“Political Voice” in a Philippine Website Blog1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Internet as a Democratizer: Exploring “Political Voice” in a Philippine Website Blog 1) Yellowbelle Del Mundo DUAQUI 2) Abstract This paper examines http://kuro-kuro.org, which is at least one of the many active sites in Philippine blogosphere, in the context of Philippine democracy. This Internet address hosts a website blog that publishes essays submitted online by Filipino citizens all over the world. It was launched by Filipino expatriate supporters during the presidential campaign of Philippine President Benigno Simeon “Noynoy” Aquino III. It is fundamentally conjectured in this paper that political blogging has become a democratizing tool in the Philippines, which deepens democracy by foregrounding the “political voice” of ordinary citizens. This paper seeks to answer the following questions: does political blogging promote freedom of expression? Does it serve as a democratizing tool? How does blogging impact mass politics and democracy in general? Keywords : political blogging, Philippine democracy, mass politics, political voice, Internet I. Introduction As of June 2010, Internet penetration rate in the Philippines was pegged at 29.7%, which translates to 29, 700,000 users out of the total population of about 99 million Filipinos, according to the research company AC Nielsen. 3) The Yahoo-Nielsen Net Index 2008 found out that 28 percent of Filipinos in the 22 major Philippine cities (including Metro Manila) have Internet access. Internet connectivity, however, is not only an urban privilege; it extends to far-reaching geographic locations, age groups and income brackets in the Philippines. The study also discovered that approximately 5 percent of its respondents use the Internet daily. The Internet is most appealing to young Filipinos, with 50% of the respondents in the 10 to 19 year-old age group having gone online the month before they participated in the study. 4) Table 1 shows the increasing trend of Internet use in the Philippines within the span of a decade, between the years 2000 to 2010. - 151 - 立命館言語文化研究23巻 4 号 Table 1. Growth of Internet Use in the Philippines, 2000-2010 Year Internet Users Population % of the Population Source 2000 2,000,000 78,181,900 2.6 % ITU 2005 7,820,000 84,174,092 9.3 % C.I. Almanac 2008 14,000,000 96,061,683 14.6 % Yahoo! 2009 24,000,000 97,976,603 24.5 % Nielsen 2010 29,700,000 99,900,177 29.7 % ITU Source: http://www.internetworldstats.com/asia/ph.htm Despite Internet penetration not being able to cover even at least half of the Philippine population, it is worth noting that the Philippine blogosphere acts as a vibrant public space and an important opinion maker. Based on a study of global Internet use conducted by the Universal McCann, approximately 90% of Internet users in the Philippines read blogs on a regular basis, trailing behind South Korea at 92%. 5) Meanwhile, the Yahoo-Nielsen Net Index 2008 study found out that Filipino Internet users are “more likely to be opinion leaders.” 6) It could be claimed, on the basis of these two studies, that there is a sustained effort in blog writing and a solid blog readership base in the Philippines. II. Literature Review Earlier analyses of the linkage between democracy and the Internet showed a positive correlation, citing the spread of democratic values and the empowerment of ordinary citizens to bypass state censorship as its clear outcomes. A. Western Literature on the Democracy-Internet Connection Simon (2002) noted that the developers themselves of the Internet intended the technology to “reinvigorate democracy and spread democratic values around the globe.” (Simon, Corrales and Wolfensberger, 2002: vii) These “idealistic technologists”, according to Simon (2002), point to the various unprecedented capabilities of the Internet in order to prove the link between democracy and the Internet: it made possible for anyone to become a publisher and gain access to a wide readership base, it allowed “new modes of free expression”, it built civil society by making freedom of association and advocacy support digitally possible, it empowered ordinary citizens by providing the tools for e-participation, and it promoted government transparency and accountability. (Simon, Corrales and Wolfensberger, 2002: vii) Simon (2002) also pointed out that the connection between democracy and the Internet can be historically validated. The development of the Internet, according to the author, coincided with the fall of the Soviet Union and Communism. The rapid expansion of the Internet also occurred contemporaneously with the transition to democracy of formerly Communist states in Eastern - 152 - The Internet as a Democratizer(DUAQUI) Europe, Russia, and certain Asian countries. (Simon, Corrales and Wolfensberger, 2002: viii) Citing Robert Keohane and Joseph Nye, Simon (2002) underscored that the information age is empowering not only the big industrial nations, but the small developing ones as well. The Internet has become a tool for soft power, changing the nature of power in international relations. (Simon, Corrales and Wolfensberger, 2002: 13) For industrial nations like the United States, the Internet was appropriated as a tool for governance. Aikat (2000) 7) discussed how the United States government is making use of the Internet on how to promote access to government information it is willing to share. The author cited a landmark legislation passed by the United States Congress in 1993, known as the Government Printing Office Electronic Information Access Enhancement Act, directing the U.S. Government Printing Office and the Office of Superintendent of Documents to improve access to federal electronic information by maintaining an electronic directory, providing a system of online access to government publications and operating an electronic storage facility. (Albarran and Goff, 2000: 34) B. Asian Polities and the Internet The 2011 Singapore elections demonstrated the power of social media to transform existing power dynamics. The People’s Action Party, which has been ruling Singapore for 52 years, had experienced an unprecedented decrease in its share of votes by 60%. The dramatic shift in the Singaporean political terrain is attributed by many politicians and scholars in Singapore to the increasing importance of online media to reach out to voters. The People’s Action Party had been observed to cling to traditional media such as the newspaper and television during the electoral campaign while neophytes had gained popularity (but not necessarily clinching political victory) as they resorted to the latest social networking tools in the Internet. 8) In national contexts where there are high levels of political censorship and repression, political blogging has been found to proliferate. China, the country that registered the highest number of political bloggers in the world, offers an interesting case. 9) Esarey and Qiang (2008) analyzed popular Chinese political blogs that mostly involved satire directed to the Chinese State and its policies. The authors cite blogging as a medium of political expression in China that is relatively impervious to state repression.10) Meanwhile, in Iran, Khiabany and Sreberny (2007) cited the writings of Iranian youth bloggers on national and international issues at the backdrop of a repressive Islamic state. Similar to the Chinese case, Persian bloggers are numerous, making the Persian language one of the top five most popular languages in the global blogosphere.11) In the Chinese and Iranian case, scholars - 153 - 立命館言語文化研究23巻 4 号 regard Internet use very positively in terms of advancing democratization in these countries. Meanwhile, political developments in Tunisia and Egypt in 2011 had led observers to refer to these events as the “Facebook Revolution.” But while analysts in popular media have disagreed to the proposition that social media had caused the widespread support to the protests, they claim that it did hasten the process. In Egypt, for example, organizing of the January 25, 2011 protest had already been done even before the Egyptian government was able to block Twitter and Facebook. According to popular media analysts, social media also largely shaped the narrative. While the Egyptian government had been trying to make the situation look anarchic, a New York-based Egyptian blogger had been able to persuade global media networks like CNN that the event constituted a legitimate uprising. Most importantly, popular media analysts underscored the role of social media in attracting international support for the Egyptian cause.12) Like the Egyptian case, Tunisian protesters also turned to Facebook and Twitter for organizing and public support. Highly educated and prolific Tunisian bloggers, who were perceived to be critics of the government, also figured prominently as the Tunisian government actively sought to block blog sites.13) C. The Use of Information and Communications Technology in Philippine Democracy Hutchcroft and Rocamora (2003) speak of a “democratic deficit” in Philippine democracy involving a mismatch between strong demands and weak institutions. They point out that it is manifested in the “deepening frustration over the inability of democratic institutions to deliver the goods, specifically goods of a public character.” Hence, crisis in Philippine democracy springs not from the lack of appeal of democratic values to Filipino citizens, but from the incapacity of democratic institutions to deliver public services in a reliable and efficient way. (Hutchcroft and Rocamora, 2003: 259-260)