DOCSLIB.ORG

The Nature of Natural Units Nick Van Remortel Demystifies Natural Unit Systems — and Advises What to Do When You See a Mass Expressed in Gev

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Nature of Natural Units Nick Van Remortel Demystifies Natural Unit Systems — and Advises What to Do When You See a Mass Expressed in Gev measure for measure The nature of natural units Nick van Remortel demystifies natural unit systems — and advises what to do when you see a mass expressed in GeV. everal unit systems for describing the to the natural units is done through the natural world exist. The International relations (rounded to 4 significant digits) System of Units (SI)1 — the most widely 1 s = 1.519 × 1015 ħ eV, 1 m = 5.068 × 106 c ħ eV–1 S 35 –2 accepted system across the sciences — is, and 1 kg = 5.610 × 10 c eV. The large although clever and successful, mainly powers involved in these conversions reflect focused towards serving the scientific the awkwardness of the SI for describing community at large, and relies heavily atomic and subatomic scales. on precision measurements of standard If one chooses the speed of light as the prototypes, objects or systems that define a fundamental scale for velocity, all velocities physical unit. As an alternative, natural units can be expressed as dimensionless fractions are truly ‘natural’ for studying the physical of that constant and c can be omitted from world of the small, in particular relativistic all equations (often referred to as putting and quantum-mechanical systems2. The c = 1). To restore the correct dimensionality, philosophy underlying natural units is one needs to remember to implicitly to have as few base units as possible, and multiply all velocities by the speed of light. to define them directly through natural 2007 MEDIA, LLC. © SPRINGER SCIENCE+BUSINESS The same applies to the (reduced) Planck physical constants. constant and ultimately, all quantities The first natural units were proposed (E and B, respectively) in the same units, can be simply expressed in powers of eV. by George J. Stoney3 (pictured). The through the introduction of the speed The latter is often a cause for confusion starting point is to adopt a minimal base of light c as a proportionality constant when dealing with natural units — but of fundamental units, from which many in the expression for the Lorentz force this confusion is not at all inherent to the other (non-base) units can be derived via F = qE + q(v/c) × B experienced by a particle natural unit system itself! So, when a particle dimensional analysis of the physical laws that with charge q moving with velocity v in an physicist says that the mass mH of the Higgs connect them. The choice of the base depends electromagnetic field. The constant needs boson is 125 GeV, this actually means that 9 –2 –25 on conventions, but for the fundamental to have the dimension of a velocity, and c mH = 125 × 10 c eV = 2.228 × 10 kg (ref. 4). laws of physics a base of three units, such as is the natural choice. Using this constant An alternative natural unit system mass, length and time (abbreviated m, l and t, immediately puts into question the choice of follows from considering Newton’s law of respectively) is sufficient. base units adopted in the SI. Indeed, there is gravitation and absorbing the gravitational Troubles arise with the laws of nothing particularly natural about the meter, constant G into a unit for mass — the Planck electromagnetism, in particular with kilogram or second. If one were to adopt mass, leading to the Planck unit system, Coulomb’s law of electrostatics: the velocity as a base quantity, it would have c as which is very appropriate for studying convention to use a specific unit for electric its natural standard. quantum gravity. charge (the coulomb) in the SI implies The same applies to mechanical action Natural unit systems are as natural as it the need for a proportionality constant (energy times time), for which the reduced gets, and lead to valuable insights concerning 1/(4πε0). One can argue whether the vacuum Planck constant ħ is the natural standard. The the scales of energy, time and distance where permittivity ε0 is truly a fundamental constant units for velocity and action can be completed our current descriptions of the forces of of nature, as it is introduced solely to match with a third fundamental constant of nature: nature no longer apply. ❐ a force, expressed in mechanical units, to the rest mass of the electron, which is related electric charges expressed in electrical units. to energy via Einstein’s relativity formula NICK VAN REMORTEL is in the Department A valid alternative is to derive the unit of E = mc2. (The choice of the electron rest mass of Physics, University of Antwerp, 2020 charge from the mechanical units by forcing is more arbitrary than the other fundamental Antwerp, Belgium. the proportionality constant to be unity. constants, as indeed any elementary particle e-mail: [email protected] In this way, the unit of charge acquires the could be chosen to provide a reference mass.) 1/2 3/2 –1 References dimension of m l t . This is how charge As a consequence, the electron volt (eV) 1. SI Brochure: The International System of Units is defined in many unit systems, such as the can be taken as the energy unit — widely (SI) 8th edn (BIPM, 2006); http://go.nature.com/2ehp2XP Gaussian cgs system. used in the fields of atomic, nuclear, particle 2. Jaffe, R. MIT Quantum Theory Notes (2007); When developing the Gaussian system, and astrophysics. One thus arrives at a new http://go.nature.com/2ebYqeU 3. Elliott, I. in Biographical Encyclopedia of Astronomers a solution was found for expressing the base of units expressed in fractions of c, ħ (eds Hockey, T. et al.) 2072–2074 (Springer, 2014). strength of electric and magnetic fields and eV. Going from the mechanical units 4. Olive, K. A. et al. Chinese Phys. C 38, 090001 (2014). 1082 NATURE PHYSICS | VOL 12 | NOVEMBER 2016 | www.nature.com/naturephysics ©2016 Mac millan Publishers Li mited, part of Spri nger Nature. All ri ghts reserved. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • An Atomic Physics Perspective on the New Kilogram Defined by Planck's Constant
    An atomic physics perspective on the new kilogram defined by Planck’s constant (Wolfgang Ketterle and Alan O. Jamison, MIT) (Manuscript submitted to Physics Today) On May 20, the kilogram will no longer be defined by the artefact in Paris, but through the definition1 of Planck’s constant h=6.626 070 15*10-34 kg m2/s. This is the result of advances in metrology: The best two measurements of h, the Watt balance and the silicon spheres, have now reached an accuracy similar to the mass drift of the ur-kilogram in Paris over 130 years. At this point, the General Conference on Weights and Measures decided to use the precisely measured numerical value of h as the definition of h, which then defines the unit of the kilogram. But how can we now explain in simple terms what exactly one kilogram is? How do fixed numerical values of h, the speed of light c and the Cs hyperfine frequency νCs define the kilogram? In this article we give a simple conceptual picture of the new kilogram and relate it to the practical realizations of the kilogram. A similar change occurred in 1983 for the definition of the meter when the speed of light was defined to be 299 792 458 m/s. Since the second was the time required for 9 192 631 770 oscillations of hyperfine radiation from a cesium atom, defining the speed of light defined the meter as the distance travelled by light in 1/9192631770 of a second, or equivalently, as 9192631770/299792458 times the wavelength of the cesium hyperfine radiation.
    [Show full text]
  • Operating Instructions Ac Snap-Around Volt-Ohm
    4.5) HOW TO USE POINTER LOCK & RANGE FINDER LIFETIME LIMITED WARRANTY 05/06 From #174-1 SYMBOLS The attention to detail of this fine snap-around instrument is further enhanced by OPERATING INSTRUCTIONS (1) Slide the pointer lock button to the left. This allows easy readings in dimly lit the application of Sperry's unmatched service and concern for detail and or crowded cable areas (Fig.8). reliability. AC SNAP-AROUND VOLT-OHM-AMMETER (2) For quick and easy identification the dial drum is marked with the symbols as These Sperry snap-arounds are internationally accepted by craftsman and illustrated below (Fig.9). servicemen for their unmatched performance. All Sperry's snap-around MODEL SPR-300 PLUS & SPR-300 PLUS A instruments are unconditionally warranted against defects in material and Pointer Ampere Higher workmanship under normal conditions of use and service; our obligations under Lock range range to the to the this warranty being limited to repairing or replacing, free of charge, at Sperry's right. right. sole option, any such Sperry snap-around instrument that malfunctions under normal operating conditions at rated use. 1 Lower Lower range range to the to the left. left. REPLACEMENT PROCEDURE Fig.8 Fig.9 Securely wrap the instrument and its accessories in a box or mailing bag and ship prepaid to the address below. Be sure to include your name and address, as 5) BATTERY & FUSE REPLACEMENT well as the name of the distributor, with a copy of your invoice from whom the (1) Remove the screw on the back of the case for battery and fuse replacement unit was purchased, clearly identifying the model number and date of purchase.
    [Show full text]
  • Modern Physics Unit 15: Nuclear Structure and Decay Lecture 15.1: Nuclear Characteristics
    Modern Physics Unit 15: Nuclear Structure and Decay Lecture 15.1: Nuclear Characteristics Ron Reifenberger Professor of Physics Purdue University 1 Nucleons - the basic building blocks of the nucleus Also written as: 7 3 Li ~10-15 m Examples: A X=Chemical Element Z X Z = number of protons = atomic number 12 A = atomic mass number = Z+N 6 C N= A-Z = number of neutrons 35 17 Cl 2 What is the size of a nucleus? Three possibilities • Range of nuclear force? • Mass radius? • Charge radius? It turns out that for nuclear matter Nuclear force radius ≈ mass radius ≈ charge radius defines nuclear force range defines nuclear surface 3 Nuclear Charge Density The size of the lighter nuclei can be approximated by modeling the nuclear charge density ρ (C/m3): t ≈ 4.4a; a=0.54 fm 90% 10% Usually infer the best values for ρo, R and a for a given nucleus from scattering experiments 4 Nuclear mass density Scattering experiments indicate the nucleus is roughly spherical with a radius given by 1 3 −15 R = RRooA ; =1.07 × 10meters= 1.07 fm = 1.07 fermis A=atomic mass number What is the nuclear mass density of the most common isotope of iron? 56 26 Fe⇒= A56; Z = 26, N = 30 m Am⋅⋅3 Am 33A ⋅ m m ρ = nuc p= p= pp = o 1 33 VR4 3 3 3 44ππA R nuc π R 4(π RAo ) o o 3 3×× 1.66 10−27 kg = 3.2× 1017kg / m 3 4×× 3.14 (1.07 × 10−15m ) 3 The mass density is constant, independent of A! 5 Nuclear mass density for 27Al, 97Mo, 238U (from scattering experiments) (kg/m3) ρo heavy mass nucleus light mass nucleus middle mass nucleus 6 Typical Densities Material Density Helium 0.18 kg/m3 Air (dry) 1.2 kg/m3 Styrofoam ~100 kg/m3 Water 1000 kg/m3 Iron 7870 kg/m3 Lead 11,340 kg/m3 17 3 Nuclear Matter ~10 kg/m 7 Isotopes - same chemical element but different mass (J.J.
    [Show full text]
  • Dimensional Analysis and the Theory of Natural Units
    LIBRARY TECHNICAL REPORT SECTION SCHOOL NAVAL POSTGRADUATE MONTEREY, CALIFORNIA 93940 NPS-57Gn71101A NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL Monterey, California DIMENSIONAL ANALYSIS AND THE THEORY OF NATURAL UNITS "by T. H. Gawain, D.Sc. October 1971 lllp FEDDOCS public This document has been approved for D 208.14/2:NPS-57GN71101A unlimited release and sale; i^ distribution is NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL Monterey, California Rear Admiral A. S. Goodfellow, Jr., USN M. U. Clauser Superintendent Provost ABSTRACT: This monograph has been prepared as a text on dimensional analysis for students of Aeronautics at this School. It develops the subject from a viewpoint which is inadequately treated in most standard texts hut which the author's experience has shown to be valuable to students and professionals alike. The analysis treats two types of consistent units, namely, fixed units and natural units. Fixed units include those encountered in the various familiar English and metric systems. Natural units are not fixed in magnitude once and for all but depend on certain physical reference parameters which change with the problem under consideration. Detailed rules are given for the orderly choice of such dimensional reference parameters and for their use in various applications. It is shown that when transformed into natural units, all physical quantities are reduced to dimensionless form. The dimension- less parameters of the well known Pi Theorem are shown to be in this category. An important corollary is proved, namely that any valid physical equation remains valid if all dimensional quantities in the equation be replaced by their dimensionless counterparts in any consistent system of natural units.
    [Show full text]
  • Units and Magnitudes (Lecture Notes)
    physics 8.701 topic 2 Frank Wilczek Units and Magnitudes (lecture notes) This lecture has two parts. The first part is mainly a practical guide to the measurement units that dominate the particle physics literature, and culture. The second part is a quasi-philosophical discussion of deep issues around unit systems, including a comparison of atomic, particle ("strong") and Planck units. For a more extended, profound treatment of the second part issues, see arxiv.org/pdf/0708.4361v1.pdf . Because special relativity and quantum mechanics permeate modern particle physics, it is useful to employ units so that c = ħ = 1. In other words, we report velocities as multiples the speed of light c, and actions (or equivalently angular momenta) as multiples of the rationalized Planck's constant ħ, which is the original Planck constant h divided by 2π. 27 August 2013 physics 8.701 topic 2 Frank Wilczek In classical physics one usually keeps separate units for mass, length and time. I invite you to think about why! (I'll give you my take on it later.) To bring out the "dimensional" features of particle physics units without excess baggage, it is helpful to keep track of powers of mass M, length L, and time T without regard to magnitudes, in the form When these are both set equal to 1, the M, L, T system collapses to just one independent dimension. So we can - and usually do - consider everything as having the units of some power of mass. Thus for energy we have while for momentum 27 August 2013 physics 8.701 topic 2 Frank Wilczek and for length so that energy and momentum have the units of mass, while length has the units of inverse mass.
    [Show full text]
  • Summary of Changes for Bidder Reference. It Does Not Go Into the Project Manual. It Is Simply a Reference of the Changes Made in the Frontal Documents
    Community Colleges of Spokane ALSC Architects, P.S. SCC Lair Remodel 203 North Washington, Suite 400 2019-167 G(2-1) Spokane, WA 99201 ALSC Job No. 2019-010 January 10, 2020 Page 1 ADDENDUM NO. 1 The additions, omissions, clarifications and corrections contained herein shall be made to drawings and specifications for the project and shall be included in scope of work and proposals to be submitted. References made below to specifications and drawings shall be used as a general guide only. Bidder shall determine the work affected by Addendum items. General and Bidding Requirements: 1. Pre-Bid Meeting Pre-Bid Meeting notes and sign in sheet attached 2. Summary of Changes Summary of Changes for bidder reference. It does not go into the Project Manual. It is simply a reference of the changes made in the frontal documents. It is not a part of the construction documents. In the Specifications: 1. Section 00 30 00 REPLACED section in its entirety. See Summary of Instruction to Bidders Changes for description of changes 2. Section 00 60 00 REPLACED section in its entirety. See Summary of General and Supplementary Conditions Changes for description of changes 3. Section 00 73 10 DELETE section in its entirety. Liquidated Damages Checklist Mead School District ALSC Architects, P.S. New Elementary School 203 North Washington, Suite 400 ALSC Job No. 2018-022 Spokane, WA 99201 March 26, 2019 Page 2 ADDENDUM NO. 1 4. Section 23 09 00 Section 2.3.F CHANGED paragraph to read “All Instrumentation and Control Systems controllers shall have a communication port for connections with the operator interfaces using the LonWorks Data Link/Physical layer protocol.” A.
    [Show full text]
  • Measuring Vibration Using Sound Level Meter Nor140
    Application Note Measuring vibration using sound level meter Nor140 This technical note describes the use of the sound level meter Nor140 for measurement of acceleration levels. The normal microphone is then substituted by an accelerometer. The note also describes calibration and the relation between the level in decibel and the acceleration in linear units. AN Vibration Ed2Rev0 English 03.08 AN Vibration Ed2Rev0 English 03.08 Introduction Accelerometer Most sound level meters and sound analysers can be used for Many types of acceleration sensitive sensors exist. For vibration measurements, even if they do not provide absolute connection to Nor140 sound level meter the easiest is to (linear) units in the display. To simplify the description, this ap- apply an ICP® or CCP type. This type of transducers has low plication note describes the use of the handheld sound level output impedance and may be supplied through a coaxial meter Norsonic Nor140. However, the described principles able. Nor1270 (Sens. 10 mV/ms-2; 23 g) and Nor1271 (Sens. also apply to other types of sound level meters. 1,0 mV/ms-2; 3,5 g) are recommended. Connect the accelero- Although several transducer principles are commercially meter through the BNC/Lemo cable Nor1438 and the BNC to available, this application note will deal with the accelerometer microdot adaptor Nor1466. You also need a BNC-BNC female only, simply because it is the transducer type most commonly connector. See the figure below. encountered when measuring vibration levels. As the name Alternatively, a charge sensitive accelerometer may be suggests, the accelerometer measures the acceleration it is used and coupled to the normal microphone preamplifier exposed to and provides an output signal proportional to the Nor1209 through the adapter with BNC input Nor1447/2 and instant acceleration.
    [Show full text]
  • Natural Units Conversions and Fundamental Constants James D
    February 2, 2016 Natural Units Conversions and Fundamental Constants James D. Wells Michigan Center for Theoretical Physics (MCTP) University of Michigan, Ann Arbor Abstract: Conversions are listed between basis units of natural units system where ~ = c = 1. Important fundamental constants are given in various equivalent natural units based on GeV, seconds, and meters. Natural units basic conversions Natural units are defined to give ~ = c = 1. All quantities with units then can be written in terms of a single base unit. It is customary in high-energy physics to use the base unit GeV. But it can be helpful to think about the equivalences in terms of other base units, such as seconds, meters and even femtobarns. The conversion factors are based on various combinations of ~ and c (Olive 2014). For example −25 1 = ~ = 6:58211928(15) × 10 GeV s; and (1) 1 = c = 2:99792458 × 108 m s−1: (2) From this we can derive several useful basic conversion factors and 1 = ~c = 0:197327 GeV fm; and (3) 2 11 2 1 = (~c) = 3:89379 × 10 GeV fb (4) where I have not included the error in ~c conversion but if needed can be obtained by consulting the error in ~. Note, the value of c has no error since it serves to define the meter, which is the distance light travels in vacuum in 1=299792458 of a second (Olive 2014). The unit fb is a femtobarn, which is 10−15 barns. A barn is defined to be 1 barn = 10−24 cm2. The prefexes letters, such as p on pb, etc., mean to multiply the unit after it by the appropropriate power: femto (f) 10−15, pico (p) 10−12, nano (n) 10−9, micro (µ) 10−6, milli (m) 10−3, kilo (k) 103, mega (M) 106, giga (G) 109, terra (T) 1012, and peta (P) 1015.
    [Show full text]
  • Guide for the Use of the International System of Units (SI)
    Guide for the Use of the International System of Units (SI) m kg s cd SI mol K A NIST Special Publication 811 2008 Edition Ambler Thompson and Barry N. Taylor NIST Special Publication 811 2008 Edition Guide for the Use of the International System of Units (SI) Ambler Thompson Technology Services and Barry N. Taylor Physics Laboratory National Institute of Standards and Technology Gaithersburg, MD 20899 (Supersedes NIST Special Publication 811, 1995 Edition, April 1995) March 2008 U.S. Department of Commerce Carlos M. Gutierrez, Secretary National Institute of Standards and Technology James M. Turner, Acting Director National Institute of Standards and Technology Special Publication 811, 2008 Edition (Supersedes NIST Special Publication 811, April 1995 Edition) Natl. Inst. Stand. Technol. Spec. Publ. 811, 2008 Ed., 85 pages (March 2008; 2nd printing November 2008) CODEN: NSPUE3 Note on 2nd printing: This 2nd printing dated November 2008 of NIST SP811 corrects a number of minor typographical errors present in the 1st printing dated March 2008. Guide for the Use of the International System of Units (SI) Preface The International System of Units, universally abbreviated SI (from the French Le Système International d’Unités), is the modern metric system of measurement. Long the dominant measurement system used in science, the SI is becoming the dominant measurement system used in international commerce. The Omnibus Trade and Competitiveness Act of August 1988 [Public Law (PL) 100-418] changed the name of the National Bureau of Standards (NBS) to the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and gave to NIST the added task of helping U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Measuring in Metric Units BEFORE Now WHY? You Used Metric Units
    Measuring in Metric Units BEFORE Now WHY? You used metric units. You’ll measure and estimate So you can estimate the mass using metric units. of a bike, as in Ex. 20. Themetric system is a decimal system of measurement. The metric Word Watch system has units for length, mass, and capacity. metric system, p. 80 Length Themeter (m) is the basic unit of length in the metric system. length: meter, millimeter, centimeter, kilometer, Three other metric units of length are themillimeter (mm) , p. 80 centimeter (cm) , andkilometer (km) . mass: gram, milligram, kilogram, p. 81 You can use the following benchmarks to estimate length. capacity: liter, milliliter, kiloliter, p. 82 1 millimeter 1 centimeter 1 meter thickness of width of a large height of the a dime paper clip back of a chair 1 kilometer combined length of 9 football fields EXAMPLE 1 Using Metric Units of Length Estimate the length of the bandage by imagining paper clips laid next to it. Then measure the bandage with a metric ruler to check your estimate. 1 Estimate using paper clips. About 5 large paper clips fit next to the bandage, so it is about 5 centimeters long. ch O at ut! W 2 Measure using a ruler. A typical metric ruler allows you to measure Each centimeter is divided only to the nearest tenth of into tenths, so the bandage cm 12345 a centimeter. is 4.8 centimeters long. 80 Chapter 2 Decimal Operations Mass Mass is the amount of matter that an object has. The gram (g) is the basic metric unit of mass.
    [Show full text]
  • Gravity and Coulomb's
    Gravity operates by the inverse square law (source Hyperphysics) A main objective in this lesson is that you understand the basic notion of “inverse square” relationships. There are a small number (perhaps less than 25) general paradigms of nature that if you make them part of your basic view of nature they will help you greatly in your understanding of how nature operates. Gravity is the weakest of the four fundamental forces, yet it is the dominant force in the universe for shaping the large-scale structure of galaxies, stars, etc. The gravitational force between two masses m1 and m2 is given by the relationship: This is often called the "universal law of gravitation" and G the universal gravitation constant. It is an example of an inverse square law force. The force is always attractive and acts along the line joining the centers of mass of the two masses. The forces on the two masses are equal in size but opposite in direction, obeying Newton's third law. You should notice that the universal gravitational constant is REALLY small so gravity is considered a very weak force. The gravity force has the same form as Coulomb's law for the forces between electric charges, i.e., it is an inverse square law force which depends upon the product of the two interacting sources. This led Einstein to start with the electromagnetic force and gravity as the first attempt to demonstrate the unification of the fundamental forces. It turns out that this was the wrong place to start, and that gravity will be the last of the forces to unify with the other three forces.
    [Show full text]
  • Volt-Ohm-Milliampere Meter (VOM) Content 1
    2141274 Electrical and Electronic Laboratory Faculty of Engineering, Chulalongkorn University Volt-Ohm-Milliampere Meter (VOM) Content 1. Objective 2. Theoretical part 2.1) Volt-Ohm-Milliampere (VOM) meter 2.2) Color codes for a resistor 2.3) Identification of diodes and transistor polarities 3. Experimental part 3.1) Experimental instructions 3.2) Experimental report 1. Objective This laboratory helps you to familiarize with a Volt-Ohm-Milliampere (VOM) meter. 2. Theoretical Part 2.1) Volt-Ohm-Milliampere (VOM) Meter A meter with a single D’Arsonval movement that can be used to measure multiple ranges of currents and voltages is called a multimeter. A common type of analog multimetera combination voltmeter, ohmmeter and milliammeteris abbreviated VOM. The block diagram of a basic multimeter is shown in Figure 1. Moving coil type Microammeter DC Voltage Measurement Selector switch AC Voltage Measurement DC Current Measurement Test terminal Resistance Measurement Test leads Figure 1: Block diagram of a basic multimeter. The ammeter in Figure 1 is a moving coil ammeter. It uses magnetic deflection, where current passing through a coil in a magnetic field from permanent magnet creates the torque and causes the coil to move clockwise. The distance of the coil moves is proportional to the passing DC current. Figure 2 illustrates the D’Arsonval movement. 1 Figure 2: D’Arsonval movement. For DC voltage measurement, large values of resistances are connected in series with a microammeter, e.g. 50 µA, 2000 Ω, in order to limit the current passing through it. The voltage obtained can be computed from the passing current and the resistance value.
    [Show full text]