Eloisa Paganoni, Bithynia in Memnon's Perì Herakleias
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Ancient History Bulletin VOLUME TWENTY-NINE: 2015 NUMBERS 1-2 Edited by: Edward Anson ò Michael Fronda òDavid Hollander Timothy Howe òJoseph Roisman ò John Vanderspoel Pat Wheatley ò Sabine Müller ISSN 0835-3638 ANCIENT HISTORY BULLETIN Volume 29 (2015) Numbers 1-2 Edited by: Edward Anson, Michael Fronda, David Hollander, Sabine Müller, Joseph Roisman, John Vanderspoel, Pat Wheatley Senior Editor: Timothy Howe Editorial correspondents Elizabeth Baynham, Hugh Bowden, Franca Landucci Gattinoni, Alexander Meeus, Kurt Raaflaub, P.J. Rhodes, Robert Rollinger, Victor Alonso Troncoso Contents of volume twenty-nine Numbers 1-2 1 John Walsh, Antipater and the Lamian War: A Study in 4th Century Macedonian Counterinsurgency Doctrine 28 Nikos Karkavelias, The End of the Four Hundred Regime 57 Eloisa Paganoni, Bithynia in Memnon’s Perì Herakleias: A Case Study for a Reappraisal of Old and New Proposals Review Article 80 Thomas Scanlon, Satan’s Business or the People’s Choice: The Decline of Athletics in Late Antiquity NOTES TO CONTRIBUTORS AND SUBSCRIBERS The Ancient History Bulletin was founded in 1987 by Waldemar Heckel, Brian Lavelle, and John Vanderspoel. The board of editorial correspondents consists of Elizabeth Baynham (University of Newcastle), Hugh Bowden (Kings College, London), Franca Landucci Gattinoni (Università Cattolica, Milan), Alexander Meeus (University of Leuven), Kurt Raaflaub (Brown University), P.J. Rhodes (Durham University), Robert Rollinger (Universität Innsbruck), Victor Alonso Troncoso (Universidade da Coruña) AHB is currently edited by: Timothy Howe (Senior Editor: [email protected]), Edward Anson, Michael Fronda, David Hollander, Sabine Müller, Joseph Roisman, John Vanderspoel and Pat Wheatley. AHB promotes scholarly discussion in Ancient History and ancillary fields (such as epigraphy, papyrology, and numismatics) by publishing articles and notes on any aspect of the ancient world from the Near East to Late Antiquity. Submitted articles should normally be in English, but the journal will consider contributions in French, German, Italian or Spanish. SUBMISSION GUIDELINES AHB adheres to the usual North American editorial policies in the submission and acceptance of articles but imposes no House Style. Authors are, however, asked to use the abbreviations of L’Année philologique (APh) for journals, and of the Thesaurus linguae latinae (TLL) for Latin authors. Please send submissions to the editor most closely identified with your field of enquiry or, in case of doubt, to Timothy Howe ([email protected]). Articles must be submitted in electronic format, preferably generated by MS Word. Greek font or other special characters must convert such to Unicode and should be accompanied by a PDF version. Authors will receive PDF offprints of their contributions. Copyright is retained by the author. Books for reviews and enquiries concerning book reviews should be directed to Joseph Roisman ([email protected]). SUBSCRIPTION INFORMATION The subscription rate for individual and institutional subscribers is USD 25.00. Detailed instructions about subscriptions and access to digital content can be found on the AHB website: http://ancienthistorybulletin.org PAYMENT Payment may be made via the subscription portal on the AHB website: http://www.ancienthistorybulletin.org/subscribed-users-area/membership-levels/ Cover image courtesy of The Nickle Arts Museum, University of Calgary Bithynia in Memnon’s Perì Herakleias: A Case Study for the Reappraisal of Old and New Proposals* Eloisa Paganoni Memnon’s Perì Herakleias, dealing with the history of Heraclea Pontica in the Classical and Hellenistic periods, is considered the best-preserved Greek local history, although just Photius’ summary of Books 9-16 is extant.1 The debate about this work raises many questions, most of them still open. However, until the appearance of Billows’ commentary on Nymphis of Heraclea in Brill’s New Jacoby (2012), scholars had agreed that Memnon used Nymphis’ Perì Herakleias as a source for the Classical and Hellenistic sections of his work.2 3 This assumption was based on Memnon’s double quotation of Nymphis and the similar judgement both the authors provide about the tyrant of Heraclea, Dionysius.4 According to Memnon, Nymphis was a democratic politician. He returned to Heraclea with the other * An early version of this paper was presented at the conference Looking Back, Looking Forward: Ancient Perspectives on the Past and the Future (King’s College, London, 2nd-3rd June 2015) with the title History of a Polis, History of a Kingdom. The Account on Bithynia in Memnon’s Perì Herakleias. I ought to express my gratitude to Professors Franca Landucci, Luisa Prandi and Thomas Corsten, who discussed many aspects of this research and provided enlightening suggestions. I also thank the anonymous reviewers of AHB for their constructive remarks. Greek texts and translations are from Brill’s New Jacoby with slight changes for uniformity. Abbreviations: ANRW = Aufstieg und Niedergang der Römischen Welt, Berlin – New York 1972-1996. BNJ = I. Worthington (ed.), Brill’s New Jacoby <http://0-referenceworks.brillonline.com./browse/brill-s- new-jacoby>. EAH = R.S. Bagnall et al. (edd.), The Encyclopedia of Ancient History, Malden 2013. Jacoby, FGrHist = F. Jacoby (ed.), Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker, Leiden 1923-1972. Müller, FHG = K. Müller (ed.), Fragmenta historicorum graecorum, vols. I-V, Paris 1841-1879. NP = Der Neue Pauly, Stuttgart – Weimar 1996-2003. OCD3 = S. Hornblower – A. Spawforth (edd.), The Oxford Classical Dictionary, 3rd ed., Oxford 1996. RE = Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft, Stuttgart – Weimar 1893-1972. 1 DESIDERI 1991: 12, WIEMER 2013: 4132. On Heraclea Pontica, see BURSTEIN 1976, SAPRYKIN 1997, BITTNER 1998. 2 Müller, FHG III: 525, Jacoby, FGrHist 434, Commentary: 255, 259-261, 267, JANKE 1963: 8-13, DESIDERI 1967: 389-391, BITTNER 1998: 4, MEISTER 1999: 1205-1206, DUECK 2006: 49-50, DESIDERI 2007: 47, GALLOTTA 2009: 444-445, HEINEMANN 2010: 238, DAVAZE 2013: 58-65, MUCCIOLI 2013: 4426-4427, GALLOTTA 2014: 68-69, cf. SANTANGELO 2004: 249 and n. 10. LAQUEUR 1926: 1100-1101 supposes that Memnon’s Books 9-10 depend on Theopompus of Chios, and Books 11-14 on Nymphis, contra Jacoby, FGrHist XXIV. Herakleia am Pontos, Commentary: 254-255, JANKE 1963: 9-11, DESIDERI 1967: 391 n. 123. On the influence of Theopompus on the Heraclean historiography, see now DAVAZE 2013: 65-63 who suggests that Nymphis might have used Theopompus. On Theopompus of Chios, see PÉDECH 1989: 19-254 SHRIMPTON 1991, FLOWER 1994, POWNALL 2004: 143-182. On Nymphis, see Müller, FHG III: 12-16, Jacoby, FGrHist 432, Commentary: 259-265, LAQUEUR 1937, DESIDERI 1967: 378-416, SEIBERT 1967: 62-63, MEISTER 2000, GALLOTTA 2009: 441-445, HEINEMANN 2010: 14-43, 196- 215, 259-265, Billows, Nymphis BNJ 432, Commentary and Biographical Essay. 3 Memnon BNJ 434, F 1, 7, 3; 16, 3 = Nymphis BNJ 432, TT 3, 4. 4 Nymphis BNJ 432, F 10, Memnon BNJ 434, F 1, 4, 7-8. For a commentary on these passages, see HEINEMANN 2010: 28-43, 96-102, DAVAZE 2013: 228-231. AHB 29 (2015): 57-79 Page 57 Eloisa Paganoni democratic exiles after Lysimachus’ death in 281 BC5 and took part in the political life of the city: in 250 BC, for example, he negotiated with the Galatians who were attacking Pontus.6 Memnon also records that Nymphis was a historian,7 and an entry of the Byzantine lexicon Suda informs us about his work: [Νύμφιδος] Ξεναγόρου, ῾Ηρακλεώτης ἐκ Πόντου, ἱστορικός. Περὶ ᾽Αλεξάνδρου καὶ τῶν Διαδόχων καὶ ᾽Επιγόνων βιβλία κδ· Περὶ ῾Ηρακλείας βιβλία ιγ· ἔχει δὲ μέχρι τῆς καθαιρέσεως τῶν τυράννων † τὰ μετὰ τοὺς ᾽Επιγόνους καὶ μέχρι τοῦ τρίτου Πτολεμαίου. [Nymphis] son of Xenagoras of Heraclea Pontica, was a historian; he wrote On Alexander, the Diadochi, and the Epigoni in 24 books, and Perì Herakleias in 13 books. He continued to the removal of the tyrants † after the Epigoni and down to the accession of Ptolemy III.8 According to this lemma, Nymphis wrote the general history, On Alexander, the Diadochi, and the Epigoni in 24 books and the local history, Perì Herakleias in 13 books. Only one fragment of the former work and fewer than twenty fragments of the latter survive. The information about the end of Nymphis’ work(s) is usually related to Nymphis’ local history and the lacuna is considered irrelevant for the meaning of the text.9 Therefore, Nymphis’ Perì Herakleias is supposed to have dealt with the history of Heraclea from mythic times to Ptolemy III’s accession (246 BC10). So, the first part of Memnon’s work—namely (the lost) Books 1-8 and Books 9-13 (or 14),11 in other words, Photius’ Chapters 1-17—would depend on Nymphis’ Perì Herakleias.12 Billows challenges this communis opinio with a new interpretation of the Suda’s passage.13 In his opinion, the two phrases of the Suda’s entry, introduced by the preposition μέχρι, refer to Nymphis’ two works. On these grounds, he claims that Nymphis’ Perì Herakleias dealt with the history of the city until the removal of the tyrants (281 BC), while Nymphis’ On Alexander, the Diadochi, and the Epigoni ended with the beginning of Ptolemy III’s reign (246 BC).14 This reading is consistent with the grammatical structure. It also takes into consideration both the different significance of the events mentioned by the Suda and the different character of Nymphis’ works. Clearly, the removal of tyrants from a city in Asia 5 Memnon BNJ 434, F 1, 7, 3 = Nymphis BNJ 432, T 3. 6 Memnon BNJ 434, F 1, 16, 3 = Nymphis BNJ 432 T 4. This information dates Nymphis’ political activity to the first half of the 3rd century BC. Thus, scholars suppose that he was born in about 310 BC (Jacoby FGrHist 432, Commentary 259, GALLOTTA 2009: 441, Billows, Nymphis BNJ 432, Biographical Essay). 7 Memnon BNJ 434, F 1, 16, 3 = Nymphis BNJ 432, T 4. 8 Suda, s.v.