TheThe FutureFuture ofof IndustrialIndustrial SocietySociety atat thethe EndEnd ofof CheapCheap Oil*Oil*

** Or,Or, It’sIt’s OnlyOnly thethe EndEnd ofof thethe WorldWorld asas WeWe KnowKnow ItIt

Gary McMurtry Dept. of Oceanography University of Hawaii, Manoa I met a traveler from an antique land Who said: “Two vast and truckless legs of stone Stand in the desert….

And on the pedestal these words appear: “My name is Ozymandias, king of kings: Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair!”

Nothing beside remains, Round the decay Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare The lone and level sands stretch far away.

“Ozymandias” by Percy Bysshe Shelley (1817)

“Alas, poor world, what treasure hast thou lost!”

“Venus and Adonis” by William Shakespeare

“It is evident that the fortunes of the world’s human population, for better or for worse, are inextricably interrelated with the use that is made of energy resources.”

M. King Hubbert (1969)

Of the two major aspects of Physical Chemistry, Thermodynamics sets the laws and the boundaries, Kinetics sets the pace. In human endeavors, one can be fine in the thermodynamic sense, and still lose because the reaction rates were too slow. AddictedAddicted toto OilOil The USA has <5% of the global population, but uses 25% of global oil resources.

The current global population is >6.5 billion.

Essentially, that translates to 300,000,000 people using the energy resources of 1,625,000,000 people!

Currently, 60% of the oil consumed by the USA is imported, mainly from our neighbors Canada, Mexico, and Venezuela. PropertiesProperties && UsesUses ofof OilOil • Amazing Energy Density (45 MJ/kg, compared with 10-30 MJ/kg for , 16 MJ/kg for dry wood) • Easily Transportable • Safe (relatively) & Cheaply Storable

Major Uses:

• Transportation Fuel for motor vehicles, trains, ships & airplanes • Fuel for Power Plants • Industrial Applications, e.g. mining, farming, manufacturing • Source of Petrochemicals, including chemical (N,P,K)*, pesticides*, herbicides*, plastics & pharmaceuticals

*Basis of the “green revolution”, as a means to ‘fix’ or reduce atmospheric nitrogen. In this usage, I include , another limited , and mineable phosphate, probably next on the global depletion list. K is abundant. ““Excess”Excess” PeoplePeople areare MadeMade ofof OilOil At the start of the Industrial Revolution, around 1850, the world population was about 1 billion.

“Excess people” are defined as those currently supported by fossil fuels, especially from those products that support “Green Revolution” industrial agriculture, mining & transportation.

If denied the support, by withdrawal of cheap and abundant fossil fuels, human populations will likely revert to pre-Industrial, or lower, levels.

Many ecologists say we are already in human population “overshoot”, and the planet cannot much longer sustain the added load.

Climate change (e.g., global warming) can only make matters worse. USAUSA OilOil ProductionProduction HistoryHistory && ProjectionProjection

The US lower-48 production peak (Texas + Rest of USA) occurred in 1970; In 1956, M. King Hubbert predicted this outcome to within a few years. Hubbert’sHubbert’s PredictionsPredictions

M. King Hubbert 1903-1989

From: K. S. Deffeyes, Hubbert’s Peak (2001) Campbell’sCampbell’s PredictionsPredictions World Oil Production

Colin J. Campbell, Founder, ASSOCIATIONASSOCIATIONASSOCIATION FORFORFOR THETHETHE STUDYSTUDYSTUDY OFOFOF PEAKPEAKPEAK OILOILOIL ANDANDAND GASGASGAS World Population

These are not kooks! It’sIt’s aboutabout thethe Food…Food…

Made available to plants by fossil fuel

Population Disaster! GlobalGlobal OilOil ProductionProduction && PredictionPrediction GlobalGlobal OilOil && NaturalNatural GasGas DepletionDepletion

From: C. J. Campbell, The End of the First Half of the Age of Oil (2005) PetroleumPetroleum DistributionDistribution byby RegionRegion

Proven at end 2004 --Source: British OilOil && GasGas areare notnot evenlyevenly distributeddistributed

From: Kenneth S. Deffeyes, (2005) MajorMajor OilOil FieldsFields ofof SaudiSaudi ArabiaArabia

Ghawar Field: King of Kings, Site of * Recent since 1951 Terrorist Attempt

From: Matthew R. Simmons, (2005) OilOil && GasGas FormationFormation Most of the world’s oil & natural gas resources were formed in two brief epochs of extreme global warming at 90 Ma and 150 Ma

Oil & gas can take millions of years to form and require specific geological conditions to mature and become trapped in reservoirs

First, a nutrient trap From: K. S. Deffeyes, must be available Hubbert’s Peak (2001)

Bottom Line: It’s renewable, but only on geologic time scales! EvolvingEvolving OilOil ExtractionExtraction MethodsMethods

Young Fields Vertical Wells, THEN Self-Pressurized (1950-1990) Flow

Lateral Well Drilling, Mature Fields Water Flooding NOW (2004-->)

From: Matthew R. Simmons, Twilight in the Desert (2005) Crude Oil Alternatives--Alberta, Canada Oil Sands

*currently 1 million barrels (MB)/day *projected to 3 MB/day in 2020 *projected to 6 MB/day “in future” *reserves equal to oil of Saudi Arabia *environmental impacts huge & scaleable

Source: K. Bourzac, Dirty Oil, MIT Tech. Review, Dec. 2005 USA Consumption vs. Alternative Oil Supplies Global Consumption vs. Alternative Oil Supplies TheThe ListList ofof AlternativesAlternatives Category Brief Comment • Heavy Oil Most helpful in near future • Oil Sands Moderate supply • Coal-Derived Liquids Moderate supply • Liquefied Natural Gas Minor supply

• Natural Gas N.A. post-peak; world will soon follow • Coal Maybe 100-200 more years--see CDL • Methane hydrates Abundant on and off-shore--impacts unknown

• Solar-voltaic Moderate supply • Hydro-electric Moderate supply--local impact • Wind Moderate supply--local impact • Tidal, Waves, Currents Minor supply--local impact • OTEC Scaleable to 15 TW, but impacts unknown • Biomass Land forms are net energy losers; marine?

• Geothermal Minor supply--local impact • Nuclear Fission, Most helpful in far future--probably Nuclear Fusion our only long-term hope ConservationConservation isis MoreMore ThanThan aa PersonalPersonal Virtue,Virtue, butbut OilOil isis Fungible…Fungible… AndAnd SomeSome WordsWords AboutAbout thethe “Hydrogen“Hydrogen Economy”Economy”

Hydrogen (H2) is an energy carrier (think: ‘battery’), not a source.

Cracking scarce hydrocarbons to get hydrogen “fuel” for fuel cells is silly. Burn the hydrocarbons, instead.

Using electrical power to crack water (H2O --> H2 + 1/2O2) is an expensive proposition. Long-term, it may provide N2 reductant. Storage of high-pressure or liquid hydrogen fuel is expensive and Potentially Dangerous (think: Hindenburg)… FossilFossil FuelFuel PlatformPlatform

Like windmills on the sea, alternative energy technology rests upon a vast pool of fossil-fuel energy that will decrease and become more expensive over time. Industries that make alloys, turbines, solar panels, batteries, & construction equipment and transportation all rely on fossil fuels. Even coal is mined with diesel-powered equipment. ERoI:ERoI: EnergyEnergy ReturnedReturned onon EnergyEnergy InvestedInvested

Or, If it takes a barrel of oil to recover a barrel of oil, why bother? MagnitudeMagnitude ofof thethe ProblemProblem or Why Most Alternatives Won’t Work, or Not in Time

To make up for the coming , a 1 Gigawatt plant needs to be built every day for the next 30 years*

* To replace 10 Terawatts or 1013 watts = 10,000 new 1 Gigawatt (109 watt) plants; , “Out of Gas, The End of the Age of Oil”, 2004. ThreeThree FactorsFactors thatthat DetermineDetermine thethe Potential*Potential* PostPost--OilOil BreakdownBreakdown

*If We Do Nothing

From: P. Thompson, “The Twilight of the Modern World” (2004) TheThe FourFour StagesStages ofof PossiblePossible BreakdownBreakdown

From: P. Thompson, “The Twilight of the Modern World” (2004) FutureFuture NorthNorth AmericaAmerica----2050+???2050+???

Inspired by “”, J. H. Kuntsler (2005) FutureFuture ofof HawaiiHawaii Burdens • >1.2 million people living thousands of miles from the nearest land • ‘Standing crop’ of >0.1 million tourists, >0.1 million military • Small land area, with limited water resources • Surrounding ocean waters are oligotrophic (biological desert)

Advantages • Equitable climate, inspiring natural landscape & educated, cosmopolitan culture • History of self-sustainability and export agriculture • Geothermal, biomass (?) and OTEC/cold-water agriculture potential on Hawaii Island

Disadvantages • Current reliance on all things imported, including most food, goods & energy • AC high-rises, suburbs & outmoded land transportation system • Economic reliance on tourism, military & soon-to-be-extinct cheap airline industry There must be some way out of here, said the joker to the thief, There’s too much confusion, I can’t get no relief.

Businessmen, they drink my wine, plowmen dig my earth, None of them along the line know what any of it is worth.

No reason to get excited, the thief, he kindly spoke, There are many here among us who feel that life is but a joke.

But you and i, we’ve been through that, and this is not our fate, So let us not talk falsely now, the hour is getting late.

All along the watchtower, princes kept the view While all the women came and went, barefoot servants, too.

Outside in the distance a wildcat did growl, Two riders were approaching, the wind began to howl.

“All Along The Watchtower” words & music by Bob Dylan (best performed by Jimi Hendrix at high volume) RecommendedRecommended ReadingReading

The Party's Over (2003, 2005) by Power Down (2005) by Richard Heinberg Hubbert's Peak (2001) by Kenneth Deffeyes Beyond Oil (2005) by Kenneth Deffeyes Out of Gas (2004) by David Goodstein Twilight in the Desert (2005) by The Long Emergency (2005) by James H. Kunstler

Related:

Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed (2005) by Jared Diamond (featuring Easter Island as the real-life version of Dr. Seuss’s tale: The Lorax) CapitalisticCapitalistic InertiaInertia MustMust bebe Overcome!Overcome!

Mahalo to Brother John for his kokua!