World Bank Document
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IPP437 Bayannaoer City Comprehensive Water Public Disclosure Authorized Environment Treatment Project Reclaimed Water Supply and Wastewater Treatment and Reuse Project Public Disclosure Authorized Social Assessment Report For Appraisal Public Disclosure Authorized Bayannaoer City Hetao Water Affairs Co., Ltd. Public Disclosure Authorized June 2010 Contents PREFACE ................................................................................................................... 1 SUMMARY.................................................................................................................. 3 1. OUTLINE OF PROJECT......................................................................................... 9 1.1 BACKGROUND OF PROJECT ................................................................................... 9 1.2 COMPOSITIONS OF PROJECT ............................................................................... 10 2 OUTLINE OF SOCIAL ASSESSMENT .................................................................. 12 2.1 TARGETS OF SOCIAL ASSESSMENT ....................................................................... 12 2.2 SOCIAL ASSESSMENT METHODS ........................................................................... 12 2.3 IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF MAIN RELATED SOCIAL ISSUES ............................. 22 3 PROJECT-RELATED AREA SOCIO-ECONOMIC SITUATION ............................. 23 3.1PROJECT AREA SOCIO-ECONOMIC SITUATION ......................................................... 23 3.1.1 Bayanor City socio-economic situation ...................................................... 23 3.1.2 Socio-economic situation of the Banners................................................... 24 3.2 INTRODUCTION TO THE WATER CONSUMPTION, WASTEWATER TREATMENT AND AGRICULTURAL RETURN WATER CONDITION IN THE PROJECT AREA ................................ 30 3.3 POVERTY IN PROJECT AREA................................................................................. 33 3.4 BASIC CONDITIONS OF QUESTIONNAIRE RESPONDENTS .......................................... 37 4. UNDERSTANDING AND ATTITUDE OF THE VILLAGERS TO THE PROJECT .. 43 5. ANALYSIS OF RELEVANT BENEFICIAL COLONY ............................................. 49 5.1 IDENTIFICATION OF RELEVANT BENEFICIAL COLONY ................................................ 49 5.2 REQUIREMENTS OF RELEVANT BENEFICIAL COLONY ............................................... 52 6. ANALYSIS OF SOCIAL IMPACT OF PROJECT ................................................... 56 6.1 POSITIVE IMPACT................................................................................................ 56 6.2 NEGATIVE IMPACT............................................................................................... 57 - i - 7. PROJECT AND ETHNIC MINORITIES................................................................. 59 7.1 DISTRIBUTION OF ETHNIC MINORITIES IN PROJECT AREA ......................................... 60 7.3 AMALGAMATION OF ETHNIC MINORITIES ................................................................ 62 7.4 CONCLUSION ..................................................................................................... 62 8. SUGGESTIONS ON PERFECTING ENGINEERING DESIGN ............................ 64 9. IDENTIFICATION AND CONTROL OF SOCIAL RISKS ....................................... 66 9.1 IDENTIFICATION OF SOCIAL RISKS ......................................................................... 66 9.2 CONTROL OF SOCIAL RISKS ................................................................................. 69 10. PUBLIC PARTICIPATING MECHANISM............................................................. 75 11. CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTIONS................................................................. 77 11.1 CONCLUSION ................................................................................................... 77 11.2 SUGGESTIONS.................................................................................................. 79 APPENDIX 1 SCHEDULE OF SOCIAL ASSESSMENT WORK OF BAYANOR CITY WATER ENVIRONMENT COMPREHENSIVE TREATMENT PROJECT ................. 81 APPENDIX 2 TOPICS AND VIEWPOINTS OF INFORMAL DISCUSSION OF BAYANOR CITY WATER ENVIRONMENT COMPREHENSIVE TREATMENT PROJECT ................................................................................................................. 83 APPENDIX 3 CALENDAR OF FARMING ACTIVITIES............................................. 84 - ii - Preface July 2009, upon entrusting by Inner Mongolia Bayanor City Hetao Water Affairs Co., Ltd. (hereafter called as “BHWAC”), Hydrochina Huadong Engineering Corporation (hereafter called as “ECIDI”) undertook preparation of resettlement action plan and report of social assessment for World Bank loaned Bayanor City water environment comprehensive treatment project. At early July 2009, ECIDI completed “Terms of reference of resettlement action plan” and “Terms of reference of social assessment” and related survey sheets and questionnaires, clarified the purpose, contents and method of the work, laying a good foundation for the follow-up site survey and feasibility study report preparation. After deep communication and exchange with related experts of World Bank and the project owner, ECIDI made careful modification and perfection and provided both parties-agreed terms of reference, survey sheets and questionnaire, which will become the basis for further work. As per the work progress determined by the World Bank Project Delegation, ECIDI social assessment group divided the site survey into two stages. From July 7, 2009 to July 26, 2009 and from Nov. 10, 2009~Nov. 20, 2009, under great support and coordination of BHWAC and local government and departments of related banners (counties), ECIDI conducted social assessment and site survey in related townships, towns and villages of 6 banners (counties) (Urad Front Banner, Urad Middle Banner, Urad Back Banner, Hanggin Rear Banner, and Wuyuan County) for two times. During the site survey period, ECIDI made informal discussion, interview and questionnaire with project interest-related groups in 4 townships (towns), 1 state- owned farm, 1 state-owned pasture and related villages covered by the 5 banners (counties), further understand the opinions, complaints and related proposal interest groups on the project and overall collected materials necessary for social assessment. After completion of site survey, ECIDI immediately summarized, sorted out and - 1 - analyzed the related materials and questionnaires, the “Social Assessment Report for Reclaimed Water Supply and Wastewater Treatment Reuse Works of World Bank- loaned Bayanor City Water Environment Comprehensive Treatment Project (for Pre- appraisal)” was completed in January 2010, and passed the pre-appraisal smoothly in April 2010 . With the combination of the related comments from the World Bank, ECIDI completed the “Social Assessment Report for Reclaimed Water Supply and Wastewater Treatment Reuse Works of World Bank-loaned Bayanor City Water Environment Comprehensive Treatment Project (for appraisal)”. This social assessment work was guided under and supported by Mr. Liu Zhefu of World Bank and the site survey was got active coordination by BHWAC, local government and related departments of each banners (counties). Here, we would like to express hereby our acknowledgement to them. - 2 - Summary The total investment of Bayanor City water environment comprehensive treatment project is 2.125 billion yuan RMB, the first phase investment is 1.2 billion yuan and the World Bank loan is 80 million USD. The project consists of three components, i.e., 1) reclaimed water supply project in the Industrial Park, including reclaimed water supply sub-project at Urad Back Banner Processing Park, reclaimed water supply sub-project at Ganqimaodu Port Processing Park, reclaimed water supply sub-project for the 3rd drain ditch and reclaimed water supply sub-project for the 7th drain ditch; 2) wastewater treatment and reuse project in industrial park, including the Processing Park (Hoh Town) wastewater treatment sub-project at Urad Back Banner, wastewater treatment and reuse sub-project at Ganqimaodu Port Processing Park (Delingshan Town) and wastewater treatment and reuse sub-project at Urad Front Banner Processing Park (XianfengTown); and 3) Wuliangsuhai comprehensive treatment project, including the Wuliangsuhai grid waterway sub- project, Wuliangsuhai artificial wetland project at eco-transition zone and non-point source demonstration sub-project. Scope of social assessment Through detailed discussion and consultation with related experts of World Bank, the scope of the social assessment as mentioned herein is determined as follows: Reclaimed Water Supply and Wastewater Treatment and Reuse Project in the industrial park. Targets of social assessment The main targets of this social assessment are determined as follows: To urge the project-affected groups and the project target groups to understand the project’s objectives and activities; To comprehend the basic socio-economic development situation of the project area, and analyze the main social factors affecting the achieving of project objectives. To identify the project interest-related groups and analyze their needs and impact; To evaluate potential positive and negative impacts of the project, analyze the potential social risks the project is proposed to bring and put forward measures to avoid or reduce the negative impacts and social risks;