A Decorative Analysis of Phil-Ellena, a Greek Revival, Philadelphia Mansion
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Theses (Historic Preservation) Graduate Program in Historic Preservation 1992 A Decorative Analysis of Phil-Ellena, A Greek Revival, Philadelphia Mansion Sheryl Farber Mikelberg University of Pennsylvania Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/hp_theses Part of the Historic Preservation and Conservation Commons Mikelberg, Sheryl Farber, "A Decorative Analysis of Phil-Ellena, A Greek Revival, Philadelphia Mansion" (1992). Theses (Historic Preservation). 340. https://repository.upenn.edu/hp_theses/340 Copyright note: Penn School of Design permits distribution and display of this student work by University of Pennsylvania Libraries. Suggested Citation: Mikelberg, Sheryl Farber (1992). A Decorative Analysis of Phil-Ellena, A Greek Revival, Philadelphia Mansion. (Masters Thesis). University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA. This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/hp_theses/340 For more information, please contact [email protected]. A Decorative Analysis of Phil-Ellena, A Greek Revival, Philadelphia Mansion Disciplines Historic Preservation and Conservation Comments Copyright note: Penn School of Design permits distribution and display of this student work by University of Pennsylvania Libraries. Suggested Citation: Mikelberg, Sheryl Farber (1992). A Decorative Analysis of Phil-Ellena, A Greek Revival, Philadelphia Mansion. (Masters Thesis). University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA. This thesis or dissertation is available at ScholarlyCommons: https://repository.upenn.edu/hp_theses/340 ^w !#!:;: UNIVERSITY^ PENNSYLVANIA. LIBRARIES y ^ A DECORATIVE ANALYSIS OF PHIL-ELLENA, A GREEK REVIVAL, PHILADELPHIA MANSION Sheryl Farber Mikelberg A THESIS in The Graduate Program in Historic Preservation Presented to the Faculties of the University of Pennsylvania in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE 1992 CUJ ^^^^ Uoi^cdJx^—— Gail Caskey Winkler, Lecturer, Historic Preservation, Advisor TliA^.^ Agtjunct Associate Professor, tion. Reader idSvi-d G. De Graduate Group Chairman ^^^ INE ARTS //'M/9^//^4l /'^ ONJVERsrrv .-_ Of IfiENNSYLvAN.A; LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS Figure 1: Elevation and plan of first floor of Phil-Ellena, A Brief Description of Phil-Ellena, 1844. Figure 2: 1848 Map of Germantown Tovmship, Philadelphia by J.C. Sidney and R. P. Smith, the Free Library of Philadelphia, Map Department. Figure 3: 1876 City Atlas of Philadelphia, 22nd Ward, Vol.1 by G. M. Hopkins, the Free Library of Philadelphia, Map Dept. Figure 4: 1899 Atlas of Philadelphia, 22nd Ward by G.W. and W.G. Bromley, the Free Library of Philadelphia, Map Dept. Figure 5: Watercolor of Phil-Ellena, no date or identification, Germantown Historical Society, Philadelphia. Figure 6: George Washington Carpenter, from the George Clarence Johnson Scrapbook, Vol. II "Pictoral Germantown Road and Vicinity and Some of its Inhabitants," 1933, Germantown Historical Society, Philadelphia. Figure 7: "Portrait Painting of George Washington Carpenter," Photograph of George Washington Carpenter by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 118. Figure 8: "Greenhouse Interior with Three Women and a Man, First Version," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. S3. Photograph possibly shows Ellen Carpenter and her two daughters, Fannie and Ellen, and son, Emlen Carpenter. Figure 9: "Front of House from East with Boy," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 9120. 60. Figure 10: "Front Facade," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 42. Figure 11: "Front Entrance with Hay Wagon," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 38. Figure 12: "Entrance and Germantown Avenue in Snow," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Coitpany of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 39. Figure 13: "Entrance Footpath with Statues and Fountain" photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 86. 11 Figure 14: "Museum Facade," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Cort^any of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 58. Figure 15: "Museum Interior," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 61. Figure 16: "Summer House," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Corrpany of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 64. Figure 17: "Clock Tower," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Corrpany of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 66. Figure 18: "Farmer's Cottage" photograph by George B. Wood, Library Conpany of Philadelphia, P. 9120. 65. Figure 19: "Main Bam with Man Grooming Horse," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 70. Figure 20: "Kitchen Garden," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 49. Figure 21: "Front Elevation for a Country Residence," ilustration designed by Minard Lafever, The Beauties of Modern Architecture, plate 75. Introduction by Denys Peter Myers. Reprint ed. New York: DaCapo Press, 1968. Figure 22: "Hall From Front, with Urns," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 4. Figure 23: "Library From Drawing Room Entrance," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 9121. 49. Figure 24: "Library from Drawing Room Entrance," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 9120. 48. Figure 25: "Entrance to Library from Drawing Room," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 9120. 52, Figure 26: "First Floor From Library Through Drawing Room," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Coitpany of Philadelphia, P. 8969.15. Figure 27: "Drawing Room From Front," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 12. Ill Figure 28: "Drawing Room From Rear," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 14. Figure 29: "Parlor From Front," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 69. Figure 30: "Parlor From Rear," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 89 69.70. Figure 31: "Breakfast Room From Parlor," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969.9. Figure 32: "Smoking Room From Library," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969. 35. Figure 33: "Office Off Breakfast Room," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969.31. Figure 34: "Bedroom A," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969.23. Figure 35: "Bedroom A," photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969.21. Figure 36: "Bedroom B, " photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969.26. Figure 37: "Bedroom C, " photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969.28. Figure 38: "Bedroom D, " photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969.29. Figure 39: "Bedroom D, " photograph by George B. Wood, Library Company of Philadelphia, P. 8969.30. IV ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank Gail Caskey Winkler for her steady and unfailing support throughout this year, from beginning to end. I would also like to thank the Library Company for the use of their facilities and Susan Oyama for her effort in reproducing the images included in this thesis. Mark Lloyd, the archivist for the University of Pennsylvania deserves thanks for his information concerning the Dun and Bradstreet reports on Carpenter and the general history of Germantown. I would like to especially acknowledge and thank my mother, father and sister, and my dear friends Sara, Cloantha, Sarah, Joni and Franny. All have been very supportive and caring during the entire process, and I am greatly appreciative. I would also like to thank Brian, my new friend, for his encouragement. V TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS v INTRODUCTION 1 CRAPTER I : HISTORICAL BACKGROUND 8 CHAPTER II : ANALYSIS OF THE SETTING AND STRUCTURE 24 The Grounds and Out.biiildinas 24 The Greek Revival style 30 CHAPTER III : AN ANALYSIS OF THE INTERIOR 38 The Plan of the Phil-Ellena 39 The Finishes 42 Panels and Frescoes 44 Graining 4 5 Scagliola and Marbleized Surfaces 50 Floor Coverings 52 Stained Glass 55 Household Furnishings 56 Library 59 Drawing Room 64 Parlor 7 Hall 73 Breakfast Parlor 7 4 Office 77 Study or Smoking Room 7 8 Bedchambers 80 The Mechanical Systems 84 Plumbing 84 Heating System 89 CONCLUSION 92 APPENDIX 96 BIBLIOGRAPHY 12 FIGURES 125 Vi INTRODUCTION Phil-Ellena, meaning "for the love of Ellen," was the name of a grand residence built in the Greek Revival style by the owner, George Washington Carpenter, in 1844 (Figures 6 and 7). Phil-Ellena was a product of favorable economics in pre- Civil War Philadelphia, when profits could be reaped easily by those with a quick entrepreneurial mind. The new-found wealth and dreams of Carpenter, a prosperous druggist and wholesale drug manufacturer, generated the construction of this residence. In 1844, Germantown, the location for Phil- Ellena, was a bustling farm/village corridor between Philadelphia and the countryside. Carpenter assembled more than 500 acres of land in Germantown in the 1830s. One hundred acres were devoted to the pleasure grounds, forests, lakes, gardens and supporting outbuildings of Phil-Ellena. The actual residence was set back two hundred feet from Germantown Avenue. Six great columns supported the front, central portico; the back facade was similar, also having six great columns. The flanking wings