Unreported Cases
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Unreported Cases INTRODUCTION UNREPORTED CASES is a continuing feature of THE DELAWARE JOURNAL OF CORPORATE LAW. All unreported cases of a corporate nature that have not been published by a reporter system will be included. The court's opinions are printed in their entirety, exactly as received. To expedite the attorney's research, all cases are headnoted according to the National Reporter key number classification system.* Indices are provided for case names, statutes construed, rules of court, and key number and classifications for this issue. 'The National Reporter key number classification system is used with the permission of the West Publishing Co., St. Paul, Minnesota 55102. DELAWARE JOURNAL OF CORPORATE LAW [Vol. 23 CASE INDEX This Issue Page H.F. AHMANSON & CO. v. GREAT WESTERN FINANCIAL CORP., No. 15,650, ISQUITH v. GREAT WESTERN FINANCIAL CORP., Nos. 15,549, 15,555, 15,556, 15,557, & 15,577 (Del. Ch. June 3, 1997) (revised June 9, 1997). JACOBS, Vice-Chancellor .................. 633 ARVIDA/JMB PARTNERS, L.P. v. VANDERBILT INCOME & GROWTH ASSOCIATES, L.L.C., No. 15,238-NC (Del. Ch. May 23, 1997). BALICK, Vice-Chancellor .... 666 iN RE BALLY'S GRAND DERIVATIVE LITIGATION, No. 14,644 (Cons.) (Del. Ch. June 4, 1997). JACOBS, Vice- Chancellor ................................. 677 BOYER v. WILMINGTON MATERIALS, INC., No. 12,549 (Del. Ch. June 27, 1997). ALLEN, Chancellor ........ 692 CARLTON INVESTMENTS v. TLC BEATRICE INTERNA- TIONAL HOLDINGS, INC., No. 13,950 (Del. Ch. May 30, 1997). ALLEN, Chancellor ................... 712 IN RE CC&F FOX HILL ASSOCIATES LIMITED PARTNER- SHIP, No. 15,430 (Del. Ch. June 12, 1997). CHANDLER, Vice-Chancellor ............................. 750 CINCINNATI SMSA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP v. CINCINNATI BELL CELLULAR SYSTEMS CO., No. 15,388 (Del. Ch. Aug 13, 1997). CHANDLER, Chancellor 760 COOKE v. OOLIE, No. 11,134 (Del. Ch. June 23, 1997). CHANDLER, Vice-Chancellor ..................... 775 INRE FUQUA INDUSTRIES, INC., SHAREHOLDER LITI- GATION, No. 11,974 (Cons.) (Del. Ch. May 13, 1997). CHANDLER, Vice-Chancellor ..................... 802 JOYCE v. CUCCIA, No. 14,953 (Del. Ch. May 14, 1997). JACOBS, Vice-Chancellor ....................... 834 KLANG v. SMITH'S FOOD & DRUG CENTERS, INC., No. 15,012 (Del. Ch. May 13, 1997). CHANDLER, Vice- Chancellor ................................. 855 LINTON v. EVERETT, No. 15,219 (Del. Ch. July 31, 1997). JACOBS, Vice-Chancellor ....................... 886 NOERR v. GREENWOOD, No. 14,320 (Del. Ch. July 16, 1997). JACOBS, Vice-Chcincellor ....................... 905 1998] UNREPORTED CASES 627 TECBNICORP INTERNATIONAL I, INC. v. JOHNSTON, No. 15,084 (Del. Ch. Aug. 22, 1997) (revised Sept 2, 1997). JACOBS, Vice-Chancellor .................. 924 ZAUCHA v. BRODY, No. 15,638-NC (Del. Ch. May 8, 1997). BALICK, Vice-Chancellor ....................... 963 DELAWARE JOURNAL OF CORPORATE LAW [Vol. 23 STATUTES CONSTRUED* This Issue DEL. CODE ANN. tit. 6 § 203 .......... ...... 802 § 203(c)(3)(iv) .......... 802 17-101(11) §211 ......... ...... 633 17-101(12) § 211(b) ....... ...... 633 17-302 .... § 211(c) ....... ...... 633 17-702(a) .. § 220 ......... ...... 924 17-704(a)(1) § 225 ......... ...... 924 17-804 .... § 228 ......... 924, 963 17-1101 ... § 242 ......... 834, 855 § 242(b)(1) ..... ...... 855 § 251 ......... ...... 855 DEL. CODE ANN. tit. 8 § 251(c) ....... ...... 855 102(b)(7) .. ° ° .. .°. ° 141 ...... DEL. CODE ANN. tit. 10 144 ...... ... 775, 802, 144(a)(1) .. .. .° ° . ° .° °. § 3114 ............... 924 152 ...... ° ,. ° . ° .° *. ° 153 ...... ° ° . ° . ,. ° ° . ° . .. 154 ...... ° ° .° . ° . ° ° . o. .. 11 U.S.C.A. 160 ...... .. .° ,. ° °. 160(a) .... ° ,. ° .. ° . ° ° .° § 523(a)(4) ............ 834 170 ...... ° . ° ° ° . ° .° .. ° § 1141(d)(1) ........... 834 172 ...... ° ° . * * ° . ° ° . ° °. *Page reference is to the first page of the case in which the statute or rule is construed. 19981 UNREPORTED CASES RULES OF COURT" This Issue Del. Court of Chancery Rule 9(b) ...................... 834 Del. Court of Chancery Rule 12(b) ..................... 834 Del. Court of Chancery Rule 12(b)(6) ........ 677, 760, 802, 905 Del. Court of Chancery Rule 12(g) ..................... 834 Del. Court of Chancery Rule 12(h) ..................... 834 Del. Court of Chancery Rule 19(a) ..................... 834 Del. Court of Chancery Rule 19(b) ..................... 834 Del. Court of Chancery Rule 23.1 ............... 677, 712, 802 Del. Court of Chancery Rule 56 .................... 760, 775 Del. Court of Chancery Rule 56(b) ...................... 924 Del. Court of Chancery Rule 56(c) ...................... 924 Del. Court of Chancery Rule 56(e) ...................... 775 'Page reference is to the first page of the case in which the statute or rule is construed. DELAWARE JOURNAL OF CORPORATE LAW [Vol. 23 KEY NUMBER INDEX* This Issue ASSIGNMENTS CORPORATIONS 1 ................. 666 38 ................ 855 90 ................ 666 54 ................ 633 57 ............. 633, 775 BANKRUPTCY 98 ................ 886 100 ............... 886 3276.1 ............. 834 105 ............... 886 3531 ............... 834 180 ............... 855 3568(2) ............. 677 182.4 .............. 692 182.4(1) ............ 692 COMPROMISE AND SETTLEMENT 182.4(2) ............ 692 187 ............... 855 23(1) .............. 712 189(12) ............. 692 57 ................ 712 191 ............ 633, 963 72 ................ 712 192 ............ 633, 963 193 ............ 633, 886 CONTRACTS 194 ............... 886 197 ........ 633, 886, 963 143 ............... 633 198 ........ 633, 855, 905 143(1) ............. 666 198(3) .......... 905, 963 143(2) .......... 666, 760 198(4) ................ 802 143.5 ........... 633, 666 201 ............ 633, 963 147(1) .......... 666, 760 206(2) .......... 677, 802 147(2) .......... 666, 760 206(4) ...... 677, 802, 905 150 ............... 666 211(5) .......... 802, 905 152 ............... 760 212 ............ 712, 905 153 ............... 760 213 ..... 633, 712, 802, 963 154 ............... 760 259(7) ............. 886 156 ............... 666 283 ............ 633, 924 159 ............... 760 283(1) .......... 633, 963 162 ............... 760 295 ............... 886 164 ............... 666 297 ............... 692 168 ............... 760 298 ............... 692 169 ............ 666, 760 298(1) ............. 692 175(2) .......... 666, 760 305 ............... 677 175(3) ............. 666 307 ............ 775, 924 *Page reference is to the first page of the case in which the statute or rule is construed. 1998] UNREPORTED CASES 308 ............... 924 DEBT, ACTION OF 308(1) ............. 924 308(5) ............. 886 3.. ............. 309 ............... 855 11 .......... OO 16. 310 ............ 633, 677 ........ *..... 310(1) .. 633, 677, 692, 712, 775, 802, 834, 855, 905, 963 EQUrrY 310(2) .......... 692, 855 312 .................. 802 ............... 760 314.5 .............. 775 315 ........ 775, 834, 963 EVIDENCE 316 ... ............ 802 316(1) . ......... 633, 677 54 ... 633 317 ... ......... 834, 905 55 ... 633 319 ... ......... 775, 924 448 ... 760 320(1) ............ 775 320(4) ............ 775 FEDERAL CIVIL PROCEDURE 320(5) ............ 677 320(6) ............ 677 1837.1 . 320(7) ............ 834 2461 ... 320(10). ............ 886 2470 ... 320(11). 775, 802, 834, 855, 2470.2 886, 905 2470.3 326 ... ............ 855 2470.4 333 ............... 855 2552 ... 372 ............ 775, 886 2533.1 . 373 ... ............ 775 2539 ... 376 ... ............ 855 2554 ... 393 ... ............ 834 426(1) ............. 905 INJUNCION 426(12). ............ 905 582 ... ......... 633, 855 1..... 583 ... ............ 633 5 ..... 9..... COURTS 138.6 138.15 10.......... 138.18 11......... 139 ... 12 ......... 190 ... 12(2.20) ..... 12(2.30) ..... DELAWARE JOURNAL OF CORPORATE LAW [Vol. 23 JUDGMENT 327(6) ............. 750 332 ............... 750 138.18 ............. 633 349 ............... 666 180 .. 775 351 ............... 750 181(1) ............. 775 352 ............... 750 181(2) .......... 692, 775 363 ............... 666 181(4) .... ° ...... 775 376 ............... 750 181(31) 775 ° ............ 185(2) 692 PLEADING ...... ° ..... 185(5) 775 185(6) 775 34(1) .............. 677 185.2(1) 775 ............ 186 .. 775 PRETRIAL PROCEDURE ............. 461(2) 924 .° .......° .... 470 924 621 ............... 834 471 677 622 ............... 834 518 924 624 ........ 677, 760, 802 ..... ° ....... 540 677 626 ............ 802, 834 ............. 634 .............7 677 643 ............... 760 650 924 679 ............ 834, 905 713 .......... ° .. 924 680 ............ 834, 905 713(1) ............. 924 681 ........ 760, 834, 905 803 o..........,.. 924 682 ............... 834 804 .... ° ......... 924 687 ..... 760, 802, 834, 905 689 ..... 760, 802, 834, 905 PARTIES RELEASE 28 ............ 834 33 ............ 834 30 ................... 802 34 ............ 834 38 ................... 802 39 ................... 802 PARTNERSHIP TORTS 70 ................ 666 71 ................ 666 12 ................ 692 79............... 666 121............... 750 225............... 666 259.5............. 750 261............... 750 279................ 750 291 ............... 750 H.F. AHMANSON & CO. v. GREAT WESTERN FINANCIAL CORP. No. 15,650 ISQUITH v. GREAT WESTERN FINANCIAL CORP. Nos. 15,549, 15,555, 15,556, 15,557 & 15,577 Court of Chancery of the State of Delaware,New Castle June 3, 1997 Revised June 9, 1997 Plaintiffs, the shareholders of defendant target corporation and the corporation who sought to conduct a hostile