Seawater-Buffered Diagenesis, Destruction of Carbon Isotope Excursions, and the Composition of DIC in Neoproterozoic Oceans
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Seawater-buffered diagenesis, destruction of carbon isotope excursions, and the composition of DIC in Neoproterozoic oceans Paul F. Hoffmana,b,1 and Kelsey G. Lamothec aSchool of Earth and Ocean Sciences, University of Victoria, Victoria, BC V8P 5C2, Canada; bDepartment of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138; and cDepartment of Earth and Planetary Sciences, McGill University, Montreal, QC H3A 0E8, Canada Edited by Mark H. Thiemens, University of California San Diego, La Jolla, CA, and approved August 16, 2019 (received for review June 4, 2019) Carbonate sediments of nonglacial Cryogenian (659 to 649 Ma) permeable lithologies on the foreslopes of carbonate platforms and early Ediacaran (635 to 590 Ma) age exhibit large positive and (Fig. 2 B and C), where seawater invasion is a response to geo- δ13 negative Ccarb excursions in a shallow-water marine platform in thermally driven porewater convection (17–21). In platform in- 13 northern Namibia. The same excursions are recorded in fringing teriors, where most Neoproterozoic δ Ccarb records have been deep-sea fans and in carbonate platforms on other paleoconti- obtained, diagenesis becomes increasingly sediment buffered with nents. However, coeval carbonates in the upper foreslope of the 13 distance along pore-fluid pathways (12). In these areas, δ Ccarb Namibian platform, and to a lesser extent in the outermost plat- values of the sediment tend to be preserved. δ13 form, have relatively uniform Ccarb compositions compatible Although C is more abundant in carbonate sediment, relative with dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) in the modern ocean. We to seawater, than is Ca or Mg, seawater-buffered diagenesis may attribute the uniform values to fluid-buffered diagenesis that oc- 13 be capable of altering δ Ccarb toward the range of open-ocean curred where seawater invaded the sediment in response to geo- 13 13 δ CDIC. If complete reequilibration occurred, the altered δ Ccarb thermal porewater convection. This attribution, which is testable δ13 δ13 would be a record of open-ocean CDIC. Our strategy, therefore, with paired Ca and Mg isotopes, implies that large Ccarb excur- was to compare δ13C records from the interior of the Otavi/ sions observed in Neoproterozoic platforms, while sedimentary in carb Swakop platform, where diagenesis is expected to have been origin, do not reflect the composition of ancient open-ocean DIC. sediment buffered, with those from the correlative upper foreslope (IPz and UFz, respectively; see Fig. 2A for definitions), where carbon isotope excursions | carbonate diagenesis | Neoproterozoic seawater | carbonate platform seawater-buffered diagenesis could have prevailed. As a test of the fidelity of the IPz records, we obtained correlative ones from turbidite fans fringing the platform (LFz and BMz; Fig. 2A), on arbon-isotope records from marine carbonate successions the assumption that they represent epi-platform sediment that aged 870 to 485 Ma (Fig. 1) exhibit large excursions outside C was advected to the foot of the foreslope, potentially beyond the the compositional range of modern seawater DIC (δ13C = 0.8 ± reach of seawater-buffered diagenesis (Fig. 2 B and C). Where the 1.5‰ Pee Dee Belemnite (PDB); ref. 1) or Cenozoic benthic δ13 = ± ‰ foreslope record was truncated by end-Cryogenian (Marinoan) foraminifera ( C 0.9 1.7 VPDB; ref. 2). Neoproterozoic δ13 δ13 − + ‰ glacial erosion, we investigated lateral Ccarb change going sea- Ccarb ranges from 12 to 9 (Vienna Pee Dee Belemnite A (VPDB)), and values of +6.0 ± 2.5‰ are sustained for as long ward across the outer platform (OPz; Fig. 2 ). as ≥50 My (3). It is often assumed that such excursions reflect secular changes in the composition of seawater DIC, because Significance they are quantitatively reproducible regionally (SI Appendix, Fig. S1)(4–8) and some are demonstrably correlative in what were Carbonate sediments of Neoproterozoic age exhibit large geographically remote successions (9, 10). Here we present age- secular excursions of carbon isotope composition outside 13 correlative δ Ccarb records from different parts of a single the range of modern seawater dissolved inorganic carbon Neoproterozoic carbonate platform, the Otavi/Swakop Group (DIC), but their origins are controversial. We show that in a (Fig. 1) in northern Namibia, which collectively support Neoproterozoic carbonate platform in Namibia, such excursions a sedimentary origin for the excursions but imply that they are disappear on the flanks of the platform, where compositions decoupled from open-ocean DIC. are more compatible with modern seawater. We attribute the Our approach was inspired by recent studies of carbonate dia- observed spatial variation to early fluid-buffered alteration on genesis within active marine carbonate platforms utilizing Ca and the flanks of the platform, where seawater invaded the sedi- Mg isotopes (11, 12). In tandem, Ca and Mg isotopes can dis- ment in response to geothermal porewater convection. Ac- criminate between 2 end-member diagenetic regimes, seawater cordingly, the isotope excursions in the platform interior are buffered and sediment buffered. Dolomites produced during decoupled from open-ocean DIC, which remained close to the seawater-buffered diagenesis have δ44Ca values that approach modern range. Our interpretation is testable and, if confirmed, that of seawater (0‰), and relatively uniform δ26Mg values that has important ramifications for the origins of ancient carbon are ∼2‰ lighter than seawater (13). In contrast, dolomites formed isotope excursions. under sediment-buffered conditions have variably elevated δ26Mg values, due to distillation of Mg in the dolomitizing fluid (11). Author contributions: P.F.H. and K.G.L. designed research; P.F.H. and K.G.L. performed Their δ44Ca values are inherited from the precursor carbonate research; K.G.L. analyzed data; and P.F.H. wrote the paper. sediment, ∼1.0‰ (calcite) to ∼1.5‰ (aragonite) lighter than The authors declare no conflict of interest. seawater (14) due to equilibrium fractionation that occurs during This article is a PNAS Direct Submission. primary carbonate production but not during diagenesis (15, 16). Published under the PNAS license. Thus, seawater-buffered dolomite has lighter Mg and heavier Ca 1To whom correspondence may be addressed. Email: [email protected]. than sediment-buffered dolomite (11). This article contains supporting information online at www.pnas.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10. Seawater-buffered diagenesis requires that seawater persis- 1073/pnas.1909570116/-/DCSupplemental. tently invades the sediment. This is most likely to occur in Published online September 4, 2019. 18874–18879 | PNAS | September 17, 2019 | vol. 116 | no. 38 www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1909570116 Downloaded by guest on September 29, 2021 GA to 2.0 km of cyclic shallow-water carbonate of the Tsumeb Subgroup (22, 23). There are no δ13C data from syn-glacial strata because + BIOTIC SM EB SS C 0.6 10 VSM Keele AA FA’s .. no primary carbonate was produced. The profiles vary appre- Coppercap Huttenberg 0.5 ciably in thickness (SI Appendix,Figs.S3andS4) and were normalized to IPz thickness (Fig. 3) by procedures described +5 SPICE 0.4 below and in SI Appendix. Samples were prepared and isoto- Gaskiers 0.3 pically analyzed according to methods described in refs. 5 (1) (2) and 41. Marinoan (VPDB) 0 0.2 Sturtian Results carb C 0.1 δ13 13 Cryogenian C profiles from the IPz exhibit 3 negative and 2 -5 Rasthof positive carbon isotope excursions (CIEs) (Fig. 3). For brevity, 0 Shuram we number them Cn1 to 5, with negative CIEs being odd num- Garvellach Bitter Springs Bitter bered and positive ones even numbered. Cn1 is named Rasthof Maieberg Russoya org Trezona -10 Taishir o (33), Cn3 Taishir (8, 42), and Cn5 Trezona (6, 43). Positive ex- 13 C(i)=-6 /oo o Ccarb Otavi/Swakop Group =27/oo cursion Cn4, named Keele peak (44), is accompanied by in- 13 T ONIAN CRYOGENIAN EDIACARAN CAMBR’N creased point-to-point δ C variability (Fig. 3 and SI Appendix, Fig. S5). 900 850 800 750 700 650 600 550 500 Cryogenian profiles from LFz turbidites generally track the Millions of years before present (Ma) IPz (Fig. 3). Cn3 is deeper, but less so than the nominal Taishir Fig. 1. Marine carbonate δ13C from 900 to 485 Ma (3, 66) compiled from CIE in Mongolia (8, 42). Cn4 is shallower than IPz with even various carbonate platforms. Gray bands are ranges for modern seawater more scatter. The descent and nadir of Cn5 went unrecorded DIC (1) and Cenozoic benthic foraminiferal CaCO3 (2). Named C-isotope ex- in the LFz because of a laterally persistent shale (Narachaams cursions in magenta italics. Vertical blue bars are glacial epochs and aqua Formation). A falling-stand carbonate wedge (Franni-aus For- box indicates total age range of the Otavi/Swakop Group in northern mation) preceding the Marinoan lowstand records the recovery Namibia. Fractional organic burial flux (forg) assumes a C-influx (C(i)) with leg of Cn5 (Fig. 3 and SI Appendix, Fig. S3) in the LFz. It climbs δ13 = − ‰ δ13 – δ13 = ‰ C 6 (VPDB) and Ccarb Corg 27 in the burial flux. Biotic first 1.5‰ higher than the IPz because accumulation continued after appearances: SM, scale microfossils (67); VSM, vase-shaped microfossils (68); the platform was subaerially exposed (35). GA, algal biomarkers (69); AA, acanthomorphic acritarchs (70); EB, Ediacara EARTH, ATMOSPHERIC, soft-body fossils (71); SS, small shelly fossils (72); C, Cambrian fauna (73). The UFz profile tracks the IPz through Cn1 and 2, but Cn3 AND PLANETARY SCIENCES and 4 are not expressed at all (Fig. 3). After Cn2, δ13C stabilizes near 3‰ in the UFz, declining slowly with stratigraphic height. Geologic Setting The top of the profile veers off toward lighter values, which we The southwestern promontory of Congo craton is blanketed by a tentatively correlate with the Cn5 downturn (Fig. 3).