Application Report Strategic Development & Planning Place Services North Devon Council Lynton House, Commercial Road, Barnstaple, EX31 1DG
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Application Report Strategic Development & Planning Place Services North Devon Council Lynton House, Commercial Road, Barnstaple, EX31 1DG Application No: 70366 Application 27 December Expiry : 2019 Application Type: Full application Ext Of Time Expiry : Publicity Expiry: 12 December 2019 Parish/Ward: WEST DOWNMORTEHOE/MORTEHOE Location: Willingcott Valley Holiday Village Bradwell Road Woolacombe EX34 7HN Proposal: Proposed improvements to leisure facilities together with woodland planting, landscaping and the erection of 107 holiday cottages and associated infrastructure works Agent: Mr Stephen Harris Applicant: Merelafan Developments Henley Road Limited Planning Case Officer: Mr. R. Pedlar Departure: N EIA Development: Y EIA C onclusion: An environment statement has been submitted. Decision Level/Reason for Report to Committee/Ward member call-in Committee (If Applicable) : (See main body of report). Site Description The site description is taken from the submitted Environmental Statement: The Site is located in the open countryside to the east of Woolacombe, to the south of Bradwell Road, which connects to the B3343 Georgeham Road at its western end and the A361 at its eastern end in Dean Cross. It lies at the head of an east facing valley which extends towards West Down and Fullabrook Down. The Site (which comprises two areas separated by Bradwell Road) previously contained a farmhouse and barns, but was developed into a holiday village, golf course and leisure facilities in stages from the 1980’s onwards. The Site occupies an area of approximately 40.5ha. It is accessed from Willingcott Hill, which is located to the south of the Site. 73 holiday homes together with a clubhouse for the former golf course and an outdoor swimming pool, access roads and car parking currently occupy the north western portion of the Site. The Site forms a self-contained and distinct ‘village’. The central/eastern area of the Site contains a number of linked ponds and the remnants of the 18-hole golf course which is currently closed and is overgrown. The northern area beyond Bradwell Road also contains the remnants of part of the golf course with a number of holes. There is no development on the northern Site area. The golf course ceased operating in early 2016 following a prolonged period of trading at a loss. This leisure use remains the current Land Use. The existing built form comprises a mixture of single storey, two and two and a half storey buildings, some in stone and others in a mixture of stone and white render. There are some groups of semi mature trees and a number of individual trees in and around the built development. There are also some lines and small groups of trees (many of them evergreen) dividing the fairways of the golf course. Outside the area of existing buildings, the Site retains an open character and is made up of managed grassland and open water bodies. A cutting of the former London and South Western Railway (Ilfracombe to Barnstaple) runs north west to south east through the Site. North Devon Council proposes to reuse this cutting as a cycle trail which would be an extension to the Tarka Trail. This proposed route of this trail through the Site is shown on the Proposals Map of the adopted North Devon and Torridge Local Plan. No Public Rights of Way are currently present within the Site or on the boundary. The nearest footpath is Mortehoe Bridleway 4 to the west which follows Harnall’s Lane. The Site is not subject to any statutory landscape designation, although it is located in close proximity to the eastern edge of the North Devon AONB. The landscape character of the Site is considered to be of no higher than of local importance and is not considered to be a "valued landscape" for the purposes of the Framework. Beyond the Site the primary land use is agricultural. The Golden Coast Holiday Village and Willingcott Caravan and Motorhome Club site lie to the north west of the Site in Ossaborough. Recommendation: Approved Legal Agreement Required:- No, if Section 111 payment made. Planning History Planning Decision Decision Date 10023 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 24 October 1989 Proposal:APPROVAL OF DETAILS PROPOSED ERECTION OF CLUBHOUSE AND COVERED SWIMMING POOL. 11354 FULL PLANNING REFUSAL 6 March 1990 Proposal:PROPOSED 2 NO. TENNIS COURTS,BOWLING GREEN AND PAVILION TOGETHER WITH ASSOCIATED LANDSCAPING 11636 FULL PLANNING REFUSAL 9 May 1990 Proposal:PROPOSED CHANGE OF USE AGRICULTURAL LAND TO GOLF COURSE WITH TREE PLANTING SCHEME LANDSCAPING AND CAR PARKING. 12648 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 18 March 1992 Proposal:PROPOSED CHANGE OF USE :AGRICULTURE TO GOLF COURSE SOLELY FOR USE OF RESIDENTS & BONA FIDE GUESTS OF HOLIDAY VILLAGE PLUS TREE PLANTING AND LANDSCAPING. 12869 WITHDRAWN 14 May 1996 Proposal:PROPOSED VARIATION OF OCCUPANCY CONDITIONS ATTACHED TO PLAN.PER.7310 AND 2/86/1302/66/1 TO ALLOW 50 WEEK USE INSTEAD OF EXISTING 44 WEEK USE. 13129 FULL PLANNING REFUSAL 22 January 1991 Proposal:PROPOSED RE-ERECTION OF RE-LOCATABLE BUILDING USED AS TEMPORARY SALES,PRESENTATION & ADMINISTRATION CENTRE IN CONNECTION WITH SALES OF HOLIDAY COTTAGES. 13541 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 6 June 1991 Proposal:PROPOSED FORMATION OF TENNIS COURT. 15702 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 21 July 1992 Proposal:PROPOSED TEMPORARY CHANGE OF USE OF EXISTING FARMHOUSE TO FORM OFFICES AND PRESENTATION SUITE FOR USE IN CONNECTION WITH THE SALE OF HOLIDAY COTTAGES. 15751 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 11 August 1992 Proposal:PROPOSED VARIATION OF PLANNING CONSENT 10023 TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION OF CLUBHOUSE AND COVERED SWIMMING POOL IN ACCORDANCE WITH AMENDED DESIGNS SHOWN ON DRAWING NUMBERS 92377.01,92377.02 AND 92377.04. (AMENDED PLANS) 18219 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 1 February 1994 Proposal:PROPOSED CONVERSION OF GARAGE TO FORM BATHROOM. 20701 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 27 July 1995 Proposal:PROPOSED SITING OF TEMPORARY DIRECTIONAL SIGN TO WILLINGCOTT VALLEY COTTAGES 21139 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 18 December 1995 Proposal:PROPOSED FORMATION OF GOLF COURSE TOGETHER WITH LANDSCAPING AND ASSOCIATED WORKS (AMENDED LAYOUT & AREA TO GOLF COURSE APPROVED UNDER PLAN. PER. 12648) 21256 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 21 November 1995 Proposal:PROPOSED CHANGE OF USE OF EXISTING LAUNDRY TO FORM GOLF SHOP 21257 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 21 November 1995 Proposal:PROPOSED CONVERSION OF EXISTING WORKS SHED TO FORM CHANGING ROOMS FOR USE IN CONNECTION WITH GOLF COURSE, LAUNDRY, SAUNA, GAMES ROOM AND TROLLEY STORE 21258 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 16 July 1997 Proposal:PROPOSED CONVERSION OF AND EXTENSION TO EXISTING FARMHOUSE TO FORM CLUBHOUSE FACILITIES AND ADDITIONAL HOLIDAY ACCOMMODATION TOGETHER WITH FORMATION OF ADDITIONAL CAR PARKING AREA 21492 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 30 January 1996 Proposal:RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION IN RESPECT OF ERECTION OF 3 NO. AGRICULTURAL SHEDS 21824 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 8 February 1999 Proposal:PROPOSED REMOVAL OF CONDITION 3 (RESTRICTION ON USE) ATTACHED TO PLAN. PER. 21139 TO ALLOW USE OF GOLF COURSE BY NON- RESIDENTS OF HOLIDAY VILLAGE 22015 WITHDRAWN 5 March 1999 Proposal:PROPOSED DEMOLITION OF EXISTING AGRICULTURAL BUILDING AND ERECTION OF NEW MAINTENANCE/STORAGE BUILDING FOR USE IN CONNECTION WITH GOLF COURSE 22016 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 30 September 2002 Proposal:PROPOSED CONVERSION OF EXISTING LAUNDRY BUILDING TO FORM ADDITIONAL ACCOMMODATION ANCILLARY TO CLUBHOUSE AND ACCOMMODATION COMPLEX 22862 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 16 July 1997 Proposal:PROPOSED CONVERSION OF AND EXTENSION TO EXISTING FARMHOUSE/ GUESTHOUSE TO FORM CLUBHOUSE INCLUDING SHOP AND RESTAURANT 22863 FULL PLANNING REFUSAL 10 December 1996 Proposal:PROPOSED SITING OF ILLUMINATED FREE STANDING ENTRANCE SIGN 22893 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 29 November 1996 Proposal:PROPOSED SITING OF TEMPORARY CHANGING ROOM FACILITIES 23354 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 17 March 1997 Proposal:PROPOSED SITING OF NON-ILLUMINATED FREE STANDING ENTRANCE SIGN 24728 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 14 January 1998 Proposal:PROPOSED TEMPORARY CHANGE OF USE OF EXISTING FUNCTION/SNOOKER ROOM TO FORM CHANGING ROOMS 27001 FINALLY DISPOSED OF 29 May 2008 Proposal:PROPOSED FORMATION OF NEW ACCESS AND DRIVEWAY TO SERVE MYRTLE COTTAGE AND WILLINGCOTT VILLAGE TOGETHER WITH CLOSURE OF EXISTING ACCESS TO HOLIDAY VILLAGE (AMENDED PLANS & APPLICATION SITE AREA) 27999 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 2 October 2001 Proposal:ALTERATIONS TO LAYOUT AND EXTENSION OF EXISTING 9 HOLE GOLF COURSE TO FORM 18 HOLE GOLF COURSE TOGETHER WITH ASSOCIATED WORKS ( AMENDED PLANS) 30438 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 19 April 2001 Proposal:CONTINUED USE OF FUNCTION/SNOOKER ROOM AS CHANGING ROOMS ( RENEWAL OF 24728) 30540 CERT OF LAWFULNESS 12 April 2001 REFUSED Proposal:APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF LAWFULNESS FOR AN EXISTING USE IN BREACH OF PLANNING CONDITION 1 ( OCCUPANCY) ATTACHED TO PLANNING CONSENT 2/86/786/66/3 IN RESPECT OF OCCUPATION OF PROPERTY AS PERMANENT DWELLING 31765 CERT OF LAWFULNESS 28 February 2002 REFUSED Proposal:CERTIFICATE OF LAWFULNESS FOR AN EXISTING USE OF PROPERTY AS FULL RESIDENTIAL DWELLING 33179 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 25 July 2002 Proposal:VARIATION OF HOLIDAY OCCUPANCY CONDITION ATTACHED TO PLANNING CONSENT 2/85/949/66/3 TO ALLOW ALL YEAR ROUND HOLIDAY OCCUPANCY 33249 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 16 October 2002 Proposal:ERECTION OF 9 NO. HOLIDAY COTTAGES 33344 FULL PLANNING APPROVAL 24 July 2002 Proposal:REPLACEMENT OF EXISTING 2 NO. WINDOWS WITH FRENCH DOORS 33525 FULL PLANNING + S106 17 April 2007 APPROVAL Proposal:CONVERSION OF & EXTENSION TO EXISTING FARMHOUSE TO FORM CLUBHOUSE FACILITIES & ADDITIONAL HOLIDAY ACCOMMODATION TOGETHER WITH FORMATION OF ADDITIONAL CAR PARKING