Statehood for Hawaii 1711 -4 Hearings Before the Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs House of Representatives Eighty-Sixth Congress First Session on H.R
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
STATEHOOD FOR HAWAII 1711 -4 HEARINGS BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON INTERIOR AND INSULAR AFFAIRS HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES EIGHTY-SIXTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION ON H.R. 50 TO PROVIDE FOR THE ADMISSION OF THE STATE OF HAWAII INTO THE UNION AND H.R. 888 TO PROVIDE FOR THE ADMISSION OF THE TERRITORY OF HAWAII INTO THE UNION JANUARY 28, 27, AND 28, 1959 Printed for the use of the Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs Serial No. 1 UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE *36761 WASHINGTON : 1959 COMMITTEE ON INTERIOR AND INSULAR AFFAIRS WAYNE N. A8PINALL, Colorado, Chairman LEO W. O'BRIEN, New York JOHN P. SAYLOR, Pennsylvania WALTER ROGERS, Texas J. ERNEST WHARTON, New York GRACIE PFOST, Idaho E. Y. BERRY, South Dakota JAMES A. HALEY, Florida JACK WESTLAND, Washington ADAM C. POWELL, New York CRAIG HOSMER, California ED EDMONDSON, Oklahoma J. EDGAR CHENOWETH, Colorado B. F. SISK, California HAROLD R. COLLIER, Illinois STEWART L. UDALL, Arizona GARDNER R. WITHROW, Wisconsin 1. T. RUTHERFORD, Texas BOB WILSON, California WALTER 8. BARING, Nevada GLENN CUNNINGCIAM, Nebraska AL ULLMAN, Oregon ODIN LANGEN, 14innesota LxROY H. ANDERSON, Montana EDNA (Mae. SID) 'IMPSON, Illinois D. 8. (JUDGE) 8AUND, California DONALD F. McGINLEY, Nebraska JOHN A. BURNS (Delegate), Hawaii THOMAS G. MORRIS, New Mexioo A. FERN6s.ISERN (Resident Commissioner), RALPH J. RIVERS, Alaska Puerto Rioo QUENTIN BURDIOK, North Dakota T. RICBABD WITMER, Co00Mtte CounSel J. L. TATLOR, Territories Conultant CONTENTS Statements of- Pae Ralph Beck, vice president, Hawaiian Telephone Co., Honolulu, T.H.. 103 Mrs. Joseph Fair Philadelphia, Pa----.. - .---....... .-...... 16 Hon. Roland D. Libonati, a Representative in the U.S. Congress from the State of Illinois-..---------------------------------------. 28 Mike M. Masaoka, Washington representative, Japanese-American Citizens League------------------------------------------- 72 Hon. John W. McCormack, a Representative in the U.S. Congress. From the State of Massachusetts and majority leader of the House of Representatives.. ------ - -------------------- 22 Rear Adm. Ken e M. McManes, Deputy -ef of Naval Operations for Admin' ation.---------------------- -- ------------- -- 69 Hon. W. Poage, a Representative in the U.S. ngress from the State Texas----------------------------- -------- 151 Geor . Riley, legislative re res tive, AFLr-CIO ----------- 101 Hon red A. Seaton etar. of the ior--------- -------- 3, 118 Lo in P. Thursto ,chair an, awaii Sta hood Commison------- 170 .H . Francis alter, Reprsentativ in the U.S. Con ess from the State Pennsylva ia and hair n, Hou e Committ on Un- American vities-..- --------- -- ------------ -- 135, 142 Oth information sub e recd: Amalgamated Meat Ci a Butcer W kme of North A erica, statement of----- - .....----.------.-------- --------------- 95 Willis A. o, state o ------.. ------ .......----- - .9 Committ Pr No 3 aii Stat d" -" 51 Democrat c Part a t faiit-- - --------- ---- 91 Johh C. E'iott, Loa ngeles, C ., ement of------------.----. 115 Hawaiian Electric statem -.- -------------------- ----- 87 awaii Statehood Jo mission letter - ------------ 90,91 awaiian 'ele ne Co. stat ient f ----- --------- ----- 88 awaii Sug anters' A , sat ement of-- ------- ------- 8 nolulu Chamber of Com e, stat nent of -- ------ ------- 86 J estown, N. Dak., or C mber f Com ce, telegr of.... 116 Be ard W. Kear , ormer Co gressm n, at ment of ,--------- 902 Rich rd K. C. M.D., pre dent, oa of health, erritory of Ha ii, letter su tulatio statistics of erritory of Haw ------- - - -------------------------- ------------- 86 Hamilton . Long, statement of.,- ------------ -------------- 168 Pineapple G users'Association of Hawaii, stat nt of------------ 90 Tom B. Shuste, udent, letter from--- --------------------- 93 Hon. William F. Q overnor of I : Statement of ------------------------ 82 ,Telegram of----------------------.............---------------- 21 Unitarian Fellowship for Social Justice, statement of------------- 93 Statements of Members of Congress:' Hon. William A. Barrett, of Pennsylvania --------. -----------.. 31 Hon. Edwin B. Dooley, of New York.------------------..--..--. 82 Hon. T. J. Dulski, of New York-----------........-------------- 31. Hon. Edith Green, of Oregon.--------------------------------. 29 Hon. Charles. Halleck, of Indiana, minority leader of the House of Representatives.--------- ------------------------------ 27 Hon. Russell V. Mack, of Washington ...------- -------------- 832 Hon. J. Arthur Younger, of California--------------------------- 80 Mx IV CONTENTS Resolutions of- Page Association of Local and Territorial Airlines ---------------------- 117 General Assembly of the States-- ----------------------------- 117 Hakalau Parent Teachers' Association, Kagalau, T.H-------------- 117 County of Kauai, Lihue, Kauai, T.H.------------. --------------- 96 442d Veterans Club, Honolulu, T.H.---------------------------- 97 Department of Hawaii, Veterans of Foreign Wars----------------- 98 Rugby Junior Chamber of Commerce, Rugby, N. Dak------------- 116 California Legislature --------------------------------------- 99 Nebraska State Legislature ------------..---..------------------ 99 New Mexico State Legislature --------------------------------. 100 Western Governors' Conference, Honolulu T. H.-.......--------------- 117 James M. Thomson, Gaylord, Clarke County, Va., statement of--------- 92 U.S. Flag Committee, statement of ----------.---------------------- 92 STATEHOOD FOR HAWAII MONDAY, JANUARY 28, 1959 HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, COMMITTEE ON INTERIOR AND INSULAR AFFAIRS, Washington, D.C. The committee met, pursuant to notice, at 9:50 a.m., in the com- mittee room, New House Office Building, Hon. Wayne N. Aspinall, chairman of the committee, presiding. Mr. ASPINALL. The Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs will now be in session for such business as is regularly calendared to come before us. Before we begin our hearing this morning I think it well that the committee pay recognition to the fact that we have lost one of the able members of this committee. I refer to the passing of our colleague, Mr. George Christopher, and unless there is an objection, when we adjourn this meeting this morning we shall adjourn the meeting, and the record will show that we adjourned, out of respect to our colleague. Hearing no objection, it is so ordered. The Secretary of the the Interior is here this morning with his staff from the Office of Territories. The reason that we have not called the Secretary and his staff members before the committee in formal session as we usually do in the beginning of a session of Congress is that we are giving first priority to the legislation now before the committee. Mr. Secretary, we shall ask you and your staff members to appear before the committee when we get through with this task which we have calendared at this time. The Chair desires to state that he wishes that the consideration of H.R. 50 and kindred bills will be handled expeditiously and com- pletely, at least as completely as reasonably possible. Those of us who have for many, many years supported legislation granting the status of statehood to Alaska and Hawaii are pleased with the first goal which we reached which was the granting of statehood to Alaska. Now let us proceed together toward the second-statehood for Hawaii-with a like dedication to our task. Let unhampered and constructive debate prevail at our proceedings. Write a record so that future generations may know that we understand the importance of the task we now undertake. Above all things, especially in this committee and while we control the legislation, may we committee members keep party partisanship at a minimum, and, if possible, remove it from our deliberations en- tirely, because this matter is a nonpartisan or rather a bipartisan matter. I wish to thank Delegate Burns for the outstanding spirit of coop- eration which he has shown. It took an understanding, a trusting, a STATEHOOD FOR HAWAII dedicated person to wait as he has for action on this legislation which means so much to the people of Hawaii. I sincerely hope that now that the hour of fulfillment for all the people of Hawaii is close at hand, that the galaxy of stars in our flag shall be filled to its presently anticipated completion. The procedure to be followed in the consideration of the legislation now before us has been agreed upon by the distinguished gentleman from New York, Mr. O'Brien, chairman of the Subcommittee on Ter- ritories and Insular Affairs and myself. Mr. O'Brien provided able and effective leadership in the fight for statehood for Alaska. His zeal in that task was second to none in the Congress of the United States. He stands likewise dedicated to securing the status of statehood for Hawaii. It is given to but few men to be privileged to be a leader in two such endeavors. Recognizing his ability and his right and honest ambition to as- sume such leadership, I am now appointing him as acting chairman of our committee for the hearings on H.R. 50 and kindred bills and the marking up of these bills. I also request that he prepare for and file with the House the com- mittee report showing the action of this committee on the legislation now before us. I request that the gentleman from New York, Mr. O'Brien, take the chair. Mr. O'BRnEN (presiding). Mr. Chairman, may I say at the out- set that I appreciate what you have just done. I think that there are few men in Congress, chairmen of powerful committees such as this, that would step aside in connection