-year old boy ears, to patronize religion and to be is brought. Being reluctant to shed the circumspect. blood of his subjects, the King asks the court judges to reconsider it. They insist King Mamun learns many more ethical that the boy’s life be taken for the survival rules for a sovereign from the inscription of the King and that of the kingdom. on the ruby bracelets on both wrists and When brought in to the King’s presence, along the wall of the mausoleum. As he is the boy laughs and says: “A son needs his circumambulating the mausoleum, he sees parents’ protection; still, my parents prefer on each side of the duodecagonal wall the gold to my life. People entrust fair inscription of a tale narrating the story of judgment to the judge; yet the court judges the past king. Before leaving, the King decide to kill me. As a subject, I implore has all the twelve tales and teachings in the King’s mercy but he loves his life the inscription written down in a more than anything else. My last resort is manuscript for himself. From then on he then to complain to God who has created strictly follows this advice and eventually many kinds of diseases. He must have becomes a pious and righteous king, just created the medication for curing them too like King Nowasawan. but I wonder why the King’s disease has no other cure except my blood.” The King The narrative of the Nithan Sip Song Liam becomes troubled at these words. He tells is composed of two parts. The first is the his courtiers: “Even if I am cured by the prologue or the kathāmukha, relating the boy’s blood, finally I can’t escape death. story of King Mamun who is impressed by My fault will be rumoured and last the righteousness of King Nowasawan forever. Whatever merit I have done will through the inscription of ethical rules and be tarnished by this mistake.” He then wise sayings. The second is a collection gives the boy some wealth and releases of twelve stories narrating how the kings him. Suddenly the disease is completely in the past dealt with their subjects and cured, just because of his righteousness. ministers and how they achieved success and happiness through their virtue. Each The second story narrates the story of story ends with a phrase like this: “…his King Humayun of Busra who lost his way land then became peaceful because of his while hunting. He meets a pomegranate-

63

Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 03:09:17AM via free access The Image of the Ideal Monarch in the Tale of Duodecagon

grower and asks for some water to drink. sovereign listening to his subjects is found The old man fetches him a bowl of in the story of King Nowasawan who pomegranate juice. When the King finds allows his people to ring the bell, out that the man has earned much wealth complaining to him. One day an emaciated from the plants, he considers collecting tax mule comes to ring the bell by pulling the from the farmer. But when he asks for cord with its teeth. Having seen the another bowl of juice, the farmer scarcely starved animal, the King sends for its fills the bowl. The surprised King asks owner who later informs the King that the why, at first, a single pomegranate yielded mule, when young, worked for him and a full bowl of juice but later even ten was fed well in return; since the animal is pomegranates can not make it. The old too old to work, he has let it find food by farmer replies that possibly the sovereign itself. The king then reprimands the man was considering the plant tax. When asked and orders him to keep the animal and to clarify, he refers to an old saying “Much feed it well as before. required will get less, but less required will get much.” Then he explains that if In the prologue, there is the advice for a farmers have much income extracted from sovereign to be considerate to his subjects. them, they will not be willing to grow It says: “Be thoughtful; they came under more plants and then the tax revenue will your patronage because they are helpless.” diminish. In contrast, low taxes will be an incentive for their planting and the tax commentary, explains: “The ant, to outward revenue will increase. On his return to his appearance, is a very small and humble palace, the King orders his men not to creature. In the great pomp and circumstances collect tax from those who have never of the world, she (generic feminine in Arabic) been taxed before, and also reduces the tax may be neglected or even trampled on by usually collected. From then on, the court people who mean her no harm. Yet, by her gains much more income and people live wisdom, she carries on her own life within her happily because the King has ruled over own sphere (“habitation”) unmolested, and make a useful contribution to the economy of the land righteously. the world. So there is room for the humblest people in the spiritual world.” In the next In the prologue, there is a saying: “The verse (27: 19) King Suleiman smiled, amused king is like a physician and people are his at the ant’s speech and then he prayed and patients who need to tell him their vowed to God that he would work the symptoms. If the former refuses to listen righteousness that would please Him. Yusuf to the latter, how can the disease be Ali (fn. 3259) here explains: “The counterpart cured?” This saying is further referred to to the position of the humble ant is the position King Suleiman who knew the language of of the great king like Suleiman. He prays that animals and listened to an ant who his power and wisdom and all other gifts may 9 be used for righteousness and particularly for complained to him. The theme of the the benefit of all around him. The ant being in his thoughts, we may suppose that he means 9 In the Qur’an (Scripture of Islam), King particularly in his prayer that he may not even Suleiman () knew the language of unwillingly tread on humble being in his animals. One day he heard an ant saying to its preoccupation with the great things of the companions: “O ye ants, get into habitations, world.” To sum up, both the governor and the lest Solomon and his hosts crush you (under governed are significant in accordance with foot) without knowing it” (chapter 27: verse their own means; a consideration for each 18). Yusuf Ali (1977: 982 fn. 3258) in his other is needed.

64

Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 03:09:17AM via free access MANUSYA: Journal of Humanities, Special Issue No.16, 2008

The theme is found in the story of King The narrative also instructs ministers and Wadinsa who has a ruby ring made by his courtiers on their behaviour towards the jeweller. The man accidentally breaks the king. For example, the advice for the king gemstone into two pieces. He is scared to to select good ministers as his eyes and death and lives in distress for many days ears, indirectly tells them how they can be before the King summons him. When the included in the selection. The Tale even king sees the gemstone in two pieces and includes the role of subjects as another the jeweller in distress, he is considerate to factor in government. The counterpart to him. He says: “The ruby is divided into the position of the great king is that of the two pieces just as I want. At first, I would humble subjects. They are humble but they like to have had two rings made from the make a useful contribution to the system. gemstone; but I didn’t ask for that, lest it The metaphors of the roots of the tree and would trouble you. Now you have made it bricks forming the root of the city wall easy for me. Go and make me two ruby indicate the significance of the people. No rings!” The jeweller is relieved and is wonder the Nithan Sip Song Liam had released, no matter how the courtiers warn been noted as a court literary work in the the King against him. The King tells his first reign of the Ratanakosin down to the men: “The jeweller is a man of fourth. incomparable skill. To punish him with death is unwise; we will not only lose him In the first reign, there was a golden- but also lose our prestige. A king should lettered court manuscript of the Nithan Sip be merciful to his people. The people are Song Liam. The colophon indicates that it the bricks forming the foundation of the was written in 1782 A.D., the year King city wall; they should not be destroyed.” Rama I ascended the throne. According to H.R.H. Prince Damrongrachanuphap, the The stories of the kings in all twelve tales Tale had been valued, since the Ayutthaya including interspersed precepts in the period, as an ethico-didactic story of narrative of the Nithan Sip Song Liam rājadharma (or rājanīti, royal policy and form the mosaic image of an ideal king statesmanship); thus the King preferred who is endowed with goodness. As is having a court copy available for him common among monarchical practices, (Damrongrachanuphap 1963: a). In the some advice in the Tale such as self- third reign when “the People’s University” sacrifice (บริจาค), angerlessness (อักโกธะ), was established at Wat Pho, the Nithan Sip Song Liam was one of the stories in the non-oppressive- ness (อวิหิงสา) and non- inscriptions of sciences and arts. As deviation from righteousness (อวิโรธนะ) is regards its content of sovereigns and their subjects, and also the wider popular access found in the Ten Virtues of a Ruler to the inscriptions, we may say that this (ทศพิธราชธรรม). Also from the Islamic was a means of instructing people how to perspective, as is evident in the Qur’an behave as subjects of the sovereign. (Scripture of Islam) and the Sunna Evidently, the story was concerned not (Prophet Muhammad’s model behaviour), only with the rājadharma but also the freedom (al-huriyya, in Arabic), equality prajādharma (popular practical conduct). (musāwāt) and justice (‘adl) are essential According to Ginsburg (1967: 7), in 1863 in the social and political context (Kamali A.D. (in the reign of King Rama IV) Adolf 1999: 2–4).

65

Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 03:09:17AM via free access The Image of the Ideal Monarch in the Tale of Duodecagon

Bastian10 brought back to Germany the meant to test the hero’s righteousness and English translation of the Nithan Sip Song intelligence. In the Nithan Iranrachatham Liam and referred to it along with the (Nithan Sip Song Liam) as well as the other other two tales, the Nithan Nang Tantrai four Pancatantra recensions, the and the Pisacapakarana11 in 1864 and narratives are meant for educating again in 1873. The Nithan Sip Song Liam listeners, or a reader in the case of King was first published in Thai by Dr. Samuel Mamun, who are characters in the story. In John Smith at his press at Bangkholaem in the Pancatantra, four irresponsible and 1870 A.D. and sold at 75 satang a copy. wayward princes are taught by a Brahmin the art of ruling in the disguise of stories. In the reign of King Rama VII, the Nithan After this course of narrative education, Sip Song Liam was published as memorial the princes eventually become well-versed books for distribution at cremation in political and ethical knowledge, ready ceremonies and later compiled into to succeed to their father’s throne. volume together with other tales or Likewise, the narrative in the Nithan Sip pakaranas. H.R.H. Prince Damrongracha- Song Liam educates King Mamun and nuphap, who was in charge of the Royal persuades him to follow the right path of Institute, states in his preface of the book his forefather, King Nowasawan. In this (1963: d): “The title ‘Sip Song Liam’ is case, the narrator is absent, leaving behind rather unattractive and conceals the him the inscription of advice and the significance of the work. Since the Tale is image of an ideal king. Both the four of Iranian [another name for Persian] princes and King Mamun are educated origin and concerns royal practices or through the constructive power of rachatham [rājadharma], the work is here narrative. So are the many enthusiastic renamed Nithan Iranrachatham.” readers. But unluckily, today the power of Unfortunately, the name Nithan narrative seems to be diminished for it has Iranrachatham seems to have faded away been hidden away on the bookshelf for too from the Thai book circle; it was published long. together with other 5 pakaranas12 with the subtitle, Prachum Pakaranam (Collection References of Tales) and today the volume remains unnoticed on the shelves of a few libraries. Al-Hashimi, Muhammad Ali. 2003. The All the six tales in the Prachum Ideal Muslim. Riyadh: International Pakaranam prove the power of narrative. Islamic Publishing House. In the Vetalapakaranam, the tales are Ali, A. Yusuf. 1977. The Glorious Qur’an. 10 Adolf Bastian (1826–1905), a German Indiana: The Muslim Students’ ethnographer who travelled to many Asian Association of the United States and countries and wrote books on their cultures and Canada. on Buddhism. 11 Details on these 2 tales are in Kusuma III, Damrongrachanuphap, Prince. 1963. 2004: 77–91. Explanation for Nithan Iranrachatham 12 Vetalapakaranam is from the Vikramaditya (อธิบายนิทานอิหรานราชธรรม). In Nithan story cycle; Nandukapakaranam, Paksipakaranam, Pisacapakaranam and Hitopadesavatthupakaranam Iranrachatham: Collection of Tales – all the four are the Pancatantra recensions; details in Kusuma III, 2004: 77–166, 175–185.

66

Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 03:09:17AM via free access MANUSYA: Journal of Humanities, Special Issue No.16, 2008

(นิทานอิหรานราชธรรม: ประชุมปกรณัม). Bangkok: Khurusapha. (In Thai)

Ginsburg, Henry D. 1967. Thai Literary Tales Derived from the Sanskrit Tantropakhyana with Special Reference to the Pisacapakaranam. Master’s Thesis, University of Hawaii.

Gladwin, Francis (tr.). 2000. The Gulistan or Rose Garden by Saadi. London: Al- Hoda.

Hattstein, Markus and Peter Delius. 2004. Islam Art and Architecture. Konigswinter: Konemann.

Iran Chamber Society. Accessed 18 June 2008. The Boostan of Saadi. [Online]. Available: http://www. iranchamber.com/literature/saadi/books /bostan_saadi.pdf

Kamali, Muhammad Hashim. 1999. Freedom Equality and Justice in Islam. Selangor: Ilmiah Publishers.

Najibullah. 1963. Islamic Literature. Washington: Washington Square Press.

Raksamani, Kusuma. 2004. Kusumawanna III: Pakaranum Nithan (กุสุมาวรรณนา 3: ปกรณัมนิทาน). Bangkok: Mae Khanphang. (In Thai)

Schweisguth, P. 1951. Étude sur la littérature siamoise. Paris: Imprimérie nationale.

Yohannan, John D. 1956. A Treasury of Asian Literature. New York: The John Day Company.

67

Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 03:09:17AM via free access