The TALMUD's Theological Language

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The TALMUD's Theological Language The TALMUD’s Theological Language -Game A Philosophical Discourse Analysis Eugene B. Borowitz The Talmud’s Theological Language-Game SUNY series in Jewish Philosophy Kenneth Seeskin, editor The Talmud’s Theological Language-Game A Philosophical Discourse Analysis Eugene B. Borowitz ļ State University of New York Press Published by State University of New York Press, Albany © 2006 State University of New York All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission. No part of this book may be stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means including electronic, electrostatic, magnetic tape, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise without the prior permission in writing of the publisher. For information, address State University of New York Press, 194 Washington Avenue, Suite 305, Albany, NY 12210-2384 Production by Judith Block Marketing by Michael Campochiaro Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Borowitz, Eugene B. The Talmud’s theological language-game : a philosophical discourse analysis / Eugene B. Borowitz p. cm. — (SUNY series in Jewish philosophy) Includes bibiographical references and index. ISBN 0-7914-6701-5 (hardcover : alk. paper) 1. Aggada—Philosophy. 2. Aggada—History and criticism—Theory, etc. 3. Samuel ben Na±man, 3rd/4th cent.—Knowledge—Aggada. 4. Discourse analysis. I. Title. II. Series. BM516.5.B67 2006 296.1'27606—dc22 2005012109 ISBN-13: 978-0-7914-6701-5 (hardcover : alk. paper) 10987654321 The classic (1965) text updated: Ļ “To my beloved Estelle (1925–2004), who (for fifty-seven years) [has] taught me the meaning of existence in covenant.” ļ Ļ Contents ļ Preface ix Part One. Entering the Maze of Rabbinic Diction Introduction to a Religious Puzzle 1 1. What Is the Aggadah Problem? 7 Part Two. Scrutinizing Talmudic Aggadah at Three Levels 2. The Surface Characteristics 31 3. The Substantive Concerns 49 4. The “Logic” 67 5. Does Extending the Sample Alter the Findings? 83 Part Three. The Limits and Nature of Aggadah 6. Is Aggadic Discourse Self-Limiting? 115 7. Positively, What Is Aggadah? 145 8. Reconstruing the Aggadah Problem 179 Afterwords Can We Theologize as the Rabbis Did? 191 On Concluding 193 Ļ vii ļ viii ļ Contents Notes 195 Bibliography of Works Cited 281 COMPILED BY TINA WEISS Index of Text Citations 293 Index of Subjects and Proper Names 307 Ļ Preface ļ or a half century or more now, thinking about thinking— philosophy examining its own roots—has substantially con- centrated on how language shapes what we can and cannot meaningfully say. Ludwig Wittgenstein pioneered that linguistic F turn and gave it the lasting gift of his notion of a “language- game.” By devising an imagined set of conditions of what one may or may not do, one can create a small world of pleasure or frustration for all who are ready to abide by the rules of the game. Writ large, some- thing like that seems to be what makes it possible for people in many diverse areas of life to communicate with one another and to express a depth of meaning and command that often perplexes those who have no feel for the particular language-game involved. For well over three decades now it has seemed to me that we prod- ucts of Western culture and its academies will better understand the classic Jewish religious mind and its enduring manifestation, rabbinic literature, if we could appreciate the rabbinic language-game. Alas for the scholar with only one lifetime in which to work on such a grand scale. The rabbinic tradition itself knows that there are two major verbal universes intertwined in its linguistic universe: halakhah, its world of mandated action, and aggadah, all the rest of its concerns, most particu- larly for my theological concerns, the explicit statement of authorita- tive opinions (sic) on matters of Jewish religious belief. Against the odds—so it has seemed to me—I have long sought to understand the linguistic game rules of aggadic utterance. I am therefore especially grateful to the people and institutions whose help, personal and ma- terial, has enabled me to bring this task to this point of closure. Institutionally, this work could not have come into being without the perennial assistance of student-aid and research funds that the Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion made available for Ļ ix ļ x ļ The Talmud’s Theological Language-Game this project. A generation or more of students have spent their sum- mers—and, some, a few winters—searching libraries, finding and photocopying studies and texts of potential interest, writing up their reactions to these materials, and, more recently, utilizing the databases that have eased the task of retrieval. None of this would have been possible without the faith and personal support of old deans and dear friends, Paul M. Steinberg, of blessed memory, and Norman Cohen, and their recent successor, Aaron Panken. At a very early stage of this project, the then cultural arm of the Jewish Material Claims Confer- ence made a helpful grant that kept the work going forward. Dr. Philip Miller, director of the Klau Library at the New York School of the HUC-JIR, has been untiring in his efforts to provide me with the wide range of materials cited in this work and many others that did not merit inclusion. Through his knowledgeable and genial efforts, the exceptional holdings of our Cincinnati School Library have also smoothly come to me. Tina Weiss of the New York Library staff brought her fine skills to the arduous task of creating the bibliography. I learned very much and should probably have cited more of the insightful comments Rick Sarason of our Cincinnati School faculty made to the first version of this manuscript. An author is fortunate indeed to have so able and willing a colleague devote his time and learning to a friend’s work. Nan and Andrew Langowitz gave me considerable insight into how computer networks work, thus enabling me to de- velop my idea that the nonlinear structure of aggadic utterance might now best be understood in terms of the dynamics of network logic. And Andrew, with exemplary patience and knowledge, helped me resolve a host of computing problems. Ken Seeskin, eminent philoso- pher and mentsh, was kind enough to see the merits of this work and commend it to the SUNY Press. I am indebted to the staff of the SUNY Press for the high professionalism and personal courtesy with which, as the Hebrew idiom puts it, they “brought this book into the light.” My particular thanks go to Judith Block for the kind and imaginative efficiency she brought to this project, to Wyatt Benner for the strength of intellect and unflagging dedication he brought to the challenges of integrating the style of this work, to Elise Brauckmann whose graphic talent turned a book cover into an evocative commentary on my text, and to Nancy Zibman for the excellent indexes, which greatly add to the usefulness of the book. My thanks and gratitude to the Ultimate One who made possible this work and so much else are expressed in the final paragraphs of this volume. ACKNOWLEDGMENTSPreface Ļ xi Ļ Part One ļ Entering the Maze of Rabbinic Diction Ļ Introduction to a Religious Puzzle ļ any world religions know the distinction between scrip- ture—a centrally significant sacred text—and tradition, the less sacred accompaniment to scripture that has subsidiary authority in theory but, as the official M interpreter of scripture, practical preeminence. In Judaism’s case, scripture comes to be called the Written Torah (or the Written Law) and, with that development, it gained a companion rev- elation on Sinai called the Oral Torah (or Oral Law). But Judaism seems unique among religions in formally understanding Tradition, the Oral Torah, as bipartite. That is, it has two identifiable, closely related modes of discourse that differ in authority, areas of concern, and the “logics” by which they set forth their propositions and seek to have them accepted. The more authoritative, because normative, dic- tion is termed the halakhah, what came to be seen as the personal and communal duties of Jews to God under the Covenant, or simply, “the law.” The less authoritative part of God’s revelation of Oral Torah is the aggadah, or simply, all else in rabbinic literature. Explicit reflection on Jewish belief—the Jewish equivalent of “theology” in Christian- ity—takes place in the aggadah. This principle is so deeply embedded in rabbinic diction but so fully evidenced in rabbinic texts that it has the quasi-authoritative status of not requiring statement or demonstra- tion; it is taken for granted. This book arises from this Jewish under- standing that its classic statements concerning its beliefs are in the aggadah—but before saying more about this, let me briefly set these abstract statements about Judaism in historical perspective. Judaism’s foundation is God’s revelation as given in various forms in the Hebrew Bible, but the religious life that grew from it over the centuries was shaped not only by its explicit language but by the interpretation of its texts. By the time of the Roman domination of Ļ 1 ļ 2 ļ The Talmud’s Theological Language-Game the Land of Israel, as the Common Era was beginning, its ongoing way of life and thinking was more and more shaped by the dynamic read- ing and interpretation of the Bible (and the traditions associated with them) by “the Rabbis,” the sages mentioned in the Mishnah and the Talmud. The Mishnah, the increasingly authoritative, orderly study- book of halakhic dicta and its significant minority of aggadic state- ments, is the rabbis’ earliest documentary record, edited about 200 CE.
Recommended publications
  • The Influence of Progressive Judaism in Poland—An Outline
    The Influence of Progressive Judaism in Poland ♦ 1 The Influence of Progressive Judaism in Poland—an Outline Michał Galas Jagiellonian University In the historiography of Judaism in the Polish lands the influence of Reform Judaism is often overlooked. he opinion is frequently cited that the Polish Jews were tied to tradition and did not accept ideas of religious reform coming from the West. his paper fills the gap in historiography by giving some examples of activities of progressive communities and their leaders. It focuses mainly on eminent rabbis and preachers such as Abraham Goldschmidt, Markus Jastrow, and Izaak Cylkow. Supporters of progressive Judaism in Poland did not have as strong a position as representatives of the Reform or Conservative Judaism in Germany or the United States. Religious reforms introduced by them were for a number of reasons moderate or limited. However, one cannot ignore this move- ment in the history of Judaism in Poland, since that trend was significant for the history of Jews in Poland and Polish-Jewish relations. In the historiography of Judaism in the Polish lands, the history of the influ- ence of Reform Judaism is often overlooked. he opinion is frequently cited that the Polish Jews were tied to tradition and did not accept ideas of religious reform coming from the West. his opinion is perhaps correct in terms of the number of “progressive” Jews, often so-called proponents of reform, on Polish soil, in comparison to the total number of Polish Jews. However, the influence of “progressives” went much further and deeper, in both the Jewish and Polish community.
    [Show full text]
  • We All Know, the Emancipation Was a Great Turning Point in the History Of
    PROGRESSIVE LITURGIES OF GERMANY AND AMERICA 585 p- John D. Rayner Introduction As we all know, the Emancipation was a great turning point in the history of Judaism, although ‘point' is hardly the right word, since it was a long-drawn- out process extending from the eighteenth century into the twentieth. Nevertheless the initial impact of it was often felt by a single generation, and in Germany by the generation of those born during the Napoleonic era. As we all know; too, the initial impact was for many of the newly emancipated German Jews a negative one so far as their Jewish religious life was concerned because the revolutionary educational, linguistic, cultural and social changes they experienced caused them to feel uncomfortable in the old- style synagogues. And as we all know as well, it is to this problem, of the alienation of emancipated Jewry from the traditional synagogue that the Reformers first and foremost addressed themselves. They believed that if only the synagogue services could be made more attractive, that would halt and perhaps reverse w the drift. 0 . _ {:1 j N In retrospect we can see that they were only partly right. There are other 8E}; factors besides the nature of synagogue worship which determine or influence the extent to which individuals will affirm their Jewish identity \ :8 " and adhere to their Jewish faith, and subsequent generations of Reformers 13E came to recognise that and to address themselves to these other issues also. (3 ‘1‘: Nevertheless the nature of synagogue worship is clearly a factor, and a big one.
    [Show full text]
  • TALMUDIC FORGERIES a CASE STUDY in ANTI-JEWISH PROPAGANDA by BEN ZION BOKSER HROUGHOUT History, the Talmud Has Been a Main Targe
    TALMUDIC FORGERIES A CASE STUDY IN ANTI-JEWISH PROPAGANDA By BEN ZION BOKSER HROUGHOUT history, the Talmud has been a main target of the attacks by enemies of Judaism. The recent rise in Nazi-inspired propaganda, accordingly, brought with it a recrudescence of the accusations made against this store- house of Jewish lore. The falsification of Talmudic texts and the distortion of their teachings are spread with increased vigor throughout the English-speaking world. The fact that these libels have been exposed repeatedly by the testimony of Jewish as well as Christian scholars has not deterred present day purveyors of these slanders from at- tempting to portray the Talmud as the fountainhead of an inferior and unethical morality. It may seem incredible to the average person that the Jewish religion, mother of all monotheistic religions of justice and mercy, should need de- fense against such accusations. But this study is less a defense and refutation than an analysis of the way these propagandists work, and the combination of unscrupulous distortion and crudity which characterizes their attack. It is also an ex- posure of the real motives for which these attacks are only an opening wedge. WHAT THE TALMUD IS The Talmud is a record of opinions and discussions on all phases of law and life culled from the utterances of those out- standing Jewish teachers who functioned in the academies of Palestine and Babylonia during the first five centuries of the 1939 TALMUDIC FORGERIES 7 common era. The earliest layer of the Talmud is the Mish- nah, a product of Palestinian scholarship and written in a clear, lucid Hebrew.
    [Show full text]
  • The Humanity of the Talmud: Reading for Ethics in Bavli ʿavoda Zara By
    The Humanity of the Talmud: Reading for Ethics in Bavli ʿAvoda Zara By Mira Beth Wasserman A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Joint Doctor of Philosophy with Graduate Theological Union, Berkeley in Jewish Studies in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Daniel Boyarin, chair Professor Chana Kronfeld Professor Naomi Seidman Professor Kenneth Bamberger Spring 2014 Abstract The Humanity of the Talmud: Reading for Ethics in Bavli ʿAvoda Zara by Mira Beth Wasserman Joint Doctor of Philosophy with Graduate Theological Union, Berkeley University of California, Berkeley Professor Daniel Boyarin, chair In this dissertation, I argue that there is an ethical dimension to the Babylonian Talmud, and that literary analysis is the approach best suited to uncover it. Paying special attention to the discursive forms of the Talmud, I show how juxtapositions of narrative and legal dialectics cooperate in generating the Talmud's distinctive ethics, which I characterize as an attentiveness to the “exceptional particulars” of life. To demonstrate the features and rewards of a literary approach, I offer a sustained reading of a single tractate from the Babylonian Talmud, ʿAvoda Zara (AZ). AZ and other talmudic discussions about non-Jews offer a rich resource for considerations of ethics because they are centrally concerned with constituting social relationships and with examining aspects of human experience that exceed the domain of Jewish law. AZ investigates what distinguishes Jews from non-Jews, what Jews and non- Jews share in common, and what it means to be a human being. I read AZ as a cohesive literary work unified by the overarching project of examining the place of humanity in the cosmos.
    [Show full text]
  • Talmud Tales Ruth Calderon Copyrighted Material Translated by Ilana Kurshan
    A Bride for One Night Talmud Tales Ruth Calderon Copyrighted Material Translated by Ilana Kurshan CONTENTS INTRODUCTION xi THE IMAGINATIVE MAP xvii The Fishpond 1 Sisters 7 The Other Side 15 Beloved Rabbi 31 Libertina 39 Return 49 A Bride for One Night 57 Nazir 67 Lamp 75 The Matron 85 The Goblet 91 The Knife 99 He and His Son 105 Sorrow in the Cave 115 Elisha 123 The Beruria Incident 133 Yishmael, My Son, Bless Me 139 NOTES 145 SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY 159 Buy the book A Bride for One Night Talmud Tales Ruth Calderon Copyrighted Material Translated by Ilana Kurshan INTRODUCTION In this book I retell stories from the Talmud and midrash that are close to my heart, to introduce them to those who, like me, did not grow up with them. I do not cast these tales in an educational, religious, or aca- demic light but, rather, present them as texts that have the power to move people. That is, I present them as literature. The Talmud contains hundreds of stories about rabbinic sages and other historical fi gures who lived during the late Second Temple and rabbinic periods, which spanned the fi rst few centuries of the Common Era. The stories were recorded long after the events they recount, and thus they are literary rather than historical accounts. For generations these stories were neglected by literary audiences and were considered the province of rabbis and academics alone. But this is no longer the case. In the past decades readers of diverse backgrounds have devel- oped an openness and a willingness to engage this literature on their own terms.
    [Show full text]
  • How Did Halacha Originate Or Did the Rabbis Tell a “Porky”?1 Definitions Written Law the Written Law Is the Torah Or Five Books of Moses
    How Did Halacha Originate or Did the Rabbis Tell a “Porky”?1 Definitions Written Law The Written Law is the Torah or Five books of Moses. Also known from the Greek as the Pentateuch. (What status is the Tanach?) Oral Law An Oral Law is a code of conduct in use in a given culture, religion or community …, by which a body of rules of human behaviour is transmitted by oral tradition and effectively respected, ...2 lit. "Torah that is on the ,תורה שבעל פה) According to Rabbinic Judaism, the Oral Torah or Oral Law mouth") represents those laws, statutes, and legal interpretations that were not recorded in the Five lit. "Torah that is in writing"), but nonetheless are ,תורה שבכתב) "Books of Moses, the "Written Torah regarded by Orthodox Jews as prescriptive and co-given. This holistic Jewish code of conduct encompasses a wide swathe of rituals, worship practices, God–man and interpersonal relationships, from dietary laws to Sabbath and festival observance to marital relations, agricultural practices, and civil claims and damages. According to Jewish tradition, the Oral Torah was passed down orally in an unbroken chain from generation to generation of leaders of the people until its contents were finally committed to writing following the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE, when Jewish civilization was faced with an existential threat.3 Halacha • all the rules, customs, practices, and traditional laws. (Lauterbach) • the collective body of Jewish religious laws derived from the Written and Oral Torah. (Wikipedia) • Lit. the path that one walks. Jewish law. The complete body of rules and practices that Jews are bound to follow, including biblical commandments, commandments instituted by the rabbis, and binding customs.
    [Show full text]
  • The Wife of Manoah, the Mother of Samson
    546 THE WIFE OF MANOAH, THE MOTHER OF SAMSON Magdel le Roux University of South Africa P O Box 392, UNISA 0003 E-mail: Lrouxm1@unisa.ac.za (Received 21/04/2016; accepted 06/07/2016) ABSTRACT The last account of the judges is that of Samson (Judges 13–16). This account has all the elements of a blockbuster. All the indications are that Samson would be an extraordinary person. And yet, even though Samson may be regarded as some sort of hero, the story suggests that Samson was also the weakest or most ineffective of the judges. Tension is created through the juxtaposition of “ideal” and “non-ideal” bodies. An alternative ideology, as a hidden polemic, is concealed in the account. As in the case of Achsah (Judges 1:11–15) and Deborah (Judges 4–5), the nameless wife of Manoah (the mother of Samson) serves as an illustration of “countercultural rhetoric” as a hidden polemic. INTRODUCTION In the dominant cultural ideology of the Israelite tribes, ideal, whole bodies were those of male Israelite soldiers without any defects. This is the image that comes to mind when one first reads about the strong man, Samson, although in time one becomes more aware of his weaknesses than his strengths. These accounts (Judges 14–16) are full of violence and of Samson’s personal revenge, but they also describe his weakness for women. In the case of Samson, an ideal male body develops into an “unwhole body” in that an aesthetic element is added to the story: God favours Samson despite his disobedience (Chs 14–16).
    [Show full text]
  • The Relationship Between Targum Song of Songs and Midrash Rabbah Song of Songs
    THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN TARGUM SONG OF SONGS AND MIDRASH RABBAH SONG OF SONGS Volume I of II A thesis submitted to The University of Manchester for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Humanities 2010 PENELOPE ROBIN JUNKERMANN SCHOOL OF ARTS, HISTORIES, AND CULTURES TABLE OF CONTENTS VOLUME ONE TITLE PAGE ............................................................................................................ 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................................. 2 ABSTRACT .............................................................................................................. 6 DECLARATION ........................................................................................................ 7 COPYRIGHT STATEMENT ....................................................................................... 8 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS AND DEDICATION ............................................................... 9 CHAPTER ONE : INTRODUCTION ........................................................................... 11 1.1 The Research Question: Targum Song and Song Rabbah ......................... 11 1.2 The Traditional View of the Relationship of Targum and Midrash ........... 11 1.2.1 Targum Depends on Midrash .............................................................. 11 1.2.2 Reasons for Postulating Dependency .................................................. 14 1.2.2.1 Ambivalence of Rabbinic Sources Towards Bible Translation .... 14 1.2.2.2 The Traditional
    [Show full text]
  • The Healing of Naaman in Missiological Perspective Walter A
    Volume 61: Number 3 July 1997 Table of Contents Eschatological Tension and Existential Angst: "Now" and "Not Yet" in Romans 214-25 and lQSll (Community Rule, Manual of Discipline) Lane A. Burgland ........................... 163 The Healing of Naaman in Missiological Perspective Walter A. Maier I11 .......................... 177 A Chapel Sermon on Exodus 20:l-17 JamesG. Bollhagen ......................... 197 Communicating the Gospel Without Theological Jargon Andrew Steinman .......................... 201 Book Reviews .................................... 215 Salvation in Christ: A Lutheran-Orthodox Dialogue. Edited with an Introduction by John Meyendorff and Robert Tobias .......................Ulrich Asendorf A History of the Bible as Literature. By David Norton. ................................ Cameron A. MacKenzie Ministry in the NmTestament. By David L. Bartlett .................................... Thomas M. Winger The Justificationof the Gentiles: Paul's Letters to the Galatians and Romans. By Hendrikus Boers ........Charles A. Gieschen Christianity and Christendom in the Middle Ages: The Relations Between Religion, Church, and Society. By Adriaan H. Bredero ...................Karl F. Fabrizius The Myste y and the Passion: A Homiletic Reading of the Gospel Traditions. By David G. Buttrick ...... Carl C. Fickenscher I1 Christ in Christian Tradition. By Aloys Grillrneier with Theresia Hainthaler ................. William C. Weinrich Theological Ethics of the New Testament. By Eduard Lohse ...................................H. Armin Moellering Paul's Narrative Thought World:The Tapestry of Tragedy and Triumph. By Ben Witherington .........Charles A. Gieschen Galileo, Bellarmine, and the Bible. By Richard J.Blackwell. ................................Cameron A. MacKenzie Teaching Law and Gospel. By William Fischer ... Erik J. Rottmann Books Received. .................................. 238 The Healing of Naaman in Missiological Perspective Walter A. Maier I11 This study analyzes the narrative of the healing of Naaman the Syrian, 2 Kings 53-19a.
    [Show full text]
  • Samson Gods Strong Man English
    Bible for Children presents SAMSON, GOD’S STRONG MAN Written by: Edward Hughes Illustrated by: Janie Forest; Alastair Paterson Adapted by: Lyn Doerksen Produced by: Bible for Children www.M1914.org ©2021 Bible for Children, Inc. License: You have the right to copy or print this story, as long as you do not sell it. Long ago, in the land of Israel, lived a man named Manoah. He and his wife had no children. One day the Angel of the LORD appeared to Mrs. Manoah. "You will have a very special baby," He said. She told her husband the wonderful news. Manoah prayed, "Oh my Lord . come to us again. Teach us what we shall do for the child." The Angel told Manoah the child must never have his hair cut, must never drink alcohol, and must never eat certain foods. God had chosen this child to be a judge. He would lead Israel. God's people certainly needed help. They left God out of their lives, and then were bullied by their enemies, the Philistines. But when they prayed, God heard. He sent this baby who would become the world's strongest man. "So the woman bore a son and called his name Samson: and the child grew, and the LORD blessed him. And the spirit of the LORD began to move upon him." Samson became very strong. One day he fought a young lion with his bare hands - and killed it! Later, Samson tasted honey from a swarm of bees which had nested in the lion's dead body.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    INTRODUCTION Hanne Trautner-Kromann n this introduction I want to give the necessary background information for understanding the nine articles in this volume. II start with some comments on the Hebrew or Jewish Bible and the literature of the rabbis, based on the Bible, and then present the articles and the background information for these articles. In Jewish tradition the Bible consists of three main parts: 1. Torah – Teaching: The Five Books of Moses: Genesis (Bereshit in Hebrew), Exodus (Shemot), Leviticus (Vajikra), Numbers (Bemidbar), Deuteronomy (Devarim); 2. Nevi’im – Prophets: (The Former Prophets:) Joshua, Judges, Samuel I–II, Kings I–II; (The Latter Prophets:) Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezek- iel; (The Twelve Small Prophets:) Hosea, Joel, Amos, Obadiah, Jonah, Micah, Nahum, Habakkuk, Zephania, Haggai, Zechariah, Malachi; 3. Khetuvim – Writings: Psalms, Proverbs, Job, The Song of Songs, Ruth, Lamentations, Ecclesiastes, Esther, Daniel, Ezra, Nehemiah, Chronicles I–II1. The Hebrew Bible is often called Tanakh after these three main parts: Torah, Nevi’im and Khetuvim. The Hebrew Bible has been interpreted and reinterpreted by rab- bis and scholars up through the ages – and still is2. Already in the Bible itself there are examples of interpretation (midrash). The books of Chronicles, for example, can be seen as a kind of midrash on the 10 | From Bible to Midrash books of Samuel and Kings, repeating but also changing many tradi- tions found in these books. In talmudic times,3 dating from the 1st to the 6th century C.E.(Common Era), the rabbis developed and refined the systems of interpretation which can be found in their literature, often referred to as The Writings of the Sages.
    [Show full text]
  • Resurrection Or Miraculous Cures? the Elijah and Elisha Narrative Against Its Ancient Near Eastern Background
    Bar, “Resurrection or Miraculous Cures?” OTE 24/1 (2011): 9-18 9 Resurrection or Miraculous Cures? The Elijah and Elisha Narrative Against its Ancient Near Eastern Background SHAUL BAR (UNIVERSITY OF MEMPHIS) ABSTRACT The Elijah and Elisha cycles have similar stories where the prophet brings a dead child back to life. In addition, in the Elisha story, a corpse is thrown into the prophet’s grave; when it comes into con- tact with one of his bones, the man returns to life. Thus the question is do these stories allude to resurrection, or “only” miraculous cures? What was the purpose of the inclusion of these stories and what message did they convey? In this paper we will show that these are legends that were intended to lend greater credence to prophetic activity and to indicate the Lord’s power over death. A INTRODUCTION There is consensus among scholars that Dan 12:2-3, which they assign to the 1 second century B.C.E., refers to the resurrection of the dead. The question be- comes whether biblical texts earlier than this era allude to this doctrine. The phrase “resurrection of the dead” never appears in the Bible. Scholars searching for biblical allusions to resurrection have cited various idioms.2 They list verbs including “arise,”3 “wake up,”4 and “live,”5 all of which can denote a return to life. We also find “take,”6 which refers to being taken to Heaven, the noun “life,”7 and “see.”8 In the present paper however, we shall examine the stories of the Elijah and Elisha cycles which include similar tales in which the prophet brings a dead child back to life: in Elijah’s case, the son of the widow of Zare- phath (1 Kgs 17:17-24); in Elisha’s, the son of the Shunammite matron (2 Kgs 4:31-37).
    [Show full text]