Review of Shearman's Collection of Raphael Documents
BOOK REVIE'WS was inserted to make it more imrnediate, in 1936, in which most documents are not of the role previously played by Golzio) for all suggest that it was the fint scene to be published in full. monographic study, and can thereby assumea painted, and technical evidence prompts us to In the period since Shearman's book has canonical position which inhibits ftesh con- reconsider the sequence of the frescos inde- appeared the re-daring ofthe Monteluce doc- sideration of the evidence. pendendy oftheir preparation on paper. uments to r5o5, not r5o3 bp.sr-96),, and of In a moment of characteristic wit. Shear- If Raphael's contemporaries averred that Raphael's appointrnent as Sctiptor Breuium in man describes what a biography of Raphael his art was not innate but born from studying I5II, not r5og (pp.r5o-52),3have made pos- based entirely upon f).lsedocuments would 'Would be other artists, they were not totally wrong, par- sible new interpretations ofthe artist's career. like (p. r 5). he have been asamused by ticularly in regard to his early career. Raphael Sadly, however, Shearman's Corpus doesn't what a student's chronology of Raphael's life seemed to need models to emulate and sur- acfually tell us very much more about based on this publication might be like? There pass. His syncretic method, by which he Raphael than we knew already. There are would be much that was good and uncon- selected from al1 available models, painting new documents in this book (for instance, tentious, but Raphael would be said to have techniques, lighting, figure moti6, poses, those connected with Alberrinelli, supplied by been in Rome in rso2/o3; in r5o4 the only 'Signed landscape motifi, backdrops, accoutrements Louis Waldman), and it is extremely useful to entry would read and dated The Spos- and cosfumes may make him particularly have them gathered together in one place (if alizio in Citti di Castello (now Milan, Brera)',6 'gilded interesting in an age of multivalent informa- not in one volume), but we do not have the wh.ile in r5o8 Raphael would have a tron.
[Show full text]