Source Book on Digital Libraries
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Source Book on Digital Libraries Version 1.0 December 6, 1993 Prepared for and Sponsored by the National Science Foundation Directorate for Computer and Information Science and Engineering (CISE) Division of Information, Robotics and Intelligent Systems (IRIS) Covering a series of NSF Invitational Workshops and Related Information Edward A. Fox, Editor ([email protected]) (C) Copyright 1993 Edward A. Fox and Virginia Tech Preface This report has its origins in discussions Mike Lesk and I had in October 1991, in connection with an NSF-sponsored workshop. With Mike McGill we drafted a White Paper, calling for a National Electronic Science, Engineering, and Technology Library. Since then, many things have changed. Now, the term “Digital Library” is more in vogue than “Electronic Library,” though one might also call it a hypermedia archive or a data/information/knowledge base. Regardless of the name, the intent is clear. Step one is for NSF to play a lead role in launching a concerted R&D program in the area. This is essential, so that any large scale development efforts by the Federal Government, along with state and private agencies, will be sensibly coordinated and undertaken in the most cost-effective and timely manner possible. We hope this initiative will begin in 1993, and proceed into the 21st Century. We feel that it must focus on large scale proto- types, and on setting the stage for a new, open, task-oriented, computer-assisted, type of access to information. Step two involves partnerships, cooperative ventures, and production conversion of back- archives. ARPA, NASA, NIST, Library of Congress, NLM, NAL, and many other groups must become involved if we are to serve the broad base of users, from kindergarten to Nobel laureate researchers. It will only be successful if supported by top-quality research on information storage and retrieval, hypertext, document processing, human-computer interaction, scaling up of infor- mation systems, networking, multimedia systems, visualization, education, training, etc. It is hoped that this Source Book will help show the potential, progress, proposals and planning efforts underway in relation to Digital Libraries --- leading to a large and effective R&D initiative Toward this aim, please send in corrections and additions so we can keep this book up-to-date.. Acknowledgements Keith Tomlin provided typing, editing, formating, FrameMaker expertise, and general secretarial assistance in assembling and organizing this report into a usable form from the myriad pieces we began with. Thanks also go to the Department of Computer Science at Virginia Tech for making software and resources available to help in this effort, and to the many students, faculty, and staff who assisted in a variety of ways. Finally, thanks go to the numerous people who provided their time in writing the various pieces included, who attended the related NSF workshops, or gave pointers to interesting work. Special thanks go to Mike Lesk and Mike McGill who have worked with me since 1991 on the topic of digital library initiatives, and to Chris Borgman and David Levy for providing lots of helpful texts and files, as well as for their support of the workshops. CHAPTER 1 Future Directions in Text Analysis, Retrieval and Understanding 1 Chapter 1, Section A: National Electronic Library 4 A National Electronic Science, Engineering, and Technology Library 4 Chapter 1, Section B: Workshop Report 24 Workshop Report 24 References 35 CHAPTER 2 July 1992 Workshop 39 Chapter 2, Section A: List of Attendees 39 Chapter 2, Section B: Agenda 40 Chapter 2, Section C: Lesk Summary 41 Workshop on Electronic Libraries 41 Chapter 2, Section D: Statements of Participants 47 Christine L. Borgman, UCLA 47 Steve Cisler, Apple Library of Tomorrow 49 Ed Fox, Virginia Tech 50 Hector Garcia-Molina, Stanford University 51 John Garrett, Corporation for National Research Initiatives 53 H. V. Jagadish, AT&T Bell Labs 56 Paul B. Kantor, Rutgers 57 Larry Lannom, DARPA 59 Judi Moline, NIST 61 CHAPTER 3 December 1992 Workshop 62 Chapter 3, Section A: List of Participants 62 Chapter 3, Section B: Agenda 63 Chapter 3, Section C: Lesk Summary 64 The Digital Library: What is it? Why should it be here? 64 Chapter 3, Section D: Statements of Participants 69 William T. Crocca, Xerox 72 Esther Dyson, EDventure Holdings Inc. 74 Source Book on Digital Libraries 1 Linda Gass, Adobe Systems, Inc. 75 Vicky Reich, Stanford University 79 Jean Mayhew, United Technologies Research Center 80 Geoffrey Nunberg, Xerox PARC 81 Gio Wiederhold, DARPA and ACM Publication Board 83 Terry Winograd, Interval Research and Stanford University 84 Chapter 3, Section E: Education Working Group Summary 88 Outline Summary from Working Group on Impact of National Digital Library (NDL) on Education 88 Chapter 3, Section F: Borgman Notes 93 December 9, 1992 Wednesday 93 December 10, 1992 Thursday 106 December 9, 1992 - What is a Digital Library? 113 Copies of Flip Charts 116 NEL Workshop Report 121 CHAPTER 4 Notable Events 143 Conferences 143 CIKM-92, First International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management 143 Computer Professionals for Social Responsibility Annual Meeting 144 Creating CD-ROMs for Science Education Conference 148 Document Delivery & Internet Conferences 148 The Electronic Library: Administrative Issues for Organization & Access Institute 149 GopherCon ‘93: Internet Gopher Workshop and Internet Gopher Conference 152 InfoFair ‘92 - Mastering the Internet Maze 161 Information Exchange Telecommunications as Part of the National Information Infrastructure 163 Invitational Symposium on Knowledge Management 164 National Net ‘93 164 2 Source Book on Digital Libraries New York Technology Summit - The Conference and Exhibition for Networking, Telecommunications, and Computing 165 ACM SIGIR ‘93 16th International Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval 166 User Interfaces for On-line Public Access Catalogs 177 WAIS Inc. Announcements and Technology Showcase 178 Workshops 179 HCI Workshop 179 Workshop on Hyperbase Systems 214 Workshop on Hypermedia and Hypertext Standards 22nd-23rd April Amsterdam 216 Information Access and the Networks - A Research Workshop 216 National Research and Education Network (NREN) Workshop 219 NSF Workshop on Visual Information Management Systems 221 Selected Legislation in the 103rd Congress Related to Electronic Information Delivery 222 Infrastructure Development 222 Government Information 229 Educational Applications 232 Library Applications 234 Health Services 235 Privacy and Intellectual Property 235 News Items from “The Computists’ Communique” 1992 237 News Items from “Electronic Frountier Foundation (EFF) Library” 246 News Items from ALAWON 255 NREN Applications Bill Summarized 255 Hearings Held on Boucher Networking Applications Bill 258 Upcoming Hearings 261 About ALAWON: 262 Other News Items and Announcements 262 Source Book on Digital Libraries 3 ALCTS Announces Publication of “After the Electronic Revolution, Will You Be the First To Go? 262 Clinton OKs Computer Access To Congressional Record, Federal Register 264 Gopher and WAIS Access to the Federal Register via the Global Internet 265 ‘Library of the Future’ Takes Shape at Columbia University Law Library 267 National Science Foundation Notice of Briefing Meeting 269 OCLC Awards Three Research Grants 270 The On-line Book Initiative - Announcement 271 CHAPTER 5 Directory of Interested Parties 274 People 274 Groups and Organizations 298 Testimonials related to the National Electronic Library 298 Internet Society 300 Library-Oriented Lists and Electronic Serials 313 Projects 321 The Clearinghouse for Networked Information Discovery and Retrieval 321 Project Envision: A User-Centered Database from the Computer Science Literature 327 Information Infrastructure Project — Science, Technology and Public Policy Program 327 Information Infrastructure Sourcebook 330 Interactive Accessibility: Breaking Barriers to the Power of Computing 336 Project JANUS - Large-scale Imaging and Text- Retrieval Project 338 The Mercury Electronic Library 340 NSF Network Information Services Awards 341 The Open Source Processing Research Initiative 344 Project on Scholarly Communication in the Network Environment 348 Soviet Archive Exhibit 351 TREC II Guidelines 353 Research Announcements 370 4 Source Book on Digital Libraries Research on Digital Libraries 370 Research on Scientific Databases 380 Library of Congress 383 Excerpts from: Workshop On Electronic Texts Proceedings 384 The Library of Congress Information System (LOCIS) is now available over the Internet. 392 CHAPTER 6 Summary and Recommendations 394 Sketch of a Digital Library Initiative 394 CHAPTER 7 Bibliography 398 References 398 From the June issue of BYTE 1991 in the State of the Art section and in the Solutions Focus section: 398 Referenced and Related Documents 400 CHAPTER 8 Glossary 406 Abbreviations 406 Terms from “Cyberpunk”, Time Magazine 408 Source Book on Digital Libraries 5 CHAPTER 1 Future Directions in Text Analysis, Retrieval and Understanding METHODOLOGIES FOR INTELLIGENT TEXT PROCESSING AND INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT: ACHIEVEMENTS AND OPPORTUNITIES Report of the NSF Invitational Workshop on Future Directions in Text Analysis, Retrieval and Understanding The Workshop was funded by NSF grant IRI-9114210 and co-sponsored by The Uni- versity of Nebraska Center for Communication and Information Sciences. Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this report are those of the workshop participants