3032 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS February 24, 1983 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS PERSONAL JUSTICE DENIED ing American citizens-were prohibited from Few Americans were familiar with Ameri living and working on the West Coast. can citizens of Japanese descent. The opin Almost all were later sent to "relocation ions of those with intelligence responsibil HON. ROBERT T. MATSUI centers"-bleak barrack camps ringed by ity, such as the FBI, who believed that OF CALIFORNIA barbed wire and military guards in isolated there was no sound basis for mass exclusion, IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES areas of the West. Most remained in the were ignored or drowned out in the fright Thursday, February 24, 1983 camps until the mass exclusion was ended in ened uproar of the time. December 1944, more than two and a half The Commission has carefully reviewed • Mr. MATSUI. Mr. Speaker, today, years after the policy of exclusion and de the extensive record of events which led to the Commission on Wartime Reloca tention began. These events are unique in Executive Order 9066. It has found no evi tion and Internment of Civilians will our history. dence of a military or security threat from deliver to Congress and release to the No program of mass exclusion or deten the Japanese Americans. As General public its report setting forth the facts tion was imposed on German and Italian DeWitt conceded at the time, no sabotage and circumstances surrounding Execu aliens nor upon American citizens of had taken place. The later justifications of German or Italian descent. fered by DeWitt in his Final Report on the tive Order 9066 and the impact of the The government justified the exclusion exclusion and by the Justice Department order on Japanese American citizens from the West Coast of all American citi which defended the exclusion in court also and resident aliens. zens of Japanese descent and Japanese resi fail to demonstrate any military or security The report, entitled "Personal Jus dent aliens on the basis of military necessi threat. In fact the realistic estimates of the tice Denied," sets forth the circum ty. The first task of the Commission has time suggested that there was as much or stances surrounding the initiation and been to look at the facts and consider more danger from other segments of the implementation of orders from the whether military necessity justified this population. highest authorities of our land to course of action. DeWitt's contention that ethnicity deter evacuate and intern American citizens The Commission has found that the mined loy?..lty was answered as early as May record does not permit the conclusion that 1942, by a Congressional Committee which and resident aliens of Japanese ances there was any military justification for the examined the impact of the · Executive try. mass exclusion and detention of American Order in extensive hearings on the West The commission, after l 1/2 years of citizens of Japanese ancestry and their resi Coast: study and after hearing from over 750 dent alien parents. "This testimony has impressed upon us in witnesses, has concluded that there There were no documented cases of sabo convincing fashion the fundamental fact was no military or security justifica tage, espionage or fifth column activity by that place of birth and technical noncitizen tion for the mass exclusion and deten Japanese Americans on the West Coast. ship alone provide no decisive criteria for as tion. The commission identified the There was a widespread-but false-belief sessing the alinement of loyalties in this causes of these decisions as race preju that the attack on Pearl Harbor had been world-wide conflict." dice, war hysteria, and a failure of po aided by sabotage and fifth column activi True of aliens, that statement can only be ties. The President and his cabinet officers more powerful with regard to Amercian citi litical leadership. did not forcefully dispel these stories and zens. Our legal system is founded on deter Mr. speaker, I commend the mem rumors. On the West Coast, where there mining guilt or fault on an individual basis, bers of the Commission on Wartime had been a long history of prejudice and dis and citizens must be given the presumption Relocation and Internment of Civil crimination against the ethnic Japanese, of loyalty. Moreover, the conclusion that ians for their outstanding report. It is there were sustained and even louder de ethnicity determined loyalty was not a mili a report that for the first time sets mands for the exclusion of Japanese Ameri tary judgment deserving of any deference. cans. These demands were made by orga Generals are not experts on race; their forth the tragic and shameful chapter nized anti-Japanese interest groups, the views on the political loyalties of civilians of our history that is unknown to mil press and the West Coast members of Con are only as good as the facts they can mar lions of Americans. It is a chapter in gress-they came from every segment of the shal in their support. The lack of any evi which over 120,000 American citizens political spectrum. dence of disloyalty on the part of Americans and resident aliens were denied their The civilian clamour for exclusion was re of Japanese ancestry in 1942 speaks for freedom without consideration for flected in the actions of the War Depart itself. their constitutional rights. ment. Lieutenant General John L. DeWitt, The Commission has concluded that the in command of Army forces on the West broad historical causes of the Executive The grave injustice forced upon Coast, recommended to Henry L. Stimson, Order wefe race prejudice, war hysteria, and these Japanese Americans is truly a the Secretary of War, that authority be a failure of political leadership. Widespread case of personal justice denied. I en sought to remove the Japanese Americans ignorance about Japanese Americans con courage all of my colleagues to read from the West Coast. DeWitt made his rec tributed to a policy conceived in haste and this report. ommendation on the ground that loyalty executed in an atmosphere of fear and was determined by ethnicity, "In the war in anger at Japan. Mr. Speaker, at this time I would which we are now engaged," DeWitt wrote like to include for the RECORD a state Secretary Stimson, "racial affinities are not Ending the exclusion was bitterly and ment by Joan Z. Bernstein, chairper severed by migration. The Japanese race is forcefully opposed on the West Coast. just an enemy race and while many second and as the decision to exclude and detain had ef son of the Commission on Wartime fectively been promoted. The Commission's Relocation and Internment of Civil third generation Japanese born on United States soil possessed of Unites States citi report provides substantial new information ians. zenship, have become 'Americanized,' the on those events. Today the Commission on Wartime Relo racial strains are undiluted." The record Secretary Stimson and John J. Mccloy, cation and Internment of Civilians is deliv shows that DeWitt's views were substantial who served as Assistant Secretary of War. ering to Congress and releasing to the ly influenced by the governors and public approved the original order of exclusion, public its findings with regard to the pro officials of the West Coast states whose but they were men who were open to an un mulgation of Executive Order 9066 and the views he sought out before taking his own derstanding of the facts and they did not wartime events which followed from it. position. accept General Dewitt's views on race or On February 19, 1942, President Franklin Secretary Stimson and President Roose believe that the Japanese Americans should D. Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066. velt did not subject this program to suffi be excluded from the West Coast for the du Under that Order 120,000 people-American ciently close and critical scrutiny. The At ration of the war. citizens of Japanese ancestry and resident torney General, Francis Biddle, did not be McCloy and Stimson opposed professional aliens of the immigrant generation from lieve the program necessary, but acceded to military opinion in deciding that the Army Japan, who were barred by law from becom- it when proposed by the War Department. would seek volunteers among the Japanese
e This "bullet" symbol identifies statements or insertions which are not spoken by the Member on the floor. February 24, 1983 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 3033 Americans, thus opening the door to per among West Coast politicians and interest and cabinet members, the President him suading even the most prejudiced of the loy groups to the return of Japanese Americans self-were personally involved in a course of alty of Japanese Americans who returned to the West Coast. These views prevailed. action which today we can only find gravely from European battlefields loaded with For at least the last six months of that unjust and deeply injurious. The bulwark of honors won in the service of the United period, immediately before the Presidential our Constitution did not withstand it. Igno States. election of 1944, the decision to continue rance was a major contributing factor in Most importantly, by the spring of 1943, the exclusion was that of President Roose these events; knowledge is the surest guardi the civilians at the head of the War Depart velt. an against their repetition. We can only ment had reached the position that no justi By any analysis with the least sensitivity hope to abide by our better judgement in fication existed any longer for excluding to American constitutional values there was the future if we have made our past our loyal Japanese American citizens from the no justification for holding loyal American own and are determined to learn by its les West Coast. In April 1943, McCloy laid out citizens of Japanese descent in detention or sons. the basic points very forcefully to General prohibiting them from traveling, living and Ronald Reagan, speaking in 1970 as Gov DeWitt, who was on the West Coast. I quote working where they chose. ernor of California, pointedly and accurate the letter at length because it states In his memoirs, Secretary Stimson cogent ly underscored what each American should succinctly the situation in the spring of 1943 ly called the evacuation of "personal injus take from this history: and lays bare the differences of opinion tice" to loyal Japanese Americans. It was a "A lesson was learned in California during with General DeWitt and those who sup personal injustice precisely because the World War II, which should be made a part ported exclusion: country failed to apply justice in a personal of the record and the heritage of Americans "The threat of Japanese attack is far from or individual manner. Men, women and chil everywhere who cherish liberty, freedom, what it was. We are better organized to dren were uprooted from their homes and and constitutional guarantees." meet such an attack if it occurred. And we their lives shattered because the United The Commission's second important task know a great deal more about our Japanese States failed to provide personal justice in was to review the evacuation of the Aleuts population. Furthermore, the War Depart time of war. It is important to emphasize from the Aleutian and Pribilof Islands and ment has established a combat team for vol that we are dealing here with American be their treatment in camps in Southeastern unteer American citizens of Japanese ances havior. It is not a question of how the Japa Alaska. try ... CTlhe War Department has initiated nese or the Nazis treated Americans or The situation in Alaska was very unlike a process for loyalty investigations of all other prisoners which is one of the darkest that on the West Coast. The Japanese at Japanese Americans to determine their eli chapters of modern history. What the Com tacked the two most western islands in the gibility for work in plants and facilities vital mission has examined and taken testimony Aleutian chain in the summer of L942 and to the war effort. In other words, . . . the about is how the United States dealt with took 42 Aleut prisoners. As part of the reac policy of the national Government, as well American citizens and residents. tion t o that attack, the military evacuated as that of the War Department, is presently The damage done by this country to its the Aleuts from the Pribilof islands and looking toward the restoration to all loyal own citizens and residents is a mosaic made from a large part of the Aleutian chain. The persons of Japanese ancestry of all their up of thousands of lives and thousands of evidence shows that the evacuation was a normal rights and privileges, to the end that personal histories. The Commission's hear rational response to the danger presented. they may be able to make their maximum ing record is replete with searing and pain Both whites and Aleuts, apart from those contribution to the war effort. The very 'en ful testimony. There is the economic loss of necessary to defense work, were removed. tering wedge' which you appear to dread is farms and homes sold in distress circum The protection of an exposed population precisely what must be accomplished. stances, of elderly people having to start was the motivating force for the evacuation. from scratch a second time after the war, of The camps to which the Aleuts were "That there is serious animosity of the families detained in camps without employ taken are an entirely different matter. Ap West Coast against all evacuated Japanese I ment and unable to meet tax and mortgage proximately 850 Aleuts were housed in do not doubt, but that does not necessarily and insurance payments; of education and abandoned buildings, typically at gold mines mean that we should trim our sails accord careers disrupted. and fish canneries. The conditions and the ingly. The longer California luxuriates in Over time and with perseverance material care were deplorable. In some camps there the total absence of the Japanese the more losses may be repaired, but the hidden were inadequate sleeping quarters and sani difficult it will be to restore them to the scares of lives damaged by this experience tation. Health conditions were particularly economy of California. They have a place in remain. Each individual excluded from the bad. Epidemics raged throughout the California as well as in any other state as West Coast and sent only with the baggage Aleuts' stay in southeastern Alaska; they long as military considerations do not inter he could carry to spend two and a half years suffered from influenza, measles and pneu vene. I cannot help but feel that social con behind barbed wire carries his own marks monia along with tuberculosis. Twenty-five siderations rather than military ones deter from that time. For people who knew their died at Funter Bay in 1943 alone, and it is mine the total exclusion policy. The Army, innocence and the injustice of their treat estimated that probably ten percent of the as I see it, is not responsible for the general ment the burden was not light. They bore evacuated Aleuts died during their two or public peace of the Western Defense Com the stigma of having been branded poten three year stay in southeastern Alaska. The mand. That responsibility still rests with tially disloyal, the deprivation of liberty and standard of care which the government the civil authorities. There may, as you sug the loss of the common decencies of daily owes to those under its protection was clear gest, be incidents, but these can be effective life. An essential foundation of our govern ly violated by this treatment. ly discouraged by prompt action by law en ment-the citizens trust that the govern The Aleuts were only returned to their is forcement agencies, with the cooperation of ment will deal with him individually and lands in 1944 and 1945. On arriving home, the military if they even assume really fairly-was deeply damaged. The injuries in they found that their communities had threatening proportions." flicted by the country on these citizens were been vandalized and looted by the military McCloy was entirely correct in his view different in kind from the suffering and loss forces. Many homes were uninhabitable and that the military situation no longer justi which the Second World War brought to all many heirlooms of great spiritual as well as fied exclusion 11--059 0-87-11 (Pt. 3) 3046 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS February 24, 1983 This course of action-voluntary Referral to a doctor participating in this EFFECTIVENESS OF CHAIRMAN help on an individual basis-has· been program can be obtained by calling 790-1838 CHUCK MANATT chosen by over 1,000 physicians in the Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 Houston area. These doctors, members p.m. of the Harris County Medical Society, The medical society spokesman said pa HON. TONY COELHO tients should first call their personal physi OF CALIFORNIA are providing free medical care to cians to determine if they are participating those in the Houston area who are in the program.• IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES temporarily unemployed, or lack medi Thursday, February 24, 1983 cal insurance. I believe this effort on the part of ESTONIAN INDEPENDENCE DAY e Mr. COELHO. Mr. Speaker, I would Harris County physicians and the like to draw attention to two recent ar Harris County Medical Society is an HON. JOHN EDWARD PORTER ticles that were published in the inspiring example of the spirit of gen Washington Post. OF ILLINOIS I hope that all the Members will erosity and community that character IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES izes our great Nation and our people. take a minute to look them over, be We are often told that it is necessary Thursday, February 24, 1983 cause they provide an excellent over for the Federal Government to pro • Mr. PORTER. Mr. Speaker, today is view of the great strides taken by our vide help to the needy and the unfor the 65th anniversary of Estonian Inde party under the able leadership of tunate, because people will not choose pendence day. In honoring this day it Chuck Manatt. to help others voluntarily. This recent is important to remember that Estonia During his 2 years as chairman of action by Harris County doctors was once a free and independent sover the Democratic National Committee, proves just how wrong that attitude is. eign democracy. It was forcefully ab Chuck Manatt has worked closely with I salute these fine physicians for their sorbed into the U.S.S.R. in 1940 along the Democratic House and Senate willingness to help those in need. with its sister states in the Baltic. leadership to rebuild our party from CFrom the Houston Chronicle, Feb. 14, The Soviets have tried to create a the ground up. 1983] "new Soviet man." They have done While the GOP got lazy, Chairman MORE THAN 1,000 PHYSICIANS OFFERING this by systematically attempting to Manatt took the DNC back to basics FREE CARE TO UNEMPLOYED suppress the culture, religion, and ex after 1980. There has been renewed