Black Seminole Involvement and Leadership During the Second Seminole War, 1835-1842
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BLACK SEMINOLE INVOLVEMENT AND LEADERSHIP DURING THE SECOND SEMINOLE WAR, 1835-1842 BY Anthony E. Dixon A Dissertation submitted to the faculty of the University Graduate School in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of History Indiana University May, 2007 Accepted by the Graduate Faculty, Indiana University, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Doctoral Committee: ________________________ Claude Clegg, Ph.D ________________________ Canter Brown, Ph.D ________________________ Akwesi Assenoh, Ph.D ________________________ Steven Stowe, Ph.D March 28, 2007 ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Throughout the course of this research, I realized that it truly becoming the culmination of years of training. I am very grateful for the patience of faculty, family, and friends. I would first like to thank: Dr. C. Clegg for supervising this process while having the patience to guide me each step of the way and Dr. L. Rivers, President Fort Valley State University, who has mentored me in such an unwavering and diligent manner. I offer gratitude to: The History and Political Science Department at Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University, Dr. Theodore Hemmingway, Dr. David Jackson, Associate Professor of History at Florida Agricultural Mechanical University; Beverly G. Perkins, Florida Agricultural Mechanical University, Stacey Reese, Florida Agricultural Mechanical University, Daniel L. Schafer, Professor of History at University of North Florida, Ian Hancock, Professor of Linguisties at University of Texas at Austin; Dr. Canter Brown, Fort Valley State University; Dr Daniel Walker, Professor of History at University of California at Riverside; Joe Knetsch, Bureau of Survey and Mapping, Division of State Lands; James Cusick, Curator at P.K. Yonge Library of Florida History, University of Florida; Althamese Barnes, John G. Riley Museum; Gloria Steele, John G Riley Museum; Dr. Tameka Hobbs, Virginia; Dr. William “Billy” Hobbs, Associate Professor at Virginia State University; Annie Speights, Visiting Professor of Political Science at Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University; Tyra Mason, Florida Agricultural Mechanical University; Erma Ellis, Florida Mechanical University; Dr. Andrew Manis, Professor of History at Macon State College; and Dr. Valerie Grimm, Associate Professor of History and African Diaspora Studies at Indiana University. iii As with anything worth having, this research has proven to be an arduous task. A task that would not have been accomplished without a support system. I am most grateful to my family: Dr. Clinton Dixon, Dr. Virginia Dixon, Dazon Dixon-Diallo, Chandra Dixon-Thomas, and Bruce Thomas. My spiritual, human, and scholarly development would be non-existent without them. I am truly blessed and thankful for you. I would also like to thank family and friends such as: Travis Walker, Andre Randolph, Deloris Walker, Troy Walker, Norman Walker, Bernice Smith, James Jones IV, Eddie “Sweat” Avant, Joseph “Jody” Isom, Anton Cooper, Notcha Lockett, Talibah Marin-Coleman, Timothy “Kulcha” Coleman, Dr. Naima Prince, Thaddeus Powell, Charles Mann, Larry Andrews, Virshawn Champion, Kieva Wiley, Claire Smith, and Patrick Barrett. Their support and contributions, were immeasurable to both my personal as well as my professional growth. I am very grateful. I am, because we are; We are, therefore I am. iv Abstract This thesis examines the involvement, leadership, and impact of the Black Seminoles during the Second Seminole War. In Florida, free Blacks, runaway slaves, and Blacks owned by Seminoles collectively became known as Black Seminoles. Black Seminoles either lived in separate communities near Seminole Indians, or joined them by cohabitating or intermarriage. Throughout this cohabitation, Blacks became an integral part of Seminole life by taking positions as advisers, counselors, and trusted interpreters to the English (who were rapidly advancing plantation society into territorial Florida). By the advent of the Second Seminole War, Black Seminoles, unlike their Seminole Indian counterparts were not given the opportunity to emigrate westward under the United States government’s Indian Removal Policy. The United States government’s objective became to return as many Black Seminoles, if not all, to slavery. Therefore, it became the Black Seminole’s objective to resist enslavement or re-enslavement (for many) on American plantations. The Introduction explains the objective and focus of this study. Moreover, it explains the need and importance of this study while examining the historiography of the Second Seminole War in relation to the Black Seminoles. The origins and cultural aspects of the Black Seminoles is the topic of chapter one. By examining the origins and cultural aspects of the Black Seminoles, this study establishes the autonomy of the Black Seminoles from their Indian counterparts. Chapter two focuses on the relationship and v alliance between Seminole Blacks and Indians. Research concerning Black Seminole involvement throughout the war allows chapter three to reconstruct the Second Seminole War from the Black Seminole perspective. A biographical approach is utilized in chapter four in order to understand the Black Seminole leadership. This chapter examines the lives of the three most prominent Black Seminole leaders during the war. The overall impact of the Black Seminole involvement in the war is the focus of chapter five. Chapter six summarizes this study and provides the historiography of the Second Seminole War with a perspective that has remained relatively obscure. It is clear that from the onset of the war, the United States government, military, and state militias grossly underestimated both the determination and the willingness of the Black Seminole to resist at all cost. Throughout the war, both United States’ military and political strategies were constructed and reconstructed to compensate for both the intensity with which the Black Seminoles fought as well as their political savvy during negotiations. This study examines the impact of the Black Seminoles on the Second Seminole War within the context of marronage and subsequently interprets the Second Seminole War itself as a form of slave rebellion. vi Table of Contents Title Page……………………………………………………..............................................i Acknowlegements………………………………………………………………………...iii Abstract..................………………………………………………………………………..v Table of Contents………………………………………………………………………..vii Table of Illustrations…………………………………………………………………….viii Introduction……………………………………………………………………………….1 Chapter 1…………………………………………………………………………………15 Origins and Cultural Character of the Black Seminole Chapter 2…………………………………………………………………………………35 Seminole and Black Seminole Alliance Chapter 3…………………………………………………………………………………55 Black Seminole Early Resistance and Involvement During the Second Seminole War Chapter 4………………………………………………………………………………..120 Black Seminole Leadership During the Second Seminole War Chapter 5………………………………………………………………………………..179 The Impact of the Black Seminoles on the Second Seminole War Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………...198 Bibliography……………………………………………………………………………205 vii Table of Illustrations Afro-Seminole Creole Language…………………………………………………………………………………25 Annual Distribution of Runaway Slaves………………………………………………..184 viii Introduction From 1817 to 1858, the United States government engaged in a bitter conflict with the Seminole Nation. This conflict would result in three distinct wars. The First Seminole War (1817-1818) is best defined as a retaliatory expedition to suppress the Seminole and black resistance to the encroachment of the Georgia plantation system in the Florida territory. The Second Seminole War (1835-1842) was conducted under the auspices of the Indian Removal Policy of the 1830’s. This war was a result of the American plantation societies’ relentless efforts to enslave the Black Seminole population. The Third Seminole War (1855-1858) erupted as a result of the United States’ attempt to remove the “last remnants of the Seminole Nation from their homes in the Everglades.”1 Research indicates a gradual process by which the United States attempted to acquire the Florida Territory and rid itself of the Seminole population while enslaving those Blacks who had become a part of or associated with the Seminole Nation. The Second Seminole War is regarded as the longest, deadliest, and most costly Indian war in American history. Recently, Florida historians have began to revisit the Second Seminole War with the assertion that the war itself was the largest slave insurrection in North America. Although Florida historians have made convincing arguments, there has not been an extensive study dedicated solely to Black Seminole efforts during the war. By focusing on the Black Seminoles involvement and leadership during the war, this research will reconstruct the Second Seminole War from the Black Seminole perspective, thus further bolstering the recent assertions made by Florida historians.2 1 This study has three primary goals. The first goal is to document the autonomy of Black Seminole society, thus countering the historiographical tendency to characterize Blacks as wholly dependent upon Indians. The second goal is to examine the Second Seminole War from the Black Seminole perspective. There have been several book- length studies on both the Second Seminole War and the Black Seminoles. However, there has not been a comprehensive study